Treatment of bilateral Wilms' tumor

Synchronous Bilateral Wilms Tumor: Five-Year Single-Center Experience with Assessment of Quality of Life

Context:

Synchronous Bilateral Wilms tumor (sBWT).

Aims:

This study aimed to assess the outcome of patients with sBWT treated on SIOP protocol.

Settings and Design:

Retrospective and prospective randomized study.

Subjects and Methods:

SIOP 93-01 protocol was used to study nine patients of sBWT in a single center and followed up over a period from 2 to 5 years.

Statistical Analysis Used:

Unpaired t-test and Mann–Whitney U-test were used for analysis.

Results:

Of nine patients, six were included in the study as three patients lost to follow-up. Among the six patients, there were four girls and two boys with a median age of 2 years. Mean regression in the size of tumor was 87% in four out of six patients. Tumor with unfavorable histology showed 32% response (ratio of favorable: unfavorable histology 2:1). Event-free survival rate was 81.3% and overall survival was 90% over 2–5 years. Recurrence was seen in two patients of whom one had Denys–Drash syndrome. Mean DTPA glomerular filtration rate was 91.4/ml/min/1.73 m² preoperatively and that of 3 months after completion of treatment was 84/ml/min/1.73 m². Health-related quality of life (HRQOL) using Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory and Lansky Play Performance Scale revealed significant improvement results of all functioning domains such as physical, social, emotional, and school subscales with P < 0.05 and performance scale (P < 0.04).

Conclusions:

We suggest SIOP protocol for sBWT and bilateral nephron-sparing surgery in two stages. However, long-term follow-up is required to assess the ultimate renal function outcome. HRQOL is an essential guide in improving the conditions of pediatric cancer survivors.

The management of bilateral Wilms tumor

Wilms tumor (WT) is the most common malignant renal tumor in childhood. Approximately 5-7% of WT patients present with bilateral disease, either synchronously or metachronously. Bilateral WT usually occurs in younger children and more often in girls. Management of a child with bilateral WT is very challenging. In contrast to unilateral WT, there has not been uniform agreement about the therapeutic strategy in the management of bilateral WT. As surgery is a critical component in the treatment of WT, the aim is to achieve a high cure rate while maintaining adequate long-term renal function in patients with bilateral WT. In the past, radical surgical procedures which lead to the patients on dialysis have been traditionally recommended in these patients. After several multicentre trials, bilateral biopsies followed by pre-operative chemotherapy and then renal salvage surgery have been recommended. The management of bilateral WT has evolved from primary surgical extirpation to kidney-preserving resection after preoperative chemotherapy. Preoperative chemotherapy often results in significant reduction in tumor size, thereby facilitating subsequent renal salvage. The analysis of children with bilateral WT shows that preservation of renal parenchyma is possible following initial preoperative chemotherapy. Only centers with experience in bilateral WT should treat the cases with bilateral WT to provide optimal treatment.

The management of synchronous bilateral Wilms tumor: a report from the National Wilms Tumor Study Group

OBJECTIVE

To provide guidelines for future trials, we reviewed the outcomes of children with synchronous bilateral Wilms tumors (BWT) treated on National Wilms Tumor Study-4 (NWTS-4).

METHODS

NWTS-4 enrolled 3335 patients including 188 patients with BWT (5.6%). Treatment and outcome data were collected.

RESULTS

Among 188 BWT patients registered with NWTS-4, 195 kidneys in 123 patients had initial open biopsy, 44 kidneys in 31 patients had needle biopsies. Although pre-resection chemotherapy was recommended, 87 kidneys in 83 patients were managed with primary resection: Complete nephrectomy 48 in 48 patients, 31 partial/wedge nephrectomies in 27 patients, enucleations 8 in 8 patients. No initial surgery was performed in 45 kidneys in 43 patients, 5 kidneys in 3 patients not coded. Anaplasia was diagnosed after completion of the initial course of chemotherapy in 14 patients (initial surgical procedure: 9 open biopsies, 4 needle biopsies, 1 partial nephrectomy). The average number of days from the start of chemotherapy to diagnosis of anaplasia was 390 (range 44-1925 days). Relapse or progression of disease occurred in 54 children. End stage renal failure occurred in 23 children, 6 of whom had bilateral nephrectomies. The 8 year event free survival for BWT with favorable histology was 74%, and overall survival was 89%; whereas the event free survival for BWT with unfavorable histology was 40%, overall survival was 45%.

CONCLUSION

The current analysis of patients with BWT treated on NWTS-4 shows that preservation of renal parenchyma is possible in many patients after initial preoperative chemotherapy. The incidence of end-stage renal disease remains significantly higher in children with BWT. Future studies are warranted to address the need for earlier biopsy in nonresponsive tumors and earlier definitive surgery to recognize unfavorable histology in these high-risk patients.

Bilateral Wilms' tumors: single-center experience with 22 cases and literature review

OBJECTIVES

Bilateral Wilms' tumors represent a therapeutic challenge. The primary aim of management is eradication of the neoplasm and preservation of renal function. We present our experience in the management of such cases in a single-center experience.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study of 22 patients with histologically proven bilateral nephroblastoma who were treated from 1993 to 2008 at our center. Of the 22 patients, 12 were girls and 10 were boys, with a median age of 3 years (range 1-9); 19 had a synchronous presentation and 3 a metachronous presentation. Of the 22 patients, 6 underwent initial surgical resection followed by chemotherapy and 16 underwent initial biopsy and preoperative chemotherapy. The final oncologic and renal outcomes were assessed.

RESULTS

The median follow-up period was 3 years (range 1-11). Of the 22 patients, 8 died, for an overall survival rate of 63.5%. The survival for the initial chemotherapy and initial surgery groups was essentially similar. Of all the variables studied, unfavorable histologic findings had a significant negative effect on survival. Of the 5 patients with unfavorable histologic findings, 4 died during the follow-up period. The median volume of preserved renal parenchyma was 40%. All patients had good renal function during follow-up, except for 1 patient who had undergone bilateral nephrectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral Wilms' tumors impose 2 conflicting issues: elimination of the pathology and preservation of the renal function. Currently, treatment regimens involving initial chemotherapy followed by conservative surgery can achieve these goals in an important proportion of patients.

Wilms' tumor. Surgical considerations and controversies

Although the therapeutic objectives for Wilms' tumor are to maximize outcomes and minimize treatment morbidity, there are some controversial issues related to different therapeutic protocols. In this article, the authors address some of the issues such as the roles of tumor biopsy, preoperative chemotherapy, contralateral exploration, and partial nephrectomy.

Nephron-sparing surgery in synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumors

BACKGROUND

Synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumor is rare and experience with renal salvage procedures and their limitations accumulates slowly at single institutions. The authors analyzed whether their growing experience with atypical renal resections and awareness of nephroblastomatosis had influenced the outcome of surgical procedures.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of patients treated from 1977 to 1995 was performed. Surgical reports, clinical sheets, and follow-up data were evaluated. All pathology slides were reviewed for histological classification and presence of nephroblastomatosis. Renal function was evaluated pre- and postoperatively and at final follow-up.

RESULTS

Fourteen patients were treated. Two to 20 years after surgery, 13 patients are alive, and none has had renal failure. Five patients had unilateral nephrectomies, and a renal salvage procedure was performed on 22 kidneys. One patient with an anaplastic bilateral Wilms' tumor died of tumor progress 1 year after surgery. Several kidneys, which would have been sacrificed by application of traditional criteria, could be salvaged by atypical and unconventional tumor resections and by superficial dissection and enucleation of supposed nephroblastomatosis. Nephrectomy appeared unavoidable with hilar invasion by tumor.

CONCLUSION

Atypical resections of localized lesions and superficial dissections of suspected nephroblastomatosis appeared as valid surgical treatment options for patients who would otherwise have been candidates for nephrectomy. In the case of hilar tumor invasion, however, nephrectomy seems unavoidable.

Long-term renal function in patients with irradiated bilateral Wilms tumor. National Wilms' Tumor Study Group

The treatment of bilateral Wilms tumor (BWT) involves a multidisciplinary approach including surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy. The long-term renal function in patients receiving all three treatment modalities has not been evaluated. Long-term renal function was evaluated in 81 children with synchronous BWT who received radiation therapy as part of their treatment. Renal function was assessed by measuring blood urea nitrogen (BUN) and serum creatinine (Cr). The normal range for the BUN was defined as 10-24 mg/dl, and the Cr was considered normal at levels of <1.5 mg/dl. Moderate elevations were defined as a BUN of 25-50 mg/dl and/or a Cr of 1.6-2.5 mg/dl and marked elevations as a BUN of >50 mg/dl and/or a Cr of >2.5 mg/dl. BUN and Cr levels were measured prior to treatment and at the following intervals: 6 months after treatment, 1 year after treatment, 2 years after treatment, and at last follow-up. Any elevation during the posttreatment follow-up period was considered abnormal. A total of 28 children (34.6%) had elevated BUN and/or Cr levels, and 18 had moderate and 10 had marked renal insufficiency. No dose-response relationship was established when comparing the radiation doses of those with elevated values to those with normal values. The renal complication rate was moderate, and other factors including surgery, extent and nature of chemotherapy, and recurrent tumor must also be taken into account. The elevations present in several children could be attributed to tumor recurrence and in one case to gentamicin toxicity. The management of children with BWT should consider all of these risks, and attempts to preserve renal parenchyma are warranted.

Renal salvage procedures in patients with synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumors: a report from the National Wilms' Tumor Study Group

Synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumor accounts for 4% to 6% of all Wilms' tumors. Renal salvage procedures (partial nephrectomy and enucleation) have been recommended to conserve renal parenchyma. The objective of this study was to review the results of renal salvage operations performed in children who had bilateral neoplasms. The authors reviewed the records of 98 children enrolled in the Fourth National Wilms' Tumor Study who had synchronous bilateral tumors and underwent renal salvage procedures. One hundred thirty-four kidneys were managed with renal salvage procedures. Complete excision of gross disease was accomplished in 118 (88%) of the 134 kidneys. Local tumor recurrence in the remnant kidney or tumor bed occurred in 11 cases (8.2%). Overall, 72% of the kidneys were preserved, and the 4-year survival rate was 81.7%. The surgical morbidity after a salvage procedure was comparable to that of a complete nephrectomy in patients with unilateral Wilms' tumor. Although the incidence of positive surgical margins is worrisome, it did not invariably lead to local recurrence in the remnant kidney or the tumor bed.

Bilateral Wilms' tumor: in situ cooling of the kidney facilitates curative excision of tumors, with preservation of renal function

Bilateral synchronous multifocal Wilms' tumor is a rare malignancy for which no optimum treatment has been established thus far. The need to preserve renal parenchyma whenever possible is obvious. The authors describe a patient who underwent removal of six subcapsular tumors from a kidney that had been protected from ischemia by in situ cooling with UW-Belzer solution and by surface cooling. This technique was safe, easy to perform, and allowed all the time required to resect the tumors under adequate visual control and to wait for analysis of the frozen sections. It might be a useful alternative to the more complicated "bench" technique.

Treatment of bilateral Wilms' tumor: comparison of initial biopsy and chemotherapy to initial surgical resection in the preservation of renal mass and function

The National Wilms' Tumor Study 3 (NWTS-3) recommended treatment of bilateral Wilms' tumor with initial biopsy followed by chemotherapy with subsequent operation to resect the remaining tumor. This study was performed to determine if this approach preserves renal mass and function when compared with initial surgical resection followed by chemotherapy. Over a 20-year period (1970 to 1990), 15 patients with synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumor were treated at the Childrens Hospital of Los Angeles. Eight patients in the surgical group underwent initial unilateral nephrectomy with contralateral biopsy, wedge resection, or partial nephrectomy and subsequent chemotherapy. The seven patients in the chemotherapy group underwent bilateral tumor biopsy, followed by chemotherapy and subsequent tumor resection. Patients were assigned to each group in a nonrandomized manner according to the preference of the attending oncologist and surgeon. Comparison of the two groups showed no significant differences in sex distribution, initial renal function, tumor histology, dose and field of radiotherapy, presence or absence of positive surgical margins, and local recurrence rates. Patients in the surgery group were slightly older than those in the chemotherapy group: 3.6 +/- 2.2 versus 2.3 +/- 2.2 years. The percent of renal mass involved by tumor for the surgery group was 52 +/- 12 versus 73 +/- 16 for the chemotherapy group (P = .03). The percent of renal mass preserved following all operations, local recurrence rates, incidence of metastases, and survival was nearly identical between the two groups. There were three cases of renal failure in the surgery group and one case of renal failure in the chemotherapy group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Metachronous bilateral Wilms tumor. Report of longest-known survivor and guidelines for conservative management

In a one-year-old black male patient a classic Wilms tumor of the left kidney was treated with left nephrectomy, chemotherapy, and irradiation to the entire abdomen. Two years later a mature Wilms tumor, consisting predominantly of rhabdomyomatous elements, was discovered in the right kidney. Although a second course of chemotherapy was given and 2,000 rad were delivered to the right flank, the mass continued to enlarge with progressive deterioration of renal function. A nephron-sparing procedure was performed, in which a 3,400-g tumor measuring 19 cm X 16 cm X 9 cm was enucleated from the right kidney without compromise to the remaining normal tissue. Pathologic examination of the surgical specimen revealed a mature Wilms tumor with a malignant anaplastic sarcoma arising in the central portion. Currently, he is disease-free with normal renal function more than twenty years after diagnosis of the metachronous bilateral Wilms tumor. We believe he is the longest known surviving metachronous Wilms tumor patient and emphasizes the importance of conservative, meticulous surgery in the management of both unilateral and bilateral Wilms tumors. The role of multimodal therapy (chemotherapy, irradiation, and surgery) as well as the current guidelines for the management of bilateral Wilms tumors as proposed by the National Wilms Tumor Study are reviewed.

Bilateral Wilms' tumor

Recent studies indicate a favorable outcome with bilateral Wilms' tumor. From 1971 to 1985, ten children between the ages of 6 months and 5 years were treated for this disease. During the early part of the series, five patients had nephrectomy on one side and partial nephrectomy on the other side, and one patient had bilateral partial nephrectomies at the same operation. More recently four patients initially had a biopsy of both tumors and lymph node sampling followed by chemotherapy. At the second-look procedure two patients had multiple biopsies because there was no obvious tumor. Histologically there was no tumor on the third-look procedure in these two patients. Nine patients had a favorable histology of the Wilms' tumor. One patient had a favorable histology on one side and an unfavorable type of histology on the other side. Eight patients are surviving between 6 months and 13 years. Two died of extensive disease within 16 months of diagnosis. One patient had an unfavorable histology. The good results following partial nephrectomies have led us to attempt to conserve additional tissue, as has been done in the last four patients. Our early results suggest biopsy of the tumor followed by chemotherapy, then a second look, and if necessary, third-look procedures may result in preservation of functioning renal tissue.

Prognostic factors and outcome in bilateral Wilms' tumor

Twenty-one patients with bilateral Wilms' tumor are reviewed and the details of diagnosis, therapy, and survival presented. All patients had an abdominal mass at the time of diagnosis. Associated findings included hypertension, aniridia, and genitourinary anomalies. Favorable histologic features were found in all simultaneously occurring tumors and in the initial tumor in nonsimultaneous tumors. Eleven of the 18 patients with simultaneously occurring tumors survived for at least 2 years, for an overall 2-year survival rate of 61%, which was similar to the 2-year survival rate of 60% found in a review of 61 other simultaneously occurring bilateral Wilms' tumors reported in the literature since 1971. Two "front-end" factors that affected prognosis were the patient's age and the stage of the most advanced tumor at the time of diagnosis. A significantly better survival was found in children whose tumor was diagnosed before the age of 2 years and in patients who had Stage I or II disease in the most advanced tumor, as compared with those who had Stage III or IV disease. The overall survival rate in this series and in the literature review is much poorer than that reported for bilateral Wilms' tumor in the National Wilm's Tumor Study; some possible reasons for this are given. The authors' current approach to diagnosis and therapy is reviewed.

Second-look laparotomy for Wilms' tumor: indications and results in 19 patients

Nineteen of 74 children with Wilms' tumor underwent second-look laparotomy. Transperitoneal operation was done in five cases referred after flank operation elsewhere. Four had a change in stage from I to II or III, while one considered "inoperable" was resected (4/5 survived). Reoperation was done in two late referrals after operations with tumor spill. One had recurrent flank disease; the other had a flank mass with unrecognized diaphragmatic and intracaval extension (1/2 survived). Three children with giant tumors initially considered unresectable were successfully resected after cytoreduction with chemotherapy (3/3 survived). Two of three patients with bilateral Wilms' tumor survived reoperative procedures (partial or total nephrectomy). Five children with late intraabdominal recurrence (3 liver: 2 flank) eventually died despite reoperation and adjunctive therapy. All five had unfavorable histology. One child with en bloc hepatic resection had successful reoperation for suprahepatic vena caval obstruction due to regeneration of liver, but subsequently died. Ten of the 19 patients survived (52.6%) following reoperation and adjunctive therapy. Second-look laparotomy is quite useful in patients inadequately staged with flank operations, in cases of bilateral Wilms' tumor, and in children with initially unresectable tumors following cytoreduction. Patients with extensive tumor spill at a previous procedure may benefit from early reoperation. Late recurrence of tumor (especially with unfavorable histology) and/or liver metastases carried an ominous prognosis.

Survival in bilateral metachronous (asynchronous) Wilms tumors

The survival of patients with Wilms tumors has improved dramatically during the last few decades. In contrast, the bilateral form of the disease, especially when the tumors are not concurrent, is still considered by many to hold a much worse prognosis. A review of 50 cases reported during the last 20 years reveals that the survival of patients with metachronous Wilms tumors has improved in parallel with survival of patients with unilateral disease and, when matched for extent of tumor spread, survivals for the last decade are almost identical to those of bilateral synchronous disease and unilateral Wilms tumors.

Treatment of bilateral Wilms' tumors--a 22-yr experience

A total of 157 children with Wilms' tumors were treated at the Children's Memorial Hospital during the years 1956-1978. Fourteen (or 9%) of these children had bilateral lesions. During the early years, treatment consisted of surgical excision of one kidney with radiation to the second tumor. During the second decade of this study a more aggressive approach to bilateral tumors was used consisting of nephrectomy on the side of the large tumor, with a heminephrectomy on the contralateral side and chemotherapy. More recently, we have attempted bilateral heminephrectomy when possible, together with increasingly aggressive chemotherapy. This series of patients allows us to compare the results of various treatment modalities among our own patients as well as those reported from other pediatric surgical centers.

Bilateral Wilms' tumor and secondary malignancies

A series of six patients with bilateral Wilms' tumor (nephroblastoma) is presented. Multimodal therapy yielded a survival rate of 83% at 2 yr of follow-up. However, at the end of a later follow-up period only two patients (33%) were alive. of the 4 patients who died. Only 1 died of Wilms' tumor. One died of complications of aggressive chemotherapy and two patients died after 12 and 16 yr following treatment of secondary malignant tumors arising in the irradiated region. Patients with bilateral tumor should be followed at regular intervals for the duration of life for the occurrence of secondary malignant tumors.

Renal transplantation for Wilms tumor: report of 20 cases

Renal transplantation as part of the treatment for Wilms tumor was done on 20 patients. In 80 per cent the neoplasms were bilateral. Transplantation is indicated in individuals whose renal function is severely impaired or absent because of the malignancy, treatment or both. Patients who received homografts less than a year after treatment of the tumors had a 47 per cent incidence of recurrence or metastases compared to a zero incidence of these problems in those whose transplants were delayed for longer periods. Survival for 2 years or more was obtained in 75 per cent of the recipients with unilateral neoplasms and in 38 per cent of the patients with bilateral tumors.

Simultaneous, contralateral hypernephroma and renal transitional cell carcinoma

The second case of simultaneous, contralateral hypernephroma and renal transitional cell carcinoma is described. Methods of managing bilateral renal tumors are reviewed.

Bilateral Wilms tumors

The current management of bilateral Wilms tumor is reviewed and the high incidence of concurrent anomalies with bilateral Wilms tumor is demonstrated in 4 of 5 children. Standardization of management has not been established. Of the 5 patients 3 survived 30 months to 11 years without recurrent tumor. Two had unilateral nephrectomy and partial nephrectomy, while 1 had bilateral nephrectomy and allotransplant. All survivors have had adjunctive chemotherapy and radiotherapy.

Wilms' tumor--model of a curable pediatric malignant solid tumor

Wilms' tumor is the model of the treatment of a pediatric solid tumor. Initially it appeared that multi-modality therapy, consisting of transabodominal nephrectomy, post-operative radiation therapy to the tumor bed and adjuvant, single agent chemotherapy provided the highest likelihood of disease-free survival. The identification of important prognostic factors, such as histology, tumor weight, lymph node involvement and age at diagnosis has led to a re-examination of the treatment of Wilms' tumor. Future therapeutic developments will include the administration of less therapy to some well defined groups of patients, and the exploration of new programs for patients who have been demonstrated to have a poor prognosis using currently accepted treatment techniques.

Survival in bilateral Wilms' tumor--review of 30 National Wilms' Tumor Study cases

Bilateral tumors were found in 33 patients or 5.4% of 606 children enrolled in the National Wilms' Tumor Study. Twenty six of 30 patients (87%) for whom detailed clinical information is available survived 2 yr after conservative surgery and radiation therapy. All patients were given one or more chemotherapeutic agents. A variety of surgical procedures were used including biopsy only, nephrectomy, and partial nephrectomies. Radiation therapy doses ranged widely, but between 1000 and 2000 rad apparently sufficed for local control in most cases. Recommendations regarding management by surgery, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy are given.

The present status of bilateral nephrectomy in transplant recipients

Routine use of bilateral nephrectomy in renal transplant patients has been replaced by a careful evaluation of the indications for the procedure and the increasing appreciation of the contributions of non-excretory kidneys. These contributions are identified and the indications are discussed. When bilateral nephrectomy is required the clear superiority of the bilateral simultaneous posterior approach over other techniques is documented.