The interaction of melittin with calmodulin and its tryptic fragments

Structures of calmodulin-melittin complexes show multiple binding modes lacking classical anchoring interactions

Calmodulin (CaM) is a Ca²⁺ sensor protein found in all eukaryotic cells that regulates a large number of target proteins in a Ca²⁺ concentration-dependent manner. As a transient type hub protein, it recognizes linear motifs of its targets, though for the Ca²⁺-dependent binding no consensus sequence was identified. Its complex with melittin, a major component of bee venom, is often used as a model system of protein - protein complexes. Yet, the structural aspects of the binding are not well understood, as only diverse, low-resolution data are available concerning the association. We present the crystal structure of melittin in complex with Ca²⁺-saturated calmodulins from two, evolutionarily distant species, Homo sapiens and Plasmodium falciparum representing three binding modes of the peptide. Results - augmented by molecular dynamics simulations - indicate that multiple binding modes can exist for CaM-melittin complexes, as an intrinsic characteristic of the binding. While the helical structure of melittin remains, swapping of its salt bridges and partial unfolding of its C-terminal segment can occur. In contrast to the classical way of target recognition by CaM, we found that different sets of residues can anchor at the hydrophobic pockets of CaM, which were considered as main recognition sites. Finally, the nanomolar binding affinity of the CaM-melittin complex is created by an ensemble of arrangements of similar stability - tight binding is achieved not by optimized specific interactions but by simultaneously satisfying less optimal interaction patterns in co-existing different conformers.

Myosins and DYNLL1/LC8 in the honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) brain

Honey bees have brain structures with specialized and developed systems of communication that account for memory, learning capacity and behavioral organization with a set of genes homologous to vertebrate genes. Many microtubule- and actin-based molecular motors are involved in axonal/dendritic transport. Myosin-Va is present in the honey bee Apis mellifera nervous system of the larvae and adult castes and subcastes. DYNLL1/LC8 and myosin-IIb, -VI and -IXb have also been detected in the adult brain. SNARE proteins, such as CaMKII, clathrin, syntaxin, SNAP25, munc18, synaptophysin and synaptotagmin, are also expressed in the honey bee brain. Honey bee myosin-Va displayed ATP-dependent solubility and was associated with DYNLL1/LC8 and SNARE proteins in the membrane vesicle-enriched fraction. Myosin-Va expression was also decreased after the intracerebral injection of melittin and NMDA. The immunolocalization of myosin-Va and -IV, DYNLL1/LC8, and synaptophysin in mushroom bodies, and optical and antennal lobes was compared with the brain morphology based on Neo-Timm histochemistry and revealed a distinct and punctate distribution. This result suggested that the pattern of localization is associated with neuron function. Therefore, our data indicated that the roles of myosins, DYNLL1/LC8, and SNARE proteins in the nervous and visual systems of honey bees should be further studied under different developmental, caste and behavioral conditions.

Melittin exhibits necrotic cytotoxicity in gastrointestinal cells which is attenuated by cholesterol

Melittin, a cationic antimicrobial peptide isolated from the venom of Apis mellifera, has shown potential as a permeability enhancer, transiently increasing intestinal permeability and enhancing the absorption of paracellular markers. Although it is cytotoxic to eukaryotic cells, its cytotoxicity is significantly lower in polarised epithelia compared to non-polarised cells. The aim of this study was to explore the mechanism of melittin cytotoxicity in gastrointestinal cells and to determine whether cytotoxicity was mediated by a necrotic or an apoptotic pathway. The role of cholesterol in melittin cytotoxicity was also examined. Using four distinct assays for apoptosis, phosphatidylserine translocation, caspase activation, DNA ladder formation and cell cycle analysis, no evidence of apoptotic pathway for cell death was observed with any of these approaches. It can therefore be concluded that cytotoxicity was likely to be mediated by necrosis in gastrointestinal epithelial cells. However, at low concentrations of melittin (<1 microM), BRDU uptake was enhanced, demonstrating proliferative effects of melittin at sub-lethal concentrations. Furthermore, melittin cytotoxicity was further enhanced by depletion of cholesterol, using methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, indicating that cholesterol depleting agents could be contradictory to its potential as an enhancer. Overall, although melittin appears to stimulate necrosis, with careful dosage selection the peptide could be considered for the oral delivery of poorly bioavailable drugs.

Melittin as a permeability enhancer II: in vitro investigations in human mucus secreting intestinal monolayers and rat colonic mucosae

PURPOSE

Melittin has shown potential as a non-cytotoxic absorption enhancer in Caco-2 monolayers. Our objectives were to assess in vitro efficacy and cytotoxicity of melittin in two intestinal permeability models and investigate the potential mechanism by which melittin might enhance gastrointestinal absorption.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The effects of melittin were examined in the mucus-secreting intestinal cell monolayers, HT29-MTX-E12 (E12), using transepithelial electrical resistance (TER), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and the MTT viability assay. The effects of melittin on TER, permeability and short circuit current (Isc) were also investigated in rat colon mucosae mounted in Ussing chambers. Ion transporting capacity of tissue was measured in response to secretagogues as surrogate markers of cytotoxicity. Melittin stability was examined by a means of a hemolytic assay. The mechanism by which melittin decreases TER across the rat mucosa was examined with a range of enzymatic inhibitors.

RESULTS

Apical addition of melittin resulted in a reversible non-cytotoxic concentration-dependent decrease in TER across E12 monolayers, which was independent of the presence of mucus. Apical addition of melittin reduced TER and increased the permeability of [(14)C]-mannitol across rat colonic mucosae. The melittin-induced drop in TER in rat colon was significantly attenuated by W7 suggesting partial mediation by calmodulin.

CONCLUSIONS

The rapid and reversible nature of melittin's permeation enhancing properties and its limited cytotoxicity in polarized intestinal epithelia, suggests a potential drug delivery role for the peptide in oral formulations of poorly absorbed drugs.

Hydroxyl radical probe of the calmodulin-melittin complex interface by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The calcium-dependent interaction of calmodulin and melittin is studied through the application of a radical probe approach in which solutions of the protein and peptide and protein alone are subjected to high fluxes of hydroxyl and other oxygen radicals on millisecond timescales. These radicals are generated by an electrical discharge within an electrospray ion source of a mass spectrometer. Condensation of the electrosprayed droplets followed by proteolytic digestion of both calmodulin and melittin has identified residues in both which participate in the interaction and/or are shielded from solvent within the protein complex. Consistent with other theoretical models and available experimental data, the tryptophan residue of melittin at position 19 is shown to be critical to the formation of the complex with the C-terminal domain of peptide enveloped by and protected from oxidation upon binding to the protein. Furthermore, the N-terminal domain (to residue 36) and tyrosine at position 99 in calmodulin are significantly protected from limited oxidation upon the binding of melittin while exposing the phenylalanine residue at position 92 of the flexible loop domain. The N-terminus (through residue 36) of calmodulin is shown to lie in closer proximity to the melittin helix than its C-terminal counterpart (residues 127-148) based upon the protection levels measured at reactive residues within these segments of the protein.

Topology of the calmodulin-melittin complex

The topology of the Ca2+-calmodulin-melittin ternary complex has been investigated by a combined strategy which integrates limited proteolysis and cross-linking experiments with mass spectrometric methodologies. The rationale behind the methods is that the interface regions of two interacting proteins are accessible to the solvent in the isolated molecules, whereas they become protected following the formation of the complex. Therefore, when limited proteolysis experiments are carried out on both the isolated proteins and the complex, differential peptide maps are obtained from which the interface regions can be inferred. Alternatively, cross-linking reactions performed under strictly controlled conditions lead to the identification of spatially closed amino acid residues in the complex. Mass spectrometry can be employed in both procedures for the definition of the cleavage sites and to identify covalently linked residues. Our results show that melittin interacts with calmodulin by adopting a parallel orientation, i.e. the N and C-terminal halves of the peptide are anchored to the amino and carboxy-terminal domains of the protein, respectively. This orientation is inverted with respect to all the peptide substrates examined so far. A model of the complex was designed and refined on the basis of the experimental results, supporting the above conclusions. This finding reveals a further dimension to the already remarkable capability of calmodulin in binding different protein substrates, providing this protein with the capability of regulating an even larger number of enzymes.

Specificity and symmetry in the interaction of calmodulin domains with the skeletal muscle myosin light chain kinase target sequence

The specificity of interaction of the isolated N- and C-terminal domains of calmodulin with peptide WFFp (Ac-KRRWKKNFIAVSAANRFK-amide) and variants of the target sequence of skeletal muscle myosin light chain kinase was investigated using CD and fluorescence. Titrations show that two molecules of either domain bind to 18-residue target peptides. For WFFp, the C-domain binds with 4-fold higher affinity to the native compared with the non-native site; the N-domain shows similar affinity for either site. The selectivity of the C-domain suggests that it promotes occupancy of the correct binding site for intact calmodulin on the target sequence. Far UV CD spectra show the extra helicity induced in forming the 2:1 C-domain-peptide or the 1:1:1 C-domain-N-domain-peptide complex is similar to that induced by calmodulin itself; binding of the C-domain to the Trp-4 site is essential for developing the full helicity. Calmodulin-MLCK-peptide complexes show an approximate two-fold rotational relationship between the two highly homologous domains, and the 2:1 C (or N)-domain-peptide complexes evidently have a similar rotational symmetry. This implies that a given domain can bind sequences with opposite peptide polarities, significantly increasing the possible range of conformations of calmodulin in its complexes, and extending the versatility and diversity of calmodulin-target interactions.

Anti-calmodulin potency of indol alkaloids in in vitro systems

We have demonstrated that bis-indol Vinca alkaloids of anti-mitotic activities (vinblastine, vincristine, and navelbine) bind to calmodulin in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner. We designed direct binding tests (fluorescence energy transfer and circular dichroism measurements) to quantify the interactions of bis-indol derivatives with calmodulin. The dissociation constants of calmodulin-navelbine and calmodulin-vinblastine complexes with 1:1 stoichiometry are 0.5 microM and 3 microM, respectively. These values indicate that the binding affinities of these Vinca alkaloids to calmodulin and tubulin are comparable. Immunological, enzyme kinetic and fluorescence anisotropy measurements showed that bis-indol alkaloids inhibit the interactions of calmodulin with target proteins. The results of indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay showed that bis-indol alkaloids effectively antagonize with anti-calmodulin antibody for calmodulin binding (IC50 = 90 microM, 400 microM, and 430 microM for navelbine, vincristine and vinblastine, respectively). According to the fluorescence anisotropy and enzyme kinetic measurements, vinblastine, vincristine and vinblastine, similarly to trifluoperazine, the classic calmodulin antagonist, compete with target enzyme [phosphofructokinase (ATP: D-fructose 6-phosphate 1-phosphotransferase, EC 2.7.1.11)] for an inhibitory effect either on immunocomplex formation or on calmodulin-enzyme interaction. Navelbine appeared in our tests as the most potent drug in inhibiting the association of calmodulin to target proteins in comparison to other bis-indol derivatives. Since navelbine and vinblastine possess identical vindoline moiety, although they differ in the catharantine part, the difference in anti-calmodulin potencies is suggested to reside predominantly on this portion of the molecules. These findings might establish the pharmacological importance of these activities in the specificity and toxicity of the drugs.

Distribution of distances between the tryptophan and the N-terminal residue of melittin in its complex with calmodulin, troponin C, and phospholipids

We used frequency-domain measurements of fluorescence resonance energy transfer to measure the distribution of distances between Trp-19 of melittin and a 1-dimethylamino-5-sulfonylnaphthalene (dansyl) residue on the N-terminal-alpha-amino group. Distance distributions were obtained for melittin free in solution and when complexed with calmodulin (CaM), troponin C (TnC), or palmitoyloleoyl-L-alpha-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) vesicles. A wide range of donor (Trp-19)-to-acceptor (dansyl) distances was found for free melittin, which is consistent with that expected for the random coil state, characterized by a Gaussian width (full width at half maxima) of 28.2 A. In contrast, narrow distance distributions were found for melittin complexed with CaM, 8.2 A, or with POPC vesicles, 4.9 A. A somewhat wider distribution was found for the melittin complex with TnC, 12.8 A, suggesting the presence of heterogeneity in the mode of binding between melittin and TnC. For all the complexes the mean Trp-19 to dansyl distance was near 20 A. This value is somewhat smaller than expected for the free alpha-helical state of melittin, suggesting that binding with CaM or TnC results in a modest decrease in the length of the melittin molecule.

Interaction of calmodulin with synthetic deletion peptides of melittin

The 26-residue peptide melittin present in bee venom has been shown to bind calmodulin tightly. In this study we synthesized the following series of deletion peptides of melittin by the solid-phase method: Mel12, Mel13, Mel14, Mel15, Mel15F. The results of this study show that the deletion peptides Mel14 and Mel15 have almost the same binding activity as the intact native peptide. Each deletion peptide forms a 1:1 complex with calmodulin according to electrophoresis analysis. When the tryptophanyl residue of Mel15 was replaced by the phenylalaninyl residue, the dissociation constant of the peptide-calmodulin complex increased. This shows the importance of the tryptophanyl residue for binding to calmodulin.

Effects of calmodulin antagonists on antibody binding to calmodulin. Distinct conformers of calmodulin induced by the binding of drugs

An indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay has been used to study the interactions between calmodulin and two calmodulin antagonists, trifluoperazine and a neuropeptide isolated from the hypothalamus. The binding of a monospecific anti-calmodulin antibody, raised in rabbit against dinitrophenylated calmodulin, to calmodulin was tested at various concentrations of these drugs under equilibrium conditions. Trifluoperazine at low concentrations stimulated, but at relatively high concentrations inhibited, immunocomplex formation. The neuropeptide displaced the antibody from calmodulin at nanomolar concentrations. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays were also carried out with the large tryptic fragments of calmodulin. The results suggest that (i) the C-terminal fragment binds the antibody with an affinity which is comparable with that of intact calmodulin; (ii) the neuropeptide can form complexes with both N- and C-terminal fragments, but with two orders of magnitude less activity in case of the C-terminal fragment; and (iii) trifluorperazine does not stimulate antibody binding to the C-terminal fragment. Therefore the tertiary structure of calmodulin must be intact to ensure long-distance interactions between the binding sites of trifluoperazine, the neuropeptide and the antibody. These interactions may produce distinct conformers of calmodulin which may exhibit altered potency, not only for antibody binding but also for stimulation/inhibition of target enzymes.

A mass spectrometry method for mapping the interface topography of interacting proteins, illustrated by the melittin-calmodulin system

The shielding of lysine groups from acetylation by acetic anhydride has been used to identify the regions of calmodulin in contact with melittin in the 1:1 complex. The estimation of the degree of acetylation was done by examining cyanogen bromide and cyanogen bromide/trypsin digests by mass spectrometry. Evidence was obtained that lysines-21, -75, and -148 are protected to some extent, with the implication that both the N- and C-terminal lobes and the connecting strand are involved in the interaction.

The interaction of troponin C with phosphofructokinase. Comparison with calmodulin

Phosphofructokinase (PFK) is a calmodulin (CaM)-binding protein [Mayr & Heilmeyer (1983) FEBS Lett. 195, 51-57]. We found that troponin C (TnC), which is homologous to CaM, also binds PFK and affects PFK's catalytic activity, aggregation states and conformational changes as CaM does in most cases. PFK titration of N-acetylaminoethyl-5-naphthylamido-1-sulphonate ('AEDANS')-TnC showed that its apparent dissociation constant is comparable with that of PFK-CaM. Fluorescent labels were also used to probe contact regions on TnC and CaM. It is likely that the C-terminal end of the connecting strand of the TnC molecule is close to PFK in the binary complex. Hydrophobic regions of TnC and CaM also possibly play roles in the binding and polymerization of PFK. TnC and CaM deactivate PFK through accelerating PFK conformational change as well as through accelerating PFK tetramer dissociation, as implied in the results of activity, light-scattering, fluorescence and c.d. experiments. The intact molecule of CaM appears to be required to deactivate PFK, because neither half of the CaM molecule has an effect on PFK activity.

Acyl carrier protein interacts with melittin

Acyl carrier protein (ACP) from Escherichia coli has been shown to form complexes with melittin, a cationic peptide from bee venom. ACP is a small (Mr 8847), acidic, Ca2(+)-binding protein, which possesses some characteristics resembling those of regulatory Ca2(+)-binding proteins including interaction with melittin. Complexing between melittin and ACP which occurred both in the presence and absence of Ca2+ was evident by chemical cross-linking the two peptides, fluorescence changes (including anisotropy measurements), and inhibition by melittin of the activity of a nonaggregated fatty acid synthetase from Euglena. Also, anti-Apis mellifera antibodies which contained antibodies against melittin specifically inhibited the same enzyme system activity relative to non-immune IgG.

The interaction of cyclosporin and calmodulin

The interaction of cyclosporin A and dansyl cyclosporin A with bovine and wheat germ calmodulin has been monitored by measurements of induced changes in dansyl and bound toluidinyl naphthalene sulfonate fluorescence. The interaction is Ca2(+)-dependent and 1:1. Measurements of the efficiency of radiationless energy transfer from bound dansyl cyclosporin A to an acceptor group located on Cys-27 of wheat germ calmodulin suggest that the primary binding site is not located on the N-terminal lobe (residues 1-65). However, studies with proteolytic fragments of calmodulin indicate that elements of the N-terminal half-molecule (residues 1-77) may be involved in the stabilization of the binding site. The binding of cyclosporin alters the physical properties of calmodulin and, in particular, reduces the localized rotational mobility of a fluorescent probe.

The interaction of calmodulin with the C-terminal M5 peptide of myosin light chain kinase

The interaction with calmodulin of the 17-residue C-terminal fragment M5 of myosin light chain kinase has been studied by several physical techniques. Circular dichroism measurements suggest that M5 exists within the complex primarily as an alpha-helix. Fluorescence intensity measurements of the single tryptophan of M5 (Trp-4) indicate that it is in a relatively nonpolar environment and is shielded from solvent. Dynamic measurements of fluorescence anisotropy decay indicate that Trp-4 changes from a freely rotating fluorophore to one which is largely immobilized upon complex formation. Static fluorescence measurements show that 2,6-TNS is displaced from its binding site on calmodulin by M5. The binding of M5 also partially inhibits the proteolytic scission by trypsin of the bond between residues 77 and 78.

The interaction of delta-hemolysin with calmodulin

Delta-Hemolysin forms a 1:1 complex with Ca2+ -liganded calmodulin. Probably because of the pronounced tendency of delta-hemolysin to self-associate, the apparent binding affinity is much less than that for melittin. Complex formation is reflected by an increase in quantum yield of Trp-15 of delta-hemolysin and by increased shielding from acrylamide quenching. There is, however, no indication of a change in peptide molecular ellipticity. The binding of 2-toluidinyl-naphthalene-6-sulfonate is reduced by complex formation, suggesting the involvement of a hydrophobic region. Complex formation also blocks the proteolysis by trypsin of the bond between residues 77 and 78. The time decays of fluorescence intensity and anisotropy for tryptophan are multiexponential for both free and complexed delta-hemolysin; the average decay time for intensity is substantially increased for the complex. The localized mobility of tryptophan is greatly reduced in the complex. Complex formation appears to involve both the C-terminal lobe and the connecting strand of calmodulin.

High-affinity formation of a 2:1 complex between gramicidin S and calmodulin

Two molecules of gramicidin S, a very rigid cyclic decapeptide rich in beta-sheet structure, can bind in a Ca2+-dependent way to a calmodulin molecule in the presence as well as in the absence of 4 M-urea. The flow-microcalorimetric titration of 25 microM-calmodulin with gramicidin S at 25 degrees C is endothermic for 21.3 kJ.mol-1; the enthalpy change is strictly linear up to a ratio of 2, indicating that the affinity constant for binding of the second gramicidin S is at least 10(7) M-1. In 4 M-urea the peptide quantitatively displaces seminalplasmin from calmodulin, as monitored by tryptophan fluorescence. An iterative data treatment of these competition experiments revealed strong positive co-operativity with K1 less than 5 X 10(5) M-1 and K1.K2 = 2.8 X 10(12) M-2. A competition assay with the use of immobilized melittin enabled us to monitor separately the binding of the second gramicidin S molecule: the K2 value is 1.9 X 10(7) M-1. By complementarity, the K1 value is 1.5 X 10(5) M-1. In the absence of urea the seminalplasmin displacement is incomplete: the data analysis shows optimal fitting with K1 less than 2 X 10(4) M-1 and K1.K2 = 3.2 X 10(11) M-2 and reveals that the mixed complex (calmodulin-seminalplasmin-gramicidin S) is quite stable and is even not fully displaced from calmodulin at high concentrations of gramicidin S. The activation of bovine brain phosphodiesterase by calmodulin is not impaired up to 0.2 microM-gramicidin S. According to our model the ternary complex enzyme-calmodulin-gramicidin is relatively important and displays the same activity as the binary complex enzyme-calmodulin. Gramicidin S also displaces melittin from calmodulin synergistically, as monitored by c.d. Our studies with gramicidin S reveal the importance of multipoint attachments in interactions involving calmodulin and confirm the heterotropic co-operativity in the binding of calmodulin antagonists first demonstrated by Johnson [(1983) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 112, 787-793].

Rotational modes of Ca2+-liganded calmodulin, as determined by time-domain fluorescence

The time decay of fluorescence anisotropy was monitored as a function of pH and temperature for complexes of 2,6-toluidinylnaphthalenesulfonate with calmodulin, with its proteolytic fragments, and with the 1:1 complex of calmodulin and melittin. For all the conditions examined the anisotropy decay of native calmodulin involved at least two rotational modes. These corresponded to a short correlation time of 2-3 ns, reflecting a localized motion in the vicinity of the binding site and a longer correlation time which arises from the rotation of a major portion of the molecule. The relative amplitudes of the two rotational modes were dependent upon temperature in the range 11-40 degrees C, the contribution of the more rapid mode increasing with temperature. The maximum immobilization of the probe occurred at pH 5.0 and 12 degrees C. While these results indicate the presence of internal rotations in Ca2+-liganded calmodulin, the magnitude of the longer correlation time is consistent with the crystallographic structure.

The interaction of melittin with troponin C

Melittin has been found to interact with troponin C with high affinity in the presence of Ca2+. The association constant approaches in magnitude that for melittin and calmodulin. The interaction results in a shift to lower wavelengths of the emission band of Trp-19 of melittin and in an increased shielding of Trp-19 from quenching. A major increase occurs in the alpha-helical content of combined melittin. Formation of the complex inhibits tryptic hydrolysis of the connecting strand. The properties of fluorescent labels attached to Met-25 and to AEDANS-98 are altered as a result of the interaction. It is concluded that the combined melittin makes extensive contact with the connecting strand and adjacent portions of the N- and C-terminal lobes.