Inhibition of azoreductase activity by antibodies against cytochromes P-450 and P-448

Genotoxic hazards of azo pigments and other colorants related to 1-phenylazo-2-hydroxynaphthalene

Azo pigments are used extensively as coloring agents in inks, paints and cosmetics. We have surveyed the literature for genotoxic and cancer data on nine colorants, which are structurally related to 1-phenylazo-2-hydroxynaphthalene (C.I. Solvent yellow 14). C.I. Solvent yellow 14 is metabolized by oxidative and peroxidative enzymes. Metabolically activated C.I. Solvent yellow 14 forms both RNA and DNA adducts. It induces liver nodules in rats upon oral administration. Although there is a mixture of negative and positive findings in short-term tests and in animal cancer studies, C.I. Solvent yellow 14 should be considered genotoxic. C.I. Pigment red 3 should be considered carcinogenic but is only weakly genotoxic. C.I. Solvent yellow 7, C.I. Pigment orange 5, C.I. Pigment red 4, and C.I. Pigment red 23 should be considered genotoxic. C.I. Pigment red 53:1 is not genotoxic, and observations of spleen tumors in male rats but not in female rats or mice seem to be related to toxic effects of high doses of C.I. Pigment red 53:1 in this organ. The data in the literature indicate that Pigment red 57:1 is not genotoxic or carcinogenic. We did not find sufficient data for a relevant evaluation of C.I. Pigment red 2 and C.I. Pigment red 64:1. Some of the colorants have in common the 2-amino-1-naphthol structure. This compound is not genotoxic. On the other hand, reductive cleavage of the azo bonds or hydrolysis of anilido bonds would produce aromatic amines, most of which have been under suspicion for genotoxicity or carcinogenicity. For C.I. Pigment red 53:1 and 57:1, sulphonated aromatic amines would be formed that are not genotoxic.

The mechanism of microsomal azoreduction: predictions based on electronic aspects of structure-activity relationships

The mechanism of microsomal azoreductase is regulated by the overall Hammett sigma substituent values on each ring. A substrate dye must exhibit an overall Hammett sigma substituent value either equal or more negative than -0.37 on either ring. Dyes with Hammett sigma substituent constants less negative than -0.37 will not be reduced by microsomal cytochrome P450. Microsomal reduction of azo dyes containing only electron-donating substituents on either ring is insensitive to both oxygen and carbon monoxide. The required Hammett sigma substituent value on the opposite benzene (prime) ring for I-substrates is therefore, sigma' P < or = 0. Reduction of azo dyes containing electron-withdrawing group on opposite (prime) is sensitive to both oxygen and carbon monoxide. The required Hammett sigma substituent value on the opposite benzene (prime) ring for S-substrates is, consequently, sigma' P > 0 (Table 3). Redox Potentials. Anaerobic cyclic voltammograms of azobenzene derivatives verify the following points: A nonsubstrate azo dye will not exhibit a positive potential. (Several nonsubstrate hydrazobenzenes exhibited positive potentials, but in a low range 0.41-0.48 V. Consequently, cyclic voltammetry can distinguish between nonsubstrate azobenzenes and their nonsubstrate half-reduced hydrazo analogs.) A substrate azo dye will exhibit a positive potential in the range +1.00 to +1.50 V. I-substrate: Both negative potentials are stable in air. S-substrate: The first negative potential will immediately quench upon exposure to air. I-substrates exhibit on average potentials which are approximately 0.6 V more negative than those for S-substrates. A comparison between the oxidative and the reductive pathway of microsomal cytochrome P450 indicates a similarity in the first two steps in the reaction cycle, for example, substrate binding and uptake of the first electron by the cytochrome [76, 109, 110]. Upon reduction of the iron, ferrous cytochrome P450 may bind oxygen or carbon monoxide in a competitive manner in the oxidative cycle or may directly transfer the electrons to the substrate in a stepwise fashion in the reductive cycle [76]. Estabrook et al. [111] suggested that carbon monoxide insensitivity can occur when the formation of ferrous cytochrome P450 substrate complex is rate limiting for the overall reaction. Structure-activity relationships of azo compounds depend on (1) the electron transport component and (2) the oxidation-reduction potential of the dye, which determines its ability to accept electrons from cytochrome P-450. Nesnow et al. examined a group of 36 aryl azo dyes for their ability to be reduced by rat liver microsomal azoreductase.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Multiple mechanisms in hepatic microsomal azoreduction

1. Microsomal reduction of azo dyes related to dimethylaminoazobenzene (DAB) is catalysed by at least two types of cytochrome P-450. The first is selectively induced by clofibrate. The second is induced by phenobarbital, beta-naphthoflavone, isosafrole, and pregnenolone-16 alpha-carbonitrile, as well as clofibrate. 2. Azoreduction by the first type of P-450 is insensitive to both O2 and CO and involves dyes with only electron-donating substituents (I substrates). 3. Azoreduction by the second type of P-450 is inhibited by both O2 and CO and involves dyes with electron-withdrawing as well as donating substituents (S substrates). 4. All azo dye substrates exhibit two negative and one positive redox potential, as measured anaerobically by cyclic voltammetry. The negative potentials reflect one- and two-electron reductions while the positive potential permits electron transfer from microsomal P-450, the redox potential for which is reported to be negative (approximately 0.35 V). The positive potential is associated with a polar electron-donating group para to the azo linkage, which is an absolute requirement for microsomal reduction. Dyes without this functional group do not exhibit positive potentials and are not reduced. 5. The first negative potential of S substrates is quenched upon admitting air to the system, whereas this potential is unaffected in I substrates. The relative stability of the one-electron reduced state may be an explanation for the differential O2 sensitivity of I and S substrate reduction.

NADPH-dependent reduction of amaranch in liver microsomes characterized the quantity of low spin forms of cytochrome P-450

We confirmed that NADPH-dependent anaerobic amaranch reduction in rat liver microsomes is compatible with the interaction of the dye with Fe(III) heme of cytochrome P-450 as the type II substrate. This process is rate-limiting in the whole reaction. High positive correlation (r = 0.949) between the values of Vmax for reaction of NADPH-dependent anaerobic amaranch reduction and the relative content low spin forms of cytochrome P-450 determined by ESR in microsomes from liver of control and induced by PB, BP, IS and 4-MP rats was observed. Relative content of low spin forms of cytochrome P-450 determined by ESR was increased according to BP less than PB less than control less than IS approximately 4-MP; Vmax values increased according to BP less than PB less than control less than IS less than 4-MP. Thus, reaction of NADPH-dependent anaerobic amaranch reduction may be used for determination of low spin forms of cytochrome P-450 at physiological conditions.

Metabolism of azo dyes: implication for detoxication and activation

Azo dyes are consumed and otherwise utilized in varying quantities in many parts of the world. Such widely used chemicals are of great concern with regard to their potential toxicity and carcinogenic properties. Their metabolism has been studied extensively and is significant for detoxication and metabolic activation. Both oxidative and reductive pathways are involved in these processes. The majority of azo dyes undergo reduction catalyzed by enzymes of the intestinal microorganisms and/or hepatic enzymes including microsomal and soluble enzymes. The selectivity of substrate and enzyme may to a large extent be determined by the oxygen sensitivity of reduction since a normal liver is mainly aerobic in all areas, whereas the microorganisms of the lower bowel exist in an anaerobic environment. However, it should be pointed out that the pO2 of centrilobular cells within the liver is only a fraction that of air, where pO2 = 150 torr. Therefore, an azo dye reduction experiment performed aerobically may not be an accurate predictor of reductive metabolism in all areas of the liver. Many of the azo dyes in common use today have highly charged substituents such as sulfonate. These resist enzymic attack and for the most part are poorly absorbed from the intestinal tract, providing poor access to the liver, the major site of the mixed-function oxidase system. Lipophilic dyes, such as DAB, which are often carcinogenic, readily access oxidative enzymes and are activated by both mixed-function oxidase and conjugating systems. Reduction of the carcinogenic dyes usually leads to loss of carcinogenic activity. By contrast, most of the highly charged water-soluble dyes become mutagenic only after reduction. Even then, most of the fully reduced amines required oxidative metabolic activation. An outstanding example is the potent human bladder carcinogen benzidine, which derives from the reduction of several azo dyes. Many problems regarding mutagenic and carcinogenic activation remain to be solved. At the present time, it is apparent that both oxidative and reductive pathways yield toxic products. Toxicologic assessment of azo dyes must consider all pathways and particularly the oxygen sensitivity of azoreduction. This is critical in the treatment of waste from chemical plants where there is a great need for soil bacteria which catalyze reduction aerobically. Consideration of secondary pathways are also of great concern. For example, azoreduction of carcinogenic dyes such as DAB removes carcinogenic activity although oxidative metabolism of the primary amines yield mutagenic products. Such apparent dilemmas must be dealt with when considering metabolism/toxicity relationships for azo dyes.

Characteristics of two classes of azo dye reductase activity associated with rat liver microsomal cytochrome P450

Azo dyes are reduced to primary amines by the microsomal enzymes NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase and cytochrome P450. Amaranth, a highly polar dye, is reduced almost exclusively by rat liver microsomal cytochrome P450 and the reaction is inhibited almost totally by oxygen or CO. Activity is induced by pretreatment with phenobarbital or 3-methylcholanthrene. In contrast, microsomal reduction of the hepatocarcinogen dimethylaminoazobenzene (DAB), a lipid soluble, weakly polar compound, is insensitive to both oxygen and CO. However, reconstitution of activity with purified NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase and a partially purified cytochrome P450 preparation indicates that activity is catalyzed almost exclusively by cytochrome P450. Activity is induced by clofibrate but not phenobarbital, beta-naphthoflavone, 3-methylcholanthrene, isosafrol, or pregnenolone-16 alpha-carbonitrile. These observations suggest the existence of at least two classes of azoreductase activity catalyzed by cytochrome P450. To investigate this possibility, the reduction of a number of azo dyes was investigated using microsomal and partially purified systems and the characteristics of the reactions were observed. Microsomal reduction of azo dyes structurally related to DAB required a polar electron-donating substituent on one ring. Activity was insensitive to oxygen and CO if the substrates had no additional substituents on either ring or contained only electron-donating substituents. Introduction of an electron-withdrawing group into the prime ring conferred oxygen and CO sensitivity on the reaction. Substrates in the former group are referred to as insensitive and substrates in the latter group as sensitive. Inhibitors of cytochrome P450 activity depressed reduction of both insensitive and sensitive substrates. In a fully reconstituted system containing lipid, highly purified NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase and a partially purified cytochrome P450 preparation, rates of reduction of various insensitive substrates varied several-fold, whereas rates of reduction of sensitive substrates varied by three orders of magnitude. Using purified enzymes, each of the insensitive substrates was shown to be reduced by reductase alone, but only at a fraction of the rate seen in the fully reconstituted system, implying that reducing electrons were transferred to the dyes mainly from cytochrome P450. Conversely, there was substantial, in some cases almost exclusive, reduction of sensitive substrates by purified reductase alone and almost no inhibition by CO. Their reduction, however, was inhibited by CO in microsomal systems.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Studies on the mechanism of reduction of azo dye carcinogens by rat liver microsomal cytochrome P-450

This laboratory has described the azoreduction of p-dimethylaminoazobenzene (1c) by rat liver microsomal cytochrome P-450. To elucidate the mechanisms involved, the reduction of structurally related azobenzenes by hepatic microsomes was investigated. High substrate reactivity was observed for 1c, its corresponding secondary (1a) and primary (1b) amines and p-hydroxyazobenzene (1d). In contrast, only negligible rates were obtained for unsubstituted azobenzene (1g), hydrazobenzene (2g), p-isopropylazobenzene (1e) and 1f, the benzoylamide derivative of 1b. These results clearly indicate that electron-donating groups, such as hydroxyl or primary, secondary and tertiary amines, are essential for binding of azo dye carcinogens to liver microsomal cytochrome P-450 and, by implication, their enzymic reduction. No inhibition of azoreduction of 1c or 1d was obtained by addition of 1e, 1g, or 2g to the reaction mixture. In the presence of hepatic microsomes, a type I binding spectrum was obtained for 1d and type II binding spectra for 1a, 1b and 1c, the reactive azo dyes. In contrast, very weak binding was observed for the unreactive compounds 1e, 1f, 1g and 2g. Thus, there is good correlation between binding and substrate reactivity. The apparent lack of binding may explain the inability of the non-reactive compounds to inhibit azoreduction. The difference in the reduction rate observed for 1g vs. 1d suggested that hydroxylation would facilitate the reduction of an otherwise non-reactive azo dye. Support for such a mechanism was obtained in two experiments. In the first, marked facilitation of azoreduction of both the inactive compounds, 2g and 2f, was seen when they were incubated with microsomes under aerobic conditions where preliminary hydroxylation can occur. In the second, azobenzene was initially incubated aerobically with microsomes from phenobarbital- or beta-naphthoflavone-induced rats. The hydroxyazobenzene formed was then readily reduced anaerobically by microsomes from untreated rats.

A CASE-SAR study of mammalian hepatic azoreduction

A group of 36 aryl azo dyes were examined for their ability to be reduced by rat liver microsomal azoreductase. This group of azo dyes featured a variety of substituents, including sulfonic acid, phenol, nitro, amide, and methyl functionalities on phenyl, alpha-naphthyl, and beta-naphthyl rings. Reduction rates for each dye were obtained using a spectrophotometric method and anaerobic incubation conditions. These rates ranged from 0 to 7.35 nmol dye reduced/min.mg protein. The reduction rates and dye structures provided the data for a CASE-SAR (computer automated structure evaluation-structure-activity relationship) fragment analysis, and three major structure fragments associated with the ability of this group of azo dyes to be reduced were identified. The three CASE fragments correctly label 92% of the azo dye structures as active or inactive and may be useful in future predictions of the ability of azo dyes to undergo reduction by rat liver azoreductase.

Studies on microsomal azoreduction. N,N-dimethyl-4-aminoazobenzene (DAB) and its derivatives

The azoreduction of N,N-dimethyl-4-aminoazobenzene (DAB) and N-methyl-4-amino-azobenzene (MAB) by rat liver microsomes was investigated. It was shown that measurement of azoreduction of DAB and structurally related azo dyes by the conventional method of substrate disappearance required an anaerobic environment since N-demethylated and ring-hydroxylated metabolites formed aerobically interfered with the assay system, producing quantitatively inaccurate results. Oxygen partially, but not totally, inhibited azoreduction of DAB. Glutathione (GSH) inhibited the azoreduction of DAB but stimulated the azoreduction of MAB. Dithiothreitol also stimulated azoreduction of MAB but had little effect on azoreduction of DAB. Para-hydroxymercuribenzoate (PHMB) and N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) blocked titratable microsomal thiol groups and inhibited azoreduction of MAB. However, the inhibitory action of NEM was weak with DAB azoreduction although PHMB was a potent inhibitor. These findings suggest that microsomal azoreduction of DAB and MAB may proceed via different mechanisms, possibly through different species of cytochrome P-450 which have selective dependence upon the sulfhydryl environment.

Solubilisation, purification and reconstitution of hepatic microsomal azoreductase activity

Microsomal NADPH-cytochrome c (P-450) reductase and cytochrome P-450 were purified from the livers of phenobarbitone-treated rats. Purified NADPH-cytochrome c (P-450) reductase effected the NADPH-dependent reduction of FMN and FAD under anaerobic conditions in a non-enzymic manner, but was unable to reduce directly the azo dye, amaranth. In the presence of FMN, the purified reductase effected reduction of amaranth through the production of reduced FMN. Incorporation of NADPH-cytochrome c (P-450) reductase into the microsomal fraction increased the azoreductase activity of liver preparations from phenobarbitone-treated rats, but had no effect on azoreductase activity in preparations from control animals. Azoreductase activity was reconstituted into dilauroyl phosphatidylcholine vesicles containing purified cytochrome P-450 and purified NADPH-cytochrome c (P-450) reductase. In the absence of supplementary FMN, amaranth reduction was completely dependent upon all three components, but in the presence of FMN, the omission of any one component failed to abolish completely azoreductase activity.

The stimulation of microsomal azoreduction by flavins

The reduction of the azo dye, amaranth, by rat liver microsomes is inhibited about 90% by carbon monoxide, suggesting that the reaction largely depends on cytochrome P-450. Reducing equivalents for this reaction are supplied by NADPH. This reaction is stimulated by riboflavin, FMN and FAD, as well as by methylviologen. A large fraction of the stimulated reaction is not blocked by CO, indicating that there is a pathway of electron transfer which is independent of cytochrome P-450. Rat liver microsomes can reduce FAD, with reducing equivalents supplied by NADPH. The FADH2 thus produced is quickly oxidized by amaranth so that two FADH2 are oxidized for every amaranth reduced. The same stoichiometry is observed with photochemically prepared FADH2, formed in the absence of microsomes.