Probing the higher order structure of RNA with peroxonitrous acid

Double methylation of tRNA-U54 to 2'-O-methylthymidine (Tm) synergistically decreases immune response by Toll-like receptor 7

Sensing of nucleic acids for molecular discrimination between self and non-self is a challenging task for the innate immune system. RNA acts as a potent stimulus for pattern recognition receptors including in particular human Toll-like receptor 7 (TLR7). Certain RNA modifications limit potentially harmful self-recognition of endogenous RNA. Previous studies had identified the 2′-O-methylation of guanosine 18 (Gm18) within tRNAs as an antagonist of TLR7 leading to an impaired immune response. However, human tRNA^Lys₃ was non-stimulatory despite lacking Gm18. To identify the underlying molecular principle, interferon responses of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells to differentially modified tRNA^Lys₃ were determined. The investigation of synthetic modivariants allowed attributing a significant part of the immunosilencing effect to the 2′-O-methylthymidine (m⁵Um) modification at position 54. The effect was contingent upon the synergistic presence of both methyl groups at positions C5 and 2’O, as shown by the fact that neither Um54 nor m⁵U54 produced any effect alone. Testing permutations of the nucleobase at ribose-methylated position 54 suggested that the extent of silencing and antagonism of the TLR7 response was governed by hydrogen patterns and lipophilic interactions of the nucleobase. The results identify a new immune-modulatory endogenous RNA modification that limits TLR7 activation by RNA.

The evolution of RNA structural probing methods: From gels to next-generation sequencing

RNA molecules are important players in all domains of life and the study of the relationship between their multiple flexible states and the associated biological roles has increased in recent years. For several decades, chemical and enzymatic structural probing experiments have been used to determine RNA structure. During this time, there has been a steady improvement in probing reagents and experimental methods, and today the structural biologist community has a large range of tools at its disposal to probe the secondary structure of RNAs in vitro and in cells. Early experiments used radioactive labeling and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis as read-out methods. This was superseded by capillary electrophoresis, and more recently by next-generation sequencing. Today, powerful structural probing methods can characterize RNA structure on a genome-wide scale. In this review, we will provide an overview of RNA structural probing methodologies from a historical and technical perspective. This article is categorized under: RNA Structure and Dynamics > RNA Structure, Dynamics, and Chemistry RNA Methods > RNA Analyses in vitro and In Silico RNA Methods > RNA Analyses in Cells.

Covalent labeling-mass spectrometry with non-specific reagents for studying protein structure and interactions

Using mass spectrometry (MS) to obtain information about a higher order structure of protein requires that a protein's structural properties are encoded into the mass of that protein. Covalent labeling (CL) with reagents that can irreversibly modify solvent accessible amino acid side chains is an effective way to encode structural information into the mass of a protein, as this information can be read-out in a straightforward manner using standard MS-based proteomics techniques. The differential reactivity of proteins under two or more conditions can be used to distinguish protein topologies, conformations, and/or binding sites. CL-MS methods have been effectively used for the structural analysis of proteins and protein complexes, particularly for systems that are difficult to study by other more traditional biochemical techniques. This review provides an overview of the non-specific CL approaches that have been combined with MS with a particular emphasis on the reagents that are commonly used, including hydroxyl radicals, carbenes, and diethylpyrocarbonate. We describe the reagent and protein factors that affect the reactivity of amino acid side chains. We also include details about experimental design and workflow, data analysis, recent applications, and some future prospects of CL-MS methods.

Nucleotide Sugar Pucker Preference Mitigates Excision by HIV-1 RT

A series of DNA primers containing nucleotides with various sugar pucker conformations at the 3'-terminus were chemically synthesized by solid-phase synthesis. The ability of wild-type (WT) HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) and AZT-resistant (AZTr) RT to excise the 3'-terminal nucleotide was assessed. Nucleosides with a preference for the North conformation were more refractory to excision by both WT-RT and AZTr-RT. We found that DNA primers that contain North puckered-nucleotides at the 3'-terminus can also affect the translocation status of the RT/template/primer complex, which provides an underlying mechanism to avoid being excised. Together, these results point to a correlation between the sugar conformation of the 3'-terminal nucleotide, the precise position of HIV-1 RT on its nucleic acid substrate, and, in turn, its catalytic function. Nucleotide sugar conformation is therefore an important parameter in defining the susceptibility to RT-catalyzed phosphorolytic excision.

tRNA structural and functional changes induced by oxidative stress

Oxidatively damaged biomolecules impair cellular functions and contribute to the pathology of a variety of diseases. RNA is also attacked by reactive oxygen species, and oxidized RNA is increasingly recognized as an important contributor to neurodegenerative complications in humans. Recently, evidence has accumulated supporting the notion that tRNA is involved in cellular responses to various stress conditions. This review focuses on the intriguing consequences of oxidative modification of tRNA at the structural and functional level.

Use of specific chemical reagents for detection of modified nucleotides in RNA

Naturally occurring cellular RNAs contain an impressive number of chemically distinct modified residues which appear posttranscriptionally, as a result of specific action of the corresponding RNA modification enzymes. Over 100 different chemical modifications have been identified and characterized up to now. Identification of the chemical nature and exact position of these modifications is typically based on 2D-TLC analysis of nucleotide digests, on HPLC coupled with mass spectrometry, or on the use of primer extension by reverse transcriptase. However, many modified nucleotides are silent in reverse transcription, since the presence of additional chemical groups frequently does not change base-pairing properties. In this paper, we give a summary of various chemical approaches exploiting the specific reactivity of modified nucleotides in RNA for their detection.

Real-time dynamics of ribosome-ligand interaction by time-resolved chemical probing methods

Three protocols to perform time-resolved in situ probing of rRNA are described. The three methods (chemical modification with DMS and rRNA backbone cleavage by hydroxyl radicals generated by either K-peroxonitrite or Fe(II)-EDTA) make use of a quench-flow apparatus and exploit reactions that are faster than the interactions of ribosomal subunits with their ligands. These methods allow the investigation of the path and dynamics, in a approximately equal 50 to 1500ms time range, of the binding and dissociation of ribosomal ligands.

The real-time path of translation factor IF3 onto and off the ribosome

Translation initiation factor IF3 is an essential bacterial protein, consisting of two domains (IF3C and IF3N) separated by a linker, which interferes with ribosomal subunit association, promotes codon-anticodon interaction in the P site, and ensures translation initiation fidelity. Using time-resolved chemical probing, we followed the dynamic binding path of IF3 on the 30S subunit and its release upon 30S-50S association. During binding, IF3 first contacts the platform (near G700) of the 30S subunit with the C domain and then the P-decoding region (near A790) with its N domain. At equilibrium, attained within less than a second, both sites are protected, but before reaching binding equilibrium, IF3 causes additional transient perturbations of both the platform edge and the solvent side of the subunit. Upon 30S-50S association, IF3 dissociates concomitantly with the establishment of the 30S-50S bridges, following the reverse path of its binding with the IF3N-A790 interaction being lost before the IF3C-G700 interaction.

Site-specific footprinting reveals differences in the translocation status of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase. Implications for polymerase translocation and drug resistance

Resistance to nucleoside analogue inhibitors of the reverse transcriptase of the HIV-1 often involves phosphorolytic excision of the incorporated chain terminator. Previous crystallographic and modeling studies suggested that this reaction could only occur when the enzyme resides in a pre-translocational stage. Here we studied mechanisms of polymerase translocation using novel site-specific footprinting techniques. Classical footprinting approaches, based on the detection of protected nucleic acid residues, are not sensitive enough to visualize subtle structural differences at single nucleotide resolution. Thus, we developed chemical footprinting techniques that give rise to hyperreactive cleavage on the template strand mediated through specific contacts with the enzyme. Two specific cuts served as markers that defined the position of the polymerase and RNase H domain, respectively. We show that the presence of the next correct dNTP, following the incorporated chain terminator, caused a shift in the position of the two cuts a single nucleotide further downstream. The footprints point to monotonic sliding motions and provide compelling evidence for the existence of an equilibrium between pre- and post-translocational stages. Our data show that enzyme translocation is reversible and uncoupled from nucleotide incorporation and the release of pyrophosphate. This translocational equilibrium ensures access to the pre-translocational stage after incorporation of the chain terminator. The efficiency of excision correlates with an increase in the population of complexes that exist in the pre-translocational stage, and we show that the latter configuration is preferred with an enzyme that contains mutations associated with resistance to nucleoside analogue inhibitors.

Rapid formation of a solvent-inaccessible core in the Neurospora Varkud satellite ribozyme

We have used hydroxyl radicals generated by decomposition of peroxynitrous acid to study Mg(2+)-dependent structure and folding of the Varkud satellite (VS) ribozyme. Protection from radical cleavage shows the existence of a solvent-inaccessible core, which includes nucleotides near two three-helix junctions, the kissing interaction between stem-loops I and V and other nucleotides, most of which have also been implicated as important for folding or activity. Kinetic folding experiments showed that the ribozyme folds very quickly, with the observed protections completely formed within 2 s of addition of MgCl(2). In mutants that disrupt the kissing interaction or entirely remove stem-loop I, which contains the cleavage site, nucleotides in the three-helix junctions and a subset of those elsewhere remain protected. Unlike smaller ribozymes, the VS ribozyme retains a significant amount of structure in the absence of its substrate. Protections that depend on proper interaction between the substrate and the rest ribozyme map to a region previously proposed as the active site of the ribozyme and along both sides of helix II, identifying candidate sites of docking for the substrate helix.

Visualizing the solvent-inaccessible core of a group II intron ribozyme

Group II introns are well recognized for their remarkable catalytic capabilities, but little is known about their three-dimensional structures. In order to obtain a global view of an active enzyme, hydroxyl radical cleavage was used to define the solvent accessibility along the backbone of a ribozyme derived from group II intron ai5gamma. These studies show that a highly homogeneous ribozyme population folds into a catalytically compact structure with an extensively internalized catalytic core. In parallel, a model of the intron core was built based on known tertiary contacts. Although constructed independently of the footprinting data, the model implicates the same elements for involvement in the catalytic core of the intron.

Characterization of the Tetrahymena ribozyme folding pathway using the kinetic footprinting reagent peroxynitrous acid

Large RNAs fold into complex structures which determine their biological activities. A full understanding of both RNA structure and dynamics will include the description of the pathways by which these structures are formed. Kinetic footprinting [Sclavi, B., et al. (1997) J. Mol. Biol. 266, 144-159] has been shown to be a powerful method for the study of dynamic processes involving RNA. Here we describe the use of a readily available reagent, peroxynitrous acid, as a kinetic footprinting tool for the study of RNA folding. Hydroxyl radicals generated from this reagent were used to footprint the Tetrahymena ribozyme during its magnesium-dependent folding-in agreement with synchroton X-ray footprinting [Sclavi, B., et al. (1998) Science 279, 1940-1943] and oligonucleotide/hybridization cleavage experiments [Zarrinkar, P. P., and Williamson, J. R. (1994) Science 265, 918-924], this work suggests an ordered, hierarchical folding pathway for the ribozyme. Several slow steps in the folding pathway were observed in the peroxynitrous acid footprinting, but none of these corresponded to the rate-determining step of folding. This suggests that the formation of the global, protected structure is followed by one or more slow local rearrangements to yield the final active structure. These studies illustrate the utility of peroxynitrous acid as a reagent for the elucidation of RNA folding pathways and the study of RNA dynamics.

Temporal coordination between initiation of HIV (+)-strand DNA synthesis and primer removal

In this study, we have analyzed the interdependence between the polymerase and RNase H active sites of human immunodeficiency virus-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) using an in vitro system that closely mimics the initiation of (+)-strand DNA synthesis. Time course experiments show that RT pauses after addition of the 12th DNA residue, and at this stage the RNase H activity starts to cleave the RNA primer from newly synthesized DNA. Comparison of cleavage profiles obtained with 3'- and 5'-end-labeled primer strands indicates that RT now translocates in the opposite direction, i.e. in the 5' direction of the RNA strand. DNA synthesis resumes again in the 3' direction, after the RNA-DNA junction was efficiently cleaved. Moreover, we further characterized complexes generated before, during, and after position +12, by treating these with Fe2+ to localize the RNase H active site on the DNA template. Initially, when RT binds the RNA/DNA substrate, oxidative strand breaks were seen at a distance of 18 base pairs upstream from the primer terminus, whereas 17 base pairs were observed at later stages when the enzyme binds more and more DNA/DNA. These data show that the initiation of (+)-strand synthesis is accompanied by a conformational change of the polymerase-competent complex.

Following the folding of RNA with time-resolved synchrotron X-ray footprinting

The rapid mixing synchrotron X-ray footprinting technique described in this article allows nucleic acid folding and ligand binding reactions to be followed on a millisecond time resolution with single nucleotide resolution. In principle, the change in .OH protection of every nucleotide in a nucleic acid hundreds of nucleotides long can be monitored separately. In addition, a wide range of solution conditions are compatible with the radiolytic generation of .OH. These characteristics of synchrotron X-ray footprinting create opportunities for conducting thermodynamic and kinetic studies of nucleic acids that are both comprehensive and detailed. Kinetic footprinting studies of a number of systems have been initiated by the Center for Synchrotron Biosciences using this technique.

Localization of the active site of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase-associated RNase H domain on a DNA template using site-specific generated hydroxyl radicals

Reverse transcriptase (RT)-associated ribonuclease H (RNase H) can cleave both the RNA template of DNA/RNA hybrids as well as double-stranded (ds) RNA. This report shows that human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-RT can also cleave the template strand of dsDNA when Mg2+ is replaced by Fe2+ in the RNase H active site of HIV-RT. The cleavage mechanisms as well as the positions of the cut vary depending on whether RNA or DNA is used. While DNA is cleaved 17 base positions upstream of the primer 3'-end, RNA is cleaved 18 base positions upstream. Competition experiments show that Fe2+ replaces the catalytically active Mg2+ of RT-associated RNase H. The bound Fe2+ is the source of locally generated OH-radicals that cleave the most proximate base in the DNA. Electrophoretic mobility studies of the cleaved fragments suggest that DNA is cleaved by an oxidative mechanism, while RNA is cleaved by an enzymatic mechanism which is indistinguishable from the Mg2+-dependent cleavage. The Fe2+-dependent cuts can be used to trace the active site of RT-associated RNase H on dsDNA as well as on dsRNA and DNA/RNA hybrids. The observed 1 base difference in the cleavage positions on DNA and RNA templates can be attributed to conformational differences of the bound nucleic acids. We suggest that the lower pitch of dsRNA and DNA/RNA hybrids compared with dsDNA permits accommodation of an additional base pair in the region between the primer 3'-end and the Fe2+-dependent cleavage position at the RNase H active site.

Influence of Mg2+ and temperature on formation of the transcription bubble

The transcription bubble formed in the binding complex of T7A1 promoter upon Escherichia coli RNA polymerase was analyzed by chemical probes, namely by single-strand specific reagents, to map the unpaired bases in the bubble, and by FeEDTA, to analyze the accessibility of the DNA backbone. The latter probe could also be used as a local hydroxyl radical probe placed close to the Mg2+-binding site in the active center. The data show that the transcription bubble consists of two parts, an Mg2+-dependent part and an Mg2+-independent part, both having individual transition temperatures. The data further suggest that formation of a transcription active open complex is preceded by a transition state complex having enhanced affinity for those Mg2+ ions presumably participating in the formation of the catalytic site. Our data also suggests that the three catalytically active Mg2+ ions in RNA polymerase are functionally not equivalent. One/two of the three Mg2+ ions are responsible for the polymerization, the other two/one for enlargement of the transcription bubble.