What determines the size of phospholipid vesicles made by detergent-removal techniques?

Measuring Lipid Transfer Protein Activity Using Bicelle-Dilution Model Membranes

In vitro assessment of lipid intermembrane transfer activity by cellular proteins typically involves measurement of either radiolabeled or fluorescently labeled lipid trafficking between vesicle model membranes. Use of bilayer vesicles in lipid transfer assays usually comes with inherent challenges because of complexities associated with the preparation of vesicles and their rather short "shelf life". Such issues necessitate the laborious task of fresh vesicle preparation to achieve lipid transfer assays of high quality, precision, and reproducibility. To overcome these limitations, we have assessed model membrane generation by bicelle dilution for monitoring the transfer rates and specificity of various BODIPY-labeled sphingolipids by different glycolipid transfer protein (GLTP) superfamily members using a sensitive fluorescence resonance energy transfer approach. Robust, protein-selective sphingolipid transfer is observed using donor and acceptor model membranes generated by dilution of 0.5 q-value mixtures. The sphingolipid transfer rates are comparable to those observed between small bilayer vesicles produced by sonication or ethanol injection. Among the notable advantages of using bicelle-generated model membranes are (i) easy and straightforward preparation by means that avoid lipid fluorophore degradation and (ii) long "shelf life" after production (≥6 days) and resilience to freeze-thaw storage. The bicelle-dilution-based assay is sufficiently robust, sensitive, and stable for application, not only to purified LTPs but also for LTP activity detection in crude cytosolic fractions of cell homogenates.

Comprehensive Study of the Self-Assembly of Phospholipid Nanodiscs: What Determines Their Shape and Stoichiometry?

Phospholipid nanodiscs have quickly become a widely used platform for studies of membrane proteins. However, the molecular self-assembly process that ultimately should place a membrane protein inside a nanodisc is not well understood. This poses a challenge for a successful high-yield reconstitution of general membrane proteins into nanodiscs. In the present work, the self-assembly process of POPC-MSP1D1 nanodiscs was carefully investigated by systematically modulating the reconstitution parameters and probing the effect with a small-angle X-ray scattering analysis of the resulting nanodiscs. First, it was established that nanodiscs prepared using the standard protocol followed a narrow but significant size distribution and that the formed nanodiscs were stable at room temperature over a time range of about a week. Systematic variation of the POPC/MSP1D1 stoichiometry of the reconstitution mixture showed that a ratio of less than 75:1 resulted in lipid-poor nanodiscs, whereas ratios of 75:1 and larger resulted in nanodiscs with constant POPC/MSP1D1 ratios of 60:1. A central step in the self-assembly process consists in adding detergent-absorbing resin beads to the reconstitution mixture to remove the reconstitution detergent. Surprisingly, it was found that this step did not play a significant role for the shape and stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs. Finally, the effect of the choice of detergent used in the reconstitution process was investigated. It was found that detergent type is a central determining factor for the shape and stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs. A significantly increasing POPC/MSP1D1 stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs was observed as the reconstitution detergent type is changed in the order: Tween80, DDM, Triton X-100, OG, CHAPS, Tween20, and Cholate, but with no simple correlation to the characteristics of the detergent. This emphasizes that the detergents optimal for solution storage and crystallization of membrane proteins, in particular DDM, should not be used alone for nanodisc reconstitution. However, our data also show that when applying mixtures of the reconstitution detergent cholate and the storage detergents DDM or OG, cholate dominates the reconstitution process and nanodiscs are obtained, which resemble those formed without storage detergents.

Detergent-aided polymersome preparation

Until now, most preparative methods used to form polymeric vesicles involve either organic cosolvents or sonication. In this communication, we demonstrate for the first time a detergent-aided method to produce polymersomes. Peptidic polymersomes were formed from the rod-rod block copolymer PBLG(36)-E, where PBLG is hydrophobic poly(gamma-benzyl l-glutamate) and E is a hydrophilic designed peptide. The block copolymer was first solubilized by detergent micelles in aqueous buffer, after which the concentration of detergent was reduced by dilution, transforming the particle morphology in solution from mixed micelles to polymersomes. The polymersome formation was monitored with dynamic light scattering and confirmed with transmission electron microscopy. Polymersomes with average diameters of approximately 300 nm were obtained as well as discs with average diameters of approximately 100 nm. This detergent-based method can be used to create polymersomes with a range of properties, as verified by its application to another biocompatible block copolymer, the flexible polybutadiene(46)-b-poly(ethylene glycol)(30). The technique will be particularly useful when delicate biomacromolecules such as (membrane) proteins, peptides, or nucleic acids are to be encapsulated in the polymersomes because the detergents used are compatible with these compounds, and the possible denaturing effect of sonication or organic solvents on the biological activity of the molecule of interest is avoided.

[Mechanism of micelle-vesicle transformation and control of vesicular sizes and properties]

The mechanism of vesicle-to-micelle or micelle-to-vesicle transition was studied in order to control sizes and fluidities of vesicles during periods of preparation. Dependence of particle sizes measured by quasi-elastic light scattering, turbidities, fluidity parameters monitored by ESR spectroscopy, and morphological changes of mixed aggregates of egg yolk phosphatidylcholine (EPC) and a detergent (octylglucoside (OG) or sodium cholate (Na-chol)) on detergent concentration provided a model of vesicle destruction. It possessed three phase transition points, and proceeded in a stepwise fashion: vesicles, small particles containing large amounts of detergents (SUV(*)), intermediate structures, and mixed micelles. Vesicle formation on removal of detergents from micelles proceeded oppositely. Micelle-vesicle transition mechanism was common to all detergents examined. The feature of the mechanism was the presence of SUV(*). Next, SUV(*) was prepared by adding appropriate amount of a detergent to small unilamellar vesicles obtained by sonication. Time-dependent size growth of the SUV(*) was remarkable in the case of OG-containing SUV(*), but was insignificant in the case of Na-chol-containing SUV(*), suggesting the size determining step to be the stage of the SUV(*). The tendency to produce large or small vesicles from micelles was related to the absence or presence, respectively, of a net charge in the detergent molecule. The fluidities of EPC micelles containing small amounts of a detergent possessing a steroidal structure (e.g., Na-chol or CHAPS) were significantly smaller than the corresponding values of a detergent without a steroidal structure (e.g., OG), suggesting a method of control of orderliness of hydrocarbon chains in EPC vesicles.

Process of destruction of large unilamellar vesicles by a zwitterionic detergent, CHAPS: partition behavior between membrane and water phases

The process of vesicle destruction by zwitterionic detergent, 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate (CHAPS), was examined to clarify the vesicle-micelle transition mechanism. The physicochemical properties including turbidity, apparent particle size, Cl(-) permeability, electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopic parameters, and freeze-fracture electron microscopy were investigated. The concentration of CHAPS was analyzed using HPLC to determine the partition coefficient during the solubilization process. The data obtained revealed that maximum turbidity and apparent particle size were found at the effective ratio (R(e)) of 0.21 and 0.49, respectively. With a further increase in CHAPS concentration, turbidity and particle size abruptly decreased, suggesting the formation of mixed micelles. The partition coefficient changed throughout the solubilization process. In the presence of low concentrations of CHAPS, CHAPS partitioned into vesicles without destruction of membrane bilayers. When the R(e)<0.04, the partition coefficient was independent of the detergent concentration with value of 24 M(-1). At R(e) greater than 0.05, the membrane barrier abruptly decreased. At 0.04</=R(e)<0.21, the gradual increase in the partition coefficient accounted for the occurrence of larger vesicles. In range of 0.21</=R(e)<0.52, the abrupt increase in the partition behavior was possibly attributed to the structural change of mixed vesicles to mixed micelles. Furthermore, the ESR results showed that the incorporation of CHAPS into vesicles led to an increase in membrane fluidity near the polar head, and a decrease near the end of the acyl chain. ESR spectra of 5-doxylstearic acid in CHAPS-containing micelles were anisotropic, indicating that the steroidal structure of CHAPS was responsible for the micelles possessing an orderly arrangement of hydrocarbon chains.

Physical properties of phosphatidylcholine vesicles containing small amount of sodium cholate and consideration on the initial stage of vesicle solubilization

The effects of sub-solubilizing concentrations of sodium cholate (Na-chol) on several physicochemical properties of phosphatidylcholine (PC) small unilamellar vesicles (SUV) were considered in connection with the initial stage of membrane solubilization. ESR spectra of 12-doxylstearic acid (12-DS) in phosphatidylcholine from egg yolk (EPC) or dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) SUV at low concentrations (insufficient to destroy the vesicles) of Na-chol were composed of two (a strongly immobilized and an additional weakly immobilized) immiscible components. The origin of the additional bands was phase separation which occurred in the hydrophobic parts of PC SUV in the presence of Na-chol. Differential scanning calorimetry measurements demonstrated that the mixed DMPC/Na-chol SUV possessed two (a sharp low-temperature and a broad high-temperature) endothermic peaks, which is consistent with the coexistence of two immiscible phases in the vesicular membranes. zeta Potentials of the EPC/Na-chol SUV revealed that high anionic densities appeared on the surfaces of the SUV at a Na-chol concentration slightly below the upper boundary of the vesicle region. Thus, the initial stage of the solubilization of PC SUV by Na-chol was caused by the aggregation of hydrophobic parts of PC membranes, followed by the occurrence of high anionic densities on the surfaces of the vesicles. The fact that removal of Na-chol from PC/Na-chol mixed systems preferentially resulted in the formation of small vesicles might originate from these anionic charges.

Enzymes inside lipid vesicles: preparation, reactivity and applications

There are a number of methods that can be used for the preparation of enzyme-containing lipid vesicles (liposomes) which are lipid dispersions that contain water-soluble enzymes in the trapped aqueous space. This has been shown by many investigations carried out with a variety of enzymes. A review of these studies is given and some of the main results are summarized. With respect to the vesicle-forming amphiphiles used, most preparations are based on phosphatidylcholine, either the natural mixtures obtained from soybean or egg yolk, or chemically defined compounds, such as DPPC (1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) or POPC (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine). Charged enzyme-containing lipid vesicles are often prepared by adding a certain amount of a negatively charged amphiphile (typically dicetylphosphate) or a positively charged lipid (usually stearylamine). The presence of charges in the vesicle membrane may lead to an adsorption of the enzyme onto the interior or exterior site of the vesicle bilayers. If (i) the high enzyme encapsulation efficiencies; (ii) avoidance of the use of organic solvents during the entrapment procedure; (iii) relatively monodisperse spherical vesicles of about 100 nm diameter; and (iv) a high degree of unilamellarity are required, then the use of the so-called 'dehydration-rehydration method', followed by the 'extrusion technique' has shown to be superior over other procedures. In addition to many investigations in the field of cheese production--there are several studies on the (potential) medical and biomedical applications of enzyme-containing lipid vesicles (e.g. in the enzyme-replacement therapy or for immunoassays)--including a few in vivo studies. In many cases, the enzyme molecules are expected to be released from the vesicles at the target site, and the vesicles in these cases serve as the carrier system. For (potential) medical applications as enzyme carriers in the blood circulation, the preparation of sterically stabilized lipid vesicles has proven to be advantageous. Regarding the use of enzyme-containing vesicles as submicrometer-sized nanoreactors, substrates are added to the bulk phase. Upon permeation across the vesicle bilayer(s), the trapped enzymes inside the vesicles catalyze the conversion of the substrate molecules into products. Using physical (e.g. microwave irradiation) or chemical methods (e.g. addition of micelle-forming amphiphiles at sublytic concentration), the bilayer permeability can be controlled to a certain extent. A detailed molecular understanding of these (usually) submicrometer-sized bioreactor systems is still not there. There are only a few approaches towards a deeper understanding and modeling of the catalytic activity of the entrapped enzyme molecules upon externally added substrates. Using micrometer-sized vesicles (so-called 'giant vesicles') as simple models for the lipidic matrix of biological cells, enzyme molecules can be microinjected inside individual target vesicles, and the corresponding enzymatic reaction can be monitored by fluorescence microscopy using appropriate fluorogenic substrate molecules.

Phase boundaries in mixtures of membrane-forming amphiphiles and micelle-forming amphiphiles

The phase behavior of mixtures of phospholipids and detergents in aqueous solutions is an issue of basic importance for understanding the solubilization and reconstitution of biological membranes. We review the existing knowledge on the compositionally induced reversible transformation of phospholipid bilayers into lipid-detergent mixed micelles. First, we describe the experimental protocols used for preparation of such mixtures and emphasize the scope and limitations of the various techniques used for evaluation of the microstructures of the self-assembled amphiphiles in the mixture. Subsequently, we interpret the existing data in terms of the spontaneous curvature of the amphiphiles and the finite size of the mixed micelles. These considerations lead to a general description of the phase behavior, which forms the basis for a rational approach to solubilization and reconstitution experiments.

Vesicle reconstitution from lipid-detergent mixed micelles

The process of formation of lipid vesicles using the technique of detergent removal from mixed-micelles is examined. Recent studies on the solubilization and reconstitution of liposomes participated to our knowledge of the structure and properties of mixed lipid-detergent systems. The mechanisms involved in both the lipid self assembly and the micelle-vesicle transition are first reviewed. The simplistic three step minimum scheme is described and criticized in relation with isothermal as well as a function of the [det]/[lip] ratio, phase diagram explorations. The techniques of detergent elimination are reviewed and criticized for advantages and disadvantages. New methods inducing micelle-vesicle transition using enzymatic reaction and T-jump are also described and compared to more classical ones. Future developments of these techniques and improvements resulting of their combinations are also considered. Proper reconstitution of membrane constituents such as proteins and drugs into liposomes are examined in the light of our actual understanding of the micelle-vesicle transition.

Vesicle size distributions measured by flow field-flow fractionation coupled with multiangle light scattering

The separation method, flow field-flow fractionation (flow FFF), is coupled on-line with multiangle laser light scattering (MALLS) for simultaneous measurement of the size and concentration of vesicles eluting continuously from the fractionator. These size and concentration data, gathered as a function of elution time, may be used to construct both number- and mass-weighted vesicle size distributions. Unlike most competing, noninvasive methods, this flow FFF/MALLS technique enables measurement of vesicle size distributions without a separate refractive index detector, calibration using particle size standards, or prior assumptions about the shape of the size distribution. Experimentally measured size distributions of vesicles formed by extrusion and detergent removal are non-Gaussian and are fit well by the Weibull distribution. Flow FFF/MALLS reveals that both the extrusion and detergent dialysis vesicle formation methods can yield nearly size monodisperse populations with standard deviations of approximately 8% about the mean diameter. In contrast to the rather low resolution of dynamic light scattering in analyzing bimodal systems, flow FFF/MALLS is shown to resolve vesicle subpopulations that differ by much less than a factor of two in mean size.

Cholesterol precipitation from cholesterol-supersaturated bile models

Bile-model systems containing cholesterol (CH), phosphatidylcholine (PC) and sodium cholate (NaC) at concentrations similar to those found in supersaturated human gall bladder bile ([CH]/[PC] = 0.60 +/- 0.01; CH saturation index, CSI = 1.58 +/- 0.03) were prepared by mixing PC-CH vesicles with NaC micellar solutions. Following mixing, the dispersion became transparent and gave rise to high resolution 1H-NMR spectra typical of mixed micellar systems. Cryo-transmission electron micrographs of specimens vitrified at that stage support the conclusion that the vesicles had become completely micellized. Following micellization, the metastable (cholesterol-supersaturated) bile-models spontaneously underwent a series of reorganizational steps: first, cholesterol-rich vesicles with a [CH]/[PC] ratio of 1.57 +/- 0.69 were formed, in co-existence with a mixed micellar system with [CH]/[PC] = 0.43 +/- 0.01 and CSI = 1.12 +/- 0.03. The resultant cholesterol-rich vesicles subsequently aggregated and cholesterol crystals of varying sizes and shapes appeared within the aggregates: needle-like structures were first observed, followed by clusters of those crystals and of helical crystals. Eventually, typical plate-like cholesterol crystals appeared, at which time some of the PC returned to the non-particulate (isotropic) phase. Consequently, the system contained cholesterol crystals coexisting with mixed micelles, whose composition was close to the limit of saturation (CSI = 1.08). These findings confirm the sequence of events preceding the appearance of cholesterol crystals, as previously proposed in our less detailed studies ((1990) Hepatology 12, 149S) and support the relevance of the morphologically similar results of Konikoff et al. ((1992) J. Clin. Invest. 90, 1155) obtained in a very dilute supersaturated bile-model.

Reconstitution of non-ionic monoalkyl amphiphile-cholesterol vesicles by dilution of lipids-octylglucoside mixed micelles

Kinetic aspects of the formation of non-ionic surfactant vesicles (NSV) using the mixed micelle dilution procedure are examined. Mixed micelles composed of a mixture of lipids, i.e. diglycerol hexadecylether (C16G2), cholesterol (CHOL), dicetylphosphate (DCP) and detergent, octylglucoside (OG), were diluted with detergent-free buffer added either instantaneously or progressively at different rates ranging from 3.47 x 10(-2) to 6.94 x 10(-4) ml/min. The resulting particles were analysed by quasielastic light scattering (QELS), high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) on gel exclusion column and cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). NSV exhibit mean diameters (MD) varying from 100 to 600 nm depending on the kinetics of OG removal. When the dilution of mixed micelles is instantaneous the vesicles are characterized by a spherical shape and MD values close to 100 nm. They show narrow size distribution and stability for 2 months. NSV recovered with progressive micelle dilution, at fast buffer addition rates (3.47 x 10(-2) and 1.39 x 10(-2) ml/min) exhibit MD values of 170-240 nm, elongated shapes, low polydispersities and 2-month stabilities. When the rate of buffer addition is lowered to 6.94 x 10(-4) ml/min, unstable particles with larger MD values and broad size distributions are obtained. Turbidity monitoring at 350 nm and 25 degrees C was used to characterize the lipids-OG mixed aggregate rearrangements either as a function of time when detergent-free buffer was continously added to the mixed micelles or after equilibrium setting when the micelles were instantaneously diluted. In the latter case the intermediate aggregates were also analysed by QELS. For continuous dilutions, the molecular composition of aggregates, [OG/lip]agg, as well as the OG concentration in the aqueous medium, [OG]bulk, were determined at the break points observed on the plots of optical density (OD) versus total OG concentration ([OG]tot). [OG/lip]agg and [OG]bulk values are independent of the rate of buffer addition, suggesting that the micelle to NSV transition is not mainly limited by the kinetics of the molecular processes involved during detergent removal from the mixed aggregates. The examination of the apparent partition coefficient of OG between the aqueous phase and the lipidic aggregates shows, however, that OG depletion from the bilayered structures is more difficult than its elimination from the mixed micelles. QELS analysis of the intermediate lipids-detergent aggregates, performed with time, demonstrates very slow supramolecular rearrangements during the vesicle closure. These rearrangements explain the significant increase in both size and polydisperity of the final vesicles observed with slow rates of buffer addition.