Ordered transcription of RNA tumor virus genomes

Dynamic Interplay of RNA and Protein in the Human Immunodeficiency Virus-1 Reverse Transcription Initiation Complex

The initiation of reverse transcription in human immunodeficiency virus-1 is a key early step in the virus replication cycle. During this process, the viral enzyme reverse transcriptase (RT) copies the single-stranded viral RNA (vRNA) genome into double-stranded DNA using human tRNA^Lys₃ as a primer for initiation. The tRNA primer and vRNA genome contain several complementary sequences that are important for regulating reverse transcription initiation kinetics. Using single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer spectroscopy, we demonstrate that the vRNA-tRNA initiation complex is conformationally heterogeneous and dynamic in the absence of RT. As shown previously, nucleic acid-RT interaction is characterized by rapid dissociation constants. We show that extension of the vRNA-tRNA primer binding site helix from 18 base pairs to 22 base pairs stabilizes RT binding to the complex and that the tRNA 5' end has a role in modulating RT binding. RT occupancy on the complex stabilizes helix 1 formation and reduces global structural heterogeneity. The stabilization of helix 1 upon RT binding may serve to destabilize helix 2, the first pause site for RT during initiation, during later steps of reverse transcription initiation.

Heterogeneous structures formed by conserved RNA sequences within the HIV reverse transcription initiation site

Reverse transcription is a key process in the early steps of HIV infection. This process initiates within a specific complex formed by the 5' UTR of the HIV genomic RNA (vRNA) and a host primer tRNA^Lys₃ Using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy, we detect two distinct conformers adopted by the tRNA/vRNA initiation complex. We directly show that an interaction between the conserved 8-nucleotide viral RNA primer activation signal (PAS) and the primer tRNA occurs in one of these conformers. This intermolecular PAS interaction likely induces strain on a vRNA intramolecular helix, which must be broken for reverse transcription to initiate. We propose a mechanism by which this vRNA/tRNA conformer relieves the kinetic block formed by the vRNA intramolecular helix to initiate reverse transcription.

In vitro synthesis of long DNA products in reactions with HIV-RT and nucleocapsid protein

In vitro reaction conditions using HIV reverse transcriptase (RT) and nucleocapsid protein (NC) that allowed efficient synthesis of single-stranded DNA products over a thousand nucleotides in length from genomic HIV RNA were characterized. Consistent with previous reports, the reactions required high concentrations of NC and RT. Long products were produced as a result of frequent strand transfer between RNA templates, averaging at least one transfer per 300 nucleotides synthesized. No change in RT processivity was observed in the reactions in the presence versus absence of NC. Synthesis of long products required formation of a high molecular mass aggregate between NC and nucleic acids. The aggregate formed rapidly and pelleted with low speed centrifugation. The aggregate was accessible to RT as pre-formed aggregates synthesized long products when RT was added. NC finger mutants lacking either finger one or two or with the finger positions switched were all effective in promoting long products. This suggests that the aggregation/condensation but not helix-destabilizing activity of NC was required. We propose that these high molecular mass aggregates promote synthesis of long reverse transcription products in vitro by concentrating nucleic acids, RT enzyme and NC to close proximity, thereby mimicking the role of the capsid environment within the host cell.

Norovirus recombination in ORF1/ORF2 overlap

Norovirus (NoV) genogroups I and II (GI and GII) are now recognized as the predominant worldwide cause of outbreaks of acute gastroenteritis in humans. Three recombinant NoV GII isolates were identified and characterized, 2 of which are unrelated to any previously published recombinant NoV. Using data from the current study, published sequences, database searches, and molecular techniques, we identified 23 recombinant NoV GII and 1 recombinant NoV GI isolates. Analysis of the genetic relationships among the recombinant NoV GII isolates identified 9 independent recombinant sequences; the other 14 strains were close relatives. Two of the 9 independent recombinant NoV were closely related to other recombinants only in the polymerase region, and in a similar fashion 1 recombinant NoV was closely related to another only in the capsid region. Breakpoint analysis of recombinant NoV showed that recombination occurred in the open reading frame (ORF)1/ORF2 overlap. We provide evidence to support the theory of the role of subgenomic RNA promoters as recombination hotspots and describe a simple mechanism of how recombination might occur in NoV.

Mismatch extension during strong stop strand transfer and minimal homology requirements for replicative template switching during Moloney murine leukemia virus replication

Reverse transcription requires two replicative template switches, called minus and plus strand strong stop transfer, and can include additional, recombinogenic switches. Donor and acceptor template homology facilitates both replicative and recombinogenic transfers, but homology-independent determinants may also contribute. Here, improved murine leukemia virus-based assays were established and the effects of varying extents of mismatches and complementarity between primer and acceptor template regions were assessed. Template switch accuracy was addressed by examining provirus structures, and efficiency was measured using a competitive titer assay. The results demonstrated that limited mismatch extension occurred readily during both minus and plus strand transfer. A strong bias for correct targeting to the U3/R junction and against use of alternate regions of homology was observed during minus strand transfer. Transfer to the U3/R junction was as accurate with five bases of complementarity as it was with an intact R, and as few as 3nt targeted transfer to a limited extent. In contrast, 12 base recombinogenic acceptors were utilized poorly and no accurate switch was observed when recombination acceptors retained only five bases of complementarity. These findings confirm that murine leukemia virus replicative and recombinogenic template switches differ in homology requirements, and support the notion that factors other than primer-template complementarity may contribute to strong stop acceptor template recognition.

Mechanistic aspects of HIV-1 reverse transcription initiation

During reverse transcription, the positive-strand HIV-1 RNA genome is converted into a double-stranded DNA copy which can be permanently integrated into the host cell genome. Recent analyses show that HIV-1 reverse transcription is a highly regulated process. The initiation reaction can be distinguished from a subsequent elongation reaction carried out by a reverse transcription complex composed of (at least) heterodimeric reverse transcriptase, cellular tRNA(lys3) and HIV-1 genomic RNA sequences. In addition, viral factors including Tat, Nef, Vif, Vpr, IN and NCp7, cellular proteins, and TAR RNA and other RNA stem-loop structures appear to influence this complex and contribute to the efficiency of the initiation reaction. As viral resistance to many antiretroviral compounds is a continuing problem, understanding the ways in which these factors influence the reverse transcription complex will likely lead to novel antiretroviral strategies.

Interactions between Ty1 retrotransposon RNA and the T and D regions of the tRNA(iMet) primer are required for initiation of reverse transcription in vivo

Reverse transcription of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Ty1 retrotransposon is primed by tRNA(iMet) base paired to the primer binding site (PBS) near the 5' end of Ty1 genomic RNA. The 10-nucleotide PBS is complementary to the last 10 nucleotides of the acceptor stem of tRNA(iMet). A structural probing study of the interactions between the Ty1 RNA template and the tRNA(iMet) primer showed that besides interactions between the PBS and the 3' end of tRNA(iMet), three short regions of Ty1 RNA, named boxes 0, 1, and 2.1, interact with the T and D stems and loops of tRNA(iMet). To determine if these sequences are important for the reverse transcription pathway of the Ty1 retrotransposon, mutant Ty1 elements and tRNA(iMet) were tested for the ability to support transposition. We show that the Ty1 boxes and the complementary sequences in the T and D stems and loops of tRNA(iMet) contain bases that are critical for Ty1 retrotransposition. Disruption of 1 or 2 bp between tRNA(iMet) and box 0, 1, or 2.1 dramatically decreases the level of transposition. Compensatory mutations which restore base pairing between the primer and the template restore transposition. Analysis of the reverse transcription intermediates generated inside Ty1 virus-like particles indicates that initiation of minus-strand strong-stop DNA synthesis is affected by mutations disrupting complementarity between Ty1 RNA and primer tRNA(iMet).

Sequence comparison of the Ty1 and Ty2 elements of the yeast genome supports the structural model of the tRNAiMet-Ty1 RNA reverse transcription initiation complex

In the reverse transcription initiation complex of the yeast Ty1 retrotransposon, interaction between the template RNA and primer tRNAiMet is not limited to base pairing of the primer binding site (PBS) with ten nucleotides at the 3' end of tRNAiMet, but three regions named boxes O, 1 and 2.1 interact with the T and D stems and loops of tRNAiMet. Sequence comparison of 33 Ty1 elements and 13 closely related Ty2 elements found in the yeast genome shows that the nucleotide sequence of all elements is highly conserved in the region spanning the PBS and the three boxes. Since the domain of the template RNA encodes a portion of protein TyA, we have calculated its amino acid profile and its nucleotide profile to evaluate the role played by nucleotide sequence conservation in the selection for TyA function and in the maintenance of base pairing interactions for the priming function of Ty1 RNA. Our results show that the nucleotide sequence conservation of Ty1 RNA is constrained not only by selection for Ty1 function but also by maintenance of a given nucleotide sequence able to base pair with the tRNAiMet in the primer-template initiation complex.

Psoralen crosslinking between human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA and primer tRNA3(Lys)

Initiation of reverse transcription is a crucial step of retroviral infection. In HIV-1, it involves hybridization of the 18 3'-terminal nucleotides of the primer tRNA3(Lys) to the primer binding site (PBS) of the viral RNA. Moreover, additional interactions between the two RNAs were recently evidenced [Isel et al. (1995) J. Mol. Biol. 247, 25269-25272]. To get further information on the topology of the viral RNA/tRNA3(Lys) complex, we used psoralen to induce RNA-RNA crosslinking. A defined intermolecular crosslinked complex was obtained. The crosslinked regions were characterized by RNase T1 digestion followed by bi-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The crosslinked residues (nucleotide mcm5S2U34 and U35 in the anticodon loop of tRNA3(Lys) and UCU154 in the viral RNA upstream of the PBS) were mapped using a retardation method coupled with random hydrolysis. The formation of this crosslink depends on the same elements that are required for the formation of the extended interactions between primer and template RNAs, i.e., the modified bases of the tRNA and a conserved A-rich loop located upstream of the PBS in the genomic RNA. Therefore, the present crosslinking data provide relevant information on the topology of the template/primer binary complex.

Role of RNA primers in initiation of minus-strand and plus-strand DNA synthesis of the yeast retrotransposon Ty1

The Ty1 retrotransposon of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is a long terminal repeat mobile genetic element that transposes through an RNA intermediate. Initiation of minus-strand and plus-strand DNA synthesis are two critical steps during reverse transcription of the retrotransposon genome. Initiation of minus-strand DNA synthesis of the Ty1 element is primed by the cytoplasmic initiator methionine tRNA base paired to the primer binding site near the 5' end of the genomic RNA. A structural probing study of the primer tRNA-Ty1 RNA binary complex reveals that besides interactions between the primer binding site and the last 10 nucleotides at the 3' end of the primer tRNA, three short regions of Ty1 RNA named box 0, box 1 and box 2.1 interact with the T and D stems and loops of the primer tRNA. Some in vivo results underline the functional importance of the nucleotide sequence of the boxes and suggest that extended interactions between genomic Ty1 RNA and the primer tRNA play a role in the reverse transcription pathway. Plus-strand DNA synthesis is initiated from an RNase H resistant oligoribonucleotide spanning a purine-rich sequence, the polypurine tract (PPT). Two sites of initiation located at the 5' boundary of the 3' long terminal repeat (PPT1) and near the middle of the TyB (pol) gene in the integrase coding sequence (PPT2) have been identified in the genome of Ty1. The two PPTs have an identical sequence, TGGGTGGTA. Mutations replacing purines by pyrimidines in this sequence significantly diminish or abolish initiation of plus-strand DNA synthesis. Ty1 elements bearing a mutated PPT2 sequence are not defective for transposition whereas mutations in PPT1 abolish transposition.

Replication of avian leukosis viruses with mutations at the primer binding site: use of alternative tRNAs as primers

We have tested whether avian leukosis viruses (ALVs) can use tRNAs other than tRNATrp to initiate reverse transcription. The primer binding site (PBS) of a wild-type ALV provirus, which is complementary to the 3' end of tRNA(Trp), was replaced with sequences homologous to the 3' ends of six different chicken tRNAs (tRN(APro), tRNA(Lys), tRNA(Met), tRNA(Ile), tRNA(Phe), and tRNA(Ser)). Transfection of these proviruses into chicken embryo fibroblasts resulted in the production of infectious viruses, all of which apparently used the tRNA specified by the mutated PBS to replicate. However, growth of these viruses resulted in reversion to the wild-type (tRNA(Trp)) PBS. Some of the viruses revert quite quickly, while others are more stable. The relative stability of a given PBS correlated with the concentration of the corresponding tRNA in the virion. We determined the percentage of viral RNA that had a tRNA bound to the PBS and found that the occupancy rate is lower in the mutants than in the wild-type virus. We conclude that many different tRNAs can be used as primers to initiate reverse transcription in ALV. However, ALVs that use tRNA(Trp) have a growth advantage over ALVs that use other tRNAs.

tRNAs as primer of reverse transcriptases

Genetic elements coding for proteins that present amino acid identity with the conserved motifs of retroviral reverse transcriptases constitute the retroid family. With the exception of reverse transcriptases encoded by mitochondrial plasmids of Neurospora, all reverse transcriptases have an absolute requirement for a primer to initiate DNA synthesis. In retroviruses, plant pararetroviruses, and retrotransposons (transposons containing long terminal repeats), DNA synthesis is primed by specific tRNAs. All these retroelements contain a primer binding site presenting a Watson-Crick complementarity with the primer tRNA. The tRNAs most widely used as primers are tRNA(Trp), tRNA(Pro), tRNA(1,2Lys), tRNA(3Lys), tRNA(iMet). Other tRNAs such as tRNA(Gln), tRNA(Leu), tRNA(Ser), tRNA(Asn) and tRNA(Arg) are also occasionally used as primers. In the retroviruses and plant pararetroviruses, the primer binding site is complementary to the 3' end of the primer tRNA. In the case of retrotransposons, the primer binding site is either complementary to the 3' end or to an internal region of the primer tRNA. Additional interactions taking place between the primer tRNA and the retro-RNA outside of the primer binding site have been evidenced in the case of Rous sarcoma virus, human immunodeficiency virus type I, and yeast retrotransposon Ty1. A selective encapsidation of the primer tRNA, probably promoted by interactions with reverse transcriptase, occurs during the formation of virus or virus-like particles. Annealing of the primer tRNA to the primer binding site appears to be mediated by reverse transcriptase and/or the nucleocapsid protein. Modified nucleosides of the primer tRNA have been shown to be important for replication of the primer binding site, encapsidation of the primer (in the case of Rous sarcoma virus), and interaction with the genomic RNA (in the case of human immunodeficiency virus type I).

Secondary structure of the HIV-2 leader RNA comprising the tRNA-primer binding site

The initiation of reverse transcription of a retroviral RNA genome occurs by a tRNA primer bound near the 5' end of the genomic RNA at a position called the primer-binding site (PBS). To understand the molecular basis for this RNA-RNA interaction, the secondary structure of the leader RNA of the human immunodeficiency virus type 2 (HIV-2) RNA was analyzed. In vitro synthesized HIV-2 RNA was probed with various structure-specific enzymes and chemicals. A computer program was then used to predict the secondary structure consistent with these data. In addition, the nucleotide sequences of different HIV-2 isolates were used to screen for the occurrence of covariation among putative base pairs. The primary sequences have diverged rapidly in some HIV-2 isolates, however, some strikingly conserved secondary structure elements were identified. Most nucleotides in the leader region are involved in base pairing. An exception is the PBS sequence, of which 15 out of 18 nucleotides are exposed in an internal loop. These findings suggest that the overall structure of the HIV-2 genome has evolved to facilitate an optimal interaction with its tRNA primer.

Interaction between retroviral U5 RNA and the T psi C loop of the tRNA(Trp) primer is required for efficient initiation of reverse transcription

The 5' end of avian sarcoma and leukosis virus RNA near the primer binding site forms two RNA secondary structures, U5-inverted repeat (U5-IR) and U5-leader stems, which are required for efficient initiation of reverse transcription. Lying between these two secondary structures is a 7-base sequence that can anneal to the T psi C loop of the tRNA(Trp) primer. Base substitutions in U5 RNA which disrupt this potential interaction result in a defect in the initiation of reverse transcription both in vivo and in vitro. The defect can be complemented in vitro by base substitutions in the primer. The U5 RNA-T psi C interaction is also dependent upon the presence of both the U5-IR and the U5-leader structures. These RNA secondary structures and primer interactions are conserved in other type C and D retroviruses, suggesting that there is a common mechanism for the initiation of reverse transcription in all of these retroviruses.

RNA recombination in animal and plant viruses

An increasing number of animal and plant viruses have been shown to undergo RNA-RNA recombination, which is defined as the exchange of genetic information between nonsegmented RNAs. Only some of these viruses have been shown to undergo recombination in experimental infection of tissue culture, animals, and plants. However, a survey of viral RNA structure and sequences suggests that many RNA viruses were derived form homologous or nonhomologous recombination between viruses or between viruses and cellular genes during natural viral evolution. The high frequency and widespread nature of RNA recombination indicate that this phenomenon plays a more significant role in the biology of RNA viruses than was previously recognized. Three types of RNA recombination are defined: homologous recombination; aberrant homologous recombination, which results in sequence duplication, insertion, or deletion during recombination; and nonhomologous (illegitimate) recombination, which does not involve sequence homology. RNA recombination has been shown to occur by a copy choice mechanism in some viruses. A model for this recombination mechanism is presented.

Abortive reverse transcription by mutants of Moloney murine leukemia virus deficient in the reverse transcriptase-associated RNase H function

The reverse transcriptase enzymes of retroviruses are multifunctional proteins containing both DNA polymerase activity and a nuclease activity, termed RNase H, specific for RNA in RNA-DNA hybrid form. To determine the role of RNase H activity in retroviral replication, we constructed a series of mutant genomes of Moloney murine leukemia virus that encoded reverse transcriptase enzymes that were specifically altered to retain polymerase function but lack RNase H activity. The mutant genomes were all replication defective. Analysis of in vitro reverse transcription reactions carried out by mutant virions showed that minus-strand strong-stop DNA was formed but did not efficiently translocate to the 3' end of the genome; rather, the DNA was stably retained in RNA-DNA hybrid form. Plus-strand strong-stop DNA was not detected. These results suggest that RNase H normally promotes strong-stop translocation, perhaps by exposing single-stranded DNA sequences for base pairing. Four new DNA species were also detected among the reaction products. Analysis of these DNAs suggested that they were minus-strand DNAs formed from VL30 RNAs encoded by the mouse genome. We suggest that reverse transcriptase can initiate DNA synthesis at any one of four alternate tRNA primer-binding sites near the 5' ends of VL30 RNAs.

Overlapping retrovirus U5 sequence elements are required for efficient integration and initiation of reverse transcription

A secondary structure in the 5' noncoding region of avian retrovirus RNA, called the U5-leader stem, was shown previously to have a role in initiation of reverse transcription (D. Cobrinik, L. Soskey, and J. Leis, J. Virol. 62:3622-3630, 1988). We now show that an additional RNA secondary structure near the U5 terminus, called the U5-IR stem, is also important for reverse transcription. Mutations that disrupt the U5-IR stem cause a replication defect associated with both a decrease in synthesis of viral DNA in infected cells and a decrease in initiation of reverse transcription in melittin-permeabilized virions. Structure-compensating base substitutions in the U5-IR restore reverse transcription efficiency. In viral DNA, U5-IR sequences are included in the U5 terminal region that functions as a viral integration donor site. When base substitutions are introduced into these sequences, a reduced efficiency of integration in vitro and in vivo is observed. These observations indicate that U5-IR sequences have a structural role in reverse transcription of viral RNA and a sequence-specific role in the integration of viral DNA.

Construction and analysis of deletion mutations in the U5 region of Moloney murine leukemia virus: effects on RNA packaging and reverse transcription

A collection of deletion mutations was generated in the U5 region of cloned DNA copies of Moloney murine leukemia virus or a related retrovirus. Cell lines expressing the mutant DNAs were generated by cotransformation, and the virions released were characterized biochemically. Deletions in the 5' part of U5 profoundly reduced packaging of the viral RNA into virions; one deletion in the 3' part of U5 did not block packaging but affected reverse transcription. One mutant with a deletion in the central part of U5 was fully viable and served to separate the two functional parts of U5.

A retroviral RNA secondary structure required for efficient initiation of reverse transcription

Genetic evidence is presented which suggests the existence of an important structural element in the 5' noncoding region of avian retrovirus RNA. The proposed structure, which we term the U5-leader stem, is composed of sequences in the middle of U5 and in the leader, flanking the primer-binding site. U5 and leader mutations which would disrupt this structure caused a partial replication defect. However, nucleotide substitutions in the leader, which would structurally compensate for a U5 deletion mutation, restored normal replication. Analysis of replication intermediates of viruses with the above mutations suggests that the U5-leader stem is required for efficient DNA synthesis in vivo and for initiation of DNA synthesis from the tRNA(Trp) primer in melittin-activated virions. However, this structure does not appear to be required for binding of the tRNA(Trp) primer to viral RNA. These results support a role for the U5-leader stem structure, independent of its primary sequence, in the initiation of retroviral replication.

In situ transcription: specific synthesis of complementary DNA in fixed tissue sections

A technique, in situ transcription, is described, in which reverse transcription of mRNAs is achieved within fixed tissue sections. An oligonucleotide complementary to proopiomelanocortin (POMC) mRNA was used as a primer for the specific synthesis of radiolabeled POMC cDNA in fixed sections of rat pituitary, thus permitting the rapid anatomical localization of POMC mRNA by autoradiography. Intermediate lobe signal intensities were sensitive to dopaminergic drugs, demonstrating that the method can be used for studies of mRNA regulation. The transcripts may also be eluted from tissue sections for a variety of uses, including the identification and cloning of autoradiographically localized cDNAs from small amounts of tissue.

An overview of retrovirus replication and classification

This introductory chapter has presented an overview of how retroviruses replicate and how they are classified within the family Retroviridae. The genomic structure of retroviruses, so reminiscent of bacterial transposons and other similar genetic elements, and reverse transcriptase, which leads to the reverse flow of genetic information from RNA to DNA, are responsible for many of the properties of these viruses which make them both fascinating and important as causes of cancer and other diseases. The requirement for integration shared by most retroviruses leads directly to most of the phenomena resulting from their interaction with target cells. Certainly latency, at the level of the organism, is one such property relevant to how we think of vaccines and therapeutic reagents. The ability of retroviruses to acquire oncogenes from cellular DNA has greatly facilitated our understanding of the genetics of neoplasia. Additionally, the use of retroviral vectors to introduce new genes into genetically defective animals is a consequence of the genetic organization of retroviruses. Classification of viruses at the species level is difficult for several reasons. In particular, viruses do not sexually reproduce in any conventional sense, and it is difficult to identify a population of virions which make up a genetically distinct pool. Thus, the definition of individual species is often controversial and is not necessarily aided by the criteria used to define larger phylogenetic groups. In the latter case, retroviruses have distinctive morphological and biochemical features which allow their classification at the family, subfamily, genus, and subgenus levels. Additional classification occurs by accounting for factors such as host range, cross neutralization, ability to compete in interspecies radioimmunoassays, and genetic homology detected by hybridization under conditions of relaxed stringency. Direct comparison of nucleotide sequences offers the hope that mathematical criteria will be developed that can define the level of differences characteristic of individual species, genuses, and subfamilies.

Analysis of intracellular small RNAs of mouse hepatitis virus: evidence for discontinuous transcription

We have previously shown the presence of multiple small leader-containing RNA species in mouse hepatitis virus (MHV)-infected cells. In this paper, we have analyzed the origin, structure, and mechanism of synthesis of these small RNAs. Using cDNA probes specific for leader RNA and genes A, D, and F, we demonstrate that subsets of these small RNAs were derived from the various viral genes. These subsets have discrete and reproducible sizes, varying with the gene from which they are derived. The size of each subset correlates with regions of secondary structure, whose free energy ranges from -1.6 to -77.1 kcal/mol, in each of the mRNAs examined. In addition, identical subsets were detected on the replicative intermediate (RI) RNA, suggesting that they represent functional transcriptional intermediates. The biological significance of these small RNAs is further supported by the detection of leader-containing RNAs of 47, 50, and 57 nucleotides in length, which correspond to the crossover sites in two MHV recombinant viruses. These data, coupled with the high frequency of RNA recombination during MHV infection, suggest that the viral polymerase may pause in or around regions of secondary structure, thereby generating pools of free leader-containing RNA intermediates which can reassociate with the template, acting as primers for the synthesis of full-length or recombinant RNAs. These data suggest that MHV transcription uses a discontinuous and nonprocessive mechanism in which RNA polymerase allows the partial RNA products to be dissociated from the template temporarily during the process of transcription.

Mitomycin C-induced bidirectional transcription from the colicin E1 promoter region in plasmid ColE1

Treatment of a colicinogenic culture with mitomycin C induces convergent transcription from two adjacent promoters at the beginning of the colicin E1 gene. S1-mapping and primer extension assays indicate that the mitomycin C-inducible transcripts correspond to colicin E1 mRNA (cea mRNA) and to a transcript, designated RNA-C, that may code for an entry exclusion function. Nucleotide sequences that strongly resemble a consensus sequence for LexA protein binding sites span the transcription start points for cea mRNA and RNA-C. These putative operator sequences overlap by one base pair and bind LexA protein (Ebina, Y., Takahara, Y., Kishi, F., Nakazawa, A. and Brent, R. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 13258-13261). The data suggest that mitomycin C-induced bidirectional transcription from the cea mRNA and RNA-C promoters is controlled by the SOS regulatory system of Escherichia coli.

Structure of a cloned circular retroviral DNA containing a tRNA sequence between the terminal repeats

In the course of analyzing a series of cloned circular retroviral DNAs, we recovered an unusual clone. The molecule consisted of a complete viral genome containing two copies of the long terminal repeat with extra sequences between the repeats. These extra bases proved to be a nearly complete DNA copy of a glycine tRNA, including bases that corresponded to modified and nonpairing bases of the mature tRNA. A model is proposed to account for the formation of the aberrant clone.

Characterization of ribosome binding on Rous sarcoma virus RNA in vitro

We determined the sites at which ribosomes form initiation complexes on Rous sarcoma virus RNA in order to determine how initiation of Pr76gag synthesis at the fourth AUG codon from the 5' end of Rous sarcoma virus strain SR-A RNA occurs. Ribosomes bind almost exclusively at the 5'-proximal AUG codon when chloride is present as the major anion added to the translational system. However, when chloride is replaced with acetate, ribosomes bind at the two 5'-proximal AUG codons, as well as at the initiation site for Pr76gag. We confirmed that the 5'-proximal AUG codon is part of a functional initiation site by identifying the seven-amino acid peptide encoded there. Our results suggest that (i) translation in vitro of Rous sarcoma virus virion RNA results in the synthesis of at least two polypeptides; (ii) the pattern of ribosome binding observed for Rous sarcoma virus RNA can be accounted for by the modified scanning hypothesis; and (iii) the interaction between 40S ribosomal subunits or 80S ribosomal complexes is stronger at the 5'-proximal AUG codon than at sites farther downstream, including the initiation site for the major viral proteins.

Functional analysis of reverse transcription by a frameshift pol mutant of murine leukemia virus

Endogenous reverse transcription by wild-type murine leukemia virus (MuLV) was compared to that catalyzed by clone 23, a pol mutant containing a reverse transcriptase protein which lacks the carboxyl-terminal third of the molecule (J. G. Levin, S. C. Hu, A. Rein, L. I. Messer, and B. I. Gerwin (1984), J. Virol. 51, 470-478). Competition immunoassays revealed that mutant virions contain normal amounts of polymerase protein, indicating that the lack of carboxyl-terminal sequences does not alter normal processing of enzyme precursors. Although the mutant enzyme was previously shown to have the ability to copy and degrade RNA:DNA hybrids, the present study demonstrates that it is defective in functions required to generate full-length copies of viral DNA. Analysis of products of endogenous reverse transcription showed that minus-strand strong-stop DNA is formed and that mutant virions synthesize a series of minus-strand DNA intermediates up to 2.2 kb in length. Comparison of mutant and wild-type MuLV reaction products indicated that the 2.2-kb termination site of the mutant corresponds to a normal pausing region for the wild-type enzyme. Computer analysis of sequences and structure within pausing regions suggested the involvement of C-rich consensus sequences plus multibranch loop structures in the general phenomenon of enzyme-pausing during reverse transcription.

Deletion in the 3' pol sequence correlates with aberration of RNA expression in certain replication-defective avian sarcoma viruses

The RNA expression of a series of replication-defective recovered avian sarcoma viruses (rASVs) were studied. Abnormal-sized viral RNAs, both larger and smaller than the genome, were observed in the nonproducer cells infected with rASVs containing env and pol deletions. Each nonproducer clone contained a single provirus integrated at a unique site and expressed a unique RNA pattern. Upon rescuing of the sarcoma virus with a helper virus and subsequent cloning, the RNA pattern of individual nonproducer clones again displayed variation according to the integration sites. This was not seen in nondefective rASV or in rASVs containing only an env deletion. The aberrant RNA expression did not result from the lack of reverse transcriptase activity per se, since neither nonconditional nor temperature-sensitive mutants of RSV expressed abnormal viral RNAs in the absence of a functional reverse transcriptase. The abnormal RNA patterns could not be corrected in trans by helper virus functions. The unusual-sized RNAs in env- pol- rASV-infected cells are not due to splicing to alternative acceptor sites for src mRNA because there are no extra viral sequences between the 5' leader and the src sequences; instead, they are due to the presence of extra sequences, most likely of cellular origin, at the 3' ends of the viral RNAs. Based upon the extent of deletions in the viral genomes, the data suggest that deletion in the 3' pol region of those rASVs results in a cis effect on the transcription and processing of the 3' ends of viral RNAs. The unusual-sized viral RNAs are most likely due to read-through transcription from the right-hand terminus of provirus into downstream cellular sequences, followed by cleavage and polyadenylation at multiple sites of the 3' region of the RNA transcripts. The extent of read-through transcription appears to depend on the chromosomal location of the provirus.

Primer binding sites corresponding to several tRNA species are present in DNAs of different members of the same retrovirus-like gene family (VL30)

We analyzed the putative tRNA primer binding site (PBS) present in several cloned copies of the murine retrovirus-like VL30 family. In the five VL30 DNA clones analyzed, we identified PBS sequences corresponding to three different tRNA species: tRNAPro, tRNAGly, and tRNAGln. The latter two PBS sequences have not been previously encountered in other retroviral or retrovirus-like systems. A unique situation was observed in which PBS sequences complementary to two different tRNA species were flanked by otherwise identical VL30 sequences. In addition, we demonstrated the use of PBS-specific synthetic oligonucleotides for the identification of the tRNA primer and their potential utility in the direct cloning of PBS-containing DNA elements.

A deletion mutation in the 5' part of the pol gene of Moloney murine leukemia virus blocks proteolytic processing of the gag and pol polyproteins

Deletion mutations in the 5' part of the pol gene of Moloney murine leukemia virus were generated by restriction enzyme site-directed mutagenesis of cloned proviral DNA. DNA sequence analysis indicated that one such deletion was localized entirely within the 5' part of the pol gene, did not affect the region encoding reverse transcriptase, and preserved the translational reading frame downstream of the mutation. The major viral precursor polyproteins (Pr65gag, Pr200gag-pol, and gPr80env) were synthesized at wild-type levels in cell lines carrying the mutant genome. These cell lines assembled and released wild-type levels of virion particles into the medium. Cleavage of both Pr65gag and Pr200gag-pol precursors to the mature proteins was completely blocked in the mutant virions. Surprisingly, these virions contained high levels of active reverse transcriptase; examination of the endogenous reverse transcription products synthesized by the mutant virions revealed normal amounts of minus-strand strong-stop DNA, indicating that the RNA genome was packaged and that reverse transcription in detergent-permeabilized virions was not significantly impaired. Processing of gPr80env to gP70env and P15E was not affected by the mutation, but cleavage of P15E to P12E was not observed. The mutant particles were poorly infectious; analysis indicated that infection was blocked at an early stage. The data are consistent with the idea that the 5' part of the pol gene encodes a protease directly responsible for processing Pr65gag, and possibly Pr200gag-pol, to the structural virion proteins. It appears that cleavage of the gag gene product is not required for budding and release of virions and that complete processing of the pol gene product to the mature form of reverse transcriptase is not required for its functional activation.

Reverse transcription of retroviral genomes: mutations in the terminal repeat sequences

The process of reverse transcription of retroviral genomes begins with the synthesis of a short DNA molecule near the 5' end of the RNA template. This molecule, termed minus-strand strong-stop DNA, is then translocated to the 3' end of the viral RNA by means of a repeated sequence, the R region, present at both ends of the template. The translocation should result in the transfer of genetic information from the 5' R region to the 3' R region. We have generated a series of mutants of Moloney murine leukemia virus with alterations in the R regions by in vitro mutagenesis of a cloned DNA copy of the viral genome. The altered DNAs were introduced into mouse cells by transfection, and the translocation of the mutations during viral replication was assessed. Some mutations were not transferred from the 5' R region to the 3' R region; these results were not in accord with current models for reverse transcription. The results can be explained if DNA molecules shorter than strong-stop DNA, formed by premature termination of synthesis, are sometimes translocated. A number of mutants with large deletions in the R region were tested and were able to replicate with normal strong-stop DNA translocation. Thus, short stretches of homology can be used by the virus to carry out strong-stop translocations.

Genetic variation among lentiviruses: homology between visna virus and caprine arthritis-encephalitis virus is confined to the 5' gag-pol region and a small portion of the env gene

Visna virus of sheep and arthritis-encephalitis virus of goats are serologically related but genetically distinct retroviruses which cause slowly progressive diseases in their natural hosts. To localize homologous regions of the DNAs of these two viruses, we constructed a physical map of caprine arthritis-encephalitis virus DNA and aligned it with the viral RNA. Cloned probes of visna virus DNA were then used to localize regions of homology with the caprine arthritis-encephalitis virus DNA. These studies showed homology in the 5' region of the genome encompassing U5 and the gag and pol genes and also in a small region in the env gene. These findings correlate with biological data suggesting that the regions of the DNA which are homologous may be responsible for virus group characteristics such as the closely related virus core antigens. Regions which did not show homology such as large sections in the env gene may represent unique sequences which control highly strain-specific characteristics such as the neutralization antigen and specific cell tropisms.

Construction and analysis of deletion mutations in the pol gene of Moloney murine leukemia virus: a new viral function required for productive infection

We have used in vitro mutagenesis to explore the functions of the gene products encoded by the pol gene of Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV). Deletions were constructed at a variety of positions in the gene, and the altered DNA copies of the viral genome were introduced into mouse cells by cotransformation. The mutants could be divided into two classes depending on the phenotype and map position of the deletion within the pol gene. Mutants with deletions mapping in the 5' portion of the gene were found to be completely deficient in reverse transcriptase activity. Mutants mapping in the 3' portion of the gene, however, assembled and released virions with normal levels of reverse transcriptase and RNAase H activities. When applied to permissive cells, these virions directed the synthesis of all three forms of unintegrated viral DNA: full-length, double-stranded linear DNA and the two circular forms with one and two copies of the long terminal repeat sequences. The infection was arrested at this point and the infected cells did not become producers of virus. Thus the 3' portion of the pol gene encodes a polypeptide with a function distinct from that of reverse transcriptase, which is not required for synthesis of viral DNA but is essential for establishment of that DNA in a stable, active form in the infected cell. We suggest that this function may be the integration of the proviral DNA.

RNA-primed initiation of Moloney murine leukemia virus plus strands by reverse transcriptase in vitro

A 190-base-pair DNA-RNA hybrid containing the Moloney murine leukemia virus origin of plus-strand DNA synthesis was constructed and used as a source of template-primer for the reverse transcriptase in vitro. Synthesis was shown to initiate precisely at the known plus-strand origin. The observation that some of the origin fragments retained ribonucleotide residues on their 5' ends suggests that the primer for chain initiation is an RNA molecule left behind by RNase H during the degradation of the RNA moiety of the DNA-RNA hybrid. If the RNase H is responsible for creating the correct primer terminus, then it must possess a specific endonucleolytic activity capable of recognizing the sequence in the RNA where plus strands are initiated. The 16-base RNase A-resistant fragment which spans the plus-strand origin can also serve as a source of the specific plus-strand primer RNA. Evidence is presented that some of the plus-strand origin fragments synthesized in the endogenous reaction contain 5' ribonucleotides, suggesting that specific RNA primers for plus-strand initiation may be generated during reverse transcription in vivo as well.

A physical map of caprine arthritis-encephalitis provirus

Terminally redundant linear proviral DNA of approximately 9.5 kb was the major unintegrated species recovered in the Hirt supernatant fraction of caprine synovial membrane cells infected with strain 75-G63 caprine arthritis-encephalitis virus. A physical map based on the cleavage sites of 13 restriction endonucleases was deduced for this proviral DNA.

Mutations in gag proteins P12 and P15 of Moloney murine leukemia virus block early stages of infection

A collection of mutants of Moloney murine leukemia virus with deletions in the gag gene was generated by restriction enzyme site-directed mutagenesis of a cloned proviral DNA. The mutants all contained deletions of the NarI site in the P12 region, and some contained deletions extending into the adjacent P15 region. The deletions did not significantly affect the assembly or release of viral particles. Examination of endogenous reverse transcription products demonstrated normal synthesis of minus- and plus-strand strong-stop DNAs, indicating that the RNA genome was packaged and that reverse transcription in detergent-permeabilized virions was not impaired. The virion particles contained high levels of an abnormal protein which corresponded to a P15-P12 fusion protein; proteolytic processing of this abnormal protein was completely blocked by all the mutations. The infectivity of the particles was dramatically reduced. Analysis of the low-molecular-weight DNA in infected NIH/3T3 cells indicated that the mutant virions could not carry out viral DNA synthesis. These data suggest that the P12 and P15 proteins may not be critical for virion assembly but do play an important role in early steps of viral infection.

Molecular cloning of unintegrated visna viral DNA and characterization of frequent deletions in the 3' terminus

Visna viral DNA, like other retroviral DNA, exists in two circular forms in infected cells. The larger probably contains two copies of the LTR, the smaller, one copy. Recombinant DNA techniques were used to clone unintegrated circular visna viral DNA in the lambda WES . lambda B vector. Circular visna viral DNA was digested with the restriction enzyme SstI, which yields a 9.2-kb viral DNA fragment containing 90% of the viral genome colinear with the restriction map of linear viral DNA. This fragment extends from a site about 900 bp from the left (5') end of the viral DNA molecule, through the 3' region, including U3 and R sequences at its right (3') end. The recombinant clones isolated contain visna viral DNA inserts which range in size from 3.1 kb to 9.2 kb. All the clones contain the 5' region intact, but most had sustained deletions of varying lengths in the 3' terminal region of the cloned fragment.

Products of reverse transcription in avian retrovirus analyzed by electron microscopy

DNA products synthesized in avian retroviral particles permeabilized with melittin have been analyzed in an electron microscope. These studies have provided further insight and subsequent refinement in the melittin activation techniques. Our electron microscope analyses verify the existence of the plus-strand single-stranded DNA branches, presumed to originate by strand-displacement synthesis (L. R. Boone and A. M. Skalka, J. Virol. 37:117-126, 1981). The branches occur at many locations along the DNA molecules and are observed at very early times, even before the minus-strand copies of the RNA genome are completed. Circular forms of different derivations are observed at early and at late times, which are possible intermediates in viral replication. Novel forms termed H structures are also described. In addition to the identification of possible intermediates, these analyses have provided further information on the sequence of events in retroviral reverse transcription. These new data are combined with previous results to generate a model of reverse transcription which incorporates strand-displacement synthesis as an essential feature.

Nucleotide sequence analysis of the long terminal repeat of integrated simian sarcoma virus: evolutionary relationship with other mammalian retroviral long terminal repeats

Nucleotide sequence analysis of the long terminal repeat (LTR) of the integrated simian sarcoma virus showed that the simian sarcoma virus LTR comprised 504 nucleotides with an inverted repeat of seven bases at its 5' and 3' termini. At the site of simian sarcoma virus integration, cellular flanking sequences adjacent to the proviral LTR contained a direct repeat of four bases. A 13-base sequence after the 5' LTR was found to be complementary to prolyl tRNA, suggesting that tRNAPro may serve as the primer for reverse transcription of simian sarcoma virus RNA. The U5 and R regions, derived respectively from the 5' end and terminally redundant sequences of the viral RNA, were found to have similar organization and sequence homology close to that of Moloney murine sarcoma virus or Moloney murine leukemia virus. These results indicate that regions within LTRs with known functionally important sequences have been most well conserved during retrovirus evolution.

Synthesis of murine leukemia viral DNA in vitro: evidence for plus-strand DNA synthesis at both ends of the genome

We studied the synthesis of B-tropic murine leukemia viral DNA in vitro by detergent-disrupted virions. The reaction products (detected by the Southern transfer technique) included full-length, infectious, double-stranded DNA and several subgenomic fragments. Restriction endonuclease analysis and hybridization and specific probes revealed two classes of subgenomic fragments: some were derived from the right end of the genome, and some were derived from the left end. Most of the fragments harbored one long terminal repeat copy at their ends, suggesting that they were initiated correctly. S1 nuclease and restriction endonuclease treatments of these fragments indicated that a single-stranded gap was present near the first initiation site of plus strong-stop DNA. The treatments also suggested the presence of a second initiation site flanked by a single-stranded gap 0.9 kilobase pairs from the right end of the genome. Our data clearly show that plus-strand DNA is synthesized at both ends of the genome, by using plus strong stop as the first initiation site and additional initiation sites.

Studies on the function of the non-primer tRNAs associated with the 70 S RNA of avian myeloblastosis virus

Significant amounts of three tRNAs are associated with the 70 S RNA of avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV). The temperatures at which they are half dissociated from the 70 S RNA in 50 mM NaCl and their respective quantities relative to 35 S RNA are: tRNAArg, 51 degree C, 1.6; tRNALys, 57 degree C, 0.7 and tRNATrp, 76 degree C, 1.0. Possible functions for the non-primer tRNAs (tRNAArg and tRNALys) were evaluated by determining the effect of their thermal dissociation on: (a) conversion of 70 S to 35 S RNA, (b) capacity of 70 S and/or 35 S RNA to be translated in vitro, and (c) capacity of 70 S and/or 35 S RNA to be reverse transcribed in vitro. Conversion of 70 S to 35 S RNA occurred with a tm of 56 degree C and is consistent with the hypothesis that tRNALys might be involved in joining two 35 S RNA subunits to form the 70 S RNA complex. There was no indication that the association of either tRNAArg or tRNALys influenced the rate or quality of translation of 70 S or 35 S RNA. A decrease in the rate at which 70 S RNA is transcribed occurs in parallel with the dissociation of tRNAArg and tRNALys.

Isolation of a transformation-defective deletion mutant of Moloney murine sarcoma virus

A transformation-defective (td) deletion mutant of Moloney murine sarcoma virus (td Mo-MSV) and a transforming component termed Mo-MSV 3 were cloned from a stock of clone 3 Mo-MSV. To define the defect of the transforming function, the RNA of td Mo-MSV was compared with those of Mo-MSV 3 and of another transforming variant termed Mo-MSV 124 and with helper Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MuLV). The RNA monomers of td Mo-MSV and Mo-MSV 3 comigrated on polyacrylamide gels and were estimated to be 4.8 kilobases (kb) in length. In agreement with previous analyses, the RNA of Mo-MSV 124 measured 5.5 kb and that of Mo-MuLV measured 8.5 kb. The interrelationships among the viral RNAs were studied by fingerprinting and mapping of RNase T(1)-resistant oligonucleotides (T(1)-oligonucleotides) and by identification of T(1)-oligonucleotides present in hybrids formed by a given viral RNA with cDNA's made from another virus. The nontransforming td Mo-MSV RNA lacked most of the Mo-MSV-specific sequence, i.e., the four 3'-proximal T(1)-oligonucleotides of the six T(1)-oligonucleotides that are shared by the Mo-MSV-specific sequences of Mo-MSV 3 and Mo-MSV 124. The remaining two Mo-MSV-specific oligonucleotides identified td Mo-MSV as a deletion mutant of MSV rather than a deletion mutant of Mo-MuLV. td Mo-MSV and Mo-MSV 124 exhibited similar deletions of gag, pol, and env sequences which were less extensive than those of Mo-MSV 3. Hence, td Mo-MSV is not simply a deletion mutant of Mo-MSV 3. In addition to their MSV-specific sequences, all three MSV variants, including td Mo-MSV, shared the terminal sequences probably encoding the proviral long terminal repeat, which differed from their counterpart in Mo-MuLV. This may indirectly contribute to the oncogenic potential of MSV. A comparison of td Mo-MSV sequences with either Mo-MSV 124 or Mo-MSV 3 indicated directly, in a fashion similar to the deletion analyses which defined the src gene of avian sarcoma viruses, that Mo-MuLV-unrelated sequences of Mo-MSV are necessary for transformation. A definition of transformation-specific sequences of Mo-MSV by deletion analysis confirmed and extended previous analyses which have identified Mo-MuLV-unrelated sequences in Mo-MSV RNA and other studies which have described transformation of mouse 3T3 fibroblasts upon transfection with DNAs containing the Mo-MSV-specific sequence.

Comparative restriction endonuclease maps of proviral DNA of the primate type C simian sarcoma-associated virus and gibbon ape leukemia virus group

Extrachromosomal DNA was purified from canine thymus cells acutely infected with different strains of infectious primate type C viruses of the woolly monkey (simian) sarcoma helper virus and gibbon ape leukemia virus group. All DNA preparations contained linear proviral molecules of 9.1 to 9.2 kilobases, at least some of which represent complete infectious proviral DNA. Cells infected with a replication-defective fibroblast-transforming sarcoma virus and its helper, a replication-competent nontransforming helper virus, also contained a 6.6- to 6.7-kilobase DNA. These proviral DNA molecules were digested with different restriction endonucleases, and the resultant fragments were oriented to the viral RNA by a combination of partial digestions, codigestion with more than one endonuclease, digestion of integrated proviral DNA, and hybridization with 3'- and 5'-specific viral probes. The 3'- and 5'-specific probes each hybridized to fragments from both ends of proviral DNA, indicating that, in common with those of other retroviruses, these proviruses contain a large terminal redundancy at both ends, each of which consists of sequences derived from both the 3' and 5' regions of the viral RNA. The proviral sequences are organized 3',5'-unique-3',5'. Four restriction enzymes (KpnI, SmaI, PstI, and SstI) recognized sites within the large terminal redundancies, and these sites were conserved within all the isolates tested. This suggests that both the 3' and 5' ends of the genomic RNA of these viruses are extremely closely related. In contrast, the restriction sites within the unique portion of the provirus were not strongly conserved within this group of viruses, even though they were related along most of their genomes. Whereas the 5' 60 to 70% of the RNA of these viruses was more closely related by liquid hybridization experiments than was the 3' 30 to 40%, restriction sites within this region were not preferentially conserved, suggesting that small sequence differences or point mutations or both exist throughout the entire unique portion of the genome among these viruses.

src Genes of ten Rous sarcoma virus strains, including two reportedly transduced from the cell, are completely allelic; putative markers of transduction are not detected

The src genes of different Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) strains have been reported to be highly conserved by some investigators using RNA-cDNA hybridization, whereas others using oligonucleotide, peptide, and serological analyses have judged src genes to be variable in 30 to 50% of the respective markers. Moreover, distinctive src oligonucleotides and peptides of so-called recovered RSVs (rRSV's) whose src genes were reported to be experimentally transduced from the cell are thought to represent specific markers of host-derived src sequences. By contrast, we have pointed out previously that these markers may represent point mutations of parental equivalents. Here we have compared the src-specific sequences of eight RSV strains and of two rRSV's to each other and to a molecular clone of the src-related chicken locus. Our comparisons are based on RNase T(1)-resistant oligonucleotides of RNA hybridized to src-specific cDNA, which was prepared by hybridizing RSV cDNA with RNA of isogenic src deletion mutants, or to a cloned cellular src-related DNA. All of the approximately 20 src-oligonucleotides of a given RSV strain were recovered by src-specific cDNA's of all other RSV strains or by cellular src-related DNA. The number of oligonucleotides varied slightly with the length of the src deletion used to prepare src-specific cDNA, thus providing a measure for src deletion mutants. Our data indicate that the src genes of all RSV strains tested, including the two reportedly transduced from the cell, are about 98% conserved and completely allelic with only scattered single nucleotide differences in certain variable regions which are subject to point mutations. Hence, based on the src oligonucleotide markers analyzed by us and others, we cannot distinguish between a cellular and viral origin of rRSV's. However, the following are not compatible with a cellular origin of rRSV's. (i) The only putative oligonucleotide marker which is exclusively shared by the two rRSV's studied and which differs from a parental counterpart in a single base was not detectable in cellular src-related DNA. (ii) The number of different allelic src markers observed by us and others in rRSV's was too large to derive from one or two known cellular src-related loci. (iii) The known absence of linkage of the cellular src-related locus with other virion sequences was extended to all non-src oligonucleotides, including some mapping directly adjacent to src. This is difficult to reconcile with the claim that transformation-defective, partial src deletion mutants of RSV which contain both, one, or, as we show here, possibly no src termini nevertheless transduce at the same frequencies, even though homologous, single or double illegitimate recombinations would be involved. Given (i) our evidence that src genes are subject to point mutation under selective conditions similar to those prevailing when rRSV's were generated and (ii) the lack of absolute evidence for the clonal purity of the transformation-defective, partial src deletion mutants of RSV used to generate rRSV's, we submit that the src genes of rRSV's could have been generated by cross-reactivation of nonoverlapping src deletions or mutation of src variants possibly present in transformation-defective, partial src deletion mutants of RSV. To prove experimental transduction, unambiguous markers need to be identified, or it would be necessary to generate rRSV's with molecularly cloned transformation-defective, partial src deletion mutants of RSV. Although our evidence casts doubt on the idea that specific src sequences of rRSV's originated by transduction, the close relationship between viral src and cellular src-related sequences argues that src genes originated at one time in evolution from the cell by events that involved illegitimate recombination and deletion of non-src sequences that interrupt the cellular src locus.