Protein-induced conformational changes in 16 S ribosomal RNA during the initial assembly steps of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit

A structural model for the assembly of the 30S subunit of the ribosome

The order in which proteins bind to 16S rRNA, the assembly map, was determined by Nomura and co-workers in the early 1970s. The assembly map shows the dependencies of binding of successive proteins but fails to address the relationship of these dependencies to the three-dimensional folding of the ribosome. Here, using molecular mechanics techniques, we rationalize the order of protein binding in terms of ribosomal folding. We determined the specific contacts between the ribosomal proteins and 16S rRNA from a crystal structure of the 30S subunit (1FJG). We then used these contacts as restraints in a rigid body Monte-Carlo simulation with reduced-representation models of the RNA and proteins. Proteins were added sequentially to the RNA in the order that they appear in the assembly map. Our results show that proteins nucleate the folding of the head, platform, and body domains, but they do not strongly restrict the orientations of the domains relative to one another. We also examined the contributions of individual proteins to the formation of binding sites for sequential proteins in the assembly process. Binding sites for the primary binding proteins are generally more ordered in the naked RNA than those for other proteins. Furthermore, we examined one pathway in the assembly map and found that the addition of early binding proteins helps to organize the RNA around the binding sites of proteins that bind later. It appears that the order of assembly depends on the degree of pre-organization of each protein's binding site at a given stage of assembly, and the impact that the binding of each protein has on the organization of the remaining unoccupied binding sites.

Crystal structure of the 30 S ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus: structure of the proteins and their interactions with 16 S RNA

We present a detailed analysis of the protein structures in the 30 S ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus, and their interactions with 16 S RNA based on a crystal structure at 3.05 A resolution. With 20 different polypeptide chains, the 30 S subunit adds significantly to our data base of RNA structure and protein-RNA interactions. In addition to globular domains, many of the proteins have long, extended regions, either in the termini or in internal loops, which make extensive contact to the RNA component and are involved in stabilizing RNA tertiary structure. Many ribosomal proteins share similar alpha+beta sandwich folds, but we show that the topology of this domain varies considerably, as do the ways in which the proteins interact with RNA. Analysis of the protein-RNA interactions in the context of ribosomal assembly shows that the primary binders are globular proteins that bind at RNA multihelix junctions, whereas proteins with long extensions assemble later. We attempt to correlate the structure with a large body of biochemical and genetic data on the 30 S subunit.

All three functional domains of the large ribosomal subunit protein L25 are required for both early and late pre-rRNA processing steps in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutational analysis has shown that the integrity of the region in domain III of 25S rRNA that is involved in binding of ribosomal protein L25 is essential for the production of mature 25S rRNA in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. However, even structural alterations that do not noticeably affect recognition by L25, as measured by an in vitro assay, strongly reduced 25S rRNA formation by inhibiting the removal of ITS2 from the 27S(B) precursor. In order to analyze the role of L25 in yeast pre-rRNA processing further we studied the effect of genetic depletion of the protein or mutation of each of its three previously identified functional domains, involved in nuclear import (N-terminal), RNA binding (central) and 60S subunit assembly (C-terminal), respectively. Depletion of L25 or mutating its (pre-)rRNA-binding domain blocked conversion of the 27S(B) precursor to 5.8S/25S rRNA, confirming that assembly of L25 is essential for ITS2 processing. However, mutations in either the N- or the C-terminal domain of L25, which only marginally affect its ability to bind to (pre-)rRNA, also resulted in defective ITS2 processing. Furthermore, in all cases there was a notable reduction in the efficiency of processing at the early cleavage sites A0, A1 and A2. We conclude that the assembly of L25 is necessary but not sufficient for removal of ITS2, as well as for fully efficient cleavage at the early sites. Additional elements located in the N- as well as C-terminal domains of L25 are required for both aspects of pre-rRNA processing.

Structure and mass analysis by scanning transmission electron microscopy

In the scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) an electron beam of a few angstroms diameter is raster scanned over a thin sample and the scattered electrons are sequentially measured for each sample element irradiated. The mass, the elemental composition and the structure of a protein can be simultaneously assessed if all detector systems of the STEM are used. Aspects affecting the accuracy of the mass measurement technique and the demands placed on the instrument's dark-field detector system are outlined. In addition, the influences of some sample preparation techniques are noted and the mass-loss induced at ambient temperatures by the incidence of 80kV electrons on various biological samples is reported. Finally, the importance of the STEM for the structural analysis of proteins is documented by examples.

Domain III of Saccharomyces cerevisiae 25 S ribosomal RNA: its role in binding of ribosomal protein L25 and 60 S subunit formation

Domain III of Saccharomyces cerevisiae 25 S rRNA contains the recognition site for the primary rRNA-binding ribosomal protein L25, which belongs to the functionally conserved EL23/L25 family of ribosomal proteins. The EL23/L25 binding region is very complex, consisting of several irregular helices held together by long-distance secondary and tertiary interactions. Moreover, it contains the eukaryote-specific V9 (D7a) expansion segment. Functional characterisation of the structural elements of this site by a detailed in vitro and in vivo mutational analysis indicates the presence of two separate regions that are directly involved in L25 binding. In particular, mutation of either of two conserved nucleotides in the loop of helix 49 significantly reduces in vitro L25 binding, thus strongly supporting their role as attachment sites for the r-protein. Two other helices appear to be primarily required for the correct folding of the binding site. Mutations that abolish in vitro binding of L25 block accumulation of 25 S rRNA in vivo because they stall pre-rRNA processing at the level of its immediate precursor, the 27 S(B) pre-rRNA. Surprisingly, several mutations that do not significantly affect L25 binding in vitro cause the same lethal defect in 27 S(B) pre-rRNA processing. Deletion of the V9 expansion segment also leads to under-accumulation of mature 25 S rRNA and a twofold reduction in growth rate. We conclude that an intact domain III, including the V9 expansion segment, is essential for normal processing and assembly of 25 S rRNA.

Ribosomal protein S7: a new RNA-binding motif with structural similarities to a DNA architectural factor

BACKGROUND

The ribosome is a ribonucleoprotein complex which performs the crucial function of protein biosynthesis. Its role is to decode mRNAs within the cell and to synthesize the corresponding proteins. Ribosomal protein S7 is located at the head of the small (30S) subunit of the ribosome and faces into the decoding centre. S7 is one of the primary 16S rRNA-binding proteins responsible for initiating the assembly of the head of the 30S subunit. In addition, S7 has been shown to be the major protein component to cross-link with tRNA molecules bound at both the aminoacyl-tRNA (A) and peptidyl-tRNA (P) sites of the ribosome. The ribosomal protein S7 clearly plays an important role in ribosome function. It was hoped that an atomic-resolution structure of this protein would aid our understanding of ribosomal mechanisms.

RESULTS

The structure of ribosomal protein S7 from Bacillus stearothermophilus has been solved at 2.5 A resolution using multiwavelength anomalous diffraction and selenomethionyl-substituted proteins. The molecule consists of a helical hydrophobic core domain and a beta-ribbon arm extending from the hydrophobic core. The helical core domain is composed of a pair of entangled helix-turn-helix motifs; the fold of the core is similar to that of a DNA architectural factor. Highly conserved basic and aromatic residues are clustered on one face of the S7 molecule and create a 16S rRNA contact surface.

CONCLUSIONS

The molecular structure of S7, together with the results of previous cross-linking experiments, suggest how this ribosomal protein binds to the 3' major domain of 16S rRNA and mediates the folding of 16S rRNA to create the ribosome decoding centre.

Assembly of a ribonucleoprotein catalyst by tertiary structure capture

CBP2 is an RNA tertiary structure binding protein required for efficient splicing of a yeast mitochondrial group I intron. CBP2 must wait for folding of the two RNA domains that make up the catalytic core before it can bind. In a subsequent step, association of the 5' domain of the RNA is stabilized by additional interactions with the protein. Thus, CBP2 functions primarily to capture otherwise transient RNA tertiary structures. This simple one-RNA, one-protein system has revealed how the kinetic pathway of RNA folding can direct the assembly of a specific ribonucleoprotein complex. There are parallels to steps in the formation of a much more complex ribonucleoprotein, the 30S ribosomal subunit.

Structures of small subunit ribosomal RNAs in situ from Escherichia coli and Thermomyces lanuginosus

Small ribosomal subunits from the prokaryote Escherichia coli and the eukaryote Thermomyces lanuginosus were imaged electron spectroscopically, and single particle analysis used to yield three-dimensional reconstructions of the net phosphorus distribution representing the nucleic acid (RNA) backbone. This direct approach showed both ribosomal RNAs to have a three domain structure and other characteristic morphological features. The eukaryotic small ribosomal subunit had a prominent bill present in the head domain, while the prokaryotic subunit had a small vestigial bill. Both ribosomal subunits contained a thick 'collar' central domain which correlates to the site of the evolutionarily conserved ribosomal RNA core, and the location of the majority of ribosomal RNA bases that have been implicated in translation. The reconstruction of the prokaryotic subunit had a prominent protrusion extending from the collar, forming a channel approximately 1.5 nm wide and potentially representing a 'bridge' to the large subunit in the intact monosome. The basal domain of the prokaryotic ribosomal subunit was protein free. In this region of the eukaryotic subunit, there were two basal lobes composed of ribosomal RNA, consistent with previous hypotheses that this is a site for the 'non-conserved core' ribosomal RNA.

Interaction of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S7 with 16S rRNA

The interaction between Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S7 and 16S rRNA was investigated using in vitro synthesized RNA transcripts. It was shown by nitrocellulose membrane filtration that RNA transcripts corresponding to the 3' major domain (nucleotides 926-1393) and to the lower half of this domain (nucleotides 926-986/1219-1393) bound S7 with the same affinity as 16S rRNA. A series of deletion mutants of the DNA coding for the lower half of the 3' major domain were constructed and the corresponding RNA fragments were assayed for their capacity to bind S7. A minimal domain of 108 nucleotides which can still efficiently bind S7 was thus obtained. In this domain, the 1304-1308/1329-1333 irregular helix and the 1351-1371 irregular hairpin were found to contain important determinants for S7 binding.

A paradigm for local conformational control of function in the ribosome: binding of ribosomal protein S19 to Escherichia coli 16S rRNA in the presence of S7 is required for methylation of m2G966 and blocks methylation of m5C967 by their respective methyltransferases

We have partially purified two 16S rRNA-specific methyltransferases, one of which forms m2G966 (m2G MT), while the other one makes m5C967 (m5C MT). The m2G MT uses unmethylated 30S subunits as a substrate, but not free unmethylated 16S rRNA, while the m5C MT functions reciprocally, using free rRNA but not 30S subunits (Nègre, D., Weitzmann, C. and Ofengand, J. (1990) UCLA Symposium: Nucleic Acid Methylation (Alan Liss, New York), pp. 1-17). We have now determined the basis for this unusual inverse specificity at adjacent nucleotides. Binding of ribosomal proteins S7, S9, and S19 to unmodified 16S rRNA individually and in all possible combinations showed that S7 plus S19 were sufficient to block methylation by the m5C MT, while simultaneously inducing methylation by the m2G MT. A purified complex containing stoichiometric amounts of proteins S7, S9, and S19 bound to 16S rRNA was isolated and shown to possess the same methylation properties as 30S subunits, that is, the ability to be methylated by the m2G MT but not by the m5C MT. Since binding of S19 requires prior binding of S7, which had no effect on methylation when bound alone, we attribute the switch in methylase specificity solely to the presence of RNA-bound S19. Single-omission reconstitution of 30S subunits deficient in S19 resulted in particles that could not be efficiently methylated by either enzyme. Thus while binding of S19 is both necessary and sufficient to convert 16S rRNA into a substrate of the m2G MT, binding of either S19 alone or some other protein or combination of proteins to the 16S rRNA can abolish activity of the m5C MT. Binding of S19 to 16S rRNA is known to cause local conformational changes in the 960-975 stem-loop structure surrounding the two methylated nucleotides (Powers, T., Changchien, L.-M., Craven, G. and Noller, H.F. (1988) J. Mol. Biol. 200, 309-319). Our results show that the two ribosomal RNA MTs studied in this work are exquisitely sensitive to this small but nevertheless functionally important structural change.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of the 70S Escherichia coli ribosome in ice: the distribution of ribosomal RNA

A reconstruction, at 40 A, of the Escherichia coli ribosome imaged by cryo-electron microscopy, obtained from 303 projections by a single-particle method of reconstruction, shows the two subunits with unprecedented clarity. In the interior of the subunits, a complex distribution of higher mass density is recognized, which is attributed to ribosomal RNA. The masses corresponding to the 16S and 23S components are linked in the region of the platform of the small subunit. Thus the topography of the rRNA regions responsible for protein synthesis can be described.

Secondary structure of coliphage Q beta RNA. Analysis by electron microscopy

The secondary structure of genomic RNA from the coliphage Q beta has been examined by electron microscopy in the presence of varying concentrations of spermidine using the Kleinschmidt spreading technique. The size and position of structural features that cover 70% of the viral genome have been mapped. The structural features that are visualized by electron microscopy in Q beta RNA are large. They range in size from 170 to 1600 nucleotides. A loop containing approximately 450 nucleotides is located at the 5' end of the RNA. It includes the initiation region for the viral maturation protein. A large hairpin containing approximately 1600 nucleotides is located in the center of the molecule. It is multibranched and includes most of the viral coat gene, the readthrough region of the A1 gene, and approximately one third of the viral replicase gene. Within the central hairpin, the initiation region for the viral replicase gene pairs with a region within the distal third of the viral coat gene. This structure may participate in the regulation of translational initiation of the viral replicase gene. Two structural variants of the central hairpin were observed. One of them brings the internal S and M viral replicase binding regions into juxtaposition. These observations suggest that the central hairpin may also participate in the regulation of translation of the viral coat gene. The secondary structures that are observed in Q beta RNA differ significantly from structures that we described previously in the genomic RNA of coliphage MS2 but are similar to structures we observed by electron microscopy in the related group B coliphage SP.

Assembly of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit reveals protein-dependent folding of the 16S rRNA domains

Protein-nucleic acid interactions involved in the assembly process of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit were quantitatively analyzed by high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy. The in vitro reconstituted ribonucleoprotein (core) particles were characterized by their morphology, mass, and radii of gyration. During the assembly of the 30S subunit, the 16S rRNA underwent significant conformational changes that were governed by the cooperative interactions of the ribosomal proteins. The sequential association of the first 12 proteins with the 16S rRNA resulted in the formation of core particles containing up to three mass centers at distinct stages of the assembly process. These globular mass centers may correspond to the three major domains (5', central, and 3') of the 16S rRNA. Through the subsequent interactions of the late assembly proteins with the 16S rRNA, two of the three domains merge, yielding the basic structural traits of the native 30S subunit. The fine morphological features of the native 30S subunit became distinctly resolved only after the addition of the full complement of proteins. The fully reconstituted 30S subunits are active in polyphenylalanine synthesis assays. Visualization of the assembly mechanism of the E. coli 30S ribosomal subunit revealed domain-specific folding of the 16S rRNA through the formation of distinct intermediate core particles hitherto not observed.

Images of 16S ribosomal RNA by scanning tunnelling microscopy

We report the use of scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) to study surface topographies of complex nucleic acid structures. From low-resolution STM images of uncoated 16S ribosomal RNA, we demonstrate the possibility of determining several objective parameters (molecular mass and radius of gyration) in order to characterize and identify the molecules observed. These parameters were compared with values obtained by other physical methods and the radius of gyration was found to be the most reliable. At high resolution, it was possible to measure the main dimensions of selected V-form particles more precisely than with electron microscopy. Images of the more compact form have been also obtained that show different domains in the macromolecular structure.

Scanning tunnelling microscopy of 16S ribosomal RNA in water

The scanning tunnelling microscope has been used to image 16S ribosomal RNA molecules in water electrophoretically deposited on graphite surface. Two kinds of images have been obtained: images showing aggregates of 16S ribosomal RNA molecules similar to those obtained from DNA solutions and others showing individual 16S ribosomal RNA molecules. An interesting characteristic of these images, recorded in constant current mode, is that the 16S ribosomal RNA molecules appear to be located below the graphite surface. The morphology and several structural parameters of the molecules were consistent with the data obtained from electron microscopy.

Heterogeneity of Escherichia coli ribosomes established by scanning transmission electron microscopy

Quantitative mass image analysis of Escherichia coli ribosomal particles by scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) provided direct evidence that presumably homogeneous preparations of ribosomes are, in reality, populations of heterogeneous particles. Variations in composition, relative molecular mass (Mr) and shape were observed both in the monosomes and in the ribosomal subunits. None of these changes can be resolved visually; they can be evaluated only by computer processing. The variations in relative mass and shape monitored by values of radius of gyration (RG) were attributed to the loss of ribosomal proteins and/or factors and correlated with the changes in ribosome composition and biological activity. The highest activity was found in monosomes prepared from the standard 0.5 M NH4Cl wash. With increasing concentrations (up to 1.5 M) of NH4Cl in the wash buffer the activity decreased slowly, then dropped rapidly to about half in 2 M NH4Cl. The most striking effects were observed in ribosomal particles washed with 0.1 M NH4Cl. The 70S monosomes and the 30S subunits attained maximum Mr and RG values (2660 kDa and 76 A, and 990 kDa and 75 A, respectively), which were greater than the theoretical values, while the activity was minimal (approximately 12%). The Mr and RG parameters of the 50S subunits remained uneffected by the NH4Cl washes (approximately 1600 kDa and 68 A).

Purification of E. coli 30S ribosomal proteins by high-performance liquid chromatography under non-denaturing conditions

High-performance ion-exchange chromatography was applied to the separation of proteins from the 30S ribosomal subunit under non-denaturing conditions. It was shown that a single chromatographic step only allows the purification of nine proteins. To increase the number of separated proteins, a prefractionation step was added that depends on the physical characteristics of the proteins to be purified. Sixteen out of 21 proteins could be purified by using prefractionation (gel permeation and lithium chloride salt washing). This method is well suited to preparing fresh samples on demand for optical studies owing to the simplicity of the buffers used and the amounts of proteins recovered in the eluted peaks (0.05-0.1 mg/ml).

Higher-order structure of the 5.8 S rRNA sequence within the yeast 35 S precursor ribosomal RNA synthesized in vitro

Dimethylsulfate, 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl)-carbodiimide metho-p-toluene-sulfonate, RNase T1 and RNase V1 have been used as structure-sensitive probes to examine the higher-order structure of the 5.8 S rRNA sequence within the yeast 35 S precursor ribosomal RNA molecule. Data produced have been used to evaluate several theoretical structure models for the 5.8 S rRNA sequence within the precursor rRNA. These models are generated by minimum free energy calculations. A model is proposed that accommodates 83% of the residues experimentally shown to be in either base-paired or single-stranded structure in the correct configuration. Several alternative suboptimal secondary structures have been evaluated. Moreover, the chemical reactivities of several residues within the 5.8 S rRNA sequence in the precursor rRNA molecule differ from those of the corresponding residues in the mature rRNA molecule. This finding provides experimental evidence to support the notion that the 5.8 S rRNA sequence within the precursor rRNA undergoes structural reorganization following rRNA processing.

Vaults. III. Vault ribonucleoprotein particles open into flower-like structures with octagonal symmetry

The structure of rat liver vault ribonucleoprotein particles was examined using several different staining techniques in conjunction with EM and digestion with hydrolytic enzymes. Quantitative scanning transmission EM demonstrates that each vault particle has a total mass of 12.9 +/- 1 MD and contains two centers of mass, suggesting that each vault particle is a dimer. Freeze-etch reveals that each vault opens into delicate flower-like structures, in which eight rectangular petals are joined to a central ring, each by a thin hook. Vaults examined by negative stain and conventional transmission EM (CTEM) also reveal the flower-like structure. Trypsin treatment of vaults resulted exclusively in cleavage of the major vault protein (p104) and concurrently alters their structure as revealed by negative stain/CTEM, consistent with a localization of p104 to the flower petals. We propose a structural model that predicts the stoichiometry of vault proteins and RNA, defines vault dimer-monomer interactions, and describes two possible modes for unfolding of vaults into flowers. These highly dynamic structural variations are likely to play a role in vault function.

Structural analysis of the 5' domain of the HeLa 18S ribosomal RNA by chemical and enzymatic probing

The secondary structure of HeLa 18S rRNA was investigated by a combination of chemical and enzymatic probing techniques. Using four chemical reagents (DMS*, kethoxal, DEPC and CMCT) which react specifically with unpaired bases and two nucleases (RNase T1 and cobra venom nuclease) which cleave the ribopolynucleotides at unpaired guanines and helical segments, we have analyzed the secondary structure of the 5' domain of 18S rRNA isolated from HeLa 40S ribosomal subunits. The sites at which chemical modifications and nuclease cleavages occurred were identified by primer extension using synthetic deoxyoligonucleotides and reverse transcriptase. These studies led to the deduction of an intra-RNA pairing pattern from the available secondary structure models based on comparative sequence analysis. Apart from the general canonical pairing we have identified noncanonical U-U, G-A, A-G, A-C, C-A and G-G pairing in HeLa 18S rRNA. The differential reactivity of bases to chemical reagents has enabled us to predict the possible configuration of these bases in some of the noncanonical pairing. The absence of chemical reactivities and cobra venom nuclease sensitivity in the terminal loops of helices 6 and 12 indicate a tertiary interaction unique to HeLa 18S rRNA. We have confirmed the existence of the complex tertiary folding recently proposed (Gutell and Woese 1990 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 87, 663-667) for the universally conserved helix 19 in HeLa 18S rRNA. The complementarity of chemical modifications and enzymatic cleavages provided experimental evidence for the proposal of a model structure for the 655 nucleotides of the 5' domain of HeLa 18S rRNA.

Visualization of ion-dependent conformational changes in Escherichia coli 23 S rRNA by scanning transmission electron microscopy

Electron micrographs of Escherichia coli 23 S rRNA molecules obtained by scanning transmission electron microscopy, unstained and under nondenaturing conditions, reveal previously unresolved structural patterns. The complexity of the pattern is dependent upon the ambient ionic strength conditions. In water and in very low ionic strength buffer, the conformation of 23 S rRNA is characterized by an extended framework, with short side branches related to the secondary and tertiary structure of the molecule. The total length of this filamentous complex is approximately 2500 A, only about one-fourth of the length of 23 S rRNA when fully stretched under the denaturing conditions used for imaging by conventional electron microscopy. These data, supplemented by the determination of the linear density (M/L), suggest that in low ionic strength the backbone of 23 S rRNA is formed by a structure corresponding, on the average, to the mass of four nucleotide strands (M/L approximately equal to 480 Da/A). With increasing ionic strength, 23 S rRNA coils into more compact forms. Molecules in these states can be characterized by apparent radii of gyration (RG), which can be calculated from the mass distribution within the digitized images of individual RNA molecules. The 23 S rRNA is in its most condensed form (RG = 115 A) in ribosomal reconstitution buffer; however, it still does not attain the compactness of the large subunit (RG = 69 A), nor does it show any resemblance to the native 50 S subunit. The net content of ordered secondary structure, as determined by circular dichroism spectroscopy, is not visibly affected by the changes of ionic strength conditions. These results imply that the observed conformational changes in 23 S rRNA are caused by intramolecular folding of the 23 S rRNA strands induced by the shielding effect of ambient charges.