Chromosome analysis of human spermatozoa exposed to antineoplastic agents in vitro

DNA damage in human sperm: The sperm chromosome assay

Background

Sperm DNA damage is a major cause of pre‐ and post‐implantation embryonic loss in humans. However, the factors that control how and when such DNA damage occurs in human sperm are poorly understood.

Methods

Here, I review information relating to sperm DNA damage that can be obtained from the sperm chromosome assays described in the existing literature.

Main findings

The sperm chromosome assays, which consist of interspecific in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection using murine oocytes and subsequent chromosome analysis, indicate that the proportion of sperm showing DNA damage is initially low and there are larger numbers of sperm with potential membrane and DNA damage that are induced after ejaculation and separation from the seminal plasma. Other assays that directly detect sperm DNA (e.g., TUNEL assays, Comet assays, and acridine orange test) are not able to distinguish and detect the initial and potential DNA damage. Furthermore, the positive values in these direct assays are influenced by the frequency of immotile sperm and amorphous sperm populations.

Conclusion

The findings in the sperm chromosome assays show that further improvements in sperm preparation protocols may result in the reduction of sperm DNA damage, followed by more successful outcomes in infertility treatment.

Chromosomal integrity and DNA damage in freeze-dried spermatozoa

Freeze-drying technology may one day be used to preserve mammalian spermatozoa indefinitely without cryopreservation. Freeze-dried mouse spermatozoa stored below 4°C for up to 1 year have maintained the ability to fertilize oocytes and support normal development. The maximum storage period for spermatozoa increases at lower storage temperatures. Freeze-drying, per se, may reduce the integrity of chromosomes in freeze-dried mouse spermatozoa, but induction of chromosomal damage is suppressed if spermatozoa are incubated with divalent cation chelating agents prior to freeze-drying. Nevertheless, chromosomal damage does accumulate in spermatozoa stored at temperatures above 4°C. Currently, no established methods or strategies can prevent or reduce damage accumulation, and damage accumulation during storage is a serious obstacle to advances in freeze-drying technology. Chromosomal integrity of freeze-dried human spermatozoa have roughly background levels of chromosomal damage after storage at 4°C for 1 month, but whether these spermatozoa can produce healthy newborns is unknown. The safety of using freeze-dried human spermatozoa must be evaluated based on the risks of heritable chromosome and DNA damage that accumulates during storage.

Characterization of chromosomal damage accumulated in freeze-dried mouse spermatozoa preserved under ambient and heat stress conditions

Structural chromosome aberrations and DNA damage generated in freeze-dried mouse spermatozoa were investigated. Freeze-dried sperm samples were preserved at 4, 25 and 50°C for short duration (1 day to 2 months) and at 25°C for long duration (2 years). The spermatozoa were injected into mouse oocytes to analyse the chromosomes of the zygotes at the first cleavage metaphase. Chromosome break of the chromosome-type aberrations was the most common type of structural chromosome aberrations observed in all freeze-dried samples. The frequency of chromatid exchanges rapidly increased in freeze-dried spermatozoa preserved at 50°C for 1-5 days. The frequency of chromatid-type aberrations (break and exchange) gradually increased in freeze-dried spermatozoa preserved at 25°C for up to 2 months. Alkaline comet assay revealed significant migration of damaged DNA accumulated in freeze-dried spermatozoa preserved at 50°C for 3 days and 25°C for 2 years. However, no DNA damage was detected using the same sperm samples by neutral comet assay, which can detect mostly DNA double-strand breaks in cellular DNA. These results suggest that DNA single-strand breaks were accumulated in freeze-dried spermatozoa preserved under ambient or heat conditions, and then chromatid-type aberrations, especially the chromatid exchanges, were formed via post-replication repair system in zygotes.

A novel method for detection of chromosomal integrity in cryopreserved livestock spermatozoa using artificially fused mouse oocytes

PURPOSE

The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of mouse oocyte volume on the efficiency of chromosomal analysis in livestock spermatozoa.

METHODS

Oocytes were injected with bull, ram, boar and dog sperm heads, and then fused with enucleated mouse oocytes.

RESULTS

The increment of oocyte volume increased the rates of morphologically normal oocytes after sperm injection, which induced much higher rates of overall chromosome detection in bull, ram and dog spermatozoa. The recipient oocyte volume did not affect the chromosomal integrity. Furthermore, in bull, the chromosomal integrity detected by fused mouse oocytes was similar to that derived from a homologous system. On the other hand, chromosomal plates of boar spermatozoa could not be detected despite the use of fused oocytes.

CONCLUSION

These data indicate that fused mouse oocytes improved the efficiency of chromosome detection in bull, ram and dog spermatozoa.

ReProComet: a new in vitro method to assess DNA damage in mammalian sperm

The increasing request of chemical safety assessment demands for the validation of alternative methods to reduce the resort to animal experimentation. Methods that evaluate reproductive toxicity are among those requiring the largest use of animals. Presently, no validated in vitro alternative exists for the assessment of reproductive toxicity. Mammalian sperm are sensitive targets of DNA-reactive chemicals, which form premutagenic adducts. Here, we propose a new method based on comet assay to detect DNA damage induced by potential germ cell mutagens in bull sperm available from assisted reproduction practices. In somatic cells, chemical-induced adducts can be revealed by comet assay that detects DNA breaks produced during adduct repair. Mature sperm, however, are devoid of repair enzymes, and adducts are processed only after fertilization. For this reason, comet assay is not sensitive to detect DNA lesions induced in sperm by most chemicals. To overcome such limitation, we developed a modified comet assay based on the addition of a protein extract from HeLa cells to agarose-embedded sperm on microscopic slides. To test the method, sperm were treated in vitro with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) or melphalan (MLP) and comet assay was conducted both with and without protein supplementation. No effect of MMS or MLP was detected without protein supplementation; on the contrary, a clear-cut dose-dependent effect was measured after addition of the cell extract. These results represent a proof of concept of a novel in vitro mutagenicity test on sperm that could offer a promising approach to complement previously validated in vivo germ cell genotoxicity assays.

Differential susceptibility to chromatid breaks induced by bleomycin in sub-fertile and fertile bovines

The rate of chromatid breaks was studied in cows with a history of sub-fertility by means of a test based on measurement of the average of breaks induced in lymphocytes of peripheral blood cultures. Fourteen female specimens were divided into two groups: fertile and sub-fertile. Peripheral blood lymphocytes were cultured and prepared for cytogenetic analysis. Two types of culture were established for each animal to evaluate the response of peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures to the genotoxic effects of bleomycin. The first culture did not receive bleomycin treatment (spontaneous chromosome aberrations). Our results showed that median breaks per cell (b/c) (+/-semirange) for spontaneous culture of the fertile and sub-fertile animals and bleomycin sensitivity assay for fertile and sub-fertile animals were 0.00+/-0.06, 0.02+/-0.03, 0.08+/-0.05 and 0.22+/-0.09, respectively. There was no significant difference (P>0.05) in the chromosomal breakage in lymphocytes not exposed to bleomycin; however, in comparing the number of chromatid breaks per cell in cultures treated with bleomycin, the sub-fertile group showed a significantly higher (P<0.05) level than the fertile group. These findings have implications both for identifying cattle with less than optimum fertility as well as for providing potential avenues to study the origins of sub-fertility.

Radiation- and chemical-induced structural chromosome aberrations in human spermatozoa

Previous studies on the clastogenic effects of mutagens on human sperm chromosomes were reviewed. A marked increase of structural chromosome aberrations (SCAs) has been reported in the spermatozoa irradiated in vitro with five kinds of ionizing radiation (137Cs gamma-, 60Co gamma-, X-, and 3H beta-rays and 252Cf neutrons). The micronucleus (MN) test with hybrid two-cell embryos generated from human sperm and hamster oocytes was shown to be useful as a simple and rapid method for assessing the effects of radiation. Radiosensitivity of human spermatozoa was highest, being followed by golden hamster, Chinese hamster and mouse spermatozoa. Chromosome-damaging effects were also found with some chemicals (bleomycin, daunomycin, methyl methanesulfonate, triethylenemelamine, neocarzinostatin, N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitorosoguanidine and mitomycin C (MMC)), but not with other chemicals (urethane, nitrobenzene, dioxin, cyclophosphamide (CP), benzo(a)pyrene (BP) and N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA)). The clastogenicity of chemical metabolites was confirmed for CP and BP, by using the S9-based metabolic activation system. The results of sperm chromosome analysis from cancer patients who had undergone radio- and/or chemotherapy were contradictory among investigators and further studies are necessary. The importance of mutagenicity testing with human spermatozoa is discussed.

Chromosome analysis of human spermatozoa following in vitro exposure to cyclophosphamide, benzo(a)pyrene and N-nitrosodimethylamine in the presence of rat liver S9

For the purpose of assessing mutagenic effects (clastogenicity) of metabolites derived from chemical mutagens/carcinogens on human sperm chromosomes, spermatozoa were exposed in vitro to cyclophosphamide (CP), benzo(a)pyrene (BP) or N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) for 2h in the presence or absence of rat liver S9, a metabolic activator of these chemicals. After in vitro fertilization between human spermatozoa and zona-free hamster oocytes, chromosome complements of sperm origin were analyzed cytogenetically. In the absence of S9, none of three chemicals (20 microg/ml CP, 200 microg/ml BP and 20mg/ml NDMA) caused a significant increase in spermatozoa with structural chromosome aberrations (8.6, 10.0 and 7.5%), as compared with their matched controls (10.9, 11.0 and 8.5%). In the presence of S9, however, a significant increase in chromosomally abnormal spermatozoa was observed in CP (37.1%, P < 0.001) and BP (31.0%, P < 0.001), indicating that enzymatic activation of CP and BP induced chromosomal abnormalities in human sperm. In contrast, NDMA did not induce chromosome aberrations in human spermatozoa by S9 treatment, although positive results have been observed in somatic cells. The present results on in vitro clastogenicity of CP, BP and NDMA are consistent with the results in previous in vivo studies with murine spermatozoa. Our S9/human sperm chromosome assay seems to be useful for estimation of hereditary risk of chemicals in human. Because most chemicals need metabolic activation to bind to DNA.

Chromosome-type aberrations induced in chromosome 9 after treatment of human peripheral blood lymphocytes with mitomycin C at the G(0) phase

To determine the fate of chromosome aberrations induced primarily by clastogenic chemicals, aberrations of chromosome 9 in cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes were analyzed after exposure to mitomycin C (MMC) at G(0) phase. Chromosome 9 painting by fluorescence in situ hybridization revealed that the translocation of 9p or 9q to another chromosome and the centric fragment representing the entire length of 9p were characteristically generated from chromatid-type aberrations involving the centromeric region of chromosome 9. These changes were not observed at 48 h after culture initiation, but persistently appeared at later stages (72-120 h postinitiation). Induction of centric fragments of 9p and micronuclei without the alpha satellite DNA of chromosome 9 suggested that most of the breaks were induced near the alpha satellite DNA locus on 9q. Modified patterns of chromosome 9 aberrations were also observed, being related to the copy number of the short or long arm of the chromosome. Such unbalanced karyotypes could remain in the lymphocyte genome over further cell divisions for at least 120 h after culture initiation, indicating that these aberrant cells can survive and that they could pose a health risk.

No induction of chromosome aberrations in human spermatozoa exposed to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields

Clastogenic effects of extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields (ELF-EMFs) on human sperm chromosomes were studied using an interspecific in vitro fertilization system with zona-free golden hamster oocytes. Semen samples from healthy men were exposed to ELF-EMFs (50 Hz, 20 mT) for 2 h at 37 degreesC under 5% CO2 in air. The samples were then cryopreserved in liquid nitrogen for shipment to a cytogenetic laboratory. After thawing the samples, motile spermatozoa were collected using a continuous Percoll density gradient centrifugation and then capacitated for in vitro fertilization with hamster oocytes. Sperm-derived chromosomes were analyzed at first cleavage metaphase. The present experiment was performed twice using semen samples from two different donors. In test-1, incidence of spermatozoa that displayed structural chromosome aberrations was 17.0% (35/206) in the exposed group and 20.8% (55/264) in the control group. In test-2, structural chromosome aberrations were observed in 11.1% (13/117) of exposed spermatozoa and 13.8% (13/94) of spermatozoa in the control group. In both tests, there was no significant difference in the incidence of chromosomally abnormal spermatozoa between the exposed group and the control group. Types of aberrations observed and their incidences per spermatozoon in the exposed group were similar to those of the control group. Despite the small sample size, the present results suggest that ELF-EMFs have no clastogenic effect on human sperm chromosomes.

Mutagenic damage to mammalian cells by therapeutic alkylating agents

Cytotoxic alkylating agents used as therapeutics include nitrogen mustards, ethyleneimines, alkyl sulfonates, nitrosoureas and triazenes. Their reactivity with DNA, RNA and proteins can cause cell death. Side-effects of treatment include tissue toxicity and secondary malignancies, likely due to the genetic damage induced. The full mutagenic potential of alkylating agents may only be realised after they undergo metabolic activation, principally by cytochromes P450. Mutagenicity is related to the ability of alkylating agents to form crosslinks and/or transfer an alkyl group to form monoadducts in DNA. The most frequent location of adducts in the DNA is at guanines. Expressed mutations involve different base substitutions, including all types of transitions and transversions. The mutational spectra of alkylating agents on mammalian cells is distinct from that induced in bacterial cells, reflecting the different codon usage by bacteria and differences in DNA repair and replication enzymes. Mutations are induced by busulfan, chlorambucil (CAB), cyclophosphamide (CP, or its metabolite), dacarbazine, mechlorethamine, melphalan, mitomycin-C (MMC), nitrosoureas and thiotepa. Although dose-dependent, the relationship is not always linear. The molarities at which alkylating agents induce cell killing and mutations vary over three orders of magnitude. The mutagenic efficiency, of alkylating agents also varies, with some agents inducing three times more mutations for equivalent cell killing. The induction of micronuclei, sister chromatid exchanges, or chromosome aberrations is variable, but has been observed for CP, CAB, MMC, melphalan and triethylenemelamine. There is insufficient information to determine whether any synergistic effects of alkylating agents used in combination will influence the cytotoxic and mutagenic damage equally. Understanding the potential synergy of alkylating agents at the cellular and molecular level should allow improvement of the therapeutic efficacy of alkylating agents without increasing the unwanted mutation induction.

Cytogenetic damage measured in human sperm following cancer chemotherapy

Germ-line cytogenetic damage is well documented in laboratory animals exposed to anti-cancer agents, but has been harder to verify in the human. This paper reviews published studies demonstrating cytogenetic damage in human sperm following exposure to anti-cancer chemicals, as measured by the human-sperm/ hamster-egg cytogenetic technique and fluorescence in situ hybridization. These two assays have provided important information on one step in the pathway leading to induced, transmissible germ line damage in the human. By way of introduction, a short review of the traditional human endpoints used to address the question of induced, transmissible genetic damage in human germ cells (mutation epidemiology) related to anti-cancer chemicals is presented.

Detection of neocarzinostatin-induced translocations in human sperm chromosomes using fluorescence in situ hybridization of chromosome 2

Mature sperm and late spermatid are known to be sensitive stages to clastogens in mammalian spermatogenesis. Certain types of chromosomal damage induced in these stages will pass to successive generations as heritable translocations. In the present study, we employed whole chromosome 2 painting with the fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) technique to detect the chemically induced translocations in human sperm. Mature human sperm were treated in vitro with an antitumor drug, neocarzinostatin (NCS), and fertilized in vitro with golden hamster oocytes. Sperm pronuclear chromosome slides were prepared at the first cleavage metaphase. To compare the characteristics of translocations between somatic and germ cells, human lymphocytes in peripheral blood treated with NCS in vitro were analyzed at first round metaphase after PHA-stimulation. From the analysis of translocations by whole chromosome 2 painting, frequencies of the haploid genomic translocations (FhG) were predicted for both sperm and lymphocytes. At 1.0 micrograms/ml, the actual percentages of sperm and lymphocytes with chromosome 2 translocations were almost identical (11.9% and 12.0%). At the same dose, however, the FhG of the sperm (1.15) was considerably higher than that of the lymphocytes (0.58), indicating that complex translocations having two or more rearranged sites were induced by NCS more frequently in sperm than in lymphocytes.

Detection of aneuploidy in human and rodent sperm using FISH and applications of sperm assays of genetic damage in heritable risk evaluation

Efficient molecular methods are being developed for detecting various types of cytogenetic genetic damage in sperm, especially numerical aneuploidy for chromosomes involved in trisomies that survive at birth. These methods provide new approaches for identifying potentially detrimental environmental exposures, genetic predisposition, chromosomal rearrangements, and physiologic factors which may increase a man's risk of fathering a genetically defective offspring. Corollary methods are also being developed for detecting sperm aneuploidy in laboratory rodents and these will be used to make inter-species comparisons of mutagen sensitivities and for investigating mechanisms of induction and persistence of aneuploidy. Validated assays for detecting genetic alterations in human and rodent sperm (of which sperm aneuploidy is a first example) permit comparisons of somatic and germinal response to mutagens within individuals, comparisons of human and rodent germinal sensitivity to mutagens, and can be applied in an extended parallelogram model to sperm for assessing heritable risk resulting from paternal mutagen exposures.

Difference in types of radiation-induced structural chromosome aberrations and their incidences between Chinese and Syrian hamster spermatozoa

The effects of ionizing radiations on sperm chromosomes were studied in the Chinese hamster (Crisetulus griseus) and the Syrian (golden) hamster (Mesocrisetus auratus). Testes of mature male Chinese hamsters (CH) were irradiated with X-rays (0.91, 1.82 and 3.63 Gy) and gamma-rays (1.10, 2.15, 2.95 and 4.01 Gy) at a single acute dosage, whereas the irradiation was done with lower doses of X-rays (0.45, 0.91 and 1.82 Gy) and gamma-rays (0.49, 0.99 and 1.98 Gy) in mature male Syrian hamsters (SH), taking the higher radiosensitivity of this species into consideration. They were mated with normal females within 6 days of exposure. Sperm-derived chromosomes were analyzed in 1125 and 1966 fertilized ova of the CH and the SH, respectively. In both species, there was no great difference in the induction of structural chromosome aberrations between X-irradiated and gamma-irradiated spermatozoa. Chromosome-type aberrations were predominantly induced. The incidence of breakage-type aberrations increased linearly, and that of exchange-type aberrations linear-quadratically with increase of dosage. A species-specific difference in chromosomal radiosensitivity of spermatozoa was clear. In spite of the same radiation dosage, the incidence of chromosomally abnormal spermatozoa in the SH was about twice as high as that in the CH (e.g. 27.0% vs. 14.7% at 0.91 Gy of X-rays). The incidences of breakage-type aberrations (69-89%) were far higher than those of exchange-type aberrations (11-31%) in the SH, while the disparity of the two incidences was much smaller in the CH (46-65% vs. 35-54%). Exchange-type aberrations consisted of both chromosome-type and chromatid-type in the SH, while almost all of them were of the chromosome-type in the CH. These results suggest that the DNA-repairing capacity of oocytes is much higher in the CH than in the SH. Moreover, it seems likely that radiation-induced sperm DNA damage is repaired with both pre-replication repair (excision repair) and post-replication repair systems in SH oocytes, whereas the excision repair system operate most exclusively in CH oocytes.