Extragenic suppression of temperature-sensitive phenotype in reovirus: mapping suppressor mutations

Evolution of the Piscine orthoreovirus Genome Linked to Emergence of Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation in Farmed Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar)

Heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) in farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) was first diagnosed in Norway in 1999. The disease is caused by Piscine orthoreovirus-1 (PRV-1). The virus is prevalent in farmed Atlantic salmon, but not always associated with disease. Phylogeny and sequence analyses of 31 PRV-1 genomes collected over a 30-year period from fish with or without HSMI, grouped the viral sequences into two main monophylogenetic clusters, one associated with HSMI and the other with low virulent PRV-1 isolates. A PRV-1 strain from Norway sampled in 1988, a decade before the emergence of HSMI, grouped with the low virulent HSMI cluster. The two distinct monophylogenetic clusters were particularly evident for segments S1 and M2. Only a limited number of amino acids were unique to the association with HSMI, and they all located to S1 and M2 encoded proteins. The observed co-evolution of the S1-M2 pair coincided in time with the emergence of HSMI in Norway, and may have evolved through accumulation of mutations and/or segment reassortment. Sequences of S1-M2 suggest selection of the HSMI associated pair, and that this segment pair has remained almost unchanged in Norwegian salmon aquaculture since 1997. PRV-1 strains from the North American Pacific Coast and Faroe Islands have not undergone this evolution, and are more closely related to the PRV-1 precursor strains not associated with clinical HSMI.

Reconciliation of rotavirus temperature-sensitive mutant collections and assignment of reassortment groups D, J, and K to genome segments

Four rotavirus SA11 temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants and seven rotavirus RRV ts mutants, isolated at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and not genetically characterized, were assigned to reassortment groups by pairwise crosses with the SA11 mutant group prototypes isolated and characterized at Baylor College of Medicine (BCM). Among the NIH mutants, three of the RRV mutants and all four SA11 mutants contained mutations in single reassortment groups, and four RRV mutants contained mutations in multiple groups. One NIH mutant [RRVtsK(2)] identified the previously undefined 11th reassortment group (K) expected for rotavirus. Three NIH single mutant RRV viruses, RRVtsD(7), RRVtsJ(5), and RRVtsK(2), were in reassortment groups not previously mapped to genome segments. These mutants were mapped using classical genetic methods, including backcrosses to demonstrate reversion or suppression in reassortants with incongruent genotype and temperature phenotype. Once located to specific genome segments by genetic means, the mutations responsible for the ts phenotype were identified by sequencing. The reassortment group K mutant RRVtsK(2) maps to genome segment 9 and has a Thr280Ileu mutation in the capsid surface glycoprotein VP7. The group D mutant RRVtsD(7) maps to segment 5 and has a Leu140Val mutation in the nonstructural interferon (IFN) antagonist protein NSP1. The group J mutant RRVtsJ(5) maps to segment 11 and has an Ala182Gly mutation affecting only the NSP5 open reading frame. Rotavirus ts mutation groups are now mapped to 9 of the 11 rotavirus genome segments. Possible segment locations of the two remaining unmapped ts mutant groups are discussed.

Type 3 reovirus neuroinvasion after intramuscular inoculation: viral genetic determinants of lethality and spinal cord infection

To better understand the mechanisms by which neurotropic viruses invade peripheral nerve pathways and produce CNS disease, we defined the type 3 (T3) reovirus genes that are determinants of the capacity of reovirus T3 strain Dearing (T3D) and T3 clone 9 (C9) to infect the spinal cord and kill mice after hindlimb injection. T3D and C9 viruses are both highly virulent (LD(50) < 10(1) PFU) after intracranial injection of neonatal mice. However, C9 is significantly more lethal than T3D after either intramuscular injection (LD(50) < 10(1) vs LD(50) 10(4) PFU) or peroral injection (LD(50) 10(3.4) vs LD(50) > 10(8.3) PFU). Using reassortant viruses containing different combinations of genes derived from T3D and C9, we found that the S1 gene, encoding the cell attachment protein sigma 1 and the nonstructural protein sigma 1s, and the L3 gene, encoding the core shell protein lambda 1 were the primary determinants of lethality after intramuscular injection. The L3 gene and the L2 gene encoding spike protein, lambda 2, determined differences in spinal cord titer after intramuscular injection. A C9 x T3D mono-reassortant containing all T3D genes except for the C9-derived L3 was lethal after peroral injection. These studies indicate that the S1, L2, and L3 genes all play a potential role in neuroinvasiveness and provide the first identification of a role in pathogenesis for the L3 gene.

Structure of the reovirus outer capsid and dsRNA-binding protein sigma3 at 1.8 A resolution

The crystallographically determined structure of the reovirus outer capsid protein sigma3 reveals a two-lobed structure organized around a long central helix. The smaller of the two lobes includes a CCHC zinc-binding site. Residues that vary between strains and serotypes lie mainly on one surface of the protein; residues on the opposite surface are conserved. From a fit of this model to a reconstruction of the whole virion from electron cryomicroscopy, we propose that each sigma3 subunit is positioned with the small lobe anchoring it to the protein mu1 on the surface of the virion, and the large lobe, the site of initial cleavages during entry-related proteolytic disassembly, protruding outwards. The surface containing variable residues faces solvent. The crystallographic asymmetric unit contains two sigma3 subunits, tightly associated as a dimer. One broad surface of the dimer has a positively charged surface patch, which extends across the dyad. In infected cells, sigma3 binds dsRNA and inhibits the interferon response. The location and extent of the positively charged surface patch suggest that the dimer is the RNA-binding form of sigma3.

In vitro recoating of reovirus cores with baculovirus-expressed outer-capsid proteins mu1 and sigma3

Reovirus outer-capsid proteins mu1, sigma3, and sigma1 are thought to be assembled onto nascent core-like particles within infected cells, leading to the production of progeny virions. Consistent with this model, we report the in vitro assembly of baculovirus-expressed mu1 and sigma3 onto purified cores that lack mu1, sigma3, and sigma1. The resulting particles (recoated cores, or r-cores) closely resembled native virions in protein composition (except for lacking cell attachment protein sigma1), buoyant density, and particle morphology by scanning cryoelectron microscopy. Transmission cryoelectron microscopy and image reconstruction of r-cores confirmed that they closely resembled virions in the structure of the outer capsid and revealed that assembly of mu1 and sigma3 onto cores had induced rearrangement of the pentameric lambda2 turrets into a conformation approximating that in virions. r-cores, like virions, underwent proteolytic conversion to particles resembling native ISVPs (infectious subvirion particles) in protein composition, particle morphology, and capacity to permeabilize membranes in vitro. r-cores were 250- to 500-fold more infectious than cores in murine L cells and, like virions but not ISVPs or cores, were inhibited from productively infecting these cells by the presence of either NH4Cl or E-64. The latter results suggest that r-cores and virions used similar routes of entry into L cells, including processing by lysosomal cysteine proteinases, even though the former particles lacked the sigma1 protein. To examine the utility of r-cores for genetic dissections of mu1 functions in reovirus entry, we generated r-cores containing a mutant form of mu1 that had been engineered to resist cleavage at the delta:phi junction during conversion to ISVP-like particles by chymotrypsin in vitro. Despite their deficit in delta:phi cleavage, these ISVP-like particles were fully competent to permeabilize membranes in vitro and to infect L cells in the presence of NH4Cl, providing new evidence that this cleavage is dispensable for productive infection.

Characterization of an ATPase activity in reovirus cores and its genetic association with core-shell protein lambda1

A previously identified nucleoside triphosphatase activity in mammalian reovirus cores was further characterized by comparing two reovirus strains whose cores differ in their efficiencies of ATP hydrolysis. In assays using a panel of reassortant viruses derived from these strains, the difference in ATPase activity at standard conditions was genetically associated with viral genome segment L3, encoding protein lambda1, a major constituent of the core shell that possesses sequence motifs characteristic of other ATPases. The ATPase activity of cores was affected by several other reaction components, including temperature, pH, nature and concentration of monovalent and divalent cations, and nature and concentration of anions. A strain difference in the response of core ATPase activity to monovalent acetate salts was also mapped to L3/lambda1 by using reassortant viruses. Experiments with different nucleoside triphosphates demonstrated that ATP is the preferred ribonucleotide substrate for cores of both strains. Other experiments suggested that the ATPase is latent in reovirus virions and infectious subviral particles but undergoes activation during production of cores in close association with the protease-mediated degradation of outer-capsid protein mu1 and its cleavage products, suggesting that mu1 may play a role in regulating the ATPase.

Association of reovirus outer capsid proteins sigma 3 and mu 1 causes a conformational change that renders sigma 3 protease sensitive

Association of the reovirus proteins sigma 3 and mu 1 influences viral entry, initiation of outer capsid assembly, and modulation of the effect of sigma 3 on cellular translation. In this study, we have addressed whether structural changes occur in sigma 3 as a result of its interaction with mu 1. Using differences in protease sensitivity to detect conformationally distinct forms of sigma 3, we showed that association of sigma 3 with mu 1 caused a conformational change in sigma 3 that converted it from a protease-resistant to a protease-sensitive structure and occurred posttranslationally. The effect of mu 1 on the structure of sigma 3 was stoichiometric. Our results are consistent with a model in which sigma 3's association with mu 1 shifts its function from translational control to assembly of an outer capsid in which sigma 3 is folded into the protease-sensitive conformation that is required for its cleavage during the next round of infection.

Genetic mapping of reovirus virulence and organ tropism in severe combined immunodeficient mice: organ-specific virulence genes

We used reovirus reassortant genetics and severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice to define viral genes important for organ tropism and virulence in the absence of antigen-specific immunity. Adult SCID mice infected with reovirus serotype 1 strain Lang (T1L) died after 20 +/- 6 days, while infection with serotype 3 strain Dearing (T3D) was lethal after 77 +/- 22 days. One hundred forty-five adult SCID mice were infected with T1L, T3D, and 25 different T1L x T3D reassortant reoviruses, and gene segments associated with the increased virulence of T1L were identified. Gene segments S1, L2, M1, and L1 accounted for > 90% of the genetically determined increase in T1L virulence. Gene segment M1 was independently important for virulence, with S1, L2, and L1 alone or in combination also playing a role. T1L grew to higher titers in multiple organs and caused more severe hepatitis than T3D. Seventy adult SCID mice, T1L, T3D, and 15 T1L x T3D reassortant viruses were used to map genetic determinants of viral titers in the brain, intestines, and liver, as well as the severity of hepatitis. Different sets of gene segments were important for determining viral titers in different organs. Gene segments L1 (encoding a core protein) and L2 (encoding the core spike of the virion) were important in all of the organs analyzed. The M1 gene segment (encoding a core protein), but not the S1 gene segment, was a critical determinant of reovirus titer in the liver and severity of hepatitis. The S1 gene segment (encoding the viral cell attachment protein and a nonstructural protein), but not the M1 gene segment, was a critical determinant of titers in intestines and brains. These studies demonstrate that viral growth in different organs is dependent on different subsets of the genes important for virulence. The virion-associated protein products of the four gene segments (L1, L2, M1, and S1) important for virulence and organ tropism in SCID mice likely form a structural unit, the reovirus vertex. Organs (the brain and intestines versus the liver) differ in properties that determine which virulence genes, and thus which parts of this structural unit, are important.

Sequence diversity within the reovirus S2 gene: reovirus genes reassort in nature, and their termini are predicted to form a panhandle motif

To better understand genetic diversity within mammalian reoviruses, we determined S2 nucleotide and deduced sigma 2 amino acid sequences of nine reovirus strains and compared these sequences with those of prototype strains of the three reovirus serotypes. The S2 gene and sigma 2 protein are highly conserved among the four type 1, one type 2, and seven type 3 strains studied. Phylogenetic analyses based on S2 nucleotide sequences of the 12 reovirus strains indicate that diversity within the S2 gene is independent of viral serotype. Additionally, we found marked topological differences between phylogenetic trees generated from S1 and S2 gene nucleotide sequences of the seven type 3 strains. These results demonstrate that reovirus S1 and S2 genes have distinct evolutionary histories, thus providing phylogenetic evidence for lateral transfer of reovirus genes in nature. When variability among the 12 sigma 2-encoding S2 nucleotide sequences was analyzed at synonymous positions, we found that approximately 60 nucleotides at the 5' terminus and 30 nucleotides at the 3' terminus were markedly conserved in comparison with other sigma 2-encoding regions of S2. Predictions of RNA secondary structures indicate that the more conserved S2 sequences participate in the formation of an extended region of duplex RNA interrupted by a pair of stem-loops. Among the 12 deduced sigma 2 amino acid sequences examined, substitutions were observed at only 11% of amino acid positions. This finding suggests that constraints on the structure or function of sigma 2, perhaps in part because of its location in the virion core, have limited sequence diversity within this protein.

Studies of the major reovirus core protein sigma 2: reversion of the assembly-defective mutant tsC447 is an intragenic process and involves back mutation of Asp-383 to Asn

The reovirus group C temperature-sensitive mutant tsC447, whose defect maps to the S2 gene, which encodes the major core protein sigma 2, fails to assemble core particles at the nonpermissive temperature. To identify other proteins that may interact with sigma 2 during assembly, we generated and examined 10 independent revertants of the mutant. To determine which gene(s) carried a compensatory suppressor mutation(s), we generated intertypic reassortants between wild-type reovirus serotype 1 Lang and each revertant and determined the temperature sensitivities of the reassortants by efficiency-of-plating assays. Results of the efficiency-of-plating analyses indicated that reversion of the tsC447 defect was an intragenic process in all revertants. To identify the region(s) of sigma 2 that had reverted, we determined the nucleotide sequences of the S2 genes. In all revertant sequences examined, the G at nucleotide position 1166 in tsC447 had reverted to the A present in the wild-type sequence. This reversion leads to the restoration of a wild-type asparagine (in place of a mutant aspartic acid) at amino acid 383 in the sigma 2 sequence. These results collectively indicate that the functional lesion in tsC447 is Asp-383 and that this lesion cannot be corrected by alterations in other core proteins. These observations suggest that this region of sigma 2, which may be important in mediating assembly of the core particle, does not interact significantly with other reovirus proteins.

Monoclonal antibodies to reovirus reveal structure/function relationships between capsid proteins and genetics of susceptibility to antibody action

Thirteen newly isolated monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) were used to study relationships between reovirus outer capsid proteins sigma 3, mu 1c, and lambda 2 (core spike) and the cell attachment protein sigma 1. We focused on sigma 1-associated properties of serotype specificity and hemagglutination (HA). Competition between MAbs revealed two surface epitopes on mu 1c that were highly conserved between reovirus serotype 1 Lang (T1L) and serotype 3 Dearing (T3D). There were several differences between T1L and T3D sigma 3 epitope maps. Studies using T1L x T3D reassortants showed that primary sequence differences between T1L and T3D sigma 3 proteins accounted for differences in sigma 3 epitope maps. Four of 12 non-sigma 1 MAbs showed a serotype-associated pattern of binding to 25 reovirus field isolates. Thus, for reovirus field isolates, different sigma 1 proteins are associated with preferred epitopes on other outer capsid proteins. Further evidence for a close structural and functional interrelationship between sigma 3/mu 1c and sigma 1 included (i) inhibition by sigma 3 and mu 1c MAbs of sigma 1-mediated HA, (ii) enhancement of sigma 1-mediated HA by proteolytic cleavage of sigma 3 and mu 1c, and (iii) genetic studies demonstrating that sigma 1 controlled the capacity of sigma 3 MAbs to inhibit HA. These data suggest that (i) epitopes on sigma 3 and mu 1c lie in close proximity to sigma 1 and that MAbs to these epitopes can modulate sigma 1-mediated functions, (ii) these spatial relationships have functional significance, since removal of sigma 3 and/or cleavage of mu 1c to delta can enhance sigma 1 function, (iii) in nature, the sigma 1 protein places selective constraints on the epitope structure of the other capsid proteins, and (iv) viral susceptibility to antibody action can be determined by genes other than that encoding an antibody's epitope.

Intracellular RNA synthesis directed by temperature-sensitive mutants of simian rotavirus SA11

The kinetics of intracellular synthesis of single-stranded (ss) RNA and double-stranded (ds) RNA directed by prototype temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants representing the 10 mutant groups of rotavirus SA11 were examined. Cells were infected with individual mutants or wild type under one-step growth conditions and maintained at permissive temperature (31 degrees) or nonpermissive temperature (39 degrees). At various times postinfection, infected cells were pulse-labeled, ssRNA and dsRNA were purified, RNA species were resolved by electrophoresis and autoradiography, and RNA synthesis was quantitated by computer-assisted densitometry. The mutants representing all groups synthesized significantly less ssRNA and dsRNA at both 31 degrees and 39 degrees, when compared to wild type. When the ratio of synthesis at 39 degrees/31 degrees was determined for ssRNA and dsRNA of each mutant, three RNA synthesis phenotypes were evident. The tsB(339), tsC(606), and tsE(1400) mutants synthesized both ssRNA and dsRNA in a temperature-dependent manner. The group G mutant, tsG(2130), synthesized ssRNA in temperature-independent fashion but was temperature-dependent for the synthesis of dsRNA. The remaining mutants, tsA(778), tsD(975), tsF(2124), tsH(2384), tsI(2403), and tsJ(2131), synthesized both ssRNA and dsRNA in a temperature-independent fashion. The RNA synthesis phenotypes of the ts mutants are discussed in terms of what is known of the function(s) of the protein species to which ts lesions have been assigned.

Phenotypes of rotavirus reassortants depend upon the recipient genetic background

We have previously characterized the biological and immunological properties of a simian rotavirus SA11 variant (4F) with an altered genome segment 4. The SA11-4F variant formed large plaques in the presence of protease, formed small clear plaques in the absence of protease, and grew to high titer in the presence of protease when compared to our standard wild type (SA11 clone 3). To determine the genome segment of the rotavirus SA11 variant 4F that encoded the unique protease-associated phenotypes of the variant, reassortants were generated that segregated the outer capsid genes of 4F onto a genetic background derived from either the bovine rotavirus B223 or our standard SA11 wild type (clone 3), both of which have contrasting protease-associated phenotypes. The parental and reassortant viruses were examined to determine which genes from the 4F variant encoded the ability (i) to form large plaques in the presence of protease, (ii) to form small clear plaques in the absence of exogenous protease, and (iii) to grow to significantly higher titer in the presence of protease. These phenotypes could be transferred to a clone 3 genetic background by a single genome segment from the 4F variant segment 4. However, in the 4F/B223 reassortants a different and unexpected situation was found. On a B223 genetic background the same phenotypes segregated with a combination of a minimum of two 4F genome segments, segments 4 and 9. These results indicate that the recipient genetic background onto which the genes of a donor rotavirus are reassorted can affect the phenotypes conferred by the presence of the donor segments. Thus, the results of segregation mapping experiments using reassortant viruses should be interpreted with caution.

Reassortant rotaviruses containing structural proteins vp3 and vp7 from different parents induce antibodies protective against each parental serotype

Genetic studies of reassortant rotaviruses have demonstrated that gene segments 4 and 9 each segregate with the serotype-specific neutralization phenotype in vitro. Reassortant rotaviruses derived by coinfection of MA-104 cells with the simian strain SA11 and the antigenically distinct bovine strain NCDV were used to determine which viral genes coded for proteins which induced a protective immune response in vivo. In addition, reassortant rotaviruses containing only the gene segment 4 or 9 protein products (vp3 and vp7, respectively) from SA11 or NCDV were used to determine the serotypic specificities of both vp3 and vp7 in several mammalian rotavirus strains. vp3 and vp7 from the murine strain Eb were shown to be indistinguishable from the corresponding proteins from strain SA11. Adult mice orally inoculated with strain Eb developed neutralizing antibodies to both vp3 and vp7. The two naturally occurring bovine rotavirus strains NCDV and UK were shown to contain antigenically similar vp7 but distinct vp3 proteins. Mouse dams orally immunized with a reassortant virus containing only gene 9 from NCDV passively protected their progeny against UK challenge, whereas mouse dams orally immunized with a reassortant virus containing only gene 4 from NCDV did not. Finally, we constructed reassortant viruses that immunized against rotaviruses of two distinct serotypes. SA11 X NCDV reassortants that contained vp3 and vp7 from different parents induced a protective immune response against both parental serotypes. vp3 and vp7 were independently capable of inducing a protective immune response after oral immunization. An understanding of the serotypic specificities of both vp3 and vp7 of human rotavirus isolates will be necessary for the development of successful strategies to protect infants against severe rotavirus infections.

Suppression of growth and protein secretion defects in Escherichia coli secA mutants by decreasing protein synthesis

We devised a new selection for conditionally lethal suppressors of secA mutants. This selection allows the isolation of both temperature-sensitive and cold-sensitive suppressor mutations, whereas previous studies were limited to nonlethal or cold-sensitive suppressor mutations. Two temperature-sensitive suppressor mutations lie in genes required for protein synthesis: asnS, the gene for the asparaginyl-tRNA synthetase, and divE, which encodes the tRNASer1. A previously characterized mutation in alaS, the gene for the alanyl-tRNA synthetase, suppresses the growth and secretion defects of a secA mutant. Although the primary effects of these suppressor mutations are different, it is likely that they cause suppression of secA mutations by altering the rate of protein synthesis, since the protein synthesis inhibitors, chloramphenicol and tetracycline, also suppress secA mutations. Chloramphenicol also suppresses the growth defect of certain other sec mutants. We postulate that the impaired secretory capacity of sec mutants can be offset by decreasing the rate of elongation of secreted proteins or by decreasing the total amount of secreted proteins per cell. The results indicate that our initial goal to identify cellular secretory components as suppressors of secA mutations might be difficult to achieve because of a high frequency of nonspecific suppressors that alter protein synthesis. Unexpectedly, the suppressor approach provides a direct genetic selection for mutants in protein synthesis.

Sequence of reovirus haemagglutinin predicts a coiled-coil structure

The use of modern techniques has led to new insights into the molecular mechanisms of viral pathogenesis. Although the infectious process is quite complex, it is clear that one critical stage, the interaction of viral attachment proteins with cell-surface receptors, often has a major role in determining the pattern of infection. The mammalian reoviruses have served as useful models for understanding the molecular basis of viral pathogenesis. The mammalian reovirus haemagglutinin (sigma 1 protein), which is an outer capsid protein, has been shown to be a major factor in determining virus-host cell interactions. To further our understanding of the structure and function of the haemagglutinin, we have cloned a complementary DNA copy of the reovirus type 3 S1 double-stranded RNA gene which encodes the virus haemagglutinin and have sequenced the DNA complementary to the S1 gene. Analysis of the predicted amino-acid sequence of the virus haemagglutinin has allowed us to determine that the amino-terminal portion contains an alpha-helical coiled-coil structure and that the carboxy-terminal portion contains the receptor-interacting domains. Using this information, we propose here a model of how the reovirus haemagglutinin is attached to the virus particle.

Assignment of simian rotavirus SA11 temperature-sensitive mutant groups B and E to genome segments

Recombinant (reassortant) viruses were selected from crosses between temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of simian rotavirus SA11 and wild-type human rotavirus Wa. The double-stranded genome RNAs of the reassortants were examined by electrophoresis in Tris-glycine-buffered polyacrylamide gels and by dot hybridization with a cloned DNA probe for genome segment 2. Analysis of replacements of genome segments in the reassortants allowed construction of a map correlating genome segments providing functions interchangeable between SA11 and Wa. The reassortants revealed a functional correspondence in order of increasing electrophoretic mobility of genome segments. Analysis of the parental origin of genome segments in ts+ SA11/Wa reassortants derived from the crosses SA11 tsB(339) X Wa and SA11 tsE(1400) X Wa revealed that the group B lesion of tsB(339) was located on genome segment 3 and the group E lesion of tsE(1400) was on segment 8.