Plasmapheresis in active systemic lupus erythematosus: effects on clinical, serum, and cellular abnormalities. Case report

Lessons learned from bone marrow failure in systemic lupus erythematosus: Case reports and review of the literature

OBJECTIVE

In the present review, four new cases of bone marrow failure are presented and the potential contribution of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is discussed. Furthermore, a comprehensive literature review of cases of autoimmune myelofibrosis (AIMF), aplastic anemia (AA), and paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) with concurrent SLE aims to allow their direct comparison. Based on a clearer characterization of reported cases and our own experience, diagnostic and therapeutic strategies of these disorders in SLE are proposed based on lessons learned from the present and previous cases.

METHODS

A literature search was done in PubMed, accessed via the National Library of Medicine PubMed interface (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed). Using PubMed, a Boolean search of the literature was performed by crossing the keywords "systemic lupus erythematosus," AND ["bone marrow fibrosis" or "bone marrow failure" or "myelofibrosis" or "aplastic anemia" or "paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria"].

RESULTS

After a stringent selection of previous cases with a clear diagnosis of SLE, we summarized in the present review 31 cases of AIMF, 26 cases of AA, and 3 cases of PNH. In addition, four new cases illustrate the problem of attribution of bone marrow failure to SLE.

CONCLUSIONS

The attribution of SLE to bone marrow failure is challenging due to a lack of biomarkers, which complicates treatment decisions. Autoimmune myelofibrosis is likely underreported, but corticosteroids and intravenous immunoglobulin appear to be effective immediate therapies. In AA attributable to SLE, a serum inhibitor of bone marrow precursors should be tested, since plasma exchange has been universally successful in these cases, and a PNH clone should be tested for in the setting of ongoing hemolysis, as complement inhibition may be effective. Further research is warranted to elucidate pathophysiological mechanisms of bone marrow failure in SLE.

Therapeutic apheresis in autoimmune diseases

Systemic autoimmune diseases based on an immune pathogenesis produce autoantibodies and circulating immune complexes, which cause inflammation in the tissues of various organs. In most cases, these diseases have a bad prognosis without treatment. Therapeutic apheresis in combination with immunosuppressive therapies has led to a steady increase in survival rates over the last 35 years. Here we provide an overview of the most important pathogenic aspects indicating that therapeutic apheresis can be a supportive therapy in some systemic autoimmune diseases, such as systemic lupus erythematosus, antiphospholipid syndrome, rheumatoid arthritis, and inflammatory eye disease. With the introduction of novel and effective biologic agents, therapeutic apheresis is indicated only in severe cases, such as in rapid progression despite immunosuppressive therapy and/or biologic agents, and in patients with renal involvement, acute generalized vasculitis, thrombocytopenia, leucopenia, pulmonary, cardiac, or cerebral involvement. In mild forms of autoimmune disease, treatment with immunosuppressive therapies and/or biologic agents seems to be sufficient. The prognosis of autoimmune diseases with varying organ manifestations has improved considerably in recent years, due in part to very aggressive therapy schemes.

The use of apheresis in immune renal disorders

Rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis (RPGN) is often associated with the presence of autoantibodies. Included in this group are the glomerulonephritides associated with anti-GBM antibody (Goodpasture's syndrome). IgA mesangial deposition (the renal component of Henoch-Schönlein purpura), lupus erythematosus, cryoglobulinemia and the antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated pauci-immune group. In each of these cases, apheresis may provide a therapeutically useful option. Apheresis has also been found useful in certain types of antibody-mediated transplant rejection and in lowering the levels of preformed cytotoxic antibodies which may preclude transplantation. Finally, there are renal diseases in which the immune component is less clearly involved with pathogenesis but for which apheresis may offer a clear benefit, such as in the renal failure associated with 'cast nephropathy' (multiple myeloma) or the recurrence of FSGS (focal segmental glomerulosclerosis) in transplanted kidneys. It is the purpose of this paper to review the evidence supporting the use of apheresis in immune-related diseases.

Aplastic Anemia in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: A Distinct Presentation of Acquired Aplastic Anemia?

Aplastic anemia is a rare but serious complication of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) with an often dramatic and unanticipated onset. The peripheral destruction of formed blood elements, which frequently accompanies the syndrome, may obscure or delay the diagnosis of bone marrow suppression, and the number of published cases may be an underestimate of the actual incidence of the disease. Furthermore, the disease course may differ significantly from other forms of acquired aplastic anemia and seems to carry a more favorable prognosis once effectively diagnosed and treated. In addition, aplastic anemia may precede other manifestations of SLE. Therefore, the possibility of bone marrow aplasia should be excluded in all SLE patients with severe pancytopenia, and conversely, the diagnosis of SLE should be explored in cases of aplastic anemia. Two patients with aplastic anemia in SLE, one with aplastic anemia preceding the onset of SLE, are described along with 15 cases reviewed from the English language literature. The presentation, prognosis, treatment, and pathogenesis of aplastic anemia complicating SLE are discussed. Recognition that cytopenias, especially pancytopenia, may occur on the basis of inhibited myelopoesis rather than peripheral destruction as either a harbinger of SLE or as a manifestation of disease flare is important. This knowledge will prompt the astute clinician to obtain screening antinuclear antibodies in the setting of otherwise unexplained bone marrow acellularity or, given the prognosis of SLE associated aplastic anemia, give early consideration to more aggressive immunosuppression.

Apheresis for lupus erythematosus: state of the art

PP is a safe, expensive, labor-intensive procedure. Its absolute SLE indications include hyperviscosity, cryoglobulinemia, pulmonary hemorrhage and TTP. PP may be useful in cyclophosphamide-resistant, serious, organ-threatening disease. It may be potentially useful in the antiphospholipid syndrome or mothers or children at risk for congenital heart block. Refinements in apheresis technology may expand the indications for PP.

Apheresis for Renal Disease

Many primary renal diseases are associated with either antibody deposition within the glomerulus or an antibody associated autoimmunity, as may be seen with certain vasculitidies. Examples of these diseases include Goodpasture's syndrome, cryoglobulinemia, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody positive syndromes, and other forms of rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis. Immunoglobulins also may be nephrotoxic to the tubules such as is the case with myeloma related light chains. Given the rapid removal of immunoglobulins by therapeutic plasma exchange, this modality has been considered an appealing management option in the treatment of these renal diseases. Although not classically considered as autoimmune diseases, thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura and hemolytic uremic syndrome are related syndromes which often involve the kidneys. Although previously unexplained, it has been long appreciated that therapeutic plasma exchange (PE) can be a useful treatment for these microangiopathic hemolytic anemias, but the most recent insights into their pathogenesis suggest that PE may be beneficial by replacing a missing enzyme or removing pathogenic autoantibodies.

Apheresis for lupus erythematosus

Indications for the use of apheresis technologies in managing lupus erythematosus have undergone numerous conceptual changes since the procedure was automated in the 1960s and first attempted for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in 1974. Once thought to be a promising treatment for a variety of aspects of SLE, apheresis has been relegated to occupying a few important niches as an adjunct in managing the disorder. This article will review the history, physiology and rationale of apheresis pertaining to SLE. A focused critical review of pertinent literature is presented, along with specific recommendations relating to the place of apheresis in the lupus therapeutic spectrum.

Therapeutic apheresis for renal disorders

Many primary renal diseases are associated with either antibody deposition within the glomerulus or an antibody associated autoimmunity, as may be seen with certain vasculitidies. Other immunoglobulins may be nephrotoxic or glomerulopathic; such may be the case with myeloma related light chains or cryoglobulins. Given the rapid removal of immunoglobulins by therapeutic plasma exchange, this modality has been considered an appealing management option in the treatment of these autoimmune related renal diseases. Although not classically considered as autoimmune diseases, thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura and hemolytic uremic syndrome are related syndromes which often involve the kidneys. In many cases therapeutic plasma exchange has been found to be a useful treatment modality for these microangiopathic hemolytic anemias. This paper will provide a concise review of the renal indications for therapeutic plasma exchange.

Bone marrow findings in systemic lupus erythematosus patients with peripheral cytopenias

We studied 21 bone marrow specimens from 21 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and peripheral cytopenias: anaemia (Hb < 10 g/dl), and/or leucopenia (white blood cell count < 4 x 10(9)/l), and/or thrombocytopenia (platelets < 150 x 10(9)/l). None of the patients had used immunosuppressive drugs in the 2 months before the study, and 11 (52.4%) had never used these drugs. The global and specific series cellularity, degree of fibrosis and necrosis were evaluated by bone marrow trephine; morphological abnormalities and iron stores were evaluated by cytological smears. The most important abnormalities viewed in bone marrow biopsies were: global hypocellularity (47.6%), increased reticulin proliferation (76.2%) with myelofibrosis in one patient, and necrosis (19.0%). The marrow aspirates were difficult to obtain in four patients, who showed an increased reticulin proliferation on histological analysis. Plasmocytosis was present in 26.7% of cases and in one there was a serum monoclonal component (IgG kappa). Iron stores were normal or increased in 26.7% of specimens and decreased or absent in 73.3%. The most frequent peripheral abnormality was leucopenia in 90.4% (19/21) and granulocytic hypoplasia was observed in 47.3% (9/19) of these patients. We conclude that the bone marrow may be a target organ in SLE with cytopenias.

Therapeutic plasma exchange for the treatment of rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis

Therapeutic plasma exchange (TPE) has been widely accepted as a successful means of removing the antiglomerular basement membrane (anti-GBM) antibodies that result in the rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis (RPGN) of Goodpasture's syndrome. TPE has also been investigated as a means of removing the immune complexes associated with the glomerulonephritides of systemic lupus erythematosus, IgA nephropathy, Henoch Schönlein purpura, and cryoglobulinemia. Recently, an antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA) has been implicated in the pathogenesis of RPGN associated with such diseases such as Wegener's granulomatosis and periarteritis nodosa. ANCA has also been found in many cases of RPGN formally considered to be idiopathic. The identification of this autoantibody has given new credence to the possibility that TPE may be beneficial in the treatment of these diseases. This article reviews the data regarding the use of TPE for RPGN.

Apheresis enhances the selective removal of antinuclear antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus

Apheresis suppresses clinical manifestations of lupus and reduces levels of antinuclear antibodies implicated in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). It is not known, however, if reduced levels of antinuclear antibodies are due to nonspecific removal, or specific mechanisms associated with decreased production, or enhanced clearance from the circulation. In order to distinguish between specific and nonspecific effects of apheresis on antinuclear antibodies in SLE, we compared plasma levels of IgG antibodies to DNA and IgG antibodies to microbial antigens in 13 SLE patients before and after apheresis. Although apheresis lowered plasma levels of IgG (21% mean reduction), there was a disproportionate reduction in IgG antibodies to DNA (42% mean reduction, p less than 0.13). In marked contrast, reduction in antibodies to microbial antigens did not exceed those of plasma IgG. A rapid rebound of serum anti-DNA antibodies following apheresis in certain SLE patients suggests that the selective reduction in anti-DNA antibodies is due to enhanced clearance from the circulation rather than decreased production. These results indicate that apheresis enhances selective removal of antinuclear antibodies in some patients with SLE.

Private idiotypes on human polyclonal IgG anti-DNA antibodies are not expressed on coexisting IgM anti-DNA antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus

Sharing of private idiotypes (Id) on human polyclonal IgG anti-double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) with coexisting IgM anti-dsDNA was investigated using rabbit (R) anti-Id raised against IgG anti-dsDNA. The R-anti-Id showed specificity to private Id in or near the antigen-binding sites. The R-anti-Id poorly bound to the immobilized enriched IgM anti-dsDNA preparation but significantly bound to IgG anti-dsDNA preparation by a direct-binding ELISA (0.020 OD vs 0.295 OD, respectively). The R-anti-Id poorly inhibited the binding of IgM anti-dsDNA to immobilized dsDNA but significantly inhibited the binding of IgG anti-dsDNA to dsDNA (6% vs 55% inhibition, respectively). This was confirmed by poor inhibition of binding of the R-anti-Id to immobilized IgG anti-dsDNA by the enriched IgM anti-dsDNA preparation (maximum of 26% inhibition at 50 micrograms/ml). Nonsharing of private Id between IgG and coexisting IgM anti-dsDNA may represent the idiotypic diversity of human anti-DNA antibodies secondary to the frequent occurrence of somatic mutation on anti-DNA antibody during class switching.

Plasma exchange improves the glomerulonephritis of systemic lupus erythematosus in selected pediatric patients

The effects of short-course plasma exchange (PE) followed by tapering dose prednisone therapy was assessed in six children with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and severe glomerulonephritis. All patients received pulse methylprednisolone therapy and three patients were treated with cytotoxic drugs prior to PE, but none had exhibited a good response. PE resulted in a rapid and sustained (greater than 1 year) remission of renal failure in the three patients with renal failure and severe glomerulonephritis. All six patients had severe nephrotic syndrome and five of six experienced a complete and sustained (greater than 1 year) remission post-PE (the sixth patient has greater than 4 month remission at the time of writing). Of interest was the high frequency of membranous [World Health Organization (WHO) Type V] and mixed membranous and diffuse proliferative SLE nephritis (WHO Type IV) on renal biopsy (4/6 patients). In addition, the severe anemia and leukopenia seen in most patients responded favorably to PE. Five of the six patients are currently managed on low-dose prednisone (0.25-0.5 mg/kg) every other day. One patient progressed to renal failure and dialysis more than 1 year post-PE. One patient required cytotoxic drug therapy post-PE (6 weeks). No significant complications were encountered; in fact, all patients eventually received their PE treatments as outpatients. We conclude that PE may provide a safe and effective therapeutic option for the treatment of severe progressive SLE nephritis in selected children who are unresponsive to steroid or cytotoxic drug therapy.

Plasma Exchange in Severe Erythema Nodosum Leprosum

Four patients with severe erythema nodosum leprosum were treated by plasma exchange and/or fresh frozen plasma infusions after failure of classical therapy.

After the procedures, the patients improved rapidly; with a follow-up between 4 and 7 years after the last plasma exchange, no clinical relapse was noted. The replacement fluids were variable; the most beneficial procedure seemed to be plasma exchange replaced with fresh frozen plasma.

Elimination of circulating immune complexes, replacement of a lacking plasma factor are possible mechanisms of action. Plasma exchange may also work like a regulator of immune mechanisms, since it has been shown that there is a depression of suppressor cells in erythema nodosum leprosum.

Immunosuppressive agents and plasmapheresis in immunological disorders

Plasmapheresis (PA) was introduced in the treatment of immunologically mediated disease at the beginning of last decade and it was initially claimed to be the panacea for several diseases. It was quickly realized that PA on its own did not have a sustained therapeutic effect and it was the immunosuppressive drugs which could help in the maintenance of an established effect. In this communication we review the immunoregulatory effects of several immunosuppressive agents and discuss their role when used in conjunction with PA primarily in the treatment of rheumatological disorders.

Aplastic anemia complicating systemic lupus erythematosus: response to androgens in two patients

We describe two female patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) who developed severe aplastic anemia. Although each patient had received multiple medications including diphenylhydantoin, the relationship to these drugs to the development of marrow aplasia was unclear. After administration of an oral androgen (oxymethalone) and corticosteroids, there was complete hematologic recovery. Both patients relapsed when oxymethalone was withdrawn, and both recovered when androgen therapy was reinstituted, with or without high-dose prednisone. In both patients, there was complete reversal of pancytopenia despite the presence of initially severe marrow aplasia (less than 10% cellularity). However, in both cases, prolonged androgen therapy (2 months) was required before hematologic improvement occurred. Androgens are known to stimulate hematopoiesis in man, and they appear to influence immune function in a mouse model of SLE. Thus androgens may be particularly useful in the treatment of SLE-associated aplastic anemia.

Aphresis

Therapeutic apheresis is a relatively new modality. Its absolute indications are few and include hyperviscosity syndrome, cryoglobulinemia, thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura, Goodpasture's syndrome, and life-threatening complications of immunologic disorders refractory to conventional management. The use of apheresis in most of the other disorders discussed in this monograph is experimental and should not be employed unless all the mitigating therapeutic considerations clearly suggest an overwhelming advantage of apheresis. The promise of apheresis is much greater than its current use, and the research applications of specific component separation and antibody removal are of great importance. It is hoped that these new developments will shortly make current devices obsolete and improve the clinical management of patients as well as increase our knowledge of disease etiopathogenesis.

Therapeutic apheresis. Applications and future directions

The past 10-15 years have been witness to major technological achievements in the field of therapeutic apheresis. Concurrently, a large number of diseases, primarily with an immunological basis, have been treated with apheresis. In this paper, we review the various applications of therapeutic apheresis, adverse reactions associated with the mode of therapy, and future research directions. Several representative diseases are also discussed in detail.

Heterogeneity of bone marrow-directed immune mechanisms in the pathogenesis of neutropenia of Felty's syndrome

Twenty-seven patients with Felty's syndrome were studied by the colony forming unit in culture (CFU-C) assay for possible immune mechanisms within the bone marrow compartment that could contribute to the neutropenia. Depletion of bone marrow suppressor T cells resulted in normal CFU-C numbers in 7 patients. In 5 patients serum antiprecursor cell activity was detected. Blood monocytes failed to generate colony stimulating factor in 5 patients. Bone marrow-directed immune mechanisms are heterogeneous and could play a role in the pathogenesis of neutropenia in some patients with Felty's syndrome.

Antibodies reactive with surface membranes of cellular elements in the blood

Autoreactive antibodies or immune complexes may accelerate clearance of mature erythrocytes, leukocytes, and platelets from the circulation in patients with rheumatologic and immunologic disorders. The most compelling evidence for immune injury to hematopoietic cells exists in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and patients with Felty's syndrome and its variants. These disorders may also cause tissue inflammation, which in turn commonly results in underproduction of erythrocytes and development of thrombocytosis. However, recent evidence indicates that underproduction of hematopoietic cells may also result from immune injury to cellular elements in the bone marrow. In many laboratories, sensitive techniques are now clinically available for the detection of cell-associated immunoglobulin and complement. These assays have helped confirm the role of antibody in the pathogenesis of autoimmune hemolytic anemia and idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura. However, recent data indicate that there is probably a continuum between the amount of immunoglobulin and complement found on normal cells and that found in a variety of disease states. In several of these disorders, additional evidence will be required to establish that the increase in cell-bound immunoglobulin leads to a decrease in the life-span of the cell. In order to provide significant help to the clinician managing an individual patient, these serologic tests must be capable of identifying the portion of the cell-associated protein actually involved in the destructive process. The availability of monoclonal reagents capable of identifying restricted regions on cell-bound immunoglobulin may help identify molecules bound specifically as antibody and may help identify the antigens involved in autoimmune disorders.

Pancytopenia with mixed cryoglobulinemia: evidence for anti-percursor cell activity of cryoglobulin--effects of plasmapheresis

The efficacy of plasmapheresis in a patient with mixed cryoglobulinemia and pancytopenia is shown. The cryoglobulin was shown to have percursor cell suppressing activity and its depletion by plasmapheresis resulted in improvement of blood counts, Indications, limitations and guidelines for plasmapheresis in various diseases are discussed.