Exocoelomic space, limb reduction, and CVS

Synthesis of evidence from epidemiological studies with interval-censored exposure due to grouping

We describe a method for assessing dose-response effects from a series of case-control and cohort studies in which the exposure information is interval censored. The interval censoring of the exposure variable is dealt with through the use of retrospective models in which the exposure is treated as a multinomial response and disease status as a binary covariate. Polychotomous logistic regression models are adopted in which the dose-response relationship between exposure and disease may be modeled in a discrete or continuous fashion. Partial conditioning is possible to eliminate some of the nuisance parameters. The methods are applied to the motivating study of the relationship between chorionic villus sampling and the occurrence of terminal transverse limb reduction.

Adverse effects of chorionic villus sampling: a meta-analysis

Meta-analysis is a popular tool for combining evidence from several related studies. The technique is usually used to combine randomized clinical trials, case-control studies or prospective studies where each study has its own exposed and unexposed groups. By including separate 'study effects' (either fixed or random), one can combine information about differences between control and exposed groups, while still allowing for study heterogeneity. In this paper, we extend existing methods to combine studies of disparate designs, where some studies do not include concurrent controls. We apply the methods to a meta-analysis of the association of prenatal testing via chorionic villus sampling with the occurrence of terminal transverse limb defects.

Chorionic villus sampling and materno-fetal transfusions: an immunological pathogenesis of vascular disruptive syndromes?

Experimental materno-embryonic transfusions with serum that is immunologically active against blood group antigens cause congenital malformations in the rat embryo. In view of the possible increased incidence of vascular disruptive syndromes after chorionic villus sampling (CVS), we investigated the occurrence of materno-fetal transfusions (MFTs) in this procedure. In 18 pregnant women experiencing two needle introductions at CVS, we looked immunohistochemically at the presence of haemoglobin A1-containing maternal erythrocytes in the fetal circulation of the separately collected first and second chorionic villus samples. In 4 of 18 patients (22 per cent), a significant increase of maternal cells was observed in the second sample compared with the first sample, indicating the occurrence of MFT by CVS. On the rare occasion of maternal immunization against fetal antigens, a CVS-associated MFT might provoke immunological damage to the fetus.

Analysis of limb reduction defects in babies exposed to chorionic villus sampling

In 1991 we reported a cluster of babies with limb abnormalities and suggested that chorionic villus sampling (CVS) was aetiologically associated with these defects. To address the issue more objectively, we have assessed reported limb reduction defects in 75 babies exposed to CVS in utero. 13 babies had an absent limb or a defect through the humerus or femur; 9 had defects through the radius or tibia; 22 defects of the carpus, tarsus, metacarpus, or metatarsus; 25 defects of the digits; and 6 defects of the terminal phalanx or nail only. There was a strong correlation between the severity of the defects and the duration of gestation when CVS was done. The median gestational age at CVS ranged from 56 (range 49-65) postmenstrual days for the most severe category to 72 (51-98) days for the least severe. The relation was seen for both isolated limb defects and for cases with oromandibular-limb hypogenesis syndromes. This relation is further evidence that CVS has an aetiological role in some limb reduction anomalies.

Transverse limb reduction defects after chorion villus sampling: a retrospective cohort study. GIDEF--Gruppo Italiano Diagnosi Embrio-Fetali

A retrospective cohort study was performed in five Italian obstetrical centres from 1984 to 1991 in order to verify the association between chorionic villus sampling (CVS) and transverse limb reduction defects (TLRDs). TLRD rates by period of gestation at CVS were calculated, and the study's results were compared with data from the general population. Of the 3430 pregnancies for which CVS was performed, 2759 had a known outcome. The overall rate for TLRDs was 1 in 1143 CVS pregnancies, four times higher than that of the general population in Italy (1 in 4458). The rate of TLRDs was 2.9/1000 for CVS performed at 9 weeks' gestation and 1.0/1000 for CVS at 10 weeks' gestation. A scalp defect was detected in a pregnancy in which CVS was performed at 10 weeks. A high proportion of pregnancies lost to follow-up and the poor quality of the data may have affected the results. Nevertheless, our results suggest an association between CVS carried out at less than 10 weeks' gestation and TLRDs which is consistent with the findings of other studies. CVS should not be prepared at less than 10 weeks' gestation until additional evidence is obtained.

Limb anomalies following chorionic villus sampling: a registry based case-control study

Using data from the Italian Multicentric Birth Defect Registry a case-control study was performed to verify if chorionic villus sampling (CVS) was associated with transverse limb defects (TLD), with or without features of oro-mandibular-limb hypogenesis complex (OMLHC), in the exposed offspring. The results show that the risk of TLD and OMLHC is increased following CVS, and is particularly high for CVS performed early in pregnancy, i.e., under 70 days of gestational age. These results, together with a review of other epidemiologic studies, biological data and clinical reports, strongly suggest a causative role of CVS as a risk factor for TLD and indicate that at this stage CVS before 70 days of gestational age should be discouraged as an option for prenatal diagnosis and that all patients wishing to undergo CVS should be informed about the possible risk of the procedure.

Distal limb deficiency following chorionic villus sampling?

We have reviewed the follow-up of almost 3000 completed pregnancies in the Münster CVS Program and identified 4 children with distal limb deficiencies. Two cases involved only minor anomalies of distal digital phalanges. One child had a Hanhart anomaly (hypoglossia hypodactylia). We also reviewed 24 cases of limb defects following CVS reported previously. With the exception of a single series, neither the overall incidence of affected children nor cases reported from larger series provide unambiguous evidence of an increased risk of distal limb deficiency caused by CVS.