Mutagenesis induced by single UV photoproducts in E. coli and yeast

Detection and Quantification of UV-irradiation-induced DNA Damages by Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry and Immunoassay†

Solar ultraviolet (UV)-induced DNA lesions are associated with skin carcinogenesis. The detection of these DNA lesions is important to understand their genotoxicity and health effects. However, sunlight exposure-relevant DNA damage measurement is still a challenge. Here, we summarize our recent progresses on the related analytical techniques, including synthesis of dimeric lesions, the optimization of procedures for ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography-coupled mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS/MS), and the maturation of anti-T(6-4)T photoproduct antibodies and their potential applications for immunoassay.

Formation of UV-induced DNA damage contributing to skin cancer development

UV-induced DNA damage plays a key role in the initiation phase of skin cancer. When left unrepaired or when damaged cells are not eliminated by apoptosis, DNA lesions express their mutagneic properties, leading to the activation of proto-oncogene or the inactivation of tumor suppression genes. The chemical nature and the amount of DNA damage strongly depend on the wavelength of the incident photons. The most energetic part of the solar spectrum at the Earth's surface (UVB, 280-320 nm) leads to the formation of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) and pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts (64PPs). Less energetic but 20-times more intense UVA (320-400 nm) also induces the formation of CPDs together with a wide variety of oxidatively generated lesions such as single strand breaks and oxidized bases. Among those, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoGua) is the most frequent since it can be produced by several mechanisms. Data available on the respective yield of DNA photoproducts in cells and skin show that exposure to sunlight mostly induces pyrimidine dimers, which explains the mutational signature found in skin tumors, with lower amounts of 8-oxoGua and strand breaks. The present review aims at describing the basic photochemistry of DNA and discussing the quantitative formation of the different UV-induced DNA lesions reported in the literature. Additional information on mutagenesis, repair and photoprotection is briefly provided.

Insight in DNA Repair of UV-induced Pyrimidine Dimers by Chromatographic Methods

UV-induced formation of pyrimidine dimers in DNA is a major deleterious event in both eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. Accumulation of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts can lead to cell death or be at the origin of mutations. In skin, UV induction of DNA damage is a major initiating event in tumorigenesis. To counteract these deleterious effects, all cell types possess DNA repair machinery, such as nucleotide excision repair and, in some cell types, direct reversion. Different analytical approaches were used to assess the efficiency of repair and decipher the enzymatic mechanisms. We presently review the information provided by chromatographic methods, which are complementary to biochemical assays, such as immunological detection and electrophoresis-based techniques. Chromatographic assays are interesting in their ability to provide quantitative data on a wide range of damage and are also valuable tools for the identification of repair intermediates.

Rhodobacter sphaeroides CryB is a bacterial cryptochrome with (6-4) photolyase activity

Photolyases are efficient DNA repair enzymes that specifically repair either cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers or (6-4) photoproducts in a light-dependent cleavage reaction. The closely related classical cryptochrome blue light photoreceptors do not repair DNA lesions; instead they are involved in regulatory processes. CryB of Rhodobacter sphaeroides was until now described as a cryptochrome that affects light-dependent and singlet oxygen-dependent gene expression and is unusual in terms of its cofactor composition. Here we present evidence for a repair activity of (6-4) photoproducts by CryB and suggest a dual character combining the functions of cryptochromes and photolyases. We investigated the effects of crucial amino acids involved in cofactor or DNA lesion binding on the light-dependent recovery of cells after UV light exposure (in vivo photoreactivation). Remarkably, impairment of one of the two light absorbing cofactors, FAD or 6,7-dimethyl-8-ribityllumazine, only marginally affected the final survival rate but strongly decelerated photoreactivation kinetics. The impairment of both of them together through mutagenesis decreased CryB-dependent photoreactivation to the level of the ∆cryB knockout strain. The third cofactor, a [4Fe4S] iron-sulfur cluster, is indispensable for the structural integrity of the protein. The reduction of FAD via the conserved tryptophan W338, which is crucial for in vitro reduction and consequently DNA repair, is not required for in vivo photoreactivation, suggesting that this reduction pathway to FAD is dispensable in the cellular environment. This demonstrates that in vitro experiments give only limited information on in vivo photolyase activity.

The significance of the Dewar valence photoisomer as a UV radiation-induced DNA photoproduct in marine microbial communities

Induction of pyrimidine dimers in DNA by solar UV radiation has drastic effects on microorganisms. To better define the nature of these DNA photoproducts in marine bacterioplankton and eukaryotes, a study was performed during a cruise along a latitudinal transect in the Pacific Ocean. The frequency of all possible cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers, pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts (64PPs) and their related Dewar valence isomers (DEWs) was determined by high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Studied samples were bacterioplankton and eukaryotic fractions isolated from sea water either collected before sunrise or exposed to ambient sunlight from sunrise to sunset. Isolated DNA dosimeters were also exposed to daily sunlight for comparison purposes. A first major result was the observation in all samples of large amounts of DEWs, a class of photoproducts rarely considered outside photochemical studies. Evidence was obtained for a major role of UVA in the formation of these photoisomerization products of 64PPs. Considerations on the ratio between the different classes of photoproducts in basal and induced DNA damage suggests that photoenzymatic repair (PER) is an important DNA repair mechanism used by marine microorganisms occupying surface seawater in the open ocean. This result emphasizes the biological role of DEWs which are very poor substrate for PER.

Reversion-reporter transgenes to analyze all six base-substitution pathways in Arabidopsis

To expand the repertoire of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) mutation-reporter transgenes, we constructed six mutant alleles in the same codon of the β-glucuronidase-encoding GUS transgene. Each allele reverts to GUS+ only via a particular one of the six transition/transversion pathways. AcV5 epitope tags, fused carboxyl terminal to the inactive GUS- proteins, enabled semiquantitative immunoassays in plant protein extracts. Spontaneous G:C→T:A transversions, previously not measured using reporter transgenes, were quite frequent. This may reflect mispairing of adenine with 8-oxoguanine in DNA attacked by endogenous oxyradicals. Spontaneous G:C→A:T was modest and other reversions were relatively low, as reported previously. Frequencies of ultraviolet C-induced TT→TC and TC→TT reversions were both high. With increased transgene copy number, spontaneous G:C→T:A reversions increased but ultraviolet C-induced reversions decreased. Frequencies of some reversion events were reduced among T4 versus T3 generation plants. Based on these and other analyses of sources of experimental variation, we propose guidelines for the employment of these lines to study genotoxic stress in planta.

Rad8Rad5/Mms2-Ubc13 ubiquitin ligase complex controls translesion synthesis in fission yeast

Many DNA lesions cause pausing of replication forks at lesion sites; thus, generating gaps in the daughter strands that are filled-in by post-replication repair (PRR) pathways. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, PRR involves translesion synthesis (TLS) mediated by Poleta or Polzeta, or Rad5-dependent gap filling through a poorly characterized error-free mechanism. We have developed an assay to monitor error-free and mutagenic TLS across single DNA lesions in Schizosaccharomyces pombe. For both main UV photolesions, we have delineated a major error-free pathway mediated by a distinct combination of TLS polymerases. Surprisingly, these TLS pathways require enzymes needed for poly-ubiquitination of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) as well as those required for mono-ubiquitination. For pathways that require several TLS polymerases the poly-ubiquitin chains of PCNA may facilitate their recruitment through specific interactions with their multiple ubiquitin-binding motifs. These error-free TLS pathways may at least partially account for the previously described poly-ubiquitination-dependent error-free branch of PRR. This work highlights major differences in the control of lesion tolerance pathways between S. pombe and S. cerevisiae despite the homologous sets of PRR genes these organisms share.

Effect of the GC content of DNA on the distribution of UVB-induced bipyrimidine photoproducts

Solar UV radiation is a major mutagen that damages DNA through the formation of dimeric photoproducts between adjacent thymine and cytosine bases. A major effect of the GC content of the genome is thus anticipated, in particular in prokaryotes where this parameter significantly varies among species. We quantified the formation of UV-induced photolesions within both isolated and cellular DNA of bacteria of different GC content. First, we could unambiguously show the favored formation of cytosine-containing photoproducts with increasing GC content (from 28 to 72%) in isolated DNA. Thymine-thymine cyclobutane dimer was a minor lesion at high GC content. This trend was confirmed by an accurate and quantitative analysis of the photochemical data based on the exact dinucleotide frequencies of the studied genomes. The observation of the effect of the genome composition on the distribution of photoproducts was then confirmed in living cells, using two marine bacteria exhibiting different GC content. Because cytosine-containing photoproducts are highly mutagenic, it may be predicted that species with genomes exhibiting a high GC content are more susceptible to UV-induced mutagenesis.

Altered translesion synthesis in E. coli Pol V mutants selected for increased recombination inhibition

Replication of damaged DNA, also termed as translesion synthesis (TLS), involves specialized DNA polymerases that bypass DNA lesions. In Escherichia coli, although TLS can involve one or a combination of DNA polymerases depending on the nature of the lesion, it generally requires the Pol V DNA polymerase (formed by two SOS proteins, UmuD' and UmuC) and the RecA protein. In addition to being an essential component of translesion DNA synthesis, Pol V is also an antagonist of RecA-mediated recombination. We have recently isolated umuD' and umuC mutants on the basis of their increased capacity to inhibit homologous recombination. Despite the capacity of these mutants to form a Pol V complex and to interact with the RecA polymer, most of them exhibit a defect in TLS. Here, we further characterize the TLS activity of these Pol V mutants in vivo by measuring the extent of error-free and mutagenic bypass at a single (6-4)TT lesion located in double stranded plasmid DNA. TLS is markedly decreased in most Pol V mutants that we analyzed (8/9) with the exception of one UmuC mutant (F287L) that exhibits wild-type bypass activity. Somewhat unexpectedly, Pol V mutants that are partially deficient in TLS are more severely affected in mutagenic bypass compared to error-free synthesis. The defect in bypass activity of the Pol V mutant polymerases is discussed in light of the location of the respective mutations in the 3D structure of UmuD' and the DinB/UmuC homologous protein Dpo4 of Sulfolobus solfataricus.

Roles of Saccharomyces cerevisiae DNA polymerases Poleta and Polzeta in response to irradiation by simulated sunlight

Sunlight causes lesions in DNA that if unrepaired and inaccurately replicated by DNA polymerases yield mutations that result in skin cancer in humans. Two enzymes involved in translesion synthesis (TLS) of UV-induced photolesions are DNA polymerase eta (Poleta) and polymerase zeta (Polzeta), encoded by the RAD30A and REV3 genes, respectively. Previous studies have investigated the TLS roles of these polymerases in human and yeast cells irradiated with monochromatic, short wavelength UVC radiation (254 nm). However, less is known about cellular responses to solar radiation, which is of higher and mixed wavelengths (310-1100 nm) and produces a different spectrum of DNA lesions, including Dewar photoproducts and oxidative lesions. Here we report on the comparative cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of simulated sunlight (SSL) and UVC radiation on yeast wild-type, rad30Delta, rev3Delta and rev3Delta rad30Delta strains. The results with SSL support several previous interpretations on the roles of these two polymerases in TLS of photodimers and (6-4) photoproducts derived from studies with UVC. They further suggest that Poleta participates in the non-mutagenic bypass of SSL-dependent cytosine-containing Dewar photoproducts and 8-oxoguanine, while Polzeta is mainly responsible for the mutagenic bypass of all types of Dewar photoproducts. They also suggest that in the absence of Polzeta, Poleta contributes to UVC- and SSL-induced mutagenesis, possibly by the bypass of photodimers containing deaminated cytosine.

UV-induced DNA damage and melanin content in human skin differing in racial/ethnic origin

DNA damage induced by UV radiation is a critical event in skin photocarcinogenesis. However, the role of racial/ethnic origin in determining individual UV sensitivity remains unclear. In this study, we examined the relationships between melanin content and DNA damage induced by UV exposure in situ in normal human skin of different racial/ethnic groups, phototypes, and UV sensitivities. The minimal erythema dose (MED) was established for each subject exposed to UVA/UVB radiation, and skin was biopsied before as well as 7 min, 1 day, and 1 wk after UV exposure. There was great variation among individuals in the amount of DNA damage incurred and rates of its removal. The results show that after exposure to 1 MED of UV, the skin of subjects from all groups suffered significant DNA damage, and that increasing content of constitutive melanin inversely correlated with the amount of DNA damage. It is clear from these results that measured erythemal UV sensitivity of the skin (MED) is a more useful predictor of DNA photodamage than is racial/ethnic origin or skin phototype and that rates of DNA damage removal following UV radiation may be the critical determinant of the UV sensitivity (including predisposition to cancer) of the skin.

Role of DNA polymerase eta in the UV mutation spectrum in human cells

In humans, inactivation of the DNA polymerase eta gene (pol eta) results in sunlight sensitivity and causes the cancer-prone xeroderma pigmentosum variant syndrome (XP-V). Cells from XP-V individuals have a reduced capacity to replicate UV-damaged DNA and show hypermutability after UV exposure. Biochemical assays have demonstrated the ability of pol eta to bypass cis-syn-cyclobutane thymine dimers, the most common lesion generated in DNA by UV. In most cases, this bypass is error-free. To determine the actual requirement of pol eta in vivo, XP-V cells (XP30RO) were complemented by the wild type pol eta gene. We have used two pol eta-corrected clones to study the in vivo characteristics of mutations produced by DNA polymerases during DNA synthesis of UV-irradiated shuttle vectors transfected into human host cells, which had or had not been exposed previously to UV radiation. The functional complementation of XP-V cells by pol eta reduced the mutation frequencies both at CG and TA base pairs and restored UV mutagenesis to a normal level. UV irradiation of host cells prior to transfection strongly increased the mutation frequency in undamaged vectors and, in addition, especially in the pol eta-deficient XP30RO cells at 5'-TT sites in UV-irradiated plasmids. These results clearly show the protective role of pol eta against UV-induced lesions and the activation by UV of pol eta-independent mutagenic processes.

In vivo deamination of cytosine-containing cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in E. coli: a feasible part of UV-mutagenesis

We have estimated in vivo deamination rates for cytosines in cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD or PyPy) in UV-irradiated E. coli deficient in uracil DNA glycosylase. The protocol consisted of UV-irradiation, holding in buffer to allow for deamination of cytosines in CPDs and photoreversal (PR) to establish uracils where cytosines in CPD deaminated. The deamination rate at TC photoproducts targeting glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations was estimated from the increase in the mutation frequency after PR (MF(PR)) that developed as UV-irradiated cells were held before PR. Evidence suggested that an earlier study with this protocol under-estimated the deamination rate at sites producing the same mutations in an E. coli B/r strain. With a K12 strain, where the targeting apparently is principally by CPD and not (6-4) photoproducts, a larger rate of k = 0.0091 min(-1) at 42 degrees C resulted. The dark assay for MF also increased significantly with time for deamination consistent with a model for efficient mutation by translesion synthesis at uracil-containing CPD. In addition, we used a strain constructed by Cupples and Miller in which beta-galactosidase was inactive because -GGG- was at codon 461 and would revert to Lac(+) only when replaced by -GAG- or -GAA- for glutamate. CC photoproducts at this target site in the opposite DNA strand could reveal effects of first and second deaminations in the same CPD. MF(PR) for Lac(+) mutations increased and then decreased as a function of deamination time (at six temperatures 36-48 degrees C). Fitting an approximate model equation that distinguished two different deamination rates to these data suggested a first deamination producing Lac(+) at a rate about eight-fold less than a second deamination restoring the Lac(-) phenotype. We conclude that deamination, changing a cytosine-containing CPD to a uracil-containing CPD, could be an integral part of UV-induced C-to-T mutations.

DNA damage-processing in E. coli: on-going protein synthesis is required for fixation of UV-induced lethality and mutation

UV irradiation of E. coli produces photoproducts in the DNA genome. In consequence, some bacteria lose viability (colony-forming ability) or remain viable as mutant cells. However, the end-points of viability inactivation (lethality) or mutation are determined by cellular processes that act on the UV-damaged DNA. We have investigated the in vivo time course for processes that deal with cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) which can be specifically removed by photoreactivation (PR). At different times during post-UV incubation, samples were challenged with PR and assayed for viability or mutation. We used excision-defective E. coli B/r cells and worked under yellow light to avoid background PR. During post-UV incubation (0-100min) in fully supplemented defined medium, inactivation and mutation were initially significantly reversed by PR but the extent of this reversal decreased during continued incubation defining "fixation" of lethality or mutation, respectively. In contrast, if protein synthesis was restricted during the post-UV incubation, no fixation developed. When chloramphenicol was added to inhibit protein synthesis after 30min of supplemented post-UV incubation, at a time sufficient for expression of UV-induced protein(s), fixation of lethality or mutation was still annulled (no change in the effectiveness of PR developed). Lethality fixation did progress when protein synthesis was restricted and the cells were incubated in the presence of puromycin or were either clpP or clpX defective. We discuss these and related results to suggest (1) on-going protein synthesis is required in the fixation process for lethality and mutation to sustain an effective level of a hypothetical protein sensitive to ClpXP proteolysis and (2) this protein plays a critical role in the process leading to exchange between Pol III activity and alternative polymerase activities required as each cell deals with damage in template DNA.

UV-induced T-->C transition at a TT photoproduct site is dependent on Saccharomyces cerevisiae polymerase eta in vivo

UV-induced reversion of the arg4-17 ochre allele in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is largely dependent on translesion polymerase eta (Rad30p), known to bypass cyclobutane-type TT dimers in an error-free fashion. arg4-17 locus reversion was predominantly due to T-->C transition of T127, the 3' T of a TT photoproduct site. This event was at least 20-fold reduced in a rad30 deletion mutant, irrespective of the status of nucleotide excision repair. These data correlate with known properties of 6-4 TT photoproducts and in vitro characteristics of polymerase eta and suggest that polymerase eta plays an important in vivo role in inserting G opposite the 3' T of 6-4 TT photoproducts at this site. Alternatively, an unprecedented error-prone processing of cyclobutane-type photoproducts at this site by polymerase eta must be assumed as the critical mechanism. Whereas photoreactivation results indeed hint at the latter possibility, a possible regulatory influence of reducing the overall UV damage load on the bypass probability of non-cyclobutane-type pyrimidine dimer photoproducts should not be dismissed.

Repair of the main UV-induced thymine dimeric lesions within Arabidopsis thaliana DNA: evidence for the major involvement of photoreactivation pathways

The UV-B induced formation of thymine cis-syn cyclobutane dimer and related (6-4) photoproduct was monitored within DNA of cultured cells and plants of Arabidopsis thaliana. This was achieved using a sensitive and accurate HPLC-tandem mass spectrometry assay. It was found that the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer was formed in a ninefold higher yield than the (6-4) photoproduct. The removal of the lesions was then studied by incubating irradiated cells either in the darkness, under visible light or upon exposure to UV-A radiation. Dark repair of both cyclobutane dimers and (6-4) photoproducts was found to be very ineffective. In contrast, a rapid decrease in the level of photoproducts was observed when UV-B-irradiated cells were exposed to UV-A and, to a lesser extent, to visible light. The removal of (6-4) adducts was found to occur more efficiently. These results strongly suggest that repair of UV-induced photolesions in plants is mainly mediated by photolyases.

Direct and indirect effects of UV radiation on DNA and its components

In this survey, emphasis was placed on the main photoreactions of nucleic acid components, involving both direct and indirect effects. The main UVB- and UVA-induced DNA photoproducts, together with the mechanisms of their formation, are described. Information on the photoproduct distribution within cellular DNA is also provided, taking into account the limitations of the different analytical methods applied to monitor the formation of the DNA damage. Thus, the formation of the main DNA dimeric pyrimidine lesions produced by direct absorption of UVB photons was assessed using a powerful HPLC-tandem mass spectrometry assay. In addition, it was found that UVA photooxidation damage mostly involves the guanine residues of cellular DNA as the result of singlet oxygen generation by still unknown endogenous photosensitizers.

In vivo formation and repair of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and 6-4 photoproducts measured at the gene and nucleotide level in Escherichia coli

In vivo formation and repair of the major UV-induced DNA photoproducts, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) and 6-4 pyrimidine-pyrimidone photoproducts (6-4 PPs), have been examined at the gene and nucleotide level in Escherichia coli. Each type of DNA photoproduct has individually been studied using photoreactivation and two newly developed assays; the multiplex QPCR assay for damage detection at the gene level and the reiterative primer extension (PE) assay for damage detection at the nucleotide level. In the E. coli lacI and lacZ genes, CPDs and 6-4 PPs form in a 2:1 ratio, respectively, during UV irradiation. Repair of 6-4 PPs is more efficient than repair of CPDs since, on the average, 42% of 6-4 PPs are repaired in both genes in the first 40 min following 200 J/m(2) UV irradiation, while 1% of CPDs are repaired. The location, relative frequency of formation, and efficiency of repair of each type of photoproduct was examined in the first 52 codons of the E. coli lacI gene at the nucleotide level. Hotspots of formation were found for each type of lesion. Most photoproducts are at sites where both CPDs and 6-4 PPs are formed. Allowing 40 min of recovery following 200 J/m(2) shows that in vivo repair of 6-4 PPs is about fourfold more efficient than the repair of CPDs. Comparison of the lesion-specific photoproduct distribution of the lacI gene with a UV-induced mutation spectrum from wild-type cells shows that most mutational hotspots are correlated with sites of a majority of CPD formation. However, 6-4 PPs are also formed at some of these sites with relatively high frequency. This information, taken together with the observation that 6-4 PPs are repaired faster than CPDs, suggest that the cause of mutagenic hotspots in wild-type E. coli is inefficient repair of CPDs.

Lesions in DNA: hurdles for polymerases

Translesion synthesis (TLS) is one of the DNA damage tolerance strategies, which have evolved to enable organisms to replicate their genome despite the presence of unrepaired damage. The process of TLS has the propensity to produce mutations, a potential origin of cancer, and is therefore of medical interest. Significant progress in our understanding of TLS has come primarily from studies of the bacterium Escherichia coli, the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and, more recently, human cells. Results from these analyses indicate that the fundamental mechanism of TLS and the proteins involved have been conserved throughout evolution from bacteria to humans.

Effect of constitutional pigmentation on ultraviolet B-induced DNA damage in fair-skinned people

Ultraviolet light has been implicated as a dominant factor in skin cancer development. Skin pigmentation is traditionally regarded as an important protection against skin cancer. Yet, little is known about how skin pigmentation is modulating induction of DNA damage, which is the primary event in carcinogenesis. We applied a recently developed 32P-postlabeling technique to measure the effect of constitutional pigmentation on the formation of major ultraviolet-induced DNA damage in human skin in vivo. The induction of photoproducts showed a statistically significant negative correlation with erythemal response and skin pigmentation. Our results demonstrated that the constitutional pigmentation is efficiently guarding DNA against the formation of photoproducts. The difference in melanin content is likely to be one of the reasons for the observed interindividual variation in levels of DNA damage after the uniform exposure to ultraviolet B.

Recombinational repair of DNA damage in Escherichia coli and bacteriophage lambda

Although homologous recombination and DNA repair phenomena in bacteria were initially extensively studied without regard to any relationship between the two, it is now appreciated that DNA repair and homologous recombination are related through DNA replication. In Escherichia coli, two-strand DNA damage, generated mostly during replication on a template DNA containing one-strand damage, is repaired by recombination with a homologous intact duplex, usually the sister chromosome. The two major types of two-strand DNA lesions are channeled into two distinct pathways of recombinational repair: daughter-strand gaps are closed by the RecF pathway, while disintegrated replication forks are reestablished by the RecBCD pathway. The phage lambda recombination system is simpler in that its major reaction is to link two double-stranded DNA ends by using overlapping homologous sequences. The remarkable progress in understanding the mechanisms of recombinational repair in E. coli over the last decade is due to the in vitro characterization of the activities of individual recombination proteins. Putting our knowledge about recombinational repair in the broader context of DNA replication will guide future experimentation.

SOS mutagenesis results from up-regulation of translesion synthesis

Irradiation of DNA with ultraviolet light generates a variety of photolesions. Among them, are cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and (6-4) photoproducts blocking lesions that interfere with DNA replication if left unrepaired. In addition to efficient pre-replicative excision repair mechanisms, cells have evolved damage tolerance pathways enabling them to replicate lesion-containing DNA molecules either by directly replicating through the damaged base (translesion synthesis, TLS) or by employing the locally undamaged complementary strand thus avoiding the lesion (damage avoidance pathways, DA). Using double-stranded vectors with a single T(6-4)T UV lesion and a strand segregation analysis (SSA), we have measured the relative utilization of the two tolerance pathways (TLS and DA) in Escherichia coli. During the SOS response the error-prone TLS pathway is strongly stimulated ( approximately 20-fold) at the expense of the error-free DA pathways. Thus, up-regulation of TLS may turn out to be a general property of the SOS response; a similar conclusion was previously reached with the frameshift-inducing N-2-acetylaminofluorene adduct. Therefore, as far as its contribution to damaged DNA replication is concerned, the SOS response appears to be an induced mutator state rather than a survival strategy. Depending on the base inserted opposite the lesion, TLS can be error-free or mutagenic. In a wild-type strain, both forms of TLS are increased to a similar extent during the SOS response. In contrast, in a DeltaumuDC strain induction of TLS is totally abolished, demonstrating that the UmuDC proteins usually thought to be specifically involved in mutagenesis facilitate the recovery of both error-free and mutagenic replication intermediates in vivo.

Sequence and time-dependent deamination of cytosine bases in UVB-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in vivo

The mutational specificity of UV-light is characterized by an abundance of C to T transition mutations at dipyrimidines containing cytosine or 5-methylcytosine. A significant percentage of these mutations are CC to TT double transitions. Of the major types of UV-induced DNA lesions, the cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) are thought to be the most mutagenic lesions, at least in mammalian cells. It has been proposed that the CPDs become mutagenic perhaps only after cytosine bases within these dimers deaminate to uracil and the resulting U-containing photolesions are correctly bypassed by DNA polymerases. In order to assess the significance of this proposed mutagenic mechanism, we have developed two methods to specifically measure deaminated CPDs in UV-irradiated human cells or DNA. The first method is based on enzymatic photoreversal of CPDs, followed by cleavage of the DNA with uracil DNA glycosylase, an AP lyase activity, and ligation-mediated PCR to map the resulting strand breaks. The second method, which can be used to detect double deamination events (CC to UU), is PCR amplification of photolyase-treated DNA using primers complemetary to the deaminated sequences. We have measured deamination events in the human p53 gene, which contains a large percentage of C to T transitions in skin cancers. The deamination reactions are specific for cytosine within CPDs, are negligible immediately after irradiation, and are time-dependent and DNA sequence context-dependent. Twenty four hours after irradiation of human fibroblasts with UVB light, between 10 and 60% of most CPD signals are converted to the deaminated form, depending on the sequence. Significant deamination occurs at skin cancer mutation sites in the p53 gene. Double deamination also occurs and this reaction can involve dimers containing 5-methylcytosine or cytosine. These double events are expected to occur more frequently in cells with a DNA repair defect because there is more time for deamination in unrepaired lesions. This may explain the relatively high frequency of CC to TT mutations in skin cancers from xeroderma pigmentosum patients. In summary, these novel detection techniques demonstrate that deamination of cytosine in pyrimidine dimers is a significant event that most likely contributes to the mutational specificity of UVB irradiation in human cells.

The beta subunit sliding DNA clamp is responsible for unassisted mutagenic translesion replication by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme

The replication of damaged nucleotides that have escaped DNA repair leads to the formation of mutations caused by misincorporation opposite the lesion. In Escherichia coli, this process is under tight regulation of the SOS stress response and is carried out by DNA polymerase III in a process that involves also the RecA, UmuD' and UmuC proteins. We have shown that DNA polymerase III holoenzyme is able to replicate, unassisted, through a synthetic abasic site in a gapped duplex plasmid. Here, we show that DNA polymerase III*, a subassembly of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme lacking the beta subunit, is blocked very effectively by the synthetic abasic site in the same DNA substrate. Addition of the beta subunit caused a dramatic increase of at least 28-fold in the ability of the polymerase to perform translesion replication, reaching 52% bypass in 5 min. When the ssDNA region in the gapped plasmid was extended from 22 nucleotides to 350 nucleotides, translesion replication still depended on the beta subunit, but it was reduced by 80%. DNA sequence analysis of translesion replication products revealed mostly -1 frameshifts. This mutation type is changed to base substitution by the addition of UmuD', UmuC, and RecA, as demonstrated in a reconstituted SOS translesion replication reaction. These results indicate that the beta subunit sliding DNA clamp is the major determinant in the ability of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme to perform unassisted translesion replication and that this unassisted bypass produces primarily frameshifts.

The ability of a variety of polymerases to synthesize past site-specific cis-syn, trans-syn-II, (6-4), and Dewar photoproducts of thymidylyl-(3'-->5')-thymidine

The role of photoproduct structure, 3' --> 5' exonuclease activity, and processivity on polynucleotide synthesis past photoproducts of thymidylyl-(3' --> 5')-thymidine was investigated. Both Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase and 3' --> 5' exonuclease-deficient (exo-) Vent polymerase were blocked by all photoproducts, whereas Taq polymerase could slowly bypass the cis-syn dimer. T7 RNA polymerase was able to bypass all the photoproducts in the order cis-syn > Dewar > (6-4) > trans-syn-II. Klenow fragment could not bypass any of the photoproducts, but an exo- mutant could bypass the cis-syn dimer to a greater extent than the others. Likewise T7 DNA polymerase, composed of the T7 gene 5 protein and Escherichia coli thioredoxin, was blocked by all the photoproducts, but the exo- mutant Sequenase 2.0 was able to bypass them all in the order cis-syn > Dewar > trans-syn-II > (6-4). No bypass occurred with an exo- gene 5 protein in the absence of the thioredoxin processivity factor. Bypass of the cis-syn and trans-syn-II products by Sequenase 2.0 was essentially non-mutagenic, whereas about 20% dTMP was inserted opposite the 5'-T of the Dewar photoproduct. A mechanism involving a transient abasic site is proposed to account for the preferential incorporation of dAMP opposite the 3'-T of the photoproducts.

Analysis of damage tolerance pathways in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: a requirement for Rev3 DNA polymerase in translesion synthesis

The replication of double-stranded plasmids containing a single N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) adduct located in a short, heteroduplex sequence was analyzed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The strains used were proficient or deficient for the activity of DNA polymerase zeta (REV3 and rev3delta, respectively) in a mismatch and nucleotide excision repair-defective background (msh2delta rad10delta). The plasmid design enabled the determination of the frequency with which translesion synthesis (TLS) and mechanisms avoiding the adduct by using the undamaged, complementary strand (damage avoidance mechanisms) are invoked to complete replication. To this end, a hybridization technique was implemented to probe plasmid DNA isolated from individual yeast transformants by using short, 32P-end-labeled oligonucleotides specific to each strand of the heteroduplex. In both the REV3 and rev3delta strains, the two strands of an unmodified heteroduplex plasmid were replicated in approximately 80% of the transformants, with the remaining 20% having possibly undergone prereplicative MSH2-independent mismatch repair. However, in the presence of the AAF adduct, TLS occurred in only 8% of the REV3 transformants, among which 97% was mostly error free and only 3% resulted in a mutation. All TLS observed in the REV3 strain was abolished in the rev3delta mutant, providing for the first time in vivo biochemical evidence of a requirement for the Rev3 protein in TLS.

Photorepair mutants of Arabidopsis

UV radiation induces two major DNA damage products, the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) and, at a lower frequency, the pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidinone dimer (6-4 product). Although Escherichia coli and Saccharomyes cerevisiae produce a CPD-specific photolyase that eliminates only this class of dimer, Arabidopsis thaliana, Drosphila melanogaster, Crotalus atrox, and Xenopus laevis have recently been shown to photoreactivate both CPDs and 6-4 products. We describe the isolation and characterization of two new classes of mutants of Arabidopsis, termed uvr2 and uvr3, that are defective in the photoreactivation of CPDs and 6-4 products, respectively. We demonstrate that the CPD photolyase mutation is genetically linked to a DNA sequence encoding a type II (metazoan) CPD photolyase. In addition, we are able to generate plants in which only CPDs or 6-4 products are photoreactivated in the nuclear genome by exposing these mutants to UV light and then allowing them to repair one or the other class of dimers. This provides us with a unique opportunity to study the biological consequences of each of these two major UV-induced photoproducts in an intact living system.

Mutagenic properties of the T-C cyclobutane dimer

G x C-->A x T transitions within T-C or C-C bipyrimidine sequences are by far the most frequent class of mutation induced by 254-nm UV irradiation in most genes and species investigated, but the reason for the high degree of mutability and specificity at these sites is uncertain. Some data implicate the deamination of cytosine to uracil as a possible cause, but other results appear to indicate that the rate of deamination is too low for this to be significant in Escherichia coli. If deamination is not the cause, the high degree of mutability must presumably reflect the inherent properties of T-C and C-C dimers. We investigated this question by transfecting excision-deficient and excision-proficient strains of E. coli with single-stranded vectors that carried a site-specific cis-syn T-C cyclobutane dimer and by analyzing the nucleotide sequences of replicated vector products. We found that replication past the T-C dimer, like replication past its T-T and U-U counterparts, is in fact >95% accurate and that the frequencies of bypass are also very similar for these photoproducts. Since the T-C dimer appears to be only weakly mutagenic, the high frequency of UV-induced mutations at T-C sites presumably depends on some other process, such as deamination, although the mechanism remains to be established.

Recent advances in the construction of bacterial genotoxicity assays

Bacterial mutagenicity assays have been widely used in genotoxicology research for two decades. We discuss the development of such assays, especially the Ames test, with particular attention to strain engineering. Genes encoding enzymes of mutagen bioactivation, including N-acetyltransferase, nitroreductase, and cytochrome P450, have been introduced into tester strains. The processing of DNA damage by the bacterial strains has also been modified in several ways, so as to enhance mutagenesis. These efforts have greatly increased the sensitivity of mutation assays and have illuminated the molecular mechanisms of mutagenesis. We also discuss the relationship between bacterial assays and in vivo mutation assays which use transgenic rodents.

Mutagenicity of a unique thymine-thymine dimer or thymine-thymine pyrimidine pyrimidone (6-4) photoproduct in mammalian cells

The mutagenic properties of UV-induced photoproducts, both the cis-syn thymine-thymine dimer (TT) and the thymine-thymine pyrimidine pyrimidone (6-4) photoproduct [T(6-4)T] were studied in mammalian cells using shuttle vectors. A shuttle vector able to replicate in both mammalian cells and bacteria was produced in its single-stranded DNA form. A unique photoproduct was inserted at a single restriction site and after recircularization of the single-stranded DNA vector, this latter was transfected into simian COS7 cells. After DNA replication the vector was extracted from cells and used to transform bacteria. Amplified DNA was finally analyzed without any selective screening, DNA from randomly picked bacterial colonies being directly sequenced. Our results show clearly that both lesions are mutagenic, but at different levels. Mutation frequencies of 2 and 60% respectively were observed with the TT dimer and the T(6-4)T. With the TT dimer the mutations were targeted on the 3'-T. With the T(6-4)T a large variety of mutations were observed. A majority of G-->T transversions were semi-targeted to the base before the 5'-T of the photoproduct. These kinds of mutations were not observed when the same plasmid was transfected directly into SOS-induced JM105 bacteria or when the T(6-4)T oligonucleotide inserted in a different plasmid was replicated in SOS-induced SMH10 Escherichia coil bacteria. These semi-targeted mutations are therefore the specific result of bypass of the T(6-4)T lesion in COS7 cells by one of the eukaryotic DNA polymerases.

Complete replication of plasmid DNA containing a single UV-induced lesion in human cell extracts

To investigate the effect of the major UV-induced lesions on SV40 origin-dependent DNA replication and mutagenesis in a mammalian cell extract, double-stranded plasmids containing a single cis,syn-cyclobutane dimer or a pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproduct at a unique TT sequence have been constructed. These plasmids have been used as templates in DNA replication-competent extracts from human HeLa cells. Plasmids containing a single pyrimidine cyclobutane dimer on the potential lagging strand for DNA replication are replicated with an efficiency approximately equal to that of an unmodified plasmid. A small decrease in replication efficiency of approximately 20% was observed when the lesion was located on the potential leading strand for DNA replication. In both orientations, DpnI-resistant, replicated closed circular plasmid DNA was sensitive to nicking by the pyrimidine dimer-specific enzyme, T4 endonuclease V, indicating that complete replication of the damaged plasmid occurs in vitro. In contrast, a (6-4) photoproduct, within the same site and sequence context on the lagging strand for DNA synthesis, inhibits replication in vitro by an average of approximately 50%, indicating that the mammalian replication complex responds differently to the two major UV-induced lesions during DNA replication in vitro. Analysis of the DpnI-resistant, replicated DNA for mutations targeted to the lesion site indicates that neither of these lesions resulted in significant mutagenesis. UV-induced lesions at TT sites may therefore be poorly mutagenic under these conditions for DNA replication in human cell extracts in vitro.

Reconstitution of repair-gap UV mutagenesis with purified proteins from Escherichia coli: a role for DNA polymerases III and II

Using a cell-free system for UV mutagenesis, we have previously demonstrated the existence of a mutagenic pathway associated with nucleotide-excision repair gaps. Here, we report that this pathway can be reconstituted by using six purified proteins: UvrA, UvrB, UvrC, DNA helicase II, DNA polymerase III core, and DNA ligase. This establishes the minimal requirements for repair-gap UV mutagenesis. DNA polymerase II could replace DNA polymerase III, although less effectively, whereas DNA polymerase I, the major repair polymerase, could not. DNA sequence analysis of mutations generated in the in vitro reaction revealed a spectrum typical of mutations targeted to UV lesions. These observations suggest that repair-gap UV mutagenesis is performed by DNA polymerase III, and to a lesser extent by DNA polymerase II, by filling-in of a rare class of excision gaps that contain UV lesions.

Mutagenic specificity of solar UV light in nucleotide excision repair-deficient rodent cells

To investigate the role of nucleotide excision repair (NER) in the cellular processing of carcinogenic DNA photoproducts induced by defined, environmentally relevant portions of the solar wavelength spectrum, we have determined the mutagenic specificity of simulated sunlight (310-1100 nm), UVA (350-400 nm), and UVB (290-320 nm), as well as of the "nonsolar" model mutagen 254-nm UVC, at the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (aprt) locus in NER-deficient (ERCC1) Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The frequency distributions of mutational classes induced by UVB and by simulated sunlight in repair-deficient CHO cells were virtually identical, each showing a marked increase in tandem CC-->TT transitions relative to NER-proficient cells. A striking increase in CC-->TT events was also previously documented for mutated p53 tumor-suppressor genes from nonmelanoma tumors of NER-deficient, skin cancer-prone xeroderma pigmentosum patients, compared to normal individuals. The data therefore indicate that the aprt gene in NER-deficient cultured rodent cells irradiated with artificial solar light generates the same distinctive "fingerprint" for sunlight mutagenesis as the p53 locus in NER-deficient humans exposed to natural sunlight in vivo. Moreover, in strong contrast to the situation for repair-component CHO cells, where a significant role for UVA was previously noted, the mutagenic specificity of simulated sunlight in NER-deficient CHO cells and of natural sunlight in humans afflicted with xeroderma pigmentosum can be entirely accounted for by the UVB portion of the solar wavelength spectrum.

Strand bias of ultraviolet light-induced mutations in a transcriptionally active gene in human cells

Ultraviolet (UV)-induced repair and mutational spectra were analyzed in an inducible marker gene, the metallothionein-l/guamine-xanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (gpt) fusion gene, carried by an Epstein-Barr virus-derived shuttle vector episomically maintained in human cells. The repair rate of UV photodimers from the shuttle-vector molecules was typical of transcriptionally active sequences, 70% of the dimers being removed within 8 h after irradiation. The spectrum obtained under basal gene transcription was compared with that obtained under induced transcription. In both cases, base substitutions at dipyrimidine sequences predominated. Multiple mutations and deletions probably due to recombinational events induced by UV damage were also observed. Most of the UV-mutated dipyrimidine sites were located in the transcribed strand and were independent of the transcriptional activity of the target gene. In contrast, the distribution of mutations throughout the coding region of the gpt gene was affected by transcription, with a preferential clustering of mutations occurring in the 3' half of the gene after transcription induction. The strand bias observed in the UV spectra most likely reflects selection for nonfunctional gpt protein.

Deamination of cytosine-containing pyrimidine photodimers in UV-irradiated DNA. Significance for UV light mutagenesis

The realization that cytosine in cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers rapidly deaminates to uracil raised the possibility that this chemical transformation, rather than an enzymatic polymerase error, is the major mutagenic step in UV mutagenesis. We have established a sensitive bioassay system that enabled us to determine the rate of deamination of cytosine in cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers in plasmid DNA. This was done by in vitro UV irradiation and deamination of a plasmid carrying the cro gene, followed by photoreactivation, and assaying uracils in DNA by their ability to cause Cro- mutations in an indicator strain that was deficient in uracil DNA N-glycosylase. DNA sequence analysis revealed that 27 out of 29 Cro- mutants carried GC --> AT transitions, as expected from deamination of cytosine. Deamination of cytosines in the cro gene in UV-irradiated plasmid pOC2 proceeded at 37 degrees C with first-order kinetics, at a rate of (3.9 +/- 0.6) x 10(-5) s-1, corresponding to a half-life of 5 h. Physiological salt conditions increased the half-life to 12 h, whereas decreasing the pH increased deamination. The temperature dependence of the rate constant yielded an activation energy of 13.6 +/- 3.3 kcal/mol. These kinetics data suggest that deamination of cytosine-containing dimers is too slow to play an important role in UV mutagenesis in Escherichia coli. However, it is likely to play an important role in mammalian cells, where the mutagenic process is slower.

UV-induced mutagenesis in the endogenous hprt gene and in hprt cDNA genes integrated at different positions of the human genome

The influence of the genomic position of a gene on UV-induced mutations was studied in the endogenous hprt gene in human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells and in cell lines derived from TK6 each containing a single copy of a hamster hprt cDNA gene integrated on a retroviral vector in different positions of the human genome. Previous studies showed that the genomic sequences surrounding the integration site influence spontaneous mutagenesis, resulting in a 10-fold difference in mutation rates among the hprt cDNA genes. Here we demonstrate that the genomic positions of three integrated hprt cDNA genes do not influence UV-induced mutagenesis. The mutability by UV irradiation in these cell lines is approximately the same (16.0 x 10(-6) per J/m2). The nature of the UV-induced mutations determined in two of the cell lines containing the integrated hprt cDNA gene (approximately 30 mutants each) was also found not to be different. The endogenous hprt gene in the parental TK6 cells exhibits a significantly lower mutability (2.1 x 10(-6) per J/m2) than the cDNA genes, but the spectrum is very similar. The spectrum in TK6 shows no influence of strand-specific repair and resembles most closely the spectrum obtained by McGregor et al. after irradiation of human cells synchronized in S-phase. This suggests that mutations arising in cells that are in S-phase at the time of irradiation constitute the majority of the mutants in an asynchronous TK6 cell population. We hypothesize that repair in the endogenous hprt gene in TK6 cells is very efficient, removing virtually all lesions before replication takes place except in cells that were in S-phase at the time of irradiation when there is not enough time for repair. Furthermore we suggest that the higher mutability of the integrated hprt cDNA genes compared with the endogenous gene is caused by a less efficient repair in the cDNA genes.

A new shuttle vector system for the identification of spontaneous and radiation-induced mutations in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe

A shuttle vector, pCRR1, has been constructed for the detection of spontaneous and radiation-induced mutations in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. This vector contains an Escherichia coli supF suppressor tRNA gene as the target for mutagenesis and bacterial pMB1 and yeast ars1 replication origins, which can be used to propagate the plasmid in bacterial and fission yeast cells, respectively. supF mutations can be detected after plasmid transformation into S. pombe and recovery in a bacterial indicator system, KS40/pKY241, by selecting for nalidixic acid resistance and/or by screening for lacZ- cells. We found that UV light or gamma-rays induced mutations in a dose-dependent manner in this system. Treatment of ultraviolet light (UV)-irradiated DNA with E. coli photolyase, which monomerizes cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers, before introduction into S. pombe reduced mutation frequencies to nearly background levels, indicating that this type of lesion is the major source of mutations. Comparison of spontaneous and UV-induced mutation frequencies in rad+, rad8-190 and rad13-A cells revealed no significant difference in background levels or induced levels after exposure to 100 J/m2 of UV. However, when plasmid DNA was UV-irradiated with 500 J/m2, the rad8-190 cells generated only 38% as many induced supF mutations as the rad+ strain, whereas the rad13-A cells produced more than a 6-fold increase in mutability relative to the level observed for the wild-type strain. These mutability patterns are consistent with previous studies that characterized rad8-190 cells as hypomutable and rad13-A cells as hypermutable by UV light at chromosomal loci. Thus, this shuttle vector system provides a useful and sensitive tool to assess mutability in S. pombe.

Different UmuC requirements for generation of different kinds of UV-induced mutations in Escherichia coli

An Escherichia coli strain bearing the dnaQ49 mutation, which results in a defective epsilon subunit of DNA polymerase III, and carrying the lexA71 mutation, which causes derepression of the SOS regulon, is totally unable to maintain high-copy-number plasmids containing the umuDC operon. The strain is also unable to maintain the pAN4 plasmid containing a partial deletion of the umuD gene but retaining the wild-type umuC gene. These results suggest that a high cellular level of UmuC is exceptionally harmful to the defective DNA polymerase III of the dnaQ49 mutant. We have used this finding as a basis for selection of new plasmid umuC mutants. The properties of two such mutants, bearing the umuC61 or umuC95 mutation, are described in detail. In the umuC122::Tn5 strain harbouring the mutant plasmids, UV-induced mutagenesis is severely decreased compared to that observed with the parental umuDC+ plasmid. Interestingly, while the frequency of UV-induced GC-->AT transitions is greatly reduced, the frequency of AT-->TA transversions is not affected. Both mutant plasmids bear frameshift mutations within the same run of seven A residues present in umuC+; in umuC61 the run is shortened to six A whereas in umuC95 is lengthened to eight A. We have found in both umuC61 and umuC95 that translation is partially restored to the proper reading frame. We propose that under conditions of limiting amounts of UmuC, the protein preferentially facilitates processing of only some kinds of UV-induced lesions.