Cellulases as chiral selectors

Enantioselective Binding of Propranolol and Analogues Thereof to Cellobiohydrolase Cel7A

At the catalytic site for the hydrolysis of cellulose the enzyme cellobiohydrolase Cel7A binds the enantiomers of the adrenergic beta-blocker propranolol with different selectivity. Methyl-to-hydroxymethyl group modifications of propranolol, which result in higher affinity and improved selectivity, were herein studied by ¹ H,¹ H and ¹ H,¹³ C scalar spin-spin coupling constants as well as utilizing the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) in conjunction with molecular dynamics simulations of the ligands per se, which showed the presence of all-antiperiplanar conformations, except for the one containing a vicinal oxygen-oxygen arrangement governed by the gauche effect. For the ligand-protein complexes investigated by NMR spectroscopy using, inter alia, transferred NOESY and saturation-transfer difference (STD) NMR experiments the S-isomers were shown to bind with a higher affinity and a conformation similar to that preferred in solution, in contrast to the R-isomer. The fact that the S-form of the propranolol enantiomer is pre-arranged for binding to the protein is also observed for a crystal structure of dihydroxy-(S)-propranolol and Cel7A presented herein. Whereas the binding of propranolol is entropy driven, the complexation with the dihydroxy analogue is anticipated to be favored also by an enthalpic term, such as for its enantiomer, that is, dihydroxy-(R)-propranolol, because hydrogen-bond donation replaces the corresponding bonding from hydroxyl groups in glucosyl residues of the natural substrate. In addition to a favorable entropy component, albeit lesser in magnitude, this represents an effect of enthalpy-to-entropy compensation in ligand-protein interactions.

A protein-based mixed selector chiral monolithic stationary phase in capillary electrochromatography

A mixed selector CSP combines the enantioselectivities of both individual proteins, thus expanding their application range practically.

Chromatographic Studies of Protein-Based Chiral Separations

The development of separation methods for the analysis and resolution of chiral drugs and solutes has been an area of ongoing interest in pharmaceutical research. The use of proteins as chiral binding agents in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) has been an approach that has received particular attention in such work. This report provides an overview of proteins that have been used as binding agents to create chiral stationary phases (CSPs) and in the use of chromatographic methods to study these materials and protein-based chiral separations. The supports and methods that have been employed to prepare protein-based CSPs will also be discussed and compared. Specific types of CSPs that are considered include those that employ serum transport proteins (e.g., human serum albumin, bovine serum albumin, and alpha1-acid glycoprotein), enzymes (e.g., penicillin G acylase, cellobiohydrolases, and α-chymotrypsin) or other types of proteins (e.g., ovomucoid, antibodies, and avidin or streptavidin). The properties and applications for each type of protein and CSP will also be discussed in terms of their use in chromatography and chiral separations.

Separation of enantiomers on chiral stationary phase based on cellulase: Effect of preparation method and silica particle diameters on chiral recognition ability

Cellulase (Cel) was immobilized onto aminopropyl-silica gels via its amino and carboxy groups, respectively, using N,N'-disuccinimidyl carbonate, and 1-ethyl-3-(3'-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodimide and N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide. They were termed N-Cel and C-Cel, respectively. Despite their smaller retention factors on a C-Cel column, the enantioseparation factors and resolution of β-blockers, propranolol, alprenolol, oxprenolol and pindolol, were similar with N- and C-Cel columns. In addition, C-Cel was prepared using aminopropyl-silica gels, whose nominal particle diameters were 5 and 3, and 2.1μm, respectively. A C-Cel column prepared with 2.1-μm aminopropyl-silica gels gave the highest enantioselectivity and column efficiency among three C-Cel columns. Furthermore, the influence of N,N-dimethyl-n-octylamine (DMOA) or cellobiose concentrations on the retentivity and enantioselectivity for β-blockers on a C-Cel column was investigated. The results indicate that single-site competition of β-blockers with DMOA or cellobiose on the catalytic binding site of Cel and the further bindings at the secondary site in a non-competitive fashion could occur. Furthermore, the enantioselective bindings of β-blockers could occur at the catalytic biding cite of Cel and at the secondary binding site.

Enantiomeric profiling of chiral drugs in wastewater and receiving waters

The aim of this paper is to discuss the enantiomer-specific fate of chiral drugs during wastewater treatment and in receiving waters. Several chiral drugs were studied: amphetamine-like drugs of abuse (amphetamine, methamphetamine, MDMA, MDA), ephedrines (ephedrine and pseudoephedrine), antidepressant venlafaxine, and beta-blocker atenolol. A monitoring program was undertaken in 7 WWTPs (utilizing mainly activated sludge and trickling filters technologies) and at 6 sampling points in receiving waters over the period of 9 months. The results revealed the enantiomer-specific fate of all studied drugs during both wastewater treatment and in the aqueous environment. The extent of stereoselectivity depended on several parameters including: type of chiral drug (high stereoselectivity was recorded for atenolol and MDMA), treatment technology used (activated sludge showed higher stereoselectivity than trickling filters), and season (higher stereoselectivity was observed in the aqueous environment over the spring/summer time).

pH dependency of ligand binding to cellobiohydrolase 1 (Cel7A)

The affinity and enantioselectivity have been determined for designed propranolol derivatives as ligands for Cel7A by capillary electrophoresis (CE) at pH 7.0. These results have been compared to measurements at pH 5.0. In agreement with previous studies, the affinity increased at the higher pH. However, the affinity was not as dependent of the ligand structure at pH 7.0 as at pH 5.0, and the selectivity was generally decreased. Instead, at pH 7.0, the changes in binding were mainly dependent on the presence of additional dihydroxyl groups, indicating an increased importance of the electrostatic interactions. To evaluate the pH dependent variations in binding, changes in both the ligand and in the enzyme had to be taken into account. To ensure that the ligands had the same charge in all measurements, pKa-values of all compounds were determined. The ligand-protein interaction has also been studied by inhibition experiments at both pHs to evaluate the specific binding to the active site when competing with the substrate p-nitrophenyl lactoside (pNPL). With support of docking computations we propose a hypothesis on the effect of the ligand structure and pH dependency of the binding and selectivity of amino alcohols to Cel7A.

Separation of drug enantiomers by liquid chromatography and capillary electrophoresis, using immobilized proteins as chiral selectors

Proteins display interesting chiral discrimination properties owing to multiple possibilities of intermolecular interactions with chiral compounds. This review deals with proteins which have been used as immobilized chiral selectors for the enantioseparation of drugs in liquid chromatography and capillary electrophoresis. The main procedures allowing the immobilization of proteins onto matrices, such as silica and zirconia particles, membranes and capillaries are first presented. Then the factors affecting the enantioseparation of drugs in liquid chromatography, using various protein-based chiral stationary phases (CSPs), are reviewed and discussed. Last, chiral separations already achieved using immobilized protein selectors in affinity capillary electrochromatography (ACEC) are presented and compared in terms of efficiency, stability and reproducibility.

Chiral separation by chromatographic and electromigration techniques. A review

This review gives a survey of different chiral separation principles and their use in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), gas chromatography (GC), supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), thin-layer chromatography (TLC), capillary electrophoresis (CE) and capillary electrochromatography (CEC) highlighting new developments and innovative techniques. The mechanisms of the different separation principles are briefly discussed and some selected applications are shown.

Protein-based chiral stationary phases for high-performance liquid chromatography enantioseparations

The enantioseparations of various compounds using proteins as the chiral selectors in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) are considered in this review. The proteins used include albumins such as bovine serum albumin and human serum albumin, glycoproteins such as alpha1-acid glycoprotein, ovomucoid, ovoglycoprotein, avidin and riboflavin binding protein, enzymes such as trypsin, alpha-chymotrypsin, cellobiohydrolase I, lysozyme, pepsin and amyloglucosidase, and other proteins such as ovotransferrin and beta-lactoglobulin. This review deals with the properties of HPLC chiral stationary phases based on proteins, and the enantioselective properties and chiral recognition mechanisms of these stationary phases.

Influence of the solute hydrophobicity on the enantioselective adsorption of beta-blockers on a cellulase protein used as the chiral selector

Adsorption isotherm data were acquired at different eluent pH values for the enantiomers of several beta-blockers on cellobiohydrolase I on silica gel. They fit well to the biLangmuir model, allowing the determination of the equilibrium constants and the monolayer capacities for chiral and nonselective adsorption. The adsorption of the S-enantiomers (eluted second) is exothermic at low pH, endothermic at high pH, and athermal in a narrow pH range depending on the beta-blocker. This transition pH range is lower for S-alprenolol than for the more hydrophobic S-propranolol, although their endothermic adsorption originates from hydrophobic interactions. This surprising observation is explained by the relative values of the isotherm coefficients. S-Alprenolol seems to have a more pronounced endothermic behavior than S-propranolol because the nonselective interactions of both compounds with the stationary phase are exothermic but their contribution to retention, relative to that of the endothermic chiral interactions, is less important for alprenolol. The order of increasing energy of the chiral interactions is the same as that of hydrophobicity, propranolol>alprenolol>metoprolol.

Retention mechanism of beta-blockers on an immobilized cellulase. Relative importance of the hydrophobic and ionic contributions to their enantioselective and nonselective interactions

The adsorption isotherms of the enantiomers of three beta-blockers, metoprolol, alprenolol, and propranolol, were measured on cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I) immobilized on silicagel, in the concentration range between 0.25 microM and 1.7 mM, at pH = 5.0, 5.5, and 6.0. In agreement with previous results, these data are accounted for by a two-sites physical model and fit closely to a Bilangmuir equation. The saturation capacities and the binding constants were determined for each enantiomer on the chiral and the nonchiral sites. The chiral sites are shown to be strongly ionic, in contrast to the nonchiral ones, which are mainly hydrophobic. However, the chiral binding of (S)-propranolol is endothermic, with a high adsorption entropy, in contrast to the chiral interactions of (R)-propranolol and to the nonchiral interactions, which are all exothermic. This indicates that hydrophobic interactions also play a role in the chiral binding. The dependence of the adsorption parameters on the hydrophobicity of the solute is discussed and interpreted in terms of the retention mechanism. The results are compared with the structure of the protein, recently elucidated by X-ray crystallography.

Apparent and true enantioselectivity in enantioseparations

The separation factor of two compounds in chromatography is the ratio of their equilibrium constants or retention factors. This parameter is universally employed to investigate their resolution and to optimize the experimental conditions of their analysis. In enantioseparations, the situation is more complex because there is a mixed retention mechanism. The retention factor is the sum of two contributions, one enantioselective, the other nonselective. Although both contribute to retention, the latter being identical for the two enantiomers and does not contribute to their separation. We show how these two contributions can be measured and how it becomes necessary to distinguish between the apparent, alpha(app), and the true, alpha(true), separation factors. The existence of nonselective sites is responsible for alpha(app) being less than alpha(true). Depending on the difference between these two factors, the more effective approach to improve a separation is either to increase the enantioselectivity or to reduce the nonselective interactions. Practical applications to separations of different beta-blockers on cellobiohydrolase are discussed. The apparent enantioselectivity of alprenolol is larger and increases faster with increasing pH than that of the more hydrophobic propranolol, in spite of the importance of hydrophobic interactions in the enantioselective mechanism. These two unexpected properties are discussed and explained.

Cellulases from the fungi Phanerochaete chrysosporium and Trichoderma reesei as chiral selectors in capillary electrophoresis: applications with displacer plugs and sample preconcentration

The cellulases CBH 58 from the fungus Phanerochaete chrysosporium and CBH I from the fungus Trichoderma reesei were compared as chiral selectors in capillary electrophoresis (CE) applying the partial filling technique. Amines, e.g., norephedrine, two bambuterol analogs, as well as acids, e.g., di-p-toluoyl tartaric acid and dibenzoyl tartaric acid, which could not be enantioseparated in the liquid chromatographic use of the selectors, could be separated in the corresponding CE experiments. Due to the very high enantioselectivities, terbutaline, alprenolol and propranolol could be completely enantioresolved with selector plugs shorter than the sample plugs. The affinity of propranolol to CBH 58 was so high at pH 7.0 that neither of the enantiomers reached the detector; therefore, a plug of the displacing disaccharide cellobiose was injected after the sample to elute the propranolol enantiomers. The enantiomers could also be made to leave the capillary at opposite ends, thereby causing an infinite enantioresolution. A new preconcentration technique was introduced, which takes advantage of the very high affinity of propranolol to CBH 58 and the eluting ability of cellobiose. A 12.5 cm long plug of rac-propranolol could be preconcentrated and enantioseparated in a single procedure.

Chromatographic evaluation of structure selective and enantioselective retention of amines and acids on cellobiohydrolase I wild type and its mutant D214N

The mechanisms of structure selective and enantioselective retentions of amines and acids on two chiral stationary phases based on wild type cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I) and its mutant D214N have been investigated. All the amino alcohols tested had an enantioselective site that overlaps with the catalytically active site of CBH I, whereas the enantioselectivity of prilocaine was not affected by the mutation. The hydroxyl group of the amino alcohols did not seem to be an important contributor to the total binding strength whereas a bromo substituent in the aromatic ring promotes a high enantioselectivity (alpha=7.05). Interestingly, the chiral recognition site of the acid warfarin overlaps with the binding site of the amino alcohols. Di-p-toluoyltartaric acid and dibenzoyltartaric acid were strongly retained probably due to electrostatic attraction, but no enantioselectivity was observed. The difference in retention characteristics for the amino alcohols on the two stationary phases was strongly pH-dependent. A change in elution order of different amino alcohols occurred when changing the pH from 5.0 to 7.0. The difference between the two phases was lower at low pH. The retention times could also be affected by ionic strength and by use of cellobiose as a mobile phase additive but no indication of ion-pair retention of the amines was observed, when adding hexanesulphonate as counter ion to the mobile phase. The temperature dependence of the retention of the enantiomers of propranolol at pH 7.0 on the mutant D214N was similar to what was earlier observed on the wild type CBH I at lower pH.

Temperature-induced inversion of elution order in the enantioseparation of sotalol on a cellobiohydrolase I-based stationary phase

The effect of temperature on the resolution of (RS)-sotalol by immobilized cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I) was studied between 5 and 40 degrees C and Van 't Hoff plots of ln k versus 1/T were acquired at different pH values of the aqueous mobile phase and in the presence of varying organic cosolvents. The elution order of the enantiomers reverses in the range between 17 and 28 degrees C. Beyond this range, enantioseparations with comparatively high resolution factors are achieved either by decreasing or by increasing the temperature. The composition of the mobile phase influences the "crossover" temperature as well as the character of the global adsorption process of the (R)-(-)-enantiomer. Under certain conditions, (R)-(-)-sotalol exhibits an unusual endothermic adsorption behavior. Its retention time increases with increasing temperature. At room temperature (23 degrees C) the enantiomeric elution order can also be regulated by the solvent additive.

Selectivity in capillary electrophoresis: the use of proteins

Proteins, by their very diverse nature, provide a wide variety of options for generating selectivity in capillary electrophoresis (CE). Their use in different modes of CE will be considered in this review. Proteins added in solution to the background electrolyte allow separations to be made in a similar fashion to other electrokinetic chromatography methods, e.g., micellar separations. Alternatively, different immobilization schemes can be used to secure proteins within the capillary; these have included capillary electrochromatography with the protein grafted onto a silica support, or immobilization of the protein within a gel structure. Compounds varying in size from small inorganic ions to biopolymers may be bound by proteins. There is the potential for any sort of intermolecular interaction to play a role in the binding process (e.g., hydrophobic interactions, electrostatic interactions, etc.). Very specific high-affinity binding often occurs, but also there is often weaker, non-selective binding. Frequently the interactions of chiral compounds with proteins are stereoselective. Obtaining chiral selectivity has been one of the main applications of protein selectors in CE, and this use will be emphasized here in a discussion structured by type of protein. As well as utilizing the selectivity of proteins to develop separations, the role of CE in investigating ligand-protein interactions will be emphasized.

The active sites of cellulases are involved in chiral recognition: a comparison of cellobiohydrolase 1 and endoglucanase 1

The cellulases cellobiohydrolase 1 (CBH 1) and endoglucanase 1 (EG 1) from the fungus Trichoderma reesei are closely related with 40% sequence identity and very similar in structure. In CBH 1 the active site is enclosed by long loops and some antiparallel beta-strands forming a 40 A long tunnel, whereas in EG 1 part of those loops are missing so that the enzyme has a more common active site groove. Both enzymes were immobilized on silica and these materials were used as chiral stationary phases for chromatographic separation of the enantiomers of two chiral drugs, propranolol and alprenolol. The CBH 1 phase showed much better resolution than did the EG 1 phase, suggesting that the tunnel structure of the protein may play an important role in the chiral separation. The chiral compounds were found to be competitive inhibitors of both enzymes when p-nitrophenyl lactoside (pNPL) was used as substrate. (S)-enantiomers showed stronger inhibitory effects and also longer retention time on the stationary phases than the (R)-enantiomers. The consistency between kinetic data and retention on the stationary phases clearly shows that the enzymatically active sites of CBH 1 and EG 1 are involved in chiral recognition.

Experimental and theoretical study of the adsorption behavior and mass transfer kinetics of propranolol enantiomers on cellulase protein as the selector

The thermodynamics and mass transfer kinetics of the retention of the R and S enantiomers of propranolol were investigated on a system comprising an acetic acid buffer solution as the mobile phase and the protein cellobiohydrolase I immobilized on silica as the stationary phase. The bi-Langmuir isotherm model fitted best to each set of single-component isotherm data. The monolayer capacity of the nonchiral type of adsorption sites was 22.9 mM. For the chiral type of sites, it was 0.24 mM for the R enantiomer and 0.64 mM for the S enantiomer. Peak tailing was observed, even at very low concentrations allowing operation of the low-capacity chiral sites under linear conditions. This tailing can be explained on the basis of heterogeneous mass transfer kinetics. At higher concentrations, which are often used in analytical applications, the isotherms on the chiral sites no longer have a linear behavior, and peak tailing is consequently more pronounced. Under those conditions, peak tailing originates from the combined effect of heterogeneous thermodynamics and heterogeneous mass transfer kinetics. These complex phenomena are explained and modeled using the transport-dispersive model with a solid film linear driving force model modified to account for heterogeneous mass transfer kinetics. The rate coefficient of the mass transfer kinetics was found to be concentration dependent.