Sense or antisense? False priming reverse transcription controls are required for determining sequence orientation by reverse transcription-PCR

[Identification regulatory noncoding RNAs of human papilloma virus type 16 (Papillomaviridae: Alphapapillomavirus: Human papillomavirus) in cervical tumors]

INTRODUCTION

High carcinogenic-risk human papillomaviruses (hrHPVs) are recognized as etiological agents of cervical cancer. Constant expression of the viral oncoproteins, E6 and E7, is required for maintenance of the malignant phenotype of tumor cells. The exact mechanism of regulation of viral oncogenes expression in tumor cells is not fully elucidated.

THE PURPOSE

identification of viral noncoding RNAs (ncRNAs) in HPV16-positve cervical cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The reverse transcription polymerase chain reactions were used to detect viral ncRNAs in HPV16-positve primary cervical squamous cell carcinomas and SiHa and CasKi cell lines. The knockdown technique with oligonucleotides complementary to ncRNAs was used to elucidate their functions.

RESULTS

We have identified ncRNAs transcribed in the upstream regulatory region of HPV16 in the cervical carcinoma cell lines and in 32 out 32 cervical squamous cell carcinomas with episomal or integrated forms of HPV16 DNA. Knockdown of sense or antisense strains of ncRNAs by oligonucleotides results in a decrease or increase of the E6 and E7 oncogenes mRNA levels in cells, respectively. These changes of oncogenes mRNA levels are accompanied by the modulation of the levels of the p53 protein, the main target of the E6 oncoprotein.

CONCLUSION

The presence of regulatory ncRNAs in all examined tumors and cell lines revealed for the first time indicates their necessity for maintenance of constant expression of E6 and E7 oncogenes in them. The findings can be useful for understanding of the fundamental aspects of the viral expression regulation in HPV16-positive tumors.

Advancing the Rose Rosette Virus Minireplicon and Encapsidation System by Incorporating GFP, Mutations, and the CMV 2b Silencing Suppressor

Plant infecting emaraviruses have segmented negative strand RNA genomes and little is known about their infection cycles due to the lack of molecular tools for reverse genetic studies. Therefore, we innovated a rose rosette virus (RRV) minireplicon containing the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene to study the molecular requirements for virus replication and encapsidation. Sequence comparisons among RRV isolates and structural modeling of the RNA dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) and nucleocapsid (N) revealed three natural mutations of the type species isolate that we reverted to the common species sequences: (a) twenty-one amino acid truncations near the endonuclease domain (named delA), (b) five amino acid substitutions near the putative viral RNA binding loop (subT), and (c) four amino acid substitutions in N (NISE). The delA and subT in the RdRp influenced the levels of GFP, gRNA, and agRNA at 3 but not 5 days post inoculation (dpi), suggesting these sequences are essential for initiating RNA synthesis and replication. The NISE mutation led to sustained GFP, gRNA, and agRNA at 3 and 5 dpi indicating that the N supports continuous replication and GFP expression. Next, we showed that the cucumber mosaic virus (CMV strain FNY) 2b singularly enhanced GFP expression and RRV replication. Including agRNA2 with the RRV replicon produced observable virions. In this study we developed a robust reverse genetic system for investigations into RRV replication and virion assembly that could be a model for other emaravirus species.

A strand-specific real-time quantitative RT-PCR assay for distinguishing the genomic and antigenomic RNAs of Rift Valley fever phlebovirus

Rift Valley Fever phlebovirus (RVFV), genus Phlebovirus, family Phenuiviridae, order Bunyavirales, has a single-stranded, negative-sense RNA genome, consisting of L, M and S segments. Here, we report the establishment of a strand-specific, quantitative reverse transcription (RT)-PCR assay system that can selectively distinguish between the genomic and antigenomic RNAs of each of the three viral RNA segments produced in RVFV-infected cells. To circumvent the obstacle of primer-independent cDNA synthesis during RT, we used a tagged, strand-specific RT primer, carrying a non-viral 'tag' sequence at the 5' end, which ensured the strand-specificity through the selective amplification of only the tagged cDNA in the real-time PCR assay. We used this assay system to examine the kinetics of intracellular accumulation of genomic and antigenomic viral RNAs in mammalian cells infected with the MP-12 strain of RVFV. The genomic RNA copy numbers, for all three viral RNA segments, were higher than that of their corresponding antigenomic RNAs throughout the time-course of infection, with a notable exception, wherein the M segment genomic and antigenomic RNAs exhibited similar copy numbers at specific times post-infection. Overall, this assay system could be a useful tool to gain an insight into the mechanisms of RNA replication and packaging in RVFV.

Detection and mitigation of spurious antisense expression with RoSA

Antisense transcription is known to have a range of impacts on sense gene expression, including (but not limited to) impeding transcription initiation, disrupting post-transcriptional processes, and enhancing, slowing, or even preventing transcription of the sense gene. Strand-specific RNA-Seq protocols preserve the strand information of the original RNA in the data, and so can be used to identify where antisense transcription may be implicated in regulating gene expression. However, our analysis of 199 strand-specific RNA-Seq experiments reveals that spurious antisense reads are often present in these datasets at levels greater than 1% of sense gene expression levels. Furthermore, these levels can vary substantially even between replicates in the same experiment, potentially disrupting any downstream analysis, if the incorrectly assigned antisense counts dominate the set of genes with high antisense transcription levels. Currently, no tools exist to detect or correct for this spurious antisense signal. Our tool, RoSA (Removal of Spurious Antisense), detects the presence of high levels of spurious antisense read alignments in strand-specific RNA-Seq datasets. It uses incorrectly spliced reads on the antisense strand and/or ERCC spikeins (if present in the data) to calculate both global and gene-specific antisense correction factors. We demonstrate the utility of our tool to filter out spurious antisense transcript counts in an Arabidopsis thaliana RNA-Seq experiment. Availability: RoSA is open source software available under the GPL licence via the Barton Group GitHub page https://github.com/bartongroup.

Development of a strand-specific real-time qRT-PCR for the accurate detection and quantitation of West Nile virus RNA

Studying the tropism and replication kinetics of West Nile virus (WNV) in different cell types in vitro and in tissues in animal models is important for understanding its pathogenesis. As detection of the negative strand viral RNA is a more reliable indicator of active replication for single-stranded positive-sense RNA viruses, the specificity of qRT-PCR assays currently used for the detection of WNV positive and negative strand RNA was reassessed. It was shown that self- and falsely-primed cDNA was generated during the reverse transcription step in an assay employing unmodified primers and several reverse transcriptases. As a result, a qRT-PCR assay using the thermostable rTth in combination with tagged primers was developed, which greatly improved strand specificity by circumventing the events of self- and false-priming. The reliability of the assay was then addressed in vitro using BV-2 microglia cells as well as in C57/BL6 mice. It was possible to follow the kinetics of positive and negative-strand RNA synthesis both in vitro and in vivo; however, the sensitivity of the assay will need to be optimized in order to detect and quantify negative-strand RNA synthesis in the very early stages of infection. Overall, the strand-specific qRT-PCR assay developed in this study is an effective tool to quantify WNV RNA, reassess viral replication, and study tropism of WNV in the context of WNV pathogenesis.

Evidence classification of high-throughput protocols and confidence integration in RegulonDB

RegulonDB provides curated information on the transcriptional regulatory network of Escherichia coli and contains both experimental data and computationally predicted objects. To account for the heterogeneity of these data, we introduced in version 6.0, a two-tier rating system for the strength of evidence, classifying evidence as either ‘weak’ or ‘strong’ (Gama-Castro,S., Jimenez-Jacinto,V., Peralta-Gil,M. et al. RegulonDB (Version 6.0): gene regulation model of Escherichia Coli K-12 beyond transcription, active (experimental) annotated promoters and textpresso navigation. Nucleic Acids Res., 2008;36:D120–D124.). We now add to our classification scheme the classification of high-throughput evidence, including chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) and RNA-seq technologies. To integrate these data into RegulonDB, we present two strategies for the evaluation of confidence, statistical validation and independent cross-validation. Statistical validation involves verification of ChIP data for transcription factor-binding sites, using tools for motif discovery and quality assessment of the discovered matrices. Independent cross-validation combines independent evidence with the intention to mutually exclude false positives. Both statistical validation and cross-validation allow to upgrade subsets of data that are supported by weak evidence to a higher confidence level. Likewise, cross-validation of strong confidence data extends our two-tier rating system to a three-tier system by introducing a third confidence score ‘confirmed’.

Database URL:http://regulondb.ccg.unam.mx/

Technique for strand-specific gene-expression analysis and monitoring of primer-independent cDNA synthesis in reverse transcription

Primer-independent cDNA synthesis during reverse transcription hinders quantitative analysis of bidirectional mRNA synthesis in eukaryotes as well as in cells infected with RNA viruses. We report a simple RT-PCR-based assay for strand-specific gene-expression analysis. By modifying the cDNA sequence during reverse transcription, the opposite strands of target sequences can be simultaneously detected by postamplification melting curve analysis and primer-initiated transcripts are readily distinguished from nonspecifically primed cDNA. We have utilized this technique to optimize the specificity of reverse transcription on a panel of 15 target genes. Primer-independent reverse transcription occurred for all target sequences when reverse transcription was performed at 42°C and accounted for 11%-57% of the final PCR amplification products. By raising the reaction temperature to 55°C, the specificity of reverse transcription could be increased without significant loss of sensitivity. We have also demonstrated the utility of this technique for analysis of (+) and (-) RNA synthesis of influenza A virus in infected cells. Thus, this technique represents a powerful tool for analysis of bidirectional RNA synthesis.

Development of a strand specific real-time RT-qPCR assay for the detection and quantitation of murine norovirus RNA

Murine norovirus (MNV), currently the only norovirus that efficiently replicates in cell culture, is often used as a model system to understand the molecular mechanisms of norovirus replication. MNV is a single stranded positive sense RNA virus of the Caliciviridae family. Replication of MNV involves the synthesis of both full length genomic and sub-genomic RNAs. The replication of these RNAs involves the synthesis of negative strand intermediates. To understand the molecular mechanism of RNA replication and the role of viral and host factors in virus replication, it is necessary to quantify accurately both positive and negative sense RNA molecules of the viral RNA during replication. Increasingly, strand specific reverse transcription-quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) is becoming the method of choice for this kind of quantitation. Many strategies have been developed to avoid the false priming property of reverse transcriptase and to amplify specifically one strand in the presence of excess opposite strand. In this report, a SYBR based, real time RT-qPCR assay was developed to detect and quantify specifically the negative and the positive sense RNAs of MNV genomic RNA. This assay is based on using a tagged RT primer containing a non-viral sequence at the 5' end of the viral strand specific sequence. This non-viral sequence is then used to amplify selectively the strand specific cDNA at the PCR stage. This assay can be used for a range of MNV strains including MNV-1 and 3, as these are now widely accepted for use in molecular studies. The specificity of this assay was determined by its ability to quantify one strand in the presence of up to 10(6) copies of competitor opposite sense RNA. Using this assay, the production of both strands of MNV-1 RNA was monitored during viral single step growth curve.

Triazole-linked DNA as a primer surrogate in the synthesis of first-strand cDNA

A phosphate-eliminated nonnatural oligonucleotide serves as a primer surrogate in reverse transcription reaction of mRNA. Despite of the nonnatural triazole linkages in the surrogate, the reverse transcriptase effectively elongated cDNA sequences on the 3'-downstream of the primer by transcription of the complementary sequence of mRNA. A structure-activity comparison with the reference natural oligonucleotides shows the superior priming activity of the surrogate containing triazole-linkages. The nonnatural linkages also protect the transcribed cDNA from digestion reactions with 5'-exonuclease and enable us to remove noise transcripts of unknown origins.

Commercial reverse transcriptase as source of false-positive strand-specific RNA detection in human cells

Recently, an increasing number of studies describe the existence of non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) involved in gene expression modulation. Since the observation that antisense ncRNAs are implicated in human disorders, there is more and more interest in ncRNAs. A commonly used technique to investigate the expression of an antisense ncRNAs is strand-specific reverse transcription coupled with polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). The advantage of this accurate technique is that it does not require any special equipment or expertise. The disadvantage is that it can lead easily to false-positive results. We applied strand-specific RT-PCR to investigate the presence of antisense ncRNA associated to Retinoic Acid Receptor Beta 2 (RARβ2) in different human tumoral cell lines. By performing this technique, we observed false-positive detection of ncRNA. For accurate interpretation of the results in RT-PCR experiments, we introduced a «No primer» control that reveals non-specific cDNA synthesis. Moreover, we report the presence of non-specific cDNA amplification with five of the most frequently used reverse transcriptase in absence of added primers. We found that the choice of the reverse transcriptase as well as the conditions of the reaction (RT temperature and PCR cycle number) are important parameters to choose as the different reverse transcriptases do not display the same cDNA synthesis background. This previously observed phenomenon was reported to originate from the «self-priming» of RNA template. Here, we report rather the presence of RNA contaminants associated with one of the reverse transcriptase studied that might contribute to non-specific cDNA synthesis.

Strand-specific transcriptome profiling with directly labeled RNA on genomic tiling microarrays

Background

With lower manufacturing cost, high spot density, and flexible probe design, genomic tiling microarrays are ideal for comprehensive transcriptome studies. Typically, transcriptome profiling using microarrays involves reverse transcription, which converts RNA to cDNA. The cDNA is then labeled and hybridized to the probes on the arrays, thus the RNA signals are detected indirectly. Reverse transcription is known to generate artifactual cDNA, in particular the synthesis of second-strand cDNA, leading to false discovery of antisense RNA. To address this issue, we have developed an effective method using RNA that is directly labeled, thus by-passing the cDNA generation. This paper describes this method and its application to the mapping of transcriptome profiles.

Results

RNA extracted from laboratory cultures of Porphyromonas gingivalis was fluorescently labeled with an alkylation reagent and hybridized directly to probes on genomic tiling microarrays specifically designed for this periodontal pathogen. The generated transcriptome profile was strand-specific and produced signals close to background level in most antisense regions of the genome. In contrast, high levels of signal were detected in the antisense regions when the hybridization was done with cDNA. Five antisense areas were tested with independent strand-specific RT-PCR and none to negligible amplification was detected, indicating that the strong antisense cDNA signals were experimental artifacts.

Conclusions

An efficient method was developed for mapping transcriptome profiles specific to both coding strands of a bacterial genome. This method chemically labels and uses extracted RNA directly in microarray hybridization. The generated transcriptome profile was free of cDNA artifactual signals. In addition, this method requires fewer processing steps and is potentially more sensitive in detecting small amount of RNA compared to conventional end-labeling methods due to the incorporation of more fluorescent molecules per RNA fragment.

Detection of antisense RNA transcripts by strand-specific RT-PCR

Comprehensive genome annotation requires extensive cDNA analysis. This analysis has identified natural antisense transcripts (NATs), which are distinct from the microRNAs, siRNAs, and piRNAs, in a number of diverse eukaryotes. This wide conservation supports the possibility of an important role for NATs in regulating cellular processes. Investigating their roles requires the confirmation of expressed sequence tag (EST) data and the detection of antisense transcripts in distinct cellular backgrounds. This chapter describes the use of a reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) method for the detection of antisense transcripts. The protocol was designed to reduce the number of first strand synthesis reactions during screening for antisense transcripts through the utilization of antisense directed primers and oligo dT to prime first strand synthesis. These results are further confirmed using sense and antisense directed primers in first strand synthesis. Results indicate that optimization of the screens requires proper controls to confirm removal of gDNA contamination and to rule out self-priming as a source of first strand products.

Regulation of FADS2 expression and activity in European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax, L.) fed a vegetable diet

Supplies of marine fish oils are limited, and continued growth in aquaculture production dictates that lipid substitutes in fish diets must be used without compromising fish health and product quality. In this study, the total substitution of a fish meal and fish oil by a blend of vegetable meals (corn, soybean, wheat and lupin) and linseed oil in the diet of European sea bass (Dicentrachus labrax) was investigated. Two groups of European sea bass were fed with fish diet (FD) or vegetable diet (VD) for 9months. VD, totally deprived of eicosapentaenoate (EPA; 20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoate (DHA; 22:6n-3), revealed a nutritional deficiency and affected growth performance. Whilst VD induced a significant increase in fatty acid desaturase 2 (FADS2) and sterol binding regulatory element-binding protein 1 (SREBP-1) mRNA levels, the desaturation rate of [1-(14)C]18:3n-3 into [1-(14)C]18:4n-3, analysed in microsomal preparations using HPLC method, did not show an upregulation of FADS2 activities in liver and intestine of fish fed VD. Moreover Western-blot analysis did not revealed any significant difference of FADS2 protein amount between the two dietary groups. These data demonstrate that sea bass exhibits a desaturase (FADS2) activity whatever their diet, but a post-transcriptional regulation of fads2 RNA prevents an increase of enzyme in fish fed a HUFA-free diet. This led to a lower fish growth and poor muscle HUFA content.

Antisense transcripts of V(D)J rearrangements; artifacts caused by false priming?

Somatic hypermutation (SH) of V(D)J rearrangements at the IGH and IGL loci diversifies the IG repertoire during the germinal center response. SH is absolutely dependent on the enzyme activation induced cytidine deaminase (AID) that initiates the SH process by deaminating C nucleotides in ssDNA. Mutations from G and C are thought to occur as a result of strand symmetrical deamination of C by AID on the coding and non-coding strands respectively. Mutations from A and T are introduced in a strand biased way during error prone repair of the AID induced lesion. SH is linked to transcription and it has been proposed that bidirectional transcription across V(D)J rearrangements occurs in activated and quiescent B cells and that it is co-opted to facilitate the accessibility of the two DNA strands by regulating accessibility of single stranded DNA to AID. We have developed a quantitative method to study directional transcription. Our method controls for differences in efficiency and specificity of reverse transcription that are known to be able to generate false positive data. This method does not detect antisense transcripts in exonic or intronic regions within the hypermutation domain of the spontaneously hypermutating cell line Ramos, or in human blood B cells or tonsil cells, providing convincing evidence that antisense transcripts are rare or absent in human B cells.

Development of a Taqman RT-PCR assay for the detection and quantification of negatively stranded RNA of human enteroviruses: evidence for false-priming and improvement by tagged RT-PCR

Human enteroviruses are among the most common viruses infecting humans. These viruses are known to be able to infect a wide range of tissues and are believed to establish persistent infections. Enteroviruses are positive-sense single-stranded RNA viruses whose replication involves the synthesis of negative strand intermediates. Therefore, the specific detection of negatively stranded viral RNA in tissues or cells is a reliable marker of active enteroviral replication. The present report presents the development of a real-time RT-PCR allowing the specific detection and quantification of negatively stranded viral RNA. Since it was known that specific amplification of single-stranded RNA can be made difficult by false-priming events leading to false-positive or overestimated results, the assay was developed by using a tagged RT primer. This tagged RT-PCR was shown to be able to amplify specifically negative RNA of enteroviruses grown in cell cultures by preventing the amplification of cDNAs generated by false-priming.

Does this band make sense? Limits to expression based cancer studies

Cancer researchers commonly employ reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for gene expression analysis of cancer cells. While this technique is facile and reproducible, it is not without limitations. The human genome contains abundant nearly identical sequences (e.g. pseudogenes) to mRNA transcript sequences, which amplify when performing RT-PCR on samples with even trace amounts of genomic DNA. Such sequences include housekeeping transcripts such as beta-actin and GAPDH. This is also true for numerous gene products whose expression is altered in disease states such as cancer (e.g. pp32). Moreover, we describe that amplification of undesirable sequences is not simply avoided by designing primers spanning multiple exons. We also found that template-specific reverse transcriptase reactions lack the specificity necessary to definitively determine the sense or anti-sense orientation of an mRNA transcript. Given the above mentioned caveats and limitations of expression analysis studies, we encourage cancer investigators to test for the existence of intronless genomic sequences that are similar to the specific transcript of the gene being studied. Further, RNA samples should be completely genomic DNA-free prior to performing RT-PCR based assays. Finally, to ensure reliability of RT-PCR or array results, we recommend not utilizing the widely accepted loading controls, GAPDH and/or beta-actin.