Comparing the use of different domestic wastewaters for coupling microalgal production and nutrient removal

Microalgae for bioremediation: advances, challenges, and public perception on genetic engineering

The increase in the global population and industrial activities has led to an extensive use of water, the release of wastewater, and overall contamination of the environment. To address these issues, efficient treatment methods have been developed to decrease wastewater nutrient content and contaminants. Microalgae are a promising tool as a sustainable alternative to traditional wastewater treatment. Furthermore, the biomass obtained from the wastewater treatment can be used in different applications, having a positive economic impact. This review describes the potential of microalgae as a biological wastewater remediation tool, including the use of genetically engineered strains. Their current industrial utilization and their untapped commercial potential in terms of bioremediation are also examined. Finally, this work discusses how microalgal biotechnology is perceived by the public and governments, analyses the potential risks of microalgae to the environment, and examines standard procedures that can be implemented for the safe biocontainment of large-scale microalgae cultures.

Evaluation of the fertilizer potential of Chlorella vulgaris and Scenedesmus obliquus grown in agricultural drainage water from maize fields

Producing microalgae with agricultural drainage water (ADW) allows recycling water and nutrients, with the production of a biofertilizer, avoiding receiving waters' contamination. Chlorella vulgaris and Scenedesmus obliquus were cultivated using ADW and standard media supplementation and presented higher productivities, relatively to the control industrial growth medium (using freshwater). Selected strains were grown outdoors in pilot flat panel photobioreactors, reaching 2.20 g L^-1 for S. obliquus and 1.15 g L^-1 for C. vulgaris, and degrading herbicides in the ADW to non-quantifiable concentrations. The potential of the C. vulgaris and S. obliquus suspensions to replace 50% of nitrogen (N) mineral fertilization of lettuce (0.5 g pot^-1) was evaluated through a pot trial, also using a 2-times (1.0 g pot^-1) and 5-times (2.5 g pot^-1) higher dose, applied 31 days before lettuce transplanting. Even the lower dose of N, applied via C. vulgaris or S. obliquus suspensions, was able to provide significantly higher lettuce fresh matter yield, relatively to the mineral fertilized control. Soil enzymatic activities were improved, with significantly higher dehydrogenase, β-glucosidase, and acid phosphatase activities for the 2.5 g pot^-1 dose, more marked for S. obliquus, which was also able to increase soil organic matter content. Both the non-fertilized control and microalgae fertilized pots led to similar soil electrical conductivities, 3-fold lower than in the N-mineral fertilized pots, evidencing the capacity of microalgae fertilizers to avoid soil secondary salinization. Results suggest benefits from using ADW from maize cultivation to produce C. vulgaris or S. obliquus suspensions, that can be further used as liquid organic slow-release fertilizer.

Application of transposon insertion site sequencing method in the exploration of gene function in microalgae

Microalgae are a large group of organisms that can produce various useful substances through photosynthesis. Microalgae need to be genetically modified at the molecular level to become "Chassis Cells" for food, medicine, energy, and environmental protection and, consequently, obtain benefits from microalgae resources. Insertional mutagenesis of microalgae using transposons is a practical possibility for understanding the function of microalgae genes. Theoretical and technical support is provided in this manuscript for applying transposons to microalgae gene function by summarizing the sequencing method of transposon insertion sites.

Light-Dependent Nitrate Removal Capacity of Green Microalgae

In the present study, Chlamydomonas sp. MACC-216 was used to investigate total nitrate removal in TAP medium with sodium nitrate as the sole nitrogen source under several light conditions made up of permuted combinations of three light colors (referred to as blue, red, and white light) and three light intensities (50 µmol m^-2 s^-1, 100 µmol m^-2 s^-1, and 250 µmol m^-2 s^-1). It was observed that nitrate removal efficiency is influenced by light color as well as light intensity. Additionally, Chlamydomonas sp. MACC-216 was cultivated in synthetic wastewater under four light conditions, namely, Blue 250, Blue 125 + Red 125, Red 250, and White 250, where it showed the highest nitrate removal efficiency and nitrate reductase activity under the Blue 125 + Red 125 light condition. To observe the impact of light color on the nitrate removal capacity of Chlamydomonas sp. MACC-216, the expression of five genes participating in nitrate transport and reduction (NRT1, NRT2.1, NRT2.2, NIA, and MCP) was also analyzed; these genes showed the highest expression under the Blue 125 + Red 125 light condition. Based on the above-mentioned findings, the blue + red light combination emerged as a promising light combination for nitrate removal. Hence, our study suggests the importance of the blue + red light combination together with high light intensity, as the optimal light condition for nitrate removal from synthetic wastewater in comparison to other monochromatic lights with high light intensity.

Photosynthetic Carbon Uptake Correlates with Cell Protein Content during Lipid Accumulation in the Microalga Chlorella vulgaris NIES 227

Large-scale microalgae cultivation for biofuel production is currently limited by the possibility of maintaining high microalgae yield and high lipid content, concomitantly. In this study, the physiological changes of Chlorella vulgaris NIES 227 during lipid accumulation under nutrient limitation was monitored in parallel with the photosynthetic capacity of the microalgae to fix carbon from the proxy of oxygen productivity. In the exponential growth phase, as the biomass composition did not vary significantly (approx. 53.6 ± 7.8% protein, 6.64 ± 3.73% total lipids, and 26.0 ± 9.2% total carbohydrates of the total biomass dry-weight), the growth capacity of the microalgae was preserved (with net O2 productivity remaining above (4.44 ± 0.93) × 10−7 g O2·µmol PAR−1). Under nutrient limitation, protein content decreased (minimum of approx. 18.6 ± 6.0%), and lipid content increased (lipid content up to 56.0 ± 0.8%). The physiological change of the microalgae was associated with a loss of photosynthetic activity, down to a minimum (1.27 ± 0.26) × 10−7 g O2·µmol PAR−1. The decrease in photosynthetic O2 productivity was evidenced to correlate to the cell internal-protein content (R2 = 0.632, p = 2.04 × 10−6, N = 25). This approach could serve to develop productivity models, with the aim of optimizing industrial processes.

Multiscale modelling of mixotrophic algal growth in pilot-scale photobioreactors and its application to microalgal cultivation using wastewater

This multiscale model quantifies transport and reaction processes in mixotrophic microalgal growth at three characteristic length scales, namely, macro (photobioreactor), meso (algal cell), micro (organelles). The macro and the meso scale equations capture the temporal dynamics of the transport of CO₂, O₂, H⁺, organic carbon and nitrogen sources in the photobioreactor and the cell, respectively, while the micro scale quantifies the reaction rates of CO₂ fixation and photorespiration in the chloroplast, and mitochondrial respiration. Our model is validated using our experiments (R² = 0.96-0.99) on urea, CO₂ (0.04-5%), and acetic acid-mediated mixotrophic cultivation of Chlorella sorokiniana for 138 h using municipal wastewater (with and without media) at 11,000 lx light in 25-liter pilot-scale bubble-column photobioreactors, which produces 0.47-2.74 g/L biomass with 22.8-29.6% lipids, while reducing the COD, ammonium, phosphate, nickel, and H⁺ concentrations by 65-89%. The alga assimilates the ammonium and the phosphates present in wastewater into amino acids and ATP, respectively. Our simulations quantify the autotrophic and heterotrophic components of mixotrophic biomass yield to find the optimal inlet CO₂ concentration (of 3%) that synergizes autotrophic CO₂ sequestration with heterotrophic assimilation of organic carbon, thereby maximizing both autotrophic and heterotrophic growths. Super-optimal levels of inlet CO₂ acidify the stroma of the chloroplast, inhibit RuBisCo's enzymatic activity for CO₂ fixation in the Calvin Cycle, decelerate carrier-mediated uptake of acetate, and reduce biomass yields. Our harvesting process drastically reduces the algal harvesting time to less than 29 min. This multiscale reaction-transport model provides a useful tool for further scaling up this pilot-scale technology that synergistically integrates CO₂ sequestration and wastewater treatment with rapid microalgal cultivation (using municipal wastewater without autoclaving) and cost-effective harvesting.

A techno-economic assessment of nutrient recovery from wastewater using microalgae: scenario in India collected from published literature

The true potential of the microalgae-based wastewater treatment (MWT) process is determined based on whether the process will provide a positive energy output and whether it is economically viable. The objectives of this study are dynamic modelling of microalgae growth based on initial wastewater concentration, temperature, solar radiation and a techno-economic assessment for an MWT scheme for application in a hot, dry climate. Through reference to relevant literature data on MWT in the Indian subcontinent, a selection of appropriate microalgal species Chlorella and Scenedesmus was made. The dynamic model developed was successfully calibrated and validated using independent experimental data collected from the published literature. Cost of production of bio-crude from microalgae grown in a hybrid photobioreactor and pond system in kitchen wastewater of Indian Institute of Technology, Hyderabad was calculated. A break-even selling price (BESP) of US$0.549/kg was obtained for the microalgae biomass. The cost of production of 1 L bio-crude was US$0.96 (Rs 69-74), which is comparable with crude oil cost. The model developed can be used by practising engineers to predict biomass growth and nutrient removal, thereby achieving a break-even point for cost efficiency.

Phycoremediation of milk processing wastewater and lipid-rich biomass production using Chlorella vulgaris under continuous batch system

This study compiles the results of phycoremediation of milk processing wastewater (MPWW) and production of lipid-rich Chlorella vulgaris biomass using a continuous batch system operated for 12-wks. After a 4-wks interval, a new MPWW was loaded photobioreactor to provide appropriate nutrient supply to algae. Results indicated that MPWW supported the algal growth efficiently and the maximum algal growth was recorded in the ranges of 400.36 to 421.58 mg L^-1 during 4-wk's of the cultivation cycle. Average reduction in total nitrogen, TN (45.82-69.18%); nitrate, NO₃ (93.32-94.54%); total ammonium nitrogen, TAN (92.94-94.54%); sulphate, SO₄^-2 (85.13-87.34%); total phosphorus (75.09-78.78%); and biochemical oxygen demands, BOD (89.53-92.40%) was recorded during 12-wks phycoremediation of MPWW. Harvested algal biomass (dry weight basis, DW) exhibited a significant content of total sugar (45.5%) and total lipid (39.7%). The lipid profiling results indicated the presence of palmitic acid (39.9%), oleic acid (21.08%), linoleic acid (13.13%), and other C18 compounds in algal biomass, suggesting the suitability of MPWW for Chlorella vulgaris cultivations. Algal biomass exhibited a high heating value (MJ/Kg of DW) in the range of 17.3 to 25.1, comparable to other lignocellulose biomass to be used for bioenergy purposes. Results of this study indicate that MPWW could be utilized as a valuable medium for Chlorella vulgaris cultivation under a circular economy approach: wastewater treatment and bioenergy feedstock production. The effect of controlled environmental conditions on algal growth behavior and lipid composition in biomass, while using MPWW as a medium, could be investigated in future studies.

Removal of carbon and nitrogen in wastewater from a poultry processing plant in a photobioreactor cultivated with the microalga Chlorella vulgaris

This study evaluates the removal of COD and nitrogen from poultry wastewater in photobioreactors. Cell growth, the effect of light intensity (3200, 9800, and 12000 lux) and air flow (1.6, 3.2, and 4.8 L min^-1) as a source of CO₂ in bold basal medium and wastewater with different concentrations of COD were evaluated. The growth kinetics were modeled by using the Gompertz model and logistic model for both culture media. COD removals of up to 95% were achieved, and poultry wastewater was found to be a viable growing medium for Chlorella vulgaris. Finally, the wastewater met Mexican standards, and biomass was obtained with products valued as lipids (3.2 g lipid/100 g biomass) and proteins (342.94 mg L^-1). The culture was found to have a dilatory behavior, and the rheological models of Ostwald de Waele, Ostwald de Waele linealized and Herschel Bulkley were utilized, showing a laminar behavior.

Outdoor phycoremediation and biomass harvesting optimization of microalgae Botryococcus sp. cultivated in food processing wastewater using an enclosed photobioreactor

Microalgae cultivation is well known as a sustainable method for eco-friendly wastewater phycoremediation and valuable biomass production. This study investigates the feasibility and kinetic removal of organic compounds and nutrients from food processing wastewater (FPW) using Botryococcus sp. in an enclosed photobioreactor. Simultaneously, response surface methodology (RSM) via face-centered central composite design (FCCCD) was applied to optimize the effects of alum and chitosan dosage and pH sensitivity on flocculation efficiency. The maximum growth rate of Botryococcus sp. cultivated in FPW was 1.83 mg day^-1with the highest removal of chemical oxygen demand (COD), total organic carbon (TOC), and total phosphorus (TP) after 12 days of phycoremediation of 96.1%, 87.2%, and 35.4%, respectively. A second-order polynomial function fits well with the experimental results. Both coagulant dosage and pH significantly (p < 0.05) affect the flocculation efficiency of Botryococcus sp. biomass cultivated in FPW. The highest flocculation efficiency (92.4%) was obtained at a dosage of 166 mg L^-1and pH 12 for alum coagulant, while 94.9% flocculation efficiency was achieved with optimum chitosan dosage and pH of 30 mg L^-1and 5.54, respectively. In general, Botryococcus sp. shows a great removal efficiency of FPW contamination, whereas RSM provides excellent analysis for biomass harvesting optimization using a flocculation technique.

Algal biopolymers as sustainable resources for a net-zero carbon bioeconomy

The era for eco-friendly polymers was ushered by the marine plastic menace and with the discovery of emerging pollutants such as micro-, nano-plastics, and plastic leachates from fossil fuel-based polymers. This review investigates algae-derived natural, carbon neutral polysaccharides and polyesters, their structure, biosynthetic mechanisms, biopolymers and biocomposites production process, followed by biodegradability of the polymers. The review proposes acceleration of research in this promising area to address the need for eco-friendly polymers and to increase the cost-effectiveness of algal biorefineries by coupling biofuel, high-value products, and biopolymer production using waste and wastewater-grown algal biomass. Such a strategy improves overall sustainability by lowering costs and carbon emissions in algal biorefineries, eventually contributing towards the much touted circular, net-zero carbon future economies. Finally, this review analyses the evolution of citation networks, which in turn highlight the emergence of a new frontier of sustainable polymers from algae.

Biochar application in organics and ultra-violet quenching substances removal from sludge dewatering leachate for algae production

Algae production in nutrient rich sludge dewatering leachate after biogas production is a promising option for wastewater treatment plants. However, the ultra-violet (UV) absorbing characteristic of UV-quenching substances (UVQS) existing in these waters can notably reduce the light transmission within the liquid body. The present work demonstrates a comparative adsorptive removal of UVQS, and other organic substances (expressed as COD and TOC) onto the "acid catalyst" functionalised adsorbent (PPhA) and commercial activated carbon (CAC) from leachate originating from leftover sludge dewatering after biogas production. Laboratory scale column studies were performed to investigate the adsorption performance of selected parameters. The PPhA increased the UV transmittance of leachate more than 4 times and outperformed CAC. Bed Depth Service Time and Yan models were used on the experimental data in order to estimate the maximum adsorption capacity and evaluate the characteristics of the fixed-bed. The PPhA equilibrium uptake of COD and TOC amounted to 5.7 mg/g and 0.9 mg/g, respectively. The postulated removal mechanism in environmentally relevant conditions (e.g., pH neutral) suggested a complex interaction between the biochar and organic macromolecules. Diluted phosphoric acid solution (0.01 mol/L) was successfully used for the column regeneration. Beside the UVQS, PPhA showed affinity towards toxic heavy metals (e.g., Pb, Ni, Co) pointing out the rich surface chemistry of the PPhA. Based on the obtained results and successfully implemented scale-up methodology, the low-cost PPhA adsorbent might effectively compete with the CAC as a highly efficient platform in wastewaters leachate processing.

Biologia Futura: potential of different forms of microalgae for soil improvement

Products derived from microalgae have great potential in diverse field. As a part of the enhancing agriculture application, various forms of microalgae applications have been developed so far. They are known to influence soil properties. The various forms of application may enhance soil in more or less similar manner. They can help improve soil health, nitrogen, and phosphorus content, and even carbon sequestration. Thus, overall, it can enhance fertility of the soil.

Resource recovery through bioremediation of wastewaters and waste carbon by microalgae: a circular bioeconomy approach

Microalgal biomass-based biofuels are a promising alternative to fossil fuels. Microalgal biofuels' major obstacles are the water and carbon sources for their cultivation and biomass harvest from the liquid medium. To date, an economically viable process is not available for algal based biofuels. The circular bioeconomy is an attractive concept for reuse, reduce, and recycle resources. The recovery of nutrients from waste and effluents by microalgae could significantly impact the escalating demands of energy and nutraceutical source to the growing population. Wastewaters from different sources are enriched with nutrients and carbon, and these resources can be recovered and utilized for the circular bioeconomy approach. However, the utilization of wastewaters and waste seems to be an essential strategy for mass cultivation of microalgae to minimizing freshwater consumption, carbon, nutrients cost, nitrogen, phosphorus removal, and other pollutants loads from wastewater and generating sustainable biomass for value addition for either biofuels or other chemicals. Hence, the amalgamation of wastewater treatment with the mass cultivation of microalgae improved the conventional treatment process and environmental impacts. This review provides complete information on the latest progress and developments of microalgae as potential biocatalyst for the remediation of wastewaters and waste carbon to recover resources through biomass with metabolites for various industrial applications and large-scale cultivation in wastewaters, and future perspectives are discussed.

Modelling of photosynthesis, respiration, and nutrient yield coefficients in Scenedemus almeriensis culture as a function of nitrogen and phosphorus

Photo-respirometric tecniques are applied for evaluating photosynthetic activity in phototrophic organisms. These methods allow to evaluate photosynthetic response under different conditions. In this work, the influence of nutrient availability (nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate) on the photosynthesis and respiration of Scenedesmus almeriensis was studied using short photo-respirometric measurements. Both photosynthesis and respiration increasing until saturation value and consecutively diminishing, presenting inhibition by high concentrations. Regarding the influence of phosphorus concentration in microalgae cells, a similar hyperbolic trend was observed but no inhibition was observed at high concentration. Based on these experimental data, the respiration, and the photosynthesis rate of S. almeriensis were modelled using Haldane equation for nitrate and ammonium data, and Monod equation for phosphate data. In addition, experiments were performed to determine the yield coefficients for both nitrogen and phosphorus in S. almeriensis cultures. The data showed that the nitrogen and phosphorous coefficient yields are not constant, being modified as a function of nutrients concentration, presenting the luxury uptake phenomena. Finally, the proposed models were incorporated into a simulation tool to evaluate the photosynthetic activity and the nutrient yield coefficients of S. almeriensis when different culture media and wastewaters are used as a nitrogen and phosphorous source for its growth. Key points • Microalgal photosynthesis/respiration vary as a function of nutrients availability. • Photosynthesis inhibition appears at high N-NO ₃ ^- and N-NH₄⁺ concentrations. • Nutrient yield coefficients are influenced by luxury uptake phenomenon.

Domestic wastewater treatment by constructed wetland and microalgal treatment system for the production of value-added products

The main aim of this study is to treat domestic wastewater in a hybrid Vertical Flow Constructed Wetland (VFCW-4.2 m²) and Microalgal Treatment System (MTS-1 m²). The objective is not only to treat Domestic wastewater (DW) but also to produce value-added products from microalgal biomass. The domestic wastewater was initially treated by VFCW and the VFCW effluent was further phycoremediated by MTS. Canna indica was used for wetland vegetation and resident microalgal consortium from VFCW effluent was used in MTS. The VFCW and MTS was operated at 1 m³/day (HRT-0.25 m³/m²-day, OLR-400 g/m²-day) and 0.03 m³/day (HRT-0.03 m³/m²-day, OLR-400 g/m²-day), respectively. The integrated system was observed to remove 68.9% COD, 77.4% NH₄-N, 75.8% TKN and 63.6% PO₄-P. The harvested Naive Biomass (NB) was observed to contain 16.7% of lipids (W/W). The Residual Biomass after Lipid Extraction (RBLE) was used as a substrate for ethanol production. The observed yield of ethanol using RBLE as a substrate was 33.4%. NB, RBLE, and Residual Biomass after Lipid and Sugar Extraction (RBLSE) indicated net biomethane yield (mL/g VS) of 211.8, 134.6 and 107.7, respectively. The present study demonstrated an initial attempt of demonstrating a hybrid wastewater treatment system for the production of value-added products in terms of biofuel.

Influence of wavelength photoperiods and N/P ratio on wastewater treatment with microalgae-bacteria

This research investigates the effect of mixing wavelength light photoperiods (12 h blue, 8 h blue: 4 h green, 4 h blue: 8 h green, and 12 h green) and N/P ratios (1.3 to 8.3) on the growth microalgae-bacteria systems, organic matter, and nutrient removals. The highest microalgae-bacteria growth performance (μ = 0.2 d^-1, 481.1 ± 15.3 mg DW L^-1) was observed when a 8 h blue: 4 h green mixed wavelength and a low N/P ratio were used. For both N/P ratios, biomass productivity was favored when using the blue light dominated at longer time periods. Mechanisms for nitrogen removal by assimilation depend on the N/P ratio, achieving assimilation between 49 and 65% at a low N/P ratio. High nitrogen removal (>50%) showed a strong relation with alkalinity culture conditions (pH > 8.5). The mixing of wavelength photoperiods seems to be a promising strategy to achieve high biomass productivity and nutrient removal. However, for optimal conditions, N/P ratios in the wastewater should be considered.

Role of Microalgae in the Recovery of Nutrients from Pig Manure

Animal production inevitably causes the emission of greenhouse gases and the generation of large amounts of slurry, both representing a serious environmental problem. Photosynthetic microorganisms such as microalgae and cyanobacteria have been proposed as alternative strategies to bioremediate agricultural waste while consuming carbon dioxide and producing valuable biomass. The current study assessed the potential of the microalga Scenedesmus sp. to remove nutrients from piggery wastewater (PWW) and the influence of the microalga on the microbial consortia. Maximum N-NH4+ consumption was 55.3 ± 3.7 mg·L−1·day−1 while P-PO43− removal rates were in the range 0.1–1.9 mg·L−1·day−1. N-NH4+ removal was partially caused by the action of nitrifying bacteria, which led to the production of N-NO3−. N-NO3− production values where lower when microalgae were more active. This work demonstrated that the photosynthetic activity of microalgae allows us to increase nutrient removal rates from PWW and to reduce the coliform bacterial load of the effluent, minimising both their environmental impact and health risks. Microalgae assimilated part of the N-NH4+ present in the media to produce biomass and did not to convert it into N-NO3− as in traditional processes.

Integrating micro-algae into wastewater treatment: A review

Improving the ecological status of water sources is a growing focus for many developed and developing nations, in particular with reducing nitrogen and phosphorus in wastewater effluent. In recent years, mixotrophic micro-algae have received increased interest in implementing them as part of wastewater treatment. This is based on their ability to utilise organic and inorganic carbon, as well as inorganic nitrogen (N) and phosphorous (P) in wastewater for their growth, with the desired results of a reduction in the concentration of these substances in the water. The aim of this review is to provide a critical account of micro-algae as an important step in wastewater treatment for enhancing the reduction of N, P and the chemical oxygen demand (COD) in wastewater, whilst utilising a fraction of the energy demand of conventional biological treatment systems. Here, we begin with an overview of the various steps in the treatment process, followed by a review of the cellular and metabolic mechanisms that micro-algae use to reduce N, P and COD of wastewater with identification of when the process may potentially be most effective. We also describe the various abiotic and biotic factors influencing micro-algae wastewater treatment, together with a review of bioreactor configuration and design. Furthermore, a detailed overview is provided of the current state-of-the-art in the use of micro-algae in wastewater treatment.

Removal of Nitrogen and Phosphorus from Thickening Effluent of an Urban Wastewater Treatment Plant by an Isolated Green Microalga

Microalgae are photosynthetic microorganisms and are considered excellent candidates for a wide range of biotechnological applications, including the removal of nutrients from urban wastewaters, which they can recover and convert into biomass. Microalgae-based systems can be integrated into conventional urban wastewater treatment plants (WW-TP) to improve the water depuration process. However, microalgal strain selection represents a crucial step for effective phytoremediation. In this work, a microalga isolated from the effluent derived from the thickening stage of waste sludge of an urban WW-TP was selected and tested to highlight its potential for nutrient removal. Ammonium and phosphate abatements by microalgae were evaluated using both the effluent and a synthetic medium in a comparative approach. Parallelly, the isolate was characterized in terms of growth capability, morphology, photosynthetic pigment content and photosystem II maximum quantum yield. The isolated microalga showed surprisingly high biomass yield and removal efficiency of both ammonium and phosphate ions from the effluent but not from the synthetic medium. This suggests its clear preference to grow in the effluent, linked to the overall characteristics of this matrix. Moreover, biomass from microalgae cultivated in wastewater was enriched in photosynthetic pigments, polyphosphates, proteins and starch, but not lipids, suggesting its possible use as a biofertilizer.

Modeling of photosynthesis and respiration rate for microalgae-bacteria consortia

In this article, the influence of culture conditions (irradiance, temperature, pH, and dissolved oxygen) on the photosynthesis and the respiration rates of microalgae-bacteria consortia in wastewater treatment was analyzed. Specifically, some short photo-respirometric experiments, simulating outdoor raceway reactors, were performed to evaluate the response of microalgae, heterotrophic bacteria, and nitrifying bacteria to variations in environmental parameters. Results demonstrate that irradiance is the most dominant variable to determine microalgae photosynthesis rates. However, reduction in microalgae activity was not observed at higher irradiance, ruling out the existence of photoinhibition phenomena. Related to heterotrophic and nitrifying bacteria, their activities were strongly affected by the influence of temperature and pH. Moreover, the effect of dissolved oxygen concentrations on microalgae, and bacteria activities was studied, displaying a reduced photosynthetic rate at dissolved oxygen concentrations above 20 mg/L. Data have been used to develop an integrated model for each population (microalgae, heterotrophic bacteria, and nitrifying bacteria) based on considering the simultaneous influence of irradiance, temperature, pH, and dissolved oxygen. The models fit the experimental results in the range of culture conditions tested, and they were validated using data obtained by the simultaneous modifications of the variables. These individual models serve as a basis for developing a global biologic microalgae-bacteria model for wastewater treatment to improve the optimal design and management of microalgae-based processes, especially outdoors, where the cultures are subject to variable daily culture conditions.

Microalgae-derived hydrochar application on rice paddy soil: Higher rice yield but increased gaseous nitrogen loss

Hydrothermal carbonization represents a promising technique for transforming microalgae into the hydrochar with abundant phytoavailable nutrients. However, the effects of microalgae-derived hydrochars on the gaseous nitrogen (N) loss from agricultural field are still unclear. Chlorella vulgaris powder (CVP) and two Chlorella vulgaris-derived hydrochars that employ water (CVHW) or citrate acid solution (CVHCA) as the reaction medium were applied to a soil column system grown with rice. The temporal variations of nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions and ammonia (NH₃) volatilization were monitored during the whole rice-growing season. Results showed that CVHW and CVHCA addition significantly increased the grain yield (by 13.5-26.8% and 10.5-23.4%) compared with control and CVP group, while concomitantly increasing the ammonia volatilization (by 53.8% and 72.9%) as well as N₂O emissions (by 2.17- and 2.82-fold) from paddy soil compared to control. The microbial functional genes (AOA, AOB, nirk, nirS, nosZ) in soil indicated that CVHW and CVHCA treatment stimulated the nitrification and denitrification, and inhibited the N₂O oxidation in soil. Notably, CVHW was recommended in the view of improving yield and controlling NH₃ volatilization because no significant difference of the yield-scale NH₃ volatilization was detected between control and CVHW treatment. This study for the first time uncovered that Chlorella vulgaris-derived hydrochars have positive effects on rice N utilization and growth but negative effects on the atmospheric environment.

Biostimulant Potential of Scenedesmus obliquus Grown in Brewery Wastewater

Microalgae are microorganisms with the capacity to contribute to the sustainable and healthy food production, in addition to wastewater treatment. The subject of this work was to determine the potential of Scenedesmus obliquus microalga grown in brewery wastewater to act as a plant biostimulant. The germination index of watercress seeds, as well as the auxin-like activity in mung bean and cucumber, and in the cytokinin-like activity in cucumber bioassays were used to evaluate the biostimulant potential. Several biomass processes were studied, such as centrifugation, ultrasonication and enzymatic hydrolysis, as well as the final concentration of microalgal extracts to determine their influence in the biostimulant activity of the Scenedesmus biomass. The results showed an increase of 40% on the germination index when using the biomass at 0.1 g/L, without any pre-treatment. For auxin-like activity, the best results (up to 60% with respect to control) were obtained at 0.5 g/L of biomass extract, after a combination of cell disruption, enzymatic hydrolysis and centrifugation. For cytokinin-like activity, the best results (up to 187.5% with respect to control) were achieved without cell disruption, after enzymatic hydrolysis and centrifugation at a biomass extract concentration of 2 g/L.

Removal of biogenic compounds from the post-fermentation effluent in a culture of Chlorella vulgaris

Wastewater rich in organic carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus may serve as a convenient source of carbon and nutrients for a year-long microalgae production. Scientific reports indicate that some single-cell microalgae such as Chlorella and Scenedesmus, are highly tolerant to wastewater environments and efficiently remove biogenic compounds. The aim of this study was to determine the possibility of using the effluent produced in the process of anaerobic degradation of whey as a culture medium for the multiplication of Chlorella vulgaris algae biomass and to characterise their growth efficiency and rate. The content of nitrogen and phosphorus in wastewater was sufficient for conducting an effective culture of algae. The efficiency of nitrogen removal in the flow system was 15.61 ± 1.38 mg N/dm³/day.

Enhanced polyunsaturated fatty acid production using food wastes and biofuels byproducts by an evolved strain of Phaeodactylum tricornutum

This study investigates the prospective of utilizing kitchen wastewater and food wastes, biofuels industry byproducts as alternative water and carbon sources. Kitchen wastewater did not impede cellular growth rate of the evolved Phaeodactylum strain E70, which indicates its potential as an alternative to freshwater resources. Among the organic wastes assessed, food waste hydrolysate significantly increased cell growth. Supplement of crude glycerol in cultivation medium enhances the total fatty acid content. Mixed food waste hydrolysate and crude glycerol remarkably increased both the cell density and total fatty acid content. Also, the supplement of butylated hydroxytoluene alleviated the oxidative stress induced by impurities in organic wastes and concomitantly increased microalgal total fatty acids and polyunsaturated fatty acids content. The experimental results reported in this study show that a waste-based biorefinery could lead to utilization of organic waste resources for the efficient production of value-added products.

Algal Remediation of Wastewater Produced from Hydrothermally Treated Septage

Hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) is a promising technology to convert wet wastes like septic tank wastes, or septage, to valuable platform chemical, fuels, and materials. However, the byproduct of HTC, process liquid, often contains large amount of nitrogen species (up to 2 g/L of nitrogen), phosphorus, and a variety of organic carbon containing compounds. Therefore, the HTC process liquid is not often treated at wastewater treatment plant. In this study, HTC process liquid was treated with algae as an alternative to commercial wastewater treatment. The HTC process liquid was first diluted and then used to grow Chlorella sp. over a short period of time (15 days). It was found that the algae biomass concentration increased by 644 mg/L over the course of 10 days, and which subsequently removed a majority of the nutrients in the HTC process liquid. Around 600 mg/L of algal biomass was collected in the process liquid at the end of treatment (day 15). Meanwhile, chemical oxygen demand (COD), total phosphorous, total Kheldjal nitrogen, and ammonia were reduced by 70.0, 77.7, 82.2, and 99.0% by fifteen days compared to the untreated wastewater, respectively. This study demonstrates that HTC process liquid can be treated by growing algae creating a potential replacement for expensive synthetic nutrient feeds for algal production.

Algal Biofuels: Current Status and Key Challenges

The current fossil fuel reserves are not sufficient to meet the increasing demand and very soon will become exhausted. Pollution, global warming, and inflated oil prices have led the quest for renewable energy sources. Algal biofuels represent a potential source of renewable energy. Algae, as the third generation feedstock, are suitable for biodiesel and bioethanol production due to their quick growth, excellent biomass yield, and high lipid and carbohydrate contents. With their huge potential, algae are expected to surpass the first and second generation feedstocks. Only a few thousand algal species have been investigated as possible biofuel sources, and none of them was ideal. This review summarizes the current status of algal biofuels, important steps of algal biofuel production, and the major commercial production challenges.

The effect of primary treatment of wastewater in high rate algal pond systems: Biomass and bioenergy recovery

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of primary treatment on the performance of two pilot-scale high rate algal ponds (HRAPs) treating urban wastewater, considering their treatment efficiency, biomass productivity, characteristics and biogas production potential. Results indicated that the primary treatment did not significantly affect the wastewater treatment efficiency (NH₄⁺-N removal of 93 and 91% and COD removal of 62 and 65% in HRAP with and without primary treatment, respectively). The HRAP without primary treatment had higher biodiversity and productivity (20 vs. 15 g VSS/m²d). Biomass from both systems presented good settling capacity. Results of biochemical methane potential test showed that co-digesting microalgae and primary sludge led to higher methane yields (238-258 mL CH₄/g VS) compared with microalgae mono-digestion (189-225 mL CH₄/g VS). Overall, HRAPs with and without primary treatment seem to be appropriate alternatives for combining wastewater treatment and bioenergy recovery.

Technology validation of photosynthetic biogas upgrading in a semi-industrial scale algal-bacterial photobioreactor

The performance of photosynthetic biogas upgrading coupled to wastewater treatment was evaluated in an outdoors high rate algal pond (HRAP) interconnected to an absorption column at semi-industrial scale. The influence of biogas flowrate (274, 370 and 459 L h^-1), liquid to biogas ratio (L/G = 1.2, 2.1 and 3.5), type of wastewater (domestic versus centrate) and hydraulic retention time in the HRAP (HRT) on the quality of the biomethane produced was assessed. The highest CO₂ and H₂S removal efficiencies (REs) were recorded at the largest L/G due to the higher biogas-liquid mass transfer at increasing liquid flowrates. No significant influence of the biogas flowrate on process performance was observed, while the type of wastewater was identified as a key operational parameter. CO₂ and H₂S-REs of 99% and 100% at a L/G_max = 3.5 were recorded using centrate. The maximum CH₄ content in the biomethane (90%) was limited by N₂ and O₂ desorption.

Effect of light/dark cycle on nitrate and phosphate removal from synthetic wastewater based on BG11 medium by Scenedesmus sp

In this study, microalgae growth in the synthetic wastewater and their ability to remove nutrients under different light levels was investigated. For this purpose, a comparative study was conducted on freshwater microalgae Scenedesmus sp. to evaluate their performance to remove nitrate and phosphate from both slaughterhouse and dairy synthetic treated wastewaters, under different light/dark cycles (12/12, 16/8 and 24/0 h), in Erlenmeyer flasks. The best light/dark cycles in Erlenmeyer flasks for nitrate and phosphate removal and growth were obtained at 24/0 h. Moreover, nitrate and phosphate removal under light conditions at 24/0 h light/dark cycles were tested in a designed open raceway pond. The maximum nitrate removal in slaughterhouse and dairy synthetic wastewater was 78% and 99.7%, and the phosphate removal was 31% and 68%, respectively. Furthermore, the highest biomass productivity in dairy and slaughterhouse synthetic wastewater during 9 days was 0.65 g L^-1 and 1.5 g L^-1, respectively. Thus, Scenedesmus sp. could be potential candidates by showing their intrinsic merit, for the reduction of nitrate and phosphate residue levels from dairy and slaughterhouse synthetic wastewaters in open raceway ponds.

A systematic comparison of the potential of microalgae-bacteria and purple phototrophic bacteria consortia for the treatment of piggery wastewater

This study evaluated the performance of two open-photobioreactors operated with microalgae-bacteria (PBR-AB) and purple photosynthetic bacteria (PBR-PPB) consortia during the treatment of diluted (5%) piggery wastewater (PWW) at multiple hydraulic retention times (HRT). At a HRT of 10.6 days, PBR-AB provided the highest removal efficiencies of nitrogen, phosphorus and zinc (87 ± 2, 91 ± 3 and 98 ± 1%), while the highest organic carbon removals were achieved in PBR-PPB (87 ± 4%). The decrease in HRT from 10.6, to 7.6 and 4.1 day caused a gradual deterioration in organic carbon and nitrogen removal, but did not influence the removal of phosphorus and Zn in both photobioreactors. The decrease in HRT caused a severe wash-out of microalgae in PBR-AB and played a key role in the structure of bacterial population in both photobioreactors. In addition, batch biodegradation tests at multiple PWW dilutions (5, 10 and 15%) confirmed the slightly better performance of algal-bacterial systems regardless of PWW dilution.

Symbiotic Co-Culture of Scenedesmus sp. and Azospirillum brasilense on N-Deficient Media with Biomass Production for Biofuels

The treatment of nitrogen-deficient agriculture wastewater, arising from the vegetable and fruit processing, is a significant problem that limits the efficiency of its biological treatment. This study evaluates the effectiveness of the symbiotic co-culture of Azospirillum brasilense and Scenedesmus sp., under two nitrogen levels (8.23 mg L−1 and 41.17 mg L−1) and mixing systems (aeration and magnetic stirring), aiming to simultaneously use the N-deficient media for their growth while producing biomass for biofuels. Microalgae growth and biomass composition, in terms of protein, carbohydrate and fatty acid contents, were evaluated at the end of the exponential growth phase (15 days after inoculation). Results show that the symbiotic co-culture of microalgae-bacteria can be effectively performed on nitrogen-deficient media and has the potential to enhance microalgae colony size and the fatty acid content of biomass for biofuels. The highest biomass concentration (103 ± 2 mg·L−1) was obtained under aeration, with low nitrogen concentration, in the presence of A. brasilense. In particular, aeration contributed to, on average, a higher fatty acid content (48 ± 7% dry weight (DW)) and higher colony size (164 ± 21 µm2) than mechanical stirring (with 39 ± 2% DW and 134 ± 21 µm2, respectively) because aeration contribute to better mass transfer of gases in the culture. Also, co-culturing contributed in average, to higher colony size (155 ± 21 µm2) than without A. brasilense (143 ± 21 µm2). Moreover, using nitrogen deficient wastewater as the culture media can contribute to decrease nitrogen and energy inputs. Additionally, A. brasilense is approved and already extensively used in agriculture and wastewater treatment, without known environmental or health issues, simplifying the biomass processing for the desired application.

Quantitative Evaluation of an Integrated System for Valorization of Wastewater Algae as Bio-oil, Fuel Gas, and Fertilizer Products

Algal systems have emerged as a promising strategy for simultaneous treatment and valorization of wastewater. However, further advancement and real-world implementation are hindered by the limited knowledge on the full energetic and nutrient product potentials of such systems and the corresponding value of these products. In this work, an aqueous-based system for the conversion of wastewater-derived algae and upgrading of crude products was designed and demonstrated. Bio-oil, fuel gas, and fertilizer products were generated from algal biomass harvested from a municipal wastewater treatment facility. Experiments showed that 68% of chemical energy contained in the algal biomass could be recovered with 44% in upgraded bio-oil and 23% in fuel gas (calculated as higher heating values), and 44% and 91% of nitrogen and phosphorus element contents in the original feedstock could be recovered as fertilizer products (ammonium sulfate and struvite), respectively. For 1,000 kg of such dry algal biomass, these products had an estimated total value of $427 (in 2014 U.S. dollars). For the first time, experiment-based energy and nutrient recovery potentials of wastewater-derived algae were presented in an integrated manner. Findings also revealed critical research needs and suggested strategies to further improve resource recovery and waste valorization in these systems.

Nutrient recovery from wastewaters by microalgae and its potential application as bio-char

The intensive agricultural practices are increasing the demand for chemical fertilizers, being currently produced from a non-environmental friendly way. Besides the environmental impacts, the nutrient uptake efficiency by the crops is very low, representing huge losses into the fields. Therefore, it is crucial to study alternatives for the current chemical fertilizers, which simultaneous improve nutrient efficiency and minimize environmental impacts. A sustainable solution is to recover nutrients from wastewater streams with microalgal cultures and the biomass conversion into bio-char for soil amendment. Wastewaters are loaded with nitrogen and phosphorus and can be used as culture medium for microalgae. Thus, nutrients can be recycled, reducing the requirement of chemical fertilizers. This paper aims to review nutrient recovery from wastewater using microalgae and the biomass conversion into bio-char. This process promotes nutrient recycling and the bio-char (when added to soil) improves the nutrient uptake efficiency by crops.

Evaluation of revolving algae biofilm reactors for nutrients and metals removal from sludge thickening supernatant in a municipal wastewater treatment facility

This work is to evaluate pilot-scale Revolving Algal Biofilm (RAB) reactors of two heights (0.9-m and 1.8-m tall) to treat supernatant from sludge sedimentation at Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago (MWRD) for removing nutrients (N and P) as well as various metals. The RAB reactors demonstrated a superior performance in N and P removal as compared to control raceway ponds. Taller 1.8-m RAB reactors performed better than 0.9-m RAB reactors in terms of total nutrient removal and algal biomass productivity. At 7-day HRT, total P (TP) and Total Kjeldahl N (TKN) removal efficiency reached to 80% and 87%, respectively, while ortho-P and ammonia removal efficiency reached to 100%. Decreasing HRT led to an enhanced TP and TKN removal rate and nutrient removal capacity. At HRT of 1.3-day, the TP removal per footprint of 1.8-m tall RAB reactors was around 7-times higher than the open pond system. The RAB reactors also showed certain capabilities of removing metals from wastewater. The study demonstrated that RAB-based treatment process is an effective method to recover nutrients from municipal wastewater.

Analysis of a photobioreactor scaling up for tertiary wastewater treatment: denitrification, phosphorus removal, and microalgae production

The present work studies the removal of nutrients (nitrate and phosphate) from a synthetic wastewater simulating a secondary treatment effluent using the microalgae Chlorella vulgaris in autotrophic photobioreactors, together with an analysis of the critical points affecting the scaling-up process from laboratory to pilot scale. Laboratory experiments were done in open agitated 1-L photobioreactors under batch operation mode, while pilot-scale experiments were done using a 150-L closed tubular photobioreactor under continuous operation mode. In both scales, nitrate was the limiting substrate and the effect of its concentration on microalgae performance was studied. From laboratory experiments, an average microalgae productivity of 85 mg_VSS L^-1 day^-1 and approximate maximum N-NO₃^- and P-PO₄^3- removal rates of 8 mg N g_VSS^-1 day^-1, and 2.6 mg P g_VSS^-1 day^-1 were found. Regarding pilot scale, the average microalgae productivity slightly decreased (76 mg_VSS L^-1 day^-1) while the approximate maximum N-NO₃^- and P-PO₄^3- removal rates slightly were increased (11.7 mg N g_VSS^-1 day^-1 and 3.04 mg P g_VSS^-1 day^-1) with respect to the laboratory-scale results. The pilot-scale operation worked under lower levels of turbulence and higher dissolved oxygen concentration and light intensity than laboratory experiments; those parameters were difficult to control and they can be identified as the critical points in the differences found on both nutrient removal and microalgae production.

RETRACTED: Effects of nutrient ratios and carbon dioxide bio-sequestration on biomass growth of Chlorella sp. in bubble column photobioreactor

This article has been retracted: please see Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/withdrawalpolicy). This article has been retracted at the request of the Editors-in-Chief. The article is a duplicate of a paper that has already been published in [Bioresource Technology, volume 208 (2016) 1 - 6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2016.02.043]. Redundant publications overweigh the relative importance of published findings and distort the academic record of the authors. One of the conditions of submission of a paper for publication is therefore that authors declare explicitly that the paper has not been previously published and is not under consideration for publication elsewhere. As such this article represents a misuse of the scientific publishing system. The scientific community takes a very strong view on this matter and apologies are offered to readers of the journal that this was not detected during the submission process.

Enhanced nitrogen removal and energy saving in a microalgal-bacterial consortium treating real municipal wastewater

The optimization of total nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater was investigated in a laboratory-scale photo-sequencing batch reactor (PSBR) operated with a mixed microalgal-bacterial consortium spontaneously acclimatized to real wastewater. No external aeration was provided in the PSBR to reduce energy consumption: oxygen was only supplied by the microalgal photosynthesis. The enhancement of total nitrogen removal was achieved through: (1) feeding of wastewater in the dark phase to provide readily biodegradable COD when oxygen was not produced, promoting denitrification; (2) intermittent use of the mixer to favor simultaneous nitrification-denitrification inside the dense flocs and to achieve 41% energy saving with respect to continuous mixing. Efficient COD removal (86 ± 2%) was observed, obtaining average effluent concentrations of 37 mg/L and 22 mg/L of total COD and soluble COD, respectively. TKN removal was 97 ± 3%, with an average effluent concentration of 0.5 ± 0.7 mg NH₄ ⁺-N/L. Assimilation of nitrogen by heterotrophic bacteria accounted only for 20% of TKN removal, whilst the major part of TKN was nitrified. In particular, the nitrification rate was 1.9 mgN L^-1 h^-1 (specific rate 2.4 mgN gTSS^-1 h^-1), measured with dissolved oxygen near zero, when the oxygen demand was higher than the oxygen produced by photosynthesis. Total nitrogen of 6.3 ± 4.4 mgN/L was measured in the effluent after PSBR optimization.

Pilot-scale outdoor production of Scenedesmus sp. in raceways using flue gases and centrate from anaerobic digestion as the sole culture medium

This work investigated the production of Scenedesmus sp. in semi-continuous mode in three pilot-scale outdoor raceways (7.2 m²) using flue gas for CO₂ supply and centrate from the anaerobic digestion of urban wastewater as the sole nutrient source. Experiments were performed at different culture depths, 5, 10 and 15 cm, while evaluating two centrate concentrations (30% and 45%) at dilution rates of 0.2 and 0.3 d^-1. Under optimal conditions of 30% centrate, 0.3 d^-1 dilution rate and a 15 cm culture depth, a maximum biomass productivity of 22.9 g m^-2 d^-1 was obtained. The optical properties of the cultures were studied and the results showed a photosynthetic efficiency of up to 2.0% and a quantum yield of 0.3 g biomass E^-1. Nitrogen and phosphorus removal rates of 3 g N m^-2 d^-1 and 0.6 g P m^-2 d^-1 were recorded, respectively. Lipid productivity of 2.3 g m^-2 d^-1 was determined possessing a suitable fatty acids profile for biofuel production.