Substituent position effect of Co porphyrin on oxygen electrocatalysis

Modulating the Oxygen Evolution Reaction Activity of Bimetallic 2D Polymers by Substituent Effects

An understanding of the structure-activity relationship is crucial for the design and synthesis of high-performance oxygen evolution reaction (OER) catalysts. In this study, the substituent effect of Co─Ni two-dimensional polymer (2DP) on OER is investigated. A series of monolayer bimetallic Co─Ni─MF─R─2DP (─R = ─H, ─CF3, ─COOCH3, ─OCH3, ─N(CH3)2) catalysts with accurately defined structures and different electron-donating or electron-withdrawing substituents is selected as the research object. This selection provides an ideal model platform to isolate their intrinsic activity from factors affecting apparent activity, such as electrical conductivity and loading property. It allows for an accurate exploration of the substituent effect on OER in bimetallic materials. The results indicate that the OER activity follows the order CoTAPP─Ni─MF─N(CH3)2─2DP > CoTAPP─Ni─MF─OCH3─2DP > CoTAPP─Ni─MF─H─2DP > CoTAPP─Ni─MF─COOCH3─2DP > CoTAPP─Ni─MF─CF3─2DP, which suggests that the catalyst activity is positively correlated with the electron-donating property of the substituents. This work provides an insight into the design of high-performance OER catalysts by the substituent effect.

Selective two-electron and four-electron oxygen reduction reactions using Co-based electrocatalysts

The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) can take place via both four-electron (4e-) and two-electron (2e-) pathways. The 4e- ORR, which produces water (H2O) as the only product, is the key reaction at the cathode of fuel cells and metal-air batteries. On the other hand, the 2e- ORR can be used to electrocatalytically synthesize hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). For the practical applications of the ORR, it is very important to precisely control the selectivity. Understanding structural effects on the ORR provides the basis to control the selectivity. Co-based electrocatalysts have been extensively studied for the ORR due to their high activity, low cost, and relative ease of synthesis. More importantly, by appropriately designing their structures, Co-based electrocatalysts can become highly selective for either the 2e- or the 4e- ORR. Therefore, Co-based electrocatalysts are ideal models for studying fundamental structure-selectivity relationships of the ORR. This review starts by introducing the reaction mechanism and selectivity evaluation of the ORR. Next, Co-based electrocatalysts, especially Co porphyrins, used for the ORR with both 2e- and 4e- selectivity are summarized and discussed, which leads to the conclusion of several key structural factors for ORR selectivity regulation. On the basis of this understanding, future works on the use of Co-based electrocatalysts for the ORR are suggested. This review is valuable for the rational design of molecular catalysts and material catalysts with high selectivity for 4e- and 2e- ORRs. The structural regulation of Co-based electrocatalysts also provides insights into the design and development of ORR electrocatalysts based on other metal elements.

Electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction with a Cu porphyrin bearing meso-CF3 substituents

Cu tetrakis(trifluoromethyl)porphyrin (1) was synthesized and examined as an electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). We showed that 1 is highly efficient for the electrocatalytic HER in acetonitrile with trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) and outperforms Cu tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin (2) by decreasing the onset overpotential by 220 mV. The icat/ip value (icat is the catalytic peak current and ip is the non-catalytic peak current) with 1 is 97, while it is 53 with 2. These results suggest that for Cu porphyrins, meso-CF3 substituents are much more effective than meso-C6F5 substituents to enhance the HER.

Edge-substituents and center metal optimization boosting oxygen electrocatalysis in porphyrin-based covalent organic polymers

The promising non-noble electrocatalyst with well-defined structure is significant for both oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) for the renewable energy devices like zinc-air batteries (ZABs). Herein, the four phenyl-linked cobaltporphyrin-based covalent organic polymers (COPs-1-4) with the different edge substituents (1 = -tBu, 2 = -Me, 3 = -F, and 4 = -CF3) are firstly designed and synthesized via a simple, efficient one-pot method. With the increase of electron donating capacity of the substituents, the highest occupied molecular orbital energy (EHOMO) gradually increases in the order of COP-4 < COP-3 < COP-2 < COP-1. Consequently, the optimal COP-1 with -tBu edge groups exhibits the highest half-wave potential (E1/2) of 0.84 V (vs. RHE) among the four COPs, which is comparable with commercial Pt/C in alkaline media. The DFT calculations further reveal that with strong electron donating capacity, the Gibbs free energy decreases in the order of COP-4 > COP-3 > COP-2 > COP-1 by modulating the adsorption energy of OOH* at rate-determining step (RDS) to promote ORR activity. Furthermore, introducing Ni (II) and Co (II) into porphyrin centers afford the bimetallic CoNi-COP-1 with both Co-N4, Ni-N4 active sites and edge substituted -tBu. The synergistic effect of Co, Ni bimetallic active sites and strong electron-donating -tBu substituents renders the CoNi-COP-1 the highest HOMO and smallest energy gap between the ELUMO and EF among the as-prepared five COPs, which leads to more filling electrons of its LUMO level, and thus exhibits the excellent ORR and OER bifunctional catalytic activities with an E1/2 as high as 0.85 V and an overpotential (η) of 0.34 V at 10 mA cm-2 in alkaline media, superior to monometallic Co-containing COPs-1-4. In particular, the assembled ZABs with bifunctional catalyst CoNi-COP-1 possesses high power density (94.10 mW cm-2), high specific capacity (841.71 mAh gZn-1) and long durability of over 160,000 s. This work exemplifies the rational design of pyrolysis-free non-noble metal COP-based electrocatalyst through optimizing the intrinsic metal center and its secondary coordination environment.

The "Pull Effect" of a Hanging ZnII on Improving the Four-Electron Oxygen Reduction Selectivity with Co Porphyrin

Due to the challenge of cleaving O-O bonds at single Co sites, mononuclear Co complexes typically show poor selectivity for the four-electron (4e-) oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). Herein, we report on selective 4e- ORR catalyzed by a Co porphyrin with a hanged ZnII ion. Inspired by Cu/Zn-superoxide dismutase, we designed and synthesized 1-CoZn with a hanging ZnII at the second sphere of a Co porphyrin. Complex 1-CoZn is much more effective than its Zn-lacking analogues to catalyze the 4e- ORR in neutral aqueous solutions, giving an electron number of 3.91 per O2 reduction. With spectroscopic studies, the hanging ZnII was demonstrated to be able to facilitate the electron transfer from CoII to O2, through an electronic "pull effect", to give CoIII-superoxo. Theoretical studies further suggested that this "pull effect" plays crucial roles in assisting O-O bond cleavage. This work is significant to present a new strategy of hanging a ZnII to improve O2 activation and O-O bond cleavage.

Covalent Tethering of Cobalt Porphyrins on Phenolic Resins for Electrocatalytic Oxygen Reduction and Evolution Reactions

Using functionalized supporting materials for the immobilization of molecular catalysts is an appealing strategy to improve the efficiency of molecular electrocatalysis. Herein, we report the covalent tethering of cobalt porphyrins on phenolic resins (PR) for improved electrocatalytic oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER). A cobalt porphyrin bearing an alkyl bromide substituent was covalently tethered on phenolic resins, through the substitution reaction of alkyl bromides with phenolic hydroxyl groups, to afford molecule-engineered phenolic resins (Co-PR). The resulted Co-PR was efficient for electrocatalytic ORR and OER by displaying an ORR half-wave potential of E1/2=0.78 V versus RHE and an OER overpotential of 420 mV to get 10 mA/cm2 current density. We propose that the many residual phenolic hydroxyl groups on PR will surround the tethered Co porphyrin and play critical roles in facilitating proton and electron transfers. Importantly, Co-PR outperformed unmodified PR and PR loaded with Co porphyrins through simple physical adsorption (termed Co@PR). The zinc-air battery assembled using Co-PR displayed a performance comparable to that using Pt/C+Ir/C. This work is significant to present phenolic resins as a functionalized material to support molecular electrocatalysts and demonstrate the strategy to improve molecular electrocatalysis with the use of phenolic resin residues.

Hierarchically porous aggregates of Co-N-C nanoparticles for oxygen electrocatalysis

Herein, a novel assembled Co-N-C (A-Co-N-C) material was reported for the first time by pyrolyzing zeolitic imidazolate framework-67 (ZIF-67) nanoparticle aggregates caused by the introduction of surfactant polystyrene sulfonic acid (PSS). The A-Co-N-C has a large surface area of 455 m2 g-1 with micropores (101 m2 g-1) and mesopores (354 m2 g-1). The A-Co-N-C exhibits good bifunctional catalytic oxygen reduction/evolution reaction (ORR/OER) and Zn-air battery activity. This work provides a simple but efficient strategy for constructing hierarchically porous aggregates of Co-N-C nanoparticles.

Identification of a Durability Descriptor for Molecular Oxygen Reduction Reaction Catalysts

The development of durable platinum-group-metal-free oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) catalysts is a key research direction for enabling the wide use of fuel cells. Here, we use a combination of experimental measurements and density functional theory calculations to study the activity and durability of seven iron-based metallophthalocyanine (MPc) ORR catalysts that differ only in the identity of the substituent groups on the MPcs. While the MPcs show similar ORR activity, their durabilities as measured by the current decay half-life differ greatly. We find that the energy difference between the hydrogenated intermediate structure and the final demetalated structure (ΔEdemetalation) of the MPcs is linearly related to the degradation reaction barrier energy. Comparison to the degradation data for the previously studied metallocorrole systems suggested that ΔEdemetalation also serves as a descriptor for the corrole systems and that the high availability of protons at the active site due to the COOH group of the o-corrole decreases the durability.

Supramolecular interaction of PCBM with porphyrins in solution: Photophysical insights

This work reports the self-assembly between [6,6]-phenyl C71 butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) and 2,3,7,8,12,13,17,18-octaethyl-21H,23H porphyrin (1)(and/2,3,7,8,12,13,17,18-octaethyl-21H,23H porphyrin Zn(II) (2) in toluene. Ground state intermolecular interaction is evidenced from absorption spectrophotometric measurements. New absorption bands are observed in the visible region which may be identified due to charge transfer (CT). Several important physicochemical factors are enumerated for PCBM-1 and PCBM-2 systems. Fluorescence investigations elicit complex formation of PCBM with porphyrins (with both 1 and 2) and reveal considerable magnitude of binding constant (K) for PCBM-2 system, i.e., KPCBM-2 = 80,435 dm3⋅mol-1 compared to PCBM-1 system, i.e., KPCM-1 = 12,600 dm3·mol-1 as well as highly ratio of selectivity in binding (KPCBM-2/KPCBM-1 ∼ 6.4). Time resolved fluorescence experiments reveal that photoexcited decay from the excited singlet state of porphyrins (i.e., 1* and 2*) by PCBM is statically controlled compared to dynamic path. Magnitude of solvent reorganization energy indicates possibility of faster charge recombination in case of PCBM-2 system. Both 1H and 13C NMR measurements provide substantial support behind complexation of PCBM with porphyrins (both 1 and 2) in solution. Ab initio calculations in vacuo support the trend in K for PCBM-1 and PCBM-2 systems and establish the proper orientation of PCBM towards 1 (and/ 2) during complexation. Transient absorption measurements establish two different mode of energy transfer pathway from porphyrin to PCBM in toluene.

Porphyrin-based conjugated microporous adsorbent material for the efficient remediation of hexavalent chromium from the aquatic environment

The encapsulation and eradication of anions from water have received a lot of scrutinize and are extremely important for virtuous production and environmental treatment. To prepare extremely efficient adsorbents, a highly functionalized and conjugated microporous porphyrin-based adsorbent material (Co-4MPP) was synthesized using the Alder Longo method. Co-4MPP featured a hierarchical microporous and mesoporous layered structure containing nitrogen and oxygen-based functional groups with a specific surface area of 685.209 m2/g and a pore volume of 0.495 cm3/g. Co-4MPP demonstrated a greater Cr (VI) adsorption empathy than the pristine porphyrin-based material did. The effects of various parameters such as pH, dose, time, and temperature were explored on the Cr (VI) adsorption by Co-4MPP. The pseudo-second-order model and the Cr (VI) adsorption kinetics were in agreement (R2 = 0.999). The Langmuir isotherm model matched the Cr (VI) adsorption isotherm, demonstrating the optimum Cr (VI) adsorption capacities: 291.09, 307.42, and 339.17 mg/g at 298K, 312K, and 320K, correspondingly, with remediation effectiveness of 96.88%. The model evaluation further revealed that Cr (VI) adsorption mechanism on Co-4MPP was endothermic, spontaneous, and entropy-rising. The detailed discussion of the adsorption mechanism suggested that it could be a reduction, chelation, and electrostatic interaction, in which the protonated nitrogen and oxygen-containing functional groups on the porphyrin ring interacted with Cr (VI) anions to form a stable complex, thus remediating Cr (VI) anions efficiently. Moreover, Co-4MPP demonstrated strong reusability, maintaining 70% of its Cr (VI) elimination rate after four consecutive adsorptions.

Electrocatalytic oxygen reduction with cobalt corroles bearing cationic substituents

Recent decades have seen increasing interest in developing highly active and selective electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). The active site environment of cytochrome c oxidases (CcOs), including electrostatic and hydrogen-bonding interactions, plays an important role in promoting the selective conversion of dioxygen to water. Herein, we report the synthesis of three Co^III corroles, namely 1 (with a 10-phenyl ortho-trimethylammonium cationic group), 2 (with a 10-phenyl ortho-dimethylamine group) and 3 (with a 10-phenyl para-trimethylammonium cationic group) as well as their electrocatalytic ORR activities in both acidic and neutral solutions. We discovered that 1 is much more active and selective than 2 and 3 for the electrocatalytic four-electron ORR. Importantly, 1 showed ORR activities with half-wave potentials at E_1/2 = 0.75 V versus RHE in 0.5 M H₂SO₄ solutions and at E_1/2 = 0.70 V versus RHE in neutral 0.1 M phosphate buffer solutions. This work is significant for outlining a strategy to increase both the activity and selectivity of metal corroles for the electrocatalytic ORR by introducing cationic units.

The pH Influence on the Water-Splitting Electrocatalytic Activity of Graphite Electrodes Modified with Symmetrically Substituted Metalloporphyrins

Hydrogen, considered to be an alternative fuel to traditional fossil fuels, can be generated by splitting water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen via the use of electrical energy, in a process whose efficiency depends directly on the employed catalytic material. The current study takes part in the relentless search for suitable and low-cost catalysts relevant to the water-splitting field by investigating the electrocatalytic properties of the O₂ and H₂ evolution reactions (OER and HER) of two metalloporphyrins: Zn(II) 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(4-pyridyl)-porphyrin and Co(II) 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(3-hydroxyphenyl)-porphyrin. The TEM/STEM characterisation of the porphyrin samples obtained using different organic solvents revealed several types of self-assembled aggregates. The HER and OER experiments performed on porphyrin-modified graphite electrodes in media with different pH values revealed the most electrocatalytically active specimens. For the OER, this specimen was the electrode manufactured with one layer of Co-porphyrin applied from dimethylsulfoxide, exhibiting an overpotential of 0.51 V at i = 10 mA/cm² and a Tafel slope of 0.27 V/dec. For the HER, it was the sample obtained by drop casting one layer of Zn-porphyrin from N,N-dimethylformamide that displayed a HER overpotential of 0.52 V at i = -10 mA/cm² and a Tafel slope of 0.15 V/dec.

Porphyrindiene-Based Tandem Diels-Alder Reaction for Preparing Low-Symmetry π-Extended Porphyrins with Push-Pull Skeletons

Tandem Diels-Alder reactions of masked porphyrindienes (i.e., sulfolenoporphyrins) with benzoquinones and stilbenes, followed by aromatization, have been developed to load porphyrin with mixed annulation units (i.e., terphenyl and naphthoquinone), furnishing the low-symmetry π-extended porphyrins (DxAy) with push-pull skeletons. All low-symmetrical chromophores display panchromatic absorption spectra, which look like a spectral combination of symmetrical congeners (D4/A4) in a certain ratio. Among them, tD2A2 with trans-arrangement of push/pull units possesses the largest maximum centered at 766 nm with the onset around 900 nm. The fusion of the electron-deficient naphthoquinone moiety on the porphyrin core results in the approximately quantitative regulation of the E_ox1 and HOMOs (i.e., 0.10-0.13 V increase for the E_ox1 and 0.14-0.16 eV decrease for the HOMOs per naphthoquinone unit). In brief, this work provides a new way to construct low-symmetry π-extended porphyrins with tunable properties resorting to the ratios and locations of the annulated push-pull units.

Recent Advances in Porphyrin-Based Systems for Electrochemical Oxygen Evolution Reaction

Oxygen evolution reaction (OER) plays a pivotal role in the development of renewable energy methods, such as water-splitting devices and the use of Zn–air batteries. First-row transition metal complexes are promising catalyst candidates due to their excellent electrocatalytic performance, rich abundance, and cheap price. Metalloporphyrins are a class of representative high-efficiency complex catalysts owing to their structural and functional characteristics. However, OER based on porphyrin systems previously have been paid little attention in comparison to the well-described oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), hydrogen evolution reaction, and CO2 reduction reaction. Recently, porphyrin-based systems, including both small molecules and porous polymers for electrochemical OER, are emerging. Accordingly, this review summarizes the recent advances of porphyrin-based systems for electrochemical OER. Firstly, the electrochemical OER for water oxidation is discussed, which shows various methodologies to achieve catalysis from homogeneous to heterogeneous processes. Subsequently, the porphyrin-based catalytic systems for bifunctional oxygen electrocatalysis including both OER and ORR are demonstrated. Finally, the future development of porphyrin-based catalytic systems for electrochemical OER is briefly prospected.

Metalloporphyrins as Catalytic Models for Studying Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution and Oxygen Reduction Reactions

The hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), oxygen evolution reaction (OER), and oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) are involved in biological and artificial energy conversions. H-H and O-O bond formation/cleavage are essential steps in these reactions. In nature, intermediates involved in the H-H and O-O bond formation/cleavage are highly reactive and short-lived, making their identification and investigation difficult. In artificial catalysis, the realization of these reactions at considerable rates and close to their thermodynamic reaction equilibria remains a challenge. Therefore, the elucidation of the reaction mechanisms and structure-function relationships is of fundamental significance to understand these reactions and to develop catalysts.This Account describes our recent investigations on catalytic HER, OER, and ORR with metalloporphyrins and derivatives. Metalloporphyrins are used in nature for light harvesting, energy conversion, electron transfer, O₂ activation, and peroxide degradation. Synthetic metal porphyrin complexes are shown to be active for these reactions. We focused on exploring metalloporphyrins to study reaction mechanisms and structure-function relationships because they have stable and tunable structures and characteristic spectroscopic properties.For HER, we identified three H-H bond formation mechanisms and established the correlation between these processes and metal hydride electronic structures. Importantly, we provided direct experimental evidence for the bimetallic homolytic H-H bond formation mechanism by using sterically bulky porphyrins. Homolytic HER has been long proposed but rarely verified because the coupling of active hydride intermediates occurs spontaneously and quickly, making their detection challenging. By blocking the bimolecular mechanism through steric effects, we stabilized and characterized the Ni^III-H intermediate and verified homolytic HER by comparing the reaction behaviors of Ni porphyrins with and without steric effects. We therefore provided an unprecedented example to control homolytic versus heterolytic HER mechanisms through tuning steric effects of molecular catalysts.For the OER, the water nucleophilic attack (WNA) on high-valent terminal Mn-oxo has been proposed for the O-O bond formation in natural and artificial water oxidation. By using Mn tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole, we identified Mn^V(O) and Mn^IV-peroxo intermediates in chemical and electrochemical OER and provided direct experimental evidence for the Mn-based WNA mechanism. Moreover, we demonstrated several catalyst design strategies to enhance the WNA rate, including the pioneering use of protective axial ligands. By studying Cu porphyrins, we proposed a bimolecular coupling mechanism between two metal-hydroxide radicals to form O-O bonds. Note that late-transition metals do not likely form terminal metal-oxo/oxyl.For the ORR, we presented several strategies to improve activity and selectivity, including providing rapid electron transfer, using electron-donating axial ligands, introducing hydrogen-bonding interactions, constructing dinuclear cooperation, and employing porphyrin-support domino catalysis. Importantly, we used Co porphyrin atropisomers to realize both two-electron and four-electron ORR, representing an unparalleled example to control ORR selectivity by tuning only steric effects without modifying molecular and/or electronic structures.Lastly, we developed several strategies to graft metalloporphyrins on various electrode materials through different covalent bonds. The molecular-engineered materials exhibit boosted electrocatalytic performance, highlighting promising applications of molecular electrocatalysis. Taken together, this Account demonstrates the benefits of exploring metalloporphyrins for the HER, OER, and ORR. The knowledge learned herein is valuable for the development of porphyrin-based catalysts and also other molecular and material catalysts for small molecule activation reactions.