Two-dimensional MOF Cu-BDC nanosheets/ILs@silica core-shell composites as mixed-mode stationary phase for high performance liquid chromatography

Recent Advances in the Construction and Applications of Monolithic and Open-tubular Capillary Electrochromatography (2022-2024)

Capillary electrochromatography (CEC) has attracted significant attention and gained considerable recognition in the field of separation science owing to its excellent separation efficiency. While numerous reviews on CEC have been published in recent years, a comprehensive and systematic summary of the typical synthesis strategies for electrochromatographic stationary phases and their state-of-the-art applications in CEC remains lacking. This review highlights recent advances (over the past 3 years) and representative applications (including chiral separation, microextraction-coupled analysis, metabolomics, enzyme analysis, and food analysis) of monolithic and open-tubular stationary phases in CEC. The advantages and limitations of each methodology are critically analyzed to present a balanced evaluation. Additionally, this work outlines future prospects regarding the development trends in electrochromatographic stationary phase preparation methods and the evolving applications of CEC.

Deep eutectic supramolecular polymers based HPLC stationary phase: Green synthesis strategy and promising application prospects

BACKGROUND

Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have been widely and significantly applied in various fields due to their outstanding features such as low cost, easy preparation and good biodegradability. As novel derivatives of DESs, deep eutectic supramolecular polymers (DESPs) combine the macroscopic state of DESs with the covalent interactions of supramolecular polymers, which also possess the properties of DESs as multifunctional materials. Therefore, DESPs are believed to be promising candidates for separation science. However, there are no studies on the application of DESPs as stationary phases for HPLC analysis.

RESULTS

In this work, a novel DESP based HPLC stationary phase (Poly(DES)@SiO2) was developed for the first time through a green synthesis method by using DES as the polymerization monomer as well as the reaction medium. The results manifest that this novel Poly(DES)@SiO2 column can well interact with analytes through various mechanisms, and realize selective separation of a wide range of structurally similar hydrophilic/hydrophobic substances. More importantly, the separation of hydrophobic analytes on the Poly(DES)@SiO2 column is less time-consuming with fewer organic eluent, although the column efficiency is slightly lower than that of commercial C18 column. Furthermore, the Poly(DES)@SiO2 column exhibits excellent mechanical stability and satisfactory separation repeatability for steroid hormones. Therefore, a reliable method was established for detecting steroid hormones in actual samples with the recoveries ranging from 94.56 % to 103.84 %, which can meet the detection needs of commonly seen steroid hormones in food and the environment.

SIGNIFICANCE

In summary, this work provides some valuable theoretical references for the synthesis of new DESP based stationary phases through a green and facile strategy, and meanwhile, verifies the feasibility of DESP for effective HPLC separations. In addition, the promising application prospect of DESP based stationary phases in the analysis of complex samples has also been demonstrated, expanding the potential application of DES in separation science.

Quasi-2D MIL-100 (Fe) synthesis via benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxylic acid self-assembly: organic dye adsorption at room temperature with dramatically enhanced kinetics

Amid increasing environmental pollution, two-dimensional materials have played pivotal roles in environmental remediation. However, two-dimensional metal-organic frameworks (2D-MOFs) have yet to be thoroughly explored. This study introduces a novel approach to synthesize 2D-MOFs, particularly focusing on MIL-100-(Fe), for the adsorption of emerging organic dyes. By harnessing the self-assembly of benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxylic acid (BTC), we formed thin solid interfaces of BTC as building blocks to control the growth of MIL-100-(Fe). This resulted in quasi-2D structures that showed over a 35% increase in adsorption capacity and a 5.5-fold increase in the adsorption kinetics of Rhodamine B removal compared to their 3D counterparts. This new method overcomes traditional synthesis limitations, offering a replicable and high-yield procedure for 2D-MOF synthesis. Compared to its three-dimensional counterpart (3D MIL-100 Fe), the prepared adsorbent exhibited remarkably higher efficacy in the adsorption of Rhodamine B, with high structural stability and recyclability. The prepared adsorbent shows over 99% adsorption within 90 minutes for initial dye concentrations of 1-40 mg L-1via the Langmuir adsorption mechanism and pseudo-second-order kinetics. Our research pioneers a method for the synthesis of quasi 2D-MIL-100-(Fe), laying the groundwork for fabricating other 2D-MOF structures, particularly those based on carboxylic acids.

Dialdehyde cellulose-based mixed-mode stationary phases for diversified high-performance liquid chromatography separations

To deal with complicated separation situations, this study successfully prepared two mixed-mode chromatography (MMC) stationary phases, CCL-SIL and PCL-SIL, by functionalizing dialdehyde cellulose (DAC) derivatives. In liquid chromatography applications, CCL-SIL exhibited superior separation performance for nucleosides and bases in HILIC mode, while PCL-SIL performed better in RPLC and IEC modes. Their distinct separation mechanisms were also elucidated by quantum chemical calculations. Both CCL-SIL and PCL-SIL showed good stability and reproducibility, with relative standard deviations of retention time, peak area, and peak height below 7.79 % and 4.37 % for multiple injections. Particularly, the PCL-SIL column and the CCL-SIL column were successfully used for the quantitative analysis of trace targets in real samples with complex matrix, demonstrating high accuracy and precision.

Novel PEI/Zein core-shell composite as mixed-mode stationary phase for high performance liquid chromatography

Based on the adhesion of polyethyleneimine (PEI), a novel PEI/zein co-modified core-shell stationary phase (PEI/Zein@SiO2) was prepared by doping zein to form a composite modification layer. The stationary phase achieved effective separation of nucleosides, bases and antibiotics in hydrophilic interaction mode on account of the hydrophilic groups of composite coating. With the hydrophobicity of zein, the flavones could be separated in reversed-phase mode. In short, the separation and analysis of hydrophilic/hydrophobic compounds were accomplished excellently by the PEI/Zein@SiO2 column with mixed double mode. The prepared chromatographic stationary phase not only avoided the dissolution of zein, but also covered the strong adsorption of some analytes caused by silica hydroxyl groups on the surface of silica spheres. The morphological structure and specific surface area of the material were reflected by various characterization techniques. Hydrophilic/hydrophobic compounds were used as tested analytes to research separation performance and retention mechanisms of PEI/Zein@SiO2 column. The stability and reproducibility of the PEI/Zein@SiO2 stationary phase were satisfied. Therefore, the modification of zein could improve the separation selectivity of stationary phase effectively for complex samples, which had the potential to be one of the significant potential application materials in stationary phase packing.

Polar alcohol guest molecules regulate the stacking modes of 2-D MOF nanosheets

The modulation of two-dimensional metal-organic framework (2-D MOF) nanosheet stacking is an effective means to improve the properties and promote the application of nanosheets in various fields. Here, we employed a series of alcohol guest molecules (MeOH, EtOH and PrOH) to modulate Zr-BTB (BTB = benzene-1,3,5-tribenzoate) nanosheets and to generate untwisted stacking. The distribution of stacking angles was statistically analyzed from high-angle annular dark-field (HAADF) and fast Fourier transform (FFT) images. The ratios of untwisted stacking were calculated, such as 77.01% untwisted stacking for MeOH, 83.45% for EtOH, and 85.61% for PrOH. The obtained untwisted Zr-BTB showed good separation abilities for different substituted benzene isomers, superior para selectivity and excellent column stability and reusability. Control experiments of 2-D Zr-TCA (TCA = 4,4',4''-tricarboxytriphenylamine) and Zr-TATB (TATB = 4,4',4''-(1,3,5-triazine-2,4,6-triyl)tribenzoic acid) nanosheets with similar pore sizes and stronger polarity regulated by the alcohol guests exhibited moderate separation performance. The electron microscopy images revealed that polar alcohol regulation dominantly generated the twisted stacking of Zr-TCA and Zr-TATB with various Moiré patterns. Polar guest molecules, such as alcohols, provide strong host-guest interactions during the regulation of MOF nanosheet stacking, providing an opportunity to design new porous Moiré materials with application prospects.

Construction of MOFs@COFs composite material as stationary phase for efficient separation of diverse organic compounds

BACKGROUND

The development of efficent chromatographic stationary phases (SP) with mixed-mode or multiple interactions in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for the separation of complex samples is a challenging task. Metal organic frameworks (MOFs)-based SP can provide desired multiple interactions and enable the separation of a diverse range of solutes, but have limitations of low column efficiency and poor stability.

RESULTS

Herein, the hybrid MOFs@Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) materials were used as SP in HPLC due to their synergistic structural features. The SiO2@NH2-UiO-66@CTF SP was synthesized by integration of NH2-UiO-66 and covalent triazine framework (CTF) onto silica surface. Due to the unique structure of SiO2@NH2-UiO-66@CTF with hierarchical-pores, this column showed higher column efficiency (up to 49,369 plates m-1 for alkylbenzenes) than the reported columns packed with MOFs-based SP. Owing to the Zr4+-N coordination bonding between CTF and NH2-UiO-66, the structural stability of SiO2@NH2-UiO-66@CTF can be improved. Furthermore, this new column exhibited remarkable column stability with relative standard deviation of retention time of <0.40% after 400 injections. With the combined advantages of multifunctional properties, high column efficiency, and good stability, SiO2@NH2-UiO-66@CTF SP showed excellent selectivity for the separation of a variety of hydrophobic, aromatic, heteroatomic, and hydrophilic analytes.

SIGNIFICANCE AND NOVELTY

This work not only offers a promising SP with multiple retention mechanisms for HPLC, but also provides an efficient strategy for development of high column efficiency MOFs-based SP with good stability. Moreover, the MOFs@COFs hybrid materials were expanded in application area through this study, and the research results can also afford the foundation for further explore its structural characteristics.

Facile synthesis of a novel polymer/covalent organic framework@silica composite material in deep eutectic solvent for mixed-mode liquid chromatographic separation

The solvothermal synthesis of covalent organic framework (COF) modified silica gel usually requires the use of harmful organic solvents, tedious steps, and harsh reaction conditions. In pursuit of green chemistry, a new strategy for the facile preparation of COF@SiO2 composite material was realized in this work by using a low-toxicity and low-cost deep eutectic solvent as the reaction medium. Additionally, a flexible polyacrylic acid (PAA) was introduced for the purpose of improving the hydrophilic selectivity and separation efficiency of COF@SiO2. Based on the above ideas, a novel PAA/COF@SiO2 composite was successfully developed as a liquid chromatographic packing material. Performance evaluation of the slurry-packed PAA/COF@SiO2 column showed that diverse types of analytes were effectively separated, and the retention behavior of polar nucleosides showed a U-shaped trend, indicating mixed-mode of hydrophobic/hydrophilic retention mechanisms. Thermodynamic studies revealed that the separation mechanism was largely independent of temperature. This work verifies the feasibility of synthesizing polymer/COF@SiO2 composite material in the deep eutectic solvent. This strategy provides a theoretical reference for the green and facile preparation of COF@SiO2 as an efficient liquid chromatographic stationary phase.

Ionic liquid/covalent organic framework/silica composite material: Green synthesis and chromatographic evaluation

BACKGROUND

Due to their large surface area and distinctive adsorption affinity, covalent organic frameworks (COFs) appear to be good candidates as liquid chromatographic separation materials with good application prospect. The development of COF materials in chromatographic science is currently in an exploratory stage. Especially, the practicability of COF@silica composite materials as liquid chromatographic stationary phases needs further exploration. Reasonably integrating a functional component such as ionic liquid (IL) into the COF@silica composite materials may provide customized functionality to achieve the purpose of synthesizing multi-functional COF based stationary phases.

RESULTS

In this study, an IL modified COF bonded silica composite material (IL-COF@SiO2) was successfully synthesized by using an environmentally friendly deep eutectic solvent as the reaction medium instead of the frequently-used organic solvent. The synthesized IL-COF@SiO2 composite material combines the excellent separation ability of COF and the excellent mass transfer function of spherical porous silica microsphere, and meanwhile, the introduction of IL endows COF@SiO2 with preferable separation performance. The slurry-packed IL-COF@SiO2 liquid chromatographic column could be applied to effectively separate hydrophobic and hydrophilic compounds with preferable separation selectivity and high column efficiency. By investigating the retention behavior and influencing factors, a mixed-mode retention mechanism was found. Multiple interaction forces endow the IL-COF@SiO2 with a hydrophilic-hydrophobic balance performance, demonstrating a good application prospect as a versatile liquid chromatographic separation material.

SIGNIFICANCE

In this study, a new strategy is proposed for greenly synthesizing a novel IL-COF@SiO2 composite material under mild conditions, which expands the potential application of COF materials in chromatographic science. One particular point to note is that the reaction medium in each step of the preparation process is low toxic and degradable deep eutectic solvent, which conforms to the concept of green chemistry.

Bipolar Molecular Torque Wrench Modulates the Stacking of Two-Dimensional Metal-Organic Framework Nanosheets

The precise modulation of nanosheet stacking modes introduces unforeseen properties and creates momentous applications but remains a challenge. Herein, we proposed a strategy using bipolar molecules as torque wrenches to control the stacking modes of 2-D Zr-1,3,5-(4-carboxylphenyl)-benzene metal-organic framework (2-D Zr-BTB MOF) nanosheets. The bipolar phenyl-alkanes, phenylmethane (P-C1) and phenyl ethane (P-C2), predominantly instigated the rotational stacking of Zr-BTB-P-C1 and Zr-BTB-P-C2, displaying a wide angular distribution. This included Zr-BTB-P-C1 orientations at 0, 12, 18, and 24° and Zr-BTB-P-C2 orientations at 0, 6, 12, 15, 24, and 30°. With reduced polarity, phenyl propane (P-C3) and phenyl pentane (P-C5) introduced steric hindrance and facilitated alkyl hydrophobic interactions with the nanosheets, primarily resulting in the modulation of eclipsed stacking for Zr-BTB-P-C3 (64.8%) and Zr-BTB-P-C5 (93.3%) nanosheets. The precise angle distributions of four Zr-BTB-P species were in agreement with theoretical calculations. The alkyl induction mechanism was confirmed by the sequential guest replacement and 2-D 13C-1H heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR). In addition, at the single-particle level, we first observed that rotational stacked pores exhibited similar desorption rates for xylene isomers, while eclipsed stacked pores showed significant discrepancy for xylenes. Moreover, the eclipsed nanosheets as stationary phases exhibited high resolution, selectivity, repeatability, and durability for isomer separation. The universality was proven by another series of bipolar acetate-alkanes. This bipolar molecular torque wrench strategy provides an opportunity to precisely control the stacking modes of porous nanosheets.

Tetraethylenepentamine-derived carbon dots and tetraethylenepentamine co-immobilized silica stationary phase for hydrophilic interaction chromatography

In this work, tetraethylenepentamine (TEPA) was used as precursor and reaction medium to prepare tetraethylenepentamine-functionalized carbon dots (TEPACDs), the resultant mixture was subsequently silanized and then grafted on the surface of bare silica. The obtained tetraethylenepentamine-functionalized carbon dots and tetraethylenepentamine co-modified silica stationary phase (Sil-TEPA/CDs) was characterized by multiple ways, such as Fourier transformed infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), elemental analysis and transmission electron microscope, which revealed the successful preparation of the mixed stationary phase and higher density of functional groups on co-modified stationary phase than precursor single-modified stationary phase. The synergistic effect of TEPACDs and TEPA was proved by comparing the separation performance of Sil-TEPA/CDs and Sil-TEPA toward amino acids, nucleosides, and nucleobases, which distinctly enhanced the selectivity of Sil-TEPA/CDs. Thus, 12 nucleosides and nucleobases and 11 amino acids was nicely separated on Sil-TEPA/CDs. By study the influences of the changes of mobile phase composition, mobile phase buffer concentration and buffer pH on the retention behaviors of Sil-TEPA and Sil-TEPA/CDs, it was found that both hydrophilic partitioning and adsorption of analytes on Sil-TEPA/CDs were enhanced benefit from the co-existence of TEPA and TEPACDs, which provided the analytes better separation performance. By comparing the column quality of Sil-TEPA/CDs with four commercially available columns, Sil-TEPA/CDs exhibited the best peak asymmetry of 0.98, and second best column efficiency of 43895 m-1 using guanosine as analyte. The RSD (n = 9) of the retention times of five selected analytes on Sil-TEPA/CDs were within 0.30-0.61% during 40 h of continuously elution, which implied excellent stability of prepared packing material.

Comparing the separation performance of poly(ethyleneimine) embedded butyric and octanoic acid based chromatographic stationary phases

Poly(ethyleneimine) (PEI) modified silica spheres were used to graft butyric acid and octanoic acid onto their surfaces, forming two stationary phases named Sil-PEI-BAD and Sil-PEI-CAD, respectively. Characterized methods including fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), elemental analysis (EA) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) were utilized to determine the successful synthesis of these two stationary phase materials. The chromatographic performance of these two stationary phases was analyzed with hydrophobic and hydrophilic compounds as analytes. Compared with Sil-PEI-CAD column, Sil-PEI-BAD column was more effective in separating hydrophilic compounds including nucleosides, alkaloids and vitamins. Hydrophobic substances including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and alkylbenzenes obtained excellent separation results on Sil-PEI-CAD column than Sil-PEI-BAD column. Additionally, according to the separation of phenols, Sil-PEI-CAD column can be used in HILIC/RPLC mixed-mode. The results showed that the properties and retention mechanisms of the prepared stationary phases depended on the length of the alkyl chains bonded on the silica surface.

Applicability of core-shell SiO2 microspheres with a high TiO2 loading as stationary phase for HPLC

BACKGROUND

Due to its high chemical stability, sufficient rigidity and zwitterionic ion exchange properties, TiO₂ can be considered as an alternative stationary phase material to SiO₂ for high performance liquid chromatography. TiO₂ stationary phase is usually prepared by coating TiO₂ onto SiO₂ support by sol-gel method. However, in the traditional coating method, in order to overcome the rapid hydrolysis rate of tetrabutyl orthotitanate, only a very low concentration of tetrabutyl orthotitanate can be used, resulting in a low loading of TiO₂ on the support.

RESULTS

TiO₂ core-shell spheres with a good monodispersity were prepared using 0.25 mol L^-1 tetrabutyl orthotitanate. The specific surface area, pore volume, pore diameter and TiO₂ loading of the TiO₂ core-shell spheres were 66 m² g^-1, 0.15 cm³ g^-1, 9.8 nm and 57%, respectively. The core-shell spheres were derivatized with n-octadecyltrichlorosilane and then packed into a stainless steel column to test the separation performance for neutral, basic and acidic samples in liquid chromatography. A baseline separation of polyaromatic hydrocarbons was achieved, showing a column efficiency for fluorene of 118075 plates m^-1. The prepared stationary phase was also used to separate acidic and basic mixtures, and column efficiencies of 54500 and 25836 plates m^-1 were obtained for N,N-dinitroaniline and p-chlorophenol, respectively. The relative standard deviations of the retention times of polyaromatic hydrocarbons for run-to-run, day-to-day and column-to-column repeatability were all below 5.1%.

SIGNIFICANCE AND NOVELTY

This work demonstrated that TiO₂ can be coated in the pores of the shell of SiO₂ core-shell spheres with high TiO₂ loading using a high concentration of tetrabutyl orthotitanate as the titania source. The experimental results show that the TiO₂ coated core-shell spheres can be a good alternative stationary phase for liquid chromatography.

Ionic Liquids Functionalized MOFs for Adsorption

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and ionic liquids (ILs) represent promising materials for adsorption separation. ILs incorporated into MOF materials (denoted as IL/MOF composites) have been developed, and IL/MOF composites combine the advantages of MOFs and ILs to achieve enhanced performance in the adsorption-based separation of fluid mixtures. The designed different ILs are introduced into the various MOFs to tailor their functional properties, which affect the optimal adsorptive separation performance. In this Perspective, the rational fabrication of IL/MOF composites is presented, and their functional properties are demonstrated. This paper provides a critical overview of an emergent class of materials termed IL/MOF composites as well as the recent advances in the applications of IL/MOF composites as adsorbents or membranes in fluid separation. Furthermore, the applications of IL/MOF in adsorptive gas separations (CO2 capture from flue gas, natural gas purification, separation of acetylene and ethylene, indoor pollutants removal) and liquid separations (separation of bioactive components, organic-contaminant removal, adsorptive desulfurization, radionuclide removal) are discussed. Finally, the existing challenges of IL/MOF are highlighted, and an appropriate design strategy direction for the effective exploration of new IL/MOF adsorptive materials is proposed.

Homochiral organic molecular cage RCC3-R-modified silica as a new multimodal and multifunctional stationary phase for high-performance liquid chromatography

In this work, homochiral reduced imine cage was covalently bonded to the surface of the silica to prepare a novel high-performance liquid chromatography stationary phase, which was applied for the multiple separation modes such as normal phase, reversed-phase, ion exchange, and hydrophilic interaction chromatography. The successful preparation of the homochiral reduced imine cage bonded silica stationary phase was confirmed by performing a series of methods including X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis, and infrared spectroscopy. From the extracted results of the chiral resolution in normal phase and reversed-phase modes, it was demonstrated that seven chiral compounds were successfully separated, among which the resolution of 1-phenylethanol reached the value of 3.97. Moreover, the multifunctional chromatographic performance of the new molecular cage stationary phase was systematically investigated in the modes of reversed-phase, ion exchange, and hydrophilic interaction chromatography for the separation and analysis of a total of 59 compounds in eight classes. This work demonstrated that the homochiral reduced imine cage not only achieved multiseparation modes and multiseparation functions performance with high stability, but also expanded the application of the organic molecular cage in the field of liquid chromatography.

Click postsynthesis of microporous organic network@silica composites for reversed-phase/hydrophilic interaction mixed-mode chromatography

Recently, the good physical and chemical properties, well-defined pore architectures, and designable topologies have made microporous organic networks (MONs) excellent potential candidates in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). However, their superior hydrophobic structures restrict their application in the reversed-phase mode. To solve this obstacle and to expand the application of MONs in HPLC, we realized the thiol-yne "click" postsynthesis of a novel hydrophilic MON-2COOH@SiO₂-MER (MER denotes mercaptosuccinic acid) microsphere for reversed-phase/hydrophilic interaction mixed-mode chromatography. SiO₂ was initially decorated with MON-2COOH using 2,5-dibromoterephthalic acid and tetrakis(4-ethynylphenyl)methane as monomers, and MER was then grafted via thiol-yne click reaction to yield MON-2COOH@SiO₂-MER microspheres (5 μm) with a pore size of ~1.3 nm. The -COOH groups in 2,5-dibromoterephthalic acid and the post-modified MER molecules considerably improved the hydrophilicity of pristine MON and enhanced the hydrophilic interactions between the stationary phase and analytes. The retention mechanisms of the MON-2COOH@SiO₂-MER packed column were fully discussed with diverse hydrophobic and hydrophilic probes. Benefiting from the numerous -COOH recognition sites and benzene rings within MON-2COOH@SiO₂-MER, the packed column exhibited good resolution for the separation of sulfonamides, deoxynucleosides, alkaloids, and endocrine-disrupting chemicals. A column efficiency of 27,556 plates per meter was obtained for the separation of gastrodin. The separation performance of the MON-2COOH@SiO₂-MER packed column was also demonstrated by comparing with those of MON-2COOH@SiO₂, commercial C18, ZIC-HILIC, and bare SiO₂ columns. This work highlights the good potential of the thiol-yne click postsynthesis strategy to construct MON-based stationary phases for mixed-mode chromatography.