A critical review of diffusive gradients in thin films technique for measuring organic pollutants: Potential limitations, application to solid phases, and combination with bioassays

A diffusive gradients in thin-films (DGT) methodology for in situ measurement of imazamox and imazapyr herbicide residues

Imidazolinones (IMIs) are a group of commonly used chiral herbicides. However, because of their persistence and mobility, IMI herbicides pose a toxicity risk to non-target aquatic organisms and sensitive crop varieties. Conventional grab sampling and the subsequent solvent extraction of IMI herbicides from environmental samples do not provide information on their bioavailability. The current study focuses on the development of an in situ passive sampling technique based on the diffusive gradients in thin-films (DGT), to measure labile imazamox (IMX) and imazapyr (IMPy) herbicide residues in soil and water systems. Eleven different materials were tested to select an efficient binding phase for the DGT. Of them, SepraZT-WAX and bioactive carbon (BAC) showed high adsorption and elution efficiency when incorporated into a polyacrylamide binding gel after extensive testing of the gel incorporation and elution procedures. The SepraZT-WAX binding gels yielded a stable elution efficiency (∼85 %) at different preloaded herbicide concentrations (0.01-5.0 μM), whereas the elution efficiency increased with increased preloaded herbicide concentration in BAC binding gels. This highlights the need to investigate a concentration-dependent elution factor when testing novel DGTs. Compared to SepraZT-WAX DGT, BAC-DGT showed a higher binding capacity and faster adsorption rate, and its performance was independent of the solution pH (4.0-9.1), electrical conductivity (1-50 mS cm-1), and bicarbonate (0-1800 mg HCO3- L-1) and sulfate (0-600 mg SO42- L-1) concentrations for both herbicides. This study demonstrates the reliability and accuracy of this DGT device for measuring IMI herbicides and other anionic contaminants frequently detected in water and soil systems.

The influence mechanism of environmental factors on DGT adsorbing sulfonamides and the migration between water and sediment

Obtaining the sulfonamides (SAs) concentrations in the water body and sediment bulk was a prerequisite to reveal their transport and partitioning behavior in sediment-water environments and accurately assess their ecological risk. In the present study, the influences of multifactor interactions on the performance of o-DGTs with XAD-18 binding gels were analyzed by central combination experiments and response surfaces analysis, in which the target compounds were 9 SAs. The results indicated that dissolved organic matter (DOM), pH, and suspended particulate matter (SS) had significant effects on the o-DGT sampling, whereas this o-DGT was independent of the ionic strength (IS). Concentning the composite influence of the four factors, the interaction between DOM and SS posed the most significant effect on all 9 SAs compounds. Subsequently, an o-DGT and DIFS model was applied to explore the SAs migration between the water-sediments interface. The difference between desorption rate (kb) and adsorption rates (kf) values suggested that the kinetics of SAs was dominated by adsorption. Moreover, the short-term sediment-water partitioning of SAs was clarified on the basis of distribution coefficient (Kdl) for the labile SAs, among which the sulfadiazine (SDZ) had the largest labile pool. The ability of sediments to release SAs to the liquid phase as a sink was determined by response time (Tc). Among the 9 SAs, the long-term release of soseulfamethoxypyridazine (SMP) from the solid phase of sediments would have a potential risk to the aquatic environment, to which more attention should be paid in the future.

Double-faced diffusive gradient in thin films sampler (df-DGT): Proposing an improved DGT sampler design for water deployments

BACKGROUND

The Diffusive Gradients in Thin Films (DGT) technique has become the most widely used passive sampling method for inorganic compounds. This widespread adoption can be partly attributed to the development of new binding phases that facilitate the sampling of numerous analytes. In contrast, to date, the DGT sampler for inorganic compounds has not seen any significant design improvements. In this manuscript, a new design for the DGT sampler is proposed. The new design, referred to as the Double-Faced DGT (df-DGT) sampler, features dual sampling windows, enabling a twofold increase in analyte mass uptake compared to the conventional DGT sampler.

RESULTS

The proposed sampler was characterized for Cd, Co, Mn, Ni, and Zn by performing the following tests: deployment curves, the effect of the diffusive boundary layer (DBL), pH, ionic strength and deployment in synthetic samplers. It was demonstrated that the df-DGT sampler can accumulate twice the mass over time compared to the conventional DGT sampler. The effects of the DBL, pH, and ionic strength on the measurements of Cd, Co, Mn, Ni, and Zn, when sampling with the df-DGT, were consistent with those previously reported for the conventional DGT sampler. When the df-DGT sampler and the DGT sampler were deployed simultaneously in synthetic samples with varying concentrations of Cd, Co, Mn, Ni, and Zn, no significant differences were observed (at the 95 % confidence level) in the results obtained from both samplers.

SIGNIFICANCE

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time a new DGT sampler, featuring conceptual innovations, is being proposed for sampling inorganic species in water. The proposed sampler is twice as effective in terms of mass uptake and is useful for short deployments or enhancing sensitivity. In the future, the application of this sampler could potentially be expanded to other uses, such as o-DGT.

The determination of thallium in the environment: A review of conventional and advanced techniques and applications

Thallium (Tl) is a potential toxicity element that poses significant ecological and environmental risks. Recently, a substantial amount of Tl has been released into the environment through natural and human activities, which attracts increasing attention. The determination of this hazardous and trace element is crucial for controlling its pollution. This article summarizes the advancement and progress in optimizing Tl detection techniques, including atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS), voltammetry, inductively coupled plasma (ICP)-based methods, spectrophotometry, and X-ray-based methods. Additionally, it introduces sampling and pretreatment methods such as diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT), liquid-liquid extraction, solid phase extraction, and cloud point extraction. Among these techniques, ICP-mass spectrometry (MS) is the preferred choice for Tl detection due to its high precision in determining Tl as well as its species and isotopic composition. Meanwhile, some new materials and agents are employed in detection. The application of novel work electrode materials and chromogenic agents is discussed. Emphasis is placed on reducing solvent consumption and utilizing pretreatment techniques such as ultrasound-assisted processes and functionalized magnetic particles. Most detection is performed in aqueous matrices, while X-ray-based methods applied to solid phases are summarized which provide non-destructive analysis. This work improves the understanding of Tl determination technology while serving as a valuable resource for researchers seeking appropriate analytical techniques.

Principles, applications, and limitations of diffusive gradients in thin films induced fluxed in soils and sediments

The diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique serves as a passive sampling method, inducing analyte transport and concentration. Its application is widespread in assessing labile components of metals, organic matter, and nutrients across various environmental media such as water, sediments, and saturated soils. The DGT devices effectively reduce the porewater concentration through irreversible binding of solutes, consequently promoting the release of labile species from the soil/sediment solid phase. However, the precise quantification of simultaneous adsorption and desorption of labile species using DGT devices alone remains a challenge. To address this challenge, the DGT-Induced Fluxes in Soils and Sediments (DIFS) model was developed. This model simulates analyte kinetics in solid phases, solutions, and binding resins by incorporating factors such as soil properties, resupply parameters, and kinetic principles. While the DIFS model has been iteratively improved to increase its accuracy in portraying kinetic behavior in soil/sediment, researchers' incomplete comprehension of it still results in unrealistic fitting outcomes and an oversight of the profound implications posed by kinetic parameters during implementation. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the optimization and utilization of DIFS models, encompassing fundamental concepts behind DGT devices and DIFS models, the kinetic interpretation of DIFS parameters, and instances where the model has been applied to study soils and sediments. It also highlights preexisting limitations of the DIFS model and offers suggestions for more precise modeling in real-world environments.

Development and application of diffusive gradients in thin films for in situ sampling of the organic UV filter 4-methylbenzylidene camphor (4-MBC) in waters

4-Methylbenzylidene camphor (4-MBC), a typical organic UV filter (OUVF) in personal care products, is considered to be a potential endocrine disruptor due to its estrogenic activity and bioaccumulation. Although 4-MBC residues have been extensively identified in aquatic waters, little is known about their occurrence, levels, and potential risk in coastal waters. This study developed a reliable sampling approach, based on diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) with XAD-2 as the binding agent, for monitoring 4-MBC in coastal waters. The diffusion coefficients of 4-MBC in freshwater and artificial seawater were 3.65 × 10-6 cm2/s and 3.83 × 10-6 cm2/s, respectively. XAD-2 binding gel showed rapid adsorption to 4-MBC. The accumulated masses of 4-MBC in XAD-2 DGT increased linearly with deployed time for 7 days in freshwater and seawater, which agreed well with theoretical predictions. The sampling performance was independent of ionic strength (0.0001-0.5 M), pH (4.0-8.5), and dissolved organic matter (0-20 mg/L). Field deployment in the river estuary and bathing beach showed that DGT-measured 4-MBC concentrations were consistent in comparison with grab sampling. Environmental risk assessment showed that 4-MBC may pose a medium risk to aquatic organisms based on computed risk quotient (RQ) values. Sewage discharge is the main source of 4-MBC risk, while the residue in recreation beaches contributes more significantly in summer. The established DGT sampling is suitable for seasonal monitoring, source identification, and risk assessment of 4-MBC in coastal waters.

Non-Steady-State Fickian Diffusion Models Decrease the Estimated Gel Layer Diffusion Coefficient Uncertainty for Diffusive Gradients in Thin-Films Passive Samplers

Mass transport in diffusive gradients in thin-film passive samplers is restricted to diffusion through a gel layer of agarose or agarose cross-linked polyacrylamide (APA). The gel layer diffusion coefficient, DGel, is typically determined using a standard analysis (SA) based on Fick's first law from two-compartment diffusion cell (D-Cell) tests. The SA assumes pseudo-steady-state flux, characterized by linear sink mass accumulation-time profiles with a typical threshold R2 ≥ 0.97. In 72 D-Cell tests with nitrate, 63 met this threshold, but the SA-determined DGel ranged from 10.1 to 15.8 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (agarose) and 9.5 to 14.7 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (APA). A regression model developed with the SA to account for the diffusive boundary layer had 95% confidence intervals (CIs) on DGel of 13 to 18 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (agarose) and 12 to 19 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (APA) at 500 rpm. A finite difference model (FDM) developed based on Fick's second law with non-steady-state (N-SS) flux decreased uncertainty in DGel tenfold. The FDM-captured decreasing source compartment concentrations and N-SS flux in the D-Cell tests and, at 500 rpm, the FDM-determined DGel ± 95% CIs were 14.5 ± 0.2 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (agarose) and 14.0 ± 0.3 × 10-6 cm2·s-1 (APA), respectively.

In Situ Insight into the Availability and Desorption Kinetics of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in Soils with Diffusive Gradients in Thin Films

The physicochemical exchange dynamics between the solid and solution phases of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in soils needs to be better understood. This study employed an in situ tool, diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT), to understand the distribution and exchange kinetics of five typical PFAS in four soils. Results show a nonlinear relationship between the PFAS masses in DGT and time, implying that PFAS were partially supplied by the solid phase in all of the soils. A dynamic model DGT-induced fluxes in soils/sediments (DIFS) was used to interpret the results and derive the distribution coefficients for the labile fraction (K_dl), response time (t_c), and adsorption/desorption rates (k₁ and k_-1). The larger labile pool size (indicated by K_dl) for the longer chain PFAS implies their higher potential availability. The shorter chain PFAS tend to have a larger t_c and relatively smaller k_-1, implying that the release of these PFAS in soils might be kinetically limited but not for more hydrophobic compounds, such as perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS), although soil properties might play an important role. K_dl ultimately controls the PFAS availability in soils, while the PFAS release from soils might be kinetically constrained (which may also hold for biota uptake), particularly for more hydrophilic PFAS.

Appraisal on the role of passive sampling for more integrative frameworks on the environmental risk assessment of contaminants

Over time multiple lines of research have been integrated as important components of evidence for assessing the ecological quality status of water bodies within the framework of Environmental Risk Assessment (ERA) approaches. One of the most used integrative approaches is the triad which combines, based on the weight-of-evidence, three lines of research, the chemical (to identify what is causing the effect), the ecological (to identify the effects at the ecosystem level) and the ecotoxicological (to ascertain the causes of ecological damage), with the agreement between the different lines of risk evidence increasing the confidence in the management decisions. Although the triad approach has proven greatly strategic in ERA processes, new assessment (and monitoring) integrative and effective tools are most welcome. In this regard, the present study is an appraisal on the boost that passive sampling, by allowing to increase information reliability, can give within each of the triad lines of evidence, for more integrative ERA frameworks. In parallel to this appraisal, examples of works that used passive samplers within the triad are presented providing support for the use of these devices in a complementary form to generate holistic information for ERA and ease the process of decision-making.

Application of diffusive gradients in thin films to determine rare earth elements in surface sediments of Daya Bay, China: Occurrence, distribution and ecotoxicological risks

Known as burgeoning contaminants, the bioavailability of rare earth elements (REEs) can be determined using diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT). As Daya Bay (South China) has been under serious anthropogenic influences, the present study examined the distribution of REEs in surface sediments and their possible ecological risks in the bay. The range of DGT-labile concentrations of REEs (∑REEs) was from 5.67 μg/L to 8.41 μg/L, with an average of 7.34 μg/L. Results of assessment of single REE toxicity revealed that the risk quotient (RQ) values of Y, Ce and Yb were >1, indicating that their potential negative impacts on the nearby environment. However, analysis of the integral toxicity of REE mixtures through assessment of probabilistic ecotoxicological risks showed that there was a negligibly low probability of toxicity of PRE surface sediments to aquatic organisms in the study area.

The study of polar emerging contaminants in seawater by passive sampling: A review

Emerging Contaminants (ECs) in marine waters include different classes of compounds, such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, showing "emerging concern" related to the environment and human health. Their measurement in seawater is challenging mainly due to the low concentration levels and the possible matrix interferences. Mass spectrometry combined with chromatographic techniques represents the method of choice to study seawater ECs, due to its sensitivity and versatility. Nevertheless, these instrumental techniques have to be preceded by suitable sample collection and pre-treatment: passive sampling represents a powerful approach in this regard. The present review compiles the existing occurrence studies on passive sampling coupled to mass spectrometry for the monitoring of polar ECs in seawater and discusses the availability of calibration data that enabled quantitative estimations. A vast majority of the published studies carried out during the last two decades describe the use of integrative samplers, while applications of equilibrium samplers represent approximately 10%. The polar Chemcatcher was the first applied to marine waters, while the more sensitive Polar Organic Chemical Integrative Sampler rapidly became the most widely employed passive sampler. The organic Diffusive Gradients in Thin film technology is a recently introduced and promising device, due to its more reliable sampling rates. The best passive sampler selection for the monitoring of ECs in the marine environment as well as future research and development needs in this area are further discussed. On the instrumental side, combining passive sampling with high resolution mass spectrometry to better assess polar ECs is strongly advocated, despite the current challenges associated.