Hadrontherapy techniques for breast cancer

Heart and lung sparing with isocentric lateral decubitus positioning compared with dorsal decubitus positioning during adjuvant localized breast cancer radiotherapy

OBJECTIVES

The cardiac and pulmonary dosimetric benefit of alternative positioning in isocentric lateral decubitus compared with dorsal decubitus during adjuvant breast irradiation has yet to be proven, in spite of the relative long-standing use of isocentric lateral decubitus.

METHODS

Eight consecutive patients with an indication for adjuvant breast irradiation without boost or lymph node irradiation were scanned in both isocentric lateral and dorsal decubitus positions. For each patient, a plan delivering 40.05 Gy in 15 fractions in isocentric lateral decubitus and in dorsal decubitus using a field-in-field technique was calculated. Doses to the heart, to various cardiac substructures, and to the lungs were compared.

RESULTS

Mean dose to the heart, to various cardiac structures (left ventricle, left coronary, right coronary), to the homolateral lung, and to the contralateral lung were significantly lower in isocentric lateral decubitus than in dorsal decubitus. Average absolute mean dose reductions were -40 cGy for the heart, -27.5 cGy for the left ventricle, -56.5 cGy for the right coronary artery, -64.5 cGy for the left coronary artery, -45.5 cGy for the sinoatrial node, -74 cGy for the homolateral lung, and -4.5 cGy for the contralateral lung. For all organs at risk, median dose-volume histograms in isocentric lateral decubitus showed lower relative volumes than in dorsal decubitus.

CONCLUSION

Lateral decubitus positioning significantly reduces dose to the heart, to various cardiac substructures, to the homolateral lung, and to the contralateral lung, compared with dorsal decubitus. This technique is easily implemented and can be widely recommended to reduce heart and lung doses to a minimum.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

Lateral decubitus positioning significantly reduces dose to the heart, to various cardiac substructures, to the homolateral lung, and to the contralateral lung, compared with dorsal decubitus. This technique is easily implemented and can be widely recommended to reduce heart and lung doses to a minimum.

Determinants of radiation dose to immune cells during breast radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

The immune system has been identified as an organ at risk in esophageal and lung cancers. However, the dosimetric impact of radiotherapy on immune system exposure in patients treated for breast cancer has never been studied.

METHODS

A monocentric retrospective dosimetric study included 163 patients treated at the Institut Curie (Paris, France) between 2010 and 2016 with locoregional helical tomotherapy after conservative surgery or total mastectomy. The effective dose to the immune system (EDIC) was calculated based on diverse dosimetric parameters. The clinical and volumetric determinants of EDIC in adjuvant radiotherapy of breast cancer were analyzed.

RESULTS

The median EDIC for the population was 4.23 Gy, ranging from 1.82 to 6.19 Gy. Right-sided radiotherapy and regional lymph node irradiation were associated with significantly higher EDIC in univariate (4.38 Gy vs. 3.94 Gy, p < 0.01, and 4.27 Gy vs. 3.44 Gy, p < 0.01, respectively) and multivariate analyses (p < 0.01 and p < 0.01). Liver overexposure was the main contributor to EDIC increase in right-sided breast cancer patients (+0.38 Gy [95%CI: +0.30; +0.46]), while the integral total dose increase was the main contributor to EDIC increase in cases of regional node irradiation (+0.63 Gy [95%CI: +0.42; +0.85]).

CONCLUSION

The EDIC score during adjuvant radiotherapy after breast cancer was statistically significantly higher in the case of right-sided radiotherapy and regional lymph node irradiation. Liver irradiation is the main contributor to immune system exposure in adjuvant irradiation of right-sided breast cancer. Populations in which an association between EDIC and survival would exist have yet to be identified but could potentially include patients treated for triple-negative breast cancer with a poor response to neoadjuvant chemoimmunotherapy.

Analytical parameterization of Bragg curves for proton beams in muscle, bone, and polymethylmethacrylate

Proton dose calculation in media other than water may be of interest for either research purposes or clinical practice. Current study aims to quantify the required parameters for analytical proton dosimetry in muscle, bone, and PMMA. Required analytical dosimetry parameters were extracted from ICRU-49 report and Janni study. Geant4 Toolkit was also used for Bragg curve simulation inside the investigated media at different proton energies. Calculated and simulated dosimetry data were compared using gamma analysis. Simulated and calculated Bragg curves are consistent, a fact that confirms the validity of reported parameters for analytical proton dosimetry inside considered media. Furthermore, derived analytical parameters for these media are different from those of water. Listed parameters can be reliably utilized for analytical proton dosimetry inside muscle, bone, and PMMA. Furthermore, accurate proton dosimetry inside each medium demands dedicated analytical parameters and one is not allowed to use the water coefficients for non-water media.

Radiation exposure of the glandular mammary tissue in women patients with mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma treated with protons

PURPOSE

Secondary breast cancer is a frequent late adverse event of mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma radiotherapy. Secondary breast cancers overwhelmingly correspond to ductal carcinoma and develop from the glandular mammary tissue. In addition, during childhood, radiation overexposure of the glandular tissue may lead to a late breast hypotrophy at adult age. The aim of this study was to evaluate the radiation exposure to the glandular tissue in patients treated for mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma with intensity-modulated proton therapy, in order to evaluate the potential dosimetric usefulness of its delineation for breast sparing.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixteen consecutive intermediate-risk mediastinal female patients with Hodgkin lymphoma treated with consolidation radiation with deep inspiration breath hold intensity-modulated proton therapy to the total dose of 30Gy were included. Breasts were delineated according to the European Society for Radiotherapy and Oncology guidelines for treatment optimization ("clinical organ at risk"). The glandular tissue ("glandular organ at risk") was retrospectively contoured on the initial simulation CT scans based on Hounsfield unit (HU) values, using a range between -80HU and 500HU.

RESULTS

The mean and maximum doses delivered to the glandular organ at risk were significantly lower than the mean and maximum doses delivered to the clinical organ at risk, but were statistically correlated. Glandular organ at risk volumes were significantly smaller.

CONCLUSION

Optimizing the treatment plans on the clinical breast contours will systematically lead to overestimation of the dose received to the glandular tissue and, consequently, to an indistinct and involuntary improved glandular tissue sparing. As such, our findings do not support the consideration of the glandular tissue as an additional organ at risk when planning intensity-modulated proton therapy for mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma in female patients.

Post-mastectomy reirradiation for ipsilateral T3N0M0 breast tumor relapse: a population-based study

INTRODUCTION

Post-mastectomy radiotherapy is commonly recommended for T3N0M0 breast cancer, particularly in the presence of adverse prognostic factors. However, for T3N0M0 ipsilateral recurrences following breast-conserving surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy, the situation is distinct. Recurrence alone signifies a negative prognostic factor. Moreover, tumor relapses within previously irradiated areas exhibit enhanced radioresistance, and reirradiation of the chest wall carries an escalated risk of radiation-induced toxicity. This study aimed to assess the impact of post-mastectomy reirradiation (PM-reRT) on patient outcomes in cases of ipsilateral T3N0M0 breast tumor recurrence, using data from the SEER database.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We identified all patients who underwent treatment for primary non-metastatic breast cancer with breast-conserving surgery followed by adjuvant radiotherapy in the SEER database; among them, those who later experienced a localized T3N0M0 breast tumor recurrence and underwent total mastectomy were included. The study's goal was to compare overall survival (OS) and cancer-specific survival (CSS) between patients who underwent only mastectomy versus those who had mastectomy followed by adjuvant PM-reRT for their ipsilateral T3N0M0 breast tumor relapse.

RESULTS

From 2000 to 2020, the SEER database recorded 44 patients with an ipsilateral T3N0M0 breast tumor recurrence after initial conservative treatment, managed with total mastectomy. No statistically significant differences in OS or CSS were observed between patients undergoing mastectomy (MT) alone versus those receiving MT combined with PM-reRT (p = 0.68 and p = 0.86, respectively). Five-year OS rates for the MT and MT + PM-reRT cohorts were 49.5% [95% CI: 29.9-81.8] and 41.7% [10.0-100.0], respectively, while 5‑year CSS rates were 51.6% [12.0-99.5] and 58.3% [15.2-100.0], respectively.

CONCLUSION

For patients undergoing total mastectomy after an ipsilateral T3N0M0 breast tumor recurrence, subsequent to initial breast cancer treatment involving breast-conserving surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy, chest wall reirradiation does not enhance survival outcomes. As such, it should not be routinely performed.

Effects of Combined Exposure to Carbon Ions and Protons on the Pool of MCF-7 Breast Cancer Stem Cells In Vitro

We studied the effects of single and combined action of protons and carbon ions 12C6+ on the pool of MCF-7 human breast cancer stem cells. Single irradiation with a beam of protons or carbon ions had no significant effects on the relative number of cancer stem cells (CSC). The effects of combined irradiation in a total equieffective dose of 4 Gy depended on the sequence of exposure to ionizing radiations: the relative number of CSC did not change after irradiation with carbon ions and then with protons, but increased in the case of the reverse sequence. The most favorable result, i.e. a decrease in the CSC pool, was observed in the case of sequential irradiation with carbon ions and protons and their equal contribution to total equieffective dose. In this case, the absolute number of CSC decreased by on average 2.1 times in comparison with the control (p<0.05). The revealed regularities are of interest for the further development of new methods of radiation therapy.

Dosimetric evaluation of the benefit of deep inspiration breath hold (DIBH) for locoregional irradiation of right breast cancer with volumetric modulated arctherapy (VMAT)

INTRODUCTION

Right-lateralized cardiac substructures can be substantially exposed during right breast cancer (R-BC) radiotherapy. The cardiac benefit of deep inspiration breath hold (DIBH) is established in combination with volumetric modulated arctherapy (VMAT) for left breast cancer with regional node irradiation but is unknown for R-BC. This study evaluated the dosimetric benefit of DIBH for locoregional irradiation of R-BC with VMAT.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

All patients treated for R-BC with adjuvant locoregional DIBH-VMAT in the Department of Radiation Oncology of the Institut Curie (Paris, France) until December 2022 were included, corresponding to 15 patients. FB- and DIBH-VMAT plans were compared both for a normofractionated regimen (50 Gy/25fx) used for treatment and a replanned hypofractionated regimen (40 Gy/15fx). Dose to the heart, cardiac substructures (sinoatrial node (SAN), atrio-ventricular node (AVN), right coronary artery, left anterior descending coronary artery, left ventricle), ipsilateral lung and liver were retrieved and compared.

RESULTS

Mean heart dose (MHD) was 3.33 Gy with FB vs. 3.10 Gy with DIBH on normofractionated plans (p = 0.489), and 2.58 Gy with FB vs. 2.41 Gy with DIBH on hypofractionated plan (p = 0.489). The benefit of DIBH was not significant for any cardiac substructure. The most exposed cardiac substructure were the SAN (mean dose of 6.62 Gy for FB- and 5.64 Gy for DIBH-VMAT on normofractionated plans) and the RCA (mean dose of 4.21 Gy for FB- and 4.06 Gy for DIBH-VMAT on normofractionated plans). The maximum benefit was observed for the RCA with a median individual dose reduction of 0.84 Gy on normofractionated plans (p = 0.599). No significant dosimetric difference were observed for right lung. Liver mean dose was significantly lower with DIBH with median values decreasing from 2.54 Gy to 0.87 Gy (p = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Adding DIBH to efficient cardiac-sparing radiotherapy techniques, such as VMAT, is not justified in the general case for locoregional R-BC irradiation. Specific R-BC patient subpopulations who could benefit from additional DIBH combination with locoregional VMAT are yet to be identified.

Cardiotoxicity model-based patient selection for Hodgkin lymphoma proton therapy

INTRODUCTION

Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) is a highly curable hematological malignancy. Consolidation radiation therapy techniques have made significant progresses to improve organ-at-risk sparing in order to reduce late radiation-induced toxicity. Recent technical breakthroughs notably include intensity modulated proton therapy (IMPT), which has demonstrated a major dosimetric benefit at the cardiac level for mediastinal HL patients. However, its implementation in clinical practice is still challenging, notably due to the limited access to proton therapy facilities. In this context, the purpose of this study was to estimate the benefit of IMPT for HL proton therapy for diverse cardiac adverse events and to propose a general frame for mediastinal HL patient selection strategy for IMPT based on cardiotoxicity reduction, patient clinical factors, and IMPT treatment availability.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This retrospective dosimetric study included 30 mediastinal HL patients treated with VMAT. IMPT plans were generated on the initial simulation scans. Dose to the heart, to the left ventricle and to the valves were retrieved to calculate the relative risk (RR) of ischemic heart disease (IHD), congestive heart failure (CHF) and valvular disease (VD). Composite relative risk reduction (cRRR) of late cardiotoxicity, between VMAT and IMPT, were calculated as the weighted mean of relative risk reduction for IHD, CHF and VD, calculated across a wide range of cardiovascular risk factor combinations. The proportion of mediastinal HL patients who could benefit from IMPT was estimated in European countries, based on the country population and on the number of active gantries, to propose country-specific cRRR thresholds for patient selection.

RESULTS

Compared with VMAT, IMPT significantly reduced average mean doses to the heart (2.36 Gy vs 0.99 Gy, p < 0.01), to the left ventricle (0.67 Gy vs 0.03, p < 0.01) and to the valves (1.29 Gy vs. 0.06, p < 0.01). For a HL patient without cardiovascular risk factor other than anthracycline-based chemotherapy, the relative risks of late cardiovascular complications were significantly lower after IMPT compared with VMAT for ischemic heart disease (1.07 vs 1.17, p < 0.01), for congestive heart failure (2.84 vs. 3.00, p < 0.01), and for valvular disease (1.01 vs. 1.06, p < 0.01). The median cRRR of cardiovascular adverse events with IMPT was 4.8%, ranging between 0.1% and 30.5%, depending on the extent of radiation fields and on the considered cardiovascular risk factors. The estimated proportion of HL patients currently treatable with IMPT in European countries with proton therapy facilities ranged between 8.0% and 100% depending on the country, corresponding to cRRR thresholds ranging from 24.0% to 0.0%.

CONCLUSION

While a statistically significant clinical benefit is theoretically expected for ischemic heart disease, cardiac heart failure and valvular disease for mediastinal HL patients with IMPT, the overall cardiotoxicity risk reduction is notable only for a minority of patients. In the context of limited IMPT availability, this study proposed a general model-based selection approach for mediastinal HL patient based on calculated cardiotoxicity reduction, taking into consideration patient clinical characteristics and IMPT facility availability.