A PHABULOSA-Controlled Genetic Pathway Regulates Ground Tissue Patterning in the Arabidopsis Root

Computational modeling of plant root development: the art and the science

Plant root development, like any developmental process, arises from the interplay between processes like gene expression, cell-cell signaling, cell growth and division, and tissue mechanics, which unfold over a wide range of temporal and spatial scales. Computational models are uniquely suited to integrate these different processes and spatio-temporal scales to investigate how their interplay determines developmental outcomes and have become part of mainstream plant developmental research. Still, for non-modeling experts, it often remains unclear how models are built, why a particular modeling approach was chosen, and how to interpret and value model outcomes. This review attempts to explain the science behind the art of model building, illustrating the simplifications that are often made to keep models simple to understand and when these are and are not justified. Similarly, it discusses when it is safe to ignore certain processes like growth or tissue mechanics and when it is not. Additionally, this review discusses a range of major breakthrough modeling articles. Their approaches are linked to classical concepts and models in developmental biology like the French flag positional information gradient of Lewis Wolpert and the repetitive patterning mechanism proposed by Turing, in addition to highlighting the lessons they taught us on plant root development.

A DOF transcriptional repressor-gibberellin feedback loop plays a crucial role in modulating light-independent seed germination

Plants have evolved several strategies to cope with the ever-changing environment. One example of this is given by seed germination, which must occur when environmental conditions are suitable for plant life. In the model system Arabidopsis thaliana seed germination is induced by light; however, in nature, seeds of several plant species can germinate regardless of this stimulus. While the molecular mechanisms underlying light-induced seed germination are well understood, those governing germination in the dark are still vague, mostly due to the lack of suitable model systems. Here, we employ Cardamine hirsuta, a close relative of Arabidopsis, as a powerful model system to uncover the molecular mechanisms underlying light-independent germination. By comparing Cardamine and Arabidopsis, we show that maintenance of the pro-germination hormone gibberellin (GA) levels prompt Cardamine seeds to germinate under both dark and light conditions. Using genetic and molecular biology experiments, we show that the Cardamine DOF transcriptional repressor DOF AFFECTING GERMINATION 1 (ChDAG1), homologous to the Arabidopsis transcription factor DAG1, is involved in this process functioning to mitigate GA levels by negatively regulating GA biosynthetic genes ChGA3OX1 and ChGA3OX2, independently of light conditions. We also demonstrate that this mechanism is likely conserved in other Brassicaceae species capable of germinating in dark conditions, such as Lepidium sativum and Camelina sativa. Our data support Cardamine as a new model system suitable for studying light-independent germination studies. Exploiting this system, we have also resolved a long-standing question about the mechanisms controlling light-independent germination in plants, opening new frontiers for future research.

OsKANADI1 and OsYABBY5 regulate rice plant height by targeting GIBERELLIN 2-OXIDASE6

Plant height is an important agronomic characteristic of rice (Oryza sativa L.). Map-based cloning analyses of a natural semi-dwarf rice mutant with inwardly curled leaves found in the field revealed that the defects were due to a mutation of a SHAQKYF-class MYB family transcription factor, OsKANADI1 (OsKAN1). OsKAN1 directly bound to the OsYABBY5 (OsYAB5) promoter to repress its expression and interacted with OsYAB5 to form a functional OsKAN1-OsYAB5 complex. GIBERELLIN 2-OXIDASE6 (OsGA2ox6), encoding an enzyme in the gibberellin (GA) catabolic pathway, was activated by OsYAB5. Furthermore, the OsKAN1-OsYAB5 complex suppressed the inhibitory effect of OsKAN1 toward OsYAB5 and inhibited OsYAB5-induced OsGA2ox6 expression. The proOsKAN1:OsYAB5 transgenic plants were taller than wild-type plants, whereas oskan1 proOsKAN1:OsYAB5 plants exhibited a severe dwarf phenotype due to the absence of the OsKAN1-OsYAB5 complex. The OsKAN1-OsYAB5 complex modulated OsGA2ox6 expression, thereby regulating the levels of bioactive gibberellins and, consequently, plant height. This study elucidated the mechanism underlying the effect of the OsKAN1-OsYAB5-OsGA2ox6 regulatory pathway on plant height at different positions in rice stems and provided insights on stem development and candidate genes for the aerial architecture improvement of crop plants.

Root development: A new player integrates two old friends

SCARECROW and SHORTROOT are key regulators of middle cortex formation in Arabidopsis roots, and gibberellin plays a crucial role in determining the timing of this process. A new study has filled the gap between these core regulators and elucidated the detailed molecular mechanisms.

Three RLKs integrate SHR-SCR and gibberellins to regulate root ground tissue patterning in Arabidopsis thaliana

Precise regulation of cell division is essential for proper tissue patterning in multicellular organisms. In Arabidopsis, the ground tissue (GT) comprises cortex and endodermis in the early stages of root development. During GT maturation, additional periclinal cell divisions (PCDs) occasionally occur of the endodermis, generating a middle cortex (MC) layer between the cortex and endodermis. Although several regulatory proteins and phytohormones were identified to mediate GT patterning, such as SHORT-ROOT (SHR), SCARECROW (SCR), CYCLIND6;1 (CYCD6;1), and gibberellins (GAs), the interrelationship among these factors is not elucidated. Here, we report that three closely related receptor-like kinases (RLKs), ARH1, FEI1, and FEI2, play crucial roles in mediating a signal transduction pathway from the SHR-SCR module to GA to regulate GT patterning. Two independent triple mutants of these RLKs (tri-1 and tri-2) exhibit increased MC formation compared with wild type. Genetic analysis indicated that all three RLKs regulate MC formation mainly in a cell-autonomous manner. The transcription levels of these RLKs are negatively controlled by SHR and SCR. The altered GT patterns in shr and scr can be partially complemented by tri-1. GA biosynthesis is significantly reduced in the roots of tri-1. The excessive MC formation in tri-1 can be greatly suppressed by the exogenous application of GA3 or by the mutation of CYCD6;1. Our results demonstrate a signaling pathway involving SHR/SCR-ARH1/FEI1/FEI2-GA-CYCD6;1 to govern GT patterning in Arabidopsis thaliana.

SPL13 controls a root apical meristem phase change by triggering oriented cell divisions

Oriented cell divisions are crucial for determining the overall morphology and size of plants, but what controls the onset and duration of this process remains largely unknown. Here, we identified a small molecule that activates root apical meristem (RAM) expression of SQUAMOSA PROMOTER BINDING PROTEIN-LIKE13 (SPL13) a known player in the shoot's juvenile-to-adult transition. This expression leads to oriented cell divisions in the RAM through SHORT ROOT (SHR) and cell cycle regulators. We further show that the RAM has distinct juvenile and adult phases typed by morphological and molecular characteristics and that SPL factors are crucially required for this transition in Arabidopsis and rice (Oryza sativa). In summary, we provide molecular insights into the age-dependent morphological changes occurring in the RAM during phase change.

Effect of gibberellin on crown root development in the mutant of the rice plasmodesmal Germin-like protein OsGER4

Rice is an essential but highly stress-susceptible crop, whose root system plays an important role in plant development and stress adaptation. The rice root system architecture is controlled by gene regulatory networks involving different phytohormones including auxin, jasmonate, and gibberellin. Gibberellin is generally known as a molecular clock that interacts with different pathways to regulate root meristem development. The exogenous treatment of rice plantlets with Gibberellin reduced the number of crown roots, whilst the exogenous jasmonic acid treatment enhanced them by involving a Germin-like protein OsGER4. Due to those opposite effects, this study aims to investigate the effect of Gibberellin on crown root development in the rice mutant of the plasmodesmal Germin-like protein OsGER4. Under exogenous gibberellin treatment, the number of crown roots significantly increased in osger4 mutant lines and decreased in the OsGER4 overexpressed lines. GUS staining showed that OsGER4 was strongly expressed in rice root systems, particularly crown and lateral roots under GA3 application. Specifically, OsGER4 was strongly expressed from the exodermis, epidermis, sclerenchyma to the endodermis layers of the crown root, along the vascular bundle and throughout LR primordia. The plasmodesmal protein OsGER4 is suggested to be involved in crown root development by maintaining hormone homeostasis, including Gibberillin.

Single-cell RNA-seq reveals a link of ovule abortion and sugar transport in Camellia oleifera

Camellia oleifera is the most important woody oil crop in China. Seed number per fruit is an important yield trait in C. oleifera. Ovule abortion is generally observed in C. oleifera and significantly decreases the seed number per fruit. However, the mechanisms of ovule abortion remain poorly understood at present. Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) was performed using mature ovaries of two C. oleifera varieties with different ovule abortion rates (OARs). In total, 20,526 high-quality cells were obtained, and 18 putative cell clusters were identified. Six cell types including female gametophyte, protoxylem, protophloem, procambium, epidermis, and parenchyma cells were identified from three main tissue types of ovule, placenta, and pericarp inner layer. A comparative analysis on scRNA-seq data between high- and low-OAR varieties demonstrated that the overall expression of CoSWEET and CoCWINV in procambium cells, and CoSTP in the integument was significantly upregulated in the low-OAR variety. Both the infertile ovule before pollination and the abortion ovule producing after compatible pollination might be attributed to selective abortion caused by low sugar levels in the apoplast around procambium cells and a low capability of hexose uptake in the integument. Here, the first single-cell transcriptional landscape is reported in woody crop ovaries. Our investigation demonstrates that ovule abortion may be related to sugar transport in placenta and ovules and sheds light on further deciphering the mechanism of regulating sugar transport and the improvement of seed yield in C. oleifera.

Gibberellin signaling regulates lignin biosynthesis to modulate rice seed shattering

The elimination of seed shattering was a key step in rice (Oryza sativa) domestication. In this paper, we show that increasing the gibberellic acid (GA) content or response in the abscission region enhanced seed shattering in rice. We demonstrate that SLENDER RICE1 (SLR1), the key repressor of GA signaling, could physically interact with the rice seed shattering-related transcription factors quantitative trait locus of seed shattering on chromosome 1 (qSH1), O. sativa HOMEOBOX 15 (OSH15), and SUPERNUMERARY BRACT (SNB). Importantly, these physical interactions interfered with the direct binding of these three regulators to the lignin biosynthesis gene 4-COUMARATE: COENZYME A LIGASE 3 (4CL3), thereby derepressing its expression. Derepression of 4CL3 led to increased lignin deposition in the abscission region, causing reduced rice seed shattering. Importantly, we also show that modulating GA content could alter the degree of seed shattering to increase harvest efficiency. Our results reveal that the "Green Revolution" phytohormone GA is important for regulating rice seed shattering, and we provide an applicable breeding strategy for high-efficiency rice harvesting.

Transcriptional control of hydrogen peroxide homeostasis regulates ground tissue patterning in the Arabidopsis root

In multicellular organisms, including higher plants, asymmetric cell divisions (ACDs) play a crucial role in generating distinct cell types. The Arabidopsis root ground tissue initially has two layers: endodermis (inside) and cortex (outside). In the mature root, the endodermis undergoes additional ACDs to produce the endodermis itself and the middle cortex (MC), located between the endodermis and the pre-existing cortex. In the Arabidopsis root, gibberellic acid (GA) deficiency and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) precociously induced more frequent ACDs in the endodermis for MC formation. Thus, these findings suggest that GA and H2O2 play roles in regulating the timing and extent of MC formation. However, details of the molecular interaction between GA signaling and H2O2 homeostasis remain elusive. In this study, we identified the PEROXIDASE 34 (PRX34) gene, which encodes a class III peroxidase, as a molecular link to elucidate the interconnected regulatory network involved in H2O2- and GA-mediated MC formation. Under normal conditions, prx34 showed a reduced frequency of MC formation, whereas the occurrence of MC in prx34 was restored to nearly WT levels in the presence of H2O2. Our results suggest that PRX34 plays a role in H2O2-mediated MC production. Furthermore, we provide evidence that SCARECROW-LIKE 3 (SCL3) regulates H2O2 homeostasis by controlling transcription of PRX34 during root ground tissue maturation. Taken together, our findings provide new insights into how H2O2 homeostasis is achieved by SCL3 to ensure correct radial tissue patterning in the Arabidopsis root.

microRNA165 and 166 modulate response of the Arabidopsis root apical meristem to salt stress

In plants, developmental plasticity allows for the modulation of organ growth in response to environmental cues. Being in contact with soil, roots are the first organ that responds to various types of soil abiotic stress such as high salt concentration. In the root, developmental plasticity relies on changes in the activity of the apical meristem, the region at the tip of the root where a set of self-renewing undifferentiated stem cells sustain growth. Here, we show that salt stress promotes differentiation of root meristem cells via reducing the dosage of the microRNAs miR165 and 166. By means of genetic, molecular and computational analysis, we show that the levels of miR165 and 166 respond to high salt concentration, and that miR165 and 166-dependent PHABULOSA (PHB) modulation is central to the response of root growth to this stress. Specifically, we show that salt-dependent reduction of miR165 and 166 causes a rapid increase in PHB expression and, hence, production of the root meristem pro-differentiation hormone cytokinin. Our data provide direct evidence for how the miRNA-dependent modulation of transcription factor dosage mediates plastic development in plants.

NAC1 regulates root ground tissue maturation by coordinating with the SCR/SHR-CYCD6;1 module in Arabidopsis

Precise spatiotemporal control of the timing and extent of asymmetric cell divisions (ACDs) is essential for plant development. In the Arabidopsis root, ground tissue maturation involves an additional ACD of the endodermis that maintains the inner cell layer as the endodermis and generates the middle cortex to the outside. Through regulation of the cell cycle regulator CYCLIND6;1 (CYCD6;1), the transcription factors SCARECROW (SCR) and SHORT-ROOT (SHR) play critical roles in this process. In the present study, we found that loss of function of NAC1, a NAC transcription factor family gene, causes markedly increased periclinal cell divisions in the root endodermis. Importantly, NAC1 directly represses the transcription of CYCD6;1 by recruiting the co-repressor TOPLESS (TPL), creating a fine-tuned mechanism to maintain proper root ground tissue patterning by limiting production of middle cortex cells. Biochemical and genetic analyses further showed that NAC1 physically interacts with SCR and SHR to restrict excessive periclinal cell divisions in the endodermis during root middle cortex formation. Although NAC1-TPL is recruited to the CYCD6;1 promoter and represses its transcription in an SCR-dependent manner, NAC1 and SHR antagonize each other to regulate the expression of CYCD6;1. Collectively, our study provides mechanistic insights into how the NAC1-TPL module integrates with the master transcriptional regulators SCR and SHR to control root ground tissue patterning by fine-tuning spatiotemporal expression of CYCD6;1 in Arabidopsis.

The miR156 juvenility factor and PLETHORA 2 form a regulatory network and influence timing of meristem growth and lateral root emergence

Plants develop throughout their lives: seeds become seedlings that mature and form fruits and seeds. Although the underlying mechanisms that drive these developmental phase transitions have been well elucidated for shoots, the extent to which they affect the root is less clear. However, root anatomy does change as some plants mature; meristems enlarge and radial thickening occurs. Here, in Arabidopsis thaliana, we show that overexpressing miR156A, a gene that promotes the juvenile phase, increased the density of the root system, even in grafted plants in which only the rootstock had the overexpression genotype. In the root, overexpression of miR156A resulted in lower levels of PLETHORA 2, a protein that affects formation of the meristem and elongation zone. Crossing in an extra copy of PLETHORA 2 partially rescued the effects of miR156A overexpression on traits affecting root architecture, including meristem length and the rate of lateral root emergence. Consistent with this, PLETHORA 2 also inhibited the root-tip expression of another miR156 gene, miR156C. We conclude that the system driving phase change in the shoot affects developmental progression in the root, and that PLETHORA 2 participates in this network.

The miR166 mediated regulatory module controls plant height by regulating gibberellic acid biosynthesis and catabolism in soybean

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are endogenous small non-coding RNAs that play critical roles in regulating plant growth and development. Here, we used Short Tandem Target Mimic (STTM) technology to generate soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) miRNA knockdown lines and identify miRNAs that regulate plant height, a key agronomic trait that affects yield. STTM166 successfully silenced miR166 in soybean and upregulated the expression of miR166 target genes, such as ATHB14-LIKE. The miR166 knockdown lines (GmSTTM166) displayed a reduced plant height phenotype. Moreover, GmSTTM166 plants contained lower levels of bioactive gibberellic acid (GA3) than wild-type plants, and application of exogenous GA partially rescued the dwarf phenotype of GmSTTM166. Knockdown of miR166 altered the expression of genes involved in GA biosynthesis and catabolism. Further analysis revealed that ATHB14-LIKE directly represses transcription of the GA biosynthesis genes GmGA1 and GmGA2, while activating transcription of the GA catabolic gene GIBBERLLIN 2 OXIDASE 2 (GmGA2ox2). Collectively, these results reveal a pivotal role for miR166 in the genetic control of plant height in soybean, thereby providing invaluable insights for molecular breeding to improve soybean yield.

Gene regulatory networks shape developmental plasticity of root cell types under water extremes in rice

Understanding how roots modulate development under varied irrigation or rainfall is crucial for development of climate-resilient crops. We established a toolbox of tagged rice lines to profile translating mRNAs and chromatin accessibility within specific cell populations. We used these to study roots in a range of environments: plates in the lab, controlled greenhouse stress and recovery conditions, and outdoors in a paddy. Integration of chromatin and mRNA data resolves regulatory networks of the following: cycle genes in proliferating cells that attenuate DNA synthesis under submergence; genes involved in auxin signaling, the circadian clock, and small RNA regulation in ground tissue; and suberin biosynthesis, iron transporters, and nitrogen assimilation in endodermal/exodermal cells modulated with water availability. By applying a systems approach, we identify known and candidate driver transcription factors of water-deficit responses and xylem development plasticity. Collectively, this resource will facilitate genetic improvements in root systems for optimal climate resilience.

CDC48B facilitates the intercellular trafficking of SHORT-ROOT during radial patterning in roots

CELL DIVISION CONTROL PROTEIN48 (CDC48) is essential for membrane fusion, protein degradation, and other cellular processes. Here, we revealed the crucial role of CDC48B in regulating periclinal cell division in roots by analyzing the recessive gen1 mutant. We identified the GEN1 gene through map-based cloning and verified that GEN1 encodes CDC48B. gen1 showed severely inhibited root growth, increased periclinal cell division in the endodermis, defective middle cortex (MC) formation, and altered ground tissue patterning in roots. Consistent with these phenotypes, CYCLIND 6;1(CYCD6;1), a periclinal cell division marker, was upregulated in gen1 compared to Col-0. The ratio of SHR_pro :SHR-GFP fluorescence in pre-dividing nuclei versus the adjacent stele decreased by 33% in gen1, indicating that the trafficking of SHORT-ROOT (SHR) decreased in gen1 when endodermal cells started to divide. These findings suggest that the loss of function of CDC48B inhibits the intercellular trafficking of SHR from the stele to the endodermis, thereby decreasing SHR accumulation in the endodermis. These findings shed light on the crucial role of CDC48B in regulating periclinal cell division in roots.

Distinct mechanisms orchestrate the contra-polarity of IRK and KOIN, two LRR-receptor-kinases controlling root cell division

In plants, cell polarity plays key roles in coordinating developmental processes. Despite the characterization of several polarly localized plasma membrane proteins, the mechanisms connecting protein dynamics with cellular functions often remain unclear. Here, we introduce a polarized receptor, KOIN, that restricts cell divisions in the Arabidopsis root meristem. In the endodermis, KOIN polarity is opposite to IRK, a receptor that represses endodermal cell divisions. Their contra-polar localization facilitates dissection of polarity mechanisms and the links between polarity and function. We find that IRK and KOIN are recognized, sorted, and secreted through distinct pathways. IRK extracellular domains determine its polarity and partially rescue the mutant phenotype, whereas KOIN’s extracellular domains are insufficient for polar sorting and function. Endodermal expression of an IRK/KOIN chimera generates non-cell-autonomous misregulation of root cell divisions that impacts patterning. Altogether, we reveal two contrasting mechanisms determining these receptors’ polarity and link their polarity to cell divisions in root tissue patterning.

Protein polarization coordinates many plant developmental processes. Here the authors show that IRK and KOIN, two LRR-receptor-kinases polarized to opposite sides of cells in the root meristem, rely on distinct mechanisms to achieve polarity.

Integrated regulation of periclinal cell division by transcriptional module of BZR1-SHR in Arabidopsis roots

The timing and extent of cell division are crucial for the correct patterning of multicellular organism. In Arabidopsis, root ground tissue maturation involves the periclinal cell division of the endodermis to generate two cell layers: endodermis and middle cortex. However, the molecular mechanism underlying this pattern formation remains unclear. Here, we report that phytohormone brassinosteroid (BR) and redox signal hydrogen peroxide (H₂ O₂ ) interdependently promote periclinal division during root ground tissue maturation by regulating the activity of SHORT-ROOT (SHR), a master regulator of root growth and development. BR-activated transcription factor BRASSINAZOLE RESISTANT1 (BZR1) directly binds to the promoter of SHR to induce its expression, and physically interacts with SHR to increase the transcripts of RESPIRATORY BURST OXIDASE HOMOLOGs (RBOHs) and elevate the levels of H₂ O₂ , which feedback enhances the interaction between BZR1 and SHR. Additionally, genetic analysis shows that SHR is required for BZR1-promoted periclinal division, and BZR1 enhances the promoting effects of SHR on periclinal division. Together, our finding reveals that the transcriptional module of BZR1-SHR fine-tunes periclinal division during root ground tissue maturation in response to hormone and redox signals.

It's Time for a Change: The Role of Gibberellin in Root Meristem Development

One of the most amazing characteristics of plants is their ability to grow and adapt their development to environmental changes. This fascinating feature is possible thanks to the activity of meristems, tissues that contain lasting self-renewal stem cells. Because of its simple and symmetric structure, the root meristem emerged as a potent system to uncover the developmental mechanisms behind the development of the meristems. The root meristem is formed during embryogenesis and sustains root growth for all the plant's lifetime. In the last decade, gibberellins have emerged as a key regulator for root meristem development. This phytohormone functions as a molecular clock for root development. This mini review discusses the latest advances in understanding the role of gibberellin in root development and highlights the central role of this hormone as developmental timer.

A small cog in a large wheel: crucial role of miRNAs in root apical meristem patterning

In both animal and plants, establishment of body axes is fundamental for proper organ development. Plant roots show two main developmental axes: the proximo-distal axis, which spans from the hypocotyl-root junction to the root tip; and the radial axis, which traverses from the vascular tissue to the epidermis. Root axes are determined in the root meristem. The root meristem occupies the tip of the root and contains self-renewing stem cells, which continuously produce new root cells. An intricate network of signalling pathways regulates meristem function and patterning to ensure proper root development and growth. In the last decade, miRNAs, 20-21 nucleotide-long molecules with morphogenetic activity, emerged as central regulators of root cell patterning. Their activity intersects with master regulators of meristematic activity, including phytohormones. In this review, we discuss the latest findings about the activity of miRNAs and their interaction with other molecular networks in the formation of root meristem axes. Furthermore, we describe how these small molecules allow root growth to adapt to changes in the environment, while maintaining the correct patterning.

Root Patterning: Tuning SHORT ROOT Function Creates Diversity in Form

Roots have a fundamental role in plant growth and adaptation to different environments. Diversity in root morphology and architecture enables plants to acquire water and nutrients in contrasting substrate conditions, resist biotic and abiotic stress, and develop symbiotic associations. At its most fundamental level, morphology is determined by discrete changes in tissue patterning. Differences in the number and arrangement of the cell layers in the root can change tissue structure, as well as root length and girth, affecting important productivity traits. Therefore, understanding the molecular mechanisms controlling variation in developmental patterning is an important goal in biology. The ground tissue (GT) system is an ideal model to study the genetic basis of morphological diversity because it displays great interspecific variability in cell layer number. In addition, the genetic circuit controlling GT patterning in Arabidopsis thaliana has been well described, although little is known about species with more complex root anatomies. In this review, we will describe the Arabidopsis model for root radial patterning and present recent progress in elucidating the genetic circuitry controlling GT patterning in monocots and the legume Medicago truncatula (Mt), species that develop roots with more complex anatomies and multilayered cortex.