Mutations in BRAT1 cause autosomal recessive progressive encephalopathy: Report of a Spanish patient

Clinical characteristics of BRAT1-related disease: a systematic literature review

BACKGROUND

BRAT1 (BRCA1-associated ataxia telangiectasia mutated activator 1) is involved in many important biological processes, including DNA damage response and maintenance of mitochondrial homeostasis. Dysfunctional BRAT1 causes variable clinical phenotypes, which hinders BRAT1-related disease from recognition and diagnosis.

METHODS

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement was the guideline for this systematic review. MEDLINE was searched by terms ("BAAT1" and "BRAT1") from inception until June 21, 2022.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight studies, screened out of 49 records, were included for data extraction. The data from fifty patients with mutated BRAT1 were collected. There are 3 high relevant phenotypes, 4 medium relevant phenotypes and 3 low relevant phenotypes. Eye-related abnormal features were most frequently reported: 27 abnormal features were observed. Thirty-nine kinds of pathogenic nucleotide change in BRAT1 were reported. Top three common mutations of BRAT1 were c.638_639insA (16 cases), c.1395G > A (5 cases) and c.294dupA (4 cases). Homozygous mutations in BRAT1 presented a more severe phenotype than those who are compound heterozygotes.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first comprehensive systematic review to present quantitative data about clinical characteristics of BRAT1-related disease, which helps doctors to recognize and diagnose it easier.

BRAT1-related disorders: phenotypic spectrum and phenotype-genotype correlations from 97 patients

BRAT1 biallelic variants are associated with rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome, lethal neonatal (RMFSL), and neurodevelopmental disorder associating cerebellar atrophy with or without seizures syndrome (NEDCAS). To date, forty individuals have been reported in the literature. We collected clinical and molecular data from 57 additional cases allowing us to study a large cohort of 97 individuals and draw phenotype-genotype correlations. Fifty-nine individuals presented with BRAT1-related RMFSL phenotype. Most of them had no psychomotor acquisition (100%), epilepsy (100%), microcephaly (91%), limb rigidity (93%), and died prematurely (93%). Thirty-eight individuals presented a non-lethal phenotype of BRAT1-related NEDCAS phenotype. Seventy-six percent of the patients in this group were able to walk and 68% were able to say at least a few words. Most of them had cerebellar ataxia (82%), axial hypotonia (79%) and cerebellar atrophy (100%). Genotype-phenotype correlations in our cohort revealed that biallelic nonsense, frameshift or inframe deletion/insertion variants result in the severe BRAT1-related RMFSL phenotype (46/46; 100%). In contrast, genotypes with at least one missense were more likely associated with NEDCAS (28/34; 82%). The phenotype of patients carrying splice variants was variable: 41% presented with RMFSL (7/17) and 59% with NEDCAS (10/17).

Clinical and Neurophysiologic Phenotypes in Neonates With BRAT1 Encephalopathy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

BRAT1 encephalopathy is an ultra-rare autosomal recessive neonatal encephalopathy. We delineate the neonatal electroclinical phenotype at presentation and provide insights for early diagnosis.

METHODS

Through a multinational collaborative, we studied a cohort of neonates with encephalopathy associated with biallelic pathogenic variants in BRAT1 for whom detailed clinical, neurophysiologic, and neuroimaging information was available from the onset of symptoms. Neuropathologic changes were also analyzed.

RESULTS

We included 19 neonates. Most neonates were born at term (16/19) from nonconsanguineous parents. 15/19 (79%) were admitted soon after birth to a neonatal intensive care unit, exhibiting multifocal myoclonus, both spontaneous and exacerbated by stimulation. 7/19 (37%) had arthrogryposis at birth, and all except 1 progressively developed hypertonia in the first week of life. Multifocal myoclonus, which was present in all but 1 infant, was the most prominent manifestation and did not show any EEG correlate in 16/19 (84%). Video-EEG at onset was unremarkable in 14/19 (74%) infants, and 6 (33%) had initially been misdiagnosed with hyperekplexia. Multifocal seizures were observed at a median age of 14 days (range: 1-29). During the first months of life, all infants developed progressive encephalopathy, acquired microcephaly, prolonged bouts of apnea, and bradycardia, leading to cardiac arrest and death at a median age of 3.5 months (range: 20 days to 30 months). Only 7 infants (37%) received a definite diagnosis before death, at a median age of 34 days (range: 25-126), and almost two-thirds (12/19, 63%) were diagnosed 8 days to 12 years postmortem (median: 6.5 years). Neuropathology examination, performed in 3 patients, revealed severely delayed myelination and diffuse astrogliosis, sparing the upper cortical layers.

DISCUSSION

BRAT1 encephalopathy is a neonatal-onset, rapidly progressive neurologic disorder. Neonates are often misdiagnosed as having hyperekplexia, and many die undiagnosed. The key phenotypic features are multifocal myoclonus, an organized EEG, progressive, persistent, and diffuse hypertonia, and an evolution into refractory multifocal seizures, prolonged bouts of apnea, bradycardia, and early death. Early recognition of BRAT1 encephalopathy allows for prompt workup, appropriate management, and genetic counseling.

BRAT1 Mutation Retrospective Diagnosis: A Case Report

Biallelic mutations in the BRAT1 gene have been reported in cases with Lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome (RMFSL), since 2012. Clinical features include progressive encephalopathy, dysmorphic features, microcephaly, hypertonia, developmental delay, refractory epilepsy, episodic apnea, and bradycardia. More recently, biallelic BRAT1 mutations have been associated with a milder phenotype in patients with migrating focal seizures in the absence of rigidity or with nonprogressive congenital ataxia with or without epilepsy (NEDCAS). It has been proposed that the loss of function caused by BRAT1 mutations may decrease cell proliferation and migration and cause neuronal atrophy through impairment of mitochondrial homeostasis. We here report a female infant with a phenotype, electroencephalogram (EEG), and brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) consistent with RMFSL, whose diagnosis was indirectly formulated three years after death upon the identification in both parents of a known pathogenetic variant in the BRAT1 gene. Our report emphasizes the remarkable potential of novel genetic technologies for the diagnosis of past unsolved clinical cases.

Case report: 7p22.3 deletion and 8q24.3 duplication in a patient with epilepsy and psychomotor delay-Does both possibly act to modulate a candidate gene region for the patient's phenotype?

Background: Psychomotor delay, epilepsy and dysmorphic features are clinical signs which are described in multiple syndromes due to chromosomal imbalances or mutations involving key genes implicated in the stages of Early Embryonic Development. In this context, we report a 10 years old Tunisian patient with these three signs. Our objective is to determine the cause of developmental, behavioral and facial abnormalities in this patient. Methods: We used banding cytogenetics (karyotype) and Array Comparative Genomic Hybridization (Array CGH) to this purpose. Results: The karyotype was in favor of a derivative of chromosome 7 in the patient and Array CGH analysis revealed a loss of genetic material in 7p22.3-p22.1 (4,56 Mb) with a gain at 8q24.23-q24 (9.20 Mb) resulting from maternal 7/8 reciprocal translocation. An in silico analysis of the unbalanced region was carried out and showed that the 7p22.3-p22.1 deletion contains eight genes. Among them, BRAT1 gene, previously described in several neurodevelopmental diseases, may be a candidate gene which absence could be correlated to the patient's phenotype. However, the 8q24.23-q24 duplication could be involved in the phenotype of this patient. Conclusion: In this study, we report for the first time a 7p deletion/8q duplication in a patient with psychomoteur delay, epilepsy and facial dysmorphism. Our study showed that Array CGH still useful for delivering a conclusive genetic diagnosis for patients having neurodevelopmental abnormalities in the era of next-generation sequencing.

Compound heterozygous loss-of-function variants in BRAT1 cause lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome

BACKGROUND

Lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome (RMFSL, OMIM 614498) is a rare autosomal recessive disease characterized by the onset of rigidity and intractable seizures at or soon after birth. The BRAT1 has been identified to be the disease-causing gene for RMFSL. This study aimed to determine the underlying pathogenic mutations of a Chinese family with RMFSL and to confirm the effect of the splice-site mutation by reverse transcription analysis.

METHODS

Detailed family history and clinical data were recorded, and peripheral blood samples were collected from all available family members. Whole exome sequencing (WES), Sanger sequencing, and bioinformatics analysis were performed to investigate the causative variants. The impact of the intronic variant on splicing was subsequently analyzed by RT-PCR analysis.

RESULTS

We identified two compound heterozygous variants in the BRAT1, c.431-2A>G in intron 3 and c.1359_1361del(p.Leu454del) in exon 9 in the proband, one inherited from each parent. Furthermore, the 3'-splice site acceptor (c.431-2A>G) variant was found to activate a cryptic acceptor splice site, which resulted in the loss of 29 nucleotides and generation of a premature stop codon at code 180, producing a truncated BRAT1 (c.432_460del; p.Ala145Argfs*36).

CONCLUSIONS

This research identified two mutations in the BRAT1 of one Chinese family with RMFSL. These data can aid in developing clinical diagnoses as well as providing genetic counseling and prenatal interventions to the family. These findings also expand our knowledge of the spectrum of BRAT1 pathogenic variants in RMFSL syndrome.

Novel Biallelic Variant in the BRAT1 Gene Caused Nonprogressive Cerebellar Ataxia Syndrome

Recessive mutations in BRAT1 cause lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome (RMFSL), a phenotype characterized by neonatal microcephaly, hypertonia, and refractory epilepsy with premature death. Recently, attenuated disease variants have been described, suggesting that a wider clinical spectrum of BRAT1-associated neurodegeneration exists than was previously thought. Here, we reported a 10-year-old girl with severe intellectual disability, rigidity, ataxia or dyspraxia, and cerebellar atrophy on brain MRI; two BRAT1 variants in the trans configuration [c.1014A > C (p.Pro338 = ); c.706delC (p.Leu236Cysfs*5)] were detected using whole-exome sequencing. RNA-seq confirmed significantly decreased BRAT1 transcript levels in the presence of the variant; further, it revealed an intron retention between exon 7 and exon 8 caused by the synonymous base substitute. Subsequent prenatal diagnosis for these two variants guided the parents to reproduce. We expand the phenotypic spectrum of BRAT1-associated disorders by first reporting the pathogenic synonymous variant of the BRAT1 gene, resulting in clinical severity that is mild compared to the severe phenotype seen in RMFSL. Making an accurate diagnosis and prognostic evaluation of BRAT1-associated neurodegeneration is important for reproductive consultation and disease management.

Novel variant in BRAT1 with the lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome

BACKGROUND

Lethal neonatal rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome (RMFSL) is caused by variants in BRAT1 (BRCA1-associated protein required for ATM activation-1). However, the molecular mechanism of RMFSL is still unclear.

METHODS

An RMFSL infant was recruited and the peripheral blood samples from his trio-family were collected. The genomic DNA was extracted, and then the whole-exome sequencing was performed. The expression of BRAT1 was analyzed by Western blotting. The subcellular localization of BRAT1 and MitoSOX (mitochondrial superoxide level) was investigated by confocal microscopy. The RNA samples were obtained from transfected cells, and then the RNA sequencing was performed.

RESULTS

In this study, a novel homozygous BRAT1 variant c.233G > C with amino acid change of R with P at residue 78 (R78P) was identified. This variant altered the peptide structure and subcellular localization, as well as the expression in vitro. However, R78P did not alter the ability of BRAT1 to downregulate MitoSOX in mitochondria. Meanwhile, R78P BRAT1 was positively correlated with temporal lobe epilepsy, autosomal recessive primary microcephaly, defective/absent horizontal voluntary eye movements, and neuron apoptotic process as indicated by gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA).

CONCLUSIONS

The BRAT1 variant spectrum has been expanded, which will be helpful for genetic counseling. We also explored the molecular mechanism altered by R78P, which will provide a better understanding of the pathogenesis of RMFSL.

IMPACT

The detailed course of an infant with lethal neonatal RMFSL was depicted. A novel disease-causing variant R78P in BRAT1 for lethal neonatal RMFSL was identified. R78P led to reduced BRAT1 expression and nuclear localization in vitro. R78P did not alter the ability of BRAT1 to downregulate MitoSOX in the mitochondria. The variant R78P in BRAT1 was positively correlated with temporal lobe epilepsy, autosomal recessive primary microcephaly, defective/absent horizontal voluntary eye movements, and neuron apoptotic process as indicated by GSEA.

A review of the clinical spectrum of BRAT1 disorders and case of developmental and epileptic encephalopathy surviving into adulthood

•

We report a patient with a BRAT1 disorder who survived into adulthood.

•

Infantile-onset developmental and epileptic encephalopathy rather than an ataxic presentation was the presenting feature.

•

Compound heterozygous BRAT1 variants may be associated with later onset of seizures and longer survival reflecting a spectrum of clinical disease.

Pathogenic variants in BRAT1 are associated with a spectrum of clinical syndromes ranging from Lethal Neonatal Rigidity and Multifocal Seizure syndrome (RMFSL) to Neurodevelopmental Disorder with Cerebellar Atrophy and with or without Seizures (NEDCAS). RMFSL is characterized by early-onset multifocal seizures with microcephaly. Death occurs during infancy although a less severe course with later onset seizures and longer survival into childhood has been described. Here, we summarize published cases of BRAT1 disorders and present the case of a 20-year-old man with two heterozygous BRAT1 variants and a relatively later age of seizure onset with survival into adulthood. This case expands the spectrum of disease associated with BRAT1 variants and highlights the utility of genetic testing to identify the cause of developmental and epileptic encephalopathies where clinical heterogeneity within a spectrum of disease exists.

Clinical variability at the mild end of BRAT1-related spectrum: Evidence from two families with genotype-phenotype discordance

Biallelic mutations in the BRAT1 gene, encoding BRCA1-associated ATM activator 1, result in variable phenotypes, from rigidity and multifocal seizure syndrome, lethal neonatal to neurodevelopmental disorder, and cerebellar atrophy with or without seizures, without obvious genotype-phenotype associations. We describe two families at the mildest end of the spectrum, differing in clinical presentation despite a common genotype at the BRAT1 locus. Two siblings displayed nonprogressive congenital ataxia and shrunken cerebellum on magnetic resonance imaging. A third unrelated patient showed normal neurodevelopment, adolescence-onset seizures, and ataxia, shrunken cerebellum, and ultrastructural abnormalities on skin biopsy, representing the mildest form of NEDCAS hitherto described. Exome sequencing identified the c.638dup and the novel c.1395G>A BRAT1 variants, the latter causing exon 10 skippings. The p53-MCL test revealed normal ATM kinase activity. Our findings broaden the allelic and clinical spectrum of BRAT1-related disease, which should be suspected in presence of nonprogressive cerebellar signs, even without a neurodevelopmental disorder.

Clinical and genetic features of PEHO and PEHO-Like syndromes: A scoping review

Progressive encephalopathy with edema, hypsarrhythmia, and optic atrophy (PEHO) syndrome is a genetic neurological condition characterized by extreme cerebellar atrophy. PEHO-Like syndrome is comparable to PEHO syndrome, with the exception that there is no typical neuro-radiologic or neuro-ophthalmic findings. PEHO spectrum disorders are highly clinically and genetically heterogeneous, and this has challenged their diagnosis. This scoping review aims to summarize and discuss common clinical and genetic features of these syndromes to help future researches. This study was performed according to a six-stage methodology structure and PRISMA guideline. A systematic search of seven databases was performed to find eligible publications prior to June 2020. Articles screening and data extraction were independently performed by two reviewers and quantitative and qualitative analyses were conducted. Thirty-eight articles were identified that fulfill the inclusion criteria. Cerebellar atrophy was the main clinical difference between the two groups but data on optic atrophy and infantile spasms/hypsarrhythmia were not consistent with the previously essential diagnostic criteria. Genetic analysis was performed in several studies, leading to identification of pathogenic variants in different genes that caused these conditions due to different mechanisms. Genetic studies could revolutionize the diagnosis process and our understanding of the etiology of this challenging group of patients by providing targeted sequencing panels and exome- or genome-scale studies in the future.

Homozygous pathogenic variant in BRAT1 associated with nonprogressive cerebellar ataxia

Objective

To investigate the pathogenicity of a novel homozygous BRAT1 variant in 2 siblings with nonprogressive cerebellar ataxia (NPCA) through functional studies on primary and immortalized patient cell lines.

Methods

BRAT1 protein levels and ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM) kinase activity in patient-derived and control cell lines were assessed by Western blotting. The impact of the novel BRAT1 variants on mitochondrial function was also assessed, by comparing patient and control cell lines for rates of oxygen consumption and for phosphorylation (S293) of the E1⍺ subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH).

Results

Two male siblings with NPCA, mild intellectual disability, and isolated cerebellar atrophy were found to be homozygous for a c.185T>A (p.Val62Glu) variant in BRAT1 by whole exome sequencing. Western blotting revealed markedly decreased BRAT1 protein levels in lymphocytes and/or fibroblast cells from both affected siblings compared to control cell lines. There were no differences between the patient and control cells in ATM kinase activation, following ionizing radiation. Mitochondrial studies were initially suggestive of a defect in regulation of PDH activity, but there was no evidence of increased phosphorylation of the E1⍺ subunit of the PDH complex. Measurement of oxygen consumption rates similarly failed to identify differences between patient and control cells.

Conclusions

Biallelic pathogenic variants in BRAT1 can be associated with NPCA, a phenotype considerably milder than previously reported. Surprisingly, despite the molecular role currently proposed for BRAT1 in ATM regulation, this disorder is unlikely to result from defective ATM kinase or mitochondrial dysfunction.

Genetics of neonatal-onset epilepsies

Although the majority of seizures in neonates are related to acute brain injury, a substantial minority are the first symptom of a neonatal-onset epilepsy often linked to a pathogenic genetic variant. Historically, studies on neonatal seizures including treatment response and long-term consequences have lumped all etiologies together. However, etiology has been consistently shown to be the most important determinant of outcome. In the past few years, an increasing number of monogenic disorders have been described and might explain up to a third of neonatal-onset epilepsy syndromes previously included under the umbrella of Ohtahara syndrome and early myoclonic encephalopathy. In this chapter, we define the concept of genetic epilepsy and review the classification. Then, we review the most relevant monogenic neonatal-onset epilepsies, detail their underlying pathophysiologic mechanisms, and present their electroclinical phenotypes. We highlight that, in some cases, such as neonates with KCNQ2 or KCNT1 gene mutations, the early recognition of the electroclinical phenotype can lead to targeted diagnostic testing and precision medicine treatment, enabling the possibility of improved outcome.