Malus rootstocks affect copper accumulation and tolerance in trees by regulating copper mobility, physiological responses, and gene expression patterns

Advances of the mechanism for copper tolerance in plants

Copper (Cu) is a vital trace element necessary for plants growth and development. It acts as a co-factor for enzymes and plays a crucial role in various physiological processes, including photosynthesis, respiration, antioxidant systems, and hormone signaling transduction. However, excessive amounts of Cu can disrupt normal physiological metabolism, thus hindering plant growth, development, and reducing yield. In recent years, the widespread abuse of Cu-containing fungicides and industrial Cu pollution has resulted in significant soil contamination. Therefore, it is of utmost importance to uncover the adverse effects of excessive Cu on plant growth and delve into the molecular mechanisms employed by plants to counteract the stress caused by excessive Cu. Recent studies have confirmed the inhibitory effects of excess Cu on mineral nutrition, chlorophyll biosynthesis, and antioxidant enzyme activity. This review systematically outlines the ways in which plants tolerate excessive Cu stress and summarizes them into eight Cu-tolerance strategies. Furthermore, it highlights the necessity for further research to comprehend the molecular regulatory mechanisms underlying the responses to excessive Cu stress.

Transcription factor AtNAC002 positively regulates Cu toxicity tolerance in Arabidopsis thaliana

Copper (Cu) is an essential micronutrient for plant growth and development, but environmental Cu pollution has become increasingly severe, adversely affecting both ecosystems and crop productivity. In this study, we identified the AtNAC002 gene as a positive regulator of Cu toxicity in Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that AtNAC002 expression was induced by Cu excess, and the atnac002 mutant was Cu-sensitive, accumulating more Cu than the wild-type. Additionally, atnac002 mutants exhibit reduced activities of antioxidant enzymes (SOD, POD, and CAT), leading to increased levels of reactive oxygen species and malondialdehyde, which decrease Cu resistance. AtNAC002 might play a role in vacuolar and mitochondrial Cu compartmentalization by regulating genes involved in Cu detoxification, specifically COX11 and HCC1. Furthermore, AtNAC002 was implicated in flavone and flavanol biosynthesis, with the atnac002 mutant showing reduced flavonoid content. Our findings suggest that AtNAC002 is integral to the regulation of Cu toxicity tolerance in A. thaliana. This knowledge is critical for advancing our understanding and offers potential molecular breeding targets to enhance plant performance under Cu excess, which is significant for improving global food security and forest restoration.

Boron-mediated amelioration of copper toxicity in Citrus sinensis seedlings involved reduced concentrations of copper in leaves and roots and their cell walls rather than increased copper fractions in their cell walls

Little information is available on how boron (B) supplementation affects plant cell wall (CW) remodeling under copper (Cu) excess. 'Xuegan' (Citrus sinensis) seedlings were submitted to 0.5 or 350 µM Cu × 2.5 or 25 µM B for 24 weeks. Thereafter, we determined the concentrations of CW materials (CWMs) and CW components (CWCs), the degree of pectin methylation (DPM), and the pectin methylesterase (PME) activities and PME gene expression levels in leaves and roots, as well as the Cu concentrations in leaves and roots and their CWMs (CWCs). Additionally, we analyzed the Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) spectra of leaf and root CWMs. Our findings suggested that adding B reduced the impairment of Cu excess to CWs by reducing the Cu concentrations in leaves and roots and their CWMs and maintaining the stability of CWs, thereby improving leaf and root growth. Cu excess increased the Cu fractions in leaf and root pectin by decreasing DPM due to increased PME activities, thereby contributing to citrus Cu tolerance. FTIR and XRD indicated that the functional groups of the CW pectin, hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin could bind and immobilize Cu, thereby reducing Cu cytotoxicity in leaves and roots.

Citrus sinensis manganese tolerance: Insight from manganese-stimulated secretion of root exudates and rhizosphere alkalization

We used manganese (Mn)-tolerant 'Xuegan' (Citrus sinensis) seedlings as materials and examined the characterization of Mn uptake and Mn-activated-release of root exudates under hydroponic conditions. We observed that root and shoot Mn bioaccumulation factor (BCF) reduced with the increase of Mn supply, and that Mn transfer factor (Tf) reduced greatly as Mn supply increased from 0 to 500 μM, beyond which Tf slightly increased with increasing Mn supply, suggesting that Mn supply reduced the ability to absorb and accumulate Mn in roots and shoots, as well as root-to-shoot Mn translocation. Without Mn, roots alkalized the solution pH from 5.0 to above 6.2, while Mn supply reduced root-induced alkalization. As Mn supply increased from 0 to 2000 μM, the secretion of root total phenolics (TPs) increased, while the solution pH decreased. Mn supply did not alter the secretion of root total free amino acids, total soluble sugars, malate, and citrate. Mn-activated-release of TPs was inhibited by low temperature and anion channel inhibitors, but not by protein biosynthesis inhibitor. Using widely targeted metabolome, we detected 48 upregulated [35 upregulated phenolic compounds + 13 other secondary metabolites (SMs)] and three downregulated SMs, and 39 upregulated and eight downregulated primary metabolites (PMs). These findings suggested that reduced ability to absorb and accumulate Mn in roots and shoots and less root-to-shoot Mn translocation in Mn-toxic seedlings, rhizosphere alkalization, and Mn-activated-release of root exudates (especially phenolic compounds) contributed to the high Mn tolerance of C. sinensis seedlings.

Comparative transcriptome analysis of ectomycorrhizal fungus Pisolithus albus in response to individual and combined stress of copper and cadmium

An ectomycorrhizal fungus Pisolithus albus establishes the natural symbiosis with plant roots on extreme heavy metal (HM)-rich soil and enables their survival in toxic metal concentrations. Understanding P. albus key genes and pathways behind strong metal tolerance is crucial for its successful application in the rehabilitation of metal-contaminated barren lands. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze the whole transcriptome profile of P. albus under individual and combined metal stress of copper (Cu) and cadmium (Cd). At 480 µM Cu and 16 µM Cd toxic concentrations, P. albus has shown growth and survival and accumulated high metal (1.46 µg Cu and 1.13 µg Cd per mg of dry mycelia). The study found a stronger response of P. albus to single-metal stress in high concentration as compared to multi-metal stress in relatively lower concentration. Hence, the intensity of fungal response to HM stress is mainly determined by the metal concentration involved in stress. We have found a total of 11 pathways significantly associated with HM stress, among which amino acid, lipid, and carbohydrate metabolisms were highly affected. The functional enrichment of differentially expressed genes has shown the induced biosynthesis of arginine, melanin, metal chelating agents, membrane phospholipids, fatty acids, folate, pantothenate, ergothioneine, and other antioxidant agents; upregulation of zinc ion uptake, potassium transporters, and lysine degradation; and reduction of phosphatidylcholine degradation, incorrect protein folding, iron uptake, and potassium efflux as the top efficient tolerance mechanisms of P. albus against HM stress. The current study would contribute to understanding fungal HM tolerance and its further utilization in the bioremediation of metal-contaminated abandoned lands. The validation of RNA-sequencing analysis with RT-qPCR of selected genes showed the high credibility of the presented data.

Remediation of the microecological environment of heavy metal-contaminated soil with fulvic acid, improves the quality and yield of apple

The excessive application of chemical fertilizers and pesticides in apple orchards is responsible for high levels of manganese and copper in soil, and this poses a serious threat to soil health. We conducted a three-year field experiment to study the remediation effect and mechanism of fulvic acid on soil with excess manganese and copper. The exogenous application of fulvic acid significantly reduced the content of manganese and copper in soil and plants; increased the content of calcium; promoted the growth of apple plants; improved the fruit quality and yield of apple; increased the content of chlorophyll; increased the activity of superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, and catalase; and reduced the content of malondialdehyde. The number of soil culturable microorganisms, soil enzyme activity, soil microbial community diversity, and relative abundance of functional bacteria were increased, and the detoxification of the glutathione metabolism function was enhanced. The results of this study provide new insights that will aid the remediation of soil with excess manganese and copper using fulvic acid.

Effects of CuO nanoparticles in composted sewage sludge on rice-soil systems and their potential human health risks

The release of metal-based nanoparticles (MNPs) into sewage systems is worrisome due to their potential impact on crop-soil systems that are amended with sewage sludge. This study aimed to investigate the effects of copper oxide nanoparticles (CuO NPs) in composted sewage sludge (CSS) on rice-soil systems and to assess the health risks associated with consuming CuO NP-contaminated rice produced by CSS amendment. CSS was treated with three doses of CuO NPs, resulting in Cu levels below the sludge limits (1500 mg Cu kg-1) for reuse as a soil amendment. Results showed that CuO NPs in CSS at environmentally acceptable levels had no negative effect on rice growth and yield. In fact, they enhanced biomass production, tillering capacity, and soil fertility by increasing N and K levels in the soil. In addition, CuO NPs in CSS (450-1450 mg Cu kg-1) promoted the accumulation of macro- and micro-minerals in rice grains, thereby improving the nutritional value of rice. However, Cu contamination in CSS led to elevated levels of toxic metals, especially As, in rice grains, posing potential health risks to both adults and children. In the presence of higher CuO NPs contamination in CSS, the hazard quotient of As exceeded one, indicating an increased risks of toxic metal exposure via rice consumption. This study raises concerns about potential long-term threats to human health posed by MNPs contamination in CSS and highlights the need to reevaluate the permissible limits of hazardous elements in sludge to ensure its safe reuse in agriculture.

Physiological and Ultrastructural Responses to Excessive-Copper-Induced Toxicity in Two Differentially Copper Tolerant Citrus Species

Over-applied copper (Cu)-based agrochemicals are toxic to citrus trees. However, less information is available discussing the ultrastructural alterations in Cu-stressed citrus species. In the present study, seedlings of Citrus sinensis and Citrus grandis that differed in Cu-tolerance were sandy-cultured with nutrient solution containing 0.5 µM Cu (as control) or 300 µM Cu (as Cu toxicity) for 18 weeks. At the end of the treatments, the physiological parameters and ultrastructural features of the citrus leaves and roots were analyzed. The results indicate that Cu toxicity significantly decreased the ratio of shoot biomass to dry weight, the Cu translocation factor and the total chlorophyll of two citrus species. The anatomical and ultrastructural alterations verified that excessive Cu resulted in starch granules accumulated in the leaves and roots of the two citrus species. Under Cu toxicity, increased root flocculent precipitate and thickened root cell wall might reduce the Cu translocation from citrus roots to the shoots. Compared with C. sinensis, C. grandis maintained a relatively integral root cellular structure under Cu toxicity, which provided a structural basis for a higher Cu tolerance than C. sinensis. The present results increase our understanding of the physiological and ultrastructural responses to Cu toxicity in citrus species.

Characterization of copper-induced-release of exudates by Citrus sinensis roots and their possible roles in copper-tolerance

Copper (Cu) excess is often observed in old Citrus orchards. Little information is available on the characterization of Cu-induced-release of root exudates and their possible roles in plant Cu-tolerance. Using sweet orange [Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck cv. Xuegan] seedlings as materials, we investigated the impacts of 0, 0.5, 25, 150, 350, 550, 1000, 2000 or 5000 μM CuCl₂ (pH 4.8) on Cu uptake, root exudates [malate, citrate, total phenolics (TP), total soluble sugars (TSS) and total free amino acids (TFAA)], electrolyte leakage and malondialdehyde, and solution pH under hydroponic conditions; the time-course of root exudates and solution pH in response to Cu; and the impacts of protein synthesis and anion-channel inhibitors, and temperature on Cu-induced-secretion of root exudates and solution pH. About 70% of Cu was accumulated in 0 and 0.5 μM Cu-exposed roots, while over 97% of Cu was accumulated in ≥25 μM Cu-exposed roots. Without Cu, the seedlings could alkalize the solution pH from 4.8 to above 6.0. Cu-stimulated-secretion of root exudates elevated with the increment of Cu concentration from 0 to 1000 μM, then decreased or remained unchanged with the further increment of Cu concentration, while root electrolyte leakage and malondialdehyde (root-induced alkalization) increased (lessened) with the increment of Cu concentration from 0 to 5000 μM. Further analysis indicated that Cu-stimulated-secretion of root exudates was an energy-dependent process and could repressed by inhibitors, and that there was no discernible delay between the onset of exudate release and the addition of Cu. To conclude, both root-induced alkalization and Cu-stimulated-release of root exudates played a key role in sweet orange Cu-tolerance via increasing root Cu accumulation and reducing Cu uptake and phytotoxicity.

Grafting with an invasive Xanthium strumarium improves tolerance and phytoremediation of native congener X. sibiricum to cadmium/copper/nickel tailings

Invasive plants could play an important role in the restoration of tailings, but their invasiveness limits their practical application. In this study, the phytoremediation potentials and invasive risks of an exotic invasive plant (Xanthium strumarium, LT), a native plant (X. sibiricum, CR), and combinations of inoculations (EG, with CR as the scion and LT as the rootstock; SG, with CR as both the scion and rootstock) were evaluated on Cd/Cu/Ni tailings. LT rootstock has a stronger nutrient and metal transport capacity, compared with CR. EG not only had higher biomass and Cd/Cu/Ni accumulation, but also abundant rhizosphere microbial communities. Hydroponic and common garden experiments showed that the growth and metal enrichment characteristics of EG are not inherited by plant offspring, which reduces the risk of the biological diffusion in the process of using exotic species. Transcriptome analysis shows that a large number of differentially-expressed genes in EG leaves and roots are involved in phenylpropanoid biosynthesis, secondary metabolite generation, and signal transduction. The genes induced in EG leaves, including cyclic nucleotide-gated ion channel, calcium-binding protein, and WRKY transcription factor, were found to be differentially expressed compared to CR. The genes induced in EG roots, included phenylalanine ammonia-lyase, cinnamoyl-CoA reductase, caffeoyl-CoA O-methyltransferase, and beta-glucosidase. We speculate that lignin and glucosinolates play an important role in the metal accumulation and transportation of EG. The results demonstrate that grafting with LT not only improved CR tolerance and accumulation of Cd, Cu, and Ni, but also created a beneficial microbial environment for plants in tailings. More importantly, grafting with LT did not enhance the invasiveness of CR. Our results provide an example of the safe use of invasive plants in the restoration of Cd/Cu/Ni tailings.

A thorough observation of an ozonation catalyst under long-term practical operation: Deactivation mechanism and regeneration

Heterogeneous catalytic oxidation, as an efficient advanced treatment technology, has been gradually applied in industrial wastewater treatment. The fixed bed technique is one of the most popular catalytic ozonation methods. However, few studies have concentrated on the long-term operation effects on catalysts. In this study, we conducted long-term (~5 years) observations of the operation of the largest petrochemical wastewater treatment plant (treatment capacity 120,000 m³/d) with catalytic ozonation technology in China. A commercial catalyst, which uses Al₂O₃ pellets supporting copper oxide was applied in this plant. The results showed that the catalytic efficiency gradually decreased from 60.65% to 25.98% since 2018, and the ozone dosage to COD removal ratio (ozone/COD) also increased from 0.82 to 1.93 mg/mg as the running time continued. By means of the comparison and characterization of fresh catalyst and used catalyst, a "mucus layer" was formed by the adsorption of negatively charged extracellular polymeric substances on the positively charged catalyst surface and the interception of the catalyst layer. The mucus layer significantly reduced the catalytic efficiency by isolating ozone with catalytic active sites and releasing extra organic contaminants during the catalytic process resulting in 53.97% TOC increase in the batch test. Meanwhile, regeneration experiments revealed that the TOC removal efficiency was 4.76% and 43.48% in presence of washed catalysts and calcinated catalysts, respectively. Compared with the fresh catalyst, 73% of the catalytic activity was recovered for calcinated catalyst. Consequently, this study provides much practical information, showing positive effects on the promotion of catalytic ozonation application in actual wastewater treatment.

Adaptive Responses of Citrus grandis Leaves to Copper Toxicity Revealed by RNA-Seq and Physiology

Copper (Cu)-toxic effects on Citrus grandis growth and Cu uptake, as well as gene expression and physiological parameters in leaves were investigated. Using RNA-Seq, 715 upregulated and 573 downregulated genes were identified in leaves of C. grandis seedlings exposed to Cu-toxicity (LCGSEC). Cu-toxicity altered the expression of 52 genes related to cell wall metabolism, thus impairing cell wall metabolism and lowering leaf growth. Cu-toxicity downregulated the expression of photosynthetic electron transport-related genes, thus reducing CO₂ assimilation. Some genes involved in thermal energy dissipation, photorespiration, reactive oxygen species scavenging and cell redox homeostasis and some antioxidants (reduced glutathione, phytochelatins, metallothioneins, l-tryptophan and total phenolics) were upregulated in LCGSEC, but they could not protect LCGSEC from oxidative damage. Several adaptive responses might occur in LCGSEC. LCGSEC displayed both enhanced capacities to maintain homeostasis of Cu via reducing Cu uptake by leaves and preventing release of vacuolar Cu into the cytoplasm, and to improve internal detoxification of Cu by accumulating Cu chelators (lignin, reduced glutathione, phytochelatins, metallothioneins, l-tryptophan and total phenolics). The capacities to maintain both energy homeostasis and Ca homeostasis might be upregulated in LCGSEC. Cu-toxicity increased abscisates (auxins) level, thus stimulating stomatal closure and lowering water loss (enhancing water use efficiency and photosynthesis).