Human health impact due to arsenic contaminated rice and vegetables consumption in naturally arsenic endemic regions

Arsenic and cadmium availability and its removal in paddy farming areas

Arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) accumulation in rice grain is a global concern threatening food security and safety to the growing population. As and Cd are toxic non-essential elements poisonous to animal and human at higher levels. Its accumulation in agro-ecosystems pose a public health risk to consumers of agro-ecosystem products. Due to their hazards, As and Cd sources should be cleared, avoiding entering plants and the human body. As and Cd removal in soils and grains in agro-ecosystems has been conducted by various materials (natural and synthesized), however, there are little documentation on their contribution on As and Cd removal or reduction in rice grains. This identified knowledge gap necessitate a systematically review to understand efficiency and mechanisms of As and Cd availability reduction and removal in paddy farming areas through utilization of various synthetic and modified materials. To achieve this, published peer reviewed articles between 2010 and 2024 were collected from various database i.e., Science Direct, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Research Gate and analyzed its content in respect to As and Cd reduction and removal. Furthermore, collected data were re-analyzed to determine standardized mean differences (SMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Based on 96 studies with 228 observations involving Fe, Ca, Si, and Se-based materials were identified, it was found that application of Fe, Ca, Si, and Se-based materials potentially reduced As and Cd in rice grains among various study sites and across studies. Among the studied materials, Fe-based materials observed to be more efficient compared to other utilized materials. However, there little or no information on performance of materials when used in combination and how they can improve crop productivity and soil health, thus requiring further studies. Thus, this study confirm Fe, Ca, Si, and Se modified materials have significant potential to reduce As and Cd availability in paddy farming areas and rice grains, thus necessary effort must be made to ensure materials access and availability for farmers utilization in paddy fields to reduce As and Cd accumulation.

Simultaneous suppression of As mobilization and N2O emission from NH4+/As-rich paddy soils by combined nitrate and birnessite amendment

The environmental impacts of As mobilization and nitrous oxide (N2O) emission in flooded paddy soils are serious issues for food safety and agricultural greenhouse gas emissions. Several As immobilization strategies utilizing microbially-mediated nitrate reducing-As(III) oxidation (NRAO) and birnessite (δ-MnO2)-induced oxidation/adsorption have proven effective for mitigating As bioavailability in flooded paddy soils. However, several inefficiency and unsustainability issues still exist in these remediation approaches. In this study, the effects of a combined treatment of nitrate and birnessite were assessed for the simultaneous suppression of As(III) mobilization and N2O emission from flooded paddy soils. Microcosm incubations confirmed that the combined treatment achieved an effective suppression of As(III) mobilization and N2O emission, with virtually no As(T) released and at least a 87% decrease in N2O emission compared to nitrate treatment alone after incubating for 8 days. When nitrate and birnessite are co-amended to flooded paddy soils, the activities of denitrifying enzymes within the denitrification electron transport pathway were suppressed by MnO2. As a result, the majority of applied nitrate participated in nitrate-dependent microbial Mn(II) oxidation. The regenerated biogenetic MnO2 was available to facilitate subsequent cycles of As(III) immobilization and concomitant N2O emission suppression, sustainable remediation strategy. Moreover, the combined nitrate-birnessite amendment promoted the enrichment of Pseudomonas, Achromobacter and Cupriavidu, which are known to participate in the oxidation of As(III)/Mn(II). Our findings document strong efficacy for the combined nitrate/birnessite treatment as a remediation strategy to simultaneously mitigate As-pollution and N2O emission, thereby improving food safety and reducing greenhouse gas emissions from flooded paddy soils enriched with NH4+ and As.

The impact of rainwater-borne H2O2-induced Fenton process on root iron plaque formation and arsenic accumulation in rice

Arsenic (As) contamination is a global concern, especially in paddy fields, as it represents a significant pathway for As reaching in the food chain. This is primarily due to the high accumulation of As in rice grains, which is a staple food for billions of people globally. Here we investigated the effect of synthetic rainwater-borne hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)-induced Fenton oxidation process in paddy soil on As uptake and speciation in rice plants at different growth stages. Results showed that adding Fenton reagents significantly accelerated root iron (Fe) plaque formation, thereby enhancing As retention in soil. Arsenic accumulation in different rice plant parts followed the order: Fe plaque > root > stem > leaf. In rice grains, inorganic As and dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) were the major As species for the first and second-season crops. Notably, that the addition of Fenton reagents to paddy soil led to a significant reduction in As accumulation in rice grains. The synthetic rainwater-borne H2O2-induced Fenton reaction significantly promoted As(V) precipitation and decreased concentration of the dissolved As in soil porewater. The current study highlights that the H2O2-induced Fenton process is an important pathway decreasing As bioavailability in paddy soil and its accumulation in rice grain. The findings have implications for understanding As behavior in paddy fields receiving rainwater-borne H2O2 and for developing cost-effective remediation programs to reduce As accumulation in rice grains.

Mitigation of arsenic accumulation in rice (Oryza sativa L.) seedlings by oxygen nanobubbles in hydroponic cultures

Arsenic (As) is a toxic non-essential metal. Its accumulation in rice has not only seriously affected the growth of rice, but also poses a significant threat to human health. Many reports have been published to decrease the arsenic accumulation in the rice plant by various additives such as chemicals, fertilizers, adsorbents, microorganisms and analyzing the mechanism. Nanobubble is a new technology widely used in agriculture because of its long existence time and high mass transfer efficiency. However, a few studies have investigated the effect of nanobubbles on arsenic uptake in rice. This study investigated the effect of oxygen nanobubbles on the growth and uptake of As in rice. The oxygen nanobubbles could rupture the salinity of nutrients and produce the hydroxyl radical. The hydroxyl radical caused the oxidation of arsenic As(III) to As (V) and the oxidation of ferrous ions. At the same time, the oxidized iron adsorbing As (V) created the iron plaque on the rice roots to stop arsenic introduction into the rice plant. The results indicated that the treatment of oxygen nanobubbles increased rice biomass under As stress, while they increased the chlorophyll content and promoted plant photosynthesis. Oxygen nanobubbles reduced the As content in rice roots to 12.5% and shoots to 46.4%. In other words, it significantly decreased As accumulation in rice. Overall, oxygen nanobubbles mitigated the toxic effects of arsenic on rice and had the potential to reduce the accumulation of arsenic in rice.

Monthly variations of groundwater arsenic risk under future climate scenarios in 2081-2100

The seasonal variations of shallow groundwater arsenic have been widely documented. To gain insight into the monthly variations and mechanisms behind high groundwater arsenic and arsenic exposure risk in different climate scenarios, the monthly probability of high groundwater arsenic in Hetao Basin was simulated through random forest model. The model was based on arsenic concentrations obtained from 566 groundwater sample sites, and the variables considered included soil properties, climate, topography, and landform parameters. The results revealed that spatial patterns of high groundwater arsenic showed some fluctuations among months under different future climate scenarios. The probability of high total arsenic and trivalent arsenic was found to be elevated at the start of the rainy season, only to rapidly decrease with increasing precipitation and temperature. The probability then increased again after the rainy season. The areas with an increased probability of high total arsenic and trivalent arsenic and arsenic exposure risk under SSP126 were typically found in the high-arsenic areas of 2019, while those with decreased probabilities were observed in low-arsenic areas. Under SSP585, which involves a significant increase in precipitation and temperature, the probability of high total arsenic and trivalent arsenic and arsenic exposure risk was widely reduced. However, the probability of high total arsenic and trivalent arsenic and arsenic exposure risk was mainly observed in low-arsenic areas from SSP126 to SSP585. In conclusion, the consumption of groundwater for human and livestock drinking remains a threat to human health due to high arsenic exposure under future climate scenarios.

Arsenic level in groundwater and biological samples in Khanewal, Pakistan

Groundwater is the most valuable natural source in our earth's planet, being contaminated in various regions worldwide. Despite considerable research, there are scarce data regarding arsenic (As) levels in groundwater and its build-up in biological samples in Pakistan. The current investigation analyzed As contamination in four tehsils of District Khanewal (Kabirwala tehsil, Jahaniyan tehsil, Mian Channu tehsil, and Khanewal tehsil). For that, 123 groundwater samples, 19 animal milk samples, 20 human nails, and 20 human hair samples were collected from the study area. Arsenic concentration in groundwater was up to 51.8 µg/L with an average value of 7.2 µg/L. About 28 water samples (23%) had As contents > WHO limit and 38 samples (31%) > DEP-NJ limit. Low levels of As were detected in biological samples. Average As levels were 23 µg/L in the milk samples and 298 µg/kg in human hair. Arsenic contents were not detected in nail samples, except in one sample from Kabirwala tehsil. The maximum values of hazard quotient and cancer risk in District Khanewal were 4.9 and 0.0022, respectively. It is anticipated that long-term use of As-containing water may led to poisoning of humans in the study area, especially in Kabirwala. Therefore, it is necessary to monitor As contamination in the groundwater of Kabirwala tehsil to reduce the potential health hazards.

An evaluation of arsenic contamination status and its potential health risk assessment in villages of Nadia and North 24 Parganas, West Bengal, India

The present study was conducted to evaluate the arsenic (As) contamination and possible associated health hazards to exposed population in four villages of two districts (Nadia and North 24 Parganas) of West Bengal, India. The study included two villages each from Nadia (Jaguli and Kugacchi) and North 24 Parganas (Chamta and Byaspur) districts. Groundwater, surface water, soil, rice grains and rice-based food samples were collected from these villages. The results revealed the presence of As in high concentrations in groundwater (35.00 to 186.00 µg L^-1), surface water (30.00 to 61.00 µg L^-1), soil (46.17 to 66.00 mg kg^-1), rice grains (0.017 to 1.27 µg g^-1) and rice-based food products (0.012 to 0.40 µg g^-1). The maximum As levels were recorded in all types of samples collected from Kugacchi village. The rice grain samples included high-yielding and local varieties, and the level of As in high-yielding varieties was found to be higher (0.72 to 1.27 µg g^-1) than in local varieties (0.25 to 1.06 µg g^-1). The data of As concentrations was used for understanding the hazard quotient (HQ) and incremental lifetime cancer risk (ILCR) to the As-exposed population, and significant non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risks were revealed considering consumption of rice grains at 400 g per day. The study demonstrates the severity of As contamination in the surveyed villages, which may pose a hindrance to attainment of sustainable development goals (SDGs) by 2030 and proposes the implementation of requisite safety measures.

Rapid and sensitive determination of Se and heavy metals in foods using electrothermal vaporization inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry with a novel transportation system

Rapid, sensitive and simultaneous determination of trace multi-elements in various plant food samples such as grain, oilseed, vegetable and tea is always a challenge thus far. In this work, a rapid determination method for Se, Cd, As and Pb in food samples by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) using slurry sampling electrothermal vaporization (SS-ETV) was developed. To improve the analytical sensitivity and precision as well as eliminate the memory effect, a gas turbulator line and signal delay device (SDD) were for the first time designed for the graphite furnace (GF) ETV coupled with ICP-MS. The signal acquisition parameters of ICP-MS, ashing and vaporization conditions, and the flow rates of carrier gas and gas turbulator were investigated for Se, Cd, As and Pb in food samples. Under the optimized conditions, the limits of determination (LODs) for Se, Cd, As and Pb were 0.5 ng g^-1, 0.3 ng g^-1, 0.3 ng g^-1 and 0.6 ng g^-1, respectively; the limits of quantification (LOQs) for Se, Cd, As and Pb were 1.7 ng g^-1, 1.0 ng g^-1, 1.0 ng g^-1 and 1.9 ng g^-1, respectively; linearity (R²) in the range of 1 to 4,000 ng g^-1 was >0.999 using the standard addition method. This method was used to analyze 5 CRMs including rice, tea and soybeans, and the concentrations detected by this method were within the range of the certified values. The recoveries of Se, Cd, As and Pb in plant food matrices including grain, oilseed, celery, spinach, carrot and tea samples were 86-118% compared to the microwave digestion ICP-MS method; and the relative standard deviations (RSDs) were 1.2-8.9% for real food sample analysis, proving a good precision and accuracy for the simultaneous determination of multi-elements. The analysis time was less than 3 min, slurry preparation time < 5 min without sample digestion process. The proposed direct slurry sampling ICP-MS method is thus suitable for rapid and sensitive determination of Se, Cd, As and Pb in food samples with advantages such as simplicity, green and safety, as well as with a promising application potential in detecting more elements to protect food safety and human health.