A century of attempts to develop an effective tuberculosis vaccine: Why they failed?

Intravenous BCG-mediated protection against tuberculosis requires CD4+ T cells and CD8α+ lymphocytes

Tuberculosis (TB) is a major health burden worldwide despite widespread intradermal (ID) BCG vaccination in newborns. We previously demonstrated that changing the BCG route and dose from 5 × 105 CFUs ID to 5 × 107 CFUs i.v. resulted in prevention of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) infection and TB disease in highly susceptible nonhuman primates. Identifying immune mechanisms protection following i.v. BCG will facilitate development of more effective vaccines against TB. Here, we depleted lymphocyte subsets prior to and during Mtb challenge in i.v. BCG-vaccinated macaques to identify those necessary for protection. Depletion of adaptive CD4 T cells, but not adaptive CD8αβ T cells, resulted in loss of protection with increased Mtb burdens and dissemination, indicating that CD4 T cells are critical to i.v. BCG-mediated protection. Depletion of unconventional CD8α-expressing lymphocytes (NK cells, innate T cells, and CD4+CD8α+ double-positive T cells) abrogated protection in most i.v. BCG-immunized macaques, supporting further investigation into which of these cell subsets contribute to protection after vaccination.

Tuberculosis vaccine - A timely analysis of the drawbacks for the development of novel vaccines

The BCG vaccine, Bacille Calmette Guerin, holds the distinction of being the most widely administered vaccine. Remarkably, a century has passed since its discovery; however, puzzlingly, questions persist regarding the effectiveness of the immune response it triggers. After years of diligent observation, it has been deduced that BCG imparts immunity primarily to a specific age group, namely children. This prompts a significant query: the rationale behind BCG's limited efficacy against TB in particular age groups and populations remains elusive. Beyond vaccinations, drug therapy has emerged as an alternative route for TB prevention. Nonetheless, this approach faces challenges in the contemporary landscape, marked by the emergence of new instances of MDR-TB and XDR-TB, compounded by the financial burden of treatment. It's noteworthy that BCG remains the sole WHO-approved vaccine for TB. This comprehensive review delves into several aspects, encompassing the immune response during infection, the shortcomings of BCG in conferring immunity, and the various factors contributing to its limitations. Within this discourse, we explore potential explanations for the observed deficiencies of the BCG vaccine and consider how these insights could catalyze the development of future vaccines. The current landscape of novel vaccine development for TB is illuminated, including a spotlight on the latest vaccine candidates.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis and host interactions in the manifestation of tuberculosis

The final step of epigenetic processes is changing the gene expression in a new microenvironment in the body, such as neuroendocrine changes, active infections, oncogenes, or chemical agents. The case of tuberculosis (TB) is an outcome of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M.tb) and host interaction in the manifestation of active and latent TB or clearance. This comprehensive review explains and interprets the epigenetics findings regarding gene expressions on the host-pathogen interactions in the development and progression of tuberculosis. This review introduces novel insights into the complicated host-pathogen interactions, discusses the challengeable results, and shows the gaps in the clear understanding of M.tb behavior. Focusing on the biological phenomena of host-pathogen interactions, the epigenetic changes, and their outcomes provides a promising future for developing effective TB immunotherapies when converting gene expression toward appropriate host immune responses gradually becomes attainable. Overall, this review may shed light on the dark sides of TB pathogenesis as a life-threatening disease. Therefore, it may support effective planning and implementation of epigenetics approaches for introducing proper therapies or effective vaccines.

Systems genetics uncover new loci containing functional gene candidates in Mycobacterium tuberculosis-infected Diversity Outbred mice

Mycobacterium tuberculosis infects two billion people across the globe, and results in 8-9 million new tuberculosis (TB) cases and 1-1.5 million deaths each year. Most patients have no known genetic basis that predisposes them to disease. Here, we investigate the complex genetic basis of pulmonary TB by modelling human genetic diversity with the Diversity Outbred mouse population. When infected with M. tuberculosis, one-third develop early onset, rapidly progressive, necrotizing granulomas and succumb within 60 days. The remaining develop non-necrotizing granulomas and survive longer than 60 days. Genetic mapping using immune and inflammatory mediators; and clinical, microbiological, and granuloma correlates of disease identified five new loci on mouse chromosomes 1, 2, 4, 16; and three known loci on chromosomes 3 and 17. Further, multiple positively correlated traits shared loci on chromosomes 1, 16, and 17 and had similar patterns of allele effects, suggesting these loci contain critical genetic regulators of inflammatory responses to M. tuberculosis. To narrow the list of candidate genes, we used a machine learning strategy that integrated gene expression signatures from lungs of M. tuberculosis-infected Diversity Outbred mice with gene interaction networks to generate scores representing functional relationships. The scores were used to rank candidates for each mapped trait, resulting in 11 candidate genes: Ncf2, Fam20b, S100a8, S100a9, Itgb5, Fstl1, Zbtb20, Ddr1, Ier3, Vegfa, and Zfp318. Although all candidates have roles in infection, inflammation, cell migration, extracellular matrix remodeling, or intracellular signaling, and all contain single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), SNPs in only four genes (S100a8, Itgb5, Fstl1, Zfp318) are predicted to have deleterious effects on protein functions. We performed methodological and candidate validations to (i) assess biological relevance of predicted allele effects by showing that Diversity Outbred mice carrying PWK/PhJ alleles at the H-2 locus on chromosome 17 QTL have shorter survival; (ii) confirm accuracy of predicted allele effects by quantifying S100A8 protein in inbred founder strains; and (iii) infection of C57BL/6 mice deficient for the S100a8 gene. Overall, this body of work demonstrates that systems genetics using Diversity Outbred mice can identify new (and known) QTLs and functionally relevant gene candidates that may be major regulators of complex host-pathogens interactions contributing to granuloma necrosis and acute inflammation in pulmonary TB.

CD4 T cells and CD8α+ lymphocytes are necessary for intravenous BCG-induced protection against tuberculosis in macaques

Tuberculosis (TB) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide despite widespread intradermal (ID) BCG vaccination in newborns. We previously demonstrated that changing the route and dose of BCG vaccination from 5×105 CFU ID to 5×107 CFU intravenous (IV) resulted in prevention of infection and disease in a rigorous, highly susceptible non-human primate model of TB. Identifying the immune mechanisms of protection for IV BCG will facilitate development of more effective vaccines against TB. Here, we depleted select lymphocyte subsets in IV BCG vaccinated macaques prior to Mtb challenge to determine the cell types necessary for that protection. Depletion of CD4 T cells or all CD8α expressing lymphoycytes (both innate and adaptive) resulted in loss of protection in most macaques, concomitant with increased bacterial burdens (~4-5 log10 thoracic CFU) and dissemination of infection. In contrast, depletion of only adaptive CD8αβ+ T cells did not significantly reduce protection against disease. Our results demonstrate that CD4 T cells and innate CD8α+ lymphocytes are critical for IV BCG-induced protection, supporting investigation of how eliciting these cells and their functions can improve future TB vaccines.

Live Attenuated Vaccines against Tuberculosis: Targeting the Disruption of Genes Encoding the Secretory Proteins of Mycobacteria

Tuberculosis (TB), a chronic infectious disease affecting humans, causes over 1.3 million deaths per year throughout the world. The current preventive vaccine BCG provides protection against childhood TB, but it fails to protect against pulmonary TB. Multiple candidates have been evaluated to either replace or boost the efficacy of the BCG vaccine, including subunit protein, DNA, virus vector-based vaccines, etc., most of which provide only short-term immunity. Several live attenuated vaccines derived from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) and BCG have also been developed to induce long-term immunity. Since Mtb mediates its virulence through multiple secreted proteins, these proteins have been targeted to produce attenuated but immunogenic vaccines. In this review, we discuss the characteristics and prospects of live attenuated vaccines generated by targeting the disruption of the genes encoding secretory mycobacterial proteins.

Systems genetics uncover new loci containing functional gene candidates in Mycobacterium tuberculosis-infected Diversity Outbred mice

Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the bacillus that causes tuberculosis (TB), infects 2 billion people across the globe, and results in 8-9 million new TB cases and 1-1.5 million deaths each year. Most patients have no known genetic basis that predisposes them to disease. We investigated the complex genetic basis of pulmonary TB by modelling human genetic diversity with the Diversity Outbred mouse population. When infected with M. tuberculosis, one-third develop early onset, rapidly progressive, necrotizing granulomas and succumb within 60 days. The remaining develop non-necrotizing granulomas and survive longer than 60 days. Genetic mapping using clinical indicators of disease, granuloma histopathological features, and immune response traits identified five new loci on mouse chromosomes 1, 2, 4, 16 and three previously identified loci on chromosomes 3 and 17. Quantitative trait loci (QTLs) on chromosomes 1, 16, and 17, associated with multiple correlated traits and had similar patterns of allele effects, suggesting these QTLs contain important genetic regulators of responses to M. tuberculosis. To narrow the list of candidate genes in QTLs, we used a machine learning strategy that integrated gene expression signatures from lungs of M. tuberculosis-infected Diversity Outbred mice with gene interaction networks, generating functional scores. The scores were then used to rank candidates for each mapped trait in each locus, resulting in 11 candidates: Ncf2, Fam20b, S100a8, S100a9, Itgb5, Fstl1, Zbtb20, Ddr1, Ier3, Vegfa, and Zfp318. Importantly, all 11 candidates have roles in infection, inflammation, cell migration, extracellular matrix remodeling, or intracellular signaling. Further, all candidates contain single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), and some but not all SNPs were predicted to have deleterious consequences on protein functions. Multiple methods were used for validation including (i) a statistical method that showed Diversity Outbred mice carrying PWH/PhJ alleles on chromosome 17 QTL have shorter survival; (ii) quantification of S100A8 protein levels, confirming predicted allele effects; and (iii) infection of C57BL/6 mice deficient for the S100a8 gene. Overall, this work demonstrates that systems genetics using Diversity Outbred mice can identify new (and known) QTLs and new functionally relevant gene candidates that may be major regulators of granuloma necrosis and acute inflammation in pulmonary TB.

Development of multi-epitope based subunit vaccine against Mycobacterium Tuberculosis using immunoinformatics approach

The etiological agent of tuberculosis (TB), Mycobacterium tuberculosis, is a deadly pathogen that adapts to thrive within the host. Since 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic has had colossal health, societal, and economic consequences, which have affected the reporting of new incidences and mortality cases of TB. As per the WHO 2022 report, 10.6 million people were diagnosed with TB, and 1.6 million died worldwide. The increase in resistant strains of tuberculosis is making it more burdensome to reach the End TB strategy. A reliable and efficient TB vaccine that may avert both primary infection and recurrence of latent TB in adults and adolescents is of the utmost importance. In this study, we used computational techniques to predict the ability of HLA molecules to display epitopes for six TB proteins (PPE68, PE_PGRS17, EspC, LDT4, RpfD, and RpfC) to design the multi-epitope subunit vaccine. From the aimed proteins, the potential B-cell, helper T lymphocyte (HTL), and cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) epitopes were predicted and linked together with LPA adjuvant, and the vaccine was designed. The vaccine's physicochemical analysis demonstrates that it is non-allergic, non-toxic, and antigenic. Then, the vaccine structure was predicted, improved, and verified to yield the optimal structure. The developed vaccine's binding mechanism with distinct immunogenic receptors (Tlr2 and MHC-II) was assessed utilizing molecular docking. The molecular dynamic simulation and MMPBSA analysis were performed to comprehend the complexes' dynamics and stability. The immune simulation was utilized to anticipate the vaccine's immunogenic attributes. In silico cloning was employed to demonstrate the efficient expression of the designed vaccine in E. coli as a host. Moreover, in vitro and in vivo animal testing is required to determine the efficacy of the in silico developed vaccine.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.