Incidence and morphometry of sellar bridges and related foramina in dry skulls: Their significance in middle cranial fossa surgery

Prevalence and Morphology of Ossified Caroticoclinoid Ligament: An Updated Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

Background: The caroticoclinoid ligament (CCL) is between the anterior and middle clinoid processes. The ligament can be variably ossified, creating the caroticoclinoid bar or foramen (CCF). When this variant occurs, it encircles the clinoidal segment of the internal carotid artery (ICA) and can cause morphological changes. The present evidence-based systematic review with meta-analysis aims to describe the CCL ossification variability (complete, incomplete, and contact), their pooled prevalence, and the pooled mean of the CCF. Methods: The systematic review was performed using four online databases to identify articles that had reported CCF prevalence by its morphology, according to the latest guidelines. The meta-analysis used an R programming software with the "meta" and "metafor" packages. The study protocol was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42024623914). Results: The systematic review retrieved a total of 49 studies that had reported on ossified CCL morphological variants. The pooled prevalence of the CCL ossification (irrespective of its morphology) was estimated at 17.47% (95% CI: 14.01-21.23). The most common morphology was the incomplete type, with a pooled prevalence of 10.08% (95% CI: 7.21-13.35). The complete CCF type was calculated at 6.44% (95% CI: 5.30-7.67). The pooled mean diameter of the CCF was 5.00 mm. The geographical distribution, type of study, side, sample size, and sexes did not influence the estimated pooled prevalence. Conclusions: The current study systematically reviewed the prevalence and morphology of CCL ossification. Various subgroup analyses were performed to investigate the possible factors affecting it. This variant has adequate clinical significance due to its close relationship with the ICA.

The Coexistence of Carotico-Clinoid Foramen and Interclinoidal Osseous Bridge: An Anatomo-Radiological Study With Surgical Implications

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The coexistence of complete carotico-clinoid bridge (CCB), an ossification between the anterior (ACP) and the middle clinoid (MCP), and an interclinoidal osseous bridge (ICB), between the ACP and the posterior clinoid (PCP), represents an uncommonly reported anatomic variant. If not adequately recognized, osseous bridges may complicate open or endoscopic surgery, along with the pneumatization of the ACP, especially when performing anterior or middle clinoidectomies.

METHODS

According to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses for Scoping Reviews guidelines, a systematic scoping review was conducted up to June 5, 2023. PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science databases, and additional citations were searched. Two hundred high-resolution noncontrast computed tomography (CT) scans (400 sides) and 41 dry skulls (82 sides) were analyzed to identify the different morphology of sellar bridges, focusing on the coexistence of complete CCF and ICB. Two embalmed latex-injected heads with coexisting CCF and ICB were dissected step-by-step to show the anatomic relationship with the surrounding structures from an endoscopic and microscopic perspective.

RESULTS

A total of 19 articles were included. The review identified a complete CCF and ICB rate ranging from 4.92% to 6.3%. The analysis of 200 CT scans revealed a rate of coexistence in 4% of the cases, all encountered in White women. Two different types of interclinoid bridges were identified based on the degree of bone mineralization. Both endoscopic and macroscopic step-by-step dissections highlighted variability in morphology and consistency of the sellar bridges and the close relationship with the cavernous sinus neurovascular structures.

CONCLUSION

The coexistence of CCF and ICB is an anatomic variation found in 4% of cases. Preoperative knowledge of the degree of mineralization and its relationship with surrounding structures is essential to performing safe surgery and minimizing cranial nerve and vascular injuries. Preoperative high-resolution CT scans can adequately identify these anatomic variations.

The Morphological Stenosis Pattern of the Caroticoclinoid Foramen

Background: The caroticoclinoid bar (CCB) or caroticoclinoid foramen (CCF) represents a well-described ossified variant of the skull base. It corresponds to an osseous bridge (resulting after homonymous ligament ossification) between the anterior and middle clinoid processes (ACPs and MCPs) surrounding the internal carotid artery (ICA)'s cavernous segment. Although extensive research has been performed on this clinically significant entity, only a few studies have been conducted on its effect on the ICA. The current study on dried skulls, using computed tomography (CT) and computed tomography angiography (CTA) scans, aimed to investigate the CCB's presence and potential morphological stenosis patterns. Methods: One hundred (100) dried adult skulls and one hundred sixty (160) skulls from CT scans of patients were obtained (a total of 520 observations). To further calculate the ICA diameter (at the ACP-MCP region) and correlate the resulting dimeters with all potential morphological stenosis patterns of the CCB, thirty (30) CTAs of patients free of the variant were selected. Results: Concerning the osseous pattern morphology, of the total of 520 sides, the CCB was identified in 17.1%, the complete variant (creating a caroticoclinoid foramen-CCF) was calculated in 11.5%, and the incomplete one was calculated in 5.6%. No side, sex, or age impact was identified for the CCB presence. Concerning the ICA dimensions, its diameter was calculated to be between 4 and 5 mm. Thus, we observed three morphological stenosis patterns of the CCF. A low-risk pattern of stenosis (>5 mm diameter) was observed in 40 CCFs (44.9%), an intermediate risk of stenosis (4-5 mm diameter) in 38 CCFs (38.2%), and a high risk of stenosis (<4 mm diameter) was depicted in 15 CCFs (16.8%). Conclusions: In the present study, we investigated the CCF presence and potential morphological stenosis patterns by calculating and correlating the ICA diameter. In 16.8% of the current sample with CCFs (irrespective of their morphology), we observed that the ICA is probably at a high risk of compression. Radiologists and neurosurgeons intervening in the area should preoperatively diagnose the possibility of ICA compression in this area.

Determination of the Surgical Landmarks for the Anterior and Middle Cranial Fossa in Dry Skulls With the Photography System, Cadavers and 3-Dimensional Computed Tomography

The present paper was designed to analyze the dimensions of such important bony structures and surgical landmarks, which are used by many clinicians in many surgical interventions, in dry skull, cadaver, and healthy subjects on computed tomography (CT) images, and to determine whether there is a significant difference between these methods, and to obtain reference values from 3 different methods. Eight cadavers and 16 dry skulls and 100 three-dimensional (3D) CT images were studied. Necessary permissions for the study were obtained from Ethics Comittee. The 16 parameters were measured with an electronic digital caliper accurate 0.01 mm (LCD Digital Vernier Dial Microcaliper (INCA, DCLA-0605, 0.6-150 mm, USA). Also, the images obtained were transferred to the 3D Slicer (version 5.6.2) software program. Eight cadavers and 16 dry skulls of Turkish adults were unknown age and sex, whereas the mean age of females and males on CT images were 31.63±11.23 and 33.70±13.34 years, respectively. All values of the surgical landmarks for the anterior and middle cranial fossa obtained from cadavers, dry skulls, and 3D CT subjects (except length of lesser wing, anterior clinoid lengths for 2 sides, and width for right side) were statistically significant between 3 groups (P<0.05). This paper was conducted for the morphometric analysis of the specific regions of the anterior cranial fossa (ACF), and middle cranial fossa (MCF), which are used in neurosurgical procedures This detailed anatomic and radiologic reference values will be an extremely important source in the planning of both clinical and surgical approaches for neurosurgeon, anatomist, and radiologists.

Evaluation of Sella Turcica Morphology and Morphometry Based on Gender and Age in Our Population Using Computed Tomography

In this study, it was aimed to determine the reference values for the healthy Turkish population by evaluating the age-related changes in the morphology and morphometry of Sella Turcica (ST) and the relationship with the body mass index. In addition, it has been investigated whether the morphology and morphometry of this structure vary in diabetes mellitus (DM) patients. The study group was consisted of a total of 524 individuals (266 females and 258 males) (426 healthy and 48 with DM) between the ages of 1 and 80, who applied to the Department of Radiology between January 2018 and February 2021. Axial brain computed tomography scans which have no pathology in ST were retrospectively examined. The ST length (STL), height (STH), diameter (STD), processus clinoideus anterior right-left (PCA R_L ), processus clinoideus posterior right-left (PCP R_L ) did not differ significantly in healthy individuals and individuals with DM ( P >0.05). When the ST morphology according to the ST shape classification performed by Meyer Marcotti and colleagues and Axellson and colleagues was evaluated, it was observed that there was no statistically significant difference between the 2 groups ( P >0.05). There was a significant difference in STL, STD values ( P <0.05), however, there was no difference in STH, PCA R_L , PCP R_L values between genders ( P >0.05). While the distance between STL, STD, PCA R_L showed a significant difference between the decades in all groups, there was no significant difference in the STH, PCP R_L in both classifications ( P >0.05). When the relationship between the parameters and body mass index was evaluated, STL, STD, PCA R_L showed a significant difference between the groups ( P <0.05). Detailed knowledge of the ST anatomy will be helpful in terms of early diagnosis of diseases that may be related and guiding surgical interventions in this region.

A morphological study on the sphenoid bone ligaments' ossification pattern

PURPOSE

The sphenoid bone (SB) extracranial ligaments (ECRLs) are the pterygoalar and pterygospinous ligaments (PTAL and PTSL) that are located at the SB lateral pterygoid plate, and inferior to the foramen ovale (FO). Their ossification may affect the mandibular nerve's distribution. The intracranial ligaments' (ICRLs) ossification (the caroticoclinoid ligament-CCLL, the anterior and posterior interclinoid ligaments-AICLL and PICLL) may impede the approaches to the sella. This study highlights the incidence of the ossified ECRLs and ICRLs location, their type (partial, or complete), considering laterality, gender, age, and ligaments' simultaneous presence.

METHODS

The sample consisted of 156 Greek adult dried skulls of both genders and variable age.

RESULTS

Ossified ligaments were identified in 57.05%, predominantly extracranially (42.31%, P = 0.003). ECRLs were predominantly identified unilaterally (30.13%, P < 0.001). The majority of the ossified ICRLs were predominantly identified in male skulls (31.1%, P = 0.048) and the majority of the ECRLs (52.8%, P = 0.028) were predominantly identified at the age of 60 years and above. The PTAL was the most ossified (32.69%), followed by the CCLL (24.36%), the PTSL (16.03%), the PICLL (6.41%), and the AICLL (4.49%).

CONCLUSIONS

Detailed knowledge of the SB morphology and ligaments' ossification extent is essential to improve the technique of the FO percutaneous approach, and sellar approaches, to minimize complications.

Osseous Bridges of the Sphenoid Bone: Frequency, Bilateral and Sex Distribution

Sellar (caroticoclinoid and interclinoid), pterygospinous and pterygoalar bridges are osseous bars of the sphenoid bone, which enclose additional foramina in the skull base and could cause entrapment of nerves, occlusion of vessels and obstruction of surgical corridors. This study aimed to investigate the frequency of sphenoid bone bridges in Bulgarians and to assess the bilateral and sex differences in their distribution. This study was performed on head CT scans of 315 Bulgarians, 148 males and 167 females. The sellar bridges were the most common type of sphenoid bridging; particularly the caroticoclinoid bridge. The pterygospinous bridge was a relatively common finding and the pterygoalar bridge was the most infrequent type of bridging. The total frequency of sellar bridges did not differ significantly between both sides and sexes. The pterygospinous bridge did not indicate significant bilateral differences but showed considerable sex differences concerning the left-side occurrence, which was significantly higher in the male series. There were no considerable bilateral and sex differences in the distribution of the pterygoalar bridging. There were no significant correlations between the different types of sphenoid bone bridges, but each type of bridging showed significant positive correlations between the right and left side co-occurrence in males and females.

The effect of morphological variability of Dorello's canal on surgical procedures - a review

Dorello's canal is an arched structure of bone-fibrous character located in the petroclival venous confluence atop the petrosal bone in the petroclival region. It is bordered by the petrosphenoidal ligament, the petrous part of the temporal bone and the lateral border of the upper part of clivus. Its content in the vast majority of variants comprises the abducens nerve, the inferior petrosal sinus, the venous drainage and the dorsal meningeal artery or its medial branch. With the development of microsurgical techniques, this area has gained huge clinical importance, mainly concerning the order in which the above-mentioned elements (especially the position of the abducens nerve) are arranged in relation to each other. These structures appear in different variant forms and necessitate an individual clinical approach. The main purpose of this review is to present condensed information about possible intercorrelations among them and to indicate, on the basis of the available literature and research, possible surgical approaches and the need to consider the variability when treatments in this region are planned.

Review of the Petroclinoid Ligament

An ossified left petroclinoid ligament was found during routine dissection of the skull base in an adult male cadaver. The petroclinoid ligament is clinically and surgically important given its anatomical relationships to cranial nerves III, V, and VI, so its ossification is a risk factor for injuries due to trauma, increased intracranial pressure, and vascular and tumor compression resulting in abducens and oculomotor palsies. The causes of petroclinoid ligament ossification are yet to be completely elucidated although several reports have associated them with age-related and physiological processes. Assessing the integrity of the petroclinoid ligament is important during skull base surgical interventions to avoid postoperative complications. Therefore, this paper reviews the petroclinoid ligament and its variation, the ossified petroclinoid ligament.

Surgical Relevance of Pediatric Anterior Clinoid Process Maturation for Anterior Skull Base Approaches

BACKGROUND

Removal of the anterior clinoid process (ACP) can expand anterior skull base surgical corridors. ACP development and anatomical variations are poorly defined in children.

OBJECTIVE

To perform a morphometric analysis of the ACP during pediatric maturation.

METHODS

Measurements of ACP base thickness (ACP-BT), midpoint thickness (ACP-MT), length (ACP-L), length from optic strut to ACP tip (ACP-OS), pneumatization (ACP-pneumo), and the presence of an ossified carotico-clinoid ligament (OCCL) or interclinoid ligament (OIL) were made from high-resolution computed-tomography scans from 60 patients (ages 0-3, 4-7, 8-11 12-15, 16-18, and >18 yr). Data were analyzed by laterality, sex, and age groups using t-tests and linear regression.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in ACP parameters by laterality or sex, and no significant growth in ACP-BT or ACP-MT during development. From ages 0-3 yr to adult, mean ACP-L increased 49%, from 7.7 to 11.5 mm. The majority of ACP-L growth occurred in 2 phases between ages 0-3 to 8-11 and ages 16-18 to adult. Conversely, ACP-OS was stable from ages 0-3 to 8-11 but increased by 63% between ages 8-11 to adult. Variations in ACP morphology (OCCL/OIL/ACP-pneumo) were found in 15% (9/60) of scans. OCCL and OIL occurred in patients as young as 3 yrs, whereas ACP-pneumo was not seen in patients younger than 11 yrs.

CONCLUSION

The ACP demonstrates stable thickness and a complex triphasic elongation and remodeling pattern with development, the understanding of which may facilitate removal in patients <12. Clinically relevant ACP anatomic variations can occur at any age.

The Petroclinoid Ligament: Its Morphometrics, Relationships, Variations, and Suggestion for New Terminology

The anatomy and definition of the petroclinoid ligament (PCL) and its relationship with the abducens nerve are variably described. The goal of this study was to clarify the anatomy of the PCL and better elucidate its relationship with the abducens nerve. Thirty-six sides from 18 fresh-frozen adult cadaveric heads were used in this study. Specimens were all Caucasian and derived from 10 males and 8 females. The mean age at death was 79 years. Dissection of the PCL and abducens nerve was performed using a surgical microscope. The anterior and posterior attachments of the PCL, and position of the abducens nerve were noted. Subsequently, the width, thickness, and length of the ligament, and diameter of the abducens nerve were measured. Thirty-one sides (86.1%) were found to have a PCL, on two sides (5.6%), the PCL was ossified, and on three sides (8.3%), the PCL was absent. The width, thickness, and length of the PCL ranged from 0.54 to 3.39, 0.07 to 0.49, and 3.27 to 17.85 mm, respectively. No PCL had an anterior attachment onto the posterior clinoid process but rather, the clivus. Therefore, based on our findings, the PCL would be better described as the petroclival ligament.

Skull base ligamentous mineralisation: evaluation using computed tomography and a review of the clinical relevance

Objectives

To determine the frequency, morphologic and demographic characteristics, and clinical relevance of the mineralisation of six skull base ligaments (interclinoid, caroticoclinoid, petrosphenoid, posterior petroclinoid, pterygospinous, and pterygoalar).

Methods

This is a retrospective review of 240 CT scans of the paranasal sinuses (ages 6–80 years). A limited systematic review was performed primarily using Embase and Medline databases.

Results

Ligamentous mineralisation was well delineated on CT and occurred at ≥ 1 location in 58.3% of patients. There was a nonsignificant trend towards a greater incidence with advancing age. The interclinoid and posterior petroclinoid ligaments were most commonly mineralised (22.1% and 18.3%, respectively); the petrosphenoid and pterygoalar ligaments were least frequently mineralised (10.8% and 6.3%, respectively). The mean age of patients with posterior petroclinoid mineralisation was significantly greater than those with interclinoid and petrosphenoid mineralisation and was not seen in patients aged 6–20 years. The literature review highlighted the clinically relevant potential for mineralised ligaments to cause barriers to surgical access (e.g. to the foramen ovale), increase the risk of neurovascular injury during surgery at the skull base (e.g. during anterior clinoidectomy), and predispose to neural impingement.

Conclusions

Skull base ligamentous mineralisation is commonly encountered on CT imaging. Given the potentially significant clinical implications, an understanding of the morphological appearances is of importance to those planning interventions at the skull base. To the authors’ knowledge, this study is the first to comprehensively evaluate such a wide range of skull base ligaments using CT. For some ligaments, the incidence on CT has not been previously described.

The carotico-clinoid bar: A systematic review and meta-analysis of its prevalence and potential implications in cerebrovascular and skull base surgery

BACKGROUND

The caroticoclinoid bar (CCB) is implicated in both transcranial and endonasal surgery. Its morphology reflects differences in the microsurgical anatomy of the parasellar area while its manipulation during an anterior or middle clinoidectomy can result in ICA injury. Although safe surgical access to the paraclinoidal region is related to adjustment of surgical technique according to CCB anatomical variants, a review of the literature indicates the lack of a systematic assortment of published data regarding the prevalence of this variable structure. As such the topic needs further investigation.

OBJECTIVE

To systematically review and document the prevalence of the CCB and its anatomic variations.

METHODS

3 Databases were systematically reviewed according to the PRISMA statement through August of 2018 for the identification of relevant studies.

RESULTS

A total of 27 articles (7,521 subjects/specimens, 14,449 sides) were included in this meta-analysis. The overall pooled prevalence of the CCB was 32.6% (95% CI 26.6% - 38.8%) when measured over subjects/specimens and 23.6% (95% CI 19.7% - 27.6%) when measured over sides. Overall prevalence of the CCB reported from imaging studies was 23.1% (95% CI 8.9% - 41.4%) when measured over subjects/specimens and 18.7% (95% CI 12.6% - 25.7%) when measured over sides. Moreover, the CCB was slightly more prevalent (p = 0.050), on the right side.

CONCLUSION

Our results indicate considerable CCB prevalence rates and that imaging studies report lower prevalence rates. Although meticulous preoperative investigation is mandatory, surgeons carrying for patients with parasellar pathologies should always be vigilant about this structure.

Incidence and morphometry of caroticoclinoid foramina in Greek dry human skulls

BACKGROUND

Ossification of the caroticoclinoid ligament (CCL) and formation of a caroticoclinoid foramen (CCF) may impose significant risk to neurosurgeons by impeding mobilization of the cavernous segment of the internal carotid artery. Although safe surgical access to the clinoidal space is related to understanding the CCF anatomical and ethnic variants, there remains a paucity of studies of the morphology and bony relationships. The current study provides a systematic morphological and morphometric analysis of the CCF, the ossification of the CCL extending between the anterior and middle clinoid processes, and their relations in a Greek population.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The incidence of unilateral and bilateral CCF, types (complete, incomplete, and contact) of ossified CCLs, and foramina diameter according to side and gender were determined in 76 Greek adult dry skulls. Findings were correlated with the morphology of optic strut (OS) (presulcal, sulcal, postsulcal, and asymmetric).

RESULTS

A CCF was detected in 74% of the specimens. The majority of skulls (51.4%) had bilateral CCF, whereas 22.3% of the skulls had unilateral foramina. Incomplete CCF were observed in 69.3%, complete in 19.8%, and contact type in 10.9%. The mean CCF diameter was 0.55 ± 0.07 cm on the left and 0.54 ± 0.08 cm on the right side. Side symmetry existed, although there were no significant differences according to gender. The CCF were more prominent in skulls with a sulcal type of OS.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study augment the current knowledge on the morphology of key anatomical landmarks, CCF, and CCL ossification in the sellar area, indicating population differences. A significant side asymmetry in caroticoclinoid osseous bridging and foramina is highlighted. These findings are necessary for a safe surgical access to the clinoidal area.