Novel TRPV4 mutation in a large Chinese family with congenital distal spinal muscular atrophy, skeletal dysplasia and scaly skin

Combined clinical, structural and cellular studies discriminate pathogenic and benign TRPV4 variants

Dominant mutations in the calcium-permeable ion channel TRPV4 (transient receptor potential vanilloid 4) cause diverse and largely distinct channelopathies, including inherited forms of neuromuscular disease, skeletal dysplasias and arthropathy. Pathogenic TRPV4 mutations cause gain of ion channel function and toxicity that can be rescued by small molecule TRPV4 antagonists in cellular and animal models, suggesting that TRPV4 antagonism could be therapeutic for patients. Numerous variants in TRPV4 have been detected with targeted and whole exome/genome sequencing, but for the vast majority, their pathogenicity remains unclear. Here, we used a combination of clinical information and experimental structure-function analyses to evaluate 30 TRPV4 variants across various functional protein domains. We report clinical features of seven patients with TRPV4 variants of unknown significance and provide extensive functional characterization of these and an additional 17 variants, including structural position, ion channel function, subcellular localization, expression level, cytotoxicity and protein-protein interactions. We find that gain-of-function mutations within the TRPV4 intracellular ankyrin repeat domain target charged amino acid residues important for RhoA interaction, whereas ankyrin repeat domain residues outside of the RhoA interface have normal or reduced ion channel activity. We further identify a cluster of gain-of-function variants within the intracellular intrinsically disordered region that may cause toxicity via altered interactions with membrane lipids. In contrast, assessed variants in the transmembrane domain and other regions of the intrinsically disordered region do not cause gain of function and are likely benign. Clinical features associated with gain of function and cytotoxicity include congenital onset of disease, vocal cord weakness and motor-predominant disease, whereas patients with likely benign variants often demonstrated late-onset and sensory-predominant disease. These results provide a framework for assessing additional TRPV4 variants with respect to likely pathogenicity, which will yield critical information to inform patient selection for future clinical trials for TRPV4 channelopathies.

TRPV4 neuromuscular disease registry highlights bulbar, skeletal and proximal limb manifestations

Dominant missense mutations of the calcium-permeable cation channel TRPV4 cause Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) type 2C and two forms of distal spinal muscular atrophy. These conditions are collectively referred to as TRPV4-related neuromuscular disease and share features of motor greater than sensory dysfunction and frequent vocal fold weakness. Pathogenic variants lead to gain of ion channel function that can be rescued by TRPV4 antagonists in cellular and animal models. As small molecule TRPV4 antagonists have proven safe in trials for other disease indications, channel inhibition is a promising therapeutic strategy for TRPV4 patients. However, the current knowledge of the clinical features and natural history of TRPV4-related neuromuscular disease is insufficient to enable rational clinical trial design. To address these issues, we developed a TRPV4 patient database and administered a TRPV4-specific patient questionnaire. Here, we report demographic and clinical information, including CMT Examination Scores (CMTES), from 68 patients with known pathogenic TRPV4 variants, 40 of whom also completed the TRPV4 patient questionnaire. TRPV4 patients showed a bimodal age of onset, with the largest peak occurring in the first 2 years of life. Compared to CMT type 1A (CMT1A) patients, TRPV4 patients showed distinct symptoms and signs, manifesting more ambulatory difficulties and more frequent involvement of proximal arm and leg muscles. Although patients reported fewer sensory symptoms, sensory dysfunction was often detected clinically. Many patients were affected by vocal fold weakness (55%) and shortness of breath (55%), and 11% required ventilatory support. Skeletal abnormalities were common, including scoliosis (64%), arthrogryposis (33%) and foot deformities. Strikingly, patients with infantile onset of disease showed less sensory involvement and less progression of symptoms. These results highlight distinctive clinical features in TRPV4 patients, including motor-predominant disease, proximal arm and leg weakness, severe ambulatory difficulties, vocal fold weakness, respiratory dysfunction and skeletal involvement. In addition, patients with infantile onset of disease appeared to have a distinct phenotype with less apparent disease progression based on CMTES. These collective observations indicate that clinical trial design for TRPV4-related neuromuscular disease should include outcome measures that reliably capture non-length dependent motor dysfunction, vocal fold weakness and respiratory disease.

Roles for TRPV4 in disease: A discussion of possible mechanisms

The transient receptor potential vanilloid 4 (TRPV4) ion channel is a ubiquitously expressed Ca2+-permeable ion channel that controls intracellular calcium ([Ca2+]i) homeostasis in various types of cells. The physiological roles for TRPV4 are tissue specific and the mechanisms behind this specificity remain mostly unclarified. It is noteworthy that mutations in the TRPV4 channel have been associated to a broad spectrum of congenital diseases, with most of these mutations mainly resulting in gain-of-function. Mutations have been identified in human patients showing a variety of phenotypes and symptoms, mostly related to skeletal and neuromuscular disorders. Since TRPV4 is so widely expressed throughout the body, it comes as no surprise that the literature is growing in evidence linking this protein to malfunction in systems other than the skeletal and neuromuscular. In this review, we summarize the expression patterns of TRPV4 in several tissues and highlight findings of recent studies that address critical structural and functional features of this channel, particularly focusing on its interactions and signaling pathways related to Ca2+ entry. Moreover, we discuss the roles of TRPV4 mutations in some diseases and pinpoint some of the mechanisms underlying pathological states where TRPV4's malfunction is prominent.

Identification and Properties of TRPV4 Mutant Channels Present in Polycystic Kidney Disease Patients

Polycystic kidney disease (PKD), a disease characterized by the enlargement of the kidney through cystic growth is the fourth leading cause of end-stage kidney disease world-wide. Transient receptor potential Vanilloid 4 (TRPV4), a calcium-permeable TRP, channel participates in kidney cell physiology and since TRPV4 forms complexes with another channel whose malfunction is associated to PKD, TRPP2 (or PKD2), we sought to determine whether patients with PKD, exhibit previously unknown mutations in TRPV4. Here, we report the presence of mutations in the TRPV4 gene in patients diagnosed with PKD and determine that they produce gain-of-function (GOF). Mutations in the sequence of the TRPV4 gene have been associated to a broad spectrum of neuropathies and skeletal dysplasias but not PKD, and their biophysical effects on channel function have not been elucidated. We identified and examined the functional behavior of a novel E6K mutant and of the previously known S94L and A217S mutant TRVP4 channels. The A217S mutation has been associated to mixed neuropathy and/or skeletal dysplasia phenotypes, however, the PKD carriers of these variants had not been diagnosed with these reported clinical manifestations. The presence of certain mutations in TRPV4 may influence the progression and severity of PKD through GOF mechanisms. PKD patients carrying TRVP4 mutations are putatively more likely to require dialysis or renal transplant as compared to those without these mutations.

The role of TRPV4 channels in cutaneous epithelia

Transient receptor potential vanilloid 4 (TRPV4) channels are multi-modally activated cation permeable channels that are expressed most organ tissues including the skin. TRPV4 is highly expressed in the skin and functions in skin resident cells such as epidermal keratinocytes, melanocytes, immune mast cells and macrophages, and cutaneous neurons. TRPV4 plays many crucial roles in skin homeostasis to affect an extensive range of processes such as temperature sensation, osmo-sensation, hair growth, cell apoptosis, skin barrier integrity, differentiation, nociception and itch. Since TRPV4 functions in a plenitude of pathological states, TRPV4 can become a versatile therapeutic target for diseases such as chronic pain, itch and skin cancer.

Coassembly of Warm Temperature-Sensitive Transient Receptor Potential Vanilloid (TRPV) 3 and TRPV4 Channel Complexes with Distinct Functional Properties

Heteromeric assembly of temperature-sensitive transient receptor potential (TRP) ion channels has been suggested to underlie the molecular basis of fine-tuning of temperature detection and chemical sensation. However, whether warm temperature-sensitive TRP vanilloid (TRPV) 3 and TRPV4 channels robustly expressed in the skin can form heteromeric assembly remains largely unknown. In this study, we show that TRPV3 and TRPV4 channels can coassemble into functional heterotetrameric channels with distinct properties. Confocal imaging reveals a colocalization and association of TRPV3 and TRPV4 proteins in cell membrane. Coimmunoprecipitation analysis demonstrates a strong protein-protein interaction between TRPV3 and TRPV4 subunits from heterogeneously expressed cells or mouse skin tissues through their C termini but not in TRPV3 knockout tissues. Coexpression of TRPV3 and TRPV4 channels yields a heterotetrameric channel complexes characterized by an intermediate single-channel conductance, distinct activation threshold, and pharmacology. Taken together, our findings demonstrate a heterotetrameric assembly of TRPV3 and TRPV4 channels, which may help explain the role of temperature-sensitive TRPV channels in fine-tuning of environmental detection and sensation in the skin. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: The coassembly of transient receptor potential vanilloid (TRPV) 3 and TRPV4 channel complexes increases the functional diversity within the channel subfamily, which may serve as a molecular basis for fine-tuning of environmental detection and temperature sensation in mammals.

TRPV4 mutations causing mixed neuropathy and skeletal phenotypes result in severe gain of function

OBJECTIVE

Distinct dominant mutations in the calcium-permeable ion channel TRPV4 (transient receptor potential vanilloid 4) typically cause nonoverlapping diseases of either the neuromuscular or skeletal systems. However, accumulating evidence suggests that some patients develop mixed phenotypes that include elements of both neuromuscular and skeletal disease. We sought to define the genetic and clinical features of these patients.

METHODS

We report a 2-year-old with a novel R616G mutation in TRPV4 with a severe neuropathy phenotype and bilateral vocal cord paralysis. Interestingly, a different substitution at the same residue, R616Q, has been reported in families with isolated skeletal dysplasia. To gain insight into clinical features and potential genetic determinants of mixed phenotypes, we perform in-depth analysis of previously reported patients along with functional and structural assessment of selected mutations.

RESULTS

We describe a wide range of neuromuscular and skeletal manifestations and highlight specific mutations that are more frequently associated with overlap syndromes. We find that mutations causing severe, mixed phenotypes have an earlier age of onset and result in more marked elevations of intracellular calcium, increased cytotoxicity, and reduced sensitivity to TRPV4 antagonism. Structural analysis of the two mutations with the most dramatic gain of ion channel function suggests that these mutants likely cause constitutive channel opening through disruption of the TRPV4 S5 transmembrane domain.

INTERPRETATION

These findings demonstrate that the degree of baseline calcium elevation correlates with development of mixed phenotypes and sensitivity to pharmacologic channel inhibition, observations that will be critical for the design of future clinical trials for TRPV4 channelopathies.

Natural history of TRPV4-Related disorders: From skeletal dysplasia to neuromuscular phenotype

TRPV4-related disorders constitute a broad spectrum of clinical phenotypes including several genetic skeletal and neuromuscular disorders, in which clinical variability and somewhat overlapping features are present. These disorders have previously been considered to be clinically distinct phenotypes before their molecular basis was discovered. However, with the identification of TRPV4 variants in the etiology, they are referred as TRPV4-related disorders (TRPV4-pathies), and are now mainly grouped into skeletal dysplasias and neuromuscular disorders. The skeletal dysplasia group includes metatropic dysplasia, parastremmatic dysplasia, spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia Maroteaux type, spondylometaphyseal dysplasia Kozlowski type, autosomal dominant brachyolmia, and familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly, whereas the neuromuscular group includes congenital distal spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), scapuloperoneal SMA and Charcot-Marie-Tooth neuropathy type 2C with common manifestations of peripheral neuropathy, joint contractures, and respiratory system involvement. Apart from familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly, skeletal dysplasia associated with TRPV4 pathogenic variants share some clinical features such as short stature with short trunk, spinal and pelvic changes with varying degrees of long bone involvement. Of note, there is considerable phenotypic overlap within and between both groups. Herein, we report on the clinical and molecular spectrum of 11 patients from six different families diagnosed with TRPV4-related disorders. This study yet represents the largest cohort of patients with TRPV4 variants from a single center in Turkey.