Activation of a primed RING E3-E2-ubiquitin complex by non-covalent ubiquitin

Structural ubiquitin contributes to K48 linkage specificity of the HECT ligase Tom1

Homologous to E6AP C terminus (HECT) ubiquitin ligases play key roles in essential pathways such as DNA repair, cell cycle control, or protein quality control. Tom1 is one of five HECT ubiquitin E3 ligases in budding yeast S. cerevisiae and is prototypical for a ligase with pleiotropic functions such as ubiquitin chain amplification, orphan quality control, and DNA damage response. Structures of full-length HECT ligases, including the Tom1 ortholog HUWE1, have been reported, but how domains beyond the conserved catalytic module contribute to catalysis remains largely elusive. Here, through cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM) snapshots of Tom1 during an active ubiquitination cycle, we demonstrate that the extended domain architecture directly contributes to activity. We identify a Tom1-ubiquitin architecture during ubiquitination involving a non-canonical ubiquitin-binding site in the solenoid shape of Tom1. We demonstrate that this ubiquitin-binding site coordinates a structural ubiquitin contributing to the fidelity of K48 poly-ubiquitin chain assembly.

Mechanism of nucleosomal H2A K13/15 monoubiquitination and adjacent dual monoubiquitination by RNF168

The DNA damage repair regulatory protein RNF168, a monomeric RING-type E3 ligase, has a crucial role in regulating cell fate and DNA repair by specific and efficient ubiquitination of the adjacent K13 and K15 (K13/15) sites at the H2A N-terminal tail. However, understanding how RNF168 coordinates with its cognate E2 enzyme UbcH5c to site-specifically ubiquitinate H2A K13/15 has long been hampered by the lack of high-resolution structures of RNF168 and UbcH5c~Ub (ubiquitin) in complex with nucleosomes. Here we developed chemical strategies and determined the cryo-electron microscopy structures of the RNF168-UbcH5c~Ub-nucleosome complex captured in transient H2A K13/15 monoubiquitination and adjacent dual monoubiquitination reactions, providing a 'helix-anchoring' mode for monomeric E3 ligase RNF168 on nucleosome in contrast to the 'compass-binding' mode of dimeric E3 ligases. Our work not only provides structural snapshots of H2A K13/15 site-specific monoubiquitination and adjacent dual monoubiquitination but also offers a near-atomic-resolution structural framework for understanding pathogenic amino acid substitutions and physiological modifications of RNF168.

A nanobody that binds to the backside of the ubiquitin conjugating enzyme Ube2G2 differentially affects interactions with its partner E3 Ligases

Ubiquitin conjugating E2 enzymes are a set of ~40 proteins that play a central role in the ubiquitination cascade. They transfer ubiquitin from an E1 enzyme to substrates with the help of an E3 enzyme. The members of the E2 family share structural similarity in their conserved UBC fold. This complicates an assessment of the specificity of E2-E3 interactions. We identified a nanobody that binds to the 'backside' region of Ube2G2, an E2 involved in ER protein quality control. This binding does not affect ubiquitin loading but shows varying degrees of inhibition on E3-mediated ubiquitination, in the order HRD1 > CHIP >> TRC8. A naturally occurring segment that binds Ube2G2's backside, referred to as G2BR (Ube2G2 Binding Region), shows a similar inhibitory effect depending on the identity of the interacting E3. The G2BR in the Ube2G2-cognate E3 Gp78 enhances Ube2G2's activity, but its deletion results in a similar inhibition upon addition of the nanobody. Occupation of a single binding site on an E2 can thus affect its interactions with different E3s.

Identification of RING E3 pseudoligases in the TRIM protein family

TRIpartite Motif (TRIM) family proteins have diverse roles across a broad variety of cellular functions, which are largely presumed to depend on their ubiquitin E3 ligase activity, conferred by a RING domain. However, recent reports have shown that some TRIMs lack detectable ubiquitination activity in isolation, despite containing a RING domain. Here, we present parallel in cellulo, in vitro, and in silico structure-function analyses of the ubiquitin E3 ligase activity and RING domain structural characteristics of the whole TRIM protein family. In-depth follow-up studies of this comprehensive dataset reveals a number of 'pseudoligases', whose RING domains have structurally diverged at either the homodimerisation or E2~ubiquitin interfaces, thereby disrupting their ability to catalyse ubiquitin transfer. Together, these data raise intriguing open questions regarding the unknown TRIM functions in physiology and disease.

DET1 dynamics underlie cooperative ubiquitination by CRL4DET1-COP1 complexes

Transcription factor ubiquitination is a decisive regulator of growth and development. The DET1-DDB1-DDA1 (DDD) complex associates with the Cullin-4 ubiquitin ligase (CRL4) and a second ubiquitin ligase, COP1, to control ubiquitination of transcription factors involved in neurological, metabolic, and immune cell development. Here, we report the structure of the human DDD complex, revealing a specific segment of DET1 that can recruit ubiquitin-conjugating (E2) enzymes. Structural variability analysis, mass spectrometry, and mutagenesis based on AlphaFold predictions suggest that dynamic closure of DET1, stabilized by DDA1, underlies coordinated recruitment of E2 enzymes and COP1. Biochemical assays suggest that the E2 acts as a recruitment factor to bring COP1 to DET1 for more effective substrate ubiquitination, which parallels a catalytically inactive E2 enzyme (COP10) in plant DDD complexes. This work provides a clear architecture for regulation and cooperative CRL4DET1-COP1 complex assembly, which can affect degradation of diverse targets by COP1 complexes.

Tsg101 mimicry of canonical E2 enzymes underlies its role in ubiquitin signaling

Tsg101 is a highly conserved protein best known as an early-functioning component of cellular ESCRT machinery participating in recognition, sorting, and trafficking of cellular cargo to various intracellular destinations. It shares sequence and structural homology to canonical ubiquitin-conjugating (E2) enzymes and is linked to diverse events regulated by Ub signaling. How it might fulfill these roles is unclear. Here, we show that Tsg101 E2 mimicry permits interactions with diverse ubiquitin ligating (E3) enzymes and underlies its multifunctional capabilities. Coexpression of Tsg101 with the E3 ligase NNedd4-2s protected the enzyme from degradation and, remarkably, other widely divergent ligases as well. Structural alignment with UbcH5, a canonical E2 enzyme, revealed that recognition at the E2-E3 interface, a region broadly conserved despite sequence and structural differences in both E2 and E3 enzymes, was critical for protection. Nevertheless, UbcH5 failed to protect NNedd4-2s, indicating that the UEV chaperone function is unique to the variant. Studies using Cy5-Ub-VME showed that Tsg101-mediated protection reduced accessibility to Cys residues in the ligase. Access to Tsg101 Ub-binding sites was critical: Rabeprazole, which interferes with Tsg101 Ub-binding, diminished E3 ligase protection. Thus, E2 mimicry permitting control of E3 ligase ubiquitin signaling underlies Tsg101's broad ability to participate in multiple cellular functions. The study provides mechanistic insight into how Tsg101, by partnering with diverse E3 ligases, can contribute to a broad range of cellular activities.

Chemical Tools for Probing the Ub/Ubl Conjugation Cascades

Conjugation of ubiquitin (Ub) and structurally related ubiquitin-like proteins (Ubls), essential for many cellular processes, employs multi-step reactions orchestrated by specific E1, E2 and E3 enzymes. The E1 enzyme activates the Ub/Ubl C-terminus in an ATP-dependent process that results in the formation of a thioester linkage with the E1 active site cysteine. The thioester-activated Ub/Ubl is transferred to the active site of an E2 enzyme which then interacts with an E3 enzyme to promote conjugation to the target substrate. The E1-E2-E3 enzymatic cascades utilize labile intermediates, extensive conformational changes, and vast combinatorial diversity of short-lived protein-protein complexes to conjugate Ub/Ubl to various substrates in a regulated manner. In this review, we discuss various chemical tools and methods used to study the consecutive steps of Ub/Ubl activation and conjugation, which are often too elusive for direct studies. We focus on methods developed to probe enzymatic activities and capture and characterize stable mimics of the transient intermediates and transition states, thereby providing insights into fundamental mechanisms in the Ub/Ubl conjugation pathways.

Ubiquitin E3 ligases in the plant Arg/N-degron pathway

Regulation of protein longevity via the ubiquitin (Ub) - proteasome pathway is fundamental to eukaryotic biology. Ubiquitin E3 ligases (E3s) interact with substrate proteins and provide specificity to the pathway. A small subset of E3s bind to specific exposed N-termini (N-degrons) and promote the ubiquitination of the bound protein. Collectively these E3s, and other N-degron binding proteins, are known as N-recognins. There is considerable functional divergence between fungi, animal, and plant N-recognins. In plants, at least three proteins (PRT1, PRT6, and BIG) participate in the Arg/N-degron pathway. PRT1 has demonstrated E3 ligase activity, whereas PRT6 and BIG are candidate E3s. The Arg/N-degron pathway plays a central role in plant development, germination, and submersion tolerance. The pathway has been manipulated both to improve crop performance and for conditional protein degradation. A more detailed structural and biochemical understanding of the Arg/N-recognins and their substrates is required to fully realise the biotechnological potential of the pathway. This perspective focuses on the structural and molecular details of substrate recognition and ubiquitination in the plant Arg/N-degron pathway. While PRT1 appears to be plant specific, the PRT6 and BIG proteins are similar to UBR1 and UBR4, respectively. Analysis of the cryo-EM structures of Saccharomyces UBR1 suggests that the mode of ubiquitin conjugating enzyme (E2) and substrate recruitment is conserved in PRT6, but regulation of the two N-recognins may be significantly different. The structurally characterised domains from human UBR4 are also likely to be conserved in BIG, however, there are sizeable gaps in our understanding of both proteins.

Structural inscrutabilities of Histone (H2BK123) monoubiquitination: A systematic review

Histone H2B monoubiquitination in budding yeast is a highly conserved post-translational modification. It is involved in normal functions of the cells like DNA Repair, RNA Pol II activation, trans-histone H3K and H79K methylation, meiosis, vesicle budding, etc. Deregulation of H2BK123ub can lead to the activation of proto-oncogenes and is also linked to neurodegenerative and heart diseases. Recent discoveries have enhanced the mechanistic underpinnings of H2BK123ub. For the first time, the Rad6's acidic tail has been implicated in histone recognition and interaction with Bre1's RBD domain. The non-canonical backside of Rad6 showed inhibition in polyubiquitination activity. Bre1 domains RBD and RING play a role in site-specific ubiquitination. The role of single Alaline residue in Rad6 activity. Understanding the mechanism of ubiquitination before moving to therapeutic applications is important. Current advancements in this field indicate the creation of novel therapeutic approaches and a foundation for further study.

Functional implications of unusual NOS and SONOS covalent linkages found in proteins

The tertiary and quaternary structures of many proteins are stabilized by strong covalent forces, of which disulfide bonds are the most well known. A new type of intramolecular and intermolecular covalent bond has been recently reported, consisting of the Lys and Cys side-chains linked by an oxygen atom (NOS). These post-translational modifications are widely distributed amongst proteins, and are formed under oxidative conditions. Similar linkages are observed during antibiotic biosynthesis, where hydroxylamine intermediates are tethered to the sulfur of enzyme active site Cys residues. These linkages open the way to understanding protein structure and function, give new insights into enzyme catalysis and natural product biosynthesis, and offer new strategies for drug design.

Structural Analyses of a GABARAP~ATG3 Conjugate Uncover a Novel Non-covalent Ubl-E2 Backside Interaction

Members of the ATG8 family of ubiquitin-like proteins (Ubls) are conjugated to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) in the autophagosomal membrane, where they recruit degradation substrates and facilitate membrane biogenesis. Despite this well-characterized function, the mechanisms underlying the lipidation process, including the action of the E2 enzyme ATG3, remain incompletely understood. Here, we report the crystal structure of human ATG3 conjugated to the mammalian ATG8 protein GABARAP via an isopeptide bond, mimicking the Ubl~E2 thioester intermediate. In this structure, the GABARAP~ATG3 conjugate adopts an open configuration with minimal contacts between the two proteins. Notably, the crystal lattice reveals non-covalent contacts between GABARAP and the backside of ATG3's E2 catalytic center, resulting in the formation of a helical filament of the GABARAP~ATG3 conjugate. While similar filament formations have been observed with canonical Ub~E2 conjugates, the E2 backside-binding interface of GABARAP is distinct from those of Ub/Ubl proteins and overlaps with the binding site for LC3 interacting region (LIR) peptides. NMR analysis confirms the presence of this non-covalent interaction in solution, and mutagenesis experiments demonstrate the involvement of the E2 backside in PE conjugation. These findings highlight the critical role of the E2 backside in the lipidation process and suggest evolutionary adaptations in the unique E2 enzyme ATG3.

Capturing the catalytic intermediates of parkin ubiquitination

Parkin is an E3 ubiquitin ligase implicated in early-onset forms of Parkinson's disease. It catalyzes a transthiolation reaction by accepting ubiquitin (Ub) from an E2 conjugating enzyme, forming a short-lived thioester intermediate, and transfers Ub to mitochondrial membrane substrates to signal mitophagy. A major impediment to the development of Parkinsonism therapeutics is the lack of structural and mechanistic detail for the essential, short-lived transthiolation intermediate. It is not known how Ub is recognized by the catalytic Rcat domain in parkin that enables Ub transfer from an E2~Ub conjugate to the catalytic site and the structure of the transthiolation complex is undetermined. Here, we capture the catalytic intermediate for the Rcat domain of parkin in complex with ubiquitin (Rcat-Ub) and determine its structure using NMR-based chemical shift perturbation experiments. We show that a previously unidentified α-helical region near the Rcat domain is unmasked as a recognition motif for Ub and guides the C-terminus of Ub toward the parkin catalytic site. Further, we apply a combination of guided AlphaFold modeling, chemical cross-linking, and single turnover assays to establish and validate a model of full-length parkin in complex with UbcH7, its donor Ub, and phosphoubiquitin, trapped in the process of transthiolation. Identification of this catalytic intermediate and orientation of Ub with respect to the Rcat domain provides important structural insights into Ub transfer by this E3 ligase and explains how the previously enigmatic Parkinson's pathogenic mutation T415N alters parkin activity.

Generation of a high confidence set of domain-domain interface types to guide protein complex structure predictions by AlphaFold

MOTIVATION

While the release of AlphaFold (AF) represented a breakthrough for the prediction of protein complex structures, its sensitivity, especially when using full length protein sequences, still remains limited. Modeling success rates might increase if AF predictions were guided by likely interacting protein fragments. This approach requires available sets of highly confident protein-protein interface types. Computational resources, such as 3did, infer interacting globular domain types from observed contacts in protein structures. Assessing the accuracy of these predicted interface types is difficult because we lack hand-curated reference sets of verified domain-domain interface (DDI) types.

RESULTS

To improve protein complex modeling of DDIs by AF, we manually inspected 80 randomly selected DDI types from the 3did resource to generate a first reference set of DDI types. Identified cases of DDI type nonapproval (40%) primarily resulted from inaccurate Pfam domain matches, crystal contacts, and synthetic protein constructs. Using logistic regression, we predicted a subset of 2411 out of 5724 considered DDI types in 3did to be of high confidence, which we subsequently applied to 53 000 human-protein interactions to predict DDIs followed by AF modeling. We obtained highly confident AF models for 604 out of 1129 predicted DDIs. Of note, for 47% of them no confident AF structural model could be obtained using full length protein sequences.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

Code is available at https://github.com/KatjaLuckLab/DDI_manuscript.

Mechanisms of RNF168 nucleosome recognition and ubiquitylation

RNF168 plays a central role in the DNA damage response (DDR) by ubiquitylating histone H2A at K13 and K15. These modifications direct BRCA1-BARD1 and 53BP1 foci formation in chromatin, essential for cell-cycle-dependent DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair pathway selection. The mechanism by which RNF168 catalyzes the targeted accumulation of H2A ubiquitin conjugates to form repair foci around DSBs remains unclear. Here, using cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and functional assays, we provide a molecular description of the reaction cycle and dynamics of RNF168 as it modifies the nucleosome and recognizes its ubiquitylation products. We demonstrate an interaction of a canonical ubiquitin-binding domain within full-length RNF168, which not only engages ubiquitin but also the nucleosome surface, clarifying how such site-specific ubiquitin recognition propels a signal amplification loop. Beyond offering mechanistic insights into a key DDR protein, our study aids in understanding site specificity in both generating and interpreting chromatin ubiquitylation.

UBE2A and UBE2B are recruited by an atypical E3 ligase module in UBR4

UBR4 is a 574 kDa E3 ligase (E3) of the N-degron pathway with roles in neurodevelopment, age-associated muscular atrophy and cancer. The catalytic module that carries out ubiquitin (Ub) transfer remains unknown. Here we identify and characterize a distinct E3 module within human UBR4 consisting of a 'hemiRING' zinc finger, a helical-rich UBR zinc-finger interacting (UZI) subdomain, and an N-terminal region that can serve as an affinity factor for the E2 conjugating enzyme (E2). The structure of an E2-E3 complex provides atomic-level insight into the specificity determinants of the hemiRING toward the cognate E2s UBE2A/UBE2B. Via an allosteric mechanism, the UZI subdomain modestly activates the Ub-loaded E2 (E2∼Ub). We propose attenuated activation is complemented by the intrinsically high lysine reactivity of UBE2A, and their cooperation imparts a reactivity profile important for substrate specificity and optimal degradation kinetics. These findings reveal the mechanistic underpinnings of a neuronal N-degron E3, its specific recruitment of UBE2A, and highlight the underappreciated architectural diversity of cross-brace domains with Ub E3 activity.

Multisite phosphorylation dictates selective E2-E3 pairing as revealed by Ubc8/UBE2H-GID/CTLH assemblies

Ubiquitylation is catalyzed by coordinated actions of E3 and E2 enzymes. Molecular principles governing many important E3-E2 partnerships remain unknown, including those for RING-family GID/CTLH E3 ubiquitin ligases and their dedicated E2, Ubc8/UBE2H (yeast/human nomenclature). GID/CTLH-Ubc8/UBE2H-mediated ubiquitylation regulates biological processes ranging from yeast metabolic signaling to human development. Here, cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), biochemistry, and cell biology reveal this exquisitely specific E3-E2 pairing through an unconventional catalytic assembly and auxiliary interactions 70-100 Å away, mediated by E2 multisite phosphorylation. Rather than dynamic polyelectrostatic interactions reported for other ubiquitylation complexes, multiple Ubc8/UBE2H phosphorylation sites within acidic CK2-targeted sequences specifically anchor the E2 C termini to E3 basic patches. Positions of phospho-dependent interactions relative to the catalytic domains correlate across evolution. Overall, our data show that phosphorylation-dependent multivalency establishes a specific E3-E2 partnership, is antagonistic with dephosphorylation, rigidifies the catalytic centers within a flexing GID E3-substrate assembly, and facilitates substrate collision with ubiquitylation active sites.

Molecular basis for PHF7-mediated ubiquitination of histone H3

The RING-type E3 ligase has been known for over two decades, yet its diverse modes of action are still the subject of active research. Plant homeodomain (PHD) finger protein 7 (PHF7) is a RING-type E3 ubiquitin ligase responsible for histone ubiquitination. PHF7 comprises three zinc finger domains: an extended PHD (ePHD), a RING domain, and a PHD. While the function of the RING domain is largely understood, the roles of the other two domains in E3 ligase activity remain elusive. Here, we present the crystal structure of PHF7 in complex with the E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2). Our structure shows that E2 is effectively captured between the RING domain and the C-terminal PHD, facilitating E2 recruitment through direct contact. In addition, through in vitro binding and functional assays, we demonstrate that the N-terminal ePHD recognizes the nucleosome via DNA binding, whereas the C-terminal PHD is involved in histone H3 recognition. Our results provide a molecular basis for the E3 ligase activity of PHF7 and uncover the specific yet collaborative contributions of each domain to the PHF7 ubiquitination activity.

Zinc finger 1 of the RING E3 ligase, RNF125, interacts with the E2 to enhance ubiquitylation

Inflammation is essential for healthy immune function, wound healing, and resolution of infection. RIG-I is a key RNA sensor that initiates an immune response, with activation and termination of RIG-I signaling reliant on its modification with ubiquitin. The RING E3 ubiquitin ligase, RNF125, has a critical role in the attenuation of RIG-I signaling, yet it is not known how RNF125 promotes ubiquitin transfer or how its activity is regulated. Here we show that the E3 ligase activity of RNF125 relies on the first zinc finger (ZF1) as well as the RING domain. Surprisingly, ZF1 helps recruit the E2, while residues N-terminal to the RING domain appear to activate the E2∼Ub conjugate. These discoveries help explain how RNF125 brings about the termination of RIG-I dependent inflammatory responses, and help account for the contribution of RNF125 to disease. This study also reveals a new role for ZF domains in E3 ligases.

Structural insights into the regulation of the human E2∼SUMO conjugate through analysis of its stable mimetic

Protein SUMOylation is a ubiquitylation-like post-translational modification (PTM) that is synthesized through an enzymatic cascade involving an E1 (SAE1:SAE2), an E2 (UBC9), and various E3 enzymes. In the final step of this process, the small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) is transferred from the UBC9∼SUMO thioester onto a lysine residue of a protein substrate. This reaction can be accelerated by an E3 ligase. As the UBC9∼SUMO thioester is chemically unstable, a stable mimetic is desirable for structural studies of UBC9∼SUMO alone and in complex with a substrate and/or an E3 ligase. Recently, a strategy for generating a mimetic of the yeast E2∼SUMO thioester by mutating alanine 129 of Ubc9 to a lysine has been reported. Here, we reproduce and further investigate this approach using the human SUMOylation system and characterize the resulting mimetic of human UBC9∼SUMO1. We show that substituting lysine for alanine 129, but not for other active-site UBC9 residues, results in a UBC9 variant that is efficiently auto-SUMOylated. The auto-modification is dependent on cysteine 93 of UBC9, suggesting that it proceeds via this residue, through the same pathway as that for SUMOylation of substrates. The process is also partially dependent on aspartate 127 of UBC9 and accelerated by high pH, highlighting the importance of the substrate lysine protonation state for efficient SUMOylation. Finally, we present the crystal structure of the UBC9-SUMO1 molecule, which reveals the mimetic in an open conformation and its polymerization via the noncovalent SUMO-binding site on UBC9. Similar interactions could regulate UBC9∼SUMO in some cellular contexts.

Structural basis for the Rad6 activation by the Bre1 N-terminal domain

The mono-ubiquitination of the histone protein H2B (H2Bub1) is a highly conserved histone post-translational modification that plays critical roles in many fundamental processes. In yeast, this modification is catalyzed by the conserved Bre1-Rad6 complex. Bre1 contains a unique N-terminal Rad6-binding domain (RBD), how it interacts with Rad6 and contributes to the H2Bub1 catalysis is unclear. Here, we present crystal structure of the Bre1 RBD-Rad6 complex and structure-guided functional studies. Our structure provides a detailed picture of the interaction between the dimeric Bre1 RBD and a single Rad6 molecule. We further found that the interaction stimulates Rad6's enzymatic activity by allosterically increasing its active site accessibility and likely contribute to the H2Bub1 catalysis through additional mechanisms. In line with these important functions, we found that the interaction is crucial for multiple H2Bub1-regulated processes. Our study provides molecular insights into the H2Bub1 catalysis.

B-box1 Domain of MID1 Interacts with the Ube2D1 E2 Enzyme Differently Than RING E3 Ligases

The MID1 TRIM protein is important for ventral midline development in vertebrates, and mutations of its B-box1 domain result in several birth defects. The B-box1 domain of the human MID1 protein binds two zinc atoms and adopt a similar ββα-RING structure. This domain is required for the efficient ubiquitination of protein phosphatase 2A, alpha4, and fused kinase. Considering the structural similarity, the MID1 B-box1 domain exhibits mono-autoubiquitination activity, in contrast to poly-autoubiquitination observed for RING E3 ligases. To understand its mechanism of action, the interaction of the B-box1 domain with Ube2D1 (UbcH5a, E2), a preferred E2 ligase, is investigated. Using isothermal titration calorimetry, the MID1 RING and B-box1 domains were observed to have similar binding affinities with the Ube2D1 protein. However, NMR ¹⁵N-¹H Heteronuclear Single Quantum Coherence titration, ¹⁵N relaxation data, and High Ambiguity Driven protein-protein DOCKing (HADDOCK) calculations show the B-box1 domain binding on a surface distinct from where RING domains bind. The novel binding interaction shows the B-box1 domain partially overlapping the noncovalent Ube2D1 and a ubiquitin binding site that is necessary for poly-autoubiquitination activity. The B-box1 domain also displaces the ubiquitin from the Ube2D1 protein. These studies reveal a novel binding interaction between the zinc-binding ββα-fold B-box1 domain and the Ube2D enzyme family and that this difference in binding, compared to RING E3 ligases, provides a rationale for its auto-monoubiquitination E3 ligase activity.

From seeds to trees: how E2 enzymes grow ubiquitin chains

Modification of proteins by ubiquitin is a highly regulated process that plays a critical role in eukaryotes, from the construction of signalling platforms to the control of cell division. Aberrations in ubiquitin transfer are associated with many diseases, including cancer and neurodegenerative disorders. The ubiquitin machinery generates a rich code on substrate proteins, spanning from single ubiquitin modifications to polyubiquitin chains with diverse linkage types. Central to this process are the E2 enzymes, which often determine the exact nature of the ubiquitin code. The focus of this mini-review is on the molecular details of how E2 enzymes can initiate and grow ubiquitin chains. In particular, recent developments and biochemical breakthroughs that help explain how the degradative E2 enzymes, Ube2s, Ube2k, and Ube2r, generate complex ubiquitin chains with exquisite specificity will be discussed.

E2 Partner Tunes the Ubiquitylation Specificity of Arkadia E3 Ubiquitin Ligase

Arkadia (RNF111) is a positive regulator of the TGF-β signaling that mediates the proteasome-dependent degradation of negative factors of the pathway. It is classified as an E3 ubiquitin ligase and a SUMO-targeted ubiquitin ligase (STUBL), implicated in various pathological conditions including cancer and fibrosis. The enzymatic (ligase) activity of Arkadia is located at its C-terminus and involves the RING domain. Notably, E3 ligases require E2 enzymes to perform ubiquitylation. However, little is known about the cooperation of Arkadia with various E2 enzymes and the type of ubiquitylation that they mediate. In the present work, we study the interaction of Arkadia with the E2 partners UbcH5B and UbcH13, as well as UbcH7. Through NMR spectroscopy, we found that the E2-Arkadia interaction surface is similar in all pairs examined. Nonetheless, the requirements and factors that determine an enzymatically active E2-Arkadia complex differ in each case. Furthermore, we revealed that the cooperation of Arkadia with different E2s results in either monoubiquitylation or polyubiquitin chain formation via K63, K48, or K11 linkages, which can determine the fate of the substrate and lead to distinct biological outcomes.

Inhibition of the Ubiquitin Transfer Cascade by a Peptidomimetic Foldamer Mimicking the E2 N-Terminal Helix

The enzymatic cascades for ubiquitin transfer regulate key cellular processes and are the intense focus of drug development for treating cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. E1 is at the apex of the UB transfer cascade, and molecules inhibiting E1 have shown promising activities against cancer cell proliferation. Compared to small molecules, peptidomimetics have emerged as powerful tools to disrupt the protein-protein interactions (PPI) with less drug resistance and high stability in the cell. Herein, we harnessed the D-sulfono-γ-AA peptide to mimic the N-terminal helix of E2 and thereby inhibit E1-E2 interaction. Two stapled peptidomimetics, M1-S1 and M1-S2, were identified as effective inhibitors to block UB transfer from E1 to E2, as shown by in vitro and cellular assays. Our work suggested that PPIs with the N-terminal helix of E2 at the E1-E2 and E2-E3 interfaces could be a promising target for designing inhibitors against protein ubiquitination pathways in the cell.

Activities and binding partners of E3 ubiquitin ligase DTX3L and its roles in cancer

Ubiquitination is a protein post-translational modification that affects protein localisation, stability and interactions. E3 ubiquitin ligases regulate the final step of the ubiquitination reaction by recognising target proteins and mediating the ubiquitin transfer from an E2 enzyme. DTX3L is a multi-domain E3 ubiquitin ligase in which the N-terminus mediates protein oligomerisation, a middle D3 domain mediates the interaction with PARP9, a RING domain responsible for recognising E2 ∼ Ub and a DTC domain has the dual activity of ADP-ribosylating ubiquitin and mediating ubiquitination. The activity of DTX3L is known to be modulated by at least two different factors: the concentration of NAD+, which dictates if the enzyme acts as a ligase or as an ADP-ribosyltransferase, and its binding partners, which affect DTX3L activity through yet unknown mechanisms. In light of recent findings it is possible that DTX3L could ubiquitinate ADP-ribose attached to proteins. Different DTX3L–protein complexes have been found to be part of multiple signalling pathways through which they promote the adhesion, proliferation, migration and chemoresistance of e.g. lymphoma, glioma, melanoma, and prostate cancer. In this review, we have covered the literature available for the molecular functions of DTX3L especially in the context of cancer biology, different pathways it regulates and how these relate to its function as an oncoprotein.

A non-canonical scaffold-type E3 ligase complex mediates protein UFMylation

Protein UFMylation, i.e., post-translational modification with ubiquitin-fold modifier 1 (UFM1), is essential for cellular and endoplasmic reticulum homeostasis. Despite its biological importance, we have a poor understanding of how UFM1 is conjugated onto substrates. Here, we use a rebuilding approach to define the minimal requirements of protein UFMylation. We find that the reported cognate E3 ligase UFL1 is inactive on its own and instead requires the adaptor protein UFBP1 to form an active E3 ligase complex. Structure predictions suggest the UFL1/UFBP1 complex to be made up of winged helix (WH) domain repeats. We show that UFL1/UFBP1 utilizes a scaffold-type E3 ligase mechanism that activates the UFM1-conjugating E2 enzyme, UFC1, for aminolysis. Further, we characterize a second adaptor protein CDK5RAP3 that binds to and forms an integral part of the ligase complex. Unexpectedly, we find that CDK5RAP3 inhibits UFL1/UFBP1 ligase activity in vitro. Results from reconstituting ribosome UFMylation suggest that CDK5RAP3 functions as a substrate adaptor that directs UFMylation to the ribosomal protein RPL26. In summary, our reconstitution approach reveals the biochemical basis of UFMylation and regulatory principles of this atypical E3 ligase complex.

DELTEX E3 ligases ubiquitylate ADP-ribosyl modification on protein substrates

Ubiquitylation had been considered limited to protein lysine residues, but other substrates have recently emerged. Here, we show that DELTEX E3 ligases specifically target the 3' hydroxyl of the adenosine diphosphate (ADP)-ribosyl moiety that can be linked to a protein, thus generating a hybrid ADP-ribosyl-ubiquitin modification. Unlike other known hydroxyl-specific E3s, which proceed via a covalent E3~ubiqutin intermediate, DELTEX enzymes are RING E3s that stimulate a direct ubiquitin transfer from E2~ubiquitin onto a substrate. However, DELTEXes follow a previously unidentified paradigm for RING E3s, whereby the ligase not only forms a scaffold but also provides catalytic residues to activate the acceptor. Comparative analysis of known hydroxyl-ubiquitylating active sites points to the recurring use of a catalytic histidine residue, which, in DELTEX E3s, is potentiated by a glutamate in a catalytic triad-like manner. In addition, we determined the hydrolase specificity profile of this modification, identifying human and severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) enzymes that could reverse it in cells.

Unveiling the Essential Role of Arkadia's Non-RING Elements in the Ubiquitination Process

Arkadia is a positive regulator of the TGFβ-SMAD2/3 pathway, acting through its C-terminal RING-H2 domain and targeting for degradation of its negative regulators. Here we explore the role of regions outside the RING domain (non-RING elements) of Arkadia on the E2-E3 interaction. The contribution of the non-RING elements was addressed using Arkadia RING 68 aa and Arkadia 119 aa polypeptides. The highly conserved NRGA (asparagine-arginine-glycine-alanine) and TIER (threonine-isoleucine-glutamine-arginine) motifs within the 119 aa Arkadia polypeptide, have been shown to be required for pSMAD2/3 substrate recognition and ubiquitination in vivo. However, the role of the NRGA and TIER motifs in the enzymatic activity of Arkadia has not been addressed. Here, nuclear magnetic resonance interaction studies with the E2 enzyme, UBCH5B, C85S UBCH5B-Ub oxyester hydrolysis, and auto-ubiquitination assays were used to address the role of the non-RING elements in E2-E3 interaction and in the enzymatic activity of the RING. The results support that the non-RING elements including the NRGA and TIER motifs are required for E2-E3 recognition and interaction and for efficient auto-ubiquitination. Furthermore, while Arkadia isoform-2 and its close homologue Arkadia 2C are known to interact with free ubiquitin, the results here showed that Arkadia isoform-1 does not interact with free ubiquitin.

Bivalent binding of p14ARF to MDM2 RING and acidic domains inhibits E3 ligase function

ARF tumor suppressor protein is a key regulator of the MDM2-p53 signaling axis. ARF interferes with MDM2-mediated ubiquitination and degradation of p53 by sequestering MDM2 in the nucleolus and preventing MDM2-p53 interaction and nuclear export of p53. Moreover, ARF also directly inhibits MDM2 ubiquitin ligase (E3) activity, but the mechanism remains elusive. Here, we apply nuclear magnetic resonance and biochemical analyses to uncover the mechanism of ARF-mediated inhibition of MDM2 E3 activity. We show that MDM2 acidic and zinc finger domains (AD-ZnF) form a weak intramolecular interaction with the RING domain, where the binding site overlaps with the E2∼ubiquitin binding surface and thereby partially reduces MDM2 E3 activity. Binding of human N-terminal 32 residues of p14ARF to the acidic domain of MDM2 strengthens the AD-ZnF-RING domain interaction. Furthermore, the N-terminal RxFxV motifs of p14ARF participate directly in the MDM2 RING domain interaction. This bivalent binding mode of p14ARF to MDM2 acidic and RING domains restricts E2∼ubiquitin recruitment and massively hinders MDM2 E3 activity. These findings elucidate the mechanism by which ARF inhibits MDM2 E3 activity.

Structural studies of antitumor compounds that target the RING domain of MDM2

Mouse double minute 2 homolog (MDM2) is an E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase that is involved in the transfer of ubiquitin to p53 and other protein substrates. The expression of MDM2 is elevated in cancer cells and inhibitors of MDM2 showed potent anticancer activities. Many inhibitors target the p53 binding domain of MDM2. However, inhibitors such as Inulanolide A and MA242 are found to bind the RING domain of MDM2 to block ubiquitin transfer. In this report, crystal structures of MDM2 RING domain in complex with Inulanolide A and MA242 were solved. These inhibitors primarily bind in a hydrophobic site centered at the sidechain of Tyr489 at the C-terminus of MDM2 RING domain. The C-terminus of MDM2 RING domain, especially residue Tyr489, is required for ubiquitin discharge induced by MDM2. The binding of these inhibitors at Tyr489 may interrupt interactions between the MDM2 RING domain and the E2-Ubiquitin complex to inhibit ubiquitin transfer, regardless of what the substrate is. Our results suggest a new mechanism of inhibition of MDM2 E3 activity for a broad spectrum of substrates.

MUL1‐RING recruits the substrate, p53‐TAD as a complex with UBE2D2–UB conjugate

The RING domain of MUL1 (RING_MUL1) alone mediates ubiquitylation of the p53‐transactivation domain (TAD_p53). To elucidate the mechanism underlying the simultaneous recruitment of UBE2D2 and the substrate TAD_p53 by RING_MUL1, we determined the complex structure of RING_MUL1:UBE2D2 and studied the interaction between RING_MUL1 and TAD_p53 in the presence of UBE2D2–UB thioester (UBE2D2~UB) mimetics. The RING_MUL1‐binding induced the closed conformation of UBE2D2^S22R/C85S–UB^K48R oxyester (UBE2D2^RS–UB^R_OE), and strongly accelerated its hydrolysis, which was suppressed by the additional N77A‐mutation of UBE2D2. Interestingly, UBE2D2^{S22R/N77A/C85S}–UB^K48R oxyester (UBE2D2^RAS–UB^R_OE) already formed a closed conformation in the absence of RING_MUL1. Although TAD_p53 exhibited weak binding for RING_MUL1 or UBE2D2 alone, its binding affinity was enhanced and even further for RING_MUL1:UBE2D2 and RING_MUL1:UBE2D2^RAS–UB^R_OE, respectively. The recognition of TAD_p53 by RING_MUL1 as a complex with UBE2D2~UB is related to the multivalency of the binding events and underlies the ability of RING_MUL1 to ubiquitylate the intrinsically disordered protein, TAD_p53.

Structure of UBE2K-Ub/E3/polyUb reveals mechanisms of K48-linked Ub chain extension

Ubiquitin (Ub) chain types govern distinct biological processes. K48-linked polyUb chains target substrates for proteasomal degradation, but the mechanism of Ub chain synthesis remains elusive due to the transient nature of Ub handover. Here, we present the structure of a chemically trapped complex of the E2 UBE2K covalently linked to donor Ub and acceptor K48-linked di-Ub, primed for K48-linked Ub chain synthesis by a RING E3. The structure reveals the basis for acceptor Ub recognition by UBE2K active site residues and the C-terminal Ub-associated (UBA) domain, to impart K48-linked Ub specificity and catalysis. Furthermore, the structure unveils multiple Ub-binding surfaces on the UBA domain that allow distinct binding modes for K48- and K63-linked Ub chains. This multivalent Ub-binding feature serves to recruit UBE2K to ubiquitinated substrates to overcome weak acceptor Ub affinity and thereby promote chain elongation. These findings elucidate the mechanism of processive K48-linked polyUb chain formation by UBE2K.

Acetylation, Phosphorylation, Ubiquitination (Oh My!): Following Post-Translational Modifications on the Ubiquitin Road

Ubiquitination is controlled by a series of E1, E2, and E3 enzymes that can ligate ubiquitin to cellular proteins and dictate the turnover of a substrate and the outcome of signalling events such as DNA damage repair and cell cycle. This process is complex due to the combinatorial power of ~35 E2 and ~1000 E3 enzymes involved and the multiple lysine residues on ubiquitin that can be used to assemble polyubiquitin chains. Recently, mass spectrometric methods have identified that most enzymes in the ubiquitination cascade can be further modified through acetylation or phosphorylation under particular cellular conditions and altered modifications have been noted in different cancers and neurodegenerative diseases. This review provides a cohesive summary of ubiquitination, acetylation, and phosphorylation sites in ubiquitin, the human E1 enzyme UBA1, all E2 enzymes, and some representative E3 enzymes. The potential impacts these post-translational modifications might have on each protein function are highlighted, as well as the observations from human disease.

Ubiquitin and a charged loop regulate the ubiquitin E3 ligase activity of Ark2C

A large family of E3 ligases that contain both substrate recruitment and RING domains confer specificity within the ubiquitylation cascade. Regulation of RING E3s depends on modulating their ability to stabilise the RING bound E2~ubiquitin conjugate in the activated (or closed) conformation. Here we report the structure of the Ark2C RING bound to both a regulatory ubiquitin molecule and an activated E2~ubiquitin conjugate. The structure shows that the RING domain and non-covalently bound ubiquitin molecule together make contacts that stabilise the activated conformation of the conjugate, revealing why ubiquitin is a key regulator of Ark2C activity. We also identify a charged loop N-terminal to the RING domain that enhances activity by interacting with both the regulatory ubiquitin and ubiquitin conjugated to the E2. In addition, the structure suggests how Lys48-linked ubiquitin chains might be assembled by Ark2C and UbcH5b. Together this study identifies features common to RING E3s, as well elements that are unique to Ark2C and related E3s, which enhance assembly of ubiquitin chains.

Attachment of ubiquitin to proteins is tightly regulated and controls many signalling pathways. Here, the authors show that addition of ubiquitin by the RING E3 ligases Arkadia and Ark2C is enhanced by ubiquitin and a charged loop that precedes the RING domain.

Impact of a Single Nucleotide Polymorphism on the 3D Protein Structure and Ubiquitination Activity of E3 Ubiquitin Ligase Arkadia

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are genetic variations which can play a vital role in the study of human health. SNP studies are often used to identify point mutations that are associated with diseases. Arkadia (RNF111) is an E3 ubiquitin ligase that enhances transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β) signaling by targeting negative regulators for degradation. Dysregulation of the TGF-β pathway is implicated in cancer because it exhibits tumor suppressive activity in normal cells while in tumor cells it promotes invasiveness and metastasis. Τhe SNP CGT > TGT generated an amino-acid (aa) substitution of Arginine 957 to Cysteine on the enzymatic RING domain of Arkadia. This was more prevalent in a tumor than in a normal tissue sample of a patient with colorectal cancer. This prompted us to investigate the effect of this mutation in the structure and activity of Arkadia RING. We used nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to analyze at an atomic-level the structural and dynamic properties of the R957C Arkadia RING domain, while ubiquitination and luciferase assays provided information about its enzymatic functionality. Our study showed that the R957C mutation changed the electrostatic properties of the RING domain however, without significant effects on the structure of its core region. However, the functional studies revealed that the R957C Arkadia exhibits significantly increased enzymatic activity supporting literature data that Arkadia within tumor cells promotes aggressive and metastatic behavior.

Structural basis for the E3 ligase activity enhancement of yeast Nse2 by SUMO-interacting motifs

Post-translational modification of proteins by ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like modifiers, such as SUMO, are key events in protein homeostasis or DNA damage response. Smc5/6 is a nuclear multi-subunit complex that participates in the recombinational DNA repair processes and is required in the maintenance of chromosome integrity. Nse2 is a subunit of the Smc5/6 complex that possesses SUMO E3 ligase activity by the presence of a SP-RING domain that activates the E2~SUMO thioester for discharge on the substrate. Here we present the crystal structure of the SUMO E3 ligase Nse2 in complex with an E2-SUMO thioester mimetic. In addition to the interface between the SP-RING domain and the E2, the complex reveals how two SIM (SUMO-Interacting Motif) -like motifs in Nse2 are restructured upon binding the donor and E2-backside SUMO during the E3-dependent discharge reaction. Both SIM interfaces are essential in the activity of Nse2 and are required to cope with DNA damage.

Nse2 is a SUMO E3 ligase component of the Smc5/6 multisubunit complex involved in the DNA repair and chromosome integrity. Here, the structure of the Nse2 in complex with an E2-SUMO thioester mimetic reveals the combined action of two SIM motifs during the E3- dependent conjugation reaction.

Mechanically transduced immunosorbent assay to measure protein-protein interactions

Measuring protein-protein interaction (PPI) affinities is fundamental to biochemistry. Yet, conventional methods rely upon the law of mass action and cannot measure many PPIs due to a scarcity of reagents and limitations in the measurable affinity ranges. Here, we present a novel technique that leverages the fundamental concept of friction to produce a mechanical signal that correlates to binding potential. The mechanically transduced immunosorbent (METRIS) assay utilizes rolling magnetic probes to measure PPI interaction affinities. METRIS measures the translational displacement of protein-coated particles on a protein-functionalized substrate. The translational displacement scales with the effective friction induced by a PPI, thus producing a mechanical signal when a binding event occurs. The METRIS assay uses as little as 20 pmols of reagents to measure a wide range of affinities while exhibiting a high resolution and sensitivity. We use METRIS to measure several PPIs that were previously inaccessible using traditional methods, providing new insights into epigenetic recognition.

Identification of Ubiquitin Variants That Inhibit the E2 Ubiquitin Conjugating Enzyme, Ube2k

Transfer of ubiquitin to substrate proteins regulates most processes in eukaryotic cells. E2 enzymes are a central component of the ubiquitin machinery, and generally determine the type of ubiquitin signal generated and thus the ultimate fate of substrate proteins. The E2, Ube2k, specifically builds degradative ubiquitin chains on diverse substrates. Here we have identified protein-based reagents, called ubiquitin variants (UbVs), that bind tightly and specifically to Ube2k. Crystal structures reveal that the UbVs bind to the E2 enzyme at a hydrophobic cleft that is distinct from the active site and previously identified ubiquitin binding sites. We demonstrate that the UbVs are potent inhibitors of Ube2k and block both ubiquitin charging of the E2 enzyme and E3-catalyzed ubiquitin transfer. The binding site of the UbVs suggests they directly clash with the ubiquitin activating enzyme, while potentially disrupting interactions with E3 ligases via allosteric effects. Our data reveal the first protein-based inhibitors of Ube2k and unveil a hydrophobic groove that could be an effective target for inhibiting Ube2k and other E2 enzymes.

A Concerted Action of UBA5 C-Terminal Unstructured Regions Is Important for Transfer of Activated UFM1 to UFC1

Ubiquitin fold modifier 1 (UFM1) is a member of the ubiquitin-like protein family. UFM1 undergoes a cascade of enzymatic reactions including activation by UBA5 (E1), transfer to UFC1 (E2) and selective conjugation to a number of target proteins via UFL1 (E3) enzymes. Despite the importance of ufmylation in a variety of cellular processes and its role in the pathogenicity of many human diseases, the molecular mechanisms of the ufmylation cascade remains unclear. In this study we focused on the biophysical and biochemical characterization of the interaction between UBA5 and UFC1. We explored the hypothesis that the unstructured C-terminal region of UBA5 serves as a regulatory region, controlling cellular localization of the elements of the ufmylation cascade and effective interaction between them. We found that the last 20 residues in UBA5 are pivotal for binding to UFC1 and can accelerate the transfer of UFM1 to UFC1. We solved the structure of a complex of UFC1 and a peptide spanning the last 20 residues of UBA5 by NMR spectroscopy. This structure in combination with additional NMR titration and isothermal titration calorimetry experiments revealed the mechanism of interaction and confirmed the importance of the C-terminal unstructured region in UBA5 for the ufmylation cascade.

Targeting TRIM Proteins: A Quest towards Drugging an Emerging Protein Class

The ubiquitylation machinery regulates several fundamental biological processes from protein homeostasis to a wide variety of cellular signaling pathways. As a consequence, its dysregulation is linked to diseases including cancer, neurodegeneration, and autoimmunity. With this review, we aim to highlight the therapeutic potential of targeting E3 ligases, with a special focus on an emerging class of RING ligases, named tri-partite motif (TRIM) proteins, whose role as targets for drug development is currently gaining pharmaceutical attention. TRIM proteins exert their catalytic activity as scaffolds involved in many protein-protein interactions, whose multidomains and adapter-like nature make their druggability very challenging. Herein, we give an overview of the current understanding of this class of single polypeptide RING E3 ligases and discuss potential targeting options.

Crystal structures of an E1-E2-ubiquitin thioester mimetic reveal molecular mechanisms of transthioesterification

E1 enzymes function as gatekeepers of ubiquitin (Ub) signaling by catalyzing activation and transfer of Ub to tens of cognate E2 conjugating enzymes in a process called E1-E2 transthioesterification. The molecular mechanisms of transthioesterification and the overall architecture of the E1-E2-Ub complex during catalysis are unknown. Here, we determine the structure of a covalently trapped E1-E2-ubiquitin thioester mimetic. Two distinct architectures of the complex are observed, one in which the Ub thioester (Ub(t)) contacts E1 in an open conformation and another in which Ub(t) instead contacts E2 in a drastically different, closed conformation. Altogether our structural and biochemical data suggest that these two conformational states represent snapshots of the E1-E2-Ub complex pre- and post-thioester transfer, and are consistent with a model in which catalysis is enhanced by a Ub(t)-mediated affinity switch that drives the reaction forward by promoting productive complex formation or product release depending on the conformational state.

Identification of a Catalytic Active but Non-Aggregating MDM2 RING Domain Variant

As a key regulator of the tumour suppressor protein p53, MDM2 is involved in various types of cancer and has thus been an attractive drug target. So far, small molecule design has primarily focussed on the N-terminal p53-binding domain although on-target toxicity effects have been reported. Targeting the catalytic RING domain of MDM2 resembles an alternative approach to drug MDM2 with the idea to prevent MDM2-mediated ubiquitination of p53 while retaining MDM2's ability to bind p53. The design of RING inhibitors has been limited by the extensive aggregation tendency of the RING domain, making it challenging to undertake co-crystallization attempts with potential inhibitors. Here we compare the purification profiles of the MDM2 RING domain from several species and show that the MDM2 RING domain of other species than human is much less prone to aggregate although the overall structure of the RING domain is conserved. Through sequence comparison and mutagenesis analyses, we identify a single point mutation, G443T, which greatly enhances the dimeric fraction of human MDM2 RING domain during purification. Neither does the mutation alter the structure of the RING domain, nor does it affect E2(UbcH5B)-Ub binding and activity. Hence, MDM2-G443T facilitates studies involving binding partners that would be hampered by the low solubility of the wild-type RING domain. Furthermore, it will be valuable for the development of MDM2 RING inhibitors.

How Is the Fidelity of Proteins Ensured in Terms of Both Quality and Quantity at the Endoplasmic Reticulum? Mechanistic Insights into E3 Ubiquitin Ligases

The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is an interconnected organelle that plays fundamental roles in the biosynthesis, folding, stabilization, maturation, and trafficking of secretory and transmembrane proteins. It is the largest organelle and critically modulates nearly all aspects of life. Therefore, in the endoplasmic reticulum, an enormous investment of resources, including chaperones and protein folding facilitators, is dedicated to adequate protein maturation and delivery to final destinations. Unfortunately, the folding and assembly of proteins can be quite error-prone, which leads to the generation of misfolded proteins. Notably, protein homeostasis, referred to as proteostasis, is constantly exposed to danger by flows of misfolded proteins and subsequent protein aggregates. To maintain proteostasis, the ER triages and eliminates terminally misfolded proteins by delivering substrates to the ubiquitin–proteasome system (UPS) or to the lysosome, which is termed ER-associated degradation (ERAD) or ER-phagy, respectively. ERAD not only eliminates misfolded or unassembled proteins via protein quality control but also fine-tunes correctly folded proteins via protein quantity control. Intriguingly, the diversity and distinctive nature of E3 ubiquitin ligases determine efficiency, complexity, and specificity of ubiquitination during ERAD. ER-phagy utilizes the core autophagy machinery and eliminates ERAD-resistant misfolded proteins. Here, we conceptually outline not only ubiquitination machinery but also catalytic mechanisms of E3 ubiquitin ligases. Further, we discuss the mechanistic insights into E3 ubiquitin ligases involved in the two guardian pathways in the ER, ERAD and ER-phagy. Finally, we provide the molecular mechanisms by which ERAD and ER-phagy conduct not only protein quality control but also protein quantity control to ensure proteostasis and subsequent organismal homeostasis.

NEDD8 and ubiquitin ligation by cullin-RING E3 ligases

RING E3s comprise the largest family of ubiquitin (UB) and ubiquitin-like protein (UBL) ligases. RING E3s typically promote UB or UBL transfer from the active site of an associated E2 enzyme to a distally-recruited substrate. Many RING E3s - including the cullin-RING ligase family - are multifunctional, interacting with various E2s (or other E3s) to target distinct proteins, transfer different UBLs, or to initially modify substrates with UB or subsequently elongate UB chains. Here we consider recent structures of cullin-RING ligases, and their partner E2 enzymes, representing ligation reactions. The studies collectively reveal multimodal mechanisms - interactions between ancillary E2 or E3 domains, post-translational modifications, or auxiliary binding partners - directing cullin-RING E3-E2 enzyme active sites to modify their specific targets.

Hug and hold tight: Dimerization controls the turnover of the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme UBE2S

Precise control of the activity and abundance of ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (E2s) ensures fidelity in ubiquitin chain synthesis. In this issue of Science Signaling, Liess et al. demonstrate that the human anaphase-promoting complex (APC/C)-associated E2 UBE2S adopts an autoinhibited dimeric state that increases the half-life of UBE2S by preventing its autoubiquitination-driven turnover.

Assessing the Direct Binding of Ark-Like E3 RING Ligases to Ubiquitin and Its Implication on Their Protein Interaction Network

The ubiquitin pathway required for most proteins’ targeted degradation involves three classes of enzymes: E1-activating enzyme, E2-conjugating enzyme, and E3-ligases. The human Ark2C is the single known E3 ligase that adopts an alternative, Ub-dependent mechanism for the activation of Ub transfer in the pathway. Its RING domain binds both E2-Ub and free Ub with high affinity, resulting in a catalytic active Ub_R-RING-E2-Ub_D complex formation. We examined potential changes in the conformational plasticity of the Ark2C RING domain and its ligands in their complexed form within the ubiquitin pathway through molecular dynamics (MD). Three molecular mechanics force fields compared to previous NMR relaxation studies of RING domain of Arkadia were used for effective and accurate assessment of MDs. Our results suggest the Ark2C Ub-RING docking site has a substantial impact on maintaining the conformational rigidity of E2-E3 assembly, necessary for the E3’s catalytic activity. In the Ub_R-RING-E2-Ub_D catalytic complex, the Ub_R molecule was found to have greater mobility than the other Ub, bound to E2. Furthermore, network-based bioinformatics helped us identify E3 RING ligase candidates which potentially exhibit similar structural modules as Ark2C, along with predicted substrates targeted by the Ub-binding RING Ark2C. Our findings could trigger a further exploration of related unrevealed functions of various other E3 RING ligases.

Structural insights into ADP-ribosylation of ubiquitin by Deltex family E3 ubiquitin ligases

Cellular cross-talk between ubiquitination and other posttranslational modifications contributes to the regulation of numerous processes. One example is ADP-ribosylation of the carboxyl terminus of ubiquitin by the E3 DTX3L/ADP-ribosyltransferase PARP9 heterodimer, but the mechanism remains elusive. Here, we show that independently of PARP9, the conserved carboxyl-terminal RING and DTC (Deltex carboxyl-terminal) domains of DTX3L and other human Deltex proteins (DTX1 to DTX4) catalyze ADP-ribosylation of ubiquitin's Gly76 Structural studies reveal a hitherto unknown function of the DTC domain in binding NAD+ Deltex RING domain recruits E2 thioesterified with ubiquitin and juxtaposes it with NAD+ bound to the DTC domain to facilitate ADP-ribosylation of ubiquitin. This ubiquitin modification prevents its activation but is reversed by the linkage nonspecific deubiquitinases. Our study provides mechanistic insights into ADP-ribosylation of ubiquitin by Deltex E3s and will enable future studies directed at understanding the increasingly complex network of ubiquitin cross-talk.

Ubiquitination in the ERAD Process

In this review, we focus on the ubiquitination process within the endoplasmic reticulum associated protein degradation (ERAD) pathway. Approximately one third of all synthesized proteins in a cell are channeled into the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) lumen or are incorporated into the ER membrane. Since all newly synthesized proteins enter the ER in an unfolded manner, folding must occur within the ER lumen or co-translationally, rendering misfolding events a serious threat. To prevent the accumulation of misfolded protein in the ER, proteins that fail the quality control undergo retrotranslocation into the cytosol where they proceed with ubiquitination and degradation. The wide variety of misfolded targets requires on the one hand a promiscuity of the ubiquitination process and on the other hand a fast and highly processive mechanism. We present the various ERAD components involved in the ubiquitination process including the different E2 conjugating enzymes, E3 ligases, and E4 factors. The resulting K48-linked and K11-linked ubiquitin chains do not only represent a signal for degradation by the proteasome but are also recognized by the AAA+ ATPase Cdc48 and get in the process of retrotranslocation modified by enzymes bound to Cdc48. Lastly we discuss the conformations adopted in particular by K48-linked ubiquitin chains and their importance for degradation.