Sensitivity of [11C]N-methylpyrrolidinyl benzilate ([11C]NMPYB) to endogenous acetylcholine: PET imaging vs tissue sampling methods

Application of cross-species PET imaging to assess neurotransmitter release in brain

RATIONALE

This review attempts to summarize the current status in relation to the use of positron emission tomography (PET) imaging in the assessment of synaptic concentrations of endogenous mediators in the living brain.

OBJECTIVES

Although PET radioligands are now available for more than 40 CNS targets, at the initiation of the Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI) "Novel Methods leading to New Medications in Depression and Schizophrenia" (NEWMEDS) in 2009, PET radioligands sensitive to an endogenous neurotransmitter were only validated for dopamine. NEWMEDS work-package 5, "Cross-species and neurochemical imaging (PET) methods for drug discovery", commenced with a focus on developing methods enabling assessment of changes in extracellular concentrations of serotonin and noradrenaline in the brain.

RESULTS

Sharing the workload across institutions, we utilized in vitro techniques with cells and tissues, in vivo receptor binding and microdialysis techniques in rodents, and in vivo PET imaging in non-human primates and humans. Here, we discuss these efforts and review other recently published reports on the use of radioligands to assess changes in endogenous levels of dopamine, serotonin, noradrenaline, γ-aminobutyric acid, glutamate, acetylcholine, and opioid peptides. The emphasis is on assessment of the availability of appropriate translational tools (PET radioligands, pharmacological challenge agents) and on studies in non-human primates and human subjects, as well as current challenges and future directions.

CONCLUSIONS

PET imaging directed at investigating changes in endogenous neurochemicals, including the work done in NEWMEDS, have highlighted an opportunity to further extend the capability and application of this technology in drug development.

Imaging of the muscarinic acetylcholine neuroreceptor in rats with the M2 selective agonist [18F]FP-TZTP

INTRODUCTION

[(18)F]FP-TZTP is an M2 muscarinic subtype selective receptor-binding radiotracer used in vivo to image human and nonhuman primate brain following both bolus injection and infusion. In order to carry out repeated studies in rodents, the techniques developed for primates must be transferred to rodents with the same precision. This includes obtaining a metabolite-corrected input function.

METHODS

We compared bolus injection with constant infusion in rats that were awake or under isoflurane anesthesia. Brain-plasma and brain-blood distribution ratios were calculated by dividing brain (18)F concentrations, determined in vivo by positron emission tomography imaging with the Advanced Technology Laboratory Animal Scanner, ex vivo by direct counting in excised brain tissue or by quantitative autoradiography by the plasma or whole blood concentrations that had been corrected for metabolite contents.

RESULTS

Blood volume constraints prevented adequate blood sampling to define a precise input function after bolus injection, thus preventing full kinetic analysis. Constant infusion, however, required fewer blood samples to define the input function, allowing calculation of distribution ratios, but complete equilibrium between plasma and tissue had not yet been reached after 120 min.

CONCLUSION

Our results showed that the blood clearance and metabolism were too rapid to obtain a reproducible input function after bolus injection. The equilibrium distribution ratios did not lead to precise biochemical parameters, but the constant infusion was more suitable in that distribution ratios between tissue and plasma were statistically more precise. Constant infusion is the better approach for studying [(18)F]FP-TZTP by small animal imaging.

Molecular Neuroimaging: From Conventional to Emerging Techniques

The use of molecular imaging techniques in the central nervous system (CNS) has a rich history. Most of the important developments in imaging-such as computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, single photon emission computed tomography, and positron emission tomography-began with neuropsychiatric applications. These techniques and modalities were then found to be useful for imaging other organs involved with various disease processes. Molecular imaging of the CNS has enabled scientists and researchers to understand better the basic biology of brain function and the way in which various disease processes affect the brain. Unlike other organs, the brain is not easily accessible, and it has a highly selective barrier at the endothelial cell level known as the blood-brain barrier. Furthermore, the brain is the most complex cellular network known to exist. Various neurotransmitters act in either an excitatory or an inhibitory fashion on adjacent neurons through a multitude of mechanisms. The various neuronal systems and the myriad of neurotransmitter systems become altered in many diseases. Some of the most devastating diseases, including Alzheimer disease, Parkinson disease, brain tumors, psychiatric disease, and numerous degenerative neurologic diseases, affect only the brain. Molecular neuroimaging will be critical to the future understanding and treatment of these diseases. Molecular neuroimaging of the brain shows tremendous promise for clinical application. In this article, the current state and clinical applications of molecular neuroimaging will be reviewed.

Anesthesia increases in vivo N-([18F]fluoroethyl)piperidinyl benzilate binding to the muscarinic cholinergic receptor

The in vivo binding of N-[18F]fluoroethyl-piperidinyl benzilate ([18F]FEPB) to the muscarinic cholinergic receptor was measured in awake and anesthetized rats. Studies were done using an equilibrium infusion technique to provide estimates of specific binding as distribution volume ratios. Anesthesia with either isoflurane or sodium pentobarbital produced a significant (65-90%) increase of radiotracer binding in receptor-rich brain regions (striatum, cortex, hippocampus) relative to awake controls. Pretreatment of anesthetized animals with the acetylcholinesterase inhibitor phenserine produced no further increases in radioligand binding, in contrast to the large (>70%) increases previously observed in awake animals following drug treatment. These studies demonstrate that anesthesia can produce significant changes in baseline biochemical measures that can obscure even very large effects of pharmacological challenges.

Effect of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors on the binding of nicotinic alpha4beta2 receptor PET radiotracer, (18)F-nifene: A measure of acetylcholine competition

Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (AChEI's) are used to treat Alzheimer's disease (AD), and the putative mode of action is to increase acetylcholine (ACh) levels. Our goal is to evaluate competition of ACh with nicotinic alpha4beta2 receptor PET agonist radiotracer, 2-[(18)F]fluoro-3-[2-((S)-3-pyrrolinyl)methoxy]pyridine ((18)F-nifene). This ability to measure ACh-(18)F-nifene competition may have potential to assess efficacy of AChEI's in vivo. In vitro studies in rat brain slices used two AChEI's, physostigmine (PHY) and galanthamine (GAL). Brain slices were incubated with (18)F-nifene and various concentrations of PHY (0.2-20 microM) or GAL (0.4-4 microM) prior to (18)F-nifene treatment. For ACh competition, slices were also incubated with PHY + 100 nM ACh or GAL + 100 nM ACh or 100 nM ACh alone. Nonspecific binding of (18)F-nifene was determined using 300 microM nicotine. In the in vitro rat brain homogenate binding assay, ACh inhibited (3)H-cytisine binding to alpha4beta2 receptors with K(i) values of 19.2 nM (with PHY) and 34.7 microM (no PHY) indicating approximately 1.8 x 10(3) weaker binding of ACh in the absence of AChEI. Binding of (18)F-nifene was not affected by PHY (0.2-20 microM) or ACh 100 nM alone but decreased substantially by PHY + ACh 100 nM in all brain regions (down by >40% of control in thalamus). Similarly, for GAL (4 microM) no effect on (18)F-nifene binding occurred but GAL (0.4-4 microM) + ACh 100 nM showed a reduction of (18)F-nifene binding in all brain regions (down by approximately 15%). The reduction in both cases is a result of ACh competition with (18)F-nifene in the presence of AChEI. These preliminary in vitro results suggest that ACh is able to compete with (18)F-nifene at the alpha4beta2 receptors in the presence of PHY or GAL. The effect is AChEI-concentration dependent and is greater for PHY than GAL. Thus (18)F-nifene has promise for assessing ACh levels and AChEI effects in vivo.

Mass effect of injected dose in small rodent imaging by SPECT and PET

This paper discusses the effect of mass (chemical quantity) of injected dose on positron emission tomography (PET) and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT). Commonly, PET or SPECT imaging study uses a "no-carrier added" dose, which contains a small amount of radioactive imaging agent (in picogram to microgram). For small animal (rodent) imaging studies, specifically targeting binding sites or biological processes, the mass (chemical quantity) in the dose may significantly modify the binding, pharmacokinetics and, ultimately, the imaging outcome. Due to differences in size and other physiological factors between humans and rodents, there is a dramatic divergence of mass effect between small animal and human imaging study. In small animal imaging studies, the mass, or effective dose (ED(50)), a dose required for 50% of receptor or binding site occupancy, is usually not directly related to binding potential (B(max)/K(d)) (measured by in vitro binding assay). It is likely that dynamic interplays between specific and nonspecific binding in blood circulation, transient lung retention, kidney excretion, liver-gallbladder flow, soft tissue retention as well as metabolism could each play a significant role in determining the concentration of the tracer in the target regions. When using small animal imaging for studying drug occupancy (either by a pretreatment, coinjection or chasing dose), the mass effects on imaging outcome are important factors for consideration.