The relative effect of climate variability on malaria incidence after scale-up of interventions in western Kenya: A time-series analysis of monthly incidence data from 2008 to 2019

Advance Warning and Response Systems in Kenya: A Scoping Review

Introduction

Infectious diseases (IDs) cause approximately 13.7 million deaths globally. The Kenyan Advance Warning and Response Systems (AW&RS) against ID outbreaks is a core capacity of the 2005 International Health Regulations and a key indicator of health security. We mapped evidence on Kenya's AW&RS and their enablers, and barriers for successfully detecting IDs, including climate-sensitive IDs.

Methods

We searched Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, Africa Index Medicus, and SCOPUS before August 26th, 2024. We also searched for grey literature on the Google Scholar search engine alongside the main repositories of Kenyan Universities. Two independent reviewers conducted study selection, while one reviewer extracted data. Discrepancies were resolved through discussion. Results were synthesised narratively and thematically.

Results

The search yielded 4,379 records from databases and 1,363 articles from websites, university repositories, and citations; we included 166 articles in the analysis. Integrated Disease Surveillance and Response (IDSR) and cohort surveillance systems were the most common (37.2%). Most studies were concentrated in Nairobi County (25.7%) and reported on malaria (23.6%). Most systems (82.4%) monitored the disease burden and outbreaks using hospital-based data (35.1%) and automated alert mechanisms (27.7%). National bulletins report a temporal association between environmental factors and disease prevalence. Malaria, Rift Valley Fever (RVF), and cholera cases increased with higher precipitation, lower temperatures and increased vegetative index. AW&RS used the accuracy and reliability of the model prediction to measure the system's performance. Effectiveness was evaluated based on system acceptability and timeliness. Health system factors were predominant, with 121 enablers and 127 barriers. Key enablers included skilled personnel (13 studies), whereas inadequate finances were a major barrier (21 studies).

Conclusion

Most AW&RS were IDSR and cohort-based surveillance. Climate changes have resulted in observed trends in diseases such as malaria and RVF, but further studies are needed to determine causal links. Insufficient funding hinders the effective implementation of AW&RS. Future research should assess the cost drivers influencing system effectiveness.

The Double Burden: Climate Change Challenges for Health Systems

Climate change presents significant challenges to human health and health systems, and there is a critical need for health systems to adapt and become more resilient in order to effectively mediate the impacts of climate change on population health. This paper analyzes existing academic literature to identify key themes, trends, and research gaps at the intersection of climate change and health systems. Utilizing a scoping review of 179 studies, we explore how health systems can enhance their resilience through effective governance, sustainable financing, resource generation, and adaptive service delivery. Our findings emphasize the importance of integrating climate considerations into health system governance, mobilizing innovative financial resources, and adapting infrastructure and workforce capacities to address climate-related health challenges. The study highlights the need for continued interdisciplinary research and targeted interventions to ensure health systems are equipped to promote equity and protect vulnerable populations in the face of climate change. These insights contribute to the development of climate-resilient health systems and identify crucial areas for future research.

Impact of Climate Variability and Interventions on Malaria Incidence and Forecasting in Burkina Faso

BACKGROUND

Malaria remains a climate-driven public health issue in Burkina Faso, yet the interactions between climatic factors and malaria interventions across different zones are not well understood. This study estimates time delays in the effects of climatic factors on malaria incidence, develops forecasting models, and assesses their short-term forecasting performance across three distinct climatic zones: the Sahelian zone (hot/arid), the Sudano-Sahelian zone (moderate temperatures/rainfall); and the Sudanian zone (cooler/wet).

METHODS

Monthly confirmed malaria cases of children under five during the period 2015-2021 were analyzed using Bayesian generalized autoregressive moving average negative binomial models. The predictors included land surface temperature (LST), rainfall, the coverage of insecticide-treated net (ITN) use, and the coverage of artemisinin-based combination therapies (ACTs). Bayesian variable selection was used to identify the time delays between climatic suitability and malaria incidence. Wavelet analysis was conducted to understand better how fluctuations in climatic factors across different time scales and climatic zones affect malaria transmission dynamics.

RESULTS

Malaria incidence averaged 9.92 cases per 1000 persons per month from 2015 to 2021, with peak incidences in July and October in the cooler/wet zone and October in the other zones. Periodicities at 6-month and 12-month intervals were identified in malaria incidence and LST and at 12 months for rainfall from 2015 to 2021 in all climatic zones. Varying lag times in the effects of climatic factors were identified across the zones. The highest predictive power was observed at lead times of 3 months in the cooler/wet zone, followed by 2 months in the hot/arid and moderate zones. Forecasting accuracy, measured by the mean absolute percentage error (MAPE), varied across the zones: 28% in the cooler/wet zone, 53% in the moderate zone, and 45% in the hot/arid zone. ITNs were not statistically important in the hot/arid zone, while ACTs were not in the cooler/wet and moderate zones.

CONCLUSIONS

The interaction between climatic factors and interventions varied across zones, with the best forecasting performance in the cooler/wet zone. Zone-specific intervention planning and model development adjustments are essential for more efficient early-warning systems.

The influence of malaria control interventions and climate variability on changes in the geographical distribution of parasite prevalence in Kenya between 2015 and 2020

BACKGROUND

The burden of malaria in Kenya was showing a declining trend, but appears to have reached a plateau in recent years. This study estimated changes in the geographical distribution of malaria parasite risk in the country between the years 2015 and 2020, and quantified the contribution of malaria control interventions and climatic/ environmental factors to these changes.

METHODS

Bayesian geostatistical models were used to analyse the Kenyan 2015 and 2020 Malaria Indicator Survey (MIS) data. Bivariate models were fitted to identify the most important control intervention indicators and climatic/environmental predictors of parasitaemia risk by age groups (6-59 months and 5-14 years). Parasitaemia risk and the number of infected children were predicted over a 1 × 1 km2 grid. The probability of the decline in parasitaemia risk in 2020 compared to 2015 was also evaluated over the gridded surface and factors associated with changes in parasitaemia risk between the two surveys were evaluated.

RESULTS

There was a significant decline in the coverage of most malaria indicators related to Insecticide Treated Nets (ITN) and Artemisinin Combination Therapies (ACT) interventions. Overall, there was a 31% and 26% reduction in malaria prevalence among children aged < 5 and 5-14 years, respectively. Among younger children, the highest reduction (50%) and increase (41%) were in the low-risk and semi-arid epi zones, respectively; while among older children there was increased risk in both the low-risk (83%) and semi-arid (100%) epi zones. Increase in nightlights and the proportion of individuals using ITNs in 2020 were associated with reduced parasitaemia risk.

CONCLUSION

Increased nightlights and ITN use could have led to the reduction in parasitaemia risk. However, the reduction is heterogeneous and there was increased risk in northern Kenya. Taken together, these results suggest that constant surveillance and re-evaluation of parasite and vector control measures in areas with increased transmission is necessary. The methods used in this analysis can be employed in other settings.

Forecasting malaria dynamics based on causal relations between control interventions, climatic factors, and disease incidence in western Kenya

Background

Malaria remains one of the deadliest diseases worldwide, especially among young children in sub-Saharan Africa. Predictive models are necessary for effective planning and resource allocation; however, statistical models suffer from association pitfalls. In this study, we used empirical dynamic modelling (EDM) to investigate causal links between climatic factors and intervention coverage with malaria for short-term forecasting.

Methods

Based on data spanning the period from 2008 to 2022, we used convergent cross-mapping (CCM) to identify suitable lags for climatic drivers and investigate their effects, interaction strength, and suitability ranges on malaria incidence. Monthly malaria cases were collected at St. Elizabeth Lwak Mission Hospital. Intervention coverage and population movement data were obtained from household surveys in Asembo, western Kenya. Daytime land surface temperature (LSTD), rainfall, relative humidity (RH), wind speed, solar radiation, crop cover, and surface water coverage were extracted from remote sensing sources. Short-term forecasting of malaria incidence was performed using state-space reconstruction.

Results

We observed causal links between climatic drivers, bed net use, and malaria incidence. LSTD lagged over the previous month; rainfall and RH lagged over the previous two months; and wind speed in the current month had the highest predictive skills. Increases in LSTD, wind speed, and bed net use negatively affected incidence, while increases in rainfall and humidity had positive effects. Interaction strengths were more pronounced at temperature, rainfall, RH, wind speed, and bed net coverage ranges of 30-35°C, 30-120 mm, 67-80%, 0.5-0.7 m/s, and above 90%, respectively. Temperature and rainfall exceeding 35°C and 180 mm, respectively, had a greater negative effect. We also observed good short-term predictive performance using the multivariable forecasting model (Pearson correlation coefficient = 0.85, root mean square error = 0.15).

Conclusions

Our findings demonstrate the utility of CCM in establishing causal linkages between malaria incidence and both climatic and non-climatic drivers. By identifying these causal links and suitability ranges, we provide valuable information for modelling the impact of future climate scenarios.

The effects of climatic and non-climatic factors on malaria mortality at different spatial scales in western Kenya, 2008-2019

BACKGROUND

Malaria mortality is influenced by several factors including climatic and environmental factors, interventions, socioeconomic status (SES) and access to health systems. Here, we investigated the joint effects of climatic and non-climatic factors on under-five malaria mortality at different spatial scales using data from a Health and Demographic Surveillance System (HDSS) in western Kenya.

METHODS

We fitted Bayesian spatiotemporal (zero-inflated) negative binomial models to monthly mortality data aggregated at the village scale and over the catchment areas of the health facilities within the HDSS, between 2008 and 2019. First order autoregressive temporal and conditional autoregressive spatial processes were included as random effects to account for temporal and spatial variation. Remotely sensed climatic and environmental variables, bed net use, SES, travel time to health facilities, proximity from water bodies/streams and altitude were included in the models to assess their association with malaria mortality.

RESULTS

Increase in rainfall (mortality rate ratio (MRR)=1.12, 95% Bayesian credible interval (BCI): 1.04-1.20), Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (MRR=1.16, 95% BCI: 1.06-1.28), crop cover (MRR=1.17, 95% BCI: 1.11-1.24) and travel time to the hospital (MRR=1.09, 95% BCI: 1.04-1.13) were associated with increased mortality, whereas increase in bed net use (MRR=0.84, 95% BCI: 0.70-1.00), distance to the nearest streams (MRR=0.89, 95% BCI: 0.83-0.96), SES (MRR=0.95, 95% BCI: 0.91-1.00) and altitude (MRR=0.86, 95% BCI: 0.81-0.90) were associated with lower mortality. The effects of travel time and SES were no longer significant when data was aggregated at the health facility catchment level.

CONCLUSION

Despite the relatively small size of the HDSS, there was spatial variation in malaria mortality that peaked every May-June. The rapid decline in malaria mortality was associated with bed nets, and finer spatial scale analysis identified additional important variables. Time and spatially targeted control interventions may be helpful, and fine spatial scales should be considered when data are available.

Relative effects of climate factors and malaria control interventions on changes of parasitaemia risk in Burkina Faso from 2014 to 2017/2018

BACKGROUND

In Burkina Faso, the prevalence of malaria has decreased over the past two decades, following the scale-up of control interventions. The successful development of malaria parasites depends on several climatic factors. Intervention gains may be reversed by changes in climatic factors. In this study, we investigated the role of malaria control interventions and climatic factors in influencing changes in the risk of malaria parasitaemia.

METHODS

Bayesian logistic geostatistical models were fitted on Malaria Indicator Survey data from Burkina Faso obtained in 2014 and 2017/2018 to estimate the effects of malaria control interventions and climatic factors on the temporal changes of malaria parasite prevalence. Additionally, intervention effects were assessed at regional level, using a spatially varying coefficients model.

RESULTS

Temperature showed a statistically important negative association with the geographic distribution of parasitaemia prevalence in both surveys; however, the effects of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) use was negative and statistically important only in 2017/2018. Overall, the estimated number of infected children under the age of 5 years decreased from 704,202 in 2014 to 290,189 in 2017/2018. The use of ITNs was related to the decline at national and regional level, but coverage with artemisinin-based combination therapy only at regional level.

CONCLUSION

Interventions contributed more than climatic factors to the observed change of parasitaemia risk in Burkina Faso during the period of 2014 to 2017/2018. Intervention effects varied in space. Longer time series analyses are warranted to determine the differential effect of a changing climate on malaria parasitaemia risk.

Malaria, climate variability, and interventions: modelling transmission dynamics

Assessment of the relative impact of climate change on malaria dynamics is a complex problem. Climate is a well-known factor that plays a crucial role in driving malaria outbreaks in epidemic transmission areas. However, its influence in endemic environments with intensive malaria control interventions is not fully understood, mainly due to the scarcity of high-quality, long-term malaria data. The demographic surveillance systems in Africa offer unique platforms for quantifying the relative effects of weather variability on the burden of malaria. Here, using a process-based stochastic transmission model, we show that in the lowlands of malaria endemic western Kenya, variations in climatic factors played a key role in driving malaria incidence during 2008-2019, despite high bed net coverage and use among the population. The model captures some of the main mechanisms of human, parasite, and vector dynamics, and opens the possibility to forecast malaria in endemic regions, taking into account the interaction between future climatic conditions and intervention scenarios.