Does duckweed ponds used for wastewater treatment emit or sequester greenhouse gases?

A review on the role of duckweed (Lemna spp.) in the rejuvenation of aquatic bodies by pollutant remediation and recovery of valuable resources

Duckweed (Lemna species) is a group of fast-growing aquatic plants, widely recognized for its potential to restore polluted water bodies and recover valuable resources. The present review focused on the ecological importance of Lemna spp. in addressing ongoing environmental challenges. In order to obtain the relevant data, a literature search was conducted using the online database (Scopus), covering the period from 2015 to 2024. It has been observed that Lemna spp. has capabilities in nutrient assimilation, sequestering nitrogen, phosphorus, heavy metals, and emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals and pesticides. Also, the plant's biomass, generated during remediation, is a valuable resource for bioenergy, animal feed, and biofertilizer production, thereby contributing to the circular economy. However, several challenges remain significant, such as variations in environmental conditions, logistical barriers, and biomass disposal concerns. Integrating Lemna spp.-based systems into water management strategies aligns with global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly those related to clean water, sustainable urban development, and climate change mitigation. Empirical studies from regions like India, China, and the USA indicated its socio-economic and environmental benefits. Thus, the present review article focused on its role in pollutant remediation, resource recovery, and potential for sustainable water resource management.

Optimization of Hoagland solution macro-elements as a culture media, for increasing protein content of duckweeds (Lemna minor)

This study aimed to increase the protein content of duckweed, a promising alternative to animal proteins and a sustainable source of plant protein cultivated via soilless agriculture, by manipulating the culture medium conditions (Hoagland solution). The contribution percentages of KH2PO4 and Ca(NO3)2, pivotal macro-elements in Hoagland solution affecting duckweed protein content, were determined using Plackett-Burman factorial design as 33.06 % and 36.61 %, respectively. Additionally, optimization was conducted employing response surface methodology, incorporating pH alongside KH2PO4 and Ca(NO3)2. Under optimal conditions of 3.92 mM KH2PO4, 7.95 mM Ca(NO3)2, and 7.22 pH, the protein content of duckweed increased significantly, reaching 51.09 % from 39.81 %. The duckweed cultivated in modified Hoagland solution exhibited protein content of 41.74 %, while duckweed grown in commercial Hoagland solution displayed protein content of 33.01 %. This study showed protein content of duckweed could significantly increase according to the growth medium and showcasing its potential as a sustainable source of plant protein.

A novel multitrophic biofloc technology for duckweed and Megalobrama amblycephala integrated culture: Improving nutrient utilization and animal welfare

Biofloc technology (BFT) is an eco-friendly aquaculture model that utilizes zero-exchange water. In this study, we investigated the integration of duckweed into BFT in an effort to enhance nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon utilization and to improve animal welfare for cultivating Megalobrama amblycephala. The experiment spanned 75 days, comparing a group of M. amblycephala supplemented with duckweed (DM) to a control group (CG) with no supplementation, where duckweed consumption relied solely on the feeding behavior of the fish. The concentrations of nitrate, total nitrogen, and phosphorus accumulation were lower in the DM than in the CG from day 45 onwards, with differences of 16.19, 26.90, and 1.45 mg/L, respectively, at the end of the experiment. The DM showed simultaneous increases of 5.77, 11.20, and 5.07 % in the absolute utilization of nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon, respectively. The abundance of TM7a (10.27 %), linked to nitrate absorption, became the dominant genus in the water of the DM. Additionally, the abundance of Cetobacterium, associated with carbohydrate digestion, was significantly higher in gut of the DM (23.83 %) than in the gut of CG (1.24 %, P < 0.05). Supplementing the diet of M. amblycephala with duckweed improved digestion and antioxidant enzyme activity. Transcriptome data showed that duckweed supplementation resulted in an increase in the expression of genes related to protein digestion and absorption and carbohydrate metabolism in M. amblycephala, and analysis of the significantly enriched pathways further supported improved antioxidant capacity. Based on the above results, we concluded that as M. amblycephala consumes more duckweed, the differences in nitrogen and phosphorus levels between the DM and CG would continue to increase, along with a simultaneous increase in fixed carbon. Thus, this study achieved the goal of recycling BFT resources and improving animal welfare by integrating duckweed.

Enhancing biomass production and biochemical compositions of Spirodela polyrhiza through superhydrophobic cultivation platforms at low light intensity

Duckweed, a floating macrophyte, has attracted interest in various fields such as animal feedstocks and bioenergy productions. Its enriched nutritional content and rapid growth rate make it particularly promising. However, common laboratory cultures of duckweed often experience fronds layering, diminishing the efficiency of sunlight capturing due to limited surface area on conventional cultivation platforms. In this work, we aimed to address the issue of fronds layering by introducing a novel cultivation platform - a superhydrophobic coated acrylic sheet. The sheet was prepared by spray-coating a suspension of beeswax and ethanol, and its effectiveness was evaluated by comparing the growth performance of giant duckweed, Spirodela polyrhiza, on this platform with that on a modified version. The superhydrophobic coated acrylic sheet (SHPA) and its variant with a metal mesh added (SHPAM) were employed as growing platforms, with a glass jar serving as the control. The plantlets were grown for 7 days with similar growth conditions under low light stress (25 μmol/m2/s). SHPAM demonstrated superior growth performance, achieving a mass gain of 102.12 ± 17.18 %, surpassing both SHPA (89.67 ± 14.97 %) and the control (39.26 ± 8.94 %). For biochemical compositions, SHPAM outperformed in chlorophyll content, protein content and lipid content. The values obtained were 1.021 ± 0.076 mg/g FW, 14.59 ± 0.58 % DW and 6.21 ± 0.75 % DW respectively. Therefore, this work proved that incorporation of superhydrophobic coatings on a novel cultivation platform significantly enhanced the biomass production of S. polyrhiza. Simultaneously, the biochemical compositions of the duckweeds were well-maintained, showcasing the potential of this approach for optimized duckweed cultivation.

The performance, mechanism and greenhouse gas emission potential of nitrogen removal technology for low carbon source wastewater

Excessive nitrogen can lead to eutrophication of water bodies. However, the removal of nitrogen from low carbon source wastewater has always been challenging due to the limited availability of carbon sources as electron donors. Biological nitrogen removal technology can be classified into three categories: heterotrophic biological technology (HBT) that utilizes organic matter as electron donors, autotrophic biological technology (ABT) that relies on inorganic electrons as electron donors, and heterotrophic-autotrophic coupling technology (CBT) that combines multiple electron donors. This work reviews the research progress, microbial mechanism, greenhouse gas emission potential, and challenges of the three technologies. In summary, compared to HBT and ABT, CBT shows greater application potential, although pilot-scale implementation is yet to be achieved. The composition of nitrogen removal microorganisms is different, mainly driven by electron donors. ABT and CBT exhibit the lowest potential for greenhouse gas emissions compared to HBT. N2O, CH4, and CO2 emissions can be controlled by optimizing conditions and adding constructed wetlands. Furthermore, these technologies need further improvement to meet increasingly stringent emission standards and address emerging pollutants. Common measures include bioaugmentation in HBT, the development of novel materials to promote mass transfer efficiency of ABT, and the construction of BES-enhanced multi-electron donor systems to achieve pollutant prevention and removal. This work serves as a valuable reference for the development of clean and sustainable low carbon source wastewater treatment technology, as well as for addressing the challenges posed by global warming.

Biofilter-constructed wetland-trophic pond system: A new strategy for effective sewage treatment and agricultural irrigation in rural area

Artificial ecosystems with high biological complexity are generally considered to be efficient in metabolizing substances and resistant to temperature shock. In this study, a novel near-natural system (BCT system), which consisted of simple biofilter, constructed wetland and trophic biology pond, was conducted to treat rural sewage in situ for irrigation into farmland. Water quality related to carbon and nutrients and microbial community were analyzed along the system to reveal the effect of each unit. The annual average removals of BCT system for TN, NH₄⁺-N, TP and COD could reach 46.53%, 52.18%, 41.48%, and 53.21%, respectively. There was no significant decrease for removal efficiencies from high temperature period (HTP, ≥15 °C) to low temperature period (LTP, <15 °C). In LTP, the trophic pond (TRP) removed 34.85% of TN, 33.93% of NH₄⁺-N, 13.71% of TP and 18.77% of COD, while the removal efficiencies of constructed wetland fluctuated greatly. The TRP facilitated the BCT system to maintain the removal capability during low temperature period. The relative abundance of denitrification functional genes in TRP increased nearly tenfold from HTP to LTP. The effluent quality from the system can meet the agricultural irrigation standards, demonstrating the effect of BCT system on sewage treatment and agricultural irrigation in rural area.

Phytoremediation of toxic chemicals in aquatic environment with special emphasis on duckweed mediated approaches

The discharge of toxic chemicals into water bodies and their linked detrimental effects on health is a global concern. Phytoremediation, an environment-friendly plant-based technology, has gained intensive interest over the last decades. For the aquatic phytoremediation process, the commonly available duckweeds have recently attracted significant attention due to their capacity to grow in diverse ecological niches, fast growth characteristics, suitable morphology for easy handling of biomass, and capacity to remove and detoxify various potential toxic elements and compounds. This review presents the progress of duckweed-assisted aquatic phytoremediation of toxic chemicals. A brief background of general phytoremediation processes, including the different phytoremediation methods and advances in understanding their underlying mechanisms, has been described. A summary of different approaches commonly practiced to assess the growth of the plants and their metal removal capacity in the phytoremediation process has also been included. A vast majority of studies have established that duckweed is an efficient plant catalyst to accumulate toxic heavy metals and organic contaminants, such as pesticides, fluorides, toxins, and aromatic compounds, reducing their toxicity from water bodies. The potential of this plant-based phytoremediation process for its downstream applications in generating value-added products for the rural economy and industrial interest has been identified.

Determining biota succession in a domestic wastewater pond system after treatment with a specific consortium microalgae

Wastewater stabilization ponds (WSPs) rely on the metabolic activities of the inhabiting microbiota to treat wastewater. A selected consortium of Chlorella vulgaris and Chlorella protothecoides were used to manipulate the natural resident microalgae assemblage to improve the treatment performance of a domestic wastewater pond treatment system in a coastal region. Since information is lacking about the resulting influence on the composition or succession of the phytoplankton or associated microbiota assemblage, the current study aimed to determine how dosing with the microalgae C. vulgaris and C. protothecoides change the efficiency of wastewater effluent treatment, as well as the composition and succession of the natural occurring phytoplankton and microbial assemblage throughout WSP system. After a year of specific microalgae inoculations, the effluent in part complied with the standards set by the Department of Water Affairs and Forestry (DWAF) and the USA, Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The cyanobacteria Microcystis aeruginosa dominated the sixth (75%) and seventh pond (97%) before the inoculation with C. vulgaris and C. protothecoide commenced. After 12 inoculation events C. vulgaris and C. protothecoides were dominant in ponds three to seven while the dominant microbial groups were Bacteroidetes, Cyanobacteria, Firmicutes, Planctomycetes, Proteobacteria, Spirochaetes, Synergistetes and Verrucomicrobia. After the microalgae treatment, the WSP effluent were more compliant regarding to the set guidelines for effluent than prior to microalgae treatment. Based on the ability of the C. vulgaris and C. protothecoides to improve the effluent water quality, it was evident that the consortium of microalgae can be use improve domestic wastewater effluent in rural nutrient sensitive catchments.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40201-022-00840-z.

Waste Stabilization Pond (WSP) for wastewater treatment: A review on factors, modelling and cost analysis

Waste stabilization pond (WSP) is natural technology which can be installed in centralized or semi-centralized sewerage systems for treatment of domestic and industrial wastewater, septage and sludge, etc. WSPs are highly efficient, simple to construct, low cost and easy to operate. It can be used as secondary or tertiary treatment unit in a treatment plant either individually or in a coupling manner. The algal-bacterial symbiosis in WSP makes it completely natural treatment process for which it becomes economic as compared to other treatment technologies in terms of its maintenance cost and energy requirement. Effluent from WSP can also be used for agricultural purpose, gardening, watering road, vehicle wash, etc. Advance technologies are being integrated for better design and efficiency of WSP, but the main challenges are the separation and removal of algal species which lead to deterioration of the water if stays long. Research is necessary to maximize algal growth yield, selection of beneficial strain and optimizing harvesting methods. This review focuses on the treatment mechanism in the pond, affecting factors, types of ponds, design equation, cost analysis.

Impact of High-Pressure Homogenization on the Cell Integrity of Tetradesmus obliquus and Seed Germination

Microalgae have almost unlimited applications due to their versatility and robustness to grow in different environmental conditions, their biodiversity and variety of valuable bioactive compounds. Wastewater can be used as a low-cost and readily available medium for microalgae, while the latter removes the pollutants to produce clean water. Nevertheless, since the most valuable metabolites are mainly located inside the microalga cell, their release implies rupturing the cell wall. In this study, Tetradesmus obliquus grown in 5% piggery effluent was disrupted using high-pressure homogenization (HPH). Effects of HPH pressure (100, 300, and 600 bar) and cycles (1, 2 and 3) were tested on the membrane integrity and evaluated using flow cytometry and microscopy. In addition, wheat seed germination trials were carried out using the biomass at different conditions. Increased HPH pressure or number of cycles led to more cell disruption (75% at 600 bar and 3 cycles). However, the highest increase in wheat germination and growth (40-45%) was observed at the lowest pressure (100 bar), where only 46% of the microalga cells were permeabilised, but not disrupted. Non-treated T. obliquus cultures also revealed an enhancing effect on root and shoot length (up to 40%). The filtrate of the initial culture also promoted shoot development compared to water (21%), reinforcing the full use of all the process fractions. Thus, piggery wastewater can be used to produce microalgae biomass, and mild HPH conditions can promote cell permeabilization to release sufficient amounts of bioactive compounds with the ability to enhance plant germination and growth, converting an economic and environmental concern into environmentally sustainable applications.

Long-term effect of sediment on the performance of a pilot-scale duckweed-based waste stabilization pond

Duckweed-based waste stabilization ponds (DWPs) have been widely used in wastewater treatment. However, the effects of sediment, an essential component of DWPs, on their performance have rarely been studied. In this study, two pilot-scale DWPs (12 m²) with sediment (DPS) and without sediment (DP) were evaluated over more than 1 year to determine the effects of sediment on duckweed growth, wastewater treatment, and greenhouse gas (GHG) production and emission in DWPs. The results indicated that the annual average duckweed growth rate were comparable, but protein content, carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) recovery rates of duckweed were slightly higher in the DPS than in the DP. Meanwhile, the dissolved oxygen (DO) and oxidation reduction potential (ORP), removal efficiencies of COD, TP, TN, NH₄⁺-N, and turbidity of pond water from the DPS were significantly lower than for DP. More importantly, the DPS had considerably higher CH₄ production/emission and global warming potential (GWP) than the DP, even though more than 90% of CH₄ released from the sediment was consumed during its passage through the water column and duckweed layer. Sediment increased the recoveries of C and N by 7.94% and 8.82%, respectively. Influencing degree for COD, TP, TN, NH₄⁺-N and turbidity were -27.92%, -20.98%, -22.61%, -24.13% and -14.91%, respectively; for pond water DO and ORP, the values were - 35.68% and -44.59%, respectively; and for CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O emission and "combined GWP", they were 21.66%, 271.67%, -8.47% and 178.02%, respectively. Thus, this study indicates that sediment formed in the DWPs has a multi-faced effect on the performance of a DWP. In particular, sediment has an unfavourable effect on the wastewater treatment and the GHGs mitigation, but a favourable effect on the protein content and the C and N recoveries in duckweed.

Productive wetlands restored for carbon sequestration quickly become net CO2 sinks with site-level factors driving uptake variability

Inundated wetlands can potentially sequester substantial amounts of soil carbon (C) over the long-term because of slow decomposition and high primary productivity, particularly in climates with long growing seasons. Restoring such wetlands may provide one of several effective negative emission technologies to remove atmospheric CO2 and mitigate climate change. However, there remains considerable uncertainty whether these heterogeneous ecotones are consistent net C sinks and to what degree restoration and management methods affect C sequestration. Since wetland C dynamics are largely driven by climate, it is difficult to draw comparisons across regions. With many restored wetlands having different functional outcomes, we need to better understand the importance of site-specific conditions and how they change over time. We report on 21 site-years of C fluxes using eddy covariance measurements from five restored fresh to brackish wetlands in a Mediterranean climate. The wetlands ranged from 3 to 23 years after restoration and showed that several factors related to restoration methods and site conditions altered the magnitude of C sequestration by affecting vegetation cover and structure. Vegetation established within two years of re-flooding but followed different trajectories depending on design aspects, such as bathymetry-determined water levels, planting methods, and soil nutrients. A minimum of 55% vegetation cover was needed to become a net C sink, which most wetlands achieved once vegetation was established. Established wetlands had a high C sequestration efficiency (i.e. the ratio of net to gross ecosystem productivity) comparable to upland ecosystems but varied between years undergoing boom-bust growth cycles and C uptake strength was susceptible to disturbance events. We highlight the large C sequestration potential of productive inundated marshes, aided by restoration design and management targeted to maximise vegetation extent and minimise disturbance. These findings have important implications for wetland restoration, policy, and management practitioners.

Zooplankton-based reactors for tertiary wastewater treatment: A pilot-scale case study

Nature-based wastewater treatments are an economic and sustainable alternative to intensive technologies in rural areas, although their efficiency needs to be improved. This study explores technological co-operation between zooplankton (e.g., Daphnia magna) and bacterial and algal biofilms in a 1.5 m³ zooplankton-based reactor for the on-site treatment of secondary urban wastewater. The efficiency of the reactor was evaluated over a 14-month period without any maintenance. The results suggest a low seasonality effect on nutrient polishing (organic matter and nitrogen) and the removal of solids (TSS and turbidity). The best performance, involving a decrease in organic carbon, nitrogen, E. coli loads, and solid content was achieved in winter when operating the reactor at 750 L d^-1. Under these conditions, the quality of the effluent water was suitable for its reuse for six different purposes in conformance with Spanish legislation. These results demonstrate that the zooplankton-based reactor presented here can be used as an eco-sustainable tertiary treatment to provide water suitable for reuse. On-site research revealed that the robustness of the reactor against temperature and oxygen fluctuations needs to be improved to ensure good performance throughout the year.

Greenhouse gases emissions from duckweed pond system treating polyester resin wastewater containing 1,4-dioxane and heavy metals

Phytoremediation of polyester resin wastewater containing 1,4-dioxane and heavy metals using Lemna gibba (L.gibba) was enhanced by incorporation of perforated polyethylene carrier materials (PCM) onto the duckweed pond (DWP) system. The DWP module was operated at a hydraulic retention times (HRTs) of 2, 4 and 6 days and as well as 1,4-dioxane loading rate of 16, 25 and 48 g/m³.d. The maximum removal efficiency of 54 ± 2.5% was achieved for 1,4-dioxane at an HRT of 6 days and loading rate of 16 g1,4-dioxane/m³.d. Similarly, the DWP system provided removal efficiencies of 28.3 ± 2.1, 93.2 ± 7.6, 95.7 ± 8.9 and 93.6 ± 4.9% for Cd²⁺, Cu²⁺, Zn²⁺ and Ni²⁺ at influent concentration of 0.037 ± 0.01, 1.2 ± 0.9, 27.2 ± 4.7 and 4.6 ± 1.2 mg/L respectively. The structural analysis by Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) clearly displayed a reduction of 1,4- dioxane in the treated effluent. A strong peak was detected for L. gibba plants at frequency of 3417.71 cm^-1 due to N-H stretching, which confirm the proposed mechanism of partially conversion of 1,4-dioxane into amino acids. Glycine, serine, aspartic, threonine and alanine content were increased in L. gibba by values of 35 ± 2.2, 40 ± 3.2, 48 ± 3.7, 31 ± 2.8, and 56 ± 4.1%, respectively. The contribution of DWP unit as a greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions were relatively low (1.65 gCO₂/Kg BOD_removed.d., and 18.3 gCO₂/Kg _biomass.d) due to photosynthesis process, low excess sludge production and consumption of CO₂ for nitrification process (1.4 gCO₂/kgN _removed.d). Based on these results, it is recommended to apply such a technology for treatment of polyester resin wastewater containing 1,4-dioxane and heavy metals at a HRT not exceeding 6 days.

Biosynthesis of the starch is improved by the supplement of nickel (Ni2+) in duckweed (Landoltia punctata)

Duckweed is a kind of floating aquatic plant and increasing its starch production is favorable for bioenergy. In this study, we found that starch biosynthesis was greatly promoted by the supplement of nickel ion (Ni²⁺) through the comparison of other different ions. The starch content in duckweed was increased by nearly eightfold when duckweed was treated with 20 µM Ni²⁺. The analysis of paraffin sections visually found that starch granules were more complete and dark blue in Ni²⁺ treated duckweed than the control. Quantitative real-time PCR demonstrated that the expressions of starch synthesis-related enzymes were up-regulated in Ni²⁺ treated duckweed. Further analysis revealed that the accumulation of Ni²⁺ in duckweed effectively increased the activity of urease, which compensated for the deficiency of certain decrease in biomass and accelerated biosynthesis of the starch. Thus, our results represent another strategy to improve starch production of duckweed.