Long-term effects of lithium and lithium-microplastic mixtures on the model species Daphnia magna: Toxicological interactions and implications to 'One Health'

Lithium with environmentally relevant concentrations interferes with mitochondrial function, antioxidant response, and autophagy processes in Daphnia magna, leading to changes in life-history traits and behavior

With the increasing production and use of lithium-based products, concerns over lithium pollution in aquatic ecosystems are increasing, whereas research on its toxicity mechanisms in aquatic organisms remains limited. The main objective of the present study was to explore the effects of environmentally relevant concentrations of lithium exposure on the life-history strategy, behavior, antioxidant system, and autophagy process of Daphnia magna. Acute (24-96 h) and chronic (21 days) exposure experiments under three lithium treatments (low: 8.34 μg/L, medium: 83.44 μg/L, and high: 834.41 μg/L) were conducted. The results indicated that exposure to medium and high lithium concentrations led to eye and tail deformities in D. magna. Furthermore, developmental and reproductive parameters such as body length, total neonates per female, and average neonates per time were negatively influenced. Lithium also interfered with energy metabolism to cause the decreasing swimming speed and the reduction in the swimming range. In addition, lithium exposure affected the expression of gsk-3β, further disrupting the dynamic balance of mitochondrial fission, fusion, and regeneration, which caused ROS accumulation and induced oxidative stress. D. magna attenuated the stress by activating the FoxO/SESN and Nrf2/Keap1 pathways, synergistically enhancing downstream antioxidant enzymes expression. Concurrently, D. magna also mitigated oxidative stress and mitochondrial damage by promoting autophagy and inhibiting apoptosis. In summary, lithium harmed the physiological and biochemical functions of D. magna through multiple mechanisms, suggesting that environmental lithium pollution may pose a potential threat to aquatic organisms.

Environmentally relevant concentrations lithium exposure induces neurotoxicity in yellowstripe goby (Mugilogobius chulae): Responses of BDNF/AKT/FoxOs in regulating glutamate excitotoxicity and mitochondrial function

The wide application of lithium in green energy and clinical psychiatry results in ubiquitous occurrence of lithium in aquatic environments. However, researches on the toxicity of lithium are largely confined to acute and/or high-dose scenarios, with insufficient data on its impacts on non-target organisms at environmental levels. The present study investigated the neurotoxicological effects of environmentally relevant concentrations of lithium exposure on yellowstripe goby (Mugilogobius chulae) and the related molecular response mechanisms. The results showed that lithium exposure significantly inhibited the expression of the target protein GSK-3β in the brain of M. chulae, and induced a series of harmful events including oxidative stress, glutamate accumulation, and even behavioral alteration. The organism mitigated the excitotoxic effects of glutamate accumulation by down-regulating ionotropic glutamate receptors. At the same time, the organism met the energy supply and alleviated oxidative stress by altering mitochondrial function. Notably, the stress regulators FoxOs and sestrins both modulated synaptic sensitivities to enhance the neural signaling and altered the energy metabolism pattern to alleviate energy crisis, all of which were important for maintaining neuronal survival and organismal homeostasis. In conclusion, lithium exposure induced glutamate excitability and led to a series of toxic events. Meanwhile, FoxOs played an important role in neural signaling and homeostatic regulation of energy metabolism in brain. This study furthered the comprehension of the neurotoxic impacts of lithium on aquatic organisms, elucidated the associated molecular mechanisms, and underscored the environmental risks posed by increasing lithium contamination.

Carcinogenicity and non-carcinogenicity health risks due to PM2.5 bound trace metals at a sub urban site in Northwest Indo-Gangetic Plain

This study investigates the PM2.5 bound metals using yearlong measurements at a regionally representative suburban site in the Northwest Indo-Gangetic Plain (NWIGP). The order of the measured annual average concentrations of PM2.5 bound metals is Fe > Zn > Ba > Sn > Pb > Cd > Ni > Mn > Cr > Li. Lithium bound to airborne PM2.5 has been reported for the first time in NWIGP. Ni (72.4 ng m-3) and Cd (36.9 ng m-3) have exceeded the acceptable limits set by NAAQS, India. Estimated the hazard quotient (HQ > 1) of Mn and hazard index (HI > 1) of measured metals exceeded the threshold limits indicating the potential non-carcinogenic health risk due to inhalation exposure of PM2.5 bound trace metals. Further, excessive lifetime cancer risk due to inhalation exposure to Cd, Ni and Cr was estimated and found to exceed the threshold limit set by the USEPA for adults and children.

Water acidification aggravates lithium-induced toxicity represented by energy supply, oxidative stress, and cell fate in Daphnia magna neonates

Lithium is extensively utilized in industrial energy production, particularly in lithium-ion batteries, and in pharmaceuticals for the treating clinical mood disorders. Consequently, lithium is frequently detected in various environmental matrices. It has been reported to cause a range of toxic effects on aquatic organisms including oxidative stress, neurological disorders, and reproductive suppression. Water acidification is a global issue with numerous negative impacts on aquatic organisms. It can alter the physio-chemical properties and bioavailability of metal ions. The acidic leaching process during lithium battery treatment and global water acidification both suggest that lithium contamination often occurs in acidic environments. In the present study, Daphnia magna neonates were exposed to four treatments (control, lithium alone, low pH, and combined) to investigate whether an acidic environment exacerbates the toxic effects of lithium on aquatic organisms and to explore potential toxic action mechanisms. The results indicated that low pH posed a significant threat to the growth and reproduction of D. magna. When exposed to both lithium and low pH, there was increased lithium accumulation and an energy trade-off response, leading to increased energy allocation to reproduction and reduced energy for growth. Lithium exposure stimulated D. magna activity, while low pH inhibited it, suggesting that an imbalance in energy consumption and supply. Combined exposure to lithium and low pH resulted in severe oxidative stress due to mitochondrial dysfunction, under-utilization of energy substances, and increased ionic homeostasis disturbances. Consequently, the exposed organism altered apoptosis and autophagy processes to maintain homeostasis. The present study demonstrated that lithium and water acidification posed a population-level threat to D. magna, and their combined exposure significantly largely exacerbated the toxic effects.

First evidence of lithium toxicity in the cryptic species complex of the estuarine copepod Eurytemora affinis

The development of renewable and low-carbon energy sources means that strategic elements such as lithium (Li) are increasingly being used. The data available on the effects of Li on aquatic organisms are relatively scarce. The copepod Eurytemora affinis, widely distributed in the brackish estuarine waters of the northern hemisphere, is a species of choice in ecotoxicology but in fact constitutes a cryptic species complex, composed of at least six cryptic species. Cryptic diversity can lead to misinterpretation and alter the reproducibility of routine ecotoxicological tests. In the present study, two cryptic species of the E. affinis complex from the Seine (European clade) and the St. Lawrence (North-Atlantic clade) estuaries were used to assess Li toxicity and to compare their differential sensitivity. Larvae were exposed to different concentrations of Li (0.4, 4.39, 35.36 and 80.83 mg L-1) under semi-static conditions for 96 h. Larval development stages were determined and log-logistic functions were fitted to evaluate mortality (LC50) and growth (EC50) parameters. After 96 h of exposure, the results showed that the European and North-Atlantic clades had LC50 values of 55.33 and 67.81 mg L-1 and EC50 values of 28.94 and 41.45 mg L-1, respectively. A moderate difference in sensitivity to Li between the European and North-Atlantic clades of the E. affinis complex was observed. Thus, the cryptic species diversity should be considered using E. affinis to avoid bias in the interpretation of the data. Despite environmental concentrations of Li are expected to increase over the next years, EC50 and LC50 found for E. affinis cryptic species are largely higher than Li environmental concentrations to provoke extreme effects.

Lithium Pollution and Its Associated Health Risks in the Largest Lithium Extraction Industrial Area in China

Lithium (Li) is an important resource that drives sustainable mobility and renewable energy. Its demand is projected to continue to increase in the coming decades. However, the risk of Li pollution has also emerged as a global concern. Here, we investigated the pollution characteristics, sources, exposure levels, and associated health risks of Li in the Jinjiang River basin, the largest area for Li2CO3 production in China. Our results revealed the dominant role of Li extraction activities in the pollution of the river, with over 95% of dissolved Li in downstream river water being emitted from this source. Moreover, the Li concentration in aquatic plants (i.e., water hyacinth) and animals (i.e., fish) significantly increased from upstream to downstream areas, indicating a significant risk to local aquatic ecosystems. More importantly, our study found that local residents were suffering potential chronic noncarcinogenic health risks primarily from consuming contaminated water and vegetables. We also investigated the pollution characteristics of associated elements present in Li ores (e.g., Rb, Cs, Ni, and F-). By uncovering the remarkable impact of Li extraction activities on the Li content in ecosystems for the first time, our study emphasizes the importance of evaluating Li pollution from Li-related industrial activities, including mining, extraction, and recovery.

Toxicological effects and mechanisms of lithium on growth, photosynthesis and antioxidant system in the freshwater microalga Chromochloris zofingiensis

The growing prevalence of lithium (Li) batteries has drawn public attention to Li as an emerging pollutant. The present study investigates the toxicity of Li+ on Chromochloris zofingiensis, examining physiological, biochemical and omics aspects. Results reveal hormesis effects of Li+ on C. zofingiensis growth. At Li+ concentrations below 5 mg L-1, Li+ can enhance chlorophyll content, mitochondrial activity, and antioxidant capacity, leading to increased dry cell weight and cell number. Conversely, when it exceeded 10 mg L-1, Li+ can reduce chlorophyll content, induce oxidative stress, and disrupt chloroplast and mitochondria structure and function, ultimately impeding cell growth. In addition, under 50 mg L-1 Li+ stress, microalgae optimize absorbed light energy use (increasing Fv/Fm and E TR ) and respond to stress by up-regulating genes in starch and lipid biosynthesis pathways, promoting the accumulation of storage components. Weighted gene co-expression network analysis indicates that peptidylprolyl cis/trans isomerase, GTPase and L-ascorbate oxidase might be the key regulators in response to Li+ stress. This research marks the toxic effects and molecular mechanisms of Li+ on freshwater microalga, which would improve our understanding of Li's toxicology and contributing to the establishment of Li pollution standards.

Concentration-dependent effects of lithium on Daphnia magna: Life-history profiles and integrated biomarker response implementation

The growing use of lithium (Li) in industrial and energy applications and increasing demand worldwide has inevitably resulted in its wide dispersal, representing a significant threat to aquatic systems. Unfortunately, as a ubiquitous emerging contaminant, the comprehensive toxicological information regarding Li at multifarious levels is limited. To diminish this gap, this work was focused to explore Li-induced cascading effects on Daphnia magna as a key species in freshwater ecosystems. Specifically, the organisms were chronically exposed to gradient Li concentrations with emphasis on characterizing life-history traits from individual to population scale, primarily as observed by a markedly concentration-dependent decrease along exposure gradients. In parallel, a robust set of biomarkers relating to energy reserves, antioxidant and biotransformation enzymes, cellular damage, ionoregulation and neurotoxicity were assayed for further understanding potential underlying mechanisms. As a result, biomarker alterations were characterized by significant decreases in energy storage and enzymatic profiles of antioxidant and biotransformation systems, not only triggering an imbalance between reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation and elimination under Li exposure, but compromising the fecundity fitness of phenotypical costs. In contrast, malondialdehyde (MDA) levels were remarkably enhanced as a consequence of inefficient antioxidant and biotransformation capacity leading to lipid peroxidation (LPO). Additionally, Li exerted a dose-dependent biphasic effect on the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD), Na+,K+-ATPase and acetylcholinesterase (AChE) by interfering with inherent balance. In terms of responsive patterns and dose-effect trends, the integrated biomarker response indices (IBRv2) and star plots were consistent with the differences in biomarker profiles, not only presenting comprehensively biological effects in a visualized form, but signaling the importance of progressive induced changes in an integrative way. Overall, these findings highlighted the need for elucidating Li-produced impacts from a comprehensive perspective, providing valuable insights into better understanding the toxicity of Li in relation to aquatic ecosystem functioning and ecological relevance.

Freshwater Lacustrine Zooplankton and Microplastic: An Issue to Be Still Explored

Lakes are essentially interlinked to humans as they provide water for drinking, agriculture, industrial and domestic purposes. The upsurge of plastic usage, its persistence, and potential detrimental effects on organisms cause impacts on the trophic food web of freshwater ecosystems; this issue, however, still needs to be explored. Zooplankton worldwide is commonly studied as an indicator of environmental risk in aquatic ecosystems for several pollutants. The aim of the review is to link the existing knowledge of microplastic pollution in zooplankton to assess the potential risks linked to these organisms which are at the first level of the lacustrine trophic web. A database search was conducted through the main databases to gather the relevant literature over the course of time. The sensitivity of zooplankton organisms is evident from laboratory studies, whereas several knowledge gaps exist in the understanding of mechanisms causing toxicity. This review also highlights insufficient data on field studies hampering the understanding of the pollution extent in lakes, as well as unclear trends on ecosystem-level cascading effects of microplastics (MPs) and mechanisms of toxicity (especially in combination with other pollutants). Therefore, this review provides insight into understanding the overlooked issues of microplastic in lake ecosystems to gain an accurate ecological risk assessment.

Toxicity of microplastics and nanoplastics: invisible killers of female fertility and offspring health

Microplastics (MPs) and nanoplastics (NPs) are emergent pollutants, which have sparked widespread concern. They can infiltrate the body via ingestion, inhalation, and cutaneous contact. As such, there is a general worry that MPs/NPs may have an impact on human health in addition to the environmental issues they engender. The threat of MPs/NPs to the liver, gastrointestinal system, and inflammatory levels have been thoroughly documented in the previous research. With the detection of MPs/NPs in fetal compartment and the prevalence of infertility, an increasing number of studies have put an emphasis on their reproductive toxicity in female. Moreover, MPs/NPs have the potential to interact with other contaminants, thus enhancing or diminishing the combined toxicity. This review summarizes the deleterious effects of MPs/NPs and co-exposure with other pollutants on female throughout the reproduction period of various species, spanning from reproductive failure to cross-generational developmental disorders in progenies. Although these impacts may not be directly extrapolated to humans, they do provide a framework for evaluating the potential mechanisms underlying the reproductive toxicity of MPs/NPs.

Presence, variation, and potential ecological impact of microplastics in the largest shallow lake of Central Europe

The presence of microplastics (MPs) in the global ecosystem has generated a rapidly growing concern worldwide. Although their presence in the marine environment has been well-studied, much less data are available on their abundance in freshwaters. MPs alone and in combination with different chemicals has been shown to cause acute and chronic effects on algae and aquatic invertebrate and vertebrate species at different biological levels. However, the combined ecotoxicological effects of MPs with different chemicals on aquatic organisms are still understudied in many species and the reported data are often controversial. In the present study, we investigated, for the first time, the presence of MPs in Lake Balaton, which is the largest shallow lake of Central Europe and an important summer holiday destination. Moreover, we exposed neonates of the well-established ecotoxicological model organism Daphnia magna to different MPs (polystyrene [3 μm] or polyethylene [≤ 100 μm]) alone and in combination with three progestogen compounds (progesterone, drospirenone, levonorgestrel) at an environmentally relevant concentration (10 ng L^-1) for 21 days. The presence of 7 polymer types of MPs in the size range of 50-100 μm was detected in Lake Balaton. Similarly to the global trends, polypropylene and polyethylene MPs were the most common types of polymer. The calculated polymer-independent average particle number was 5.5 particles m^-3 (size range: 50 μm - 100 μm) which represents the values detected in other European lakes. Our ecotoxicological experiments confirmed that MPs and progestogens can affect D. magna at the behavioral (body size and reproduction) and biochemical (detoxification-related enzyme activity) levels. The joint effects were negligible. The presence of MPs may lead to reduced fitness in the aquatic biota in freshwaters such as Lake Balaton, however, the potential threat of MPs as vectors for progestogens may be limited.

A critical review on the interaction of polymer particles and co-existing contaminants: Adsorption mechanism, exposure factors, effects on plankton species

This review considers the interaction of microplastics (MPs)/nanoplastics (NPs) and co-existing contaminants, including organic contaminants, potentially toxic elements (PTEs), and metal/metal-oxide nanoparticles. Stronger adsorption between plastic particles and co-existing contaminants can either facilitate or prevent more contaminants to enter plankton. The characteristics of MPs/NPs, such as polymer type, size, functional groups, and weathering, affect combined effects. Mixture toxicity is affected by those factors simultaneously and also affected by the type of co-existing contaminants, their concentrations, exposure time, dissolved organic matter, and surfactant. For co-exposure involving organics and metal nanoparticles, marine Skeletonema costatum generally had antagonistic effects, while marine Chlorella pyrenoidosa, Platymonas subcordiformis, and Tetraselmis chuii, showed synergistic effects. For co-exposure involving organics and PTEs, both Chlorella sp. and Microcystis aeruginosa generally demonstrated antagonistic effects. Freshwater Chlorella reinhardtii and Scenedesmus obliquus had synergistic effects for co-exposure involving metal/metal oxide nanoparticles. Zooplankton shows more unpredicted sensitivity towards the complex system. Different co-existing contaminants have different metabolism pathways. Organic contaminants could be biodegraded, which may enhance or alleviate mixture toxicity. PTEs could be adsorbed and desorbed under changing environments, and further affect the combined effects. The presence of metal/metal-oxide nanoparticles is more complicated, since some may release ion metals, increasing contaminant composition.

Microplastics enhance the toxicity and phototoxicity of UV filter avobenzone on Daphnia magna

Microplastics (MPs) and ultraviolet (UV) filters cause pollution in aquatic ecosystems. Moreover, regulations on the use and discharge of UV filters in personal care products are lacking. Therefore, the combined toxicity of MPs (virgin polystyrene (PS) spheres; size: 200 nm) and avobenzone (AVO; a UV filter) on Daphnia magna were assessed. The exposure groups were AVO, AVO + UV irradiation for 6 h [AVO (UV)], AVO with MPs (Mix), and AVO with MPs + UV irradiation for 6 h [Mix (UV)]. The daphnids were exposed to these treatments for 48 h and observed for an additional 6 h. Energy reserves of all treated groups increased compared to that of the control group. Growth in the Mix group was inhibited despite a high food uptake, and food uptake and growth inhibition were validated in the Mix (UV) group. Additionally, the food uptake of the AVO (UV) and Mix (UV) groups decreased during the recovery period, possibly owing to a decrease in the normal feeding ability resulting from an increase in abnormality. These results indicate that the combined toxicity of MPs+AVO can be exacerbated under natural conditions; the complex toxicity should be considered when assessing aquatic environment pollution.

Anthropogenic pollutants in Nephrops norvegicus (Linnaeus, 1758) from the NW Mediterranean Sea: Uptake assessment and potential impact on health

Anthropogenic pollution is considered one of the main threats to the marine environment, and there is an imperious need to assess its potential impact on ecologically and economically relevant species. This study characterises plastic ingestion and tissue levels of potentially toxic metallic elements in Nephrops norvegicus and their simultaneous levels in abiotic compartments from three locations of the Catalan coast (NW Mediterranean Sea). A multidisciplinary assessment of the health condition of N. norvegicus through condition indices, enzymatic biomarkers and histological techniques is provided, and its relationship with anthropogenic pollutant levels explored. Plastic fibres were commonly found in stomachs of N. norvegicus (85% of the individuals), with higher abundances (13 ± 21 fibres · ind^-1) in specimens captured close to Barcelona. The presence of long synthetic fibres in near-bottom waters, as well as the mirroring trends in abundance among locations for water and ingested plastics, suggest that uptake from water may be occurring potentially through suspension feeding. The spatial variability in the levels of metallic elements in N. norvegicus was poorly correlated to the variability in sediments. In any case, present levels in abdominal muscle are considered safe for human consumption. Levels of ingested plastics only showed significant, yet weak, correlations with glutathione S-transferase and catalase activities. However, no other health parameter analysed showed any trend potentially associated to anthropogenic pollutant levels. Neither the condition indices nor the histopathological assessment evidenced any signs of pathologic conditions affecting N. norvegicus. Thus, it was concluded that presently there is no evidence of a negative impact of the studied pollutants on the health condition of N. norvegicus in the studied grounds.

Toxicopathic effects of lithium in mussels

The rising use of lithium (Li) in industrial processes, modern technology and medicine has generated concerns in the scientific community, in particular its potential impact on the environment. Unfortunately, there is only scarce information concerning the toxicity of lithium in marine organisms. The objective of this study is to determine the toxicity of Li using Mytilus galloprovincialis as model organism, based on acute and sublethal toxicity tests. In the first experiment, mussels were exposed for 9 days to a range of acute concentrations of Li (0, 2, 5, 13, 34, 89, 233 and 610 mg/L Li) in order to find the median lethal concentration. In the sublethal experiment, mussels were exposed to environmentally relevant concentrations of Li (0, 0.1, 1, 10 mg/L Li) for 21 days. Digestive gland and gonad samples were taken at day 0, 1, 7 and 21 for histopathological analysis. Samples of the whole mussels were taken for chemical analysis at day 0 and after 21 days. Results showed that M. galloprovincialis had a LC50 value of 153 mg/L Li after 9 days of exposure. Lower concentrations (environmentally relevant), led to Li bioaccumulation in a dose-dependent manner and histopathological effects in a time-dependent manner. Atrophy of the digestive alveoli epithelium and degeneration of the digestive gland were observed after 21 days of exposure. These findings open new perspectives for the understanding of the toxic effects of Li on marine organisms and evidence the need for further long-term research at different levels of biological organizations.

Lithium Accumulation in Salvinia natans Free-Floating Aquatic Plant

The new context of the intensive use of lithium-based batteries led to increased production of Li and Li-containing wastes. All these activities are potential sources of environmental pollution with Li. However, the negative impact of Li on ecosystems, its specific role in the plants' development, uptake mechanism, and response to the induced stress are not fully understood. In this sense, the Li uptake and changes induced by Li exposure in the major and trace element contents, photosynthetic pigments, antioxidant activity, and elemental composition of Salvinia natans were also investigated. The results showed that Salvinia natans grown in Li-enriched nutrient solutions accumulated much higher Li contents than those grown in spring waters with a low Li content. However, the Li bioaccumulation factor in Salvinia natans grown in Li-enriched nutrient solutions was lower (13.3-29.5) than in spring waters (13.0-42.2). The plants exposed to high Li contents showed a decrease in their K and photosynthetic pigments content, while their total antioxidant activity did not change substantially.