Phosphorus recovery and reuse in water bodies with simple ball-milled Ca-loaded biochar

Phosphorus recovery and reuse: Innovating with biochar in the circular economy

Global challenges of phosphorus pollution and scarcity underscore an urgent need for the efficient recycling of this critical resource. Biochar, a sustainable and economical material, has demonstrated significant potential as an adsorbent for phosphorus, offering a viable solution for its recovery from wastewater. Various techniques have been explored to improve the ability of biochar to adsorb inorganic phosphate. While numerous studies have reviewed methods of biochar modification, the underlying adsorption mechanisms, and the thermodynamics and kinetics involved, a thorough examination that addresses the practical challenges of real-world wastewater treatment is currently lacking. This review aims to fill this gap by quantitatively analyzing the impact of coexisting species in wastewater on the adsorption of phosphate and by exploring the potential for simultaneous removal of other contaminants, such as nutrients, heavy metals, and dissolved organic matter. The review also discusses factors that affect the desorption of phosphate from biochar and presents practical applications for biochars post-adsorption. These applications include their use as slow-release phosphorus fertilizers, additives in concrete, and as novel adsorbents for the removal of heavy metals. This comprehensive analysis serves to synthesize current research on phosphate recovery by biochars and to propose practical uses for the adsorbed phosphorus, thereby guiding the development of biochar adsorption technology towards more effective and practical phosphorus management strategies.

Surface-bound Fe(0) and Fe(II) mediated by 2-picolinic acid functionalized zero-valent iron for highly Cr(VI) removal

Electron transfer of zero-valent iron (ZVI) is significantly impeded by its oxide layer, and limiting its removal of pollutants. In this study, 2-picolinic acid (PA) and ZVI were co-ball milled to improve electron transfer in ZVI (PA-ZVIbm), and used for the removal of heavy metal Cr(VI). Characterization analysis showed that the presence of electron-rich groups on the surface of PA-ZVIbm promoted the transfer of electrons from the Fe(0) core to the surface, and the surface Fe(0) and Fe(II) contents increased from 1.1 % to 6.3 % and from 60.2 % to 72.9 %, respectively, effectively reducing Cr(VI) through an electron transfer mechanism. Theoretical calculations showed that the modification of PA enhanced the adsorption of Cr(VI) on the ZVI surface, and the adsorption energy decreased from -3.561 eV to -5.119 eV. PA-ZVIbm showed strong advantages in the removal of Cr(VI), with a reaction rate constant and adsorption capacity 17 and 13 times that of ZVIbm, respectively, and a conversion rate of 100 %. Moreover, PA-ZVIbm showed excellent performance over a wide pH range (3-10) and under different coexisting ions, while being cost-effective and having low environmental risks. This study explored the relationship between ZVI surface modification and performance, and provided new insights into the modification of ZVI using small molecule oxygen-containing organic acids.

Effects of the combined use of lanthanum carbonate and activated carbon capping materials on phosphorus and dissolved organic matter in lake sediments

Lanthanum carbonate (LC) represents a novel material for the immobilization of internal phosphorus (P) in sediments. Activated carbon (AC) is a traditional adsorbent that has been employed in the remediation of sediments on a wide scale. The objective of this study is to examine the mechanisms and effects of the combined use of LC and AC capping materials on the immobilization of P and dissolved organic matter (DOM) in sediments, through a 90-day incubation experiment. The results of isotherm experiments showed that the adsorption mechanism of P on LC and AC was mainly chemisorption. The XPS analyses showed the adsorption mechanism of P on LC was mainly ligand exchange and inner-sphere complexation; while the adsorption mechanism of P on AC was mainly ligand exchange and electrostatic adsorption. The results demonstrated that the concentrations of soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) and DOM in the 0 to -100 mm sediment layer were reduced by 69.79% and 33.93%, respectively, in comparison to the control group with the LC + AC group. Moreover, the HCl-P and Res-P (stable P) in the 0-5 cm sediment layer were increased by 50.07% and 21.04%, respectively, in the LC + AC group. This indicates that the combined application of LC and AC has the potential to reduce the risk of P release. Furthermore, the formation of Fe(III)/Mn(IV) oxyhydroxides by LC + AC treatment resulted in an increased adsorption of SRP and DOM. Moreover, the effect of LC + AC capping on microbial community was smaller than that of LC/AC capping alone. The findings of this study indicated that the combined use of LC and AC represents a novel approach to the effective treatment of internal P and DOM in eutrophic lake sediments.

Phosphorus removal from municipal wastewater using calcium/iron oxide composites: Adsorption efficiency and impact on plant growth

Phosphate minerals are crucial for the production of fertilizers, but limited availability does not meet the growing agricultural demand. At the same time, the discharge of phosphorus by municipal wastewater treatment plants leads to eutrophication. Removal and recovery of phosphorus from wastewater can both provide nutrients to agriculture and decrease eutrophication. This research aims to evaluate phosphorus removal from municipal wastewater in Latvia by mineral-based calcium/iron composites and examine spent oxides' phytotoxic effect on plant growth. Two CaFeOxides from Latvian earth pigments (iron oxide pigments) deposits were synthesized and characterised by X-ray powder diffraction, differential scanning calorimetry/thermogravimetry, scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray analysis and specific surface area analysis. Adsorption properties of obtained oxides were evaluated with a standard phosphate solution, and real municipal wastewater. The phytotoxic effect of P-loaded composites was evaluated in a hydroponic system with common wheat (Triticum aestivum). The results indicated that calcium/iron oxide composites have higher P adsorption efficiency than the commercial Polonite material. The maximum sorption capacity of CaFeOxides was 63.29 and 83.33 mg P/g, and 53.19 mg/g for Polonite. Furthermore, the P-loaded CaFeOxides demonstrated no phytotoxic effect on the growth of Triticum aestivum, and at higher CaFeOxides concentrations, morphological and physiological parameters of wheat increased, showing great potential for reuse in agriculture.

Molecular insights and thermodynamic feasibility of phosphate adsorption on Ca-biocomposites using a simplified carbon structure

The removal of phosphorous from water sources is a critical challenge in mitigating water eutrophication. Adsorption using Ca-biocomposite-derived materials has proven to be highly effective for phosphorus removal. These biocomposites contain Ca, CaO, and Ca-(hydr)oxide species, which form Ca-P apatite phases, a potential fertilizer, holding promise for phosphorus recycling and promoting a circular economy. Density Functional Theory calculations were conducted to gain molecular insights into the thermodynamic feasibility of calcium-based adsorbents. Four models were used, viz. Ca2+, CaO monomer and dimmer, and Ca-(hydr)oxide, all embedded in a carbon matrix. Several binding modes were evaluated for [H2PO4]- and [H2PO4.6H2O]-, including monodentate mononuclear, bidentate mononuclear, and bidentate binuclear denticities. Adsorption, enthalpy, and Gibbs free energy changes were used as descriptors, together with Natural Bond Orbitals analysis. The findings indicate that [H2PO4.6H2O]- adsorption is thermodynamically favored primarily on the CaO dimmer, followed by the CaO monomer, and finally on Ca2+, suggesting a preference for binding phosphate through a monodentate mononuclear mode. The [H2PO4]- adsorption on the Ca-(hydr)oxide model was found to resemble the system's pH considering the H2O/OH ratio, an approximation of acid, intermediate, and basic pH conditions. Our research demonstrated the phosphate adsorption feasibility across a range of pH conditions, providing a solid foundation for further analysis such as infrared and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The Ca-(hydr)oxide model effectively simulates interactions between phosphate species and calcium-based adsorbents, approximating real environments. It enhances understanding of adsorption across various chemical environments, including the pH effect, and aligns with observed structural changes during phosphate adsorption. By combining theory with practical applications, this model aids in comprehending phosphate removal processes, guiding adsorbent optimization, and environmental strategies like eutrophication mitigation.

Microalgae-derived hydrogels/membranes for phosphorus removal and recovery from aquaculture tailwater: Waste utilization and phosphorus recycling

Efficient removal and recovery of phosphorus from aquaculture tailwater is challenging due to increasing strict water environment restrictions. This study presents a sustainable approach by using microalgae-waste-derived hydrogels/membranes for phosphorus adsorption and microalgae cultivation. Waste from Euglena gracilis (or Haematococcus pluvialis), modified with magnesium, was converted into biochars (abbreviated as MEBC or MHBC). This biochars were then combined with sodium alginate to fabricate hydrogels and with polyvinyl chloride to create membranes. Due to the almost 100 % phosphorus removal of MEBC (or MHBC) biochar, the as-obtained hydrogels/membranes demonstrated excellent phosphate adsorption, reducing total phosphorus in real aquaculture tailwater from 11 mg/L to 0. Additionally, the phosphorus-saturated hydrogel served as a phosphorus source for microalgae cultivation, while the membranes facilitated microalgae harvesting with a water flux over 40 L/m2/h. This study provides an eco-friendly solution for using microalgae-waste-derived materials to effectively address phosphorus removal and recovery challenges in aquaculture tailwater.

Recycling and reuse of waste agricultural plastics with hydrothermal pretreatment and low-temperature pyrolysis method

Recycling and reuse of agricultural plastics is an urgent worldwide issue. In this work, it is shown that low-density polyethylene (PE) typically used in mulch films can be converted into high-capacity P and N adsorbents through a two-step method that uses hydrothermal pretreatment (180 °C, 24 h) followed by pyrolysis at 500 °C with Ca(OH)2 additive. CaPE@HC500 materials prepared with the proposed two-step method were found to have high adsorption capacities for phosphate (263.6 mg/g) and nitrogen (200.7 mg/g) over wide ranges of pH (3-11). Dynamic adsorption of phosphate by CaPE@HC500 material in a packed-bed had a half-time breakthrough of 210 min indicating the feasibility of continuous systems. Material stability, cost, environmental-friendliness, and recyclability of the CaPE@HC500 material were determined to be superior to literature-proposed Ca-containing adsorbents. The two-step method for converting waste agricultural plastic mulch films into adsorbents is robust and highly-applicable to industrial settings.

Ca-Mg modified attapulgite for phosphate removal and its potential as phosphate-based fertilizer

The urgent concerns of controlling water body eutrophication and the alleviating phosphorus shortage have led to an urgent need for action. The removal of phosphate from polluted waters and its reuse are essential for the prevention of eutrophication and for the sustainable utilization of phosphate resources. In this study, modified attapulgite with different Ca:Mg molar ratios was synthesized to facilitate the recovery of phosphate, with subsequent use of soil fertilizer. Ca-Mg modified attapulgite with the optimal ratio (ACM-5:3) exhibited an exceptional adsorption quality, achieving a maximum adsorption capacity of 63.2 mg/g. The pseudo-second-order model and Langmuir model could well describe the adsorption kinetics and isotherms, respectively. The adsorption mechanism analyses suggested that the interaction between ACM-5:3 and phosphate depended mainly on ion exchange and electrostatic attraction. Moreover, phosphate-laden-ACM-5:3 demonstrated a significant potential as a phosphorus-releasing fertilizer. It could promote corn growth by ensuring a continuous supply of phosphorus and minimizing phosphorus runoff losses. The above results suggested that ACM-5:3 was a potential adsorbent for efficient phosphate removal and recovery.

Study on the removal efficacy and mechanism of phosphorus from wastewater by eggshell-modified biochar

The excessive discharge of phosphorus from rural domestic sewage is a problem that worthy of attention. If the phosphorus in the sewage were recovered, addressing this issue could significantly contribute to mitigating the global phosphorus crisis. In this study, corn straw, a common agricultural waste, was co-pyrolytically modified with eggshells, a type of food waste from university cafeterias. The resulting product, referred to as corn straw eggshell biochar (EGBC) was characterized using SEM, XRD, XPS, XRF, and other methods. Batch adsorption experiments were conducted to determine the optimal preparation conditions of EGBC and to explore its adsorption characteristics. EGBC showed strong adsorption effectiveness within a pH range of 5-12. The adsorption isotherm closely followed the Sips model (R2  > 0.9011), and the adsorption kinetics were more consistent with the pseudo-second-order model (R2  > 0.9899). The process was found to be both spontaneous and endothermic. Under optimal conditions, the phosphorus adsorption capacity of EGBC was measured to be 288.83 mg/g. This demonstrates the high efficiency of EGBC for phosphorus removal and illustrates an effective method of utilizing food waste for environmental remediation. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Biochar prepared from waste eggshell was used to removal and recovery phosphorus in wastewater treatment. EGBC has an impressive adsorption capacity that can reach up to 288.83 mg/g. EGBC has excellent adsorption and filtration capabilities, and there is a sudden increase in concentration at 900 min in the breakthrough curve of EGBC. EGBC has good regeneration performance, with an adsorption effect of 65% and an adsorption capacity of 121 mg/g after four desorption and regeneration cycles.

Efficient Adsorption of Nitrogen and Phosphorus in Wastewater by Biochar

Nitrogen and phosphorus play essential roles in ecosystems and organisms. However, with the development of industry and agriculture in recent years, excessive N and P have flowed into water bodies, leading to eutrophication, algal proliferation, and red tides, which are harmful to aquatic organisms. Biochar has a high specific surface area, abundant functional groups, and porous structure, which can effectively adsorb nitrogen and phosphorus in water, thus reducing environmental pollution, achieving the reusability of elements. This article provides an overview of the preparation of biochar, modification methods of biochar, advancements in the adsorption of nitrogen and phosphorus by biochar, factors influencing the adsorption of nitrogen and phosphorus in water by biochar, as well as reusability and adsorption mechanisms. Furthermore, the difficulties encountered and future research directions regarding the adsorption of nitrogen and phosphorus by biochar were proposed, providing references for the future application of biochar in nitrogen and phosphorus adsorption.

Enhanced simultaneous removal of phosphate and ammonium from swine wastewater using magnetic magnesium-loaded Chinese herbal medicine residues: Performance, mechanism, and resource utilization

Magnetic magnesium (Mg)-loaded Chinese herbal medicine residues (MM-TCMRs) were fabricated to simultaneously remove and recover phosphate and ammonium from wastewater. The MM-TCMRs exhibited larger specific surfaces and rougher structures with massive spherical particles than those of original residues. They could be separated by adjusting the magnetic field. The phosphate and ammonium adsorption by MM-TCMRs were matched with the pseudo-second-order model, while the Langmuir model yielded the maximum adsorption capacities of 635.35 and 615.57 mg g-1, respectively. Struvite precipitation on the MM-TCMRs surface was the primary removal mechanism with electrostatic attraction, ligand exchange, intra-particle diffusion, and ion exchange also involved. The recyclability of MM-TCMRs confirmed their good structural stability. More importantly, the nutrient-loaded MM-TCMRs enhanced alfalfa growth and improved soil fertility in planting experiments. Collectively, the MM-TCMRs are promising candidates for nutrient removal and recovery from wastewater.

Enhancing efficient reclaim of phosphorus from simulated urine by magnesium-functionalized biochar: Adsorption behaviors, molecular-level mechanistic explanations and its potential application

Magnesium-functionalized Magnolia grandiflora Linn leaf-derived biochar (MBC) capable of efficiently reclaiming phosphorus from urine was synthesized by slow co-pyrolysis. Four adsorption kinetic and seven adsorption isotherm models were fitted to the batch adsorption and desorption experimental data, and it was found that pseudo-first-order kinetic model and multilayer model with saturation best described the phosphate-phosphorus (PO43--P) adsorption process by MBC. MBC and phosphorus-saturated MBC (P-MBC) were found to offer outstanding phosphorus adsorption and slow release properties, respectively. Based on material characterization, statistical physics, adsorption energy distribution and statistical thermodynamics, a multi-ionic, inclined orientation, entropy-driven spontaneous endothermic process of MBC on PO43--P was proposed, involving physicochemical interactions (porous filling, electrostatic attraction, ligand exchange and surface precipitation). Further, seed germination and early seedling growth experiments proved that P-MBC can be used as a slow-release fertilizer. Overall, MBC offers prospective applications as an efficient phosphorus adsorbent and then as a slow-release fertilizer.

Recyclable Magnesium-Modified Biochar Beads for Efficient Removal of Phosphate from Wastewater

Although ball milling is effective for biochar modification with metal oxides for efficient phosphate removal, the recyclability of the adsorbent as well as the precursors for modification, still need to be optimized. Herein, a magnesium-modified biochar was first prepared with the precursor of MgCl₂·6H₂O through the solvent-free ball milling method. After that, recyclable biochar beads were fabricated with the introduction of sodium alginate and Fe₃O_4. The beads were proved to have excellent adsorption performance for phosphate with a saturated capacity of 53.2 mg g^-1, which is over 12 times higher than that of pristine biochar beads. Although the particle size reduction, surface area, and O-containing group increments after milling are beneficial for adsorption, the remarkable promotion in performance should mainly result from the appropriate formation of magniferous crystals on biochar, which greatly accelerates the electrostatic interactions as well as precipitation for adsorption. The beads also exhibited excellent magnetism-driven recyclability, which greatly avoids secondary contamination and broadens the application field of the adsorbent.