Differences in the internal PFAS patterns of herbivores, omnivores and carnivores - lessons learned from target screening and the total oxidizable precursor assay

A machine learning multimodal profiling of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyls (PFAS) distribution across animal species organs via clustering and dimensionality reduction techniques

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) contamination in aquatic and terrestrial organisms poses significant environmental and health risks. This study quantified 15 PFAS compounds across various tissues (liver, kidney, gill, muscle, skin, lung, blood, breast, feather) from fish (Clarias gariepinus, Oreochromis niloticus, Lates niloticus, Tilapia zilli), livestock (camel, cow, sheep, ram, goat), and birds (pigeon, chicken, turkey). Among the fishes, C. gariepinus exhibited the highest PFAS accumulation, with PFOA (46.5 ng/g) and PFTrDA (50.1 ng/g) dominant in liver and kidney, while O. niloticus showed elevated PFTrDA (56.87 ng/g) and PFUnDA (29.43 ng/g). In livestock, camel liver contained high PFNA (9.22 ng/g), and cow liver had the highest PFOS (8.1 ng/g). Among the birds, pigeon liver showed the highest PFNA (7.83 ng/g). To analyze PFAS distribution patterns, dimensionality reduction and clustering techniques were employed. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) captured 68.28 % of total variance, revealing two distinct clusters whereby fish species are strongly related with higher PFAS concentration, while poultry showed unique PFAS profiles when compared to other types of meat. Clustering of PFOS, PFOA, and other PFAS compounds near the center explained their influence across the general meat types particularly the fish species, while t-Distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE) confirmed clear separations in high-dimensional space. Clustering analyses, including K-means, hierarchical clustering, DBSCAN, and Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM), identified well-defined patterns, with DBSCAN and GMM detecting overlapping categories and outliers. Feature importance analysis using a Random Forest model highlighted total PFAS as the most significant predictor, with PFHxA and PFDODA also contributing strongly, while organ type and species played a lesser role. These findings demonstrate the effectiveness of unsupervised learning techniques in characterizing PFAS bioaccumulation patterns across species and tissues, providing valuable information for ecological and toxicological risk assessments.

The quest for the perfect "total PFAS" method: how can the total oxidisable precursor (TOP) assay be made reliable?

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) make up a large and complex class of manmade chemicals. They have been widely used in numerous industrial branches and are incorporated into many consumer products. Today, there is a consensus on the fact that PFAS are present in all environmental compartments and that populations all over the world are subjected to them via internal exposure. It has been estimated that thousands of individual PFAS have been manufactured and marketed since the 1950s, to which impurities present in commercial products and intermediate environmental transformation products should be added. Since it is unrealistic to be able to individually identify, detect and quantify all the PFAS present in a sample, several analytical approaches have been developed to assess the presence of "hidden/unseen" PFAS. One of these, known as the total oxidisable precursor (TOP) assay, was first described in 2012. Basically, it converts some PFAS, hereafter referred to as precursors, into stable terminal products readily measurable by routine target methods. This review is based on more than 100 studies in which the original TOP assay was simply applied or optimised. The review found that the TOP assay was selective, sensitive, applicable to many matrices, useful within a forensic context, inexpensive, and easy to implement and has been assessed in the literature on a wide range of precursors. However, this method comprises many subtleties and has some flaws that operators should be made aware of so that they may be addressed as far as possible. Finally, this review tries to lay the foundations for better practices and quality assurance/quality control measures, in order to improve accuracy and reliability of TOP assay results.

Shellfish and shorebirds from the East-Asian Australian flyway as bioindicators for unknown per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances using the total oxidizable precursor assay

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) have gained significant global attention due to their extensive industrial use and harmful effects on various organisms. Among these, perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) are well-studied, but their diverse precursors remain challenging to monitor. The Total Oxidizable Precursor (TOP) assay offers a powerful approach to converting these precursors into detectable PFAAs. In this study, the TOP assay was applied to samples from the East Asian-Australian Flyway, a critical migratory route for millions of shorebirds. Samples included shellfish from China's coastal mudflats, key stopover sites for these birds, and blood and liver samples from shorebirds overwintering in Australia. The results showed a substantial increase in perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs) across all sample types following the TOP assay, with the most significant increases in shorebird livers (Sum PFCAs increased by 18,156 %). Intriguingly, the assay also revealed unexpected increases in perfluorosulfonic acids (PFSAs), suggesting the presence of unidentified precursors. These findings highlight the need for further research into these unknown precursors, their sources, and their ecological impacts on shorebirds, other wildlife, and potential human exposure. This study also provides crucial insights into the TOP assay's strengths and limitations in studying PFAS precursor dynamics in biological matrices.

Environmental Occurrence and Biotic Concentrations of Ultrashort-Chain Perfluoroalkyl Acids: Overlooked Global Organofluorine Contaminants

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are a large group of anthropogenic fluorinated chemicals. Ultrashort-chain perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) have recently gained attention due to their prevalence in the environment and increasing environmental concerns. In this review, we established a literature database from 1990 to 2024, encompassing environmental and biological concentrations (>3,500 concentration records) of five historically overlooked ultrashort-chain PFAAs (perfluoroalkyl carboxylic and sulfonic acids with less than 4 carbons): trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), perfluoropropanoic acid (PFPrA), trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (TFMS), perfluoroethanesulfonate (PFEtS), and perfluoropropanesulfonate (PFPrS). Our data mining and analysis reveal that (1) ultrashort-chain PFAAs are globally distributed in various environments including water bodies, solid matrices, and air, with concentrations usually higher than those of longer-chain compounds; (2) TFA, the most extensively studied ultrashort-chain PFAA, shows a consistent upward trend in concentrations in surface water, rainwater, and air over the past three decades; and (3) ultrashort-chain PFAAs are present in various organisms, including plants, wildlife, and human blood, serum, and urine, with concentrations sometimes similar to those of longer-chain compounds. The current state of knowledge regarding the sources and fate of TFA and other ultrashort-chain PFAAs is also reviewed. Amid the global urgency to regulate PFASs, particularly as countries worldwide have intensified such efforts, this critical review will inform scientific research and regulatory policies.

Determination of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in six different fish species from Swiss lakes

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are persistent environmental contaminants with bioaccumulation potential, particularly affecting aquatic ecosystems and human health also via fish consumption. There is therefore a need for reliable extraction methods and studies to accurately assess PFAS levels in fish, crucial for understanding bioaccumulation and potential toxicological effects on both fish and humans through consumption. This study investigated PFAS levels in freshwater fish from Swiss lakes, focusing on six common species: Coregonus wartmanni, Cyprinus carpio, Oncorhynchus mykiss, Perca fluviatilis, Salmo trutta, and Squalius cephalus. Utilizing an optimized QuEChERS extraction method, 15 PFAS were analyzed in 218 fish fillet samples using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). The results were compared to EU regulations and EFSA guidelines for tolerable weekly intake (TWI), with a specific focus on correlations between fish size and PFAS concentration. Our findings reveal significant PFAS contamination, particularly in Perca fluviatilis with perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS) and perfluorohexane sulfonic acid (PFHxS) levels often exceeding EU safety limits. TWI, calculated for a person of 70 kg body weight and an intake of 200 g of fish fillet, is exceeded in 95% of Coregonus wartmanni, 100% of Squalius cephalus, and in 55%, 50%, and 36% of the specimens Oncorhynchus mykiss, Salmo trutta, and Perca fluviatilis respectively. Correlation analysis between PFAS concentration and fish size in 121 Salmo trutta specimens revealed significant positive correlations for perfluorobutane sulfonic acid (PFBS), perfluorodecanoic acid (PFDA), and perfluorohexane sulfonic acid (PFHxS), and a negative correlation for perfluoropentanoic acid (PFPeA). These results underscore the critical need for continuous monitoring and regulatory efforts to mitigate PFAS exposure risks to both ecosystems and human health.

Role of niche and micro-habitat preferences in per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances occurrence in the gills of tropical lake fish species

The present study has investigated per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in the gill tissues of various fish species inhabiting different trophic levels within Eleyele Lake, a tropical freshwater lake in Nigeria. The mean concentrations of PFAS congeners were determined, and their trends and patterns were analyzed across different trophic species. The results revealed variations in congener abundance and species-specific patterns that was influenced by habitat and niche preferences. Multivariate associations using canonical-correlation analysis (CCA) revealed distinct trends in the relationships between gill concentrations of specific PFAS congeners and different trophic groups. The strongest congener relationships were observed in the pelagic omnivore (Oreochromic niloticus: ON) with positive associations for 4:2 FTS, 9CL-PF3ONS, PFTDA, MeFOSA and PFHxS. The differences in congener profiles for the two herbivorous fish (Sarotherodon melanotheron (SM) and Coptodon galilaeus (CG)) reflect possible divergence in microhabitat and niche preferences. Furthermore, the congener overlaps between the herbivore (CG), and benthic omnivore (Clarias gariepinus: ClG) indicate a possible niche and microhabitat overlap. Our study provides valuable insights into the congener dynamics of PFAS at Eleyele Lake. However, the dissimilarity and overlapping PFAS congener profile in fish gills reflects the interplay of species niche preference and microhabitat associations. The present study highlights the need for further research to assess ecological risks and develop effective PFAS management strategies.

Forever Pesticides: A Growing Source of PFAS Contamination in the Environment

BACKGROUND

Environmental contamination by fluorinated chemicals, in particular chemicals from the per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) class, has raised concerns around the globe because of documented adverse impacts on human health, wildlife, and ecosystem quality. Recent studies have indicated that pesticide products may contain a variety of chemicals that meet the PFAS definition, including the active pesticide ingredients themselves. Given that pesticides are some of the most widely distributed pollutants across the world, the legacy impacts of PFAS addition into pesticide products could be widespread and have wide-ranging implications on agriculture and food and water contamination, as well as the presence of PFAS in rural environments.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this commentary is to explore different ways that PFAS can be introduced into pesticide products, the extent of PFAS contamination of pesticide products, and the implications this could have for human and environmental health.

METHODS

We submitted multiple public records requests to state and federal agencies in the United States and Canada and extracted relevant data from those records. We also compiled data from publicly accessible databases for our analyses.

DISCUSSION

We found that the biggest contributor to PFAS in pesticide products was active ingredients and their degradates. Nearly a quarter of all US conventional pesticide active ingredients were organofluorines and 14% were PFAS, and for active ingredients approved in the last 10 y, this had increased to 61% organofluorines and 30% PFAS. Another major contributing source was through PFAS leaching from fluorinated containers into pesticide products. Fluorination of adjuvant products and "inert" ingredients appeared to be limited, although this represents a major knowledge gap. We explored aspects of immunotoxicity, persistence, water contamination, and total fluorine load in the environment and conclude that the recent trend of using fluorinated active ingredients in pesticides may be having effects on chemical toxicity and persistence that are not given adequate oversight in the United States. We recommend a more stringent risk assessment approach for fluorinated pesticides, transparent disclosure of "inert" ingredients on pesticide labels, a complete phase-out of post-mold fluorination of plastic containers, and greater monitoring in the United States. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP13954.

Fluorine mass balance analysis in wild boar organs from the Bohemian Forest National Park

Wild boars have been reported as bioindicators for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in a variety of studies. However, data about PFAS levels in wild boars from sites with limited industrial and general human activity is scarce. In this study, wild boar (Sus scrofa) organs from the Bohemian Forest National Park (Czech Republic) were used as bioindicators for PFAS pollution. In this work, 29 livers and 24 kidneys from 30 wild boars (0.5-5 years) were investigated using a fluorine mass balance approach. For this, the samples were measured using high performance liquid chromatography with electrospray ionisation tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-ESI-MS/MS), targeting 30 PFAS, including legacy and replacement PFAS, direct total oxidisable precursor assay (dTOPA) and combustion ion chromatography (CIC). Perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs) from C7 to C14 and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) were detected in >50 % of samples. In the livers, PFCAs dominated the profile with median concentrations of 230 μg/kg for perfluorononanoic acid (PFNA) and 75 μg/kg perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). PFOA and PFNA concentrations in the livers were one order of magnitude higher than in livers from wild boars caught in rural NE Germany considered as background concentration. PFOS in liver contributed only 30 % to the Σc(PFASTarget) with a median concentration of 170 μg/kg. Kidneys and livers contain an average of 2460 μg F/kg and 6800 μg F/kg extractable organic fluorine (EOF) respectively. Σc(PFASTarget) add up to a maximum of 10 % of the extractable organic fluorine. After oxidisation of the samples, PFOA, PFNA and Σc(PFASdTOPA) increased in livers, but could not explain the EOF. The elevated concentration of PFOA and PFNA may indicate differences in biomagnification for different habitats or an unidentified PFAS source in proximity to the national park.

Bioaccumulation of Perfluoroalkyl Sulfonamides (FASA)

Hundreds of sites across the United States have high concentrations of perfluoroalkyl sulfonamides (FASA), but little is known about their propensity to accumulate in fish. FASA are precursors to terminal per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) that are abundant in diverse consumer products and aqueous film-forming foams manufactured using electrochemical fluorination (ECF AFFF). In this study, FASA with C3-C8 carbon chain lengths were detected in all fish samples from surface waters up to 8 km downstream of source zones with ECF AFFF contamination. Short-chain FASA ≤ C6 have rarely been included in routine screening for PFAS, but availability of new standards makes such analyses more feasible. Bioaccumulation factors (BAF) for FASA were between 1 and 3 orders of magnitude greater than their terminal perfluoroalkyl sulfonates. Across fish species, BAF for FASA were greater than for perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS), which is presently the focus of national advisory programs. Similar concentrations of the C6 FASA (<0.36-175 ng g-1) and PFOS (0.65-222 ng g-1) were detected in all fish species. No safety thresholds have been established for FASA. However, high concentrations in fish next to contaminated sites and preliminary findings on toxicity suggest an urgent need for consideration by fish advisory programs.

Enhanced coagulation coupled with cyclic IX adsorption-ARP regeneration for removal of PFOA in drinking water treatment

Laboratory investigations were conducted to demonstrate a potentially transformative, cost-efficient per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) treatment approach, consisting of enhanced coagulation and repeated ion exchange (IX)-advanced reduction process (ARP) for concurrent PFAS removal and IX resin regeneration. Enhanced alum coagulation at the optimal conditions (pH 6.0, 60 mg/L alum) could preferentially remove high molecular-weight, hydrophobic natural organic matter (NOM) from 5.0- to ~1.2-mg/L DOC in simulated natural water. This facilitated subsequent IX adsorption of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA, a model PFAS in this study) (20 μg/L) using IRA67 resin by minimizing the competition of NOM for functional sites on the resin. The PFOA/NOM-laden resin was then treated by ARP, generating hydrated electrons (eaq - ) that effectively degraded PFOA. The combined IX-ARP regeneration process was applied over six cycles to treat PFOA in pre-coagulated simulated natural water, nearly doubling the PFOA removal compared with the control group without ARP regeneration. This study underscores the potential of enhanced coagulation coupled with cyclic IX-ARP regeneration as a promising, cost-effective solution for addressing PFOA pollution in water. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Enhanced alum coagulation can substantially mitigate NOM to favor the following IX removal of PFOA in water. Cyclic IX adsorption-ARP regeneration offers an effective, potentially economical solution to the PFOA pollution in water. ARP can effectively degrade PFOA during the ARP regeneration of PFOA/NOM-laden resin.