Interspecies calibration for biomonitoring metal contamination in coastal waters using oysters and mussels

Hidden threat in turbid waters: Quantifying and modeling the bioaccumulation and risks of particulate metals to clams

A major proportion of metal contaminants in aquatic environments is bound to suspended particulate matter (SPM), yet environmental monitoring typically focuses on dissolved metals, with the filtration step removing SPM. This step may inadvertently hide the potential risks posed by particulate metals. In this study, we used stable isotope tracers to quantify the contributions of SPM-bound metals to the bioaccumulation of nickel (Ni), copper (Cu), zinc (Zn), cadmium (Cd), and lead (Pb) in Ruditapes philippinarum, a widely distributed clam crucial to global aquaculture. A microporous hollow-fiber filter system was employed to maintain consistent dissolved metal concentrations across treatments, enabling precise assessment of elevated bioaccumulation due to particle ingestion. Our results demonstrated that particulate metals contributed negligible Cd, but accounted for 21.1% of Ni, 67.3% of Zn, 69.5% of Pb, and 73.6% of Cu bioaccumulation in the presence of 10-68 mg L-1 SPM. Assimilation efficiencies varied among metals, with Pb at 1.5%, Ni at 14.7%, Zn at 48.4%, and Cu at 85.8%. Toxicokinetic modeling further revealed that the bio-uptake of particulate metals can surpass the dissolved metal, challenging the assumption that particulate metals are less bioavailable. Field sampling validated the model's predictive capacity for metal bioaccumulation. These findings underscore the need to reconsider environmental monitoring protocols and revise water quality criteria, especially in turbid coastal waters where aquaculture is prevalent.

Reduced copper uptake and efflux by the mussel Mytilus coruscus after Cu exposure: Implication for biomonitoring

The hard-shell mussels Mytilus coruscus have been extensively employed in pollution biomonitoring. Earlier studies indicated that metal concentrations in Mytilus coruscus may not accurately reflect the true metal contamination levels in the sampling areas, possibly due to their modified metal uptake and efflux. Given the likelihood of mussels in the field being exposed to intermittent metal contaminants, this study investigated whether different Cu pre-exposures significantly affected its uptake and efflux upon Cu exposure. We found significant reduction in Cu uptake rate constant (ku) and efflux rate constant (ke) in the mussels with varying Cu pre-exposure regimes. Specifically, the ku decreased from 1.55 ± 0.37 L g-1 d-1 in the control group to 0.65 ± 0.19 after 5 days and 0.53 ± 0.28 after 15 days of exposure to 20 μg L-1 Cu, respectively, and then was further reduced to as low as 0.096 ± 0.046 L g-1 d-1 following a 5-day exposure at 50 μg L-1 Cu. Similarly, the ke decreased from 0.18 ± 0.020 to 0.15 ± 0.015 d-1 following 5-15 days of exposure to 20 μg L-1 Cu, and further decreased to 0.081 ± 0.023 d-1 after a 5-day exposure at 50 μg L-1 Cu. Our subcellular distribution analysis underscored the critical role of the metallothionein-like protein (MTLP) fraction in modifying both Cu ku and ke during the rapid-depuration phase (ke1), whereas the metal-rich granule (MRG) fraction influenced the ke during the second depuration phase (ke2). This study demonstrated that environmental assessments utilizing biomonitoring species should consider the exposure of these organisms to ensure accurate interpretations of metal contamination in marine ecosystems and enhance the effectiveness of these species in environmental monitoring. This crucial factor is often overlooked, potentially skewing data and leading to misinterpretations of environmental health and pollution levels.

Combined copper isotope and elemental signatures in bivalves and sediments from the Korean coast: Applicability for monitoring anthropogenic contamination

This study investigates the applicability of elemental and Cu isotope compositions in sediments and bivalves from the Korean coast to monitor anthropogenic Cu contamination. Sediments with high Cu (>64.4 mg/kg) and/or moderate enrichment levels (EFCu) exhibit homogenous δ65CuAE647 values (-0.12 to +0.16 ‰), suggesting similar anthropogenic Cu fingerprints along the Korean coast. Sediments with Cu concentrations near natural background levels (< 20.6 mg/kg) display large isotopic variability (Δ65Cumax-mim: ~0.8 ‰), encompassing those from sediments under anthropic influences. We hypothesize that Cu isotopic compositions of Korean geology are heterogeneous, therefore, natural end-members of source mixing models should be established locally at small scales. Cu concentrations in Oysters correlate with sediments, and their isotopic compositions are more suitable for monitoring Cu contamination, while mussel's regulatory mechanisms seem to affect source records. The current Cu isotope data will help to detect shifts attributable to anthropic contamination in future biomonitoring.

Opportunistic omnivory impairs the use of the Atlantic blue crab Callinectes sapidus as a trace metal biomonitor in invaded Mediterranean coastal waters

The contribution of non-indigenous species to the transfer of contaminants in invaded food webs represents an active research area. Here we measured trace metals and CN stable isotopes in five populations of the invasive Atlantic blue crab Callinectes sapidus and in baseline bivalve species from Spain, Italy and Greece. They were used to estimate trophic transfer effects and the trophic position and isotopic niche of C. sapidus. Maximum trophic transfer effects occurred where the crab showed the largest isotopic niches and highest trophic positions; furthermore, the consistency of trace metal profiles between bivalves and crabs co-varied with the trophic position of the latters. Omnivory may influence the success of an invasive species, but also limit its effectiveness for biomonitoring. However, our results indicated that stable isotopes analysis provides a clarifying background where to cast patterns of contamination of the blue crab as well as of other omnivorous biomonitor species.

Heavy Metal Accumulation in Oysters from an Aquaculture Area in the Luoyangjiang River Estuary

Oysters are a group of economically important bivalves in China, with estuaries serving as one of their primary cultivation areas. However, heavy metal pollution in these estuarine environments poses a potential threat to aquaculture by leading to the accumulation of heavy metals in farmed oysters, which could impact their safety and marketability. This study was conducted in the aquaculture area of the Luoyangjiang River estuary, where eight sampling sites were selected. Water, sediment, and oysters categorized by shell length were collected from each site. The concentrations of heavy metals (Ag, As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn) were determined in both the environmental samples and oyster tissues. Additionally, multiplex species-specific PCR was used to identify oyster species. The results showed significant variations in dissolved-phase and suspended particulate matter (SPM) metal concentrations across different sampling sites, while sediment metal concentrations were more consistent but similar to those in SPM. The large oysters were comprised of 50% Magallana angulata and 50% Magallana gigas, while small oysters were identified as Magallana sikamea. The Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn levels in both size groups of oysters exceeded data from previous studies, indicating contamination in the estuary. The observed differences in heavy metal concentrations between large and small oysters primarily reflect species-specific variability in metal accumulation, which may also be influenced by factors such as growth and exposure duration. Furthermore, the lack of significant correlation between metal concentrations in environmental media and oysters suggests that oysters may be exposed to multiple sources of metal contamination.

Toxicokinetics and Mussel Watch: Addressing Interspecies Differences for Coastal Cadmium Contamination Assessment

Bivalves are often employed for biomonitoring contaminants in marine environments; however, in these large-scale programs, unavoidably, using multiple species presents a significant challenge. Interspecies differences in contaminant bioaccumulation can complicate data interpretation, and direct comparisons among species may result in misleading conclusions. Here, we propose a robust framework based on toxicokinetic measurements that accounts for interspecies differences in bioaccumulation. Specifically, via a recently developed double stable isotope tracer technique, we determined the toxicokinetics of cadmium (Cd)─a metal known for its high concentrations in bivalves and significant interspecies bioaccumulation variability─in six widespread bivalve species including mussels (Perna viridis, Mytilus unguiculatus, Mytilus galloprovincialis) and oysters (Magallana gigas, Magallana hongkongensis, Magallana angulata). Results show that oysters generally have higher Cd uptake rate constants (ku: 1.18-3.09 L g-1 d-1) and lower elimination rate constants (ke: 0.008-0.017 d-1) than mussels (ku: 0.21-0.64 L g-1 d-1; ke: 0.018-0.037 d-1). The interspecies differences in tissue Cd concentrations are predominantly due to Cd uptake rather than elimination. Utilizing toxicokinetic parameters to back-calculate Cd concentrations in seawater, we found that the ranking of Cd contamination levels at the six sites markedly differs from those based on tissue Cd concentrations. We propose that this approach will be useful for interpreting data from past and future biomonitoring programs.

Turbid Waters and Clearer Standards: Refining Water Quality Criteria for Coastal Environments by Encompassing Metal Bioavailability from Suspended Particles

Suspended particulate matter (SPM) carries a major fraction of metals in turbid coastal waters, markedly influencing metal bioaccumulation and posing risks to marine life. However, its effects are often overlooked in current water quality criteria for metals, primarily due to challenges in quantifying SPM's contribution. This contribution depends on the SPM concentration, metal distribution coefficients (Kd), and the bioavailability of SPM-bound metals (assimilation efficiency, AE), which can collectively be integrated as a modifying factor (MF). Accordingly, we developed a new stable isotope method to measure metal AE by individual organisms from SPM, employing the widely distributed filter-feeding clam Ruditapes philippinarum as a representative species. Assessing SPM from 23 coastal sites in China, we found average AEs of 42% for Zn, 26% for Cd, 20% for Cu, 8% for Ni, and 6% for Pb. Moreover, using stable isotope methods, we determined metal Kd of SPM from these sites, which can be well predicted by the total organic carbon and iron content (R2 = 0.977). We calculated MFs using a Monte Carlo method. The calculated MFs are in the range 9.9-43 for Pb, 8.5-37 for Zn, 2.9-9.7 for Cu, 1.4-2.7 for Ni, and 1.1-1.6 for Cd, suggesting that dissolved-metal-based criteria values should be divided by MFs to provide adequate protection to aquatic life. This study provides foundational guidelines to refine water quality criteria in turbid waters and protect coastal ecosystems.

The assessment of bioavailability and environmental risk of dissolved and particulate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the seawater of typical bays

The pollution of dissolved and particulate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in coastal waters has been increasing in recent decades. However, limited research has been conducted on the characteristics of dissolved and particulate PAHs in seawater and their associated risk assessment. Here, we focused on the bioavailability and environmental risk of PAHs in four typical bays of Shandong Province, China, and used scallop Chlamys farreri and clam Mactra veneriformis as sentinel species. The results revealed that dissolved PAHs tended to bioaccumulate in scallop C. farreri, and their ecological risk exhibited a significant correlation with the health risk of bioaccumulated PAHs and the bioeffect of screened biomarkers in scallop. Conversely, particulate PAHs demonstrated a higher bioaccumulation potential in the clam M. veneriformis, showing a stronger correlation between their ecological risk, health risk, and bioeffect in clams. This study provides the first elucidation of the connection between the ecological risk, health risk, and bioeffect of PAHs. Furthermore, based on the better correlation of health risk and bioeffect caused by PAHs with total PAHs in seawater, we propose that the clam M. veneriformis is a more suitable sentinel species for assessing environmental risk in typical bays of Shandong Province.

Bioavailability and health risk assessment of Zn and Cd in edible tissues of two typical shellfish species using in vitro gastrointestinal digestion

Dynamic extraction of edible tissues of Jinjiang oyster (Crassostrea rivularis) and Flower clam (Paphia undulata) was conducted using a fully biomimetic digestion (in vitro) method. The impact of different cooking methods on the bioavailability of Zn and Cd in the edible shellfish tissues was analyzed, and the human health risk of Zn and Cd was evaluated. The results show that the gastric biomimetic extractions of Zn and Cd in unheated samples of C. rivularis and P. undulata were higher than those in the intestinal biomimetic extraction. The extraction patterns of cooked samples were consistent with those of raw samples. The bioavailability of Zn and Cd in cooked samples of C. rivularis was 94.9% and 82.5%, respectively, indicating increased Zn bioavailability but decreased Cd bioavailability compared to the raw samples. The bioavailability of Zn and Cd in cooked samples of P. undulata was 85.1% and 83.0%, respectively, both of which decreased compared to the raw samples. Consumption of C. rivularis can provide 21.0% to 34.2% of the daily required Zn intake, while consumption of P. undulata can provide 3.8% to 6.4%. The intake of Cd from both shellfish species is below the monthly tolerable intake recommended by FAO/WHO. Consuming cooked C. rivularis can increase the intake of Zn and decrease the intake of Cd.