Ecotoxicology of hexavalent chromium in fish: An updated review

Mixture of arsenic and chromium alters antioxidant, DNA repair and tumor suppressor gene expressions in zebrafish brain at environmental concentrations

Arsenic (As) and chromium (Cr) are two harmful toxicants as well as carcinogens which can coexist in polluted surface water and groundwater. This coexistence leads to mixture effects in animals including fish. Both of these heavy metals are reported to manifest reactive oxygen species (ROS) mediated toxicity. Though individual neurotoxic effects have been reported, their mixture effects, its mechanism and cellular responses against oxidative stress and DNA damages remain unknown. The present study evaluated the individual and mixture effects of As and Cr at their environmentally relevant concentrations in zebrafish (Danio rerio) brain after 15, 30 and 60 days of exposure. Nrf2, a transcription factor is involved in the expressional regulation of enzymes needed to maintain cellular redox homeostasis. This study reported the expressional pattern of Nrf2 and its associated xenobiotic metabolizing enzyme Nqo1 and other markers of oxidative stress such as ROS generation, reduced glutathione level, lipid peroxidation and catalase activity. Increased malondialdehyde (MDA) content, glutathione level, and catalase activity indicated oxidative stress in exposed groups. In addition, this study revealed expressional alterations of neurotoxicity marker (ache), DNA repair (ogg1, apex1, creb1, polb, mlh1, msh2 and msh6) and tumor suppressor (p53, brca2) genes. Results of ROS generation, MDA level, histopathological analysis, gene expression and immunofluorescence study confirmed that As and Cr did not show antagonistic effects in combination rather indicated additive effects which was dose-dependent but not always linear.

Construction of hierarchical nanostructured surface on an organic hybrid selenidostannate with light trapping effect to achieve sunlight-driven environmental remediation

Due to the low intensity of sunlight, it is a great challenge to realize highly efficient sunlight-driven photocatalysis. To maximize the utilization of sunlight, increasing the light capturing ability of photocatalysts is a prerequisite to attain high catalytic performances. Due to the multiple reflections of light in the hierarchical nanostructures, constructing hierarchical nanostructured surface should boost the sunlight capturing ability of a photocatalyst. Herein we used a surface oxidation etching method to construct a hierarchical nanostructure on the surface of an organic hybrid selenidostannate [Bmim]4[Sn9Se20], namely BTSe. After 24 hours of etching by ammonium persulfate, the surface of BTSe-O24 turned into a hierarchical nanostructure. FDTD simulation proved that the hierarchical nanostructure can effectively decline the loss of incident light and enhance light capturing ability of BTSe-O24. As a result, BTSe-O24 can completely reduce Cr(VI) (100 mg/L) in 8 min with a conversion rate of 750 mg/(g h) under sunlight. The catalytic performance of BTSe-O24 under sunlight is even better than those of most reported photocatalysts under high-power xenon lamps. More importantly, BTSe-O24 can maintain high photocatalytic efficiency in the whole daytime (from 8:00 to 16:00 in autumn and winter). Our research opens a new perspective on the design of sunlight-driven photocatalysts.

Ferulic Acid Ameliorates Chromium-Induced Nephrotoxicity: Modulation of PERK/eIF2α/ATF4/CHOP, Nrf2, and Inflammatory Signaling

Hexavalent chromium (HVC) is a highly toxic heavy metal that induces organ damage especially to the kidney. It induces tubular damage and glomerular dysfunction basically through triggering inflammation, redox imbalance, and apoptotic cell death. The current study aimed at investigating the possible protective ability of ferulic acid (FA) against HVC-induced nephrotoxicity employing male Wistar rats as an experimental model. The results revealed the ability of FA to suppress the HVC-evoked renal tissue injury and to improve the renal function, as evidenced by enhanced histopathological picture, reduced levels of the tubular injury biomarker KIM- 1, and the glomerular dysfunction biomarkers serum cystatin C and urea, along with boosted glomerular filtration rate. At the molecular level, FA suppressed HVC-induced inflammation, as indicated by decreased nuclear NF-κB p65 protein abundance and phosphorylation, and reduced cyclooxygenase- 2, IL- 1β, and TNF-α levels. FA significantly alleviated the HVC-induced redox imbalance as demonstrated by reduced lipids and DNA oxidation, upregulation of Nrf2 signaling, improved activity of the antioxidant enzymes thioredoxin reductase, catalase, and glutathione peroxidase, along with significant elevation of the reduced glutathione level. FA inhibited apoptosis in the HVC-intoxicated rats as evidenced by reduced activity of the apoptotic marker caspase- 3 and modulation of BAX and Bcl2 proteins. Interestingly, FA suppressed the unfolded protein response signaling molecules including PERK, eIF2α, ATF4, and CHOP, which play essential roles in induction of apoptosis and inflammation. Together, these results underscore the nephroprotective impact of FA against HVC-evoked nephrotoxicity and highlight PERK, eIF2α, ATF4, CHOP, Nrf2, and NF-κB as potential molecular targets.

Noble metal/metal-organic framework nanoparticle-based electrochemical sensors for evaluating fish quality: a comprehensive review

Fish quality is a big-picture issue because of the possible presence of many chemical and biological pollutants, that may affect fish leading to environmental and health hazards. In this regard, researchers focus on developing efficient strategies for evaluating fish quality in terms of safety and freshness. Fish safety is determined based on assessing various pollutants, such as heavy metals, pesticides, dyes, and drugs, in fish tissue. Additionally, fish freshness evaluation is based on assessing some indicators including xanthine, hypoxanthine, uric acid, and histamine. Many chromatographic methods can assess all of these chemical indicators to evaluate the fish quality. However, these methods are expensive and often require sophisticated steps. Thus, electrochemical methods based on noble metal nanoparticles (NMNPs), metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) NPs, and their composites as electrode modifiers were investigated as potential replacements for the chromatographic ones. These materials showed high catalytic activity and electrical conductivity compared to the other electrode modifiers. In this review, we spotlight the role of NMNPs and MOF NPs in evaluating the quality of fish samples as a food source. Overall, NMNPs and MOF NPs are considered promising electrode materials for the electrochemical monitoring of fish quality.

Ecotoxicological efficiency of Cr(VI) removal treatment with reductive biogenic iron-based material determined by amphibian larval bioassays

Due to the toxic effects of chromium, its high environmental persistence, and potential for bioaccumulation, it is imperative to develop sustainable strategies for managing its contamination. In the present study, the synthesis time of supported biogenic iron-based microparticles (BioFe-MMT) and their performance in the Cr(VI) removal process were analyzed. Its lethal and sublethal ecotoxicological effects were subsequently evaluated through standardized bioassays using amphibian Rhinella arenarum larvae exposed to BioFe-MMT and Cr(VI) before and after the removal treatment. Results demonstrated that BioFe-MMT biosynthesized for 3 weeks had smaller particle size and better Cr(VI) and total Cr removal efficiency (>99% and >91%, respectively) compared to longer synthesis times. Ecotoxicological bioassays showed that Cr(VI) caused a significant increment of lethal toxicity to larvae with 50% Lethal Concentration (LC 50) at 96 and 504 h of 25.1 and 0.04 mg L-1, respectively. Several sublethal effects were observed such as reduced body size, wavy and underdeveloped tail, and behavioral disorders. This toxicity could be explained by the Bioconcentration Factor (BCF) at 96 h, which was 12.26 L kg-1. On the other hand, BioFe-MMT and the supernatant obtained after the treatment had negligible toxic effects. Larvae exposed to the sludge obtained after Cr(VI) removal treatment (Cr-BioFe-MMT) presented significant mortality from 216 h, which was explained by Cr(VI) desorption from the Cr-BioFe-MMT sludge. These results highlight the BioFe-MMT potential use in Cr(VI) removal due to its efficiency and the reduced toxicity of the treated solution.

Hexavalent chromium induces ferroptosis in small intestinal tissue of broilers through GPX4/HMGB1/p38-MAPK pathway

As a major environmental heavy metal pollutant, hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) causes irreversible damage to animals and humans. Nevertheless, how Cr(VI) exposure causes intestinal damage in broilers remains inadequately explored. This study explores Cr(VI)-induced poisoning using potassium dichromate to build a Cr(VI) poisoning model. The results indicate that Cr(VI) exposure evidently reduced the body weight and the functions of liver and kidney in broilers. Histopathological analysis revealed different degrees of structural damage in all three segments of the small intestines by Cr(VI) exposure. Moreover, Cr(VI) exposure downregulated ZO-1, Occludin, and Claudin-1, while altering the diversity of cecal microbiota to impair the intestinal barrier function. Additionally, with increasing Cr(VI) concentration, the contents of Fe2+, ROS, and LPO in all three intestinal segments showed a dose-dependent increase. The levels of GPX4, SLC7A11, FTL, and FTH1 were downregulated by Cr(VI), while the levels of p38-MAPK, phosphorylated p38, TFR1, and HMGB1 were upregulated. This study suggests that Cr(VI)-induced ROS can trigger ferroptosis through the GPX4/HMGB1/p38-MAPK pathway, leading to intestinal barrier dysfunction and ultimately reducing the production performance of broilers. This provides foundation of theory for understanding the effects of Cr(VI) exposure on the small intestine.

Activity pattern of antioxidant enzymes in relation to the time of exposure of hexavalent chromium to Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus

Hexavalent chromium (Cr (VI)), a toxicant of environmental concern, frequently enters into water bodies and produces oxidative stress in fish. The antioxidant enzymes, Superoxide dismutase (SOD), Catalase (CAT), and Glutathion S-transferase (GST) are activated to counteract the oxidative stress in fish. This study explores the pattern of activation of these enzymes in gill, muscle, liver, and kidney tissues of Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus exposed to 9.35 mg/L and 18.70 mg/L of Cr (VI) for 96 h. The optimal hour of activity of these enzymes was revealed through extensive regression analysis. The results indicate a bell-shaped time response curve in the activity of the enzymes in both the treatments, except CAT in the gill of fish exposed to 18.70 mg/L Cr (VI) and GST in the gill, liver, and kidney of fish exposed to 18.70 mg/L Cr (VI). The results indicate that the optimal hour of activity of SOD changes in tandem with CAT, SOD responding first followed by CAT, both diminishing within 96 h. However, deviating from the bell-shaped pattern, the activity of CAT in gill and GST in gill, liver, and kidney in fish exposed to 18.70 mg/L Cr (VI) continued to rise even at 96 h, indicating that these antioxidant enzymes could not diminish the oxidative stress produced by the higher dose of Cr (VI). It was concluded that the activity of SOD, CAT, and GST between 30 and 70 h in the gill, liver, and kidney of Nile tilapia could serve as excellent biomarkers of oxidative stress under low doses of Cr (VI).

Arsenic and Chromium Induced Toxicity on Zebrafish Kidney: Mixture Effects on Oxidative Stress and Involvement of Nrf2-Keap1-ARE, DNA Repair, and Intrinsic Apoptotic Pathways

In polluted water, cooccurrences of two carcinogens, arsenic (As) and chromium (Cr), are extensively reported. Individual effects of these heavy metals have been reported in kidney of fishes, but underlying molecular mechanisms are not well established. There is no report on combined exposure of As and Cr in kidney. Thus, the present study investigated and compared individual and combined effects of As and Cr on zebrafish (Danio rerio) kidney treating at their environmentally relevant concentrations for 15, 30, and 60 days. Increased ROS levels, lipid peroxidation, GSH level, and decreased catalase activity implied oxidative stress in treated zebrafish kidney. Damage in histoarchitecture in treated groups was also noticed. The current study involved gene expression study of Nrf2, an important transcription factor of cellular stress responses along with its negative regulator Keap1 and downstream antioxidant genes nqo1 and ho1. Results indicated activation of Nrf2-Keap1 pathway after combined exposure. Expression pattern of ogg1, apex1, polb, and creb1 revealed the inhibition of base excision repair pathway in treatments. mRNA expression of tumor suppressor genes p53 and brca2 was also altered. Expressional alteration in bax, bcl2, caspase9, and caspase 3 indicated apoptosis (intrinsic pathway) induction, which was maximum in combined group. Inhibition of DNA repair and induction of apoptosis indicated that the activated antioxidant system was not enough to overcome the damage caused by As and Cr. Overall, this study revealed additive effects of As and Cr in zebrafish kidney after chronic exposure focusing cellular antioxidant and DNA damage responses.

Chronic Cr(VI) exposure-induced biotoxicity involved in liver microbiota-gut axis disruption in Phoxinus lagowskii Dybowski based on multi-omics technologies

Cr(VI) is widely used in industry and has high toxicity, making it one of the most common environmental pollutants. Long-term exposure to Cr(VI) can cause metabolic disorders and tissue damage. However, the effects of Cr(VI) on liver and gut microbes in fish have rarely been reported. In this study, 240 fish were randomly divided into 3 groups: the control group, low-dose Cr(VI) group (0.5 mg/L), and high-dose Cr(VI) group (2 mg/L). The mechanism by which Cr(VI) affects the enterohepatic axis of common carp was elucidated via multiomic analysis, serology, histomorphology, and physiological and biochemical indices. The results revealed that Cr(VI) stress led to hepatocyte damage, nuclear lysis, inflammatory cell infiltration, and vacuolated degeneration. The structure of the intestinal villi was severely damaged, and the length and width of the intestinal villi were significantly reduced. We also found that the accumulation of Cr(VI) in tissues increased in a concentration-dependent manner, and the content of Cr(VI) in each tissue increased in the order of gut > gill > liver > muscle. Multiple omics studies have revealed that chronic Cr(VI) stress leads to disturbances in the intestinal flora, with a significant reduction in the abundance of the beneficial bacterium Akkermansia and a significant increase in the abundance of the harmful bacterium Escherichia/Shigella. Intestinal injury and dysbiosis lead to an increase in blood LPS levels, further inducing metabolic disorders in the liver. The metabolites in the liver, including geniposide, leucine, C17 sphingosine, and 9,10-DiHODE, were significantly increased, whereas the beneficial metabolites, such as carnitine propionate and palmitoyl ethanolamide, were significantly reduced. In conclusion, our results suggest that chronic Cr(VI) stress leads to disturbances in gut microbial homeostasis and disturbed fatty acid and amino acid metabolism in the liver. LPS released into the bloodstream reaches the liver through the portal circulation, further exacerbating Cr(VI) stress-induced hepatotoxicity. This study revealed the mechanism of Cr(VI) toxicity to the liver-microbiota-gut axis of common carp. Our study provides new insights into the effects of Cr(VI) on the liver-microbiota-gut axis.

Solar-based technologies for removing potentially toxic metals from water sources: a review

Technological advances have led to a proportional increase in the deposition of contaminants across various environmental compartments, including water sources. Heavy metals, also known as potentially toxic metals, are of particular concern due to their significant harmful impacts on environmental and human health. Among the available methods for mitigating the threat of these metals in water, solar radiation-based technologies stand out for their cleanliness, cost-effectiveness, and efficiency in removing or reducing the toxicity of heavy metals. The performance and productivity of these methods in removing heavy metals such as arsenic (As), chromium (Cr), mercury (Hg), and uranium (U) from water still need to be comprehensively synthesized. Thus, this work aims to address that gap. The performance, potential, and challenges of real-world applications of conventional solar stills (CSS), membrane-based solar stills, and solar heterogeneous photocatalysis are concisely summarized and critically reviewed. CSS and membrane-based stills are highly effective (efficacy > 98%) in removing and capturing heavy metals from water. However, structural and functional improvements are needed to enhance productivity (especially for CSS) and usability in real-world environmental remediation and drinking water supply scenarios. Solar heterogeneous photocatalysis is highly effective in removing and/or converting As, Cr, Hg, and U into their non-toxic or less toxic forms, which subsequent processes can easily remove. Further research is necessary to evaluate the safety of photocatalytic materials, their integration into scalable solar reactors, and their usability in real-world environmental remediation applications.

Potential Environmental Impacts and Management Strategies for Metal Release during Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Using Olivine

Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) based on enhanced weathering of olivine (EWO) is a promising marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) technique. Previous research primarily focuses on the toxicological effects of potentially toxic metals (PTMs) released from olivine. In this Perspective, we explore the overlooked impacts of EWO on environmental media in two scenarios: olivine applied to beaches/shallow continental shelves and offshore dispersion by vessels. We analyze the potential migration pathways of iron and PTMs (e.g., nickel and chromium) after their release, and their interactions with manganese oxides in sediments, potentially causing secondary contamination. Additionally, we propose mitigation strategies to prevent PTM concentrations from exceeding local environmental quality standards, including the use of alkalization equipment to control PTM levels. This Perspective underscores the need for thorough environmental assessments prior to large-scale implementation to ensure the sustainability and efficacy of mCDR efforts.

Sight of Aged Microplastics Adsorbing Heavy Metal Exacerbated Intestinal Injury: A Mechanistic Study of Autophagy-Mediated Toxicity Response

Contaminant-bearing polystyrene microplastics (PSMPs) may exert significantly different toxicity profiles from their contaminant-free counterparts, with the role of PSMPs in promoting contaminant uptake being recognized. However, studies investigating the environmentally relevant exposure and toxic mechanisms of aged PSMPs binding to Cr are limited. Here, we show that loading of chromium (Cr) markedly alters the physicochemical properties and toxicological profiles of aged PSMPs. Specifically, Cr-bearing aged PSMPs induced severe body weight loss, oxidative stress (OS), autophagy, intestinal barrier injury, inflammation-pyroptosis response, and enteropathogen invasion in mice. Mechanistic investigations revealed that PSMPs@Cr exacerbated the OS, resulting in intestinal barrier damage and inflammation-pyroptosis response via overactivated Notch signaling and autophagy/cathepsin B/IL-1β pathway, respectively, which ultimately elevated mortality related to bacterial pathogen infection. In vitro experiments confirmed that autophagy-mediated reactive oxygen species (ROS) overproduction resulted in severe pyroptosis and impaired intestinal stem cells differentiation alongside the overactivation of Notch signaling in PSMPs@Cr-exposed organoids. Overall, our findings provide an insight into autophagy-modulated ROS overproduction within the acidic environment of autophagosomes, accelerating the release of free Cr from PSMPs@Cr and inducing secondary OS, revealing that PSMPs@Cr is a stable hazard material that induces intestinal injury. These findings provided a potential therapeutic target for environmental MPs pollution caused intestinal disease in patients.

Speciation-specific chromium bioaccumulation and detoxification in fish using hydrogel microencapsulated biogenic nanosilver and zeolite synergizing with biomarkers

Grass carp intestinal waste-mediated biosynthesized nanosilver (AgNPs) was valorized using guaran and zeolite matrices, resulting in AgNPs-guaran, AgNPs-zeolite, and AgNPs-guaran -zeolite composites. The valorized products were examined using Environmental Scanning Electron Microscopy, Energy Dispersive X-ray analysis and X-ray Diffraction analysis to confirm uniform dispersion and entrapment of AgNPs within the matrixes. These valorized products were evaluated for their efficacy in detoxifying the ubiquitous and toxic hexavalent chromium (Cr6+) in aquatic environments, with Anabas testudineus exposed to 2 mg l-1 of Cr6+ for 60 days. Remarkable reduction of Cr6+ concentration to 0.86 ± 0.007 mg l-1 was achieved with AgNPs-guaran-zeolite composite, indicating successful reclamation of contaminated water and food safety assurance. Consistency in results was further corroborated by minimal stress-related alterations in fish physiological parameters and integrated biomarker response within the experimental group treated with the AgNPs-guaran-zeolite composite. Despite observed chromium accumulation in fish tissues, evidence of physiological stability was apparent, potentially attributable to trivalent chromium accumulation, serving as an essential nutrient for the fish. Additionally, the challenge study involving Anabas testudineus exposed to Aeromonas hydrophila exhibited the lowest cumulative mortality (11.11%) and highest survival rate (87.5%) within the same experimental group. The current study presents a novel approach encompassing the valorization of AgNPs for Cr6+ detoxification under neutral to alkaline pH conditions, offering a comprehensive framework for environmental remediation.

Chronic low-dose chromium VI exposure induces oxidative stress and apoptosis with altered expressions of DNA repair genes and promoter hypermethylation in the liver of Swiss albino mice

The present investigation dealt with harmful effects of hexavalent chromium (Cr [VI]) on liver of Swiss albino mice. This variant exhibited cytotoxicity, mutagenicity, and carcinogenicity. Our study focused on elucidating the hepatotoxic effects of chronic low-dose exposure to Cr (VI) (2, 5, and 10 ppm) administered via drinking water for 4 and 8 months. The observed elevation in SGPT, ALP, and SGOT and increased oxidative stress markers unequivocally confirmed the severe disruption of liver homeostasis at these low treatment doses. Noteworthy alterations in histoarchitecture, body weight, and water intake provided further evidences of the harmful effects of Cr (VI). Production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) during metabolism led to DNA damages. Immunohistochemistry and qRT-PCR analyses revealed that chronic low-dose exposure of Cr (VI) induced apoptosis in liver tissue. Our study exhibited alterations in the expression pattern of DNA repair genes (Rad51, Mutyh, Mlh1, and Ogg1), coupled with promoter hypermethylation of Mutyh and Rad51, leading to transcriptional inhibition. Our findings underscored the potential of low-dose Cr (VI) exposure on hepatotoxicity by the intricate interplay between apoptosis induction and epigenetic alterations of DNA repair genes.

Magnetic Ion-Imprinted Materials for Selective Adsorption of Cr(VI): Adsorption Behavior and Mechanism Study

With the increase of hexavalent Cr(VI) wastewater discharged from industrial production, it seriously pollutes water bodies and poses a risk to human health. Adsorption is used as an effective means to treat Cr(VI), but its effectiveness is affected by pH, and the adsorption performance decreases when acidity is strong. Furthermore, research on the mechanism of Cr(VI) adsorption using DFT calculations needs to be developed. This study focuses on the development of magnetically responsive core-shell nano-ion imprinted materials (Fe3O4@GO@IIP) through magnetic separation and surface imprinting techniques. Characterization techniques including FT-IR, XRD, and EDS confirmed the core-shell nanostructure of Fe3O4@GO@IIP. Batch adsorption experiments and model simulations demonstrated the exceptional adsorption capacity of Fe3O4@GO@IIP for Cr(VI) in strongly acidic solutions (pH = 1), reaching a maximum of 89.18 mg/g. The adsorption mechanism was elucidated through XPS and DFT calculations, revealing that Fe3O4@GO@IIP operates through electrostatic interactions and chemical adsorption, with charge transfer dynamics quantified during the process. This research provides new insights for addressing Cr(VI) treatment in highly acidic environments.

Arsenic and chromium induced hepatotoxicity in zebrafish (Danio rerio) at environmentally relevant concentrations: Mixture effects and involvement of Nrf2-Keap1-ARE pathway

Arsenic (As) and chromium (Cr), two well-known cytotoxic and carcinogenic metals are reported to coexist in industrial effluents and groundwater. Their individual toxicities have been thoroughly studied but the combined effects, especially the mechanism of toxicity and cellular stress response remain unclear. Considering co-exposure as a more realistic scenario, current study compared the individual and mixture effects of As and Cr in the liver of zebrafish (Danio rerio). Fish were exposed to environmentally relevant concentrations of As and Cr for 15, 30 and 60 days. ROS generation, biochemical stress parameters like lipid peroxidation, reduced glutathione content, catalase activity and histological alterations were studied. Results showed increase in ROS production, MDA content and GSH level; and vicissitude in catalase activity as well as altered histoarchitecture, indicating oxidative stress conditions after individual and combined exposure of As and Cr which were additive in nature. This study also included the expression of Nrf2, the key regulator of antioxidant stress responses and its nuclear translocation. Related antioxidant and xenobiotic metabolizing enzyme genes like keap1, nqo1, ho1, mnsod and cyp1a were also studied. Overall results indicated increased nrf2, nqo1, ho1, mnsod expression at all time points and increased cyp1a expression after 60 days exposure. Emphasizing on the Nrf2-Keap1 pathway, this study exhibited additive or sometimes synergistic effects of As and Cr in zebrafish liver.

Elements in cultured fishes in Chittagong, Bangladesh and risk assessment

The concentrations of manganese, iron, copper, lead, nickel, cadmium, arsenic, copper and mercury were determined in 10 cultured fish species, which were collected from local markets of Chittagong, Bangladesh, in June 2021. Measurements were performed by atomic absorption spectrophotometry, after acid digestion of the samples. In some cases, the concentration of the investigated elements was more than the maximum limit set by the WHO. Although the concentration of toxic elements in fishes was relatively high in some species, no health risk has been identified in comparison to the estimated daily intake and the maximum limit. Calculated hazard indices were below 1, which indicates the investigated fish would not cause human health risks. Carcinogenic risk indices for Cr, As, and Cu in all species were considered to be significant.