Epilepsy surgery in the first six months of life: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Surgical versus medical treatment of drug resistant epilepsy in children: Seizure and non-seizure outcomes

The goal of epilepsy treatment is to achieve the most significant seizure reduction, aiming for seizure freedom, in the absence of consequential adverse effects. For children with drug resistant epilepsy (DRE), surgical therapy may offer the best chance of seizure freedom, but is vastly underutilized. In cases where seizure freedom is not possible, surgery may still provide meaningful seizure reduction over that expected from continued medical management. In addition, seizure freedom and reduction can have meaningful impact on non-seizure outcomes including mortality, cognition, behavior, and cost of care. It is essential to compare the relative risks and benefits of continued medical therapy versus surgical therapy in order to best inform choice of treatment in pediatric DRE and avoid unnecessary delays. In this review, we explore the seizure and non-seizure benefits of epilepsy surgery, including curative procedures and those expected to result in meaningful seizure reduction, compared to continued medical management in children.

Developmental outcome in infancy after epilepsy surgery and its associated factors: A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the impact of epilepsy surgery on the developmental outcome in infancy with pharmacoresistant epilepsy and its associated factors.

METHOD

This systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted in adherence with PRISMA 2020. Literature searching was done using PubMed, CENTRAL, and Scopus database. The risk of bias within included studies was evaluated using ROBINS-I. The developmental outcome was explored by comparing the developmental quotient (DQ) between before and after the epilepsy surgery. The subgroup analysis was planned for sex, etiology, affected side, affected lobe, surgical method and intention, and seizure-free state after the surgery. Age at onset of epilepsy, age at surgery, duration of disease, and follow-up time were explored as well in meta-regression.

RESULT

Ten articles were included in this review yielded 361 participants. The overall meta-analysis did not show a significant change of DQ after the surgery (MD -2.38; 95%CI -5.53 - 0.78). The comparison of delta DQ between seizure-free and not seizure-free population was not significantly different (seizure-free group; MD -4.33; 95%CI -20.37 - 11.70 vs. non-seizure-free group; MD -4.34; 95%CI -16.22 - 7.54). No independent significant moderator was identified.

CONCLUSION

Epilepsy surgery may offer some benefits in infants with PRE despite most participants having stable developmental progress. Seizure-free state following epilepsy surgery is crucial for infants' development; however, not all epileptogenic lesions are located in the favourable and resectable area. Hence, seizure control with palliative surgery shall be offered.

Somatic DNA Variants in Epilepsy Surgery Brain Samples from Patients with Lesional Epilepsy

Epilepsy affects 50 million people worldwide and is drug-resistant in approximately one-third of cases. Even when a structural lesion is identified as the epileptogenic focus, understanding the underlying genetic causes is crucial to guide both counseling and treatment decisions. Both somatic and germline DNA variants may contribute to the lesion itself and/or influence the severity of symptoms. We therefore used whole exome sequencing (WES) to search for potentially pathogenic somatic DNA variants in brain samples from children with lesional epilepsy who underwent epilepsy surgery. WES was performed on 20 paired DNA samples extracted from both lesional brain tissue and reference tissue from the same patient, such as leukocytes or fibroblasts. The paired WES data were jointly analyzed using GATK Mutect2 to identify somatic single nucleotide variants (SNVs) or insertions/deletions (InDels), which were subsequently evaluated in silico for their disease-causing potential using MutationTaster2021. We identified known pathogenic somatic variants in five patients (25%) with variant allele frequencies (VAF) ranging from 3-35% in the genes MTOR, TSC2, PIK3CA, FGFR1, and PIK3R1 as potential causes of cortical malformations or central nervous system (CNS) tumors. Depending on the VAF, we used different methods such as Sanger sequencing, allele-specific qPCR, or targeted ultra-deep sequencing (amplicon sequencing) to confirm the variant. In contrast to the usually straightforward confirmation of germline variants, the validation of somatic variants is more challenging because current methods have limitations in sensitivity, specificity, and cost-effectiveness. In our study, WES identified additional somatic variant candidates in additional genes with VAFs ranging from 0.7-7.0% that could not be validated by an orthogonal method. This highlights the importance of variant validation, especially for those with very low allele frequencies.

Impact of epilepsy surgery on developmental trajectories of children under 3 years of age

AIM

To investigate the developmental effects of epilepsy surgery in young children.

METHOD

This study retrospectively reviewed 315 consecutive children under 3 years of age, and ultimately included 89 children (48 males, 41 females) with pre- and postsurgery developmental evaluations.

RESULTS

The mean general quotient before surgery was 46.7 (SD 24.7). Before surgery, the general quotient decreased in 77.6% of patients, while after surgery it increased in 55.1%. Furthermore, 70% of those 20 patients whose presurgical general quotient decreased by more than 10 points experienced positive changes. General quotient scores decreased in 15 out of the 22 patients classified in the normal/marginal presurgical category. Children who underwent surgery before the age of 12 months had a median gain in general quotient score by 7.6. Short-term general quotient scores were highly correlated with long-term scores (r = 0.909, p < 0.001).

INTERPRETATION

Surgical intervention was more inclined to positively impact developmental trajectories within a short postsurgical period, particularly among those affected by severe epileptic activity. However, in children with relatively typical development, certain developmental setbacks may arise. Postsurgical short-term developmental outcomes could predict longer-term outcomes.

Trends, outcomes, and complications of surgery for lesional epilepsy in infants and toddlers: A multicenter study

OBJECTIVE

To assess seizure and developmental outcomes, their predictors, and complications in 160 children who, between 1998 and 2022, underwent surgery for lesional epilepsy with curative intent before the age of 3 years. To compare trends in epilepsy surgery in this age group before and after the year 2014.

METHODS

Retrospective multicenter study. Descriptive and univariate analyses, and multivariable models for all outcomes.

RESULTS

These 160 patients (76 F; 47.5%) underwent 169 surgeries (age at surgery 20.4 ± 9.4 months). At the last follow-up (77 ± 57.4 months), 121 patients (75.6%) were in Engel class I, 106 (66.2%) of whom were in Engel class Ia. Antiseizure medications were stopped in 84 patients (52.5%). Complications requiring reoperations were observed in 16 patients (10%; 9.5% of surgeries) and unexpected permanent deficits in 12 (7.5%; 7.1% of surgeries). Postoperative cognitive functions remained unchanged in 56 patients (44.4%), improved in 51 (40.5%), and worsened in 19 (15.1%). Multivariable analyses showed that the probability of achieving Engel class Ia was lower when the duration of epilepsy was longer, patients underwent preoperative video-EEG, and unexpected postoperative permanent deficits occurred. Cognitive improvement after surgery was associated with lower preoperative seizure frequency, better preoperative developmental level, and a longer postoperative follow-up. FCDII and tumors were the histopathologies carrying a higher probability of achieving seizure freedom, while polymicrogyria was associated with a lower probability of cognitive improvement. The number of patients operated on after 2014 was higher than before (61.3% vs. 38.7%), with stable outcomes.

SIGNIFICANCE

Epilepsy surgery is effective and safe in infants and toddlers, although the complication rate is higher than seen in older patients. Shorter duration of epilepsy, lower seizure frequency, no need for video-EEG, tumors, and some malformations of cortical development are robust predictors of seizure and cognitive outcome that may be exploited to increase earlier referral.

PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY

This study analyzed the results of epilepsy surgery in 160 children who had been operated on before the age of 3 years at four Italian centers between 1998 and 2022. At the last follow-up (77 ± 57.4 months), 121 patients (75.6%) were free from disabling seizures, of which 106 (66.2%) were completely seizure-free since surgery. Major surgical complications occurred in 28 patients (17.5%), which is higher than observed with epilepsy surgery in general, but similar to hemispheric/multilobar surgery. Postoperative cognitive function remained unchanged in 56 patients (44.4%), improved in 51 (40.5%), and worsened in 19 (15.1%). Epilepsy surgery is effective and safe in infants and toddlers.

The importance of routine genetic testing in pediatric epilepsy surgery

Genetic variants in relevant genes coexisting with MRI lesions in children with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) can negatively influence epilepsy surgery outcomes. Still, presurgical evaluation does not include genetic diagnostics routinely. Here, we report our presurgical evaluation algorithm that includes routine genetic testing. We analyzed retrospectively the data of 68 children with DRE operated at a mean age of 7.8 years (IQR: 8.1 years) at our center. In 49 children, genetic test results were available. We identified 21 gene variants (ACMG III: n = 7, ACMG IV: n = 2, ACMG V: n = 12) in 19 patients (45.2%) in the genes TSC1, TSC2, MECP2, DEPDC5, HUWE1, GRIN1, ASH1I, TRIO, KIF5C, CDON, ANKD11, TGFBR2, ATN1, COL4A1, JAK2, KCNQ2, ATP1A2, and GLI3 by whole-exome sequencing as well as deletions and duplications by array CGH in six patients. While the results did not change the surgery indication, they supported counseling with respect to postoperative chance of seizure freedom and weaning of antiseizure medication (ASM). The presence of genetic findings leads to the postoperative retention of at least one ASM. In our cohort, the International League against Epilepsy (ILAE) seizure outcome did not differ between patients with and without abnormal genetic findings. However, in the 7/68 patients with an unsatisfactory ILAE seizure outcome IV or V 12 months postsurgery, 2 had an abnormal or suspicious genetic finding as a putative explanation for persisting seizures postsurgery, and 3 had received palliative surgery including one TSC patient. This study highlights the importance of genetic testing in children with DRE to address putative underlying germline variants as genetic epilepsy causes or predisposing factors that guide patient and/or parent counseling on a case-by-case with respect to their individual chance of postoperative seizure freedom and ASM weaning. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Genetic variants in children with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) can negatively influence epilepsy surgery outcomes. However, presurgical evaluation does not include genetic diagnostics routinely. This retrospective study analyzed the genetic testing results of the 68 pediatric patients who received epilepsy surgery in our center. We identified 21 gene variants by whole-exome sequencing as well as deletions and duplications by array CGH in 6 patients. These results highlight the importance of genetic testing in children with DRE to guide patient and/or parent counseling on a case-by-case with respect to their individual chance of postoperative seizure freedom and ASM weaning.

Connectome-based approaches in pediatric epilepsy surgery: "State-of-the art" and future perspectives

Modern epilepsy science has overcome the traditional interpretation of a strict region-specific origin of epilepsy, highlighting the involvement of wider patterns of altered neuronal circuits. In selected cases, surgery may constitute a valuable option to achieve both seizure freedom and neurocognitive improvement. Although epilepsy is now considered as a brain network disease, the most relevant literature concerning the "connectome-based" epilepsy surgery mainly refers to adults, with a limited number of studies dedicated to the pediatric population. In this review, the Authors summarized the main current available knowledge on the relevance of WM surgical anatomy in epilepsy surgery, the post-surgical modifications of brain structural connectivity and the related clinical impact of such modifications within the pediatric context. In the last part, possible implications and future perspectives of this approach have been discussed, especially concerning the optimization of surgical strategies and the predictive value of the epilepsy network analysis for planning tailored approaches, with the final aim of improving case selection, presurgical planning, intraoperative management, and postoperative results.

Real-world experience with cenobamate: A systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Despite many new ASM, the rate of patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) has not changed. Cenobamate (CNB) is a novel ASM for the treatment of focal-onset seizures in adults with high seizure freedom rates in randomized controlled trials (RCT). Although CNB appears to be effective, it is not commonly prescribed to patients with DRE, resulting in a lack of "real-world data".

METHODS

To evaluate the real-world effect of CNB and to assess the generalizability of RCT data, a systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted. Pooled proportions were calculated using a random intercept logistic regression model.

RESULTS

The analysis included seven studies with a total of 229 patients with DRE, 77.3 % of whom were adults and 91.5 % had focal-onset seizures. Seizure reduction >50 % was achieved in 68 % of patients [54.54; 79.07], with seizure freedom in 16.2 % [8.38; 28.97]. There was no difference between pediatric and adult patients. CNB was discontinued in 10 % [6.74; 14.6] of patients, mostly due to lack of efficacy (39 %) or adverse effects (AE, 43 %). AE, observed in 57.3 % [39.7; 73.2] of patients, included fatigue and vertigo. A comparison of the rates calculated in this meta-analysis to the active arm of equivalent RCTs revealed no significant difference.

CONCLUSION

CNB achieves a good treatment response in patients with DRE in real-world settings, like the effect reported in RCTs. The high heterogeneity between studies calls for studies focusing on specific DRE subpopulations.

Epilepsy surgery in early infancy: A retrospective, multicenter study

Although epilepsy surgery is the only curative therapeutic approach for lesional drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE), there is reluctance to operate on infants due to a fear of complications. A recent meta-analysis showed that epilepsy surgery in the first 6 months of life can achieve seizure control in about two thirds of children. However, robust data on surgical complications and postoperative cognitive development are lacking. We performed a retrospective multicenter study of infants who underwent epilepsy surgery in the first 6 months of life. 15 infants underwent epilepsy surgery at a median age of 134 days (IQR: 58) at four centers. The most common cause was malformation of cortical development, and 13 patients underwent a hemispherotomy. Two thirds required intraoperative red blood transfusions. Severe intraoperative complications occurred in two patients including death in one infant due to cardiovascular insufficiency. At a median follow-up of 1.5 years (IQR: 1.8), 57% of patients were seizure-free. Three patients where reoperated at a later age, resulting in 79% seizure freedom. Anti-seizure medication could be reduced in two thirds, and all patients improved in their development. Our findings suggest that early epilepsy surgery can result in good seizure control and developmental improvement. However, given the perioperative risks, it should be performed only in specialized centers.

Cenobamate significantly improves seizure control in intellectually disabled patients with drug-resistant epilepsy and allows drug load reduction

Introduction

Epilepsy patients with intellectual disability often suffer from drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE), which severely affects patients' quality of life. Cenobamate (CNB) is a recently approved novel and effective ASM that can achieve high rates of seizure freedom in previously drug-resistant patients.

Methods

We performed a retrospective data analysis of the first patients treated with CNB at a single center. Outcome and treatment response were assessed at two different time points, and ASM burden was calculated.

Results

A 12 patients (7 males and 5 females) began treatment at a median age of 43 years, six of whom had developmental and epileptic encephalopathies. Prior to treatment with CNB, patients had tried a median of 13 different ASM. At the start of CNB therapy, patients were taking a median of 3 ASM. Treatment outcomes were available for 11 patients. After the first follow-up period (median 9 months), 55% of patients showed a significant seizure reduction of more than 50%, with three patients showing a reduction of more than 75% (27%). One patient achieved complete seizure freedom, while one patient did not respond to treatment. These response rates were consistently maintained at second follow-up after a median of 22 months. Ten patients (83%) reported adverse events (AE), the most common of which were dizziness and fatigue. No cases of drug reactions with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms (DRESS) were observed. The majority of AEs were mild and resolved over time. In addition, most patients were able to reduce their concomitant ASM.

Discussion

Cenobamate has been shown to be an effective ASM in patients with DRE and in patients with intellectual disabilities. After more than 1 year of treatment with CNB, close monitoring and management of drug-drug interactions may reduce enzyme-inducing ASMs and lead to better long-term outcomes. With CNB treatment, many patients can achieve a reduced overall drug burden while maintaining a reduction in seizures.

Is There a Cognitive Decline in Pediatric Patients Following Epilepsy Surgery?

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy surgery is currently the only way to cure drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE). The loss of epileptic activity or its propagation in the developing brain may not only result in seizure freedom but also be associated with further positive effects. Here, we analyzed the cognitive development of children and adolescents with DRE after epilepsy surgery.

METHODS

We evaluated retrospectively the cognitive development of children and adolescents before and after epilepsy surgery.

RESULTS

Fifty-three children and adolescents underwent epilepsy surgery at a median age of 7.62 years. Overall seizure freedom was 86.8% at a current median observation period of 20 months. Presurgically, 81.1% had the clinical diagnosis of cognitive impairment, which was confirmed by standardized tests in 43 of 53 patients (76.7%). Further 10 patients had severe cognitive impairment rendering a standardized test impossible. The median intelligence quotient (IQ)/development quotient value was 74. After surgery, caretakers reported developmental progress in all patients, whereas the median IQ decreased slightly (P = 0.404). In eight patients the IQ points decreased after surgery; however, their individual raw scores increased in line with their reported increase in cognitive abilities.

CONCLUSIONS

We did not detect any cognitive deterioration in children following epilepsy surgery. A loss of IQ points did not correspond to a real loss of cognitive abilities. These patients developed more slowly than age-matched peers with an average development speed but profited individually as seen in their raw scores. Therefore, an individual analysis of raw scores is relevant to assess the cognitive development after surgery.

Family Burden and Epilepsy Surgery in Children with Drug-Resistant Epilepsy

INTRODUCTION

 Family burden (FB) in pediatric patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) is significantly higher than that in children with non-DRE. Epilepsy surgery is an established approach to treat DRE, and this study examines the impact of pediatric epilepsy surgery on FB.

METHODS

 We retrospectively analyzed data of families and pediatric patients with focal structural DRE treated with epilepsy surgery at our epilepsy center from April 2018 to November 2021. We examined the relationship between cognitive, behavioral, and epilepsy-specific data and the FB measured with the German version of the Impact on Family Scale before and after epilepsy surgery.

RESULTS

 The study cohort included 31 children with DRE at a mean age of 9 years at surgery (range = 0-16) and a mean epilepsy duration of 3 years (range = 0-14). Cognitive impairment correlated with FB in children with DRE prior to surgery. At the last assessment, 14.5 months (mean, range = 6-24) after epilepsy surgery, 87.2% of patients were seizure-free, FB values had decreased by 75.0%, and behavioral problems had decreased by 85,7%. Cognitive functions remained stable following epilepsy surgery.

CONCLUSION

 In children with DRE, epilepsy surgery reduces FB. Given the considerable impact of families on the development and wellbeing of their children, the impact of epilepsy surgery should be communicated to affected families.

Surgical Resection of Focal Cortical Dysplasia in a Neonate with Novel TSC1 Mutation Leading to Resolution of Refractory Seizures: Case Report

We describe a neonate presenting on first day of life with refractory seizures secondary to a single, large area of focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) who underwent surgical resection at age 3 weeks leading to resolution of seizure activity and dramatic improvement in developmental trajectory. Surgical intervention for epilepsy is infrequently offered for neonates, often reserved only for those with catastrophic presentations. This case demonstrates that surgical intervention can be safe and efficacious in neonates for pharmaco-resistant seizures associated with a focal lesion. Rapid whole exome sequencing in this case yielded a germline novel de novo TSC1 mutation, leading to a genetic diagnosis of tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC). Our patient demonstrates an atypical neonatal presentation of TSC. Limited data is available for those with isolated FCD in TSC; this is the first reported case in a neonate.

Real-World Experience Treating Pediatric Epilepsy Patients With Cenobamate

Introduction

In one third of all patients with epilepsy, seizure freedom is not achieved through anti-seizure medication (ASM). These patients have an increased risk of earlier death, poorer cognitive development, and reduced quality of life. Cenobamate (CNB) has recently been approved as a promising novel ASM drug for the treatment of adults with focal-onset epilepsy. However, there is little experience for its application in pediatric patients.

Methods

In a multicenter study we evaluated retrospectively the outcome of 16 pediatric patients treated “off label” with CNB.

Results

In 16 patients with a mean age of 15.38 years, CNB was started at an age of 15.05 years due to DRE. Prior to initiation of therapy, an average of 10.56 (range 3–20) ASM were prescribed. At initiation, patients were taking 2.63 (range 1–4) ASM. CNB was increased by 0.47 ± 0.27mg/kg/d every 2 weeks with a mean maximum dosage of 3.1 mg/kg/d (range 0.89–7) and total daily dose of 182.81 mg (range 50–400 mg). Seizure freedom was achieved in 31.3% and a significant seizure reduction of >50% in 37.5%. Adverse events occurred in 10 patients with fatigue/somnolence as the most common. CNB is taken with high adherence in all but three patients with a median follow-up of 168.5 days

Conclusion

Cenobamate is an effective ASM for pediatric patients suffering from drug-resistant epilepsy. In addition to excellent seizure reduction or freedom, it is well-tolerated. Cenobamate should be considered as a novel treatment for DRE in pediatric patients.