The exploration of pluripotency space: Charting cell state transitions in peri-implantation development

The building blocks of embryo models: embryonic and extraembryonic stem cells

The process of a single-celled zygote developing into a complex multicellular organism is precisely regulated at spatial and temporal levels in vivo. However, understanding the mechanisms underlying development, particularly in humans, has been constrained by technical and ethical limitations associated with studying natural embryos. Harnessing the intrinsic ability of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) to self-organize when induced and assembled, researchers have established several embryo models as alternative approaches to studying early development in vitro. Recent studies have revealed the critical role of extraembryonic cells in early development; and many groups have created more sophisticated and precise ESC-derived embryo models by incorporating extraembryonic stem cell lines, such as trophoblast stem cells (TSCs), extraembryonic mesoderm cells (EXMCs), extraembryonic endoderm cells (XENs, in rodents), and hypoblast stem cells (in primates). Here, we summarize the characteristics of existing mouse and human embryonic and extraembryonic stem cells and review recent advancements in developing mouse and human embryo models.

The regulatory architecture of the primed pluripotent cell state

Despite extensive research, the gene regulatory architecture governing mammalian cell states remains poorly understood. Here we present an integrative systems biology approach to elucidate the network architecture of primed state pluripotency. Using an unbiased methodology, we identified and experimentally confirmed 132 transcription factors as master regulators (MRs) of mouse epiblast stem cell (EpiSC) pluripotency, many of which were further validated by CRISPR-mediated functional assays. To assemble a comprehensive regulatory network, we silenced each of the 132 MRs to assess their effects on the other MRs and their transcriptional targets, yielding a network of 1273 MR → MR interactions. Network architecture analyses revealed four functionally distinct MR modules (communities), and identified key Speaker and Mediator MRs based on their hierarchical rank and centrality. Our findings elucidate the de-centralized logic of a "communal interaction" model in which the balanced activities of four MR communities maintain primed state pluripotency.

Inhibition of PRC2 enables self-renewal of blastoid-competent naive pluripotent stem cells from chimpanzee

Naive pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) are counterparts of early epiblast in the mammalian embryo. Mouse and human naive PSCs differ in self-renewal requirements and extraembryonic lineage potency. Here, we investigated the generation of chimpanzee naive PSCs. Colonies generated by resetting or reprogramming failed to propagate. We discovered that self-renewal is enabled by inhibition of Polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2). Expanded cells show global transcriptome proximity to human naive PSCs and embryo pre-implantation epiblast, with shared expression of a subset of pluripotency transcription factors. Chimpanzee naive PSCs can transition to multilineage competence or can differentiate into trophectoderm and hypoblast, forming tri-lineage blastoids. They thus provide a higher primate comparative model for studying pluripotency and early embryogenesis. Genetic deletions confirm that PRC2 mediates growth arrest. Further, inhibition of PRC2 overcomes a roadblock to feeder-free propagation of human naive PSCs. Therefore, excess deposition of chromatin modification H3K27me3 is an unexpected barrier to naive PSC self-renewal.

Pluripotent cell states and fates in human embryo models

Pluripotency, the capacity to generate all cells of the body, is a defining property of a transient population of epiblast cells found in pre-, peri- and post-implantation mammalian embryos. As development progresses, the epiblast cells undergo dynamic transitions in pluripotency states, concurrent with the specification of extra-embryonic and embryonic lineages. Recently, stem cell-based models of pre- and post-implantation human embryonic development have been developed using stem cells that capture key properties of the epiblast at different developmental stages. Here, we review early primate development, comparing pluripotency states of the epiblast in vivo with cultured pluripotent cells representative of these states. We consider how the pluripotency status of the starting cells influences the development of human embryo models and, in turn, what we can learn about the human pluripotent epiblast. Finally, we discuss the limitations of these models and questions arising from the pioneering studies in this emerging field.

Progress in understanding the vertebrate segmentation clock

The segmentation clock is a molecular oscillator that regulates the periodic formation of somites from the presomitic mesoderm during vertebrate embryogenesis. Synchronous oscillatory expression of a Hairy homologue or Hairy-related basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) transcriptional repressor in presomitic mesoderm cells regulates periodic expression of downstream factors that control somite segmentation with a periodicity that varies across species. Although many of the key components of the clock have been identified and characterized, less is known about how the clock is synchronized across cells and how species-specific periodicity is achieved. Advances in live imaging, stem cell and organoid technologies, and synthetic approaches have started to uncover the detailed mechanisms underlying these aspects of somitogenesis, providing insight into how morphogenesis is coordinated in space and time during embryonic development.

Epigenetic control of cell identities from epiblast to gastrulation

Epigenetic modifications of chromatin are essential for the establishment of cell identities during embryogenesis. Between embryonic days 3.5-7.5 of murine development, major cell lineage decisions are made that discriminate extraembryonic and embryonic tissues, and the embryonic primary germ layers are formed, thereby laying down the basic body plan. In this review, we cover the contribution of dynamic chromatin modifications by DNA methylation, changes of chromatin accessibility, and histone modifications, that in combination with transcription factors control gene expression programs of different cell types. We highlight the differences in regulation of enhancer and promoter marks and discuss their requirement in cell lineage specification. Importantly, in many cases, lineage-specific targeting of epigenetic modifiers is carried out by pioneer or master transcription factors, that in sum mediate the chromatin landscape and thereby control the transcription of cell-type-specific gene programs and thus, cell identities.

The transcription factor GABPA is a master regulator of naive pluripotency

The establishment of naive pluripotency is a continuous process starting with the generation of inner cell mass (ICM) that then differentiates into epiblast (EPI). Recent studies have revealed key transcription factors (TFs) for ICM formation, but which TFs initiate EPI specification remains unknown. Here, using a targeted rapid protein degradation system, we show that GABPA is not only a regulator of major ZGA, but also a master EPI specifier required for naive pluripotency establishment by regulating 47% of EPI genes during E3.5 to E4.5 transition. Chromatin binding dynamics analysis suggests that GABPA controls EPI formation at least partly by binding to the ICM gene promoters occupied by the pluripotency regulators TFAP2C and SOX2 at E3.5 to establish naive pluripotency at E4.5. Our study not only uncovers GABPA as a master pluripotency regulator, but also supports the notion that mammalian pluripotency establishment requires a dynamic and stepwise multi-TF regulatory network.

A brief chronicle of research on human pluripotent stem cells

Today, human pluripotent stem cell technologies find widespread application across biomedical research, as models for early human development, as platforms for functional human genomics, as tools for the study of disease, drug screening and toxicology, and as a renewable source of cellular therapeutics for a range of intractable diseases. The foundations of this human pluripotent stem cell revolution rest on advances in a wide range of disciplines, including cancer biology, assisted reproduction, cell culture and organoid technology, somatic cell nuclear transfer, primate embryology, single-cell biology, and gene editing. This review surveys the slow emergence of the study of human pluripotency and the exponential growth of the field during the past several decades.

Sensing and guiding cell-state transitions by using genetically encoded endoribonuclease-mediated microRNA sensors

Precisely sensing and guiding cell-state transitions via the conditional genetic activation of appropriate differentiation factors is challenging. Here we show that desired cell-state transitions can be guided via genetically encoded sensors, whereby endogenous cell-state-specific miRNAs regulate the translation of a constitutively transcribed endoribonuclease, which, in turn, controls the translation of a gene of interest. We used this approach to monitor several cell-state transitions, to enrich specific cell types and to automatically guide the multistep differentiation of human induced pluripotent stem cells towards a haematopoietic lineage via endothelial cells as an intermediate state. Such conditional activation of gene expression is durable and resistant to epigenetic silencing and could facilitate the monitoring of cell-state transitions in physiological and pathological conditions and eventually the 'rewiring' of cell-state transitions for applications in organoid-based disease modelling, cellular therapies and regenerative medicine.

The transcription factor GABPA is a master regulator of naïve pluripotency

The establishment of naïve pluripotency is a continuous process starting with the generation of inner cell mass (ICM) which then differentiating into epiblast (EPI). Recent studies have revealed key transcription factors (TFs) for ICM formation, but which TFs initiate EPI specification remains unknown. Here, using a targeted rapid protein degradation system, we show that GABPA is not only a regulator of major ZGA, but also a master EPI specifier required for naïve pluripotency establishment by regulating 47% of EPI genes during E3.5 to E4.5 transition. Chromatin binding dynamics analysis suggests that GABPA controls EPI formation at least partly by binding to the ICM gene promoters occupied by the pluripotency regulators TFAP2C and SOX2 at E3.5 to establish naïve pluripotency at E4.5. Our study not only uncovers GABPA as a master pluripotency regulator, but also supports the notion that mammalian pluripotency establishment requires a dynamic and stepwise multi-TFs regulatory network.

Chromatin landscape dynamics during reprogramming towards human naïve and primed pluripotency reveals the divergent function of PRDM1 isoforms

Induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) technology holds great potential in both scientific research and clinical applications. It enables the generation of naïve and primed iPSCs from various cell types through different strategies. Despite extensive characterizations of transcriptional and epigenetic factors, the intricacies of chromatin landscape dynamics during naïve and primed reprogramming, particularly in humans, remain poorly understood. In this study, we employed ATAC-seq and RNA-seq analyses to delineate and compare the chromatin landscape of naïve and primed pluripotency through the human secondary reprogramming system. Our investigations revealed several key transcriptional and epigenetic factors pivotal for reprogramming-associated chromatin remodeling. Notably, we found two isoforms of PRDM1, PRDM1α, and PRDM1β, bind to distinct genomic loci and play different roles in the naïve reprogramming process. We proposed an auto-regulatory model explaining the distinct functions of PRDM1α and PRDM1β. Overall, our findings highlight the complexity and diversity of transcription factors in shaping chromatin landscape dynamics and directing the fates of pluripotent cells.

Highly efficient generation of self-renewing trophoblast from human pluripotent stem cells

Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) represent a powerful model system to study early developmental processes. However, lineage specification into trophectoderm (TE) and trophoblast (TB) differentiation remains poorly understood, and access to well-characterized placental cells for biomedical research is limited, largely depending on fetal tissues or cancer cell lines. Here, we developed novel strategies enabling highly efficient TE specification that generates cytotrophoblast (CTB) and multinucleated syncytiotrophoblast (STB), followed by the establishment of trophoblast stem cells (TSCs) capable of differentiating into extravillous trophoblast (EVT) and STB after long-term expansion. We confirmed stepwise and controlled induction of lineage- and cell-type-specific genes consistent with developmental biology principles and benchmarked typical features of placental cells using morphological, biochemical, genomics, epigenomics, and single-cell analyses. Charting a well-defined roadmap from hPSCs to distinct placental phenotypes provides invaluable opportunities for studying early human development, infertility, and pregnancy-associated diseases.

Embryonic Stem Cell Differentiation to Definitive Endoderm As a Model of Heterogeneity Onset During Germ Layer Specification

Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) hold great promise for regenerative medicine thanks to their ability to self-renew and differentiate into somatic cells and the germline. ESCs correspond to pluripotent epiblast - the tissue from which the following three germ layers originate during embryonic gastrulation: the ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm. Importantly, ESCs can be induced to differentiate toward various cell types by varying culture conditions, which can be exploited for in vitro modeling of developmental processes such as gastrulation. The classical model of gastrulation postulates that mesoderm and endoderm specification is made possible through the FGF-, BMP-, Wnt-, and Nodal-signaling gradients. Hence, it can be expected that one of these signals should direct ESC differentiation towards specific germ layers. However, ESC specification appears to be more complicated, and the same signal can be interpreted differently depending on the readout. In this research, using chemically defined culture conditions, homogeneous naïve ESCs as a starting cell population, and the Foxa2 gene-driven EGFP reporter tool, we established a robust model of definitive endoderm (DE) specification. This in vitro model features formative pluripotency as an intermediate state acquired by the epiblast in vivo shortly after implantation. Despite the initially homogeneous state of the cells in the model and high Activin concentration during endodermal specification, there remains a cell subpopulation that does not reach the endodermal state. This simple model developed by us can be used to study the origins of cellular heterogeneity during germ layer specification.

ERK5 promotes autocrine expression to sustain mitogenic balance for cell fate specification in human pluripotent stem cells

The homeostasis of human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) requires the signaling balance of extracellular factors. Exogenous regulators from cell culture medium have been widely reported, but little attention has been paid to the autocrine factor from hPSCs themselves. In this report, we demonstrate that extracellular signal-related kinase 5 (ERK5) regulates endogenous autocrine factors essential for pluripotency and differentiation. ERK5 inhibition leads to erroneous cell fate specification in all lineages even under lineage-specific induction. hPSCs can self-renew under ERK5 inhibition in the presence of fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2) and transforming growth factor β (TGF-β), although NANOG expression is partially suppressed. Further analysis demonstrates that ERK5 promotes the expression of autocrine factors such as NODAL, FGF8, and WNT3. The addition of NODAL protein rescues NANOG expression and differentiation phenotypes under ERK5 inhibition. We demonstrate that constitutively active ERK5 pathway allows self-renewal even without essential growth factors FGF2 and TGF-β. This study highlights the essential contribution of autocrine pathways to proper maintenance and differentiation.

ETV4 is a mechanical transducer linking cell crowding dynamics to lineage specification

Dynamic changes in mechanical microenvironments, such as cell crowding, regulate lineage fates as well as cell proliferation. Although regulatory mechanisms for contact inhibition of proliferation have been extensively studied, it remains unclear how cell crowding induces lineage specification. Here we found that a well-known oncogene, ETS variant transcription factor 4 (ETV4), serves as a molecular transducer that links mechanical microenvironments and gene expression. In a growing epithelium of human embryonic stem cells, cell crowding dynamics is translated into ETV4 expression, serving as a pre-pattern for future lineage fates. A switch-like ETV4 inactivation by cell crowding derepresses the potential for neuroectoderm differentiation in human embryonic stem cell epithelia. Mechanistically, cell crowding inactivates the integrin-actomyosin pathway and blocks the endocytosis of fibroblast growth factor receptors (FGFRs). The disrupted FGFR endocytosis induces a marked decrease in ETV4 protein stability through ERK inactivation. Mathematical modelling demonstrates that the dynamics of cell density in a growing human embryonic stem cell epithelium precisely determines the spatiotemporal ETV4 expression pattern and, consequently, the timing and geometry of lineage development. Our findings suggest that cell crowding dynamics in a stem cell epithelium drives spatiotemporal lineage specification using ETV4 as a key mechanical transducer.

Lumen expansion is initially driven by apical actin polymerization followed by osmotic pressure in a human epiblast model

Post-implantation, the pluripotent epiblast in a human embryo forms a central lumen, paving the way for gastrulation. Osmotic pressure gradients are considered the drivers of lumen expansion across development, but their role in human epiblasts is unknown. Here, we study lumenogenesis in a pluripotent-stem-cell-based epiblast model using engineered hydrogels. We find that leaky junctions prevent osmotic pressure gradients in early epiblasts and, instead, forces from apical actin polymerization drive lumen expansion. Once the lumen reaches a radius of ∼12 μm, tight junctions mature, and osmotic pressure gradients develop to drive further growth. Computational modeling indicates that apical actin polymerization into a stiff network mediates initial lumen expansion and predicts a transition to pressure-driven growth in larger epiblasts to avoid buckling. Human epiblasts show transcriptional signatures consistent with these mechanisms. Thus, actin polymerization drives lumen expansion in the human epiblast and may serve as a general mechanism of early lumenogenesis.

Why study human embryo development?

Understanding the processes and mechanisms underlying early human embryo development has become an increasingly active and important area of research. It has potential for insights into important clinical issues such as early pregnancy loss, origins of congenital anomalies and developmental origins of adult disease, as well as fundamental insights into human biology. Improved culture systems for preimplantation embryos, combined with the new tools of single cell genomics and live imaging, are providing new insights into the similarities and differences between human and mouse development. However, access to human embryo material is still restricted and extended culture of early embryos has regulatory and ethical concerns. Stem cell-derived models of different phases of human development can potentially overcome these limitations and provide a scalable source of material to explore the early postimplantation stages of human development. To date, such models are clearly incomplete replicas of normal development but future technological improvements can be envisaged. The ethical and regulatory environment for such studies remains to be fully resolved.

Hallmarks of totipotent and pluripotent stem cell states

Though totipotency and pluripotency are transient during early embryogenesis, they establish the foundation for the development of all mammals. Studying these in vivo has been challenging due to limited access and ethical constraints, particularly in humans. Recent progress has led to diverse culture adaptations of epiblast cells in vitro in the form of totipotent and pluripotent stem cells, which not only deepen our understanding of embryonic development but also serve as invaluable resources for animal reproduction and regenerative medicine. This review delves into the hallmarks of totipotent and pluripotent stem cells, shedding light on their key molecular and functional features.

Complex regulatory networks influence pluripotent cell state transitions in human iPSCs

Stem cells exist in vitro in a spectrum of interconvertible pluripotent states. Analyzing hundreds of hiPSCs derived from different individuals, we show the proportions of these pluripotent states vary considerably across lines. We discover 13 gene network modules (GNMs) and 13 regulatory network modules (RNMs), which are highly correlated with each other suggesting that the coordinated co-accessibility of regulatory elements in the RNMs likely underlie the coordinated expression of genes in the GNMs. Epigenetic analyses reveal that regulatory networks underlying self-renewal and pluripotency are more complex than previously realized. Genetic analyses identify thousands of regulatory variants that overlapped predicted transcription factor binding sites and are associated with chromatin accessibility in the hiPSCs. We show that the master regulator of pluripotency, the NANOG-OCT4 Complex, and its associated network are significantly enriched for regulatory variants with large effects, suggesting that they play a role in the varying cellular proportions of pluripotency states between hiPSCs. Our work bins tens of thousands of regulatory elements in hiPSCs into discrete regulatory networks, shows that pluripotency and self-renewal processes have a surprising level of regulatory complexity, and suggests that genetic factors may contribute to cell state transitions in human iPSC lines.

Shear stress in the intervillous space promotes syncytial formation of iPS cells-derived trophoblasts†

The intervillous space of human placenta is filled with maternal blood, and villous trophoblasts are constantly exposed to the shear stress generated by maternal blood pressure and flow throughout the entire gestation period. However, the effects of shear stress on villous trophoblasts and their biological significance remain unknown. Here, using our recently established naïve human pluripotent stem cells-derived cytotrophoblast stem cells (nCTs) and a device that can apply arbitrary shear stress to cells, we investigated the impact of shear stress on early-stage trophoblasts. After 72 h of exposure to 10 dyn/cm2 shear stress, nCTs became fused and multinuclear, and mRNA expression of the syncytiotrophoblast (ST) markers, such as glial cell missing 1, endogenous retrovirus group W member 1 envelope, chorionic gonadotropin subunit beta 3, syndecan 1, pregnancy specific beta-1-glycoprotein 3, placental growth factor, and solute carrier family 2 member 1 were significantly upregulated compared to static conditions. Immunohistochemistry showed that shear stress increased fusion index, human chorionic gonadotropin secretion, and human placental lactogen secretion. Increased microvilli formation on the surface of nCTs under flow conditions was detected using scanning electron microscopy. Intracellular cyclic adenosine monophosphate significantly increased under flow conditions. Moreover, transcriptome analysis of nCTs subjected to shear stress revealed that shear stress upregulated ST-specific genes and downregulated CT-specific genes. Collectively, these findings indicate that shear stress promotes the differentiation of nCTs into ST.

Pluripotency state transition of embryonic stem cells requires the turnover of histone chaperone FACT on chromatin

The differentiation of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) begins with the transition from the naive to the primed state. The formative state was recently established as a critical intermediate between the two states. Here, we demonstrate the role of the histone chaperone FACT in regulating the naive-to-formative transition. We found that the Q265K mutation in the FACT subunit SSRP1 increased the binding of FACT to histone H3-H4, impaired nucleosome disassembly in vitro, and reduced the turnover of FACT on chromatin in vivo. Strikingly, mouse ESCs harboring this mutation showed elevated naive-to-formative transition. Mechanistically, the SSRP1-Q265K mutation enriched FACT at the enhancers of formative-specific genes to increase targeted gene expression. Together, these findings suggest that the turnover of FACT on chromatin is crucial for regulating the enhancers of formative-specific genes, thereby mediating the naive-to-formative transition. This study highlights the significance of FACT in fine-tuning cell fate transition during early development.

Generation of induced pluripotent stem cells from Bornean orangutans

Introduction: Orangutans, classified under the Pongo genus, are an endangered non-human primate (NHP) species. Derivation of induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) represents a promising avenue for conserving the genetic resources of these animals. Earlier studies focused on deriving orangutan iPSCs (o-iPSCs) from Sumatran orangutans (Pongo abelii). To date, no reports specifically target the other Critically Endangered species in the Pongo genus, the Bornean orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus). Methods: Using Sendai virus-mediated Yamanaka factor-based reprogramming of peripheral blood mononuclear cells to generate iPSCs (bo-iPSCs) from a female captive Bornean orangutan. In this study, we evaluate the colony morphology, pluripotent markers, X chromosome activation status, and transcriptomic profile of the bo-iPSCs to demonstrate the pluripotency of iPSCs from Bornean orangutans. Results: The bo-iPSCs were successfully derived from Bornean orangutans, using Sendai virus-mediated Yamanaka factor-based reprogramming of peripheral blood mononuclear cells. When a modified 4i/L/A (m4i/L/A) culture system was applied to activate the WNT signaling pathway in these bo-iPSCs, the derived cells (m-bo-iPSCs) manifested characteristics akin to human naive pluripotent stem cells, including high expression levels of KLF17, DNMT3L, and DPPA3/5, as well as the X chromosome reactivation. Comparative RNA-seq analysis positioned the m-bo-iPSCs between human naive and formative pluripotent states. Furthermore, the m-bo-iPSCs express differentiation capacity into all three germlines, evidenced by controlled in vitro embryoid body formation assay. Discussion: Our work establishes a novel approach to preserve the genetic diversity of endangered Bornean orangutans while offering insights into primate stem cell pluripotency. In the future, derivation of the primordial germ cell-like cells (PGCLCs) from m-bo-iPSCs is needed to demonstrate the further specific application in species preservation and broaden the knowledge of primordial germ cell specification across species.

Transcription Factor EB-Mediated Lysosomal Function Regulation for Determining Stem Cell Fate under Metabolic Stress

Stem cells require high amounts of energy to replicate their genome and organelles and differentiate into numerous cell types. Therefore, metabolic stress has a major impact on stem cell fate determination, including self-renewal, quiescence, and differentiation. Lysosomes are catabolic organelles that influence stem cell function and fate by regulating the degradation of intracellular components and maintaining cellular homeostasis in response to metabolic stress. Lysosomal functions altered by metabolic stress are tightly regulated by the transcription factor EB (TFEB) and TFE3, critical regulators of lysosomal gene expression. Therefore, understanding the regulatory mechanism of TFEB-mediated lysosomal function may provide some insight into stem cell fate determination under metabolic stress. In this review, we summarize the molecular mechanism of TFEB/TFE3 in modulating stem cell lysosomal function and then elucidate the role of TFEB/TFE3-mediated transcriptional activity in the determination of stem cell fate under metabolic stress.

Dissecting embryonic and extraembryonic lineage crosstalk with stem cell co-culture

Embryogenesis necessitates harmonious coordination between embryonic and extraembryonic tissues. Although stem cells of both embryonic and extraembryonic origins have been generated, they are grown in different culture conditions. In this study, utilizing a unified culture condition that activates the FGF, TGF-β, and WNT pathways, we have successfully derived embryonic stem cells (FTW-ESCs), extraembryonic endoderm stem cells (FTW-XENs), and trophoblast stem cells (FTW-TSCs) from the three foundational tissues of mouse and cynomolgus monkey (Macaca fascicularis) blastocysts. This approach facilitates the co-culture of embryonic and extraembryonic stem cells, revealing a growth inhibition effect exerted by extraembryonic endoderm cells on pluripotent cells, partially through extracellular matrix signaling. Additionally, our cross-species analysis identified both shared and unique transcription factors and pathways regulating FTW-XENs. The embryonic and extraembryonic stem cell co-culture strategy offers promising avenues for developing more faithful embryo models and devising more developmentally pertinent differentiation protocols.

The many dimensions of germline competence

Primordial germ cell (PGC) specification is the first step in the development of the germline. Recent work has elucidated human-mouse differences in PGC differentiation and identified cell states with enhanced competency for PGC-like cell (PGCLC) differentiation in vitro in both species. However, it remains a subject of debate how different PGC competent states in vitro relate to each other, to embryonic development, and to the origin of PGCs in vivo. Here we review recent literature on human PGCLC differentiation in the context of mouse and non-human primate models. In contrast to what was previously thought, recent work suggests human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) are highly germline competent. We argue that paradoxical observations regarding the origin and signaling requirements of hPGCLCs may be due to local cell interactions. These confound assays of competence by generating endogenous signaling gradients and spatially modulating the ability to receive exogenous inductive signals. Furthermore, combinatorial signaling suggests that there is no unique germline competent state: rather than a one-dimensional spectrum of developmental progression, competence should be considered in a higher dimensional landscape of cell states.

In vitro models of human hypoblast and mouse primitive endoderm

The primitive endoderm (PrE, also named hypoblast), a predominantly extraembryonic epithelium that arises from the inner cell mass (ICM) of the mammalian pre-implantation blastocyst, plays a fundamental role in embryonic development, giving rise to the yolk sac, establishing the anterior-posterior axis and contributing to the gut. PrE is specified from the ICM at the same time as the epiblast (Epi) that will form the embryo proper. While in vitro cell lines resembling the pluripotent Epi have been derived from a variety of conditions, only one model system currently exists for the PrE, naïve extraembryonic endoderm (nEnd). As a result, considerably more is known about the gene regulatory networks and signalling requirements of pluripotent stem cells than nEnd. In this review, we describe the ontogeny and differentiation of the PrE or hypoblast in mouse and primate and then discuss in vitro cell culture models for different extraembryonic endodermal cell types.

Analysis of regulatory network modules in hundreds of human stem cell lines reveals complex epigenetic and genetic factors contribute to pluripotency state differences between subpopulations

Stem cells exist in vitro in a spectrum of interconvertible pluripotent states. Analyzing hundreds of hiPSCs derived from different individuals, we show the proportions of these pluripotent states vary considerably across lines. We discovered 13 gene network modules (GNMs) and 13 regulatory network modules (RNMs), which were highly correlated with each other suggesting that the coordinated co-accessibility of regulatory elements in the RNMs likely underlied the coordinated expression of genes in the GNMs. Epigenetic analyses revealed that regulatory networks underlying self-renewal and pluripotency have a surprising level of complexity. Genetic analyses identified thousands of regulatory variants that overlapped predicted transcription factor binding sites and were associated with chromatin accessibility in the hiPSCs. We show that the master regulator of pluripotency, the NANOG-OCT4 Complex, and its associated network were significantly enriched for regulatory variants with large effects, suggesting that they may play a role in the varying cellular proportions of pluripotency states between hiPSCs. Our work captures the coordinated activity of tens of thousands of regulatory elements in hiPSCs and bins these elements into discrete functionally characterized regulatory networks, shows that regulatory elements in pluripotency networks harbor variants with large effects, and provides a rich resource for future pluripotent stem cell research.

Modeling post-implantation stages of human development into early organogenesis with stem-cell-derived peri-gastruloids

In vitro stem cell models that replicate human gastrulation have been generated, but they lack the essential extraembryonic cells needed for embryonic development, morphogenesis, and patterning. Here, we describe a robust and efficient method that prompts human extended pluripotent stem cells to self-organize into embryo-like structures, termed peri-gastruloids, which encompass both embryonic (epiblast) and extraembryonic (hypoblast) tissues. Although peri-gastruloids are not viable due to the exclusion of trophoblasts, they recapitulate critical stages of human peri-gastrulation development, such as forming amniotic and yolk sac cavities, developing bilaminar and trilaminar embryonic discs, specifying primordial germ cells, initiating gastrulation, and undergoing early neurulation and organogenesis. Single-cell RNA-sequencing unveiled transcriptomic similarities between advanced human peri-gastruloids and primary peri-gastrulation cell types found in humans and non-human primates. This peri-gastruloid platform allows for further exploration beyond gastrulation and may potentially aid in the development of human fetal tissues for use in regenerative medicine.

Shifting early embryology paradigms: Applications of stem cell-based embryo models in bioengineering

Technologies to reproduce specific aspects of early mammalian embryogenesis in vitro using stem cells have skyrocketed over the last several years. With these advances, we have gained new perspectives on how embryonic and extraembryonic cells self-organize to form the embryo. These reductionist approaches hold promise for the future implementation of precise environmental and genetic controls to understand variables affecting embryo development. Our review discusses recent progress in cellular models of early mammalian embryo development and bioengineering advancements that can be leveraged to study the embryo-maternal interface. We summarize current gaps in the field, emphasizing the importance of understanding how intercellular interactions at this interface contribute to reproductive and developmental health.

Esrrb guides naive pluripotent cells through the formative transcriptional programme

During embryonic development, naive pluripotent epiblast cells transit to a formative state. The formative epiblast cells form a polarized epithelium, exhibit distinct transcriptional and epigenetic profiles and acquire competence to differentiate into all somatic and germline lineages. However, we have limited understanding of how the transition to a formative state is molecularly controlled. Here we used murine embryonic stem cell models to show that ESRRB is both required and sufficient to activate formative genes. Genetic inactivation of Esrrb leads to illegitimate expression of mesendoderm and extra-embryonic markers, impaired formative expression and failure to self-organize in 3D. Functionally, this results in impaired ability to generate formative stem cells and primordial germ cells in the absence of Esrrb. Computational modelling and genomic analyses revealed that ESRRB occupies key formative genes in naive cells and throughout the formative state. In so doing, ESRRB kickstarts the formative transition, leading to timely and unbiased capacity for multi-lineage differentiation.

Local immune recognition of trophoblast in early human pregnancy: controversies and questions

The role of the maternal immune system in reproductive success in humans remains controversial. Here we focus on the events that occur in the maternal decidua during the first few weeks of human pregnancy, because this is the site at which maternal leukocytes initially interact with and can recognize fetal trophoblast cells, potentially involving allorecognition by both T cells and natural killer (NK) cells. NK cells are the dominant leukocyte population in first-trimester decidua, and genetic studies point to a role of allorecognition by uterine NK cells in establishing a boundary between the mother and the fetus. By contrast, definitive evidence that allorecognition by decidual T cells occurs during the first trimester is lacking. Thus, our view is that during the crucial period when the placenta is established, damaging T cell-mediated adaptive immune responses towards placental trophoblast are minimized, whereas NK cell allorecognition contributes to successful implantation and healthy pregnancy.

Translational landscape in human early neural fate determination

Gene expression regulation in eukaryotes is a multi-level process, including transcription, mRNA translation and protein turnover. Many studies have reported sophisticated transcriptional regulation during neural development, but the global translational dynamics are still ambiguous. Here, we differentiate human embryonic stem cells (ESCs) into neural progenitor cells (NPCs) with high efficiency and perform ribosome sequencing and RNA sequencing on both ESCs and NPCs. Data analysis reveals that translational controls engage in many crucial pathways and contribute significantly to regulation of neural fate determination. Furthermore, we show that the sequence characteristics of the untranslated region (UTR) might regulate translation efficiency. Specifically, genes with short 5'UTR and intense Kozak sequence are associated with high translation efficiency in human ESCs, whereas genes with long 3'UTR are related to high translation efficiency in NPCs. In addition, we have identified four biasedly used codons (GAC, GAT, AGA and AGG) and dozens of short open reading frames during neural progenitor differentiation. Thus, our study reveals the translational landscape during early human neural differentiation and provides insights into the regulation of cell fate determination at the translational level.

Dissecting embryonic and extra-embryonic lineage crosstalk with stem cell co-culture

Faithful embryogenesis requires precise coordination between embryonic and extraembryonic tissues. Although stem cells from embryonic and extraembryonic origins have been generated for several mammalian species(Bogliotti et al., 2018; Choi et al., 2019; Cui et al., 2019; Evans and Kaufman, 1981; Kunath et al., 2005; Li et al., 2008; Martin, 1981; Okae et al., 2018; Tanaka et al., 1998; Thomson et al., 1998; Vandevoort et al., 2007; Vilarino et al., 2020; Yu et al., 2021b; Zhong et al., 2018), they are grown in different culture conditions with diverse media composition, which makes it difficult to study cross-lineage communication. Here, by using the same culture condition that activates FGF, TGF-β and WNT signaling pathways, we derived stable embryonic stem cells (ESCs), extraembryonic endoderm stem cells (XENs) and trophoblast stem cells (TSCs) from all three founding tissues of mouse and cynomolgus monkey blastocysts. This allowed us to establish embryonic and extraembryonic stem cell co-cultures to dissect lineage crosstalk during early mammalian development. Co-cultures of ESCs and XENs uncovered a conserved and previously unrecognized growth inhibition of pluripotent cells by extraembryonic endoderm cells, which is in part mediated through extracellular matrix signaling. Our study unveils a more universal state of stem cell self-renewal stabilized by activation, as opposed to inhibition, of developmental signaling pathways. The embryonic and extraembryonic stem cell co-culture strategy developed here will open new avenues for creating more faithful embryo models and developing more developmentally relevant differentiation protocols.

Molecular versatility during pluripotency progression

A challenge during development is to ensure lineage segregation while preserving plasticity. Using pluripotency progression as a paradigm, we review how developmental transitions are coordinated by redeployments, rather than global resettings, of cellular components. We highlight how changes in response to extrinsic cues (FGF, WNT, Activin/Nodal, Netrin-1), context- and stoichiometry-dependent action of transcription factors (Oct4, Nanog) and reconfigurations of epigenetic regulators (enhancers, promoters, TrxG, PRC) may confer robustness to naïve to primed pluripotency transition. We propose the notion of Molecular Versatility to regroup mechanisms by which molecules are repurposed to exert different, sometimes opposite, functions in close stem cell configurations.

Human embryos in a dish – modeling early embryonic development with pluripotent stem cells

Stem cell-based embryo models present new opportunities to study early embryonic development. In a recent study, Kagawa et al. identified an approach to create human pluripotent stem cell-based blastoids that resemble the human blastocysts. These blastoids efficiently generated analogs of the EPI, TE, PrE lineages with transcriptomes highly similar to those found in vivo. Furthermore, the formation of these lineages followed the same sequence and pace of blastocyst development, and was also dependent on the same pathways required for lineage specification. Finally, the blastoids were capable of attaching to stimulated endometrial cells to mimic the process of implantation. While more comprehensive analysis is needed to confirm its validity and usefulness, this new blastoid system presents the latest development in the attempt to model early human embryogenesis in vitro.

Naive Pluripotent and Trophoblastic Stem Cell Lines as a Model for Detecting Missing Proteins in the Context of the Chromosome-Centric Human Proteome Project

The Chromosome-centric Human Proteome Project (C-HPP) aims at identifying the proteins as gene products encoded by the human genome, characterizing their isoforms and functions. The existence of products has now been confirmed for 93.2% of the genes at the protein level. The remaining mostly correspond to proteins of low abundance or difficult to access. Over the past years, we have significantly contributed to the identification of missing proteins in the human spermatozoa. We pursue our search in the reproductive sphere with a focus on early human embryonic development. Pluripotent cells, developing into the fetus, and trophoblast cells, giving rise to the placenta, emerge during the first weeks. This emergence is a focus of scientists working in the field of reproduction, placentation and regenerative medicine. Most knowledge has been harnessed by transcriptomic analysis. Interestingly, some genes are uniquely expressed in those cells, giving the opportunity to uncover new proteins that might play a crucial role in setting up the molecular events underlying early embryonic development. Here, we analyzed naive pluripotent and trophoblastic stem cells and discovered 4 new missing proteins, thus contributing to the C-HPP. The mass spectrometry proteomics data was deposited on ProteomeXchange under the data set identifier PXD035768.

Laminin111-based defined culture promoting self-renewing human pluripotent stem cells with properties of the early post-implantation epiblast

In the mammalian embryo, a formative pluripotent phase is proposed to exist at the early post-implantation period, during the transition from the pre-implantation naive-to the post-implantation primed-epiblast. By recapitulating a laminin component of the extracellular matrix niche during embryonic formative transition, and defined culture conditions, we generated cultures highly enriched for self-renewing human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), exhibiting properties of early post-implantation epiblast cells. These hPSCs display post-implantation-epiblast gene expression profiles. FGF and TGF-β signaling maintain their self-renewal for multiple passages. They have inactive canonical Wnt signaling, do not express primitive streak markers, and are competent to initiate differentiation toward germline and somatic fates. hPSCs exhibiting early post-implantation epiblast properties may shed light on human embryonic PSCs development and may serve for initiating somatic and germ cell specification.

Stabilization of cell-cell adhesions prevents symmetry breaking and locks in pluripotency in 3D gastruloids

3D embryonic stem cell (ESC) aggregates self-organize into embryo-like structures named gastruloids that recapitulate the axial organization of post-implantation embryos. Crucial in this process is the symmetry-breaking event that leads to the emergence of asymmetry and spatially ordered structures from homogeneous cell aggregates. Here, we show that budesonide, a glucocorticoid drug widely used to treat asthma, prevents ESC aggregates to break symmetry. Mechanistically, the effect of budesonide is glucocorticoid receptor independent. RNA sequencing and lineage fate analysis reveal that budesonide counteracts exit from pluripotency and modifies the expression of a large set of genes associated with cell migration, A-P axis formation, and WNT signaling. This correlates with reduced phenotypic and molecular cell heterogeneity, persistence of E-CADHERIN at the cell-cell interface, and cell aggregate compaction. Our findings reveal that cell-cell adhesion properties control symmetry breaking and cell fate transition in 3D gastruloids and suggest a potential adverse effect of budesonide on embryo development.

Human epiblast lumenogenesis: From a cell aggregate to a lumenal cyst

The formation of a central lumen in the human epiblast is a critical step for development. However, because the lumen forms in the epiblast coincident with implantation, the molecular and cellular events of this early lumenogenesis process cannot be studied in vivo. Recent developments using new model systems have revealed insight into the underpinnings of epiblast formation. To provide an up-to-date comprehensive review of human epiblast lumenogenesis, we highlight recent findings from human and mouse models with an emphasis on new molecular understanding of a newly described apicosome compartment, a novel 'formative' state of pluripotency that coordinates with epiblast polarization, and new evidence about the physical and polarized trafficking mechanisms contributing to lumenogenesis.

Modeling human extraembryonic mesoderm cells using naive pluripotent stem cells

A hallmark of primate postimplantation embryogenesis is the specification of extraembryonic mesoderm (EXM) before gastrulation, in contrast to rodents where this tissue is formed only after gastrulation. Here, we discover that naive human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) are competent to differentiate into EXM cells (EXMCs). EXMCs are specified by inhibition of Nodal signaling and GSK3B, are maintained by mTOR and BMP4 signaling activity, and their transcriptome and epigenome closely resemble that of human and monkey embryo EXM. EXMCs are mesenchymal, can arise from an epiblast intermediate, and are capable of self-renewal. Thus, EXMCs arising via primate-specific specification between implantation and gastrulation can be modeled in vitro. We also find that most of the rare off-target cells within human blastoids formed by triple inhibition (Kagawa et al., 2021) correspond to EXMCs. Our study impacts our ability to model and study the molecular mechanisms of early human embryogenesis and related defects.

Transcriptomics, regulatory syntax, and enhancer identification in mesoderm-induced ESCs at single-cell resolution

Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) can adopt lineage-specific gene-expression programs by stepwise exposure to defined factors, resulting in the generation of functional cell types. Bulk and single-cell-based assays were employed to catalog gene expression, histone modifications, chromatin conformation, and accessibility transitions in ESC populations and individual cells acquiring a presomitic mesoderm fate and undergoing further specification toward myogenic and neurogenic lineages. These assays identified cis-regulatory regions and transcription factors presiding over gene-expression programs occurring at defined ESC transitions and revealed the presence of heterogeneous cell populations within discrete ESC developmental stages. The datasets were employed to identify previously unappreciated genomic elements directing the initial activation of Pax7 and myogenic and neurogenic gene-expression programs. This study provides a resource for the discovery of genomic and transcriptional features of pluripotent, mesoderm-induced ESCs and ESC-derived cell lineages.

The Divergent Pluripotent States in Mouse and Human Cells

Pluripotent stem cells (PSCs), which can self-renew and give rise to all cell types in all three germ layers, have great potential in regenerative medicine. Recent studies have shown that PSCs can have three distinct but interrelated pluripotent states: naive, formative, and primed. The PSCs of each state are derived from different stages of the early developing embryo and can be maintained in culture by different molecular mechanisms. In this review, we summarize the current understanding on features of the three pluripotent states and review the underlying molecular mechanisms of maintaining their identities. Lastly, we discuss the interrelation and transition among these pluripotency states. We believe that comprehending the divergence of pluripotent states is essential to fully harness the great potential of stem cells in regenerative medicine.

Epigenetics as "conductor" in "orchestra" of pluripotent states

Pluripotent character is described as the potency of cells to differentiate into all three germ layers. The best example to reinstate the term lies in the context of embryonic stem cells (ESCs). Pluripotent ESC describes the in vitro status of those cells that originate during the complex process of embryogenesis. Pre-implantation to post-implantation development of embryo embrace cells with different levels of stemness. Currently, four states of pluripotency have been recognized, in the progressing order of "naïve," "poised," "formative," and "primed." Epigenetics act as the "conductor" in this "orchestra" of transition in pluripotent states. With a distinguishable gene expression profile, these four states associate with different epigenetic signatures, sometimes distinct while otherwise overlapping. The present review focuses on how epigenetic factors, including DNA methylation, bivalent chromatin, chromatin remodelers, chromatin/nuclear architecture, and microRNA, could dictate pluripotent states and their transition among themselves.

Capturing Transitional Pluripotency through Proline Metabolism

In this paper, we summarize the current knowledge of the role of proline metabolism in the control of the identity of Embryonic Stem Cells (ESCs). An imbalance in proline metabolism shifts mouse ESCs toward a stable naïve-to-primed intermediate state of pluripotency. Proline-induced cells (PiCs), also named primitive ectoderm-like cells (EPLs), are phenotypically metastable, a trait linked to a rapid and reversible relocalization of E-cadherin from the plasma membrane to intracellular membrane compartments. The ESC-to-PiC transition relies on the activation of Erk and Tgfβ/Activin signaling pathways and is associated with extensive remodeling of the transcriptome, metabolome and epigenome. PiCs maintain several properties of naïve pluripotency (teratoma formation, blastocyst colonization and 3D gastruloid development) and acquire a few traits of primed cells (flat-shaped colony morphology, aerobic glycolysis metabolism and competence for primordial germ cell fate). Overall, the molecular and phenotypic features of PiCs resemble those of an early-primed state of pluripotency, providing a robust model to study the role of metabolic perturbations in pluripotency and cell fate decisions.

Pluripotent cell states and unexpected fates

Pluripotent stem cells provide a powerful model for the study of human development and its disorders. Recent studies, including two in this issue of Stem Cell Reports, raise important questions concerning the developmental potential of human pluripotent stem cells, and how the behavior of these cells in vitro mirrors normal embryogenesis.

Current understanding of genomic stability maintenancein pluripotent stem cells

Pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) are able to generate all cell types in the body and have wide applications in basic research and cell-based regenerative medicine. Maintaining stable genome in culture is the first priority for stem cell application in clinics. In addition, genomic instability in PSCs can cause developmental failure or abnormalities. Understanding how PSCs maintain genome stability is of critical importance. Due to their fundamental role in organism development, PSCs must maintain superior stable genome than differentiated cells. However, the underlying mechanisms are far from clear. Very limited studies suggest that PSCs utilize specific strategies and regulators to robustly improve genome stability. In this review, we summarize the current understandings of the unique properties of genome stability maintenance in PSCs.

Cnot8 eliminates naïve regulation networks and is essential for naïve-to-formative pluripotency transition

Mammalian early epiblasts at different phases are characterized by naïve, formative, and primed pluripotency states, involving extensive transcriptome changes. Here, we report that deadenylase Cnot8 of Ccr4-Not complex plays essential roles during the transition from naïve to formative state. Knock out (KO) Cnot8 resulted in early embryonic lethality in mice, but Cnot8 KO embryonic stem cells (ESCs) could be established. Compared with the cells differentiated from normal ESCs, Cnot8 KO cells highly expressed a great many genes during their differentiation into the formative state, including several hundred naïve-like genes enriched in lipid metabolic process and gene expression regulation that may form the naïve regulation networks. Knockdown expression of the selected genes of naïve regulation networks partially rescued the differentiation defects of Cnot8 KO ESCs. Cnot8 depletion led to the deadenylation defects of its targets, increasing their poly(A) tail lengths and half-life, eventually elevating their expression levels. We further found that Cnot8 was involved in the clearance of targets through its deadenylase activity and the binding of Ccr4-Not complex, as well as the interacting with Tob1 and Pabpc1. Our results suggest that Cnot8 eliminates naïve regulation networks through mRNA clearance, and is essential for naïve-to-formative pluripotency transition.

Glucose-6-Phosphate Dehydrogenase, Redox Homeostasis and Embryogenesis

Normal embryogenesis requires complex regulation and precision, which depends on multiple mechanistic details. Defective embryogenesis can occur by various mechanisms. Maintaining redox homeostasis is of importance during embryogenesis. NADPH, as produced from the action of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD), has an important role in redox homeostasis, serving as a cofactor for glutathione reductase in the recycling of glutathione from oxidized glutathione and for NADPH oxidases and nitric oxide synthases in the generation of reactive oxygen (ROS) and nitrogen species (RNS). Oxidative stress differentially influences cell fate and embryogenesis. While low levels of stress (eustress) by ROS and RNS promote cell growth and differentiation, supra-physiological concentrations of ROS and RNS can lead to cell demise and embryonic lethality. G6PD-deficient cells and organisms have been used as models in embryogenesis for determining the role of redox signaling in regulating cell proliferation, differentiation and migration. Embryogenesis is also modulated by anti-oxidant enzymes, transcription factors, microRNAs, growth factors and signaling pathways, which are dependent on redox regulation. Crosstalk among transcription factors, microRNAs and redox signaling is essential for embryogenesis.