Persistently increased cell-free DNA concentrations only modestly contribute to outcome and host response in sepsis survivors with chronic critical illness

Inflammatory Response and Anti-Inflammatory Treatment in Persistent Inflammation-Immunosuppression-Catabolism Syndrome (PICS)

Many patients now survive their initial critical events but subsequently develop chronic critical illness (CCI). CCI is characterized by prolonged hospital stays, poor outcomes, and significant long-term mortality. The incidence of chronic critical illness (CCI) is estimated to be 34.4 cases per 100,000 population. The incidence varies significantly with age, peaking at 82.1 cases per 100,000 in individuals aged 75-79. The one-year mortality rate among CCI patients approaches 50%. A subset of these patients enters a state of persistent inflammation, immune suppression, and ongoing catabolism, a condition termed persistent inflammation, immunosuppression, and catabolism syndrome (PICS) in 2012. In recent years, some progress has been made in treating PICS. For instance, recent advancements such as the persistent expansion of MDSCs (myeloid-derived suppressor cells) and the mechanisms underlying intestinal barrier dysfunction have provided new directions for therapeutic strategies, as discussed below. Persistent inflammation, a key feature of PICS, has received comparatively little research attention. In this review, we examine the potential pathophysiological changes and molecular mechanisms underlying persistent inflammation and its role in PICS. We also discuss current therapies about inflammation and offer recommendations for managing patients with PICS.

A Qualitative Study of the Experience of Multidisciplinary Teamwork in Chronic Critical Illness Patients

Purpose

To explore the reasons for poor multidisciplinary team (MDT) cooperation of Chronic Critical Illness (CCI) patients and their needs and expectations for carrying out MDT cooperation, with a view to providing references for improving MDT cooperation of CCI patients.

Methods

Semi-structured interviews with 15 members of the MDT of CCI patients in a hospital of Henan Province were conducted in September and October of 2024 using a descriptive qualitative design. The data were analyzed using the thematic analysis method developed by Braun and Clarke.

Results

Three themes emerged: Theme 1: The collaborative experience of MDT members, with three sub-themes: essential MDT cooperation, absence of specialized MDT, and the nurse's diminished role; Theme 2: Barriers to MDT cooperation, with three sub-themes: unclear cooperation process and job responsibilities, lack of effective communication, and insufficient observation and feedback; Theme 3: Facilitators to MDT cooperation, divided into three sub-themes: timely and effective communication, a leading role, well-developed MDT tools.

Conclusion

Due to the following deficiencies: unclear cooperation process and job responsibilities, lack of effective communication, and insufficient observation and feedback, it is urgent to take appropriate measures to promote MDT cooperation for CCI patients.

Definitions, epidemiology, and outcomes of persistent/chronic critical illness: a scoping review for translation to clinical practice

BACKGROUND

Medical advances in intensive care units (ICUs) have resulted in the emergence of a new patient population-those who survive the initial acute phase of critical illness, but require prolonged ICU stays and develop chronic critical symptoms. This condition, often termed Persistent Critical Illness (PerCI) or Chronic Critical Illness (CCI), remains poorly understood and inconsistently reported across studies, resulting in a lack of clinical practice use. This scoping review aims to systematically review and synthesize the existing literature on PerCI/CCI, with a focus on definitions, epidemiology, and outcomes for its translation to clinical practice.

METHODS

A scoping review was conducted using MEDLINE and Scopus, adhering to the PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Peer-reviewed original research articles published until May 31, 2024 that described adult PerCI/CCI in their definitions of patient populations, covariates, and outcomes were included. Data on definitions, epidemiology, and outcomes were extracted by a data charting process from eligible studies and synthesized.

RESULTS

Ninety-nine studies met the inclusion criteria. Of these studies, 64 used the term CCI, 18 used PerCI, and 17 used other terms. CCI definitions showed greater variability, while PerCI definitions remained relatively consistent, with an ICU stay ≥ 14 days for CCI and ≥ 10 days for PerCI being the most common. A meta-analysis of the prevalence of PerCI/CCI among the denominators of "all ICU patients", "sepsis", "trauma", and "COVID-19" showed 11% (95% confidence interval 10-12%), 28% (22-34%), 24% (15-33%), and 35% (20-50%), respectively. A meta-analysis of in-hospital mortality was 27% (26-29%) and that of one-year mortality was 45% (32-58%). Meta-analyses of the prevalence of CCI and PerCI showed 17% (16-18%) and 18% (16-20%), respectively, and those for in-hospital mortality were 28% (26-30%) and 26% (24-29%), respectively. Functional outcomes were generally poor, with many survivors requiring long-term care.

CONCLUSIONS

This scoping review synthesized many studies on PerCI/CCI, highlighting the serious impact of PerCI/CCI on patients' long-term outcomes. The results obtained underscore the need for consistent terminology with high-quality research for PerCI/CCI. The results obtained provide important information to be used in discussions with patients and families regarding prognosis and care options.

Molecular basis of sepsis: A New insight into the role of mitochondrial DNA as a damage-associated molecular pattern

Sepsis remains a critical challenge in the field of medicine, claiming countless lives each year. Despite significant advances in medical science, the molecular mechanisms underlying sepsis pathogenesis remain elusive. Understanding molecular sequelae is gaining deeper insights into the roles played by various damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) and pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) in disease pathogenesis. Among the known DAMPs, circulating cell-free mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) garners increasing attention as a key player in the immune response during sepsis and other diseases. Mounting evidence highlights numerous connections between circulating cell-free mtDNA and inflammation, a pivotal state of sepsis, characterized by heightened inflammatory activity. In this review, we aim to provide an overview of the molecular basis of sepsis, particularly emphasizing the role of circulating cell-free mtDNA as a DAMP. We discuss the mechanisms of mtDNA release, its interaction with pattern recognition receptors (PRRs), and the subsequent immunological responses that contribute to sepsis progression. Furthermore, we discuss the forms of cell-free mtDNA; detection techniques of circulating cell-free mtDNA in various biological fluids; and the diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic implications offering insights into the potential for innovative interventions in sepsis management.

Risk factors, biomarkers, and mechanisms for persistent inflammation, immunosuppression, and catabolism syndrome (PICS): a systematic review and meta-analysis

INTRODUCTION

Persistent inflammation, immunosuppression, and catabolism syndrome (PICS) has been proposed as an endotype of chronic critical illness (CCI). The aim of this systematic review is to synthesise the available evidence of risk factors, biomarkers, and biological mechanisms underlying PICS.

METHODS

MEDLINE, CENTRAL, and EMBASE were searched on June 2, 2023. Our population of interest was adult intensive care unit survivors. The exposure group was patients with PICS and the comparator group was patients with no PICS, CCI, or rapid recovery. Mean differences were pooled for each biomarker using a random effects DerSimonian-Laird method. Risk of bias assessment was done using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

RESULTS

Six papers were included. Five were single-centre retrospective cohort studies, and one was a prospective cohort study, with sample sizes ranging from 22 to 391 patients. Two studies showed an increased incidence of PICS with age, and two studies showed an association between PICS and Charlson Comorbidity Index scores. PICS was associated with requiring mechanical ventilation in four studies. Meta-analysis showed a 34.4 mg L-1 higher C-reactive protein (95% confidence interval [CI] 12.7-56.2 mg L-1; P<0.01), a 4.4 g L-1 lower albumin (95% CI 0.5-8.3 g L-1; P<0.01), and a 0.36×109 L-1 lower lymphocyte count (95% CI 0.25-0.47×109 L-1; P=0.01) in the PICS compared with the non-PICS group. There are a large variety of other potential biomarkers but limited validation studies. The overall quality of evidence is limited, and these results should be interpreted accordingly.

CONCLUSIONS

While older patients and those with co-morbidities could be at greater risk for PICS, acquired risk factors, such as injury severity, are potentially more predictive of PICS than intrinsic patient characteristics. There are many potential biomarkers for PICS, but limited validation studies have been conducted. Persistent myeloid-derived suppressor cell expansion, the continual release of danger-associated molecular patterns and pathogen-associated molecular patterns propagating inflammation, and bioenergetic failure are all mechanisms underlying PICS that could offer potential for novel biomarkers and therapeutic interventions.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION

International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO; CRD42023427749).

Role of cell-free DNA levels in the diagnosis and prognosis of sepsis and bacteremia: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Sepsis remains a major cause of mortality in intensive care units (ICUs). Prompt diagnosis and effective management are imperative for better outcomes. In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we explore the potential of circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA), as a promising tool for early sepsis detection and prognosis assessment, aiming to address limitations associated with traditional diagnostic methods.

METHODS

Following PRISMA guidelines, we collected relevant literature from thirteen databases. Studies were included if they analyzed quantitative diagnostic or prognostic cfDNA levels in humans in case of sepsis. We collected data on basic study characteristics, baseline patient demographics (e.g. age and sex), and cfDNA levels across different stages of sepsis. Pooled SMD with 95%-CI was calculated, and Comprehensive Meta-Analysis (CMA) software facilitated meta-analysis. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were generated to assess cfDNA's combined sensitivity and specificity in diagnostics and prognostics.

RESULTS

We included a final of 44 studies, of which, only 32 with 2950 participants were included in the meta-analysis. cfDNA levels were higher in septic patients compared to healthy controls (SMD = 3.303; 95%-CI [2.461-4.145], p<0.01). Furthermore, cfDNA levels were higher in non-survivors than survivors (SMD = 1.554; 95%-CI [0.905-2.202], p<0.01). Prognostic studies demonstrated a pooled sensitivity and specificity of 0.78, while diagnostic studies showed a sensitivity of 0.81 and a specificity of 0.87.

CONCLUSION

These findings show that cfDNA levels are significantly higher in sepsis patients compared to control groups and non-survivors in comparison to survivors among both adult and pediatric populations.

The Tri-Steps Model of Critical Conditions in Intensive Care: Introducing a New Paradigm for Chronic Critical Illness

Background: The prevailing model for understanding chronic critical illness is a biphasic model, suggesting phases of acute and chronic critical conditions. A major challenge within this model is the difficulty in determining the timing of the process chronicity. It is likely that the triad of symptoms (inflammation, catabolism, and immunosuppression [ICIS]) could be associated with this particular point. We aimed to explore the impact of the symptom triad (inflammation, catabolism, immunosuppression) on the outcomes of patients hospitalized in intensive care units (ICUs). Methods: The eICU-CRD database with 200,859 ICU admissions was analyzed. Adult patients with the ICIS triad, identified by elevated CRP (>20 mg/L), reduced albumin (<30 g/L), and low lymphocyte counts (<0.8 × 109/L), were included. The cumulative risk of developing ICIS was assessed using the Nelson-Aalen estimator. Results: This retrospective cohort study included 894 patients (485 males, 54%), with 60 (6.7%) developing ICIS. The cumulative risk of ICIS by day 21 was 22.5%, with incidence peaks on days 2-3 and 10-12 after ICU admission. Patients with the ICIS triad had a 2.5-fold higher mortality risk (p = 0.009) and double the likelihood of using vasopressors (p = 0.008). The triad onset day did not significantly affect mortality (p = 0.104). Patients with ICIS also experienced extended hospital (p = 0.041) and ICU stays (p < 0.001). Conclusions: The symptom triad (inflammation, catabolism, immunosuppression) during hospitalization increases mortality risk by 2.5 times (p = 0.009) and reflects the chronicity of the critical condition. Identifying two incidence peaks allows the proposal of a new Tri-steps model of chronic critical illness with acute, extended, and chronic phases.

Cell-free DNA in patients with sepsis: long term trajectory and association with 28-day mortality and sepsis-associated acute kidney injury

Introduction

Outcome-prediction in patients with sepsis is challenging and currently relies on the serial measurement of many parameters. Standard diagnostic tools, such as serum creatinine (SCr), lack sensitivity and specificity for acute kidney injury (AKI). Circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA), which can be obtained from liquid biopsies, can potentially contribute to the quantification of tissue damage and the prediction of sepsis mortality and sepsis-associated AKI (SA-AKI).

Methods

We investigated the clinical significance of cfDNA levels as a predictor of 28-day mortality, the occurrence of SA-AKI and the initiation of renal replacement therapy (RRT) in patients with sepsis. Furthermore, we investigated the long-term course of cfDNA levels in sepsis survivors at 6 and 12 months after sepsis onset. Specifically, we measured mitochondrial DNA (mitochondrially encoded NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase chain 1, mt-ND1, and mitochondrially encoded cytochrome C oxidase subunit III, mt-CO3) and nuclear DNA (nuclear ribosomal protein S18, n-Rps18) in 81 healthy controls and all available samples of 150 intensive care unit patients with sepsis obtained at 3 ± 1 days, 7 ± 1 days, 6 ± 2 months and 12 ± 2 months after sepsis onset.

Results

Our analysis revealed that, at day 3, patients with sepsis had elevated levels of cfDNA (mt-ND1, and n-Rps18, all p<0.001) which decreased after the acute phase of sepsis. 28-day non-survivors of sepsis (16%) had higher levels of cfDNA (all p<0.05) compared with 28-day survivors (84%). Patients with SA-AKI had higher levels of cfDNA compared to patients without AKI (all p<0.05). Cell-free DNA was also significantly increased in patients requiring RRT (all p<0.05). All parameters improved the AUC for SCr in predicting RRT (AUC=0.88) as well as APACHE II in predicting mortality (AUC=0.86).

Conclusion

In summary, cfDNA could potentially improve risk prediction models for mortality, SA-AKI and RRT in patients with sepsis. The predictive value of cfDNA, even with a single measurement at the onset of sepsis, could offer a significant advantage over conventional diagnostic methods that require repeated measurements or a baseline value for risk assessment. Considering that our data show that cfDNA levels decrease after the first insult, future studies could investigate cfDNA as a "memoryless" marker and thus bring further innovation to the complex field of SA-AKI diagnostics.

The Citrullination-Neutrophil Extracellular Trap Axis in Chronic Diseases

Citrullination of proteins is crucial for the formation of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) − strands of nuclear DNA expulsed in the extracellular environment along with antimicrobial proteins in order to halt the spread of pathogens. Paradoxically, NETs may be immunogenic and contribute to inflammation. It is known that for the externalization of DNA, a group of enzymes called peptidyl arginine deiminases (PADs) is required. Current research often looks at citrullination, NET formation, PAD overexpression, and extracellular DNA (ecDNA) accumulation in chronic diseases as separate events. In contrast, we propose that citrullination can be viewed as the primary mechanism of autoimmunity, for instance by the formation of anti-citrullinated protein antibodies (ACPAs) but also as a process contributing to chronic inflammation. Therefore, citrullination could be at the center, connecting and impacting multiple inflammatory diseases in which ACPAs, NETs, or ecDNA have already been documented. In this review, we aimed to highlight the importance of citrullination in the etiopathogenesis of a number of chronic diseases and to explore the diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic potential of the citrullination-NET axis.

STING1 in sepsis: Mechanisms, functions, and implications

Sepsis is a life-threatening clinical syndrome and one of the most challenging health problems in the world. Pathologically, sepsis and septic shock are caused by a dysregulated host immune response to infection, which can eventually lead to multiple organ failure and even death. As an adaptor transporter between the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi apparatus, stimulator of interferon response cGAMP interactor 1 (STING1, also known as STING or TMEM173) has been found to play a vital role at the intersection of innate immunity, inflammation, autophagy, and cell death in response to invading microbial pathogens or endogenous host damage. There is ample evidence that impaired STING1, through its immune and non-immune functions, is involved in the pathological process of sepsis. In this review, we discuss the regulation and function of the STING1 pathway in sepsis and highlight it as a suitable drug target for the treatment of lethal infection.

Is intensive care unit mortality a valid survival outcome measure related to critical illness?

RATIONALE

Use of death as an outcome of intensive care unit (ICU) admission may be biased by differential discharge decisions.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the validity of ICU survival status as an outcome measure of all cause case-fatality.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort of first admissions among adults to four ICUs in North Brisbane, Australia was assembled. Death in ICU (censored at discharge or 30 days) was compared with 30-day overall case-fatality.

RESULTS

The 30-day overall case-fatality was 8.1% (2436/29,939). One thousand six hundred and thirty-one deaths occurred within the ICU stay and 576 subsequent during hospital post-ICU discharge within 30-days; ICU and hospital case-fatality rates were 5.4% and 7.4%, respectively. An additional 229 patients died after hospital separation within 30 days of ICU admission of which 110 (48.0%) were transferred to another acute care hospital, 80 (34.9%) discharged home, and 39 (17.0%) transferred to an aged care/chronic care/rehabilitation facility. Patients who died after ICU discharge were older, had higher APACHE III scores, were more likely to be elective surgical patients, and were less likely to be out of state residents or managed in a tertiary referral hospital. Limiting determination of case-fatality to ICU information alone would correctly detect 95% (780/821) of all-cause mortality at day 3, 90% (1093/1213) at day 5, 75% (1524/2019) at day 15, 72% (1592/2244) at day 21, and 67% (1631/2436) at day 30 of follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Use of ICU case-fatality significantly underestimates the true burden and biases assessment of determinants of critical illness-related mortality in our region.

Elevated levels of circulating mitochondrial DNA predict early allograft dysfunction in patients following liver transplantation

BACKGROUND AND AIM

The role of circulating mitochondrial DNA (cmtDNA) in transplantation remains to be elucidated. cmtDNA may be released into the circulation as a consequence of liver injury; yet recent work also suggests a causative role for cmtDNA leading to hepatocellular injury. We hypothesized that elevated cmtDNA would be associated with adverse events after liver transplantation (LT) and conducted an observational cohort study.

METHODS

Twenty-one patients were enrolled prospectively prior to LT.

RESULTS

Postoperative complications were observed in 47.6% (n = 10). Seven patients (33.3%) had early allograft dysfunction (EAD), and six patients (28.5%) experienced acute cellular rejection within 6 months of LT. cmtDNA levels were significantly elevated in all recipients after LT compared with healthy controls and preoperative samples (1 361 937 copies/mL [IQR 586 781-3 399 687] after LT; 545 531 copies/mL [IQR 238 562-1 381 015] before LT; and 194 562 copies/mL [IQR 182 359-231 515] in healthy controls) and returned to normal levels by 5 days after transplantation. cmtDNA levels were particularly elevated in those who developed EAD in the early postoperative period (P < 0.001). In all patients, there was initially a strong overall positive correlation between cmtDNA and plasma hepatocellular enzyme levels (P < 0.05). However, the patients with EAD demonstrated a second peak in cmtDNA at postoperative day 7, which did not correlate with liver function tests.

CONCLUSIONS

The early release of plasma cmtDNA is strongly associated with hepatocellular damage; however, the late surge in cmtDNA in patients with EAD appeared to be independent of hepatocellular injury as measured by conventional tests.

Emerging methods for and novel insights gained by absolute quantification of mitochondrial DNA copy number and its clinical applications

The past thirty years have seen a surge in interest in pathophysiological roles of mitochondria, and the accurate quantification of mitochondrial DNA copy number (mCN) in cells and tissue samples is a fundamental aspect of assessing changes in mitochondrial health and biogenesis. Quantification of mCN between studies is surprisingly variable due to a combination of physiological variability and diverse protocols being used to measure this endpoint. The advent of novel methods to quantify nucleic acids like digital polymerase chain reaction (dPCR) and high throughput sequencing offer the ability to measure absolute values of mCN. We conducted an in-depth survey of articles published between 1969 -- 2020 to create an overview of mCN values, to assess consensus values of tissue-specific mCN, and to evaluate consistency between methods of assessing mCN. We identify best practices for methods used to assess mCN, and we address the impact of using specific loci on the mitochondrial genome to determine mCN. Current data suggest that clinical measurement of mCN can provide diagnostic and prognostic value in a range of diseases and health conditions, with emphasis on cancer and cardiovascular disease, and the advent of means to measure absolute mCN should improve future clinical applications of mCN measurements.

Dysregulated Immunity and Immunotherapy after Sepsis

Implementation of protocolized surveillance, diagnosis, and management of septic patients, and of surgical sepsis patients in particular, is shown to result in significantly increased numbers of patients surviving their initial hospitalization. Currently, most surgical sepsis patients will rapidly recover from sepsis; however, many patients will not rapidly recover, but instead will go on to develop chronic critical illness (CCI) and experience dismal long-term outcomes. The elderly and comorbid patient is highly susceptible to death or CCI after sepsis. Here, we review aspects of the Persistent Inflammation, Immunosuppression, and Catabolism Syndrome (PICS) endotype to explain the underlying pathobiology of a dysregulated immune system in sepsis survivors who develop CCI; then, we explore targets for immunomodulatory therapy.

Sirtuin 2 expression levels may predict the progression of sepsis survivors to chronic critical illness

Background

Sirtuin 2 (SIRT2) is a conserved deacetylase that participates in the regulation of inflammation in sepsis. In this observational prospective study, we investigated the predictive value of the SIRT2 expression level in the development of chronic critical illness (CCI) in patients with sepsis.

Methods

A total of 128 critically ill patients with sepsis or septic shock were enrolled and assigned to the CCI group, rapid recovery (RAP) group, or early death group according to their clinical trajectories. Patients’ demographic and clinical information, as well as laboratory data, including C-reactive protein (CRP) level and total lymphocyte counts, were collected. Blood samples were obtained at admission and on days 1, 4, 7, 10, 14, and 21 (days 14 and 21 for the CCI group only). Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated, and SIRT2 expression was measured by real-time polymerase chain reaction. Serum levels of interleukin (IL)-6 and IL-10 were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

Results

Our cohort included 37 CCI and 82 RAP patients, and 9 early death patients, who died within 14 days of intensive care unit (ICU) admission. Compared with the RAP group, CCI patients showed elevated CRP and IL-6 levels throughout the observation period, reflecting a sustained inflammatory response. However, decreases in total lymphocyte count and IL-10 expression in these patients were indicative of immunosuppression. SIRT2 mRNA level was lower in CCI and RAP patients compared with healthy controls at the initial stage of hospitalization, but increased starting on day 4 and continued to increase for the duration of hospitalization. By day 10, SIRT2 expression had almost returned to normal in RAP patients; however, in CCI patients, it continued to increase until the end of the observation period. A receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis showed that the expression level of SIRT2 at 10 days predicts the occurrence of CCI (P<0.05).

Conclusions

SIRT2 expression may be a useful marker for identifying sepsis survivors who are at risk of progressing to CCI.

Abdominal sepsis patients have a high incidence of chronic critical illness with dismal long-term outcomes

BACKGROUND

As hospital sepsis mortality has decreased, more surgical ICU survivors are progressing into chronic critical illness (CCI). This study documents the incidence of CCI and long-term outcomes of patients with abdominal sepsis. We hypothesized that patients developing CCI would have biomarker evidence of immune and metabolic derangement, with a high incidence of poor 1-year outcomes.

METHODS

Review of abdominal sepsis patients entered in a prospective longitudinal study of surgical ICU sepsis.

RESULTS

Of the 144 study patients, only 6% died early, 37% developed CCI (defined as ICU days ≥14 with organ dysfunction) and 57% were classified rapid recovery (RAP). Compared to RAP, CCI patients a) were older (66 vs 58), males who were sicker at baseline (Charlson Comorbidity Index 4 vs 2), b) had persistently elevated biomarkers of dysregulated immunity/metabolism (IL-6, IL-8, sPDL-1, GLP1), c) experienced more secondary infections (4.9 vs 2.3) and organ failure (Denver MOF frequency 40 vs 1%), d) were much more likely to have poor dispositions (85 vs 22%) with severe persistent disabilities by Zubrod Score and e) had a notably higher 1-year mortality of 42% (all p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Over 1/3rd surgical ICU patients treated for abdominal sepsis progress into CCI and experience dismal long-term outcomes.