Preparation of environmental samples for chemical speciation of metal/metalloids: A review of extraction techniques

Multimodal chemical speciation techniques based on simultaneous high resolution molecular/atomic mass spectrometry applied to online target/non-target analysis: A tutorial review

BACKGROUND

If identifying target species is challenging regarding chemical speciation, non-target species present even more significant difficulties. Thus, to improve the performance of the methods, multimodal online coupling involving atomic and molecular mass spectrometry (LC-ICP-MS-ESI-HRMS) is an advance in this direction. Then, this kind of coupling is highlighted in this Tutorial Review, as well as some references emphasizing its potentialities and possible limitations. Some crucial definitions of speciomics, chemical speciation, and others are also included.

RESULTS

The main parameters that influence the coupling of an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer with a high-resolution mass spectrometer through a chromatographic system are critically commented on, and a diversity of results is demonstrated by using a turtle liver (Caretta caretta) as a model sample. The parameters were discussed in detail in a step-by-step manner: ICP-MS/MS acquisition modes and instrumental parameters, HRMS acquisition modes and instrumental parameters, and data processing strategies (Full MS - Top N, All Ion Fragmentation - AIF, Parallel Reaction Monitoring - PRM). Additionally, this Tutorial Review also demonstrates a diversity of results through target and non-target analysis.

SIGNIFICANCE

Constituting a guide for those who are interested in a non-targeted analysis of molecular non-volatile/semi-volatile compounds, this Tutorial Review presents trans and multidisciplinary proposals for those communities involving chemistry, biochemistry, medicine, biology, environmental, pharmaceutical, food safety, and omics, among others, where metal (also metalloids or semi-metals and non-metals or heteroatoms) and molecular species are necessary for a good understanding of the studied system. This kind of coupling also allows the discovery of novel biological active elemental species in diverse matrices.

Speciation Analysis of Metals and Metalloids by Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

The presence of metalloids and heavy metals in the environment is of critical concern due to their toxicological impacts. However, not all metallic species have the same risk level. Specifically, the physical, chemical, and isotopic speciation of the metal(loids) dictate their metabolism, toxicity, and environmental fate. As such, speciation analysis is critical for environmental monitoring and risk assessment. In the past two decades, surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) has seen significant developments regarding trace metal(loid) sensing due to its ultrahigh sensitivity, readiness for in situ real-time applications, and cost-effectiveness. However, the speciation of metal(loid)s has not been accounted for in the design and application of SERS sensors. In this Perspective, we examine the potential of SERS for metal(loid) speciation analysis and highlight the advantages, progress, opportunities, and challenges of this application.

An Update on Current Trend in Sample Preparation Automation in Bioanalysis: strategies, Challenges and Future Direction

Automation in sample preparation improves accuracy, productivity, and precision in bioanalysis. Moreover, it reduces resource consumption for repetitive procedures. Automated sample analysis allows uninterrupted handling of large volumes of biological samples originating from preclinical and clinical studies. Automation significantly helps in management of complex testing methods where generation of large volumes of data is required for process monitoring. Compared to traditional sample preparation processes, automated procedures reduce associated expenses and manual error, facilitate laboratory transfers, enhance data quality, and better protect the health of analysts. Automated sample preparation techniques based on robotics potentially increase the throughput of bioanalytical laboratories. Robotic liquid handler, an automated sample preparation system built on a robotic technique ensures optimal laboratory output while saving expensive solvents, manpower, and time. Nowadays, most of the traditional extraction processes are being automated using several formats of online techniques. This review covered most of the automated sample preparation techniques reported till date, which accelerated and simplified the sample preparation procedure for bioanalytical sample analysis. This article critically analyzed different developmental aspects of automated sample preparation techniques based on robotics as well as conventional sample preparation methods that are accelerated using automated technologies.

Simultaneous preconcentration and quantification of ultra-trace tin and lead species in seawater by online SPE coupled with HPLC-ICP-MS

BACKGROUND

Tin and lead contamination is a global threat to marine ecosystems considering their species-specific toxicity, bioavailability and mobility. Hence simultaneous measurement of multiple tin and lead compounds at μg L-1 to pg L-1 levels in environmental water is always an indispensable but challengeable task. High performance liquid chromatography coupled with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (HPLC-ICP-MS) is one of the most widely used choices for this purpose because of good sensitivity, strong separation power and good compatibility. Previous HPLC-ICP-MS methods based on a single elemental speciation strategy are low-efficiency and sensitivity-insufficient for a large set of unstable samples and interaction of multiple metal(loid)s down to ng L-1 levels.

RESULTS

In this study, we developed a sensitive, efficient and environment-friendly analytical method for accurate quantification of inorganic and organic species of tin and lead simultaneously based on HPLC-ICP-MS with online integration of solid phase extraction (SPE). By using graphene oxide modified silica conditioned with 1 mM benzoic acid to enrich tin and lead species from 10 mL sample, detection limits were improved to 2-8 pg per liter due to satisfactory enrichment factors (522-2848 folds). The SPE-HPLC-ICP-MS method was applicable to quantification of ultra-trace tin and lead species at pg L-1 levels in uncontaminated seawater. Tributyltin was the only tin species detected at subnanograms per liter levels while Pb(II) was the only lead species detected at several nanograms per liter in thirteen coastal seawater samples collected in Hangzhou Bay, indicating light contamination of tin and lead.

SIGNIFICANCE

Overall, the proposed SPE-HPLC-ICP-MS method is highly sensitive, efficient and environment-friendly that are fairly suitable to routine speciation analysis of tin and lead in environmental, food, and biological samples.

Polymeric Materials in Speciation Analysis Based on Solid-Phase Extraction

Speciation analysis is a relevant topic since the (eco)toxicity, bioavailability, bio (geo)chemical cycles, and mobility of a given element depend on its chemical forms (oxidation state, organic ligands, etc.). The reliability of analytical results for chemical species of elements depends mostly on the maintaining of their stability during the sample pretreatment step and on the selectivity of further separation step. Solid-phase extraction (SPE) is a matter of choice as the most suitable and widely used procedure for both enrichment of chemical species of elements and their separation. The features of sorbent material are of great importance to ensure extraction efficiency from one side and selectivity from the other side of the SPE procedure. This review presents an update on the application of polymeric materials in solid-phase extraction used in nonchromatographic methods for speciation analysis.

Bioaccumulation and speciation of arsenic in plankton from tropical soda lakes along a salinity gradient

Uptake and transformation of arsenic (As) by living organisms can alter its distribution and biogeochemical cycles in the environment. Although well known for its toxicity, several aspects of As accumulation and biological transformation by field species are still little explored. In this study, the bioaccumulation and speciation of As in phytoplankton and zooplankton from five soda lakes in the Brazilian Pantanal wetland were studied. Such lakes exhibited contrasting biogeochemical characteristics along an environmental gradient. Additionally, the influence of contrasting climatic events was assessed by collecting samples during an exceptional drought in 2017 and a flood in 2018. Total As (AsTot) content and speciation were determined using spectrometric techniques, while a suspect screening of organoarsenicals in plankton samples was carried out by high-resolution mass spectrometry. Results showed that AsTot content ranged from 16.9 to 62.0 mg kg-1 during the dry period and from 2.4 to 12.3 mg kg-1 during the wet period. The bioconcentration and bioaccumulation factors (BCF and BAF) in phytoplankton and zooplankton were found to be highly dependent on the lake typology, which is influenced by an ongoing evapoconcentration process in the region. Eutrophic and As-enriched lakes exhibited the lowest BCF and BAF values, possibly due to the formation of non-labile As complexes with organic matter or limited uptake of As by plankton caused by high salinity stress. The season played a decisive role in the results, as significantly higher BCF and BAF values were observed during the flooding event when the concentration of dissolved As in water was low. The diversity of As species was found to be dependent on the lake typology and on the resident biological community, cyanobacteria being responsible for a significant portion of As metabolism. Arsenosugars and their degradation products were detected in both phytoplankton and zooplankton, providing evidence for previously reported detoxification pathways. Although no biomagnification pattern was observed, the diet seemed to be an important exposure pathway for zooplankton.

A novel bio-washing eluent obtained from fermentation of fruit wastes for removal of soil Pb: efficiency, mechanism, and risk assessment

Agricultural wastes are inexpensive materials for soil remediation. However, the direct water extracts from these wastes showed low efficiency for Pb removal, thus limiting their application. In this study, citrus pericarp (CP) and pineapple peel (PP), as the common agricultural wastes, were inoculated with lactic acid bacteria to produce fermentation liquors (FCP and FPP) for improving Pb removal efficiency. Results showed that the Pb removal rates by FCP and FPP reached 37.3 and 43.6%, and increased by almost 50.0% than those by CP and PP. The ecological risk of Pb reduced by 83.0-88.2% after five times continuous washing with FCP and FPP, and the Pb concentrations conformed to soil remediation standard of China. Moreover, soil organic carbon 1.5 times increased in the washed soils, while total potassium improved by 40.7-68.0%. The mechanisms of Pb removal by these wastes involved in adsorption-desorption of Pb²⁺, complexation with organic ligands, and co-precipitation of Pb complexes. The increase of low molecular organic acids during the fermentation promoted dissolution of Pb and provided more hydroxyl, carboxyl, and amine groups to interact with Pb²⁺, thus improving its removal rate. Therefore, fermentation liquid from fruit wastes is a novel, effective, and ecofriendly bio-washing eluent for Pb removal from contaminated soils.

[Magnetic ion imprinting techniques for the separation and analysis of elemental speciation]

Metal and metalloid elements have various possible isotopic compositions and oxidation states and often form coordination or covalent compounds with inorganic and organic small molecules or biological macromolecules, resulting in complex elemental speciation. Different species of the same element often have different properties, which dictate their behavior. Thus, elemental speciation analysis is vital for comprehensively and accurately assessing an element's environmental and biological effects and the corresponding risks. Because elemental speciation determines the behavior of an element in different environmental and biological processes, the analysis of elemental species has, in recent years, been important in various subjects, including analytical chemistry, environmental chemistry, geochemistry, ecology, agronomy, and biomedicine. The complexity of environmental and biological sample matrices, as well as the multiformity, low levels, and lability of chemical forms pose severe challenges in elemental speciation analysis. Therefore, the highly selective identification and efficient separation of native species is necessary for conducting the identification, quantification, ecotoxicity evaluation, and physiological function study of elemental speciation. Sample pretreatment by solid-phase extraction is an effective solution to the aforementioned problems, but the existing methods do not meet the requirements of current research. The transition of the target species from pre-processing to the detection device includes both on- and off-line arrangements. Compared with the on-line approach, the off-line approach requires more manual participation, increasing the analysis workload. However, the off-line approach can improve the analysis efficiency through high-throughput pretreatment when large batches of samples are encountered, meaning the off-line approach is still an effective model. Ion imprinting technology has been developed based on existing molecular imprinting technology, with four main steps present in the synthesis of ion imprinted polymers. First, ion imprinting technology uses metal ions as templates. Then, these templates are combined with the functional monomers through coordination, electrostatic or hydrogen bonding. The functional monomers simultaneously surround and fix the templates, after which the cross-linkers and functional monomers polymerize to prepare ion-imprinted polymers with a specific structure and composition. Finally, the imprinted holes are created in the polymers by eluting the template ions. Therefore, the template molecules, functional monomers, and cross-linkers are three precursors necessary for synthesizing ion-imprinted polymers. These polymers can specifically bind to the imprinted metal ions with accuracy, sensitivity, and reliability. In recent years, they have been widely used in separating, enriching, analyzing, and detecting elemental species. During solid-phase extraction, the non-magnetic adsorbent materials dispersed in the sample solution need to be separated by centrifugation or filtration, which is time-consuming and laborious. Because an external magnetic field can be used for rapid magnetic solid-phase extraction, it has become a potential method for separating and enriching elemental species. This review systematically summarizes the latest progress in ion-imprinting technology, including its principle and the preparation methods of ion-imprinted polymers. The challenges faced by ion imprinting technology are analyzed in the context of the development of ion-imprinting magnetic solid-phase extraction in elemental speciation analysis. Finally, the direction of future development and the strategies of ion imprinting technology in elemental speciation analysis are proposed. It is important to exploit novel organic-inorganic hybrid polymerization-based multifunctional ion-imprinted magnetic nanocomposites for the magnetic solid-phase extraction and separation of elemental species. By establishing the pretreatment protocols with high recognition selectivity, strong separation ability, large adsorption capacity, and good speciation stability, we expect to achieve the research objectives of simultaneously separating and enriching the multiple-species of typical metal/metalloid elements in environmental and biological samples.

Reliable Quantification of Ultratrace Selenium in Food, Beverages, and Water Samples by Cloud Point Extraction and Spectrometric Analysis

Selenium is a trace element essential for the proper functioning of human body. Since it can only be obtained through our diet, knowing its concentrations in different food products is of particular importance. The measurement of selenium content in complex food matrices has traditionally been a challenge due to the very low concentrations involved. Some of the difficulties may arise from the abundance of various compounds, which are additionally present in examined material at different concentration levels. The solution to this problem is the efficient separation/preconcentration of selenium from the analyzed matrix, followed by its reliable quantification. This review offers an insight into cloud point extraction, a separation technique that is often used in conjunction with spectrometric analysis. The method allows for collecting information on selenium levels in waters of different complexity (drinking water, river and lake waters), beverages (wine, juices), and a broad range of food (cereals, legumes, fresh fruits and vegetables, tea, mushrooms, nuts, etc.).

Selective separation of uranyl ions from some lanthanide elements using a promising β-enaminoester ligand by cloud point extraction

For uranyl extraction, a distinctive chelating ligand, namely ethyl 2-amino-6-hydroxy-5-(4-methoxyphenyldiazenyl)-4-phenyl-4H-benzo[f]chromene-3-carboxylate, has been synthesized and characterized using FT-IR, NMR, and ESI-MS. Subsequently, a cloud point extraction (CPE) protocol has been developed for the selective separation of the trace amounts of uranyl ions from some lanthanide ions after being captured by the ligand in the presence of non-ionic surfactant (Triton X-114). The extraction procedure has been optimized based on the concentration of the complexing agent and the non-ionic surfactant, phase separation temperatures, pH, and ionic strength. The developed CPE procedure exhibited a relatively low detection limit of 0.5 ng mL-1 in the linear range from 3 ng mL-1 to 250 ng mL-1. Furthermore, interference studies have been carried out to study the selectivity of our protocol. These studies revealed that the recoveries of uranyl ions were in the range from 96.1% to 99.9% in the presence of some lanthanide ions such as Th4+, Gd3+, and Sm3+. It is worth mentioning that the geometry optimization, reactivity, and molecular electrostatic potential maps of the ligand and the proposed UO2 2+ complex were acquired via DFT calculations to study their stabilities based on the geometry and binding affinity. The theoretical data confirmed the octahedral geometry of the UO2 2+ complex with the lowest energy and excellent stability. The robustness of the proposed methodology was evaluated by the detection of uranyl ions in different environmental samples and synthetic mixtures.

In situ fractionation and redox speciation of arsenic in soda lakes of Nhecolândia (Pantanal, Brazil) using the diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique

In situ fractionation and redox speciation of As in three different saline-alkaline lakes (green, black and crystalline lakes) in the Pantanal of Nhecolândia (Brazil) were performed by using Diffusive Gradients in Thin films (DGT). The results indicated that As is present mainly in dissolved form. Total As concentration was similar when using different filter membranes, demonstrating that the species adsorbed by DGT devices were <10 kDa. Higher concentrations of labile total As were observed in the center of the lakes, indicating that the nature of the organic matter influences the formation of As complexes. Total As concentrations determined by using ZrO₂ DGT were consistent with As concentration in ultrafiltered water samples collected in the black lake. However, part of the data about As(III) obtained in grab samples contrasted with DGT results. The differences observed may indicate that alterations in the species occur during the storage period before analysis by ultrafiltration. As(III) concentrations measured by DGT in the black and crystalline lakes were 1-3 μg L^-1 and 4-7 μg L^-1, respectively, accounting for only 4%-8% of the total DGT inorganic As. In the green lake, As(III) concentrations were significantly higher at the center (217 μg L^-1). Both the phytoplankton community and the dissolved organic carbon influence the As speciation and bioavailability in the lakes of Nhecolândia. The DGT approach used in the present work was able to perform As speciation and demonstrates that in situ sampling analytical techniques are essential in understanding As speciation and its behavior in complex natural aquatic systems.

In situ arsenic speciation at the soil/water interface of saline-alkaline lakes of the Pantanal, Brazil: A DGT-based approach

Arsenic (As) is a naturally occurring element in the Earth's crust, exhibiting toxicity towards a wide range of living organisms. Its properties and environmental dynamics are strongly regulated by its speciation, and the species As(III) and As(V) are the most commonly found in environmental systems. Recently, high concentrations of As were found in saline-alkaline lakes of the Pantanal (Brazil), which is the largest wetland area in the world. Therefore, we evaluated As contamination and its redox speciation (As(III) and As(V)) at the soil/water interface of biogeochemically distinct saline-alkaline lakes of Pantanal wetlands (Brazil). Both conventional sampling and in situ diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique were employed. Zirconium oxide and 3-mercaptopropyl were used as ligand phases in DGT to selectively bind As species. High concentrations of total dissolved As in a shallow water table were found (<2337.5 μg L^-1), whereas levels in soils were up to 2.4 μg g^-1. Distinct scenarios were observed when comparing speciation analysis through spot sampling and DGT. Considering spot sampling, As(V) was the main species detected, whereas As(III) was only detected in only a few samples (<4.2 μg L^-1). Conversely, results obtained by DGT showed that labile As(III) dominated arsenic speciation at the soil/water interface with levels up to 203.0 μg L^-1. Coupling DGT data and DGT induced fluxes in sediments and soils model allowed obtaining kinetic data, showing that the soil barely participated in the arsenic dynamics on the shore of the lakes, and that this participation depends on the evapoconcentration process occurring in the region. Therefore, soil acts like a nonreactive matrix depending on the natural concentration process. In addition, our results reinforced the different geochemical characteristics of the studied saline-alkaline lakes and highlights the importance of robust passive sampling techniques in the context of metal/metalloid speciation in environmental analysis.

Extraction Induced by Emulsion and Microemulsion Breaking for Metal Determination by Spectrometric Methods - A Review

This review focuses on extraction induced by the destabilization of emulsified systems combined with spectrometric techniques for metal analysis in oily samples. This approach is based on the formation and breaking of an emulsion (extraction induced by emulsion breaking - EIEB) or microemulsion (extraction induced by microemulsion breaking - EIMB) to transfer the analytes from the oil sample to the aqueous phase, which is separated in the process. Its simplicity, speed, and low cost have contributed to its growing popularity among researchers. However, the potential of EIEB and EIMB is far from being fully exploited. Therefore, this paper aims to provide relevant information to expand the applicability of these methods. The principle of the methods is discussed, and a brief description of emulsified systems is presented. The parameters affecting the extraction efficiency and calibration strategy are also critically discussed. Furthermore, the analytical applications of the methods are reviewed. Trends and opportunities in this field are also considered.

Preconcentration and determination of trace Hg(ii) using ultrasound-assisted dispersive solid phase microextraction

Defect rich molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂) nanosheets were hydrothermally synthesized and their potential for ultrasound assisted dispersive solid phase microextraction of trace Hg(ii) ions was assessed. Ultrasonic dispersion allows the MoS₂ nanosheets to chelate rapidly and evenly with Hg(ii) ions and results in improving the precision and minimizing the extraction time. The multiple defect rich surface was characterized by X-ray diffraction and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy. The surface charge of intrinsically sulfur rich MoS₂ nanosheets and their elemental composition was characterized by zeta potential measurements, energy dispersive spectroscopy, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The cracks and holes on the basal planes of MoS₂ led to diffusion of the Hg(ii) ions into the interior channels. Inner-sphere chelation along with outer-sphere electrostatic interaction were the proposed mechanism for the Hg(ii) adsorption onto the MoS₂ surface. The experimental data showed good selectivity of MoS₂ nanosheets towards Hg(ii) adsorption. The systematic and constant errors of the proposed method were ruled out by the analysis of the Standard Reference Material (>95% recovery with <5% RSD). The Student's t-test values for the analyzed Standard Reference Material were found to be less than the critical Student's t value at 95% confidence level. The limit of detection (3S) was found to be 0.01 ng mL⁻¹. The MoS₂ nanosheets were successfully employed for the analysis of Hg(ii) in environmental water samples.

Hg(ii) ion adsorption onto an MoS₂ surface.

Elemental Speciation Analysis in Environmental Studies: Latest Trends and Ecological Impact

Speciation analysis is a key aspect of modern analytical chemistry, as the toxicity, environmental mobility, and bioavailability of elemental analytes are known to depend strongly on an element’s chemical species. Henceforth, great efforts have been made in recent years to develop methods that allow not only the determination of elements as a whole, but also each of its separate species. Environmental analytical chemistry has not ignored this trend, and this review aims to summarize the latest methods and techniques developed with this purpose. From the perspective of each relevant element and highlighting the importance of their speciation analysis, different sample treatment methods are introduced and described, with the spotlight on the use of modern nanomaterials and novel solvents in solid phase and liquid-liquid microextractions. In addition, an in-depth discussion of instrumental techniques aimed both at the separation and quantification of metal and metalloid species is presented, ranging from chromatographic separations to electro-chemical speciation analysis. Special emphasis is made throughout this work on the greenness of these developments, considering their alignment with the precepts of the Green Chemistry concept and critically reviewing their environmental impact.

Trace Metal Contamination of Bottom Sediments: A Review of Assessment Measures and Geochemical Background Determination Methods

This paper provides an overview of different methods of assessing the trace metal (TM) contamination status of sediments affected by anthropogenic interference. The geochemical background determination methods are also described. A total of 25 papers covering rivers, lakes, and retention tanks sediments in areas subjected to anthropogenic pressure from the last three years (2019, 2020, and 2021) were analysed to support our examination of the assessment measures. Geochemical and ecotoxicological classifications are presented that may prove useful for sediment evaluation. Among the geochemical indices, several individual pollution indices (CF, Igeo, EF, Pi (SPI), PTT), complex pollution indices (PLI, Cdeg, mCdeg, Pisum, PIAvg, PIaAvg, PIN, PIProd, PIapProd, PIvectorM, PINemerow, IntPI, MPI), and geochemical classifications are compared. The ecotoxicological assessment includes an overview of Sediment Quality Guidelines (SQG) and classifications introduced nationally (as LAWA or modified LAWA). The ecotoxicological indices presented in this review cover individual (ERi) and complex indices (CSI, SPI, RAC, PERI, MERMQ). Biomonitoring of contaminated sites based on plant bioindicators is extensively explored as an indirect method for evaluating pollution sites. The most commonly used indices in the reviewed papers were Igeo, EF, and CF. Many authors referred to ecotoxicological assessment via SQG. Moreover, PERI, which includes the toxic response index, was just as popular. The most recognised bioindicators include the Phragmites and Salix species. Phragmites can be considered for Fe, Cu, Cd, and Ni bioindication in sites, while Salix hybrid cultivars such as Klara may be considered for phytostabilisation and rhizofiltration due to higher Cu, Zn, and Ni accumulation in roots. Vetiveria zizanoides demonstrated resistance to As stress and feasibility for the remediation of As. Moreover, bioindicators offer a feasible tool for recovering valuable elements for the development of a circular economy (e.g., rare earth elements).