Enzyme-based biosensors for choline analysis: A review

Nanowire-like phosphorus modulated carbon-based iron nanozyme with oxidase-like activity for sensitive detection of choline and dye degradation

Choline is mainly supplemented through food intake, lack of choline would result in diseases like liver cirrhosis, hardening of the arteries, or neurodegenerative disorders. The accurate detection of choline is important for human health. Herein, a novel nanowire-like phosphorus/nitrogen co-doped carbon-based iron nanozyme (Fe-NPC) with outstanding oxidase-like activity was synthesized, and the influence of phosphorus doping on oxidase-like activity was explored. Proper phosphorus doping was found to enhance the oxidase-like activity of Fe-NPC by increasing surface defects, promoting iron loading, and modulating chemical environment of central site. The oxidase-like activity of Fe-NPC was successfully applied to colorimetric-fluorescent dual mode detection of choline, and good linear relationship in the ranges of 3-200 μM were achieved with LODs of 1.95 and 1.50 μM, respectively. The fluorescent detection was constructed based on the fluorescence quenching of silicon quantum dots (Si QDs) by quinone-imine. The quenching mechanism was attributed to FRET due to the large spectra overlap, reduced fluorescence lifetime and proper donor-acceptor distance. The successful application to the detection of choline in milk proved the practicability of the proposed sensing method. The oxidase-like properties of Fe-NPC was further used in the degradation of cationic dye methyl blue, high degradation efficiency of 74 % was achieved within 5 min under optimal conditions, proving the enormous potential of Fe-NPC for application in environment protection.

Stable detection of diazinon residues in vegetables by an electrochemiluminescent aptasensor based on the in-situ production of H2O2 from dual-catalytic glucose

Stable detection of diazinon (DZN) residues in vegetables is important for food safety. In this work, an electrochemiluminescence (ECL) aptasensor with dual-catalytic glucose in-situ production of H2O2 was constructed for the stable detection of DZN in vegetables. Firstly, MWCNTs@MB was prepared using π-π stacking interactions between methylene blue (MB) and multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) to enhance the loading of MB on an electrode and thus catalyze the generation of H2O2 from glucose. Secondly, Cu2O@AuNPs was formed by loading AuNPs on the surface of Cu2O through spontaneous reduction reaction, which improved the interfacial charge transfer, Cu2O nano-enzyme had glucose oxidase mimicking activity and could further catalyze the production of more H2O2 from glucose. MWCNTs@MB and Cu2O@AuNPs played a key role in the in-situ generation of co-reacting reagent H2O2, which solved the problem of unstable detection caused by the easy decomposition of the H2O2 solution added to the luminescence system. In addition, the aptamer was immobilized on the electrode surface by forming Au-S bonds with Cu2O@AuNPs. As a result, the ECL aptasensor performed good linearity in 1.00 pg mL-1-1.00 μg mL-1 and a low limit of detection (LOD) to 0.39 pg mL-1 (S/N = 3). This work provided an effective method for the accurate and stable detection of DZN residues in vegetables, which was of great significance in ensuring food safety and assessing the environmental risk of DZN.

Bifunctional enzyme-mimicking metal-organic frameworks for sensitive acetylcholine analysis

The development of nanomaterials with multi-enzyme-like activity is crucial for addressing challenges in multi-enzyme-based biosensing systems, including cross-talk between different enzymes and the complexities and costs associated with detection. In this study, Pt nanoparticles (Pt NPs) were successfully supported on a Zr-based metal-organic framework (MOF-808) to create a composite catalyst named MOF-808/Pt NPs. This composite catalyst effectively mimics the functions of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and peroxidase (POD). Leveraging this capability, we replaced AChE and POD with MOF-808/Pt NPs and constructed a biosensor for sensitive detection of acetylcholine (ACh). The MOF-808/Pt NPs catalyze the hydrolysis of ACh, resulting in the production of acetic acid. The subsequent reduction in pH value further enhances the POD-like activity of the MOFs, enabling signal amplification through the oxidation of a colorimetric substrate. This biosensor capitalizes on pH variations during the reaction to modulate the different enzyme-like activities of the MOFs, simplifying the detection process and eliminating cross-talk between different enzymes. The developed biosensor holds great promise for clinical diagnostic analysis and offers significant application value in the field.

State-of-the-art in engineering small molecule biosensors and their applications in metabolic engineering

Genetically encoded biosensors are crucial for enhancing our understanding of how molecules regulate biological systems. Small molecule biosensors, in particular, help us understand the interaction between chemicals and biological processes. They also accelerate metabolic engineering by increasing screening throughput and eliminating the need for sample preparation through traditional chemical analysis. Additionally, they offer significantly higher spatial and temporal resolution in cellular analyte measurements. In this review, we discuss recent progress in in vivo biosensors and control systems-biosensor-based controllers-for metabolic engineering. We also specifically explore protein-based biosensors that utilize less commonly exploited signaling mechanisms, such as protein stability and induced degradation, compared to more prevalent transcription factor and allosteric regulation mechanism. We propose that these lesser-used mechanisms will be significant for engineering eukaryotic systems and slower-growing prokaryotic systems where protein turnover may facilitate more rapid and reliable measurement and regulation of the current cellular state. Lastly, we emphasize the utilization of cutting-edge and state-of-the-art techniques in the development of protein-based biosensors, achieved through rational design, directed evolution, and collaborative approaches.

Enzyme engineering of choline oxidase for improving stability

Functioning as a flavoprotein, choline oxidase facilitates the transformation of choline into glycine betaine. Notably, choline oxidase and its resultant product, glycine betaine, find extensive applications across various industries and fields of study. However, its high sensitivity and tendency to lose functional activity at high temperatures reduces its industrial usage. MD simulation and mutation studies have revealed the role of certain residues responsible for the enzyme's thermal instability. This study focuses on inducing thermal stability to choline oxidase of A. globiformis through computational approaches at a maximum temperature of 60 °C. MD simulation analysis showed that Trp 331, Val 464 and Ser 101 contribute to structural instability, leading to the instability at 60 °C. Mutation of these residues with phenylalanine residues and simulation of the mutated enzyme at 60 °C exhibited thermostability and insignificant residual fluctuation. The re-docking and MM/GBSA analyses further validated the mutated enzyme's binding affinity and catalytic activity.

Molecularly imprinted polymers: A closer look at the template removal and analyte binding

Molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs), which first appeared over half a century ago, are now attracting considerable attention as artificial receptors, particularly for sensing. MIPs, especially applied to biomedical analysis in biofluids, contribute significantly to patient diagnosis at the point of care, thereby allowing health monitoring. Despite the importance given to MIPs, removal of templates and binding of analytes have received little attention and are currently the least focused steps in MIP development. This critical review is dedicated to a comprehensive analysis and discussion of cutting-edge concepts and methodologies in the removal and binding steps pertaining to various types of analytes, including ions, molecules, epitopes, proteins, viruses, and bacteria. The central objective of this review is to comprehensively examine and discuss a range of removal methods, including soxhlet extraction, immersion, microwave-assisted technique, ultrasonication, electrochemical approach, and proteolytic digestion, among others. Additionally, we will explore various binding methods, such as soaking, drop-casting, and batch sorption, to provide a comprehensive overview of the subject. Furthermore, the current challenges and perspectives in removal and binding are highlighted. Our review, at the interface of chemistry and sensors, will offer a wide range of opportunities for researchers whose interests include MIPs, (bio)sensors, analytical chemistry, and diagnostics.

Mo Single-Atom Nanozyme Anchored to the 2D N-Doped Carbon Film: Catalytic Mechanism, Visual Monitoring of Choline, and Evaluation of Intracellular ROS Generation

Single-atom nanozymes (SANs) have attracted great attention in constructing devices for instant biosensing due to their excellent stability and atom utilization. Here, Mo atoms were immobilized in 2D nitrogen-doped carbon films by cascade-anchored one-pot pyrolysis to obtain Mo single-atom nanozyme (Mo-SAN) with high atomic loading (4.79 wt %) and peroxidase-like activity. The coordination environment and enzyme-like activity mechanism of Mo-SAN were studied by combining synchrotron radiation and density functional theory. The strong oxophilicity of single-atom Mo makes the catalytic center more capable of transferring electrons to free radicals to selectively generate ^•OH in the presence of H₂O₂. Choline oxidase and Mo-SAN were used as signal opening unit and signal amplification unit, respectively. Combining the portability and visualization functions of smartphone and test strips, a paper-based visual sensing platform was constructed, which can accurately identify choline at a concentration of 0.5-35 μM with a limit of detection as low as 0.12 μM. The recovery of human serum samples was 96.4-102.2%, with an error of less than 5%. Furthermore, the potential of Mo-SAN to efficiently generate toxic ^•OH in tumor cells was intuitively confirmed. This work provides a technical and theoretical basis for designing highly active SANs and detecting neurological markers.

Balancing "on" and "off" response of hydroxyl groups to a nanozyme-catalyzing system for the construction of an ultra-sensitive and selective "signal-on" detection platform for dopamine

Targeting the functional groups present in analytes by nanozyme-catalyzed systems is a promising strategy to construct sensitive and selective platforms for the sensing of specific analytes. Herein, various groups (-COOH, -CHO, -OH, and -NH₂) on benzene were introduced in an Fe-based nanozyme system with MoS₂-MIL-101(Fe) as the model peroxidase nanozyme, H₂O₂ as the oxidizing agent, and TMB as the chromogenic substrate, and the effects of these groups at both a low concentration and high concentration were further investigated. It was found that the hydroxyl group-based substance catechol showed an "on" effect at a low concentration to increase the catalytic rate and enhance the absorbance signal, whereas an "off" effect at a high concentration with a decreased absorbance signal. Based on these results, the "on" mode and "off" mode for the biological molecule dopamine, a type of catechol derivative, were proposed. In the control system, MoS₂-MIL-101(Fe) catalyzed the decomposition of H₂O₂ to produce ROS, which further oxidized TMB. In the "on" mode, the hydroxyl groups of dopamine could combine with the Fe(iii) site of the nanozyme to lower its oxidation state, resulting in higher catalytic activity. In the "off" mode, the excess dopamine could consume ROS, which inhibited the catalytic process. Under the optimal conditions, by balancing the "on" and "off" modes, the "on" mode for the detection of dopamine was found to have better sensitivity and selectivity. The LOD was as low as 0.5 nM. This detection platform was successfully applied for the detection of dopamine in human serum with satisfactory recovery. Our results can pave the way for the design of nanozyme sensing systems with sensitivity and selectivity.

Bioactive Ion-Based Switchable Supercapacitors

Switchable supercapacitors (SCs) enable a reversible electrically-driven uptake/release of bioactive ions by polarizing porous carbon electrodes. Herein we demonstrate the first example of a bioactive ion-based switchable supercapacitor. Based on choline chloride and porous carbons we unravel the mechanism of physisorption vs. electrosorption by nuclear magnetic resonance, Raman, and impedance spectroscopy. Weak physisorption facilitates electrically-driven electrolyte depletion enabling the controllable uptake/release of electrolyte ions. A new 4-terminal device is proposed, with a main capacitor and a detective capacitor for monitoring bioactive ion adsorption in situ. Ion-concentration control in printed choline-based switchable SCs realizes switching down to 8.3 % residual capacitance. The exploration of adsorption mechanisms in printable microdevices will open an avenue of manipulating bioactive ions for the application of drug delivery, neuromodulation, or neuromorphic devices.

Colorimetric Nanobiosensor Design for Determining Oxidase Enzyme Substrates in Food and Biological Samples

Biological enzymes have high catalytic activity and unique substrate selectivity; their immobilization may provide cost reduction and reusability. Using magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) as support materials for enzymes ensures easy separation from reaction media by an external magnetic field. Thus, MNPs were prepared by the coprecipitation method, coated with silanol groups, then -NH₂-functionalized, and finally activated with glutaraldehyde. Finally, three different oxidase enzymes, i.e., uricase, glucose oxidase, and choline oxidase, were separately immobilized on their surfaces by covalent attachment. Hence, colorimetric nanobiosensors for the determination of three biologically important substrates, i.e., uric acid (UA), glucose (Glu), and choline (Ch), were developed. Hydrogen peroxide liberated from enzyme-substrate reactions was determined by the cupric ion reducing antioxidant capacity (CUPRAC) reagent, bis-neocuproine copper(II) chelate. In addition, UA-free total antioxidant capacity could also be measured via the developed system. Kinetic investigations were carried out for these nanobiosensors to enable the calculation of their Michaelis constants (K _m), revealing no affinity loss for the substrate as a result of immobilization. Enzyme-immobilized MNPs could be reused at least five times. The linear concentration ranges were 5.43-65.22 μM for UA, 11.1-111.1 μM for Glu, and 2.78-44.4 μM for Ch, and the limit of detection (LOD) values with the same order were 0.34, 0.59, and 0.20 μM, respectively. Besides phenolic and thiol-type antioxidants, UA could be determined with an error range of 0.18-4.87%. The method is based on a clear redox reaction with a definite stoichiometry for the enzymatically generated H₂O₂ (which minimizes chemical deviations from Beer's law of optical absorbances), and it was successfully applied to the determination of Glu and UA in fetal bovine serum and Ch in infant formula as real samples.

Integrating Microfluidics and Electronics in Point-of-Care Diagnostics: Current and Future Challenges

Point-of-Care (POC) diagnostics have gained increasing attention in recent years due to its numerous advantages over conventional diagnostic approaches. As proven during the recent COVID-19 pandemic, the rapidity and portability of POC testing improves the efficiency of healthcare services and reduces the burden on healthcare providers. There are hundreds of thousands of different applications for POC diagnostics, however, the ultimate requirement for the test is the same: sample-in and result-out. Many technologies have been implemented, such as microfluidics, semiconductors, and nanostructure, to achieve this end. The development of even more powerful POC systems was also enabled by merging multiple technologies into the same system. One successful example is the integration of microfluidics and electronics in POC diagnostics, which has simplified the sample handling process, reduced sample usage, and reduced the cost of the test. This review will analyze the current development of the POC diagnostic systems with the integration of microfluidics and electronics and discuss the future challenges and perspectives that researchers might have.

Recent Trends in Biosensors for Environmental Quality Monitoring

The monitoring of environmental pollution requires fast, reliable, cost-effective and small devices. This need explains the recent trends in the development of biosensing devices for pollutant detection. The present review aims to summarize the newest trends regarding the use of biosensors to detect environmental contaminants. Enzyme, whole cell, antibody, aptamer, and DNA-based biosensors and biomimetic sensors are discussed. We summarize their applicability to the detection of various pollutants and mention their constructive characteristics. Several detection principles are used in biosensor design: amperometry, conductometry, luminescence, etc. They differ in terms of rapidity, sensitivity, profitability, and design. Each one is characterized by specific selectivity and detection limits depending on the sensitive element. Mimetic biosensors are slowly gaining attention from researchers and users due to their advantages compared with classical ones. Further studies are necessary for the development of robust biosensing devices that can successfully be used for the detection of pollutants from complex matrices without prior sample preparation.

Micromolar Metabolite Measurement in an Electronically Multiplexed Format

The detection of metabolites such as choline in blood are important in clinical care for patients with cancer and cardiovascular disease. Choline is only present in human blood at low concentrations hence accurate measurement in an affordable point-of-care format is extremely challenging. Integration of microfluidics on to complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) technology has the potential to enable advanced sensing technologies with extremely low limit of detection that are well suited to multiple clinical metabolite measurements. Although CMOS and microfluidics are individually mature technologies, their integration has presented challenges that we overcome in a novel, cost-effective, single-step process. To demonstrate the process, we present the microfluidic integration of a metabolomics-on-CMOS point-of-care platform with four capillary microfluidic channels on top of a CMOS optical sensor array. The fabricated device was characterised to verify the required structural profile, mechanical strength, optical spectra, and fluid flow. As a proof of concept, we used the device for the in-vitro quantification of choline in human blood plasma with a limit of detection of 3.2 M and a resolution of 1.6 M.

Detection of Acetylcholine at Nanoscale NPOE/Water Liquid/Liquid Interface Electrodes

The interface between two immiscible electrolyte solutions (ITIES) has become a very powerful analytical platform for sensing a diverse range of chemicals (e.g., metal ions and neurotransmitters) with the advantage of being able to detect non-redox electroactive species. The ITIES is formed between organic and aqueous phases. Organic solvent identity is crucial to the detection characteristics of the ITIES [half-wave transfer potential (E_1/2), potential window range, limit of detection, transfer coefficient (α), standard heterogeneous ion-transfer rate constant (k⁰), etc.]. Here, we demonstrated, for the first time at the nanoscale, the detection characteristics of the NPOE/water ITIES. Linear detection of the diffusion-limited current at different concentrations of acetylcholine (ACh) was demonstrated with cyclic voltammetry (CV) and i-t amperometry. The E_1/2 of ACh transfer at the NPOE/water nanoITIES was -0.342 ± 0.009 V versus the E_1/2 of tetrabutylammonium (TBA⁺). The limit of detection of ACh at the NPOE/water nanoITIES was 37.1 ± 1.5 μM for an electrode with a radius of ∼127 nm. We also determined the ion-transfer kinetics parameters, α and k⁰, of TBA⁺ at the NPOE/water nanoITIES by fitting theoretical cyclic voltammograms to experimental voltammograms. This work lays the basis for future cellular studies using ACh detection at the nanoscale and for studies to detect other analytes. The NPOE/water ITIES offers a potential window distinct from that of the 1,2-dichloroethane (DCE)/water ITIES. This unique potential window would offer the ability to detect analytes that are not easily detected at the DCE/water ITIES.

Enhanced Electrocatalytic Detection of Choline Based on CNTs and Metal Oxide Nanomaterials

Choline is an officially established essential nutrient and precursor of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. It is employed as a cholinergic activity marker in the early diagnosis of brain disorders such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease. Low levels of choline in diets and biological fluids, such as blood plasma, urine, cerebrospinal and amniotic fluid, could be an indication of neurological disorder, fatty liver disease, neural tube defects and hemorrhagic kidney necrosis. Meanwhile, it is known that choline metabolism involves oxidation, which frees its methyl groups for entrance into single-C metabolism occurring in three phases: choline oxidase, betaine synthesis and transfer of methyl groups to homocysteine. Electrocatalytic detection of choline is of physiological and pathological significance because choline is involved in the physiological processes in the mammalian central and peripheral nervous systems and thus requires a more reliable assay for its determination in biological, food and pharmaceutical samples. Despite the use of several methods for choline determination, the superior sensitivity, high selectivity and fast analysis response time of bioanalytical-based sensors invariably have a comparative advantage over conventional analytical techniques. This review focuses on the electrocatalytic activity of nanomaterials, specifically carbon nanotubes (CNTs), CNT nanocomposites and metal/metal oxide-modified electrodes, towards choline detection using electrochemical sensors (enzyme and non-enzyme based), and various electrochemical techniques. From the survey, the electrochemical performance of the choline sensors investigated, in terms of sensitivity, selectivity and stability, is ascribed to the presence of these nanomaterials.

Copper and Nickel Microsensors Produced by Selective Laser Reductive Sintering for Non-Enzymatic Glucose Detection

In this work, the method of selective laser reductive sintering was used to fabricate the sensor-active copper and nickel microstructures on the surface of glass-ceramics suitable for non-enzymatic detection of glucose. The calculated sensitivities for these microsensors are 1110 and 2080 μA mM⁻¹·cm⁻² for copper and nickel, respectively. Linear regime of enzymeless glucose sensing is provided between 0.003 and 3 mM for copper and between 0.01 and 3 mM for nickel. Limits of glucose detection for these manufactured micropatterns are equal to 0.91 and 2.1 µM for copper and nickel, respectively. In addition, the fabricated materials demonstrate rather good selectivity, long-term stability and reproducibility.

Efficient Portable Urea Biosensor Based on Urease Immobilized Membrane for Monitoring of Physiological Fluids

Numerous studies have addressed the utilization of glutaraldehyde (GA) as a homobifunctional cross-linker. However, its applicability has been impeded due to several issues, including the tendency of GA molecules to undergo polymerization. Herein, a portable urea biosensor was developed for the real-time monitoring of the flow of physiological fluids; this was achieved by using disuccinimidyl cross-linker-based urease immobilization. Urease was immobilized on a porous polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) solid support using different disuccinimidyl cross-linkers, namely disuccinimidyl glutarate (DSG), disuccinimidyl suberate (DSS) and bis-N-succinimidyl-(pentaethylene glycol) ester (BS(PEG)₅). A urease activity test revealed that DSS exhibited the highest urease immobilizing efficiency, whereas FT-IR analysis confirmed that urease was immobilized on the PTFE membrane via DSS cross-linking. The membrane was inserted in a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) fluidic chamber that generated an electrochemical signal in the presence of a flowing fluid containing urea. Urea samples were allowed to flow into the urea biosensor (1.0 mL/min) and the signal was measured using chronoamperometry. The sensitivity of the DSS urea biosensor was the highest of all the trialed biosensors and was found to be superior to the more commonly used GA cross-linker. To simulate real-time monitoring in a human patient, flowing urea-spiked human serum was measured and the effective urease immobilization of the DSS urea biosensor was confirmed. The repeatability and interference of the urea biosensor were suitable for monitoring urea concentrations typically found in human patients.

Emerging biosensors in detection of natural products

Natural products (NPs) are a valuable source in the food, pharmaceutical, agricultural, environmental, and many other industrial sectors. Their beneficial properties along with their potential toxicities make the detection, determination or quantification of NPs essential for their application. The advanced instrumental methods require time-consuming sample preparation and analysis. In contrast, biosensors allow rapid detection of NPs, especially in complex media, and are the preferred choice of detection when speed and high throughput are intended. Here, we review diverse biosensors reported for the detection of NPs. The emerging approaches for improving the efficiency of biosensors, such as microfluidics, nanotechnology, and magnetic beads, are also discussed. The simultaneous use of two detection techniques is suggested as a robust strategy for precise detection of a specific NP with structural complexity in complicated matrices. The parallel detection of a variety of NPs structures or biological activities in a mixture of extract in a single detection phase is among the anticipated future advancements in this field which can be achieved using multisystem biosensors applying multiple flow cells, sensing elements, and detection mechanisms on miniaturized folded chips.

Electrochemical immunoassay based on choline oxidase-peroxidase enzymatic cascade

Horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-based electrochemical immunoassays are considered promising techniques for point-of-care clinical diagnostics, but the necessary addition of unstable H₂O₂ in the enzymatic system may hinder their practical application. Although glucose oxidase (GOx) has been widely explored for in situ generation of H₂O₂ in HRP-based immunoassay, the GOx-catalyzed reduction of oxidized peroxidase substrate may limit the immunosensing performance. Here, we report a sensitive electrochemical immunosensor based on a choline oxidase (ChOx)-HRP cascade reaction. In this design, ChOx catalyzes the oxidation of choline, during which H₂O₂ is generated in situ and thus oxidizes acetaminophen (APAP) in the presence of HRP. The electrochemical behavior of APAP in the ChOx-HRP cascade was compared with that of the commonly used GOx-HRP cascade, which confirmed that ChOx could be a superior preceding enzyme for sensitive immunoassay based on the bienzymatic cascade. The developed ChOx-HRP cascade was also further explored for a sandwich-type electrochemical immunoassay of parathyroid hormone in artificial and clinical serum. The calculated detection limit was ~3 pg/mL, indicating that the ChOx-HRP cascade is especially promising for highly sensitive electrochemical immunoassays when APAP is used as the peroxidase substrate.

Comparison of LC-MS/MS and Enzymatic Methods for the Determination of Total Choline and Total Carnitine in Infant Formula and Milk Products

BACKGROUND

Choline and l-carnitine are classified as pseudo-vitamins because of their conditionally essential status. As they are involved in multiple physiological metabolic pathways in the human body, they are routinely fortified in infant and adult nutritional formulas.

OBJECTIVE

The performance of an LC-MS/MS method for the analysis of choline and carnitine, compared with enzymatic methods in routine use for the analysis of total carnitine and total choline, is described.

METHOD

Powder samples were reconstituted, with release of carnitine and choline facilitated by both acid and alkaline hydrolysis and the extract analyzed by LC-MS/MS. Quantitation was by internal standard technique using deuterium-labeled carnitine and deuterium-labeled choline.

RESULTS

Method range, specificity, sensitivity, precision, recovery, accuracy, and ruggedness were assessed for milk powders, infant formulas, and soy- and milk-based nutritional products. Spike recoveries of 94.0-108.4% were obtained for both total carnitine and choline, and no statistical bias (α = 0.05) between measured results and certified values (choline: P = 0.36; free carnitine: P = 0.67) was found for NIST 1849a certified reference material (NIST1849a). Precision, as repeatability relative standard deviation (RSD), was 2.0% RSDr for total carnitine and 1.7% RSDr for total choline. Equivalent results for total choline and total carnitine were obtained by LC-MS/MS and enzymatic methods (n = 30).

CONCLUSIONS

The described LC-MS/MS method is fit for purpose for routine product compliance release testing environments. This validation study has confirmed that alternative enzymatic assays can be used with confidence in laboratories in which LC-MS/MS platforms are unavailable.

HIGHLIGHTS

An LC-MS/MS method was evaluated and found to be fit-for-purpose for routine product compliance release testing of infant formula. The LC-MS/MS method was compared with enzymatic methods for the analysis of total carnitine and total choline. Alternative enzymatic assays can be used with confidence in laboratories in which LC-MS/MS platforms are unavailable.