The role of current product release criteria for identification of human islet preparations suitable for clinical transplantation

Biological hypoxia in pre-transplant human pancreatic islets induces transplant failure in diabetic mice

Evaluating the quality of isolated human islets before transplantation is crucial for predicting the success in treating Type 1 diabetes. The current gold standard involves time-intensive in vivo transplantation into diabetic immunodeficient mice. Given the susceptibility of isolated islets to hypoxia, we hypothesized that hypoxia present in islets before transplantation could indicate compromised islet quality, potentially leading to unfavorable outcomes. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed expression of 39 hypoxia-related genes in human islets from 85 deceased donors. We correlated gene expression profiles with transplantation outcomes in 327 diabetic mice, each receiving 1200 islet equivalents grafted into the kidney capsule. Transplantation outcome was post-transplant glycemic control based on area under the curve of blood glucose over 4 weeks. In linear regression analysis, DDIT4 (R = 0.4971, P < 0.0001), SLC2A8 (R = 0.3531, P = 0.0009) and HK1 (R = 0.3444, P = 0.0012) had the highest correlation with transplantation outcome. A multiple regression model of 11 genes increased the correlation (R = 0.6117, P < 0.0001). We conclude that assessing pre-transplant hypoxia in human islets via gene expression analysis is a rapid, viable alternative to conventional in vivo assessments. This approach also underscores the importance of mitigating pre-transplant hypoxia in isolated islets to improve the success rate of islet transplantation.

Pancreatic islet transplantation under the kidney capsule of mice: model of refinement for molecular and ex-vivo graft analysis

Diabetes cell therapy by human islet transplantation can restore an endogenous insulin secretion and normal glycaemic control in type 1 diabetic patients for as long as 10 years post transplantation. Before transplantation, each clinical islet preparation undergoes extensive in-vitro and in-vivo quality controls. The in-vivo quality control assay consists of transplanting human islets under the kidney capsule of immunocompromised mice. Currently, it is considered the best predictive factor to qualify clinical transplant efficiency. This chimeric model offers a wide area of study since it combines the possibility of producing not only quantitative but also a maximum of qualitative data. Today's technological advances allow us to obtain more accurate and stronger data from the animals used in research while ensuring their comfort and well-being throughout the protocol, including cage enrichment and pain treatment during and after surgery. As demonstrated in this valuable model, we are able to generate more usable results (Refine), while reducing the number of animals used (Reduce), by focusing on the development of ex-vivo analysis techniques (Replace), which clearly highlights the Burch and Russell 3Rs concept.

The Effect of Recovery Warm-up Time Following Cold Storage on the Dynamic Glucose-stimulated Insulin Secretion of Isolated Human Islets

Standardized islet characterization assays that can provide results in a timely manner are essential for successful islet cell transplantation. A critical component of islet cell quality is β-cell function, and perifusion-based assessments of dynamic glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (GSIS) are the most informative method to assess this, as they provide the most complex in vitro evaluation of GSIS. However, protocols used vary considerably among centers and investigators as they often use different low- and high-glucose concentrations, exposure-times, flow-rates, oxygen concentrations, islet numbers, analytical methods, measurement units, and instruments, which result in different readouts and make comparisons across platforms difficult. Additionally, the conditions of islet storage and shipment prior to assessment may also affect islet function. Establishing improved standardized protocols for perifusion GSIS assays should be an integral part of the ongoing effort to increase the rigor of human islet studies. Here, we performed detailed evaluation of GSIS of human islets using a fully automated multichannel perifusion instrument following various warm-up recovery times after cold storage that corresponds to current shipping conditions (8°C). We found that recovery times shorter than 18 h (overnight) resulted in impaired insulin secretion. While the effects were relatively moderate on second-phase insulin secretion, first-phase peaks were restored only following 18-h incubation. Hence, the biphasic profile of dynamic GSIS was considerably affected when islets were not allowed to recover for a sufficient time after being maintained in cold. Accordingly, while cold storage might improve islet cell survival during shipment and prolong the length of culture, functional assessments should be performed only after allowing for at least overnight recovery at physiological temperatures.

Improved harmonization of critical characterization assays across cell therapies

The field of cell therapy has blossomed, providing exciting new options for treating a variety of diseases. While few cell therapy products have US FDA approval, there are thousands of cell treatments at various stages of development, pointing to a potential revolutionary shift in patient care. The expanding number and nature of cellular therapies necessitate greater standardization. Several international organizations are collaborating to pursue some level of global standardization, especially concerning cell banking. However, less harmonization surrounds assays used for critical quality characterization including: identity, purity, safety and potency. Frequently, there is divergence regarding the terms describing the characterization assays across regulatory authorities and guidances. This review summarizes the critical quality assays currently used for different categories of cell therapies. Areas of harmonization and an absence of standardization are highlighted. We propose potential solutions to facilitate harmonization of critical quality characterization assays and the language used to describe them.

High Fractions of Large Islets in Human Islet Preparations Detrimentally Affect Posttransplant Outcomes in Streptozotocin-Induced Diabetic Immunodeficient Mice

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to determine whether the size of islets isolated from human donors-measured pretransplant-impacts transplantation outcomes in diabetic mice.

METHODS

Human islets (1200 islet equivalents) were transplanted into the kidney capsules of streptozotocin-induced diabetic immunodeficient mice. Data from a total of 174 mice that received islets from 45 isolations were analyzed to evaluate the correlation between pretransplant islet size and posttransplant diabetes reversal. Fluorescent images of islet clusters were used to categorize individual islets by size (small, 50-150 μm; medium, 150-250 μm; large, >250 μm), and the fractions of islets in each category were calculated.

RESULTS

The fraction of large islets negatively correlated with diabetes reversal rates. Mice that received islet grafts containing 0% to 5%, 5% to 10%, and more than 10% large islets had diabetes reversal rates of 75%, 61%, and 45%, respectively (P = 0.0112). Furthermore, mice that exhibited diabetes reversal received smaller fractions of large islets than mice that did not (5.5% vs 8.0%, P = 0.0003). Intriguingly, the fractions of medium and small islets did not correlate with diabetes reversal outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The fraction of large islets is a sensitive predictor of human islet transplantation outcomes in diabetic mice.

Semi-Automated Assessment of Human Islet Viability Predicts Transplantation Outcomes in a Diabetic Mouse Model

In clinical and experimental human pancreatic islet transplantations, establishing pretransplant assessments that accurately predict transplantation outcomes is crucial. Conventional in vitro viability assessment that relies on manual counting of viable islets is a routine pretransplant assessment. However, this method does not correlate with transplantation outcomes; to improve the method, we recently introduced a semi-automated method using imaging software to objectively determine area-based viability. The goal of the present study was to correlate semi-automated viability assessment with posttransplantation outcomes of human islet transplantations in diabetic immunodeficient mice, the gold standard for in vivo functional assessment of isolated human islets. We collected data from 61 human islet isolations and 188 subsequent in vivo mouse transplantations. We assessed islet viability by fluorescein diacetate and propidium iodide staining using both the conventional and semi-automated method. Transplantations of 1,200 islet equivalents under the kidney capsule were performed in streptozotocin-induced diabetic immunodeficient mice. Among the pretransplant variables, including donor factors and post-isolation assessments, viability measured using the semi-automated method demonstrated a strong influence on in vivo islet transplantation outcomes in multivariate analysis. We calculated an optimized cutoff value (96.1%) for viability measured using the semi-automated method and showed a significant difference in diabetes reversal rate for islets with viability above this cutoff (77% reversal) vs. below this cutoff (49% reversal). We performed a detailed analysis to show that both the objective measurement and the improved area-based scoring system, which distinguished between small and large islets, were key features of the semi-automated method that allowed for precise evaluation of viability. Taken together, our results suggest that semi-automated viability assessment offers a promising alternative pretransplant assessment over conventional manual assessment to predict human islet transplantation outcomes.

Concentration-Dependency and Time Profile of Insulin Secretion: Dynamic Perifusion Studies With Human and Murine Islets

The detailed characterization and quantification of the kinetics of glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (GSIS) by normal pancreatic islets is of considerable interest for characterizing β-cell dysfunction, assessing the quality of isolated islets, and improving the design of artificial pancreas devices. Here, we performed dynamic evaluation of GSIS by human and mouse islets at high temporal resolution (every minute) in response to different glucose steps using an automated multichannel perifusion instrument. In both species, insulin responses were biphasic (a transient first-phase peak followed by a sustained second-phase), and the amount of insulin released showed a sigmoid-type dependence on glucose concentration. However, compared to murine islets, human islets have (1) a less pronounced first-phase response, (2) a flat secretion rate during second-phase response, (3) a left-shifted concentration response (reaching half-maximal response at 7.9 ± 0.4 vs. 13.7 ± 0.6 mM), and (4) an ~3-fold lower maximal secretion rate (8.3 ± 2.3 vs. 23.9 ± 5.1 pg/min/islet at 30 mM glucose). These results can be used to establish a more informative protocol for the calculation of the stimulation index, which is widely used for islet assessment in both research and clinical applications, but without an accepted standard or clear evidence as to what low- to high-glucose steps can provide better characterization of islet function. Data obtained here suggest that human islet functionality might be best characterized with a dynamic stimulation index obtained with a glucose step from a low of 4-5 to a high of 14-17 mM (e.g., G4 → G16).

Determination of Islet Viability Using a Zinc-Specific Fluorescent Dye and a Semiautomated Assessment Method

Islet transplantation is an effective therapy that allows the achievement of insulin independence in patients with type 1 diabetes (T1D). To ensure successful transplantation, islet viability and function are of great importance. Viability assessments most often use fluorescein diacetate (FDA)/propidium iodide (PI) staining. However, results using this method often do not correlate well with graft function. Because FDA nonspecifically penetrates all cells present in the islet preparation, including islets and contaminating acinar cells, its use often complicates viability assessments of the overall cell population. Furthermore, the manual method for determining viability percentages is highly subjective. Shortcomings of the conventional islet viability assay can be potentially improved by staining cells with Newport Green (NG). NG, is a zinc-specific fluorescent dye that specifically reacts with zinc-rich β cells. Two kinds of NG dyes, NG-DCF and NG-PDX, are currently available. We examined the zinc specificity of these NG dyes and compared NG staining with traditional FDA staining to explore the potential of NG dyes to improve islet viability assessment. Of the two NGs tested, NG-DCF showed the higher specificity toward a β-cell line as well as human islets. NG-DCF accurately identified the islet area, even in low-purity islets, while neither FDA nor NG-PDX did. Although NG-DCF staining required a longer incubation time, the addition of poloxamer F127 and incubation at 37°C allowed viability assessment to take place within 30 min. Unlike FDA/PI staining, NG-DCF/PI staining allowed for islet-specific assessment. We also introduced a semiautomated measurement to determine NG-DCF/PI staining results, which enabled us to obtain objective and reproducible results. NG-DCF/PI staining is easy and reliable, and this method permits highly objective islet-specific viability assessments.

Clinical Islet Isolation

The overarching success of islet transplantation relies on the success in the laboratory to isolate the islets. This chapter focuses on the processes of human islet cell isolation and the ways to optimally provide islet cells for transplantation. The major improvements in regards to the choice of enzyme type, way the digested pancreas tissue is handled to best separate islets from the acinar and surrounding tissues, the various methods of purification of the islets, their subsequent culture and quality assurance to improve outcomes to culminate in safe and effective islet transplantation will be discussed. After decades of improvements, islet cell isolation and transplantation now clearly offer a safe, effective and feasible therapeutic treatment option for an increasing number of patients suffering from type 1 diabetes specifically for those with severe hypoglycaemic unawareness.

Adenine nucleotide levels in a closed enzymatic digestion system for porcine islet isolation

Obtaining viable islets is a crucial step for successful islet transplantation. Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) is a marker of cell viability. However, little is known about any changes in the energy status of the tissues that are being digested during the digestion phase. We herein examined whether the ATP content in serially digested pancreatic tissue samples could be specific objective parameters that signal the optimal point to stop the digestion process. We obtained partial pancreata (body to tail) from 4- to 5-year-old pigs from a slaughterhouse. The tissue samples were preserved in M-Kyoto solution for less than 3 h. They were digested using an automated enzymatic and mechanical dissociation system at 37°C for 90 min following intraductal injection of Liberase HI. Samples were collected from the digestive circuit every 5 or 10 min to determine the ATP level, total adenine nucleotide (TAN) level, islet count (count/g), and yield of islet equivalent (IEQ) in the serial digestive fluids. The ATP and TAN levels, IEQ and islet count were increased and then decreased during digestion process. The profile of these parameters differed from case to case. However, when ATP changing ratio (respective value/precedent value) was compared with IEQ changing ratio, a greater than threefold increase in the ATP changing ratio followed by an increase in the islet count changing ratio within 5 min was consistently observed, indicating the optimal time to stop the digestion. The ATP levels of the handpicked islets in the digested samples were lower in the overdigested phase in comparison to those in the earlier digested phase. These results indicate that the ATP level in digested fluid could be an effective indicator to estimate the viability of cells as well as determine the optimal time to terminate the digestion process in order to obtain viable islets.

Quantitative assessment of islets of Langerhans encapsulated in alginate

Improved methods have recently been developed for assessing islet viability and quantity in human islet preparations for transplantation, and these measurements have proven useful for predicting transplantation outcome. The objectives of this study were to adapt these methods for use with microencapsulated islets, to verify that they provide meaningful quantitative measurements, and to test them with two model systems: (1) barium alginate and (2) barium alginate containing a 70% (w/v) perfluorocarbon (PFC) emulsion, which presents challenges to use of these assays and is of interest in its own right as a means for reducing oxygen supply limitations to encapsulated tissue. Mitochondrial function was assessed by oxygen consumption rate measurements, and the analysis of data was modified to account for the increased solubility of oxygen in the PFC-alginate capsules. Capsules were dissolved and tissue recovered for nuclei counting to measure the number of cells. Capsule volume was determined from alginate or PFC content and used to normalize measurements. After low oxygen culture for 2 days, islets in normal alginate lost substantial viable tissue and displayed necrotic cores, whereas most of the original oxygen consumption rate was recovered with PFC alginate, and little necrosis was observed. All nuclei were recovered with normal alginate, but some nuclei from nonrespiring cells were lost with PFC alginate. Biocompatibility tests revealed toxicity at the islet periphery associated with the lipid emulsion used to provide surfactants during the emulsification process. We conclude that these new assay methods can be applied to islets encapsulated in materials as complex as PFC-alginate. Measurements made with these materials revealed that enhancement of oxygen permeability of the encapsulating material with a concentrated PFC emulsion improves survival of encapsulated islets under hypoxic conditions, but reformulation of the PFC emulsion is needed to reduce toxicity.

Functional MRI characterization of isolated human islet activation

The noninvasive assessment of pancreatic islets would be an invaluable tool in advancing the treatment of type I diabetes and in understanding its pathophysiology. As shown previously in rodents, manganese-enhanced MRI (MEMRI) can be successfully used to quantify β-cell function. In this study, we successfully applied this technique to isolated human pancreatic islets in both a static and, more significantly, MRI-compatible perfusion set-up. Unlike rodent islets, which produced a significant increase in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) when treated with 25 µM MnCl(2) or less, human islets demonstrated significant manganese uptake when exposed to an extracellular concentration of 50 µM MnCl(2). Nonspecific passive manganese uptake was present and quantified in a 15% SNR increase over the control group. However, glucose-induced manganese uptake caused an SNR increase equal to 45% over nonactivated islets. This corresponds to a statistically significant decrease in the T(1) relaxation time from 1501 ms for untreated islets to 1362 ms following passive uptake, and to 861 ms following glucose stimulation. As expected, no manganese cytotoxicity was measured, as shown by normal insulin secretion profiles. These data confirm the viability of MEMRI to assess isolated human islet functionality in vitro, and this technique shows promise for the monitoring of their performance in vivo following transplantation.

A simplified approach to human islet quality assessment

BACKGROUND

The successful treatment of patients with type 1 diabetes by islet transplantation is affected by a multitude of factors of which infusion of the highest quality tissue is essential. The current standard pretransplant quality assessments lack sensitivity, accuracy, and objectivity in the determination of islet viability and potency. We hypothesized that a multiparametric approach focused on islet cell metabolic state, mitochondrial integrity, and in vitro glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (GSIS) could provide data predictive of in vivo function. The objective of this study was to validate a novel set of islet quality assays and develop a simplified islet quality scoring system for both basic research and clinical applications.

METHODS

A series of 42 human islet preparations were screened using standard and novel methods, which included determination of yield, viability by fluorescent microscopy, GSIS, percentage of islet loss in culture, quantification of adenine nucleotides, flow cytometric measurement of viability, apoptosis, and mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP). In vivo functional potency was tested by minimal model transplant in streptozotocin-induced diabetic NOD.scid mice.

RESULTS

Functionally potent islet preparations showed significantly greater numbers of cells with polarized MMP, higher ATP-to-ADP ratios, and increased glucose-induced insulin secretion. The MMP, ATP-to-ADP ratio, and GSIS data were combined into a single islet scoring formula that showed more than 86% accuracy in predicting in vivo functional potency.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates that a multiparametric approach using objective assessments focused on islet cell mitochondrial integrity and in vitro function can provide data predictive of in vivo function.

A novel predictive method for assessing the quality of isolated pancreatic islets using scanning electrochemical microscopy

INTRODUCTION

The current methods for evaluating islet potency are not useful in clinical transplantation. Therefore, we need reliable, rapid methods enabling accurate prediction of islet quality.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We evaluated respiratory activity using scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM), glucose-stimulated respiratory activity, glucose-stimulated insulin release, ADP/ATP assays, insulin/DNA levels, and Trypan blue exclusion tests as predictive methods for the ability of isolated rat islets to cure syngeneic diabetic rats.

RESULTS

Although glucose-stimulated respiratory activity, basal respiratory activity, ADP/ATP ratio, and glucose-stimulated insulin release were significantly correlated with the outcome of transplantation into diabetic rats, there was no correlation between outcomes, insulin/DNA ratios, and Trypan blue exclusion tests. The glucose-stimulated respiratory activity in islet preparations that could cure diabetic rats was significantly greater than those unable to cure diabetes. Rat islets with >1.5-fold glucose-stimulated respiratory activity consistently cured diabetic rats, whereas those with a value <1.5 hardly cured any rats.

CONCLUSION

Measurement of the glucose-stimulated respiratory activity using SECM technique is a novel method that may be useful as a rapid, potent predictor of the outcome of clinical islet transplantation.

Quality control for clinical islet transplantation: organ procurement and preservation, the islet processing facility, isolation, and potency tests

Pancreatic islet transplantation has become one of the ideal treatments for patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus due to improvements in isolation techniques and immunosuppression regimens. In order to ensure the safety and rights of patients, isolated islets need to meet the criteria for regulation as both a biological product and a drug product. For the constant success of transplantation, therefore, all investigators involved in clinical islet transplantation must strive to ensure the safety, purity, and potency of islets in all the phases of clinical islet isolation and transplantation. In this review, we summarize the quality control for clinical islet isolation and transplantation, and the latest topics of pre-transplant islet assessment.

ATP measurement predicts porcine islet transplantation outcome in nude mice

Current nude mice islet transplantation studies cannot be used prospectively. Therefore, to predict transplantation outcomes, reliable and rapid assays for islet quality assessment are warranted. This study evaluated the predictive power of the porcine islet ATP content on the outcomes of islet transplantation in nude mice. Here, we report that the ATP measurement using a small number of handpicked islets with a diameter of 100 to 150 mum is a good predictor of islet graft efficacy in nude mice. Using receiver-operator characteristic analysis, the area under the curve of the ATP content using a small number of handpicked islets was 0.867 (95% confidence interval 0.744-0.989, P<0.001). The sensitivity and the specificity measured were 83.3% and 73.3%, respectively. In conclusion, a simple and a rapid measurement of intraislet ATP content could be a promising substitute for current nude mice islet transplantation studies.

Glucose-stimulated increment in oxygen consumption rate as a standardized test of human islet quality

Standardized assessment of islet quality is imperative for clinical islet transplantation. We have previously shown that the increment in oxygen consumption rate stimulated by glucose (DeltaOCR(glc)) can predict in vivo efficacy of islet transplantation in mice. To further evaluate the approach, we studied three factors: islet specificity, islet composition and agreement between results obtained by different groups. Equivalent perifusion systems were set up at the City of Hope and the University of Washington and the values of DeltaOCR(glc) obtained at both institutions were compared. Islet specificity was determined by comparing DeltaOCR(glc) in islet and nonislet tissue. The DeltaOCR(glc) ranged from 0.01 to 0.19 nmol/min/100 islets (n = 14), a wide range in islet quality, but the values obtained by the two centers were similar. The contribution from nonislet impurities was negligible (DeltaOCR(glc) was 0.12 nmol/min/100 islets vs. 0.007 nmol/min/100 nonislet clusters). The DeltaOCR(glc) was statistically independent of percent beta cells, demonstrating that DeltaOCR(glc) is governed more by islet quality than by islet composition. The DeltaOCR(glc), but not the absolute level of OCR, was predictive of reversal of hyperglycemia in diabetic mice. These demonstrations lay the foundation for testing DeltaOCR(glc) as a measurement of islet quality for human islet transplantation.

A stirred microchamber for oxygen consumption rate measurements with pancreatic islets

Improvements in pancreatic islet transplantation for treatment of diabetes are hindered by the absence of meaningful islet quality assessment methods. Oxygen consumption rate (OCR) has previously been used to assess the quality of organs and primary tissue for transplantation. In this study, we describe and characterize a stirred microchamber for measuring OCR with small quantities of islets. The device has a titanium body with a chamber volume of about 200 microL and is magnetically stirred and water jacketed for temperature control. Oxygen partial pressure (pO(2)) is measured by fluorescence quenching with a fiber optic probe, and OCR is determined from the linear decrease of pO(2) with time. We demonstrate that measurements can be made rapidly and with high precision. Measurements with betaTC3 cells and islets show that OCR is directly proportional to the number of viable cells in mixtures of live and dead cells and correlate linearly with membrane integrity measurements made with cells that have been cultured for 24 h under various stressful conditions.

The ADP/ATP ratio: A novel predictive assay for quality assessment of isolated pancreatic islets

The current standard assays for islet product release criteria are unable to predict the outcome after clinical islet transplantation. Therefore, establishment of reliable and rapid assays enabling pre-transplantation prediction of islet potency is warranted. In the present study, we have evaluated the adenosine diphosphate (ADP)/adenosine triphosphate (ATP) test, the glucose-stimulated insulin release, the loss of islets during the first 24 h in culture, and the insulin/deoxyribonucleic acid as predictive assays for the ability of isolated porcine islets to cure athymic mice with streptozotocin-induced diabetes. From the results presented, it is concluded that the measurement of the ADP/ATP ratio was the only test that correlated with transplantation outcome. In summary, we propose that the ADP/ATP assay is worthwhile as applied to human islet transplantation and seek to validate it as a rapid and potent predictor of transplant outcome.

Glucose stimulation of cytochrome C reduction and oxygen consumption as assessment of human islet quality

BACKGROUND

An in vitro method to assess human islets could prevent transplantation of nonviable islets and facilitate the optimization of islet preparation. We hypothesize that glucose-stimulated cytochrome c reduction and oxygen consumption by human islets can be used as predictors of transplant success.

METHODS

Isolated human islets were obtained from research-grade pancreata. Using a previously developed islet flow culture system, the response of cytochrome c reduction and oxygen consumption to glucose was compared to the ability of islets transplanted into nondiabetic NOD-SCID mice to secrete C-peptide in response to a glucose tolerance test conducted 7 days following transplant (n=10).

RESULTS

In vitro responses by human islets were qualitatively similar to those seen in rat islets: glucose increased both oxygen consumption and cytochrome c reduction. However, the responses were smaller in magnitude and quite variable. Scatter plots of C-peptide and quantiles for ln(C-peptide) indicated that 12 ng/ml could be used as threshold of transplant success with which to evaluate the diagnostic potential of cytochrome c and oxygen consumption. Data was analyzed by generating receiver operating curves and the area under the curve was 0.889 (95% CI: 0.645-1.000) and 0.738 (95% CI: 0.413-1.000) for cytochrome c reduction and oxygen consumption respectively (1 indicates absolute predictive capability and 0.5 indicates no predictive capability).

CONCLUSIONS

The detection of glucose-stimulated cytochrome c reduction and oxygen consumption may have utility as criteria for the assessment of human islet quality.