Chemolithotrophic denitrification with elemental sulfur for groundwater treatment

Development of nitrification and elemental sulfur-based denitrification/anammox (NS0DA) process for mainstream nitrogen removal

The implementation of mainstream anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) can facilitate the realization of carbon-neutral wastewater treatment. However, this technology remains challenging owing to the inability to stably provide nitrite. In this study, we developed a novel nitrification and elemental sulfur-based partial autotrophic denitrification/anammox (NS0DA) process for mainstream nitrogen removal. The NS0DA system consists of a nitrification reactor and a combined elemental sulfur-based denitrification and anammox (S0DA) reactor. Each reactor was independently initiated and optimized before being integrated. At mainstream nitrogen levels (48.5 ± 1.7 mg NH4+-N/L) and 25 °C, the NS0DA system achieved 89.1 ± 5.7 % total nitrogen (TN) removal efficiency, with an effluent TN concentration of 5.4 ± 2.8 mg N/L. The system exhibited a low N2O emission factor (0.23 %), significantly lower than other anammox-based systems. The S0DA reactor achieved a nitrogen removal rate of 0.53 kg N/(m3·d) with a short hydraulic retention time (2 h). Anammox accounted for 87.3 ± 7.0 % of the TN removal in the S0DA reactor. Isotope experiments and kinetic analysis revealed the cooperation between anammox and denitrification for nitrogen removal. Polysulfides formed in the S0DA reactor enhanced the utilization rate of elemental sulfur. High-throughput sequencing identified Thiobacillus and Candidatus Brocadia as the dominant genera of sulfur oxidation and anammox, respectively. The nitrogen and sulfur metabolic pathways were further verified through metagenomic analysis. Overall, the NS0DA process provides a stable and efficient nitrogen removal process, minimizing oxygen demand, eliminating organic carbon requirements, and reducing N2O emissions compared to conventional nitrification/denitrification. This approach offers a promising solution for mainstream nitrogen removal in wastewater treatment.

Influences of fluctuating nutrient loadings on nitrate-reducing microorganisms in rivers

Rivers serve important functions for human society and are significantly impacted by anthropogenic nutrient inputs (e.g. organic and sulfur compounds). Reduced organic and sulfur compounds influence the nitrogen cycle as they are electron donors of microbial nitrate reduction. Water pollution caused by individual nutrients and the mechanisms have been studied, but how the variation in multiple nutrient loadings influences nitrate-reducing microorganisms is less understood. Two sets of microcosms were established and exposed to nitrate, along with either acetate or thiosulfate, at different times. Nutrient concentrations responded to the loading pollutant. The nutrient loading order was more important in shaping microbial community structure and microbial interactions through the exchange of growth-required substances. This indicated that upstream or historical nutrient inflows impacted current nitrate reduction by changing the seeding microbial community, highlighting the importance of river connectivity. Based on metatranscriptome analysis, although the order and type of nutrient loadings were equally important in regulating global transcriptomes, transcripts of enzymes for key metabolisms (nitrate reduction, sulfur oxidation, etc.) more actively responded to the nutrient type. The regulation of a small set of genes was sufficient to make the transition, while most transcripts were not degraded and regenerated. These insights are important for understanding the varying pollution status of rivers and for developing effective solutions, such as remediation.

Enterobacter sp. HIT-SHJ4 isolated from wetland with carbon, nitrogen and sulfur co-metabolism and its implication for bioremediation

Both autotrophic and heterotrophic denitrification are known as important bioprocesses of microbe-mediated nitrogen cycle in natural ecosystems. Actually, mixotrophic denitrification co-driven by organic matter and reduced sulfur substances are also common, especially in hypoxic environments such as estuarine sediments. However, carbon, nitrogen and sulfur co-metabolism during mixotrophic denitrification in natural water ecosystems has rarely been reported in detail. Therefore, this study investigated the co-metabolism of carbon, nitrogen and sulfur using samples collected from four distinct natural water ecosystems. Results demonstrated that samples from various sources all exhibited the ability for co-metabolism of carbon, nitrogen and sulfur. Microbial community analysis showed that Pseudomonas and Paracoccus were dominant bacteria ranging from 65.6% to 75.5% in mixotrophic environment. Enterobacter sp. HIT-SHJ4, a mixotrophic denitrifying strain which owned the capacity for co-metabolism of carbon, nitrogen and sulfur, was isolated and reported here for the first time. The strain preferred methanol as its carbon source and demonstrated remarkable efficiency for removing sulfide and nitrate with below 100 mg/L sulfide. Under weak acid conditions (pH 6.5-7.0), it exhibited enhanced capability in converting sulfide to elemental sulfur. Its bioactivity was evident within a temperature from 25 °C to 40 °C and C/N ratios from 0.75 to 3. This study confirmed the widespread presence of microbial-mediated synergistic carbon, nitrogen and sulfur metabolism in natural aquatic ecosystems. HIT-SHJ4 emerges as a novel strain, shedding light on carbon, nitrogen and sulfur co-metabolism in natural water bodies. Furthermore, it also serves as a promising candidate microorganism for in-situ ecological remediation, particularly in dealing with contamination posed by nitrate, sulfide, and organic matter.

Water flush boosts performance of elemental sulfur-based denitrification packed-bed systems: Optimization and mechanisms

Despite the promising potential of elemental sulfur-based denitrification (ESDeN) packed-bed progresses, challenges such as excessive biofilm growth and gas entrapment persist, leading to denitrification deterioration. Water flush (WF) is recognized as an effective strategy, yet its effects remain underexplored. To address this knowledge gap, this study systematically investigated WF effects on ESDeN packed-bed denitrification. Results demonstrated that controlling WF effectively regulated denitrification, achieving superior and stable rates. Compared to no WF (0.45 kgN·m-3·d-1), rates improved by 1.20 ∼ 1.56 times under low-frequency (weekly WF, 0.54 kgN·m-3·d-1) and low-intensity WF (0.54 ∼ 0.70 kgN·m-3·d-1). High-frequency (hours WF) and high-intensity WF (30 & 50 m/h) further amplified denitrification rates by 1.73 ∼ 2.29 times. The enhanced denitrifications under low-frequency/intensity WF were mainly attributed to prolonged actual hydraulic retention time (AHRT), while high-frequency/intensity WF improved both AHRT prolonging and biofilm thinning, facilitating mass transfer. This study offers a promising avenue for fine-tuning denitrification rates via strategic WF adjustments.

Intertwining of the C-N-S cycle in passive and aerated constructed wetlands

The microbial processes occurring in constructed wetlands (CWs) are difficult to understand owing to the complex interactions occurring between a variety of substrates, microorganisms, and plants under the given physicochemical conditions. This frequently leads to very large unexplained nitrogen losses in these systems. In continuation of our findings on Anammox contributions, our research on full-scale field CWs has suggested the significant involvement of the sulfur cycle in the conventional C-N cycle occurring in wetlands, which might closely explain the nitrogen losses in these systems. This paper explored the possibility of the sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification (SDAD) pathway in different types of CWs, shallow and deep and passive and aerated systems, by analyzing the metagenomic bacterial communities present within these CWs. The results indicate a higher abundance of SDAD bacteria (Paracoccus and Arcobacter) in deep passive systems compared to shallow systems and presence of a large number of SDAD genera (Paracoccus, Thiobacillus, Beggiatoa, Sulfurimonas, Arcobacter, and Sulfuricurvum) in aerated CWs. The bacteria belonging to the functional category of dark oxidation of sulfur compounds were found to be enriched in deep and aerated CWs hinting at the possible role of the SDAD pathway in total nitrogen removal in these systems. As a case study, the percentage nitrogen removal through SDAD pathway was calculated to be 15-20% in aerated wetlands. The presence of autotrophic pathways for nitrogen removal can prove highly beneficial in terms of reducing sludge generation and hence reducing clogging, making aerated CWs a sustainable wastewater treatment solution.

A novel coupling process to replace the traditional multi-stage anammox process-sulfur autotrophic denitrification coupled anammox system

A novel coupling process to replace the traditional multi-stage anammox process-sulfur autotrophic denitrification (SAD) coupled anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) system was designed, which solved problems of nitrate produced in anammox process and low nitrate conversion rate caused by nitrite accumulation in SAD process. Different filter structures (SAD filter and anammox granular sludge) were investigated to further explore the excellent performance of the novel integrated reactor. The results of sequential batch experiments indicated that nitrite accumulation occurred during SAD, which inhibited the conversion of nitrate to dinitrogen gas. When SAD filter and anammox granular sludge were added to packed bed reactor simultaneously, the nitrate removal rate increased by 37.21% and effluent nitrite concentration decreased by 100% compared to that achieved using SAD. The stratified filter structure solved groove flow. Different proportion influence of SAD filter and anammox granular sludge on the stratified filter structure was evaluated. More suitable ratio of SAD filter to anammox granular sludge was 2:1. Proteobacteria (57.26%), Bacteroidetes (20.12%) and Chloroflexi (9.95%) were the main phyla. The dominant genera of denitrification functional bacteria were Thiobacillus (39.80%), Chlorobaculum (3.99%), norank_f_PHOs-HE36 (2.90%) and Ignavibacterium (2.64%). The dominant genus of anammox bacterium was Candidatus_Kuenenia (3.05%).

Manganese sulfide-sulfur and limestone autotrophic denitrification system for deep and efficient nitrate removal: Feasibility, performance and mechanism

Despite the great potential of sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification, an improvement in nitrate removal rate is still needed. This study used the desulfurized products of Mn ore to develop the MnS-S0-limestone autotrophic denitrification system (MSLAD). The feasibility of MSLAD for denitrification was explored and the possible mechanism was proposed. The nitrate (100 mg/L) was almost removed within 24 h in batch experiment in MSLAD. Also, an average TN removal of 98 % (472.0 mg/L/d) at hydraulic retention time of 1.5 h in column experiment (30 mg/L) was achieved. MnS and S0 could act as coupled electron donors and show synergistic effects for nitrate removal. γ-MnS with smaller particle size and lower crystallinity was more readily utilized by the bacterium and had higher nitrate removal efficiency than that of α-MnS. Thiobacillus and Sulfurimonas were the core functional bacterium in denitrification. Therefore, MnS-S0-limestone bio-denitrification provides an efficient alternative method for nitrate removal in wastewater.

Overlooked in-situ sulfur disproportionation fuels dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium in sulfur-based system: Novel insight of nitrogen recovery

Sulfur-based denitrification is a promising technology in treatments of nitrate-contaminated wastewaters. However, due to weak bioavailability and electron-donating capability of elemental sulfur, its sulfur-to-nitrate ratio has long been low, limiting the support for dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) process. Using a long-term sulfur-packed reactor, we demonstrate here for the first time that DNRA in sulfur-based system is not negligible, but rather contributes a remarkable 40.5 %-61.1 % of the total nitrate biotransformation for ammonium production. Through combination of kinetic experiments, electron flow analysis, 16S rRNA amplicon, and microbial network succession, we unveil a cryptic in-situ sulfur disproportionation (SDP) process which significantly facilitates DNRA via enhancing mass transfer and multiplying 86.7-210.9 % of bioavailable electrons. Metagenome assembly and single-copy gene phylogenetic analysis elucidate the abundant genomes, including uc_VadinHA17, PHOS-HE36, JALNZU01, Thiobacillus, and Rubrivivax, harboring complete genes for ammonification. Notably, a unique group of self-SDP-coupled DNRA microorganism was identified. This study unravels a previously concealed fate of DNRA, which highlights the tremendous potential for ammonium recovery and greenhouse gas mitigation. Discovery of a new coupling between nitrogen and sulfur cycles underscores great revision needs of sulfur-driven denitrification technology.

The impact of benzoic acid and lactic acid on the treatment efficiency and microbial community in the sulfur autotrophic denitrification process

Nitrate poses a potential threat to aquatic ecosystems. This study focuses on the sulfur autotrophic denitrification mechanism in the process of water culture wastewater treatment, which has been successfully applied to the degradation of nitrogen in water culture farm effluents. However, the coexistence of organic acids in the treatment process is a common environmental challenge, significantly affecting the activity of denitrifying bacteria. This paper aims to explore the effects of adding benzoic acid and lactic acid on denitrification performance, organic acid removal rate, and microbial population abundance in sulfur autotrophic denitrification systems under optimal operating conditions, sulfur deficiency, and high hydraulic load. In experiments with 50 mg·L-1 of benzoic acid or lactic acid alone, the results show that benzoic acid and lactic acid have a stimulating effect on denitrification activity, with the stimulating effect significantly greater than the inhibitory effect. Under optimal operating conditions, the average denitrification rate of the system remained above 99%; under S/N = 1.5 conditions, the average denitrification rate increased from 88.34% to 91.93% and 85.91%; under HRT = 6 h conditions, the average denitrification rate increased from 75.25% to 97.79% and 96.58%. In addition, the addition of organic acids led to a decrease in microbial population abundance. At the phylum level, Proteobacteria has always been the dominant bacterial genus, and its relative abundance significantly increased after the addition of benzoic acid, from 40.2% to 61.5% and 62.4%. At the genus level, Thiobacillus, Sulfurimonas, Chryseobacterium, and Thermomonas maintained high population abundances under different conditions. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Employing autotrophic denitrification process for treating high-nitrate wastewater. Utilizing organic acids as external carbon sources. Denitrifying bacteria demonstrate high utilization efficiency towards organic acids. Organic acids promote denitrification more than they inhibit it. The promotion is manifested in the enhancement of activity and microbial abundance.

In situ incubation of iron(II)-bearing minerals and Fe(0) reveals insights into metabolic flexibility of chemolithotrophic bacteria in a nitrate polluted karst aquifer

Groundwater nitrate pollution is a major reason for deteriorating water quality and threatens human and animal health. Yet, mitigating groundwater contamination naturally is often complicated since most aquifers are limited in bioavailable carbon. Since metabolically flexible microbes might have advantages for survival, this study presents a detailed description and first results on our modification of the BacTrap© method, aiming to determine the prevailing microbial community's potential to utilize chemolithotrophic pathways. Our microbial trapping devices (MTDs) were amended with four different iron sources and incubated in seven groundwater monitoring wells for ∼3 months to promote growth of nitrate-reducing Fe(II)-oxidizing bacteria (NRFeOxB) in a nitrate-contaminated karst aquifer. Phylogenetic analysis based on 16S rRNA gene sequences implies that the identity of the iron source influenced the microbial community's composition. In addition, high throughput amplicon sequencing revealed increased relative 16S rRNA gene abundances of OTUs affiliated to genera such as Thiobacillus, Rhodobacter, Pseudomonas, Albidiferax, and Sideroxydans. MTD-derived enrichments set up with Fe(II)/nitrate/acetate to isolate potential NRFeOxB, were dominated by e.g., Acidovorax spp., Paracoccus spp. and Propionivibrio spp. MTDs are a cost-effective approach for investigating microorganisms in groundwater and our data not only solidifies the MTD's capacity to provide insights into the metabolic flexibility of the aquifer's microbial community, but also substantiates its metabolic potential for anaerobic Fe(II) oxidation.

Tourmaline mediated enhanced autotrophic denitrification: The mechanisms of electron transfer and Paracoccus enrichment

Autotrophic denitrification (AD) without carbon source is an inevitable choice for denitrification of municipal wastewater under the carbon peaking and carbon neutrality goals. This study first employed sulfur-tourmaline-AD (STAD) as an innovative nitrate removal trial technique in wastewater. STAD demonstrated a 2.23-fold increase in nitrate‑nitrogen (NO3--N) removal rate with reduced nitrite‑nitrogen (NO2--N) accumulation, effectively removing 99 % of nitrogen pollutants compared to sulfur denitrification. Some denitrifiers microorganisms that could secrete tyrosine, tryptophan, and aromatic protein (extracellular polymeric substances (EPS)). Moreover, according to the EPS composition and characteristics analysis, the secretion of loosely bound extracellular polymeric substances (LB-EPS) that bound to the bacterial endogenous respiration and enriched microbial abundance, was produced more in the STAD system, further improving the system stability. Furthermore, the addition of tourmaline (Tm) facilitated the discovery of a new genus (Paracoccus) that enhanced nitrate decomposition. Applying optimal electron donors through metabolic pathways and the microbial community helps to strengthen the AD process and treat low carbon/nitrogen ratio wastewater efficiently.

Inducement mechanism and control of self-acidification in elemental sulfur fluidizing bioreactor

The sulfur fluidizing bioreactor (S0FB) has significant superiorities in treating nitrate-rich wastewater. However, substantial self-acidification has been observed in engineering applications, resulting in frequent start-up failures. In this study, self-acidification was reproduced in a lab-scale S0FB. It was demonstrated that self-acidification was mainly induced by sulfur disproportionation process, accounting for 93.4 % of proton generation. Supplying sufficient alkalinity to both the influent (3000 mg/L) and the bulk (2000 mg/L) of S0FB was essential for achieving a successful start-up. Furthermore, the S0FB reached 10.3 kg-N/m3/d of nitrogen removal rate and 0.13 kg-PO43-/m3/d of phosphate removal rate, respectively, surpassing those of the documented sulfur packing bioreactors by 7-129 times and 26-65 times. This study offers a feasible and practical method to avoid self-acidification during restart of S0FB and highlights the considerable potential of S0FB in the treatment of nitrate-rich wastewater.

Adapting to seasonal temperature variations: A dynamic multi-subunit strategy for sulfur autotrophic denitrification bioreactors

Elemental sulfur autotrophic denitrification (S0AD) processes are temperature-sensitive, presenting a substantial challenge for the practical implementation of S0AD bioreactors. In this study, a comprehensive methodology for designing and operating S0AD bioreactors was developed, effectively managing fluctuations in nitrogen removal efficiency caused by seasonal temperature variations. Initially, the nitrate removal rate was correlated with simulated on-site temperature and nitrate loading, revealing correlation coefficients of k1, k2, k3, and A as 5.42×10-4, -0.41, 0.04, and 0.13, respectively, to establish a mathematical model for predicting S0AD efficiency. Subsequently, by considering influence factors such as dissolved oxygen and dynamic sulfur consumption, the model was employed to accurately design a pilot-scale S0AD bioreactor for a case study. By utilizing an alternative multi-subunit operation, a stable effluent nitrate concentration of less than 8 mg-N/L was maintained throughout the year. Importantly, this approach resulted in a substantial reduction of 76.8% in excessive nitrate removal, sulfur consumption, and sulfate production. This study aims to provide an optimal design and operation strategy for the practical application of S0AD bioreactors, thereby enhancing reliability and cost-effectiveness in the face of seasonal temperature changes.

Advance in the sulfur-based electron donor autotrophic denitrification for nitrate nitrogen removal from wastewater

In the field of wastewater treatment, nitrate nitrogen (NO3--N) is one of the significant contaminants of concern. Sulfur autotrophic denitrification technology, which uses a variety of sulfur-based electron donors to reduce NO3--N to nitrogen (N2) through sulfur autotrophic denitrification bacteria, has emerged as a novel nitrogen removal technology to replace heterotrophic denitrification in the field of wastewater treatment due to its low cost, environmental friendliness, and high nitrogen removal efficiency. This paper reviews the advance of reduced sulfur compounds (such as elemental sulfur, sulfide, and thiosulfate) and iron sulfides (such as ferrous sulfide, pyrrhotite, and pyrite) electron donors for treating NO3--N in wastewater by sulfur autotrophic denitrification technology, including the dominant bacteria types and the sulfur autotrophic denitrification process based on various electron donors are introduced in detail, and their operating costs, nitrogen removal performance and impacts on the ecological environment are analyzed and compared. Moreover, the engineering applications of sulfur-based electron donor autotrophic denitrification technology were comprehensively summarized. According to the literature review, the focus of future industry research were discussed from several aspects as well, which would provide ideas for the application and optimization of the sulfur autotrophic denitrification process for deep and efficient removal of NO3--N in wastewater.

Metabolic versatility enables sulfur-oxidizers to dominate primary production in groundwater

High rates of CO2 fixation and the genetic potential of various groundwater microbes for autotrophic activity have shown that primary production is an important source of organic C in groundwater ecosystems. However, the contribution of specific chemolithoautotrophic groups such as S-oxidizing bacteria (SOB) to groundwater primary production and their adaptation strategies remain largely unknown. Here, we stimulated anoxic groundwater microcosms with reduced S and sampled the microbial community after 1, 3 and 6 weeks. Genome-resolved metaproteomics was combined with 50at-% 13CO2 stable isotope probing to follow the C flux through the microbial food web and infer traits expressed by active SOB in the groundwater microcosms. Already after 7 days, 90% of the total microbial biomass C in the microcosms was replaced by CO2-derived C, increasing to 97% at the end of incubation. Stable Isotope Cluster Analysis revealed active autotrophs, characterized by a uniform 13C-incorporation of 45% in their peptides, to dominate the microbial community throughout incubation. Mixo- and heterotrophs, characterized by 10 to 40% 13C-incorporation, utilized the primarily produced organic C. Interestingly, obligate autotrophs affiliated with Sulfuricella and Sulfuritalea contained traits enabling the storage of elemental S in globules to maintain primary production under energy limitation. Others related to Sulfurimonas seemed to rapidly utilize substrates for fast proliferation, and most autotrophs further maximized their energy yield via efficient denitrification and the potential for H2 oxidation. Mixotrophic SOB, belonging to Curvibacter or Polaromonas, enhanced metabolic flexibility by using organic compounds to satisfy their C requirements. Time series data spanning eight years further revealed that key taxa of our microcosms composed up to 15% of the microbial groundwater community, demonstrating their in-situ importance. This showed that SOB, by using different metabolic strategies, are able to account for high rates of primary production in groundwater, especially at sites limited to geogenic nutrient sources. The widespread presence of SOB with traits such as S storage, H2 oxidation, and organic C utilization in many aquatic habitats further suggested that metabolic versatility governs S-fueled primary production in the environment.

Autotrophic denitrification supported by sphalerite and oyster shells: Chemical and microbiome analysis

This research evaluated the metal-sulfide mineral, sphalerite, as an electron donor for autotrophic denitrification, with and without oyster shells (OS). Batch reactors containing sphalerite simultaneously removed NO₃^- and PO₄^3- from groundwater. OS addition minimized NO₂^- accumulation and removed 100% PO₄^3- in approximately half the time compared with sphalerite alone. Further investigation using domestic wastewater revealed that sphalerite and OS removed NO₃^- at a rate of 0.76 ± 0.36 mg NO₃^--N/(L · d), while maintaining consistent PO₄^3- removal (∼97%) over 140 days. Increasing the sphalerite and OS dose did not improve the denitrification rate. 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing indicated that sulfur-oxidizing species of Chromatiales, Burkholderiales, and Thiobacillus played a role in N removal during sphalerite autotrophic denitrification. This study provides a comprehensive understanding of N removal during sphalerite autotrophic denitrification, which was previously unknown. Knowledge from this work could be used to develop novel technologies for addressing nutrient pollution.

Performance of sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification process for nitrate removal from permeate of an MBR treating textile wastewater and concentrate of a real scale reverse osmosis process

Textile is one of the industrial sectors generating the highest amount of wastewater with various polluting substances. Lately, water reuse in textile industries, especially, with the reverse osmosis (RO) process following membrane bioreactor (MBR) treatment has been applied more commonly. In this study, an autotrophic sulfur-based denitrifying column performance was evaluated, for the first time, for nitrate reduction from permeate of a lab-scale MBR receiving real textile wastewater and from the concentrate stream of a real scale-RO plant used for recovering water from textile wastewater. Nitrate concentration in the MBR effluent and RO concentrate averaged 35 ± 3 and 12 ± 2 mg-N/L, respectively. With the sulfur-based column bioreactor, quite high (≥90%) denitrification performances were attained both for MBR effluent and RO concentrate up to nitrate loadings of 0.432 and 0.12 g-N/(L.d), respectively. COD present in wastewater was not utilized in the column bioreactor, which illustrates no or minimal contribution of heterotrophic denitrification. Alkalinity concentration in the wastewater was enough to buffer the acid formation during autotrophic denitrification. Sulfate was generated accompanied by nitrate reduction and sulfide was formed at low nitrate loadings. In the batch tests, the denitrification rates for the MBR effluent and RO concentrate were 0.31 and 0.28 g-N/(g-VSS.d), respectively, which were relatively higher than the ones observed for the synthetic nitrate-contaminated groundwater. Autotrophic sulfur-based denitrification is a promising and robust process alternative even for textile RO concentrate with high concentrations of salinity, non-biodegradable COD, and color.

Iron mediated autotrophic denitrification for low C/N ratio wastewater: A review

In recent years, iron mediated autotrophic denitrification has been a concern because it overcomes the absence of organic carbon and has been successfully used in denitrification for low C/N ratio wastewater. However, there is currently a lack of a more systematic summary of iron-based materials that can be used for denitrification, and no detailed overview about the mechanism of iron mediated autotrophic denitrification has been reported. In this study, the iron materials with different valence states that can be used for denitrification were summarized, and emphasized, as well as the mechanism in different interaction systems were emphasize. In addition, the contribution of various microorganisms in nitrate reduction were analyzed and the effects of operating conditions and water quality were evaluated. Finally, the challenges and shortcomings of the denitrification process were discussed aiming to find better practical engineering applications of iron-based denitrification.

Electrochemical Reduction of Nitrate with Simultaneous Ammonia Recovery Using a Flow Cathode Reactor

The presence of excessive concentrations of nitrate in industrial wastewaters, agricultural runoff, and some groundwaters constitutes a serious issue for both environmental and human health. As a result, there is considerable interest in the possibility of converting nitrate to the valuable product ammonia by electrochemical means. In this work, we demonstrate the efficacy of a novel flow cathode system coupled with ammonia stripping for effective nitrate removal and ammonia generation and recovery. A copper-loaded activated carbon slurry (Cu@AC), made by a simple, low-cost wet impregnation method, is used as the flow cathode in this novel electrochemical reactor. Use of a 3 wt % Cu@AC suspension at an applied current density of 20 mA cm^-2 resulted in almost complete nitrate removal, with 97% of the nitrate reduced to ammonia and 70% of the ammonia recovered in the acid-receiving chamber. A mathematical kinetic model was developed that satisfactorily describes the kinetics and mechanism of the overall nitrate electroreduction process. Minimal loss of Cu to solution and maintenance of nitrate removal performance over extended use of Cu@AC flow electrode augers well for long-term use of this technology. Overall, this study sheds light on an efficient, low-cost water treatment technology for simultaneous nitrate removal and ammonia generation and recovery.

Perspective on inorganic electron donor-mediated biological denitrification process for low C/N wastewaters

Nitrate is the most common water environmental pollutant in the world. Inorganic electron donor-mediated denitrification is a typical process with significant advantages in treating low carbon-nitrogen ratio water and wastewater and has attracted extensive research attention. This review summarizes the denitrification processes using inorganic substances, including hydrogen, reductive sulfur compounds, zero-valent iron, and iron oxides, ammonium nitrogen, and other reductive heavy metal ions as electron donors. Aspects on the functional microorganisms, critical metabolic pathways, limiting factors and mathematical modeling are outlined. Also, the typical inorganic electron donor-mediated denitrification processes and their mechanism, the available microorganisms, process enhancing approaches and the engineering potentials, are compared and discussed. Finally, the prospects of developing the next generation inorganic electron donor-mediated denitrification process is put forward.

Effect of electric current intensity on performance of polycaprolactone/FeS2-based mixotrophic biofilm-electrode reactor

In this study, a bioelectrochemical system consisting of pyrite-based autotrophic denitrification (PAD) and heterotrophic denitrification (HD) was established to polish nitrate wastewater. The loading of electric current (EC) could stimulate the dissolution of pyrite. Appropriate EC (I ≤ 30 mA) was conducive to nitrate removal, too high EC (I = 40 mA) would inhibit nitrate removal and lead to an obvious accumulation of NO₂^--N and NH₄⁺-N. Microbial analysis revealed that the increase of EC could inhibit the diversity of heterotrophic microbes, but appropriate EC (I = 10 mA) could increase the diversity of autotrophic microbes. The EC loading was conducive to the enrichment of iron autotrophic denitrifiers (Ferritrophicum), pyrite-oxidizing bacteria (Thiobacillus, Sulfurimonas), and sulfur autotrophic denitrifiers (Dechloromonas, Thiobacillus, and Arenimonas). The EC loading enlarged the contribution of PAD, making PAD a dominant pathway in denitrification.

Pyrite-Based Autotrophic Denitrifying Microorganisms Derived from Paddy Soils: Effects of Organic Co-Substrate Addition

The presence of organic co-substrate in groundwater and soils is inevitable, and much remains to be learned about the roles of organic co-substrates during pyrite-based denitrification. Herein, an organic co-substrate (acetate) was added to a pyrite-based denitrification system, and the impact of the organic co-substrate on the performance and bacterial community of pyrite-based denitrification processes was evaluated. The addition of organic co-substrate at concentrations higher than 48 mg L^-1 inhibited pyrite-based autotrophic denitrification, as no sulfate was produced in treatments with high organic co-substrate addition. In contrast, both competition and promotion effects on pyrite-based autotrophic denitrification occurred with organic co-substrate addition at concentrations of 24 and 48 mg L^-1. The subsequent validation experiments suggested that competition had a greater influence than promotion when organic co-substrate was added, even at a low concentration. Thiobacillus, a common chemolithoautotrophic sulfur-oxidizing denitrifier, dominated the system with a relative abundance of 13.04% when pyrite served as the sole electron donor. With the addition of organic co-substrate, Pseudomonas became the dominant genus, with 60.82%, 61.34%, 70.37%, 73.44%, and 35.46% abundance at organic matter concentrations of 24, 48, 120, 240, and 480 mg L^-1, respectively. These findings provide an important theoretical basis for the cultivation of pyrite-based autotrophic denitrifying microorganisms for nitrate removal in soils and groundwater.

Extracellular DNA plays a key role in the structural stability of sulfide-based denitrifying biofilms

Sulfide-based biofilm processes are increasingly used for wastewater denitrification, yet little is known about the extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) composition of sulfide-oxidizing biofilms. This can have an important impact on biofilm mechanical strength and stability. In this research, the properties and roles of EPS components in biofilm stability were investigated. Weak biofilm stability characterized by high roughness and numerous "needle" structures was visualized by optical coherence tomography (OCT) and microscopy. A high abundance of extracellular DNA (eDNA) and a low protein to polysaccharide ratio were found in the biofilm. The roles of eDNA, protein and polysaccharide in biofilm cohesion and adhesion were identified through enzyme treatment and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The enzymatic hydrolysis of eDNA increased the elastic modulus of biofilms by 57 times and reduced the adhesion energy by 96%. The hydrolysis of proteins led to an increase of elastic modulus by 27 times and a loss of adhesion energy by 95.5%. The enzymatic hydrolysis of polysaccharides caused minimal changes in elastic modulus and adhesion energy. These results suggest that eDNA was the key EPS component for biofilm cohesion and adhesion, possibly because it provided special binding sites and can form strong cross-linking with magnesium or other multivalent cations. This study provided new insights into the role of eDNA in biofilm stability and shed light on the development of sulfide-based denitrifying biofilms.

Assessing Intermediate Formation and Electron Competition during Thiosulfate-Driven Denitrification: An Experimental and Modeling Study

There is increasing interest in thiosulfate-driven denitrification for low C/N wastewater treatment, but the denitrification performance varies with the thiosulfate oxidation pathways. Models have been developed to predict the products of denitrification, but few consider thiosulfate reduction to elemental sulfur (S⁰), an undesirable reaction that can intensify electron competition with denitrifying enzymes. In this study, the model using indirect coupling of electrons (ICE) was developed to predict S⁰ formation and electron competition during thiosulfate-driven denitrification. Kinetic data were obtained from sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (SOB) dominated by the branched pathway and were used to calibrate and validate the model. Electron competition was investigated under different operating conditions. Modeling results reveal that electrons produced in the first step of thiosulfate oxidation typically prioritize thiosulfate reduction, then nitrate reduction, and finally nitrite reduction. However, the electron consumption rate for S⁰ formation decreases sharply with the decline of thiosulfate concentration. Thus, a continuous feeding strategy was effective in alleviating the competition between thiosulfate reduction and denitrifying enzymes. Electron competition leads to nitrite accumulation, which could be a reliable substrate for anammox. The model was further evaluated with anammox integration. Results suggested that the branched pathway and continuous supply of thiosulfate are favorable to create a symbiotic relationship between SOB and anammox.

Effect of sulfur sources on the competition between denitrification and DNRA

The fate of nitrogen is controlled by the competition between nitrate reduction pathways. Denitrification removes nitrogen in the system to the atmosphere, whereas dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonia (DNRA) retains nitrate in the form of ammonia. Different microbes specialize in the oxidation of different electron donors, thus electron donors might influence the outcomes of the competition. Here, we investigated the fate of nitrate with five forms of sulfur as electron donors. Chemoautotrophic nitrate reduction did not continue after the passages of the enrichments with sulfide, sulfite and pyrite. Nitrate reduction rate was the highest in the enrichment with thiosulfate. Denitrification was stimulated and no DNRA was observed with thiosulfate, while both denitrification and DNRA were stimulated with elemental sulfur. Metagenomes of the enrichments were assembled and binned into ten genomes. The enriched populations with thiosulfate included Thiobacillus, Lentimicrobium, Sulfurovum and Hydrogenophaga, all of which contained genes involved in sulfur oxidation. Elemental sulfur-based DNRA was performed by Thiobacillus (with NrfA and NirB) and Nocardioides (with only NirB). Our study established a link between sulfur sources, nitrate reduction pathways and microbial populations.

A new inoculation method of sulfur autotrophic denitrification reactor for accelerated start-up and better low-temperature adaption

Elemental sulfur (S⁰) autotrophic denitrification (SAD) has been proved feasible for nitrate removal from aquatic environments. The long start-up period up to weeks of the SAD reactor impedes its industrial application. To accelerate the start-up process, this study employed S⁰ powder packed sequencing batch reactor operated for 10 days to obtain a seed biofilm, which was inoculated into a regular S⁰ flake packed bed reactor afterwards. Merely two days after inoculation, the reactor inoculated with seed biofilm was well started up and outperformed the control reactor, which was inoculated with regular anaerobic sludge and operated for more than 10 days, delivering much increased denitrification rate of 126 ± 0.68 mg N/(L·d) and a high nitrate removal efficiency of 93.0%. Batch tests during the start-up period showed that the seed biofilm developed well on S⁰ flakes and delivered improved nitrate removal performance than the control. Extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) analysis revealed an abundant content of protein in tightly bound EPS in the biofilm developed from the seed biofilm, which was recognized as a major contributor to facilitate the biofilm's attachment and growth onto S⁰ flakes. After operating under moderate temperature, the reactors were tested at a reduced temperature of 15 °C. Results indicated that the reactor inoculated with seed biofilm showed stronger adaptation ability towards low temperature and sustained better denitrification performance than the control, which was attributed to increased protein content in tightly bound EPS produced by the microbes against low-temperature. Determination of the microbial communities in tested reactors when the whole experiment was closing found that sulfur-related genera were dominating in the packed-bed reactor inculcated with seed biofilm, which played an important role in the S⁰-based denitrification process.

Modelling the effect of SMP production and external carbon addition on S-driven autotrophic denitrification

The aim of this study was to develop a mathematical model to assess the effect of soluble microbial products production and external carbon source addition on the performance of a sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification (SdAD) process. During SdAD, the growth of autotrophic biomass (AUT) was accompanied by the proliferation of heterotrophic biomass mainly consisting of heterotrophic denitrifiers (HD) and sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB), which are able to grow on both the SMP derived from the microbial activities and on an external carbon source. The process was supposed to occur in a sequencing batch reactor to investigate the effects of the COD injection on both heterotrophic species and to enhance the production and consumption of SMP. The mathematical model was built on mass balance considerations and consists of a system of nonlinear impulsive differential equations, which have been solved numerically. Different simulation scenarios have been investigated by varying the main operational parameters: cycle duration, day of COD injection and quantity of COD injected. For cycle durations of more than 15 days and a COD injection after the half-cycle duration, SdAD represents the prevailing process and the SRB represent the main heterotrophic family. For shorter cycle duration and COD injections earlier than the middle of the cycle, the same performance can be achieved increasing the quantity of COD added, which results in an increased activity of HD. In all the performed simulation even in the case of COD addition, AUT remain the prevailing microbial family in the reactor.

Advances in elemental sulfur-driven bioprocesses for wastewater treatment: From metabolic study to application

Elemental sulfur (S0) is known to be an abundant, non-toxic material with a wide range of redox states (-2 to +6) and may serve as an excellent electron carrier in wastewater treatment. In turn, S0-driven bioprocesses, which employ S0 as electron donor or acceptor, have recently established themselves as cost-effective therefore attractive solutions for wastewater treatment. Numerous related processes have, to date, been developed from laboratory experiments into full-scale applications, including S0-driven autotrophic denitrification for nitrate removal and S0-reducing organic removal. Compared to the conventional activated sludge process, these bioprocesses require only a small amount of organic matter and produce very little sludge. There have been great efforts to characterize chemical and biogenic S0 and related functional microorganisms in order to identify the biochemical pathways, upgrade the bioprocesses, and assess the impact of the operating factors on process performance, ultimately aiming to better understand and to optimize the processes. This paper is therefore a comprehensive overview of emerging S0-driven biotechnologies, including the development of S0-driven autotrophic denitrification and S0-based sulfidogenesis, as well as the associated microbiology and biochemistry. Also reviewed here are the physicochemical characteristics of S0 and the effects that environmental factors such as pH, influent sulfur/nitrate ratio, temperature, S0 particle size and reactor configurations have on the process. Research gaps, challenges of process applications and potential areas for future research are further proposed and discussed.

Alkalinity regulation in a sulfur autotrophic denitrifying filter substantially reduced total dissolved solids and sulfate in effluent

Sulfur autotrophic denitrification (SAD) filters are considered a promising technology due to their stable and excellent performance in nitrogen removal, affordable costs, and operational advantages. In this work, a novel operational strategy that employed sodium bicarbonate as an alkalinity source in the autotrophic denitrification filter (S-SAD) was established. With the sufficient supply of alkalinity, the S-SAD reached an excellent denitrification performance (98.01%±0.43%) with a nitrate concentration of 10 mg/L in influent and hydraulic retention time of 3 hrs. The total dissolved solids increment and sulfate concentration in effluent were significantly reduced by one-third, compared with that of the traditional SAD process under the same conditions. The analysis of microbial community indicated that Thiobacilhus, typical species with the functions of simultaneous sulfur oxidation and denitrification, was evidently enriched in the S-SAD. Thus, this present work demonstrated a feasible, relatively cost-effective and environmentally friendly approach to operate SAD towards further application.

A critical review of existing mechanisms and strategies to enhance N2 selectivity in groundwater nitrate reduction

The pollution of nitrate (NO3-) in groundwater has become an environmental problem of general concern and requires immediate remediation because of adverse human and ecological impacts. NO3- removal from groundwater is conducted mainly by chemical, biological, and coupled methods, with the removal efficiency of NO3- considered the sole performance indicator. However, in addition to the harmless form of N2, the reduced NO3- could be transformed into other intermediates, such as nitrite (NO2-), nitrous oxide (N2O), and ammonia (NH4+), which may have direct or indirect negative impacts on the environment. Therefore, increasing N2 selectivity is a significant challenge in reducing NO3- in groundwater, which seriously impedes the large-scale implementation of available remediation technologies. In this work, we comprehensively overview the most recent advances in N2 selectivity regarding the understanding of emerging groundwater NO3- removal technologies. Mechanisms of by-product production and strategies to enhance the selective reduction of NO3- to N2 are discussed in detail. Furthermore, we proposed topics for further research and hope that the total environmental impacts of remediation schemes should be evaluated comprehensively by quantifying all potential intermediate products, and promising strategies should be further developed to enhance N2 selectivity, to improve the feasibility of related technologies in actual remediation.

Biofilm carrier type affects biogenic sulfur-driven denitrification performance and microbial community dynamics in moving-bed biofilm reactors

Autotrophic denitrification with biosulfur (ADBIOS) provides a sustainable technological solution for biological nitrogen removal from wastewater driven by biogenic S⁰, derived from biogas desulfurization. In this study, the effect of different biofilm carriers (conventional AnoxK™ 1 and Z-200 with a pre-defined maximum biofilm thickness) on ADBIOS performance and microbiomics was investigated in duplicate moving bed-biofilm reactors (MBBRs). The MBBRs were operated parallelly in continuous mode for 309 days, whilst gradually decreasing the hydraulic retention time (HRT) from 72 to 21 h, and biosulfur was either pumped in suspension (days 92-223) or supplied in powder form. Highest nitrate removal rates were approximately 225 (±11) mg/L·d and 180 (±7) mg NO₃^--N/L·d in the MBBRs operated with K1 and Z-200 carriers, respectively. Despite having the same protected surface area for biofilm development in each MBBR, the biomass attached onto the K1 carrier was 4.8-fold more than that on the Z-200 carrier, with part of the biogenic S⁰ kept in the biofilm. The microbial communities of K1 and Z-200 biofilms could also be considered similar at cDNA level in terms of abundance (R = 0.953 with p = 0.042). A relatively stable microbial community was formed on K1 carriers, while the active portion of the microbial community varied significantly over time in the MBBRs using Z-200 carriers.

Exploration and verification of the feasibility of the sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification integrated biomass-based heterotrophic denitrification systems for wastewater treatment: From feasibility to application

The sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification (SAD) and the solid organic carbon-based denitrification processes are both efficient techniques to remove nitrate from wastewater, and the hydrogen ions generated by the SAD process would be consumed in the heterotrophic denitrification process. Therefore, it is possible to improve the denitrification capacity when the solid organic carbon was added into a SAD reactor. In this study, corncob powder and sawdust powder were selected as solid organic carbon sources, and the sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification integrated biomass-based heterotrophic denitrification system was formed (SBD). The laboratory and field experiments showed that SBD could shorten the start-up period, decrease the sulfate productivity, and maintain a good denitrification performance when treated wastewater. According to the field experiment results, when the HRT was 1 h, the effluent total nitrogen (TN) concentration was always lower than 15 mg L^-1. In addition, nitrite inhibition was observed when the concentration of nitrite in the reactors reached above 30 mg L^-1. The mixture of elemental sulfur powder, shell powder, corncob powder, and sawdust powder with a mass ratio of 6:2:1:1 was the optimal filter for the SBD system, with an average nitrate reduction rate (NAR) of 420 mg NO₃^-N·L^-1·d^-1 obtained at the end of the study. During the whole operation, the major autotrophs in the SBD systems were Thermomonas, Ferritrophicum, and Thiobacillus, while the major heterotrophs were Saprospiraceae, Ferruginibacter, Dokdonella, and Simplicispira. Overall, the SBD system was a feasible and practically favorable way to remove nitrate from wastewater.

Increase of N2O production during nitrate reduction after long-term sulfide addition in lake sediment microcosms

Microbial denitrification is a main source of nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions which have strong greenhouse effect and destroy stratospheric ozone. Though the importance of sulfide driven chemoautotrophic denitrification has been recognized, its contribution to N₂O emissions in nature remains elusive. We built up long-term sulfide-added microcosms with sediments from two freshwater lakes. Chemistry analysis confirmed sulfide could drive nitrate respiration in long term. N₂O accumulated to over 1.5% of nitrate load in both microcosms after long-term sulfide addition, which was up to 12.9 times higher than N₂O accumulation without sulfide addition. Metagenomes were extracted and sequenced during microcosm incubations. 16 S rRNA genes of Thiobacillus and Defluviimonas were gradually enriched. The nitric oxide reductase with c-type cytochromes as electron donors (cNorB) increased in abundance, while the nitric oxide reductase receiving electrons from quinols (qNorB) decreased in abundance. cnorB genes similar to Thiobacillus were enriched in both microcosms. In parallel, enrichment was observed for enzymes involved in sulfur oxidation, which supplied electrons to nitrate respiration, and enzymes involved in Calvin Cycle, which sustained autotrophic cell growth, implying the coupling relationship between carbon, nitrogen and sulfur cycling processes. Our results suggested sulfur pollution considerably increased N₂O emissions in natural environments.

Various electron donors for biological nitrate removal: A review

Nitrate (NO₃^-) pollution in water and wastewater has become a serious global issue. Biological denitrification, which reduces NO₃^- to N₂ (nitrogen gas) by denitrifying microorganisms, is an efficient and economical process for the removal of NO₃^- from water and wastewater. During the denitrification process, electron donor is required to provide electrons for reduction of NO₃^-. A variety of electron donors, including organic and inorganic compounds, can be used for denitrification. This paper reviews the state of the art of various electron donors used for biological denitrification. Depending on the types of electron donors, denitrification can be classified into heterotrophic and autotrophic denitrification. Heterotrophic denitrification utilizes organic compounds as electron donors, including low-molecular-weight organics (e.g. acetate, methanol, glucose, benzene, methane, etc.) and high-molecular-weight organics (e.g. cellulose, polylactic acid, polycaprolactone, etc.); while autotrophic denitrification utilizes inorganic compounds as electron donors, including hydrogen (H₂), reduced sulfur compounds (e.g. sulfide, element sulfur and thiosulfate), ferrous iron (Fe²⁺), iron sulfides (e.g. FeS, Fe_1-xS and FeS₂), arsenite (As(Ш)) and manganese (Mn(II)). The biological denitrification processes and the representative denitrifying microorganisms are summarized based on different electron donors, and their denitrification performance, operating costs and environmental impacts are compared and discussed. The pilot- or full-scale applications were summarized. The concluding remarks and future prospects were provided. The biodegradable polymers mediated heterotrophic denitrification, as well as H₂ and sulfur mediated autotrophic denitrification are promising denitrification processes for NO₃^- removal from various types of water and wastewater.

Sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification of nitric oxide for efficient nitrous oxide recovery

Nitrous oxide (N₂ O) was previously deemed as a potent greenhouse gas but is actually an untapped energy source, which can accumulate during the microbial denitrification of nitric oxide (NO). Compared with the organic electron donor required in heterotrophic denitrification, elemental sulfur (S⁰ ) is a promising electron donor alternative due to its cheap cost and low biomass yield in sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification. However, no effort has been made to test N₂ O recovery from sulfur-driven denitrification of NO so far. Therefore, in this study, batch and continuous experiments were carried out to investigate the NO removal performance and N₂ O recovery potential via sulfur-driven NO-based denitrification under various Fe(II)EDTA-NO concentrations. Efficient energy recovery was achieved, as up to 35.5%-40.9% of NO was converted to N₂ O under various NO concentrations. N₂ O recovery from Fe(II)EDTA-NO could be enhanced by the low bioavailability of sulfur and the acid environment caused by sulfur oxidation. The NO reductase (NOR) and N₂ O reductase (N₂ OR) were inhibited distinctively at relatively low NO levels, leading to efficient N₂ O accumulation, but were suppressed irreversibly at NO level beyond 15 mM in continuous experiments. Such results indicated that the regulation of NO at a relatively low level would benefit the system stability and NO removal capacity during long-term system operation. The continuous operation of the sulfur-driven Fe(II)EDTA-NO-based denitrification reduced the overall microbial diversity but enriched several key microbial community. Thauera, Thermomonas, and Arenimonas that are able to carry out sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification became the dominant organisms with their relative abundance increased from 25.8% to 68.3%, collectively.

Metagenomic analysis revealed the sulfur- and iron- oxidation capabilities of heterotrophic denitrifying sludge

Heterotrophic denitrification is widely applied in wastewater treatment processes to remove nitrate. However, the ability of the heterotrophic denitrifying sludge to use inorganic matter as electron donors to perform autotrophic denitrification has rarely been investigated. In this study, we enriched heterotrophic denitrifying sludge and demonstrated its sulfur- and iron- oxidizing abilities and denitrification performance with batch experiments. Based on high-throughput sequencing of 16S rRNA genes, high diversity and abundance of sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (SOB) (e.g., Sulfuritalea, Thiobacillus, and Thiothrix) and iron (II)-oxidizing bacteria (FeOB) (e.g., Azospira and Thiobacillus) were observed. Metagenomic sequencing and genome binning results further suggested that the SOB in the heterotrophic denitrifying sludge were mainly Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria instead of Gammaproteobacteria and Epsilonproteobacteria. The similarities of potential iron-oxidizing genes with known sequences were very low (32-51%), indicating potentially novel FeOB species in this system. The findings of this study suggested that the heterotrophic denitrifying sludge harbors diverse mixotrophic denitrifying bacterial species, and based on this finding, we proposed that organic carbon and inorganic electron donors (e.g., sulfur, thiosulfate, and iron) could be jointly used in engineering practices according to the quality and quantity of wastewater to balance the cost and efficiency of the denitrification process.

Elemental sulfur as electron donor and/or acceptor: Mechanisms, applications and perspectives for biological water and wastewater treatment

Biochemical oxidation and reduction are the principle of biological water and wastewater treatment, in which electron donor and/or acceptor shall be provided. Elemental sulfur (S⁰) as a non-toxic and easily available material with low price, possesses both reductive and oxidative characteristics, suggesting that it is a suitable material for water and wastewater treatment. Recent advanced understanding of S⁰-respiring microorganisms and their metabolism further stimulated the development of S⁰-based technologies. As such, S⁰-based biotechnologies have emerged as cost-effective and attractive alternatives to conventional biological methods for water and wastewater treatment. For instance, S⁰-driven autotrophic denitrification substantially lower the operational cost for nitrogen removal from water and wastewater, compared to the conventional process with exogenous carbon source supplementation. The introduction of S⁰ can also avoid secondary pollution commonly caused by overdose of organic carbon. S⁰ reduction processes cost-effectively mineralize organic matter with low sludge production. Biological sulfide production using S⁰ as electron acceptor is also an attractive technology for metal-laden wastewater treatment, e.g. acid mine drainage. This paper outlines an overview of the fundamentals, characteristics and advances of the S⁰-based biotechnologies and highlights the functional S⁰-related microorganisms. In particular, the mechanisms of microorganisms accessing insoluble S⁰ and feasibility to improve S⁰ bio-utilization efficiency are critically discussed. Additionally, the research knowledge gaps, current process limitations, and required further developments are identified and discussed.

Realization of nitrite accumulation in a sulfide-driven autotrophic denitrification process: Simultaneous nitrate and sulfur removal

The study was based on the removal of nitrate and sulfide, and aimed to nitrite accumulation. The process of autotrophic denitrification driven by sulfide as an electron donor was investigated in a sequencing batch reactor. The research showed that autotrophic denitrification successfully started on day 22, and the removal rates of NO₃^--N and S^2--S were 95.8% and 100%, respectively, when the S/N molar ratio was 1.45. When the S/N ratio was reduced to 0.94, the phenomenon of NO₂^--N accumulation was observed. NO₂^--N continuously accumulated, and the maximum accumulation rate was 55.3% when the S/N ratio was 0.8. In the batch test, the study showed that NO₂^--N accumulation was optimal when the S/N ratio was 0.8, and the NO₂^--N concentration increased with increasing NO₃^--N concentration at the same S/N ratio. Microbial communities also changed based on the high-throughput analysis, and Proteobacteria (59.5%-84%) was the main phylum. Arenimonas (11.4%-28.2%) and uncultured_f_ Chromatiaceae (5.7%-27.5%) were the dominant bacteria, which complete denitrification and desulfurization throughout the operating system. Therefore, this study provided a theoretical basis for the simultaneous removal of NO₃^--N and S^2--S, as well as the accumulation of nitrite, and provided material support for anaerobic ammonia oxidation technology.

Sulfur autotrophic denitrification filter and heterotrophic denitrification filter: Comparison on denitrification performance, hydrodynamic characteristics and operating cost

Sulfur autotrophic denitrification (SAD) process, as an alternative to heterotrophic denitrification (HD) filter, receives growing interest in polishing the effluent from secondary sewage treatment. Although individual studies have indicated several advantages of SAD over HD, rare study has compared these two systems under identical condition and by using real secondary effluent. In this study, two small pilot scale filters (SAD and HD) were designed with identical configuration and operated parallelly by feeding the real secondary effluent from a WWTP. The results showed SAD filter can be started up without the addition of soluble electron donor, although the time (14 days) was about 3 times longer than that of HD filter. The nitrate removal rate of SAD filter at HRT of 1.4 h was measured as 0.268 ± 0.047 kg N/(m³∙d). Similar value was observed in HD filter with supplementing 90 mg/L COD. The COD concentration of effluent always kept lower than that of influent in SAD filter but not in HD filter. In addition, SAD filter could maintain a stable denitrification performance without backwash for 15 days, while decline of nitrate removal rate was observed in HD filter just 2 days after stopping the backwash. This different behavior was further confirmed as the SAD filter had a better hydraulic flow pattern. Analysis according to high-throughput 16S rRNA gene-based Illumina MiSeq sequencing clearly showed the microbial community evolution and differentiation among the samples of seed sludge, SAD and HD filters. Finally, the economic assessment was carried out, showing the operation cost of SAD filter was over 50% lower than that of HD filter.

Autotrophic denitrification in constructed wetlands: Achievements and challenges

The use of constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment is rapidly increasing worldwide due to their advantages of low operating and maintenance costs. Denitrification in constructed wetlands is dependent on the presence of organic carbon sources, and the shortage of organic carbon is the primary hurdle for nitrate removal. Therefore, the use of inorganic electronic donors has emerged as an alternative. This paper provides a comprehensive review of nitrate removal pathways using various inorganic electron donors and the performance and development of autotrophic denitrification in constructed wetlands. The main environmental parameters and operating conditions for nitrate removal in wetlands are discussed, and the challenges currently faced in the application of enhanced autotrophic denitrification wetlands are emphasized. Overall, this review illustrates the need for a deep understanding of the complex interrelationships among environmental and operational parameters and wetland substrates for improving the wastewater treatment performance of constructed wetlands.

Effect of influent feeding pattern on municipal tailwater treatment during a sulfur-based denitrification constructed wetland

This work studied three parallel pilot-scale constructed wetlands based on sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification (SAD-CWs) with horizontal, vertical-horizontal and integrated vertical inflow for nitrogen removal of municipal tailwater. SAD system played the predominant role for nitrate removal and the integrated vertical inflow pattern was the most efficient pattern with 96.1% NO₃^--N and 44.3% total phosphorus (TP) removal efficiency, respectively, at the condition of 3.5 h hydraulic retention time (HRT) and 18.5-23.5 °C. Although no great and serious change for microbial community structure was observed among these systems, the diversity in term of abundance of microbes and certain function species was observed. Proteobacteria, Ignavibacterae and Chloroflexi were the dominant phyla and accounted for over 59.1%, 7.5%, and 6.0% in SAD-CWs, respectively. Moreover, the richness and diversity of denitrifies in SAD-CWs with integrated vertical inflow were both higher than that in the other two reactors, especially sulfur autotrophic denitrifying bacteria.

Biological conversion of sulfamethoxazole in an autotrophic denitrification system

Sulfamethoxazole (SMX) is a common antibiotic prescribed for treating infections, which is frequently detected in the effluent of conventional wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Its degradation and conversion in a laboratory-scale sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification reactor were for the first time investigated through long-term reactor operation and short-term batch experiments. Co-metabolism of SMX and nitrate by autotrophic denitrifiers was observed in this study. The specific SMX removal rate was 3.7 ± 1.4 μg/g SS-d, which was higher than those reported in conventional wastewater treatment processes. The removal of SMX by the enriched denitrifying sludge was mainly attributed to biodegradation. Four transformation products (three known with structures and one with unknown structure) were identified, of which the structures of the two transformation products (TPs) were altered in the isoxazole ring. Additionally, the presence of SMX significantly shaped the microbial community structures, leading to the dominant denitrifier shifting from Sulfuritalea to Sulfurimonas to maintain the stability of system. Collectively, the sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification process could effectively remove SMX in addition to efficient nitrate removal, and further polish the effluent from conventional WWTPs.

Characterizing the biofilm stoichiometry and kinetics on the media in situ based on pulse-flow respirometer coupling with a new breathing reactor

Biofilm based systems and the hybrid between activated sludge and biofilms have been popularly applied for wastewater treatment. Unlike the suspended biomass, the biofilm concentration and kinetics on the media cannot be easily measured. In this study, a novel and easy-to-use approach has been developed based on pulse-flow respirometer to characterize the biofilm stoichiometry and kinetics in situ. With the new designed breathing reactor, the mutual interference between the magnetic stirring and biofilm media that happened in the conventional breathing reactor was solved. Moreover, Microsoft Excel based programs had been developed to fit the oxygen uptake rate curves with dynamic nonlinear regression. With this new approach, the yield coefficient, maximum oxidation capacity, and half-saturation constant of substrate for the heterotrophic biofilms in a fix bed reactor were determined to be 0.46 g-VSS/g-COD, 67.0 mg-COD/(h·L-media), and 4.4 mg-COD/L, respectively. Those parameters for biofilm ammonia oxidizers from a moving bed biofilm reactor were determined to be 0.17 g-VSS/g-N, 18.6 mg-N/(h·L-media), and 1.2 mg-N/L, respectively, and they were 0.11 g-VSS/g-N, 20.9 mg-N/(h·L-media), and 0.98 mg-N/L for nitrite oxidizers in the same biofilms. This study also found that the maximum specific substrate utilization rate for detached biofilms increased by 3.2 times, indicating that maintaining biofilm integrity was very important in the kinetic tests. Using this approach, the biofilm kinetics on the media can be regularly measured for treatment optimization.

A sulfur-based cyclic denitrification filter for marine recirculating aquaculture systems

Nitrogen removal from saline wastewater is challenging due to adverse effects of salinity on biological processes. A novel sulfur-autotrophic cyclic denitrification filter (CDF) was tested for marine recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) under varying conditions. Low ammonia, nitrite and sulfide concentrations were maintained at residence times between 4 and 12 h. After introduction of Poecilia sphenops, concentrations of NH₄⁺-N, NO₂^--N, NO₃^--N were maintained below 1, 1, and 60 mg/L, respectively. Fish waste inputs to the CDF contributed to mixotrophic denitrification and low sulfate production. A mass balance showed that 7% of the feed nitrogen was assimilated by fish, 6% was removed by passive denitrification (e.g., in anoxic zones in filters), 60% in the CDF and 27% was discharged during sampling and solids removal. Daily fresh water addition was <2% of fish tank volumes. The results are promising as a low cost alternative for saline wastewater denitrification.

Elemental sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification in stoichiometric S0/N ratio: Calibration and validation of a kinetic model

The inclusion of S⁰ hydrolysis in a kinetic model of autotrophic denitrification has been recently proposed; however the model has not been calibrated or validated yet. Thus, a new methodology was developed and applied to calibrate and validate this kinetic model for the first time. An inoculum adapted from a poultry wastewater treatment plant at stoichiometric S⁰/NO₃^- ratio was used. The model was calibrated with batch data (initial nitrate concentrations of 50 and 6.25 mg NO₃^--N/L) at an S⁰/N ratio = 2.29 mg S/mg N and validated with seven different batch data. The sensitivity analysis showed that the most sensitive parameters are related to S⁰ hydrolysis. The kinetic model was successfully calibrated with the new methodology and validated, with Theil inequality coefficient values lower than 0.21. Thus, the proposed model and methodology were proved to be well suited for the simulation of elemental sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification in batch systems.

Performance enhancement of H2S-based autotrophic denitrification with bio-gaseous CO2 as sole carbon source through new pH adjustment materials

H₂S-based denitrification could achieve synchronous removal of nitrate and H₂S and had been regarded as an efficient way for biogas desulfurization and wastewater denitrification. Using CO₂ in biogas as carbon source had a potential of saving cost further, but the performance deteriorated due to the drop in pH. Two kinds of nature ore, medical stone and phosphate ore, were added as new pH adjustment materials in this study, and feasibility of using CO₂ as sole carbon source for H₂S-based denitrification was investigated. As a result, both materials could increase the pH from 4.5 to above 6.0. Compared with medical stone, higher level of pH (up to 6.39) and nitrate removal efficiency (99.1%) were obtained with phosphate ore. In addition, ATP increased more rapidly than the control, reflecting improvement on microbial activities. Therefore, phosphate ore as the pH adjustment material could improve H₂S-based denitrification performance obviously.

Comparison of biogenic and chemical sulfur as electron donors for autotrophic denitrification in sulfur-fed membrane bioreactor (SMBR)

Two sulfur-oxidizing membrane bioreactors (SMBRs) performing autotrophic denitrification at different HRTs (6-26 h), one supplemented with biogenic elemental sulfur (S⁰_bio) and the other with chemically-synthesized elemental sulfur (S⁰_chem), were compared in terms of nitrate reduction rates, impact on membrane filtration and microbial community composition. Complete denitrification with higher rates (up to 286 mg N-NO₃^-/L d) was observed in the SMBR supplemented with S⁰_bio (SMBR_bio), while nitrate was never completely reduced in the SMBR fed with S⁰_chem (SMBR_chem). Trans membrane pressure was higher for SMBR_bio due to smaller particle size and colloidal properties of S⁰_bio. Microbial communities in the two SMBRs were similar and dominated by Proteobacteria, with Pleomorphomonas and Thermomonas being the most abundant genera in both bioreactors. This study reveals that S⁰_bio can be effectively used for nitrate removal in autotrophic denitrifying MBRs and results in higher nitrate reduction rates compared to S⁰_chem.

Denitrification with non-organic electron donor for treating low C/N ratio wastewaters

Denitrification with non-organic electron donors for treating low C/N ratio wastewater has attracted growing interests. Hydrogen, reduced sulfur compounds and ferrous ions are mainly used in autotrophic denitrification, holding promise for achieving practical applications. Recently, the development of autotrophic denitrification-based processes, such as bioelectrochemically-supported hydrogenotrophic denitrification and sulfur-/iron-based denitrification assisted multi-contaminant removal, provide opportunities for applying these processes in wastewater treatment. Exploration of the autotrophic denitrification process in terms of contaminant removal mechanism, interaction among functional microorganisms, and potential full-scale applications is thus of great importance. Here, an overview of the commonly used non-organic electron donors, e.g., hydrogen, reduced sulfur compounds and ferrous ions, in denitrification for treating low C/N ratio wastewater is provided. Also, the feasibility of applying the combined processes based on autotrophic denitrification with the compounds is discussed. Furthermore, challenges and future possibilities as well as concerns about the practical applications are envisaged in this review.

Efficient nitrogen removal in separate coupled-system of anammox and sulfur autotrophic denitrification with a nitrification side-branch under substrate fluctuation

In order to achieve efficient nitrogen removal, a separate coupled-system of anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) and sulfur autotrophic denitrification (S⁰-SADN) was established. In this study, the operational feasibility and stability of the coupled-system under substrate fluctuations were investigated. Results showed that the coupled-system improved the total nitrogen removal efficiency (TNRE) to 99.15 ± 0.68%. The tryptophan-like substances in anammox effluent positively impacted the growth of the S⁰-SADN biofilm. This positive cooperativity boosted the S⁰-SADN to achieve rapid 12-day startup and stable operation thereafter. The TNRE was determined at 95.27 ± 1.51% and 93.44 ± 0.96% under excessive nitrite and ammonium, respectively. The coupled-system recovered quickly after 21 days of starvation deterioration. To further treat the excessive ammonium, the nitrification side-branch of the coupled-system improved the TNRE to 99.08 ± 0.68%. Extracellular polymeric substances analysis revealed that the anammox and S⁰-SADN bacteria secreted protein-like substances to resist substrate fluctuation. Microbial community analysis indicated that the stability of bacterial community supported the stability of the coupled-system. These results collectively suggested that the separate coupled-system exhibited excellent performance and provided a platform for practical wastewater treatment in future.