Newborn screening for Tyr-I: two years' experience of the New York State program

Maleic acid is a biomarker for maleylacetoacetate isomerase deficiency; implications for newborn screening of tyrosinemia type 1

Dried blood spot succinylacetone (SA) is often used as a biomarker for newborn screening (NBS) for tyrosinemia type 1 (TT1). However, false-positive SA results are often observed. Elevated SA may also be due to maleylacetoacetate isomerase deficiency (MAAI-D), which appears to be clinically insignificant. This study investigated whether urine organic acid (uOA) and quantitative urine maleic acid (Q-uMA) analyses can distinguish between TT1 and MAAI-D. We reevaluated/measured uOA (GC-MS) and/or Q-uMA (LC-MS/MS) in available urine samples of nine referred newborns (2 TT1, 7 false-positive), eight genetically confirmed MAAI-D children, and 66 controls. Maleic acid was elevated in uOA of 5/7 false-positive newborns and in the three available samples of confirmed MAAI-D children, but not in TT1 patients. Q-uMA ranged from not detectable to 1.16 mmol/mol creatinine in controls (n = 66) and from 0.95 to 192.06 mmol/mol creatinine in false-positive newborns and MAAI-D children (n = 10). MAAI-D was genetically confirmed in 4/7 false-positive newborns, all with elevated Q-uMA, and rejected in the two newborns with normal Q-uMA. No sample was available for genetic analysis of the last false-positive infant with elevated Q-uMA. Our study shows that MAAI-D is a recognizable cause of false-positive TT1 NBS results. Elevated urine maleic acid excretion seems highly effective in discriminating MAAI-D from TT1.

Inter-laboratory analytical improvement of succinylacetone and nitisinone quantification from dried blood spot samples

BACKGROUND

Nitisinone is used to treat hereditary tyrosinemia type 1 (HT-1) by preventing accumulation of toxic metabolites, including succinylacetone (SA). Accurate quantification of SA during newborn screening is essential, as is quantification of both SA and nitisinone for disease monitoring and optimization of treatment. Analysis of dried blood spots (DBS) rather than plasma samples is a convenient method, but interlaboratory differences and comparability of DBS to serum/plasma may be issues to consider.

METHODS

Eight laboratories with experience in newborn screening and/or monitoring of patients with HT-1 across Europe participated in this study to assess variability and improve SA and nitisinone concentration measurements from DBS by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Quantification of nitisinone from both DBS and plasma was performed to assess sample comparability. In addition, efforts to harmonize laboratory procedures of SA and nitisinone quantifications during 5 rounds of analysis are described.

RESULTS

Nitisinone levels measured from DBS and plasma strongly correlated (R 2 = 0.93). Due to partitioning of nitisinone to the plasma, levels were higher in plasma by a factor of 2.34. In the initial assessment of laboratory performance, all had linear calibrations of SA and nitisinone although there was large inter-laboratory variability in actual concentration measurements. Subsequent analytical rounds demonstrated markedly improved spread and precision over previous rounds, an outcome confirmed in a final re-test round.

CONCLUSION

The study provides guidance for the determination of nitisinone and SA from DBS and the interpretation of results in the clinic. Inter-laboratory analytical harmonization was demonstrated through calibration improvements.

Comparison of a full systematic review versus rapid review approaches to assess a newborn screening test for tyrosinemia type 1

BACKGROUND

Rapid reviews are increasingly used to replace/complement systematic reviews to support evidence-based decision-making. Little is known about how this expedited process affects results.

OBJECTIVES

To assess differences between rapid and systematic review approaches for a case study of test accuracy of succinylacetone for detecting tyrosinemia type 1.

METHODS

Two reviewers conducted an "enhanced" rapid review then a systematic review. The enhanced rapid review involved narrower searches, a single reviewer checking 20% of titles/abstracts and data extraction, and quality assessment using an unadjusted QUADAS-2. Two reviewers performed the systematic review with a tailored QUADAS-2. Post hoc analysis examined rapid reviewing with a single reviewer (basic rapid review).

RESULTS

Ten papers were included. Basic rapid reviews would have missed 1 or 4 of these (dependent on which reviewer). Enhanced rapid and systematic reviews identified all 10 papers; one paper was only identified in the rapid review through reference checking. Two thousand one hundred seventy-six fewer title/abstracts and 129 fewer full texts were screened during the enhanced rapid review than the systematic review. The unadjusted QUADAS-2 generated more "unclear" ratings than the adjusted QUADAS-2 [29/70 (41.4%) versus 16/70 (22.9%)], and fewer "high" ratings [22/70 (31.4%) versus 42/70 (60.0%)]. Basic rapid reviews contained important inaccuracies in data extraction, which were detected by a second reviewer in the enhanced rapid and systematic reviews.

CONCLUSIONS

Enhanced rapid reviews with 20% checking by a second reviewer may be an appropriate tool for policymakers to expeditiously assess evidence. Basic rapid reviews (single reviewer) have higher risks of important inaccuracies and omissions.

Newborn screening for Tyrosinemia type 1 using succinylacetone - a systematic review of test accuracy

Background

Tyrosinemia type 1 is an autosomal recessive disorder of amino acid metabolism. Without treatment, death in childhood is common. Treatment with nitisinone and dietary restrictions are associated with improved outcomes; some studies suggest better outcomes when treatment begins at an asymptomatic stage. Newborn screening allows for earlier identification, but there is uncertainty regarding the test accuracy of the current method: succinylacetone measurement in dried blood spots using tandem mass spectrometry.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review of literature published up to January 2016. Two reviewers independently assessed titles, abstracts, full texts, and conducted quality appraisals. A single reviewer extracted data, which was checked by a second reviewer.

Results

Ten studies provided test accuracy data: five studies reporting screening experiences and five case–control studies. Sensitivity (29 cases in total) and specificity (34,403 controls in total) were 100% in the case–control studies, but could not be calculated in the studies reporting screening experiences due to a lack of follow-up of screen-negative babies. Positive predictive values in the screening experience studies ranged from 66.7% (2 true positive cases, 1 false positive case from ~500,000 people screened) to 100% (8 true positive cases from 856,671 people screened); negative predictive values could not be calculated. Positive and negative predictive values cannot be calculated from case–control studies.

Conclusions

Screening for Tyrosinemia type 1 using tandem mass spectrometry measurement of succinylacetone from dried blood spots appears to be promising. Confirmation of test accuracy data should be obtained from studies that include a two-year follow-up of individuals who screen negative.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13023-017-0599-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Outcome of children with hereditary tyrosinaemia following newborn screening

BACKGROUND

Nitisinone has transformed the management of hereditary tyrosinaemia type 1 (HT1). However, the risk of developing hepatocellular carcinoma is related to the age at which treatment is commenced. Little data on the outcome of children treated pre-emptively exist.

AIM

To describe the outcome of children with HT1 treated with nitisinone following selective newborn screening (NBS) and to compare their outcome with index siblings who had presented clinically.

SUBJECTS

12 children with HT1 were detected by NBS. Seven children were screened for HT1 because of an affected sibling (n=5). Four children were detected due to raised tyrosine concentrations on routine NBS and one child was born in a country with universal NBS for HT1.

OUTCOME

Nitisinone was commenced at 4 (1-52) days old. 6 children had an initial coagulopathy which resolved after 4 (1-7) days treatment. Currently at median age 8.5 (3-12.5) years all are clinically normal, with normal liver function tests and imaging. Those of school age are in normal classes but four have reported learning difficulties. Five index siblings presented clinically with acute liver failure (four) and chronic liver disease (one) at median 4 (1.5-17) months. One died of liver failure prior to nitisinone's availability. Four were treated with nitisinone; one failed to respond and underwent liver transplantation and three responded. One responder died from complications of prematurity and the remaining two have compensated liver disease.

SUMMARY

Children with HT1 treated with nitisinone following NBS have an excellent outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

Universal NBS for HT1 should be introduced in the UK.

Hereditary tyrosinemia type 1 in Turkey: twenty year single-center experience

BACKGROUND

Hereditary tyrosinemia type 1(HT1) is a chronic disorder leading to severe hepatic, renal and peripheral nerve damage if left untreated. Despite nitisinone treatment HT1 still carries the risks of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) and neuropsychological outcome.

METHODS

A retrospective single center study was carried out based on the phenotype, therapy and outcome in 38 Turkish patients with HT1 diagnosed during the last 20 years.

RESULTS

None of the patients was diagnosed on newborn screening. The patients were grouped according to acute, subacute and chronic forms of the disorder. The main clinical manifestations were hepatosplenomegaly, liver and renal tubular dysfunction. Thirty-six patients were treated with nitisinone. The mean duration of nitisinone treatment was 64 months and the mean dosage was 1.2 mg/kg/day. Dietary compliance problems were frequent. Eleven patients had cognitive evaluation (mean total IQ, 84 points). Six patients had living donor liver transplantation despite nitisinone treatment: three due to suspected HCC, two for non-compliance to diet, and one for both, at a median age of 90 months.

CONCLUSION

Nitisinone treatment is effective and improves both short- and long-term prognosis of HT1. Early diagnosis on newborn screening is needed because delay in treatment increases the risk of the persistence of hepatic disease and HCC. Interruption of the drug can lead to re-occurrence of hepatocellular damage and neurological crisis. Increased α-fetoprotein and new hypoechoic nodule formation are the warning signs for HCC.

Geographical and Ethnic Distribution of Mutations of the Fumarylacetoacetate Hydrolase Gene in Hereditary Tyrosinemia Type 1

Hereditary tyrosinemia type 1 (HT1) (OMIM 276700) is a severe inherited metabolic disease affecting mainly hepatic and renal functions that leads to a fatal outcome if untreated. HT1 results from a deficiency of the last enzyme of tyrosine catabolism, fumarylacetoacetate hydrolase (FAH). Biochemical findings include elevated succinylacetone in blood and urine; elevated plasma concentrations of tyrosine, methionine and phenylalanine; and elevated tyrosine metabolites in urine. The HT1 frequency worldwide is about 1 in 100,000 individuals. In some areas, where the incidence of HT1 is noticeably higher, prevalence of characteristic mutations has been reported, and the estimated incidence of carriers of a specific mutation can be as high as 1 out of 14 adults. Because the global occurrence of HT1 is relatively low, a considerable number of cases may go unrecognized, underlining the importance to establish efficient prenatal and carrier testing to facilitate an early detection of the disease. Here we describe the 95 mutations reported so far in HT1 with special emphasis on their geographical and ethnic distributions. Such information should enable the establishment of a preferential screening process for mutations most predominant in a given region or ethnic group.

Newborn screening for hepatorenal tyrosinemia-I by tandem mass spectrometry using pooled samples: a four-year summary by the New England newborn screening program

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to develop an isotope dilution liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry assay to screen for hepatorenal tyrosinemia (HT) from newborn filter paper samples using pooled extracts to increase high throughput screening.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Succinylacetone (SUAC), the marker for HT, was extracted from dried blood spots with the formation of the hydrazone derivative of SUAC; up to eight sample extracts were pooled and the SUAC-derivative was analyzed by mass spectrometry methods with an injection-to-injection time of one minute. If any pooled sample extract screened positive, then the samples comprising the pooled sample were assayed individually.

RESULTS

Two newborn infants were identified with high levels of SUAC (7 & 23μM) and later confirmed to have HT. Three older children whose initial filter paper samples were taken at 195days to 614days of age with elevated SUAC (range 4.9-5μM) were identified; one of the three had clinical signs of HT and was placed on treatment (diagnosis of the other two are unavailable).

CONCLUSION

MS/MS analysis of pooled dried blood sample extracts permits sensitive, reduced instrumental analytical time and increase high throughput screening for HT.

Recommendations for the management of tyrosinaemia type 1

The management of tyrosinaemia type 1 (HT1, fumarylacetoacetase deficiency) has been revolutionised by the introduction of nitisinone but dietary treatment remains essential and the management is not easy. In this review detailed recommendations for the management are made based on expert opinion, published case reports and investigational studies as the evidence base is limited and there are no prospective controlled studies.

The added value of this paper is that it summarises in detail current clinical knowledge about HT1 and makes recommendations for the management.

Recommendations for the management of tyrosinaemia type 1

The management of tyrosinaemia type 1 (HT1, fumarylacetoacetase deficiency) has been revolutionised by the introduction of nitisinone but dietary treatment remains essential and the management is not easy. In this review detailed recommendations for the management are made based on expert opinion, published case reports and investigational studies as the evidence base is limited and there are no prospective controlled studies.The added value of this paper is that it summarises in detail current clinical knowledge about HT1 and makes recommendations for the management.

Tyrosinemia Type III detected via neonatal screening: management and outcome

Tyrosinemia Type III is caused by the deficiency of 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (4-HPPD), an enzyme involved in the catabolic pathway of tyrosine. To our knowledge, only a few patients presenting with this disease have been described in the literature, and the clinical phenotype remains variable and unclear. We report the case of a boy with tyrosinemia Type III detected using neonatal screening, who is homozygous for the splice donor mutation IVS11+1G>A in intron 11 of the HPD gene. At the age of 30 months, the boy's outcome under mild protein restriction was characterized by normal growth and psychomotor development.

Performance of succinylacetone assays and their associated proficiency testing outcomes

BACKGROUND

Succinylacetone (SUAC) is the primary metabolic marker for hepatorenal tyrosinemia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We used results reported for dried-blood-spot proficiency testing (PT) specimens and hepatorenal tyrosinemia patients' newborn screening (NBS) samples to demonstrate analytic biases in SUAC recoveries and differences in presumptive clinical classifications.

RESULTS

SUAC recoveries from non-kit and NeoBase™ kit tandem mass spectrometry methods were markedly different. Kit users that set high cutoff values submitted discordant clinical assessments of "within normal limits" for PT specimens enriched with 10-15 μmol SUAC/L in blood. SUAC levels in tyrosinemia patients' NBS samples analyzed by NeoBase™ kit were lower than those in samples analyzed by non-kit methods.

CONCLUSIONS

From 2009 to 2011, analytic biases in SUAC recoveries were consistent. Discordant clinical assessments of PT specimens were associated with high cutoff values for NeoBase™ kit results. Method-related differences in SUAC concentrations of tyrosinemia patients' samples were consistent with those of PT specimens.