Surprising causes of C5-carnitine false positive results in newborn screening

Analysis of a second-tier test panel in dried blood spot samples using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry in Catalonia's newborn screening programme

OBJECTIVES

Acylcarnitine and amino acid analyses of dried blood spot (DBS) samples using tandem mass spectrometry in newborn screening (NBS) programmes can generate false positive (FP) results. Therefore, implementation of second-tier tests (2TTs) using DBS samples has become increasingly important to avoid FPs. The most widely used 2TT metabolites include methylmalonic acid, 3-hydroxypropionic acid, methylcitric acid, and homocysteine.

METHODS

We simultaneously measured 46 underivatised metabolites, including organic acids, acylglycine and acylcarnitine isomers, homocysteine, and orotic acid, in DBS samples using tandem mass spectrometry. To validate this method, we analysed samples from 147 healthy newborns, 160 patients with genetic disorders diagnosed via NBS, 20 patients with acquired vitamin B12 deficiency, 10 newborns receiving antibiotic treatment, and nine external quality control samples.

RESULTS

The validation study revealed that 31 metabolites showed good analytical performance. Furthermore, this method detected key metabolites for all diseases associated with increased levels of the following acylcarnitines: C3, C4, C5, C4DC/C5OH, and C5DC. The sensitivity of this method to detect all diseases was 100 %, and the specificity was 74-99 %, except for glutaric aciduria type 1. This method can also be used to diagnose mitochondrial fatty acid β-oxidation disorders (FAODs) and urea cycle defects (UCDs).

CONCLUSIONS

We have described a 2TT panel of 31 metabolites in DBS samples based on an easy and rapid method without derivatisation. Its implementation allowed us to distinguish between different organic acidurias, some FAODs, and UCDs. This new strategy has increased the efficiency of our NBS programme by reducing FP and false negative results, second sample requests, and the time required for diagnosis.

Research on the Clinical Practical Use of Pivoxil-Conjugated Antibodies and the Risk of Carnitine Deficiency Using Real-World Data

In Japan, pivoxil-conjugated antibodies (PVs) are commonly used to treat infections. However, carnitine deficiency is a known adverse drug reaction associated with PV treatment. This study aimed to research the practical use of PV and assess the risk of carnitine deficiency in patients receiving PV compared to their amoxicillin (AM)-treated counterparts. The Pediatric Medical Information Collection System (P-MICS) served as the data source for this study. The study cohort comprised patients aged 0-15 years prescribed PV between April 2016 and March 2021. Data on the actual PV prescriptions were extracted for each patient. To evaluate the risk of carnitine deficiency, adverse events (AEs) were defined as carnitine deficiency and its associated symptoms. Propensity score matching was employed to compare the AE incidence between the PV and AM groups. The number of cases of PV prescriptions decreased year-on-year between 2016 and 2021, and >80% of prescriptions were dispensed in the clinic. The propensity score matching analysis demonstrated no statistically significant difference in the incidence of carnitine deficiency and its associated symptoms between the PV and AM groups. Our findings suggest that the risk of carnitine deficiency in children treated with PV is not significantly higher than that associated with other antibiotics.

Neonatal screening for isovaleric aciduria: Reducing the increasingly high false-positive rate in Germany

Newborn screening (NBS) for isovaleric acidemia (IVA) is performed by flow injection tandem mass spectrometry quantifying C5 carnitines (C5). Isovalerylcarnitine, however, is isomeric with pivaloylcarnitine which can be present in blood due to maternal use of pivaloylester-containing antibiotics, available in Germany since late 2016. During a 36-month period (January 19-December 21), all newborns screened in Hamburg with a C5 above cutoff (NeoGram®: 0.50 μmol/L or Neobase®2: 0.45 μmol/L) were included in the study. As a second-tier test, a simple ultra performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS/MS) method was developed to differentiate the C5 isomers pivaloyl-, 2-methylbutyryl-, isovaleryl-, and valerylcarnitine. Out of 156 772 newborns tested, one turned out to have genetically proven IVA while 99 were false positive (C5: 0.5-8.2 μmol/L) due to the presence of pivaloylcarnitine. These cases have increased year by year and show local clusters. Retrospective analysis of another 39 cases from 287 206 neonates tested at the NBS center in Heidelberg with C5 elevation (0.9-10.6 μmol/L) but clinical and biochemical exclusion of IVA yielded evidence of pivaloylcarnitine in all cases. Inclusion of a second-tier test into NBS significantly reduces the high and increasing false-positive rate of IVA screening. This avoids further diagnostic steps, prevents unnecessary stress and anxiety of parents in a remarkably high number of cases. If Hamburg data of 2021 are extrapolated to all of Germany, one can assume around 800 (1‰) false-positive cases in comparison to an average of two classic IVA cases per year. Unless licensing of pivaloylester-containing drugs for use during pregnancy is reconsidered, a second-tier test for C5 determination is indispensable.

A Simple Flow Injection Analysis-Tandem Mass Spectrometry Method to Reduce False Positives of C5-Acylcarnitines Due to Pivaloylcarnitine Using Reference Ions

Flow injection analysis−tandem mass spectrometry (FIA-TMS) has been applied in a first-tier test of newborn screening (NBS). Although isovalerylcarnitine (i-C5), which is a diagnostic indicator of isovaleric acidemia (IVA), is isobaric with pivaloylcarnitine (p-C5), 2-methylbutyrylcarnitine, and n-valerylcarnitine, these isomers cannot be distinguished by the FIA-TMS. There are many reports of false positives derived from p-C5 due to the use of pivalate-conjugated antibiotics. In this study, we developed a new FIA-TMS method to distinguish i-C5 and p-C5. We found that the intensity ratio of product ions for i-C5 and p-C5 was different in a certain range even under the same analytical conditions. The product ions with the most distinct differences in ionic intensity between the isomers and the collision energies that produce them were determined to be m/z 246.2 > 187.1 and −15 V, respectively. In addition to the quantification ion, a reference ion was defined, and the similarity of the i-C5 and p-C5 reference ion ratios (i-C5 score and p-C5 score, respectively) were used to estimate which isomer (i-C5 and p-C5) was responsible for elevated C5 acylcarnitine in dried blood spots (DBSs). As a result of analyses of 11 DBS samples derived from pivalate-conjugated antibiotics and four DBS samples from IVA patients using our method, it was found that our method was able to correctly determine the type of C5-acylcarnitine (i-C5 or p-C5) in the DBS samples. Implementation of this new FIA-TMS method into the current NBS protocol will allow for a reduction in false positives in IVA.

Development of Strategies to Decrease False Positive Results in Newborn Screening

The expansion of national newborn screening (NBS) programmes has provided significant benefits in the diagnosis and early treatment of several rare, heritable conditions, preventing adverse health outcomes for most affected infants. New technological developments have enabled the implementation of testing panel covering over 50 disorders. Consequently, the increment of false positive rate has led to a high number of healthy infants recalled for expensive and often invasive additional testing, opening a debate about the harm-benefit ratio of the expanded newborn screening. The false-positive rate represents a challenge for healthcare providers working in NBS systems. Here, we give an overview on the most commonly used strategies for decreasing the adverse effects due to inconclusive screening results. The focus is on NBS performance improvement through the implementation of analytical methods, the application of new and more informative biomarkers, and by using post-analytical interpretive tools. These strategies, used as part of the NBS process, can to enhance the positive predictive value of the test and reduce the parental anxiety and healthcare costs related to the unnecessary tests and procedures.

Newborn screening for isovaleric acidemia in Quanzhou, China

BACKGROUND

Isovaleric acidemia (IVA) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder of leucine metabolism caused by a defective isovaleryl-CoA dehydrogenase (IVD) gene. Reports of IVA diagnoses following newborn screening (NBS) in the Chinese population are few.

METHODS

We investigated the biochemical, clinical, and molecular profiles of 5 patients with IVA in China. The estimated incidence of IVA in Quanzhou, China is 1 in 1:84,469.

RESULTS

Initial NBS revealed mild to markedly increased isovalerylcarnitine (C5) concentrations in all 5 patients, and differential diagnosis revealed increased urinary isovaleryglycine concentrations in 2 patients. One patient presented with acute neonatal symptoms, whereas the other 4 remained asymptomatic. Eight distinct IVD gene variants were identified. The most common variant was c.1208A > G (p.Y403C), with an allele frequency of 30%. Five variants were previously unreported, namely, c.499A > G (p.M167V), c.640A > G (p.T214A), c.740G > A (p.G247E), c.832G > C (p.V278L), and c.1195G > C (p.D399H). Different in silico prediction analyses suggested that these previously unreported missense variants are pathogenic. Protein modelling analyses also showed that these missense variants may cause structural damage and dysfunction in IVD.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with IVA may have C5 concentrations approaching the cut-off values, highlighting the need for stringent recall criteria and second-tier tests to improve screening performance.

Aspects of Newborn Screening in Isovaleric Acidemia

Isovaleric acidemia (IVA), an inborn error of leucine catabolism, is caused by mutations in the isovaleryl-CoA dehydrogenase (IVD) gene, resulting in the accumulation of derivatives of isovaleryl-CoA including isovaleryl (C5)-carnitine, the marker metabolite used for newborn screening (NBS). The inclusion of IVA in NBS programs in many countries has broadened knowledge of the variability of the condition, whereas prior to NBS, two distinct clinical phenotypes were known, an "acute neonatal" and a "chronic intermittent" form. An additional biochemically mild and potentially asymptomatic form of IVA and its association with a common missense mutation, c.932C>T (p.A282V), was discovered in subjects identified through NBS. Deficiency of short/branched chain specific acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (2-methylbutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase), a defect of isoleucine degradation whose clinical significance remains unclear, also results in elevated C5-carnitine, and may therefore be detected by NBS for IVA. Treatment strategies for the long-term management of symptomatic IVA comprise the prevention of catabolism, dietary restriction of natural protein or leucine intake, and supplementation with l-carnitine and/or l-glycine. Recommendations on how to counsel and manage individuals with the mild phenotype detected by NBS are required.

Raising Awareness of False Positive Newborn Screening Results Arising from Pivalate-Containing Creams and Antibiotics in Europe When Screening for Isovaleric Acidaemia

While the early and asymptomatic recognition of treatable conditions offered by newborn screening confers clear health benefits for the affected child, the clinical referral of patients with screen positive results can cause significant harm for some families. The use of pivalate-containing antibiotics and more recently the inclusion of neopentanoate as a component within moisturising creams used as nipple balms by nursing mothers can result in a significant number of false positive results when screening for isovaleric acidaemia (IVA) by measuring C5 acylcarnitine. A recent survey conducted within centres from nine countries indicated that this form of contamination had been or was a significant confounding factor in the detection of IVA in seven of the nine who responded. In three of these seven the prominent cause was believed to derive from the use of moisturising creams and in another three from antibiotics containing pivalate; one country reported that the cause was mixed. As a result, four of these seven centres routinely perform second tier testing to resolve C5 isobars when an initial C5 result is elevated, and a fifth is considering making this change within their national programme. The use of creams containing neopentanoate by nursing mothers and evolving patterns in the prescription of pivalate-containing antibiotics during pregnancy require those involved in the design and operation of newborn screening programmes used to detect IVA and the doctors who receive clinical referrals from these programmes to maintain an awareness of the potential impact of this form of interference on patient results.

Brain carnitine deficiency causes nonsyndromic autism with an extreme male bias: A hypothesis

Could 10-20% of autism be prevented? We hypothesize that nonsyndromic or "essential" autism involves extreme male bias in infants who are genetically normal, but they develop deficiency of carnitine and perhaps other nutrients in the brain causing autism that may be amenable to early reversal and prevention. That brain carnitine deficiency might cause autism is suggested by reports of severe carnitine deficiency in autism and by evidence that TMLHE deficiency - a defect in carnitine biosynthesis - is a risk factor for autism. A gene on the X chromosome (SLC6A14) likely escapes random X-inactivation (a mixed epigenetic and genetic regulation) and could limit carnitine transport across the blood-brain barrier in boys compared to girls. A mixed, common gene variant-environment hypothesis is proposed with diet, minor illnesses, microbiome, and drugs as possible risk modifiers. The hypothesis can be tested using animal models and by a trial of carnitine supplementation in siblings of probands. Perhaps the lack of any Recommended Dietary Allowance for carnitine in infants should be reviewed. Also see the video abstract here: https://youtu.be/BuRH_jSjX5Y.

Selective and accurate C5 acylcarnitine quantitation by UHPLC-MS/MS: Distinguishing true isovaleric acidemia from pivalate derived interference

Tandem MS acylcarnitine "profiles" are extremely valuable. Although used appropriately in newborn screening programs to identify patients with possible diseases, their inadequate quantitative accuracy and lack of selectivity is problematic for confirmatory testing. In this report, we show the application of our validated, selective, accurate, precise, and robust UHPLC-MS/MS method for quantitation of acylcarnitines, specifically to C5 acylcarnitines: pivaloyl-, 2-methylbutyryl-, isovaleryl-, and valerylcarnitine. Standardized calibrants were used to generate 13-point, 200-fold concentration range calibration curves. Samples were isolated by solid-phase extraction and derivatized with pentafluorophenacyl trifluoromethanesulfonate. Acylcarnitine pentafluorophenacyl esters were eluted in 14min chromatograms. Data demonstrating quantitative stability and method robustness over a five year time period are shown and these results validate the method's accuracy and robustness. Urine from patients with isovaleric acidemia (with the disease marker isovalerylcarnitine) and with pivaloylcarnitine present are shown. These results demonstrate the method's ability to distinguish true isovaleric acidemia from pivalate derived interference. Our method for acylcarnitine quantitation is shown to be accurate, precise, and robust for selective quantitation of isovalerylcarnitine, and thus is recommended for confirmatory testing of suspected isovaleric acidemia patients.

Introduction of a Simple Second Tier Screening Test for C5 Isobars in Dried Blood Spots: Reducing the False Positive Rate for Isovaleric Acidaemia in Expanded Newborn Screening

In 2015 the English Newborn Screening programme expanded to include Isovaleric Acidaemia (IVA). Screening is performed by flow injection analysis tandem mass spectrometry of isovalerylcarnitine. Isovalerylcarnitine is isobaric with pivaloylcarnitine which can be present in blood due to the use of pivalic ester pro-drugs or pivalic acid derivatives used as emollients in some nipple creams; the potential for false positives (FP) is well documented. A pilot study in England screened 438,164 babies, 18 had presumptive positive results but only 4 were confirmed as true positives (TP). We developed a simple test to separate the isobaric compounds and investigate these samples further.We studied newborn screening blood spots from 122 randomised controls and 34 infants with an initial raised C5 result. Dried blood spots were eluted with 30% acetonitrile (150 μL) and injected into a Waters Acquity UPLC coupled to a Waters Premier XE tandem mass spectrometer operating in positive ion mode. Isocratic separation of isovalerylcarnitine, pivaloylcarnitine, valerylcarnitine and 2-methylbutyrylcarnitine was achieved within 8 min. Assay performance characteristics were acceptable and non-parametric reference ranges (n = 122) were determined for each analyte.If this method had been used as a second tier test for the 34 presumptive positive samples, the number of FP's would have reduced from 24 to 8 and the positive predictive value of the screening test would have increased from 29 to 56%. Introduction of this test into the screening protocol has the potential to significantly reduce FP results for IVA and prevent unnecessary anxiety.

Quantitative acylcarnitine determination by UHPLC-MS/MS--Going beyond tandem MS acylcarnitine "profiles"

Tandem MS "profiling" of acylcarnitines and amino acids was conceived as a first-tier screening method, and its application to expanded newborn screening has been enormously successful. However, unlike amino acid screening (which uses amino acid analysis as its second-tier validation of screening results), acylcarnitine "profiling" also assumed the role of second-tier validation, due to the lack of a generally accepted second-tier acylcarnitine determination method. In this report, we present results from the application of our validated UHPLC-MS/MS second-tier method for the quantification of total carnitine, free carnitine, butyrobetaine, and acylcarnitines to patient samples with known diagnoses: malonic acidemia, short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (SCADD) or isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (IBD), 3-methyl-crotonyl carboxylase deficiency (3-MCC) or ß-ketothiolase deficiency (BKT), and methylmalonic acidemia (MMA). We demonstrate the assay's ability to separate constitutional isomers and diastereomeric acylcarnitines and generate values with a high level of accuracy and precision. These capabilities are unavailable when using tandem MS "profiles". We also show examples of research interest, where separation of acylcarnitine species and accurate and precise acylcarnitine quantification is necessary.

Elevation of pivaloylcarnitine by sivelestat sodium in two children

BACKGROUND

Sivelestat sodium (sivelestat), a neutrophil elastase inhibitor, is used to treat acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). We report two cases that developed elevated C5-acylcarnitine (C5-AC) levels following treatment with sivelestat. Case 1 was a 14-day-old female infant born at 25 weeks and 1 day of gestation who was treated with sivelestat for the prophylaxis of Wilson-Mikity syndrome soon after birth. Isovaleric acidemia (IVA) was suspected based on a newborn screening using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). Her C5-AC level was elevated to 4.49 μM (cut-off, <1.0) after treatment with sivelestat. Case 2 was a 4-year-old female with pneumocystis pneumonia that developed during chemotherapy for disseminated medulloblastoma. Sivelestat was given for the complication of ARDS. Her C5-AC level increased (1.09 μM) after eight days of treatment with sivelestat.

RESULTS

In both cases, IVA was ruled out because isovalerylglycine was not observed in the urinary organic acid analysis. Case 1 was associated with carnitine deficiency (C0 9.16 μM; reference value, 10-60). Liquid chromatography-MS/MS confirmed elevated pivaloylcarnitine (PVC) in both cases.

DISCUSSION

Similar to antibiotics containing pivalic acid (PVA), sivelestat contains PVA, which has the potential to cause secondary carnitine deficiency. In addition, elevated PVC can lead to false positive findings of IVA in newborns screened using MS/MS.

Newborn screening for medium chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency: performance improvement by monitoring a new ratio

Medium chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (MCAD) deficiency is a fatty acid oxidation disorder included on newborn screening (NBS) panels in many regions that have expanded to using tandem mass spectrometry for acylcarnitine screening. False positive (FP) screening results for MCAD deficiency have previously been linked to very low birth weight (VLBW) infants and those who are heterozygous for the common mutation, p.K324E. Previous studies have identified these causes of FP screens by sequencing residual dried blood spots. From our cohort of FP screens in Georgia, we identified an elevation at the same mass as octenoylcarnitine (C8:1) causing elevations of octanoylcarnitine (C8) not due to MCAD deficiency. We reviewed biochemical results from 2011 to 2013 for all newborn screens positive for MCAD deficiency in Georgia to identify screening criteria to allow these cases to be identified prospectively, thus saving families the stress of additional testing on their newborn and reducing healthcare costs while improving screening performance for the screening program. We identified the C8/C8:1 ratio as an effective marker, and developed criteria that will reduce FP screening results due to this interfering substance.

Clinical and genetical heterogeneity of late-onset multiple acyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase deficiency

BACKGROUND

Multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (MADD) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by deficiency of electron transfer flavoprotein or electron transfer flavoprotein dehydrogenase. The clinical picture of late-onset forms is highly variable with symptoms ranging from acute metabolic decompensations to chronic, mainly muscular problems or even asymptomatic cases.

METHODS

All 350 cases of late-onset MADD reported in the literature to date have been analyzed and evaluated with respect to age at presentation, diagnostic delay, biochemical features and diagnostic parameters as well as response to treatment.

RESULTS

Mean age at onset was 19.2 years. The mean delay between onset of symptoms and diagnosis was 3.9 years. Chronic muscular symptoms were more than twice as common as acute metabolic decompensations (85% versus 33% of patients, respectively). 20% had both acute and chronic symptoms. 5% of patients had died at a mean age of 5.8 years, while 3% of patients have remained asymptomatic until a maximum age of 14 years. Diagnosis may be difficult as a relevant number of patients do not display typical biochemical patterns of urine organic acids and blood acylcarnitines during times of wellbeing. The vast majority of patients carry mutations in the ETFDH gene (93%), while mutations in the ETFA (5%) and ETFB (2%) genes are the exceptions. Almost all patients with late-onset MADD (98%) are clearly responsive to riboflavin.

CONCLUSIONS

Late-onset MADD is probably an underdiagnosed disease and should be considered in all patients with acute or chronic muscular symptoms or acute metabolic decompensation with hypoglycemia, acidosis, encephalopathy and hepatopathy. This may not only prevent patients from invasive diagnostic procedures such as muscle biopsies, but also help to avoid fatal metabolic decompensations.