Autogenous grafts made to order

Current biofabrication methods for vascular tissue engineering and an introduction to biological textiles

Cardiovascular diseases are the leading cause of mortality in the world and encompass several important pathologies, including atherosclerosis. In the cases of severe vessel occlusion, surgical intervention using bypass grafts may be required. Synthetic vascular grafts provide poor patency for small-diameter applications (< 6 mm) but are widely used for hemodialysis access and, with success, larger vessel repairs. In very small vessels, such as coronary arteries, synthetics outcomes are unacceptable, leading to the exclusive use of autologous (native) vessels despite their limited availability and, sometimes, quality. Consequently, there is a clear clinical need for a small-diameter vascular graft that can provide outcomes similar to native vessels. Many tissue-engineering approaches have been developed to offer native-like tissues with the appropriate mechanical and biological properties in order to overcome the limitations of synthetic and autologous grafts. This review overviews current scaffold-based and scaffold-free approaches developed to biofabricate tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) with an introduction to the biological textile approaches. Indeed, these assembly methods show a reduced production time compared to processes that require long bioreactor-based maturation steps. Another advantage of the textile-inspired approaches is that they can provide better directional and regional control of the TEVG mechanical properties.

Application of decellularized vascular matrix in small-diameter vascular grafts

Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) remains the most common procedure used in cardiovascular surgery for the treatment of severe coronary atherosclerotic heart disease. In coronary artery bypass grafting, small-diameter vascular grafts can potentially replace the vessels of the patient. The complete retention of the extracellular matrix, superior biocompatibility, and non-immunogenicity of the decellularized vascular matrix are unique advantages of small-diameter tissue-engineered vascular grafts. However, after vascular implantation, the decellularized vascular matrix is also subject to thrombosis and neoplastic endothelial hyperplasia, the two major problems that hinder its clinical application. The keys to improving the long-term patency of the decellularized matrix as vascular grafts include facilitating early endothelialization and avoiding intravascular thrombosis. This review article sequentially introduces six aspects of the decellularized vascular matrix as follows: design criteria of vascular grafts, components of the decellularized vascular matrix, the changing sources of the decellularized vascular matrix, the advantages and shortcomings of decellularization technologies, modification methods and the commercialization progress as well as the application prospects in small-diameter vascular grafts.

Pre-implantation evaluation of a small-diameter, long vascular graft (Biotube®) for below-knee bypass surgery in goats

There are no small-diameter, long artificial vascular grafts for below-knee bypass surgery in chronic limb-threatening ischemia. We have developed tissue-engineered vascular grafts called "Biotubes®" using a completely autologous approach called in-body tissue architecture (iBTA). This study aimed at pre-implantation evaluation of Biotube and its in vivo preparation device, Biotube Maker, for use in below-knee bypass surgery. Forty nine makers were subcutaneously embedded into 17 goats for predetermined periods (1, 2, or 3 months). All makers produced Biotubes as designed without inflammation over all periods, with the exception of a few cases with minor defects (success rate: 94%). Small hole formation occurred in only a few cases. All Biotubes obtained had an inner diameter of 4 mm and a length of 51 to 52 cm with a wall thickness of 594 ± 97 μm. All Biotubes did not kink when completely bent under an internal pressure of 100 mmHg and did not leak without any deformation under a water pressure of 200 mmHg. Their burst strength was 2409 ± 473 mmHg, and suture retention strength was 1.75 ± 0.27 N, regardless of the embedding period, whereas tensile strength increased from 7.5 ± 1.3 N at 1 month to 9.7 ± 2.0 N at 3 months with the embedding period. The amount of water leakage from the needle holes prepared in the Biotube wall was approximately 1/7th of that in expanded polytetrafluoroethylene vascular grafts. The Biotubes could be easily connected to each other without cutting or anastomosis leaks. They could be stored for at least 1 year at room temperature. This study confirmed that even Biotubes formed 1 month after embedding of Biotube Makers had properties comparable to arteries.

Mechanically reinforced biotubes for arterial replacement and arteriovenous grafting inspired by architectural engineering

There is a lack in clinically-suitable vascular grafts. Biotubes, prepared using in vivo tissue engineering, show potential for vascular regeneration. However, their mechanical strength is typically poor. Inspired by architectural design of steel fiber reinforcement of concrete for tunnel construction, poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) fiber skeletons (PSs) were fabricated by melt-spinning and heat treatment. The PSs were subcutaneously embedded to induce the assembly of host cells and extracellular matrix to obtain PS-reinforced biotubes (PBs). Heat-treated medium-fiber-angle PB (hMPB) demonstrated superior performance when evaluated by in vitro mechanical testing and following implantation in rat abdominal artery replacement models. hMPBs were further evaluated in canine peripheral arterial replacement and sheep arteriovenous graft models. Overall, hMPB demonstrated appropriate mechanics, puncture resistance, rapid hemostasis, vascular regeneration, and long-term patency, without incidence of luminal expansion or intimal hyperplasia. These optimized hMPB properties show promise as an alternatives to autologous vessels in clinical applications.

Pulmonary artery augmentation and aortic valve repair using novel tissue-engineered grafts

Objectives

The objectives of this study were to evaluate the results when tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) are used as alternatives to autologous pericardium for surgically augmenting the pulmonary artery (PA) or aortic valve.

Methods

TEVG molds were embedded into subcutaneous spaces for more than 4 weeks preoperatively. Since 2014, 6 patients have undergone PA reconstruction, whereas 1 has undergone aortic valve plasty (AVP) with TEVGs. The time from mold implantation to the operation was 8.9 (range, 6.0-26.4) months. The age and body weight at the time of operation were 2.7 (range, 1.8-9.2) and 11.6 (range, 7.9-24.4) kg, respectively. Concomitant procedures comprised the Rastelli, palliative Rastelli, and Fontan operations in 2, 2, and 1 patient, respectively.

Results

The median follow-up period was 14.4 (range, 3-39.6) months. There were no early or late mortalities. Moreover, there were no TEVG-related complications, including aneurysmal changes, degeneration, and infection. In 5 patients who underwent PA augmentation, the postoperative PA configuration was satisfactorily dilated. The reconstructed aortic valve function was good in the patient who underwent AVP. Decreased leaflet flexibility due to leaflet thickening was not observed. One patient had postoperative PA re-stenosis; therefore, re-PA augmentation with TEVGs was performed. On histological examination, TEVGs consisted of collagen fibers and few fibroblasts, and elastic fiber formation and/or smooth muscle cells were not observed.

Conclusions

The midterm results of PA reconstruction and AVP with TEVGs were satisfactory. TEVGs might be a useful alternative to autologous pericardium in pediatric cardiovascular surgeries that often require multistage operations.

Modifications of the mechanical properties of in vivo tissue-engineered vascular grafts by chemical treatments for a short duration

In vivo tissue-engineered vascular grafts constructed in the subcutaneous spaces of graft recipients have functioned well clinically. Because the formation of vascular graft tissues depends on several recipient conditions, chemical pretreatments, such as dehydration by ethanol (ET) or crosslinking by glutaraldehyde (GA), have been attempted to improve the initial mechanical durability of the tissues. Here, we compared the effects of short-duration (10 min) chemical treatments on the mechanical properties of tissues. Tubular tissues (internal diameter, 5 mm) constructed in the subcutaneous tissues of beagle dogs (4 weeks, n = 3), were classified into three groups: raw tissue without any treatment (RAW), tissue dehydrated with 70% ET (ET), and tissue crosslinked with 0.6% GA (GA). Five mechanical parameters were measured: burst pressure, suture retention strength, ultimate tensile strength (UTS), ultimate strain (%), and Young’s modulus. The tissues were also autologously re-embedded into the subcutaneous spaces of the same dogs for 4 weeks (n = 2) for the evaluation of histological responses. The burst pressure of the RAW group (1275.9 ± 254.0 mm Hg) was significantly lower than those of ET (2115.1 ± 262.2 mm Hg, p = 0.0298) and GA (2570.5 ± 282.6 mm Hg, p = 0.0017) groups. Suture retention strength, UTS or the ultimate strain did not differ significantly among the groups. Young’s modulus of the ET group was the highest (RAW: 5.41 ± 1.16 MPa, ET: 12.28 ± 2.55 MPa, GA: 7.65 ± 1.18 MPa, p = 0.0185). No significant inflammatory tissue response or evidence of residual chemical toxicity was observed in samples implanted subcutaneously for four weeks. Therefore, short-duration ET and GA treatment might improve surgical handling and the mechanical properties of in vivo tissue-engineered vascular tissues to produce ideal grafts in terms of mechanical properties without interfering with histological responses.

Strategies for re-vascularization and promotion of angiogenesis in trauma and disease

The maintenance of a healthy vascular system is essential to ensure the proper function of all organs of the human body. While macrovessels have the main role of blood transportation from the heart to all tissues, microvessels, in particular capillaries, are responsible for maintaining tissues' functionality by providing oxygen, nutrients and waste exchanges. Occlusion of blood vessels due to atherosclerotic plaque accumulation remains the leading cause of mortality across the world. Autologous vein and artery grafts bypassing are the current gold standard surgical procedures to substitute primarily obstructed vascular structures. Ischemic scenarios that condition blood supply in downstream tissues may arise from blockage phenomena, as well as from other disease or events leading to trauma. The (i) great demand for new vascular substitutes, arising from both the limited availability of healthy autologous vessels, as well as the shortcomings associated with small-diameter synthetic vascular grafts, and (ii) the challenging induction of the formation of adequate and stable microvasculature are current driving forces for the growing interest in the development of bioinspired strategies to ensure the proper function of vasculature in all its dimensional scales. Here, a critical review of well-established technologies and recent biotechnological advances to substitute or regenerate the vascular system is provided.

Cellular remodeling of fibrotic conduit as vascular graft

The replacement of small-diameter arteries remains an unmet clinical need. Here we investigated the cellular remodeling of fibrotic conduits as vascular grafts. The formation of fibrotic conduit around subcutaneously implanted mandrels involved not only fibroblasts but also the trans-differentiation of inflammatory cells such as macrophages into fibroblastic cells, as shown by genetic lineage tracing. When fibrotic conduits were implanted as vascular grafts, the patency was low, and many fibrotic cells were found in neointima. Decellularization and anti-thrombogenic coating of fibrotic conduits produced highly patent autografts that remodeled into neoarteries, offering an effective approach to obtain autografts for clinical therapy. While autografts recruited mostly anti-inflammatory macrophages for constructive remodeling, allogenic DFCs had more T cells and pro-inflammatory macrophages and lower patency. Endothelial progenitors and endothelial migration were observed during endothelialization. Cell infiltration into DFCs was more efficient than decellularized arteries, and infiltrated cells remodeled the matrix and differentiated into smooth muscle cells (SMCs). This work provides insight into the remodeling of fibrotic conduits, autologous DFCs and allogenic DFCs, and will have broad impact on using fibrotic matrix for regenerative engineering.

Can a Peritoneal Conduit Become an Artery?

Objective

Current vascular grafts all have limitations. This study examined peritoneum as a potential graft material and the in vivo transfer of peritoneum into a functional artery like conduit after end to end anastomosis into the common carotid artery of sheep. The aim was to investigate whether implantation of a peritoneal tube into the arterial tree results in a structure with function, histological findings, and gene expression like an artery, and whether such arterialisation occurs through a conversion of the phenotype of peritoneal cells or from host cell migration into the implant.

Methods

Peritoneum with adherent rectus aponeurosis from sheep was used to form tubular vascular grafts that were implanted into the common carotid artery of six sheep, then removed after five months. Two sheep received allogenic peritoneal grafts and four sheep received autologous peritoneal grafts.

Results

One sheep died shortly after implantation, so five of the six sheep were followed. Five months after implantation, four of the five remaining grafts were patent. Three of four patent grafts were aneurysmal. The four patent grafts had developed an endothelial layer indistinguishable from that of the adjacent normal artery, and a medial layer with smooth muscle cells with a surrounding adventitia. The new conduit displayed vasomotor function not present at the time of implantation. DNA genotyping showed that the media in the new conduit consisted of recipient smooth muscle cells. Little difference in mRNA expression was demonstrated between the post-implantation conduit and normal artery.

Conclusion

During a five month implantation period in the arterial system, peritoneum converted into a tissue that histologically and functionally resembled a normal artery, with a functional genetic expression that resembled that of an artery. Single nucleotide polymorphism analysis indicated that this conversion occurs through host cell migration into the graft.

•

Alternative vascular graft material examined in a large mammal.

•

Peritoneal graft converts into artery – like conduit after 5 months in arterial system.

•

Arterialisation through host cell migration into graft.

•

Potential model of aneurysm with low risk of rupture.

A novel method for engineering autologous non-thrombogenic in situ tissue-engineered blood vessels for arteriovenous grafting

The durability of prosthetic arteriovenous (AV) grafts for hemodialysis access is low, predominantly due to stenotic lesions in the venous outflow tract and infectious complications. Tissue engineered blood vessels (TEBVs) might offer a tailor-made autologous alternative for prosthetic grafts. We have designed a method in which TEBVs are grown in vivo, by utilizing the foreign body response to subcutaneously implanted polymeric rods in goats, resulting in the formation of an autologous fibrocellular tissue capsule (TC). One month after implantation, the polymeric rod is extracted, whereupon TCs (length 6 cm, diameter 6.8 mm) were grafted as arteriovenous conduit between the carotid artery and jugular vein of the same goats. At time of grafting, the TCs were shown to have sufficient mechanical strength in terms of bursting pressure (2382 ± 129 mmHg), and suture retention strength (SRS: 1.97 ± 0.49 N). The AV grafts were harvested at 1 or 2 months after grafting. In an ex vivo whole blood perfusion system, the lumen of the vascular grafts was shown to be less thrombogenic compared to the initial TCs and ePTFE grafts. At 8 weeks after grafting, the entire graft was covered with an endothelial layer and abundant elastin expression was present throughout the graft. Patency at 1 and 2 months was comparable with ePTFE AV-grafts. In conclusion, we demonstrate the remodeling capacity of cellularized in vivo engineered TEBVs, and their potential as autologous alternative for prosthetic vascular grafts.

Engineering blood vessels and vascularized tissues: technology trends and potential clinical applications

Vascular tissue engineering has the potential to make a significant impact on the treatment of a wide variety of medical conditions, including providing in vitro generated vascularized tissue and organ constructs for transplantation. Since the first report on the construction of a biological blood vessel, significant research and technological advances have led to the generation of clinically relevant large and small diameter tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs). However, developing a biocompatible blood-contacting surface is still a major challenge. Researchers are using biomimicry to generate functional vascular grafts and vascular networks. A multi-disciplinary approach is being used that includes biomaterials, cells, pro-angiogenic factors and microfabrication technologies. Techniques to achieve spatiotemporal control of vascularization include use of topographical engineering and controlled-release of growth/pro-angiogenic factors. Use of decellularized natural scaffolds has gained popularity for engineering complex vascularized organs for potential clinical use. Pre-vascularization of constructs prior to implantation has also been shown to enhance its anastomosis after implantation. Host-implant anastomosis is a phenomenon that is still not fully understood. However, it will be a critical factor in determining the in vivo success of a TEVGs or bioengineered organ. Many clinical studies have been conducted using TEVGs, but vascularized tissue/organ constructs are still in the research & development stage. In addition to technical challenges, there are commercialization and regulatory challenges that need to be addressed. In this review we examine recent advances in the field of vascular tissue engineering, with a focus on technology trends, challenges and potential clinical applications.

In Situ Generated Medical Devices

Medical devices play a major role in all areas of modern medicine, largely contributing to the success of clinical procedures and to the health of patients worldwide. They span from simple commodity products such as gauzes and catheters, to highly advanced implants, e.g., heart valves and vascular grafts. In situ generated devices are an important family of devices that are formed at their site of clinical function that have distinct advantages. Among them, since they are formed within the body, they only require minimally invasive procedures, avoiding the pain and risks associated with open surgery. These devices also display enhanced conformability to local tissues and can reach sites that otherwise are inaccessible. This review aims at shedding light on the unique features of in situ generated devices and to underscore leading trends in the field, as they are reflected by key developments recently in the field over the last several years. Since the uniqueness of these devices stems from their in situ generation, the way they are formed is crucial. It is because of this fact that in this review, the medical devices are classified depending on whether their in situ generation entails chemical or physical phenomena.

Development of xenogeneic decellularized biotubes for off-the-shelf applications

In earlier studies, we developed in vivo tissue-engineered, autologous, small-caliber vascular grafts, called "biotubes," which withstand systemic blood pressure and exhibit excellent performance as small-caliber vascular prostheses in animal models. However, biotube preparation takes 4 weeks; therefore, biotubes cannot be applied in emergency situations. Moreover, for responses to various types of surgery, grafts should ideally be readily available in advance. The aim of this study was to develop novel, off-the-shelf, small-caliber vascular grafts by decellularizing in vivo tissue-engineered xenogeneic tubular materials. Silicone rod molds (diameter: 2 mm, length: 70 mm) placed in subcutaneous pouches of a beagle dog for 4 weeks were harvested with their surrounding connective tissues. Tubular connective tissues were obtained after pulling out the impregnated molds. Subsequently, they were decellularized by perfusion with sodium dodecyl sulfate and Triton X-100. They were stored as off-the-shelf grafts at -20°C for 1 week. The decellularized grafts derived from the beagle dog were xenogeneically transplanted to the abdominal aortas of rats (n = 3). No signs of abnormal inflammation or immunological problems due to the xenogeneic material were observed. Echocardiography confirmed the patency of the grafts at 1 month after implantation. Histological evaluation revealed that the grafts formed neointima on the luminal surface, and that the graft walls had cell infiltration. Little accumulation of CD68-positive macrophages in the graft wall was observed. Xenogeneic decellularized tubular tissues functioned as small-caliber vascular grafts, as well as autologous biotubes. This technology enables the easy fabrication of grafts from xenogeneic animals in advance and their storage for at least a week, satisfying the conditions for off-the-shelf grafts.

Regeneration of a neoartery through a completely autologous acellular conduit in a minipig model: a pilot study

Background

Vascular grafts are widely used as a treatment in coronary artery bypass surgery, hemodialysis, peripheral arterial bypass and congenital heart disease. Various types of synthetic and natural materials were experimented to produce tissue engineering vascular grafts. In this study, we investigated in vivo tissue engineering technology in miniature pigs to prepare decellularized autologous extracellular matrix-based grafts that could be used as vascular grafts for small-diameter vascular bypass surgery.

Methods

Autologous tissue conduits (3.9 mm in diameter) were fabricated by embedding Teflon tubings in the subcutaneous pocket of female miniature pigs (n = 8, body weight 25–30 kg) for 4 weeks. They were then decellularized by CHAPS decellularization solution. Heparin was covalently-linked to decellularized tissue conduits by Sulfo-NHS/EDC. We implanted these decellularized, completely autologous extracellular matrix-based grafts into the carotid arteries of miniature pigs, then sacrificed the pigs at 1 or 2 months after implantation and evaluated the patency rate and explants histologically.

Results

After 1 month, the patency rate was 100% (5/5) while the inner diameter of the grafts was 3.43 ± 0.05 mm (n = 5). After 2 months, the patency rate was 67% (2/3) while the inner diameter of the grafts was 2.32 ± 0.14 mm (n = 3). Histological staining confirmed successful cell infiltration, and collagen and elastin deposition in 2-month samples. A monolayer of endothelial cells was observed along the inner lumen while smooth muscle cells were dominant in the graft wall.

Conclusion

A completely autologous acellular conduit with excellent performance in mechanical properties can be remodeled into a neoartery in a minipig model. This proof-of-concept study in the large animal model is very encouraging and indicates that this is a highly feasible idea worthy of further study in non-human primates before clinical translation.

Quickening: Translational design of resorbable synthetic vascular grafts

Traditional tissue-engineered vascular grafts have yet to gain wide clinical use. The difficulty of scaling production of these cell- or biologic-based products has hindered commercialization. In situ tissue engineering bypasses such logistical challenges by using acellular resorbable scaffolds. Upon implant, the scaffolds become remodeled by host cells. This review describes the scientific and translational advantages of acellular, synthetic vascular grafts. It surveys in vivo results obtained with acellular synthetics over their fifty years of technological development. Finally, it discusses emerging principles, highlights strategic considerations for designers, and identifies questions needing additional research.

Cardiovascular tissue engineering: From basic science to clinical application

Valvular heart disease is an increasing population health problem and, especially in the elderly, a significant cause of morbidity and mortality. The current treatment options, such as mechanical and bioprosthetic heart valve replacements, have significant restrictions and limitations. Considering the increased life expectancy of our aging population, there is an urgent need for novel heart valve concepts that remain functional throughout life to prevent the need for reoperation. Heart valve tissue engineering aims to overcome these constraints by creating regenerative, self-repairing valve substitutes with life-long durability. In this review, we give an overview of advances in the development of tissue engineered heart valves, and describe the steps required to design and validate a novel valve prosthesis before reaching first-in-men clinical trials. In-silico and in-vitro models are proposed as tools for the assessment of valve design, functionality and compatibility, while in-vivo preclinical models are required to confirm the remodeling and growth potential of the tissue engineered heart valves. An overview of the tissue engineered heart valve studies that have reached clinical translation is also presented. Final remarks highlight the possibilities as well as the obstacles to overcome in translating heart valve prostheses into clinical application.

Bioengineered hemodialysis access grafts

There is a need for bioengineered therapies to improve the overall health of the growing and aging world population. Patients with renal failure have a life-long requirement for a durable form of hemodialysis vascular access. In this article, we review the history of tissue engineering as it pertains to bioengineered grafts and vessels for hemodialysis access. Over the years, various strategies have been utilized to develop ideal, humanized vessels for vascular replacement such as fixation of animal or human vessels, cell seeding of synthetic materials, and the synthesis of completely autologous or allogeneic bioengineered vessels. Tissue engineering technologies from two companies have progressed to reach phase 2 and phase 3 clinical trials, but the prospect of newer strategies on the horizon may offer improved manufacturing efficiency, a greater variety of conduit size and length, and reduce the cost to produce.

A short discourse on vascular tissue engineering

Vascular tissue engineering has significant potential to make a major impact on a wide array of clinical problems. Continued progress in understanding basic vascular biology will be invaluable in making further advancements. Past and current achievements in tissue engineering of microvasculature to perfuse organ specific constructs, small vessels for dialysis grafts, and modified synthetic and pediatric large caliber-vessel grafts will be discussed. An emphasis will be placed on clinical trial results with small and large-caliber vessel grafts. Challenges to achieving engineered constructs that satisfy the physiologic, immunologic, and manufacturing demands of engineered vasculature will be explored.

Utilizing the Foreign Body Response to Grow Tissue Engineered Blood Vessels in Vivo

It is well known that the number of patients requiring a vascular grafts for use as vessel replacement in cardiovascular diseases, or as vascular access site for hemodialysis is ever increasing. The development of tissue engineered blood vessels (TEBV's) is a promising method to meet this increasing demand vascular grafts, without having to rely on poorly performing synthetic options such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or Dacron. The generation of in vivo TEBV's involves utilizing the host reaction to an implanted biomaterial for the generation of completely autologous tissues. Essentially this approach to the development of TEBV's makes use of the foreign body response to biomaterials for the construction of the entire vascular replacement tissue within the patient's own body. In this review we will discuss the method of developing in vivo TEBV's, and debate the approaches of several research groups that have implemented this method.

Late spontaneous nonanastomotic transgraft hemorrhage from biological material-impregnated fabric vascular graft may be due to autologous tissue detachment: a clinical hypothesis

Spontaneous nonanastomotic transgraft hemorrhage occurring several years after grafting may be a new late complication of biological material-impregnated fabric vascular grafts (BMIFVs). Autologous connective tissue detachment may be caused by high porosity of the fabric graft and high blood pressure. Bleeding around the fiber is the first sign of development. Fabric grafts with optimal porosity and biocompatibility should be used for manufacturing BMIFVs.

Vascular engineering for bypass surgery

Since the introduction of synthetic vascular grafts in the 1960s, only two-stage endothelial cell seeding has demonstrated any significant improvement over conventional vascular grafts, and its benefits have yet to be demonstrated on a large scale. Tissue engineering is a rapidly expanding field with great potential, but efforts to construct tissue-engineered arterial grafts have, to date, yielded little clinical success. This review explores the latest approaches to the construction of a superior vascular graft, along with its potential for use in the clinic in the future.

APPLICATIONS OF COLLAGEN IN MEDICAL DEVICES

Collagen is the most abundant natural protein found in living systems. While there is a whole family of different collagen types, each differing in sequence, the properties that make this protein so attractive as the building blocks for medical devices, are reflected largely by the unique fibrillar structure of the molecule, as well as defined functional regions that interact with the surrounding cells and other matrix components. As a commercial medical product, collagen can be part of the natural tissue used in the device, or it can be fabricated as a reconstituted product from animal or recombinant sources. Both types of uses have distinct properties that convey advantages and disadvantages to the end product. This review examines the chemistry and biology of collagen and describes some well-documented examples of collagen-based medical devices produced in one or other of these formats.

New biological solutions for hemodialysis access

Since Scribner described the first prosthetic chronic dialysis shunt in 1961, the surgical techniques and strategies to maintain vascular access have improved dramatically. Today, hundreds of thousands of patients worldwide are treated with some combination of native vein fistula, synthetic vascular graft, or synthetic semipermanent catheter. Despite significantly lower efficacy compared with autologous fistulae, the basic materials used for synthetic shunts and catheters have evolved surprisingly slowly. The disparity between efficacy rates and concomitant maintenance costs has driven a strong campaign to decrease the use of synthetic grafts and catheters in favor of native fistulae. Whether arguing the benefits of Fistula First or "Catheter Last," the fact that clinicians are in need of an alternative to expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) is irrefutable. The poor performance of synthetic materials has a significant economic impact as well. End-stage renal disease (ESRD) accounts for approximately 6% of Medicare's overall budget, despite a prevalence of about 0.17%. Of that, 15%-25% is spent on access maintenance, making hemodialysis access a critical priority for Medicare. This clinical and economic situation has spawned an aggressive effort to improve clinical care strategies to reduce overall cost and complications. While the bulk of this effort has historically focused on developing new synthetic biomaterials, more recently, investigators have developed a variety of cell-based strategies to create tissue-engineered vascular grafts. In this article, we review the evolution of the field of cardiovascular tissue engineering. We also present an update on the Lifeline™ vascular graft, an autologous, biological, and tissue-engineered vascular graft, which was the first tissue-engineered graft to be used clinically in dialysis patients.

The evolution of vascular tissue engineering and current state of the art

Dacron® (polyethylene terephthalate) and Goretex® (expanded polytetrafluoroethylene) vascular grafts have been very successful in replacing obstructed blood vessels of large and medium diameters. However, as diameters decrease below 6 mm, these grafts are clearly outperformed by transposed autologous veins and, particularly, arteries. With approximately 8 million individuals with peripheral arterial disease, over 500,000 patients diagnosed with end-stage renal disease, and over 250,000 patients per year undergoing coronary bypass in the USA alone, there is a critical clinical need for a functional small-diameter conduit [Lloyd-Jones et al., Circulation 2010;121:e46-e215]. Over the last decade, we have witnessed a dramatic paradigm shift in cardiovascular tissue engineering that has driven the field away from biomaterial-focused approaches and towards more biology-driven strategies. In this article, we review the preclinical and clinical efforts in the quest for a tissue-engineered blood vessel that is free of permanent synthetic scaffolds but has the mechanical strength to become a successful arterial graft. Special emphasis is given to the tissue engineering by self-assembly (TESA) approach, which has been the only one to reach clinical trials for applications under arterial pressure.

Autologous small-caliber "biotube" vascular grafts with argatroban loading: a histomorphological examination after implantation to rabbits

Functional autologous tubular tissues, termed "biotubes," have been developed as small-caliber vascular grafts. Biotubes can be easily and safely constructed in vivo by using a novel concept in regenerative medicine-in body tissue architecture technology, which requires neither clean specialized laboratories nor complex cell management. Biotubes with "anastomotic reinforcement cuffs" were prepared by embedding a silicone rod (diameter, 3 mm; length, 30 mm) as a mold in the dorsal subcutaneous pouches of rabbits. The rod was covered at both ends with 2 pieces of polyurethane sponge tubes (length, 3 mm), and it was removed when the grafts were harvested. These biotubes had homogeneous thin connective tissue walls (thickness: 76 +/- 37 microm) that were primarily composed of collagen and fibroblasts. The resulting cuff-impregnated biotubes were auto-implanted in the carotid arteries for predetermined periods of up to 12 weeks and then morphologically examined. On implantation of the biotubes after argatroban loading, the total patency was 9/11 without any instance of aneurysm formation or rupture. At 12 weeks after implantation, no significant neointimal thickening was observed (170 +/- 30 microm). In addition, minimal thrombus formation was observed on the luminal surfaces, which were completely covered with endothelial cells regularly oriented longitudinally. The regenerated vascular walls comprised multilayered smooth muscle cells and dense collagen fibers with regular circumferential orientation with few elastin fibers and were similar to native arteries. Biotubes with argatroban loading could thus be used as small-caliber vascular prostheses that greatly facilitate healing process and exhibit excellent biocompatibility.

In vitro maturation of "biotube" vascular grafts induced by a 2-day pulsatile flow loading

Autologous vascular tissues with a small diameter, "biotubes," were developed in vivo using a novel concept in regenerative medicine, "in-body tissue architecture technology." The effect of pulsatile flow in vitro was investigated on the structural and functional properties of the biotubes. Silicone rods (diameter, 3.0 mm; length, 35.0 mm), used as molds, were embedded into dorsal subcutaneous spaces of Wister rats. After 4 weeks, the autologous tubular tissues formed around the rods were harvested. Some tissues were incubated for 2 days under pulsatile flow simulating conditions in the human arteries with small caliber (wall shear stress (WSS), 15.5-77.3 dyn/cm(2); circumferential stress (CS), 0.6-4.5 x 10(5) dyn/cm(2)). Upon flow loading, the sparse, randomly oriented collagen fibers in the biotubes became dense and oriented in the regular circumferential direction. Compliances (beta values) of the control (ca. 30) and flow-loaded (ca. 20) biotubes were equivalent to that of the human coronary arteries and femoral arteries, respectively. Further, upon flow loading, the burst pressure significantly increased from ca. 1000 mmHg to ca. 1800 mmHg, along with the alpha-SMA-positive cell ratio. Pulsatile flow loading in vitro for 2 days could induce biotube maturation in terms of collagen structures and mechanical properties.

Technology Insight: the evolution of tissue-engineered vascular grafts—from research to clinical practice

There is a considerable clinical need for alternatives to the autologous vein and artery tissues used for vascular reconstructive surgeries such as CABG, lower limb bypass, arteriovenous shunts and repair of congenital defects to the pulmonary outflow tract. So far, synthetic materials have not matched the efficacy of native tissues, particularly in small diameter applications. The development of cardiovascular tissue engineering introduced the possibility of a living, biological graft that might mimic the functional properties of native vessels. While academic research in the field of tissue engineering in general has been active, as yet there has been no clear example of clinical and commercial success. The recent transition of cell-based therapies from experimental to clinical use has, however, reinvigorated the field of cardiovascular tissue engineering. Here, we discuss the most promising approaches specific to tissue-engineered blood vessels and briefly introduce our recent clinical results. The unique regulatory, reimbursement and production challenges facing personalized medicine are also discussed.

In vivo cellular repopulation of tubular elastin scaffolds mediated by basic fibroblast growth factor

In vivo tissue engineering has been explored as a method to repopulate scaffolds with autologous cells to create a functional, living, and non-immunogenic tissue substitute. In this study, we describe an approach to in vivo cellular repopulation of a tissue-derived tubular elastin scaffold. Pure elastin scaffolds were prepared from porcine carotid arteries (elastin tubes). Elastin tubes were filled with agarose gel containing basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) to allow sustained release of growth factor. These tubes were implanted in subdermal pouches in adult rats. The elastin tubes with growth factor had significantly more cell infiltration at 28 days than those without growth factor. Immunohistochemical staining indicated that most of these cells were fibroblasts, of which a few were activated fibroblasts (myofibroblasts). Microvasculature was also observed within the scaffolds. Macrophage infiltration was seen at 7 days, which diminished by 28 days of implantation. None of the elastin tubes with bFGF calcified. These results demonstrated that the sustained release of bFGF brings about repopulation of elastin scaffolds in vivo while inhibiting calcification. Results showing myofibroblast infiltration and vascularization are encouraging since such an in vivo implantation technique could be used for autologous cell repopulation of elastin scaffolds for vascular graft applications.

Tissue engineering of viable pulmonary arteries for surgical correction of congenital heart defects

BACKGROUND

Tissue-engineered pulmonary arteries could overcome the drawbacks of homografts or prosthetic conduits used in the repair of many congenital cardiac defects. However, the ideal scaffold material for tissue-engineered conduits is still subject of intensive debate. In this study, we evaluated an acellularized allogeneic matrix scaffold for pulmonary artery tissue engineering with and without in-vitro reseeding with autologous endothelial cells in the pulmonary circulation in a growing sheep model.

METHODS

Ovine pulmonary arteries (n = 10) were acellularized by trypsin/ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid incubation. Autologous endothelial cells were harvested from carotid arteries, and the pulmonary conduits were seeded with endothelial cells. We implanted in-vitro, autologous, reendothelialized (group A, n = 5) and acellularized pulmonary conduits (group B, n = 5) in the pulmonary circulation. The animals were sacrificed 6 months after the operation. Explanted valves were examined histologically and by immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

The conduit diameter increased in both groups (group A, 44% +/- 11%; group B, 87% +/- 18%; p < 0.05). In group A, however, a proportional increase in diameter was present, whereas in group B, a disproportionate increase resulting in aneurysm formation was observed. Histologically, the conduit wall integrity was destroyed in group B and preserved in group A. In group B, the extracellularmatrix degenerated with a reduced amount of collagens and proteoglycanes. Furthermore, no elastic fibers were detectable. In contrast, the extracellularmatrix in group A was close to native ovine tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

Tissue-engineered pulmonary conduits (autologous endothelial cells and allogeneic matrix scaffolds) functioned well in the pulmonary circulation. They demonstrated an increase in diameter and an extracellular matrix comparable to that of native ovine tissue.

Tissue-engineered blood vessels: alternative to autologous grafts?

Although vascular bypass grafting remains the mainstay for revascularization for ischemic heart disease and peripheral vascular disease, many patients do not have healthy vessels suitable for harvest. Thus, prosthetic grafts made of synthetic polymers were developed, but their use is limited to high-flow/low-resistance conditions because of poor elasticity, low compliance, and thrombogenicity of their synthetic surfaces. To fill this need, several laboratories have produced in vivo or in vitro tissue-engineered blood vessels using molds or prosthetic or biodegradable scaffolds, but each artificial graft has significant problems. Recently, conduits have been grown in the peritoneal cavity of the same animals in which they will be grafted, ensuring no rejection, in the short time of 2 to 3 weeks. Remodeling occurs after grafting such that the tissue is almost indistinguishable from native vessels. This conduit is derived from cells of bone marrow origin, opening new possibilities in vascular modeling and remodeling.

Substituts vasculaires

Performed since the 1950s, vascular grafting has opened modern era of vascular surgery. Autologous venous grafts are of first choice for revascularisation of small arteries. Synthetic grafts are mainly modelled using microporous polytetrafluoroethylene or terephtalate polyethylene. These prosthesis are mainly used for revascularization of medium and large size arteries.

Dog peritoneal and pleural cavities as bioreactors to grow autologous vascular grafts

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to grow "artificial blood vessels" for autologous transplantation as arterial interposition grafts in a large animal model (dog).

METHOD AND RESULTS

Tubing up to 250 mm long, either bare or wrapped in biodegradable polyglycolic acid (Dexon) or nonbiodegradable polypropylene (Prolene) mesh, was inserted in the peritoneal or pleural cavity of dogs, using minimally invasive techniques, and tethered at one end to the wall with a loose suture. After 3 weeks the tubes and their tissue capsules were harvested, and the inert tubing was discarded. The wall of living tissue was uniformly 1-1.5 mm thick throughout its length, and consisted of multiple layers of myofibroblasts and matrix overlaid with a single layer of mesothelium. The myofibroblasts stained for alpha-smooth muscle actin, vimentin, and desmin. The bursting strength of tissue tubes with no biodegradable mesh scaffolds was in excess of 2500 mm Hg, and the suture holding strength was 11.5 N, both similar to that in dog carotid and femoral arteries. Eleven tissue tubes were transplanted as interposition grafts into the femoral artery of the same dog in which they were grown, and were harvested after 3 to 6.5 months. Eight remained patent during this time. At harvest, their lumens were lined with endothelium-like cells, and wall cells stained for alpha-actin, smooth muscle myosin, desmin and smoothelin; there was also a thick "adventitia" containing vasa vasorum.

CONCLUSION

Peritoneal and pleural cavities of large animals can function as bioreactors to grow myofibroblast tubes for use as autologous vascular grafts.

Advances in vascular tissue engineering

Coronary and peripheral artery bypass grafting is commonly used to relieve the symptoms of vascular deficiencies, but the supply of autologous artery or vein may not be sufficient or suitable for multiple bypass or repeat procedures, necessitating the use of other materials. Synthetic materials are suitable for large bore arteries but often thrombose when used in smaller arteries. Suitable replacement grafts must have appropriate characteristics, including resistance to infection, low immunogenicity and good biocompatability and thromboresistance, with appropriate mechanical and physiological properties and cheap and fast manufacture. Current avenues of graft development include coating synthetic grafts with either biological chemicals or cells with anticoagulatory properties. Matrix templates or acellular tubes of extracellular matrix (such as collagen) may be coated or infiltrated with cultured cells. Once placed into the artery, these grafts may become colonised by host cells and gain many of the properties of normal artery. "Tissue-engineered blood vessels" may also be formed from layers of human vascular cells grown in culture. These engineered vessels have many of the characteristics of arteries formed in vivo. "Artificial arteries" may be also be derived from peritoneal granulation tissue in body "bioreactors" by adapting the body's natural wound healing response to produce a hollow tube.

Creation of viable pulmonary artery autografts through tissue engineering

BACKGROUND

"Repair" of many congenital cardiac defects requires the use of conduits to establish right ventricle to pulmonary artery continuity. At present, available homografts or prosthetic conduits lack growth potential and can become obstructed by tissue ingrowth or calcification leading to the need for multiple conduit replacements. Tissue engineering is an approach by which cells are grown in vitro onto biodegradable polymers to construct "tissues" for implantation. A tissue engineering approach has recently been used to construct living cardiac valve leaflets from autologous cells in our laboratory. This study assesses the feasibility of a tissue engineering approach to constructing tissue-engineered "living" pulmonary artery conduits.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ovine artery (group A, n = 4) or vein (group V, n = 3) segments were harvested, separated into individual cells, expanded in tissue culture, and seeded onto synthetic biodegradable (polyglactin/polyglycolic acid) tubular scaffolds (20 mm long x 15 mm diameter). After 7 days of in vitro culture, the autologous cell/polymer vascular constructs were used to replace a 2 cm segment of pulmonary artery in lambs (age 68.4 +/- 15.5 days, weight 18.7 +/- 2.0 kg). One other control animal received an acellular polymer tube sealed with fibrin glue without autologous cells. Animals were sacrificed at intervals of 11 to 24 weeks (mean follow-up 130.3 +/- 30.8 days, mean weight 38.9 +/- 13.0 kg) after echocardiographic and angiographic studies. Explanted tissue-engineered conduits were assayed for collagen (4-hydroxyproline) and calcium content, and a tissue deoxyribonucleic acid assay (bis-benzimide dye) was used to estimate number of cell nuclei as an index of tissue maturity.

RESULTS

The acellular control graft developed progressive obstruction and thrombosis. All seven tissue-engineered grafts were patent and demonstrated a nonaneurysmal increase in diameter (group A = 18.3 +/- 1.3 mm = 95.3% of native pulmonary artery; group V = 17.1 +/- 1.2 mm = 86.8% of native pulmonary artery). Histologically, none of the biodegradable polymer scaffold remained in any tissue-engineered graft by 11 weeks. Collagen content in tissue-engineered grafts was 73.9% +/- 8.0% of adjacent native pulmonary artery. Histologically, elastic fibers were present in the media layer of tissue-engineered vessel wall and endothelial specific factor VIII was identified on the luminal surface. Deoxyribonucleic acid assay showed a progressive decrease in numbers of cell nuclei over 11 and 24 weeks, suggesting an ongoing tissue remodeling. Calcium content of tissue-engineered grafts was elevated (group A = 7.95 +/- 5.09; group V = 13.2 +/- 5.48; native pulmonary artery = 1.2 +/- 0.8 mg/gm dry weight), but no macroscopic calcification was found.

CONCLUSIONS

Living vascular grafts engineered from autologous cells and biodegradable polymers functioned well in the pulmonary circulation as a pulmonary artery replacement. They demonstrated an increase in diameter suggesting growth and development of endothelial lining and extracellular matrix, including collagen and elastic fibers. This tissue-engineering approach may ultimately allow the development of viable autologous vascular grafts for clinical use.

A completely biological tissue-engineered human blood vessel

Mechanically challenged tissue-engineered organs, such as blood vessels, traditionally relied on synthetic or modified biological materials for structural support. In this report, we present a novel approach to tissue-engineered blood vessel (TEBV) production that is based exclusively on the use of cultured human cells, i.e., without any synthetic or exogenous biomaterials. Human vascular smooth muscle cells (SMC) cultured with ascorbic acid produced a cohesive cellular sheet. This sheet was placed around a tubular support to produce the media of the vessel. A similar sheet of human fibroblasts was wrapped around the media to provide the adventitia. After maturation, the tubular support was removed and endothelial cells were seeded in the lumen. This TEBV featured a well-defined, three-layered organization and numerous extracellular matrix proteins, including elastin. In this environment, SMC reexpressed desmin, a differentiation marker known to be lost under standard culture conditions. The endothelium expressed von Willebrand factor, incorporated acetylated LDL, produced PGI2, and strongly inhibited platelet adhesion in vitro. The complete vessel had a burst strength over 2000 mmHg. This is the first completely biological TEBV to display a burst strength comparable to that of human vessels. Short-term grafting experiment in a canine model demonstrated good handling and suturability characteristics. Taken together, these results suggest that this novel technique can produce completely biological vessels fulfilling the fundamental requirements for grafting: high burst strength, positive surgical handling, and a functional endothelium.

Development of an ovine collagen-based composite biosynthetic vascular prosthesis

The search for an ideal vascular prosthesis to bypass peripheral vascular obstructive lesions is necessary where autologous tissues are either unavailable or unsuitable. This paper will outline the development and use of vascular conduits, principally of biological origin. The clinical benefits and limitations of these materials are discussed. The development of a composite biosynthetic prosthesis (Omniflow¿) is described, together with the testing methods used to determine and predict its suitability for use as an arterial substitute. The ovine biosynthetic prosthesis has significantly improved surface and mural properties over previous attempts at producing prostheses for vascular reconstruction. Immunohistological studies on samples recovered from dogs after 4 years show that the original ovine collagen is still present after 4 years, and it is further augmented by the deposition of new, host-derived connective tissue.

Another look at the Sparks-Mandril arterial graft precursor for vascular repair. - Pathology by scanning electron microscopy

The Sparks-Mandril blood vessel precursor system, an autogenous tissue growth-promoting device, in spite of its ingenuity and its surgical elegance, has received only limited usage. At technique for peripheral blood vessels by several authors. In the latter period, this laboratory also undertook similar work. The results of seven implantations in dogs and two in patients are reported here in the context of a program on the evaluation of blood vessel substitutes, their mode of operation and their long term performance. The clinical status and the pathology of the grafts at time of failure were investigated using techniques of scanning electron microscopy. This work confirms the findings of other centres regarding the generally unsatisfactory performance of the Sparks-Mandril system. Possible causes for failure in mandril-formed blood vessels are discussed.

Can a small blood vessel prosthesis be derived from heterologous foreign body reactive tissue?

This study investigated as a small diameter vascular replacement the tissue formed adjacent to an implanted cylindrical foreign body, heterologously transplanted. Grafts of 4 mm i.d. were grown in rabbits and transplanted to dogs as segmental carotid and femoral artery replacements. These maintained 50% patency after 3 weeks. Variables in the further development of this concept are discussed.

Clinical experience with the expanded polytetrafluoroethylene vascular prosthesis

Expanded polytetrafluoroethylene grafts were used in 44 patients in the last 18 months. In 13 patients the graft was used for various types of peripheral vascular reconstructive procedures, as a substitute of the autogenous saphenous veins. In 31 patients the prosthesis was used for the construction of vascular access for hemodialysis. Results of the use of this new vascular prosthesis are comparable to those achieved with the autogenous saphenous vein when used for the same purposes. A much longer period of observation is necessary before a definitive verdict can be reached on the safety and clinical applicability of any new vascular prosthetic material. But preliminary clinical results with the PTFE vascular prosthesis are encouraging and seem to justify continued cautious application of this vascular substitute.

The Sparks' mandril graft. A seven year follow-up of mandril grafts placed by Charles H. Sparks and his associates

A clinical follow-up study of the Sparks' mandril graft used for lower extremity revascularization between 1968 and 1973 is presented. Of seventy-three mandril grafts placed, sixty were used to revascularize lower extremities in fifty-four patients. Results show 100 per cent patency in the ilioiliac and ilio-femoral sites, 26 per cent patency in the femoropopliteal sites, and 0 per cent patency in the femorotibial and axillofemoral grafts. Complications include poor maturation of the graft, early thrombosis, postoperative hemorrhage, and aneurysm.

Silicone mandril method for growing reinforced autogenous femoro-popliteal artery grafts in situ

Images