A simple and reliable method for meiotic studies on testicular samples used for intracytoplasmic sperm injection

Defect in the nuclear pore membrane glycoprotein 210-like gene is associated with extreme uncondensed sperm nuclear chromatin and male infertility: a case report

After the two meiotic divisions, haploid round spermatids undergo dramatic changes to become mature spermatozoa. One of the main transformations consists of compacting the cell nucleus to confer the sperm its remarkable hydrodynamic property and to protect its DNA from the oxidative stress it will encounter during its reproductive journey. Here, we studied an infertile subject with low sperm count, poor motility and highly abnormal spermatozoa with strikingly large heads due to highly uncondensed nuclear sperm DNA. Whole-exome sequencing was performed on the subject's DNA to identify the genetic defect responsible for this severe sperm anomaly. Bioinformatics analysis of exome sequence data uncovered a homozygous loss of function variant, ENST00000368559.7:c.718-1G>A, altering a consensus splice site expected to prevent the synthesis of the nucleoporin 210 like (NUP210L) protein. High-resolution mass spectrometry of sperm protein extracts did not reveal any NUP210L peptide sequence in the patient's sperm, contrary to what was observed in control donors, thus confirming the absence of NUP210L in the patient's sperm. Interestingly, homozygous Nup210l knock-out mice have been shown to be infertile due to a reduced sperm count, a high proportion of round-headed sperm, other head and flagella defects and a poor motility. NUP210L is almost exclusively expressed in the testis and sequence analogy suggests that it encodes a nuclear pore membrane glycoprotein. The protein might be crucial to regulate nuclear trafficking during and/or before spermiogenesis, its absence potentially impeding adequate nuclear compaction by preventing the entry of histone variants/transition proteins/protamines into the nucleus and/or by preventing the adequate replacement of core histones. This work describes a new gene necessary for male fertility, potentially improving the efficiency of the genetic diagnosis of male infertility. The function of NUP210L still remains to be resolved and its future investigation will help to understand the complex mechanisms necessary for sperm compaction.

LEM-domain proteins are lost during human spermiogenesis but BAF and BAF-L persist

During spermiogenesis the spermatid nucleus is elongated, and dramatically reduced in size with protamines replacing histones to produce a highly compacted chromatin. After fertilisation, this process is reversed in the oocyte to form the male pronucleus. Emerging evidence, including the coordinated loss of the nuclear lamina (NL) and the histones, supports the involvement of the NL in spermatid nuclear remodelling, but how the NL links to the chromatin is not known. In somatic cells, interactions between the NL and the chromatin have been demonstrated: LEM-domain proteins and LBR interact with the NL and respectively, the chromatin proteins BAF and HP1. We therefore sought to characterise the lamina-chromatin interface during spermiogenesis, by investigating the localisation of six LEM-domain proteins, two BAF proteins and LBR, in human spermatids and spermatozoa. Using RT-PCR, IF and western blotting, we show that six of the proteins tested are present in spermatids: LEMD1, LEMD2 (a short isoform), ANKLE2, LAP2β, BAF and BAF-L, and three absent: Emerin, LBR and LEMD3. The full-length LEMD2 isoform, required for nuclear integrity in somatic cells, is absent. In spermatids, no protein localised to the nuclear periphery, but five were nucleoplasmic, receding towards the posterior nuclear pole as spermatids matured. Our study therefore establishes that the lamina-chromatin interface in human spermatids is radically distinct from that defined in somatic cells. In ejaculated spermatozoa, we detected only BAF and BAF-L, suggesting that they might contribute to the shaping of the spermatozoon nucleus and, after fertilisation, its transition to the male pronucleus.

Nuclear envelope remodelling during human spermiogenesis involves somatic B-type lamins and a spermatid-specific B3 lamin isoform

The nuclear lamina (NL) is a filamentous protein meshwork, composed essentially of lamins, situated between the inner nuclear membrane and the chromatin. There is mounting evidence that the NL plays a role in spermatid differentiation during spermiogenesis. The mouse spermatid NL is composed of the ubiquitous lamin B1 and the spermatid-specific lamin B3, an N-terminally truncated isoform of lamin B2. However, nothing is known about the NL in human spermatids. We therefore investigated the expression pattern and localization of A-type lamins (A, C and C2) and B-type lamins (B1, B2 and B3) during human spermiogenesis. Here, we show that a lamin B3 transcript is present in human spermatids and that B-type lamins are the only lamins detectable in human spermatids. We determine that, as shown for their mouse counterparts, human lamin B3, but not lamin B2, induces strong nuclear deformation, when ectopically expressed in HeLa cells. Co-immunofluorescence revealed that, in human spermatids, B-type lamins are present at the nuclear periphery, except in the region covered by the acrosome, and that as the spermatid matures the B-type lamins recede towards the posterior pole. Only lamin B1 remains detectable on 33-47% of ejaculated spermatozoa. On spermatozoa selected for normal head density, however, this fell to <6%, suggesting that loss of the NL signal may be linked to complete sperm nucleus compaction. The similarities revealed between lamin expression during human and rodent spermiogenesis, strengthen evidence that the NL and lamin B3 have conserved functions during the intense remodelling of the mammalian spermatid nucleus.

Exposure to low-dose bisphenol A impairs meiosis in the rat seminiferous tubule culture model: a physiotoxicogenomic approach

BACKGROUND

Bisphenol A (BPA) is one of the most widespread chemicals in the world and is suspected of being responsible for male reproductive impairments. Nevertheless, its molecular mode of action on spermatogenesis is unclear. This work combines physiology and toxicogenomics to identify mechanisms by which BPA affects the timing of meiosis and induces germ-cell abnormalities.

METHODS

We used a rat seminiferous tubule culture model mimicking the in vivo adult rat situation. BPA (1 nM and 10 nM) was added to the culture medium. Transcriptomic and meiotic studies were performed on the same cultures at the same exposure times (days 8, 14, and 21). Transcriptomics was performed using pangenomic rat microarrays. Immunocytochemistry was conducted with an anti-SCP3 antibody.

RESULTS

The gene expression analysis showed that the total number of differentially expressed transcripts was time but not dose dependent. We focused on 120 genes directly involved in the first meiotic prophase, sustaining immunocytochemistry. Sixty-two genes were directly involved in pairing and recombination, some of them with high fold changes. Immunocytochemistry indicated alteration of meiotic progression in the presence of BPA, with increased leptotene and decreased diplotene spermatocyte percentages and partial meiotic arrest at the pachytene checkpoint. Morphological abnormalities were observed at all stages of the meiotic prophase. The prevalent abnormalities were total asynapsis and apoptosis. Transcriptomic analysis sustained immunocytological observations.

CONCLUSION

We showed that low doses of BPA alter numerous genes expression, especially those involved in the reproductive system, and severely impair crucial events of the meiotic prophase leading to partial arrest of meiosis in rat seminiferous tubule cultures.

Sex Chromosome Alignment at Meiosis of Azoospermic Men With Azoospermia Factor Microdeletion

Deletions in the q arm of the Y chromosome result in spermatogenesis impairment. The aim of the present study was to observe the X and Y chromosome alignment in the spermatocytes of men with Y chromosome microdeletion of the azoospermia factor (AZF) region. This was performed by multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization probes for the centromere and telomere regions. Testicular biopsies were performed in a testicular sperm extraction-intracytoplasmic sperm injection set-up in 11 azoospermic men: 8 (nonobstructive) with AZF deletions and 3 (obstructive) controls. Histological sections, cytology preparations of the testicular biopsies, and evaluation of the meiosis according to the percentage of XY and 18 bivalents formation were assessed. Spermatozoa were identified in at least one location in controls and specimens with AZFc-deleted Y chromosomes. Complete spermatocyte arrest was found in those with a deletion that included the entire AZFb region. Bivalent formation rate of chromosome 18 was high in all samples (81%-99%). In contrast, the rate of bivalent X-Y as determined by centromeric probes was lower but in the range favorable with spermatozoa findings in controls and patients with the AZFc deletion (56%-90%), but not in those with AZFb-c deletions (28%-29%). A dramatic impairment in the normal alignment of X and Y telomeres in the specimen with AZFb-c deletion was shown (29%), compared to the specimens with AZFc deletion (70%-94%). It is suggested that the absence of sperm cells in specimens with the entire AZFb and with AZFb-c deletions is accompanied by meiosis impairment, perhaps as a result of the extent of the deletion or because of the absence of genes that are involved in the X and Y chromosome alignment.

Complete deletion of the AZFb interval from the Y chromosome in an oligozoospermic man

BACKGROUND

Deletion of the entire AZFb interval from the Y chromosome is strictly associated with azoospermia arising from maturation arrest during meiosis. Here, we describe the exceptional case of an oligozoospermic man, 13-1217, with an AZFb + c (P5/distal-P1) deletion. Through the characterization of this patient, and two AZFb (P5/proximal-P1) patients with maturation arrest, we have explored three possible explanations for his exceptionally progressive spermatogenesis.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We have determined the precise breakpoints of the deletion in 13-1217, and shown that 13-1217 is deleted for more AZFb material than one of the AZFb-deleted men (13-5349). Immunocytochemical analysis of spermatocytes with an antibody against a synaptonemal complex component indicates synapsis to be largely unaffected in 13-1217, in contrast to 13-5349 where extended asynapsis is frequent. Using PCR-based analyses of RNA and DNA from the same testicular biopsy, we show that 13-1217 expresses post-meiotic germ cell markers in the absence of genomic DNA and transcripts from the AZFb and AZFc intervals. We have determined the Y chromosome haplogroup of 13-1217 to be HgL-M185.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that the post-meiotic spermatogenesis in 13-1217 is not a consequence of mosaicism or retention of a key AZFb gene. On the contrary, since the Hg-L Y chromosome carried by 13-1217 is uncommon in Western Europe, a Y-linked modifier locus remains a possible explanation for the oligozoospermia observed in patient 13-1217. Further cases must now be studied to understand how germ cells complete spermatogenesis in the absence of the AZFb interval.

Meiotic chromosome abnormalities in fertile men: are they increasing?

OBJECTIVE

To determine the basal frequencies of meiotic chromosome abnormalities in fertile men.

DESIGN

Descriptive design.

SETTING

Research university laboratory and clinical andrology service.

PATIENT(S)

Seventeen fertile donors undergoing vasectomy.

INTERVENTION(S)

Analysis of testicular biopsies.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Meiotic chromosome abnormalities in metaphase I spermatocytes.

RESULT(S)

A total of 1,407 spermatocytes I was analyzed. The main meiotic abnormality was absence or low chiasma number of individual bivalents (23.4%), followed by structural (3.3%) and numerical (0.7%) abnormalities. Sex chromosomes and G-group chromosomes were the most commonly found as univalents at metaphase I. Statistically significant heterogeneity was found for meiotic abnormalities among fertile men, caused by interindividual variation in the level of dissociated sex chromosomes (ranging from 3.2% to 43.7%). The mean total percentage of meiotic abnormalities in spermatocytes I from fertile men was 27.4%, 1.7 times higher than those described a few decades ago in fertile and even in infertile men.

CONCLUSION(S)

Fertile men are a heterogeneous group for meiotic errors, with individuals showing percentages of meiotic abnormalities as high as 50%. From these findings, caution is recommended when using meiotic studies to diagnose and provide genetic counselling to patients consulting for infertility.

[Assessment of azoospermia and histological evaluation of spermatogenesis]

Azoospermia may be obstructive (blockage of the genital ducts) or non-obstructive (a lack of testicular production). The distinction is based on an ensemble of clinical, spermiological, hormonal, ultrasound, genetic and histological data. Azoospermia is the main indication for testicular biopsy for therapeutic and diagnostic purposes. Testicular spermatozoids are processed in the reproductive biology laboratory (simultaneously with oocyte retrieval or not) for in vitro fertilization with intra-cytoplasmic sperm injection. The histological study of spermatogenesis is usually performed on a testicular biopsy sample taken at the same time and provides additional diagnostic information on infertility. Histological alterations in the testicular tissues are frequently observed in azoospermic men. In non-obstructive azoospermia, three histological situations prevail: hypospermatogenesis, Sertoli-cell-only syndrome and germ cell arrest. One can distinguish between pure forms (in which all the seminiferous tubules have the same appearance) and mixed forms (in which the tubules' aspects are heterogeneous). Hypospermatogenesis is highly prevalent in azoospermia and is characterized by a low, basal level of spermatozoid production. The prevalence of Sertoli-cell-only syndrome varies from 27 to 68% and the mean spermatozoid recovery rate is between 16 and 33%. Germ cell arrests are rare phenotypes and have a poor prognosis for spermatozoid recovery. Overall, histological examination (still the only way to fully describe spermatogenesis) must be qualitative and quantitative, with the adoption of a standardized, universally understood terminology. It is essential to compare the histological data with (i) recovery of testicular spermatozoids, (ii) clinical, ultrasound, hormonal and genetic data and (iii) the outcome of IVF/ICSI procedures.

Meiotic abnormalities in patients bearing complete AZFc deletion of Y chromosome

BACKGROUND

We studied meiosis in three infertile patients presenting complete AZFc microdeletion and three controls.

METHODS

Primary spermatocytes were immunolabeled with SCP3, BRCA1 and gammaH2AX. We quantified the leptotene, zygotene and pachytene stages, and pachytene abnormalities: asynapsis and fragmented and dotted synaptonemal complexes (SCs).

RESULTS

SCP3 level was significantly higher in leptotene and zygotene (bouquet) stages in patients, suggesting AZFc may have a direct effect on early prophase. SCs were abnormal in 77.3% of pachytene nuclei of patients versus 30.8% of controls. The two groups differed significantly (P < 0.001) in asynapsed nuclei, fragmented SC and dotted SCs. In patients, asynapsis were short and limited to a few bivalents. Staging of pachytene nuclei based on the morphology of the XY pair with BRCA1 revealed a prevalence of early pachytene substages (70.7%) in patients. H2AX was normally phosphorylated.

CONCLUSIONS

In the absence of the AZFc region, the transient zygotene stage is extended, and chromosome condensation is reduced. The low level of limited asynapsis, the normal H2AX staining and the incomplete loss of germ cells at the pachytene checkpoint indicate that the AZFc region is not critical for meiotic recombination. We suggest that the pachytene phenotype develops secondarily to a primary defect that influences meiosis.

Meiotic arrest at the midpachytene stage in a patient with complete azoospermia factor b deletion of the Y chromosome

OBJECTIVE

To study the meiosis of a patient with complete azoospermia factor (AZF)b deletion of the Y chromosome.

DESIGN

Case report.

SETTING

La Conception University Hospital, Marseille, France.

PATIENT(S)

One azoospermic patient.

INTERVENTION(S)

Yq deletion testing, testicular sperm extraction, and meiotic study with immunocytochemistry.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Abnormal synapsis rates in spermatocytes.

RESULT(S)

We found that most spermatocytes were at an early stage of meiosis. Half of the meiotic germ cells analyzed showed asynapsis, which was mostly extended or total. Discontinuity in the synaptonemal complex was seen in one third of the meiotic cells analyzed. An unusually small number of normal pachytene nuclei were found, all at early pachytene substages.

CONCLUSION(S)

This is the first demonstration that the synaptic process is impaired in a man with complete deletion of the AZFb interval. Our findings provide evidence that the pachytene checkpoint is situated at the midpachytene substage in humans.

Meiotic anomalies in infertile men with severe spermatogenic defects

BACKGROUND

This study was aimed at evaluating the rate of pairing failure in pachytene spermatocytes of patients presenting either an obstructive (O) or a non-obstructive (NO) infertility.

METHODS

Forty-one patients and 13 controls underwent testicular biopsy. Among the patients, 19 had an O infertility and 22 a NO infertility. Preparations of all patients and controls were Giemsa-stained, and synaptonemal complexes from nine of these patients and one control were immunostained.

RESULTS

In all, 2931 pachytene nuclei were analysed. The mean rate of asynapsed nuclei from the NO group (25.4%) was significantly higher than that of the O group (9.8%). There was no significant difference between the O group and the controls (10.6%). Immunocytochemistry showed that the number of pachytene nuclei decreased from the early to late pachytene sub-stage in all patients. Two NO patients, one azoospermic and one oligozoospermic, had a high percentage of asynapsed nuclei (86 and 91.8% respectively); one of these patients also presented a precocious localized separation of sister chromatids.

CONCLUSION

high levels of extended asynapsis could arise from a primary meiotic defect which may be responsible for 9% of the NO male infertilities at our centre. The prevalence of early pachytene substages suggests that the pachytene checkpoint is localized at the mid-pachytene stage in humans.

Kinetics of meiosis in azoospermic males: a joint histological and cytological approach

We have developed a protocol for the identification of aberrant chromosome behavior during human male meiosis up to metaphase of the secondary spermatocyte. Histological evaluation by the Johnsen score of a testicular biopsy was combined with immunofluorescence of first meiotic prophase spermatocytes, using antibodies against synaptonemal complex protein 3 (SYCP3) and the product of the ataxia telangiectasia and rad3-related gene (ATR). This combination enables accurate meiotic prophase substaging and the identification of pachytene spermatocytes with asynapsis. Furthermore, we also investigated the competence of late pachytene primary spermatocytes to complete the first meiotic division up to metaphase and of secondary spermatocytes to transform into metaphase by an in vitro challenge with okadaic acid (OA). We tested this protocol on five males with normal Johnsen scores that presented with obstructive azoospermia, five males with low Johnsen scores and non-obstructive azoospermia and six vasectomized control males of proven fertility and normal Johnsen scores. In all azoospermics, the profiling of meiotic prophase stages by immunofluorescence increases the resolving power of the Johnsen score. In both obstructive and non-obstructive azoospermic patients, relatively more leptotene meiotic prophase stages were counted compared to the controls. In non-obstructive azoospermics, a marked heterogeneity in spermatogenesis was found, after combining the results of all three approaches, pointing at functional mosaicism of the germinal epithelium. Asynaptic pachytene spermatocytes were rarely encountered. Also, when first meiotic metaphase could be induced by OA, chiasma counts were normal. In none of the non-obstructive azoospermic males did the pattern of spermatogenesis resemble that of knock-out mouse azoospermics. We conclude that this combined histological and cytological approach enables a detailed phenotypic classification of infertile males, at a level comparable to that applied for male-sterile knock-out mice with a meiotic defect. This may facilitate the identification of candidate genes for human male infertility.

Meiotic studies of infertile men in case of non-obstructive azoospermia with normal karyotype and no microdeleted Y-chromosome precise the clinical couple management

To identify meiotic criteria for infertility management in non-obstructive azoospermic men, a prospective and multicentric study was organized in Andrological Departments of Paris (France), Roma (Italy) and Budapest (Hungary). In 117 non-obstructive azoospermic men with normal karyotype and no Y-chromosome microdeletion, histology and meiotic studies on bilateral bipolar testicular biopsies were done. Histologically, 40 patients (34%) presented spermatocyte or spermatid arrest, 39 (33%) hypospermatogenesis whereas no meiotic cell could be observed in the remaining patients (33%). Cytogenetically, meiotic figures could only be obtained from the two first histological groups. Meiotic abnormalities were observed in a total of 44 patients (37.6%) including nine patients (7.7%) with severe class I and class IIB anomalies and 19 patients (16.2%) with class IIC environmentally linked meiotic abnormalities. These results provided essential clues for an accurate clinical management. For patients with no meiotic figures and patients with class I and class IIB anomalies, an hormonal stimulation is illusory and a sperm gift should be directly proposed. An hormonal stimulation should be proposed to all the other patients, either directly or following the treatment of the testicular microenvironment for the patients presenting class IIC anomalies. The genetic risk and possibility of prenatal chromosomal analysis in case of pregnancy should be clearly exposed to all the couples in all the cases where type IIA, III or IV anomalies are present. This therapeutical strategy has been applied to all the patients in our series.

Reduced human germ cell-less (HGCL) expression in azoospermic men with severe germinal cell impairment

Germ cell-less (GCL) protein is a nuclear envelope protein highly conserved between the mammalian and Drosophila orthologues. In Drosophila, maternal GCL protein is required to establish the germ lineage during embryonic development. In mammals, it is suggested that the GCL function is mainly in spermatogenesis and that it might be related to the ability of mouse GCL to repress transcription. Using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction analyses, we investigated the role of human GCL (HGCL) in spermatogenesis by studying its expression in the testicular tissue of 67 azoospermic men with normal karyotype and no Y-chromosome microdeletion. Their testicular biopsy specimens underwent meticulous histological and cytological analysis as well as molecular analysis with various markers of spermatogenesis (RBM1, DAZ, and CDY1). The rate of X-Y and 18 chromosome bivalent formation during meiosis was additionally assessed in 22 of these biopsy specimens and correlated to HGCL expression. Expression of HGCL was affected in parallel with the severity of testicular impairment found. Defective sperm motility was associated with the absence of HGCL. Nevertheless, the absence of HGCL expression did not influence the normal process of chromosome bivalent formation in meiosis. Our results suggest that HGCL is not essential for the chromosomal events of meiosis but might be involved in later aspects of spermatogenesis.