Photosynthesis in Species of Flaveria CO2 Compensation Concentration, O2 Influence on Photosynthetic Gas Exchange and δ13C Values in Species of Flaveria (Asteraceae)

Russ Monson and the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Early in his career, Russ Monson produced a series of influential eco-physiological papers that helped lay the foundation for the study of C₄ plant evolution. Among the most important was a 1984 paper with Maurice Ku and Gerry Edwards that outlined the pathway for the evolutionary bridge from C₃ to C₄ photosynthesis. This model proposed C₄ photosynthesis arose out of a shuttle that imported photorespiratory metabolites into bundle sheath (BS) cells, where glycine decarboxylase cleaved off CO₂, allowing it to accumulate and be efficiently refixed by BS Rubisco. By the mid-1990's, Monson's research focus had shifted away from C₄ plants, save for one 2003 paper on C₃ versus C₄ stomatal control with Travis Huxman, and a series of critical reviews on C₄ evolution. These reviews heavily influenced the modern synthesis of C₄ evolutionary studies, which incorporates phylogenomic understanding with physiological, molecular, and structural characterizations of trait shifts in multiple evolutionary lineages. Subsequent research supported the Monson et al. model from 1984, by showing a glycine shuttle occurs in nearly all C₃-C₄ intermediate species identified. Monson also examined the physiological controls over the ecological distribution of C₃, C₃-C₄ intermediate, and C₄ photosynthesis, building our understanding of the fitness value of the intermediate and C₄ pathway in relevant microenvironments. By establishing the foundation for discoveries that followed, Russ Monson can rightly be considered a leading pioneer contributing to the evolutionary biology of C₄ photosynthesis.

Are changes in sulfate assimilation pathway needed for evolution of C4 photosynthesis?

C4 photosynthesis characteristically features a cell-specific localization of enzymes involved in CO2 assimilation in bundle sheath cells (BSC) or mesophyll cells. Interestingly, enzymes of sulfur assimilation are also specifically present in BSC of maize and many other C4 species. This localization, however, could not be confirmed in C4 species of the genus Flaveria. It was, therefore, concluded that the bundle sheath localization of sulfate assimilation occurs only in C4 monocots. However, recently the sulfate assimilation pathway was found coordinately enriched in BSC of Arabidopsis, opening new questions about the significance of such cell-specific localization of the pathway. In addition, next generation sequencing revealed expression gradients of many genes from C3 to C4 species and mathematical modeling proposed a sequence of adaptations during the evolutionary path from C3 to C4. Indeed, such gradient, with higher expression of genes for sulfate reduction in C4 species, has been observed within the genus Flaveria. These new tools provide the basis for reexamining the intriguing question of compartmentalization of sulfur assimilation. Therefore, this review summarizes the findings on spatial separation of sulfur assimilation in C4 plants and Arabidopsis, assesses the information on sulfur assimilation provided by the recent transcriptomics data and discusses their possible impact on understanding this interesting feature of plant sulfur metabolism to find out whether changes in sulfate assimilation are part of a general evolutionary trajectory toward C4 photosynthesis.

C2 photosynthesis generates about 3-fold elevated leaf CO2 levels in the C3-C4 intermediate species Flaveria pubescens

Formation of a photorespiration-based CO2-concentrating mechanism in C3-C4 intermediate plants is seen as a prerequisite for the evolution of C4 photosynthesis, but it is not known how efficient this mechanism is. Here, using in vivo Rubisco carboxylation-to-oxygenation ratios as a proxy to assess relative intraplastidial CO2 levels is suggested. Such ratios were determined for the C3-C4 intermediate species Flaveria pubescens compared with the closely related C3 plant F. cronquistii and the C4 plant F. trinervia. To this end, a model was developed to describe the major carbon fluxes and metabolite pools involved in photosynthetic-photorespiratory carbon metabolism and used quantitatively to evaluate the labelling kinetics during short-term (14)CO2 incorporation. Our data suggest that the photorespiratory CO2 pump elevates the intraplastidial CO2 concentration about 3-fold in leaves of the C3-C4 intermediate species F. pubescens relative to the C3 species F. cronquistii.

The C(4) plant lineages of planet Earth

Using isotopic screens, phylogenetic assessments, and 45 years of physiological data, it is now possible to identify most of the evolutionary lineages expressing the C(4) photosynthetic pathway. Here, 62 recognizable lineages of C(4) photosynthesis are listed. Thirty-six lineages (60%) occur in the eudicots. Monocots account for 26 lineages, with a minimum of 18 lineages being present in the grass family and six in the sedge family. Species exhibiting the C(3)-C(4) intermediate type of photosynthesis correspond to 21 lineages. Of these, 9 are not immediately associated with any C(4) lineage, indicating that they did not share common C(3)-C(4) ancestors with C(4) species and are instead an independent line. The geographic centre of origin for 47 of the lineages could be estimated. These centres tend to cluster in areas corresponding to what are now arid to semi-arid regions of southwestern North America, south-central South America, central Asia, northeastern and southern Africa, and inland Australia. With 62 independent lineages, C(4) photosynthesis has to be considered one of the most convergent of the complex evolutionary phenomena on planet Earth, and is thus an outstanding system to study the mechanisms of evolutionary adaptation.

Seasonal differences in photosynthesis between the C3 and C4 subspecies of Alloteropsis semialata are offset by frost and drought

The regional abundance of C(4) grasses is strongly controlled by temperature, however, the role of precipitation is less clear. Progress in elucidating the direct effects of photosynthetic pathway on these climate relationships is hindered by the significant genetic divergence between major C(3) and C(4) grass lineages. We addressed this problem by examining seasonal climate responses of photosynthesis in Alloteropsis semialata, a unique grass species with both C(3) and C(4) subspecies. Experimental manipulation of rainfall in a common garden in South Africa tested the hypotheses that: (1) photosynthesis is greater in the C(4) than C(3) subspecies under high summer temperatures, but this pattern is reversed at low winter temperatures; and (2) the photosynthetic advantage of C(4) plants is enhanced during drought events. Measurements of leaf gas exchange over 2 years showed a significant photosynthetic advantage for the C(4) subspecies under irrigated conditions from spring through autumn. However, the C(4) leaves were killed by winter frost, while photosynthesis continued in the C(3) plants. Unexpectedly, the C(4) subspecies also lost its photosynthetic advantage during natural drought events, despite greater water-use efficiency under irrigated conditions. This study highlights previously unrecognized roles for climatic extremes in determining the ecological success of C(3) and C(4) grasses.

The functional significance of C3-C4 intermediate traits in Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): gas exchange perspectives

We demonstrate for the first time the presence of species exhibiting C3-C4 intermediacy in Heliotropium (sensu lato), a genus with over 100 C3 and 150 C4 species. CO2 compensation points (Gamma) and photosynthetic water-use efficiencies (WUEs) were intermediate between C3 and C4 values in three species of Heliotropium: Heliotropium convolvulaceum (Gamma = 20 micromol CO2 mol(-1) air), Heliotropium racemosum (Gamma = 22 micromol mol(-1)) and Heliotropium greggii (Gamma = 17 micromol mol(-1)). Heliotropium procumbens may also be a weak C3-C4 intermediate based on a slight reduction in Gamma (48.5 micromol CO2 mol(-1)) compared to C3Heliotropium species (52-60 micromol mol(-1)). The intermediate species H. convolvulaceum, H. greggii and H. racemosum exhibited over 50% enhancement of net CO2 assimilation rates at low CO2 levels (200-300 micromol mol(-1)); however, no significant differences in stomatal conductance were observed between the C3 and C3-C4 species. We also assessed the response of Gamma to variation in O2 concentration for these species. Heliotropium convolvulaceum, H. greggii and H. racemosum exhibited similar responses of Gamma to O2 with response slopes that were intermediate between the responses of C3 and C4 species below 210 mmol O2 mol(-1) air. The presence of multiple species displaying C3-C4 intermediate traits indicates that Heliotropium could be a valuable new model for studying the evolutionary transition from C3 to C4 photosynthesis.

Leaf anatomy, gas exchange and photosynthetic enzyme activity in Flaveria kochiana

Flaveria (Asteraceae) is one of the few genera known to contain both C₃ and C₄ species, in addition to numerous biochemically-intermediate species. C₃-C₄ and C₄-like intermediate photosynthesis have arisen more than once in different phylogenetic clades of Flaveria. Here, we characterise for the first time the photosynthetic pathway of the recently described species Flaveria kochiana B.L. Turner. We examined leaf anatomy, activity and localisation of key photosynthetic enzymes, and gas exchange characteristics and compared these trait values with those from related C₄ and C₄-like Flaveria species. F. kochiana has Kranz anatomy that is typical of other C₄ Flaveria species. As in the other C₄ lineages within the Flaveria genus, the primary decarboxylating enzyme is NADP-malic enzyme. Immunolocalisation of the major C₄ cycle enzymes, PEP carboxylase and pyruvate, orthophosphate dikinase, were restricted to the mesophyll, while Rubisco was largely localised to the bundle sheath. Gas exchange analysis demonstrated that F. kochiana operates a fully functional C₄ pathway with little sensitivity to ambient oxygen levels. The CO₂ compensation point (2.2 µbar) was typical for C₄ species, and the O₂-response of the CO₂ compensation point was the same as the C₄ species F. trinervia. Notably, F. vaginata (B.L. Robinson & Greenman), a putative C₄-like species that is the nearest relative of F. kochiana, had an identical response of the CO₂ compensation point to O₂. Furthermore, F. vaginata, exhibited a carbon isotope ratio (-15.4‰) similar to C₄ species including F. australasica Hooker, F. trinervia Spreng. C. Mohr and the newly characterised F. kochiana. F. vaginata could be considered a C₄ species, but additional studies are necessary to confirm this hypothesis. In addition, our results show that F. kochiana uses an efficient C₄ cycle, with the highest initial slope of the A/C_i curve of any C₄ Flaveria species.

H-protein of glycine decarboxylase is encoded by multigene families in Flaveria pringlei and F. cronquistii (Asteraceae)

In Flaveria pringlei and F. cronquistii unlike other plants, H-protein of the glycine cleavage system is encoded by small multigene families. From leaf cDNA libraries and by reverse transcription of mRNA with subsequent polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification, we have obtained three different H-protein cDNA clones from each species. The relative levels of total H-protein mRNA, as well as of different H-protein transcripts, have been determined in leaves, stems, and roots of F. pringlei. Stems, with a total of 22% relative to leaves, contain substantial amounts of H-protein transcripts. The corresponding level in roots is relatively low (2.3% relative to leaves) but easily detectable. One of the transcripts occurs only in leaves (HFP20) and another one (HFP13) is present exclusively in photosynthesizing organs. Only one of the H-protein transcripts (HFP4) was found in all three organs, in leaves, stems, and roots of F. pringlei.

Leaf anatomical characteristics in Flaveria trinervia (C4), Flaveria brownii (C 4-like) and their F 1 hybrid

Several leaf anatomical and ultrastructural characteristics usually related with photosynthetic capacity were examined in two Flaveria species with strong differences in anatomy and their F1 hybrid. Flaveria trinervia (Spreng.) Mohr (C4) was the female parent and F. brownii A.M. Powell (C4-like) was the male parent. Quantitative anatomical analysis was made on transverse sections of leaves at both the light and electron microscope level. Four kinds of photosynthetic tissues were considered: bundle sheath (BS), mesophyll adjacent to the BS, mesophyll not adjacent to the BS, and larger spongy mesophyll cells. Flaveria trinvervia partitioned a larger proportion of its photosynthetic cells to BS and the mesophyll layer adjacent to BS and also possessed larger chloroplasts, especially in BS, than did F. brownii. These results suggest that although F. brownii is very C4-like, its anatomy is not as completely C4 as is the case for F. trinervia. In the F1 hybrid the relative contribution of the different tissues to the total photosynthetic tissue volume and area per unit leaf area was quite similar to that of F. trinervia. On the other hand, the chloroplast density and size of the F1 hybrid were fairly similar to those of F. brownii, especially in BS. Thus, there was no evidence of maternal inheritance in the chloroplast characteristics studied. A negative correlation (P<0.05) between chloroplast size and density was observed among species and relicates within each kind of tissue. This correlation was highest (r=-0.94, P<0.001) for the BS and when values were plotted on a logarithmic scale. Thus, higher chloroplast numbers for F. brownii and the F1 hybrid were offset by larger chloroplasts in F. trinervia. Less complete C4 photosynthesis in F. brownii may be partially due to incomplete development of Kranz anatomy usually associated with C4 photosynthesis.

Reassimilation of carbon dioxide by Flaveria (Asteraceae) species representing different types of photosynthesis

The capability to reassimilate CO2 originating from intracellular decarboxylating processes connected with the photorespiratory glycolate pathway and-or decarboxylation of C4 acids during C4 photosynthesis has been investigated with four species of the genus Flaveria (Asteraceae). The C3-C4 intermediate species F. pubescens and F. anomala reassimilated CO2 much more efficiently than the C3 species F. cronquistii and, with respect to this feature, behaved similarly to the C4 species F. trinervia. Therefore, under atmospheric conditions the intermediate species photorespired with rates only between 10-20% of that measured with F. cronquistii. At low oxygen concentrations (1,5%) the reassimilation potential of F. anomala approached that of F. trinervia and was distinct from that found with F. pubescens. The data are discussed with respect to a possible sequence of events during evolution of C4 photosynthesis. If compared with related data for C3-C4 intermediate species from other genera they support the hypothesis that, during evolution of C4 photosynthesis, an efficient capacity for CO2 reassimilation evolved prior to a CO2-concentrating mechanism.

Co-function of C3-and C 4-photosynthetic pathways in C3, C 4 and C 3-C 4 intermediate Flaveria species

The potential for C4 photosynthesis was investigated in five C3-C4 intermediate species, one C3 species, and one C4 species in the genus Flaveria, using (14)CO2 pulse-(12)CO2 chase techniques and quantum-yield measurements. All five intermediate species were capable of incorporating (14)CO2 into the C4 acids malate and aspartate, following an 8-s pulse. The proportion of (14)C label in these C4 products ranged from 50-55% to 20-26% in the C3-C4 intermediates F. floridana Johnston and F. linearis Lag. respectively. All of the intermediate species incorporated as much, or more, (14)CO2 into aspartate as into malate. Generally, about 5-15% of the initial label in these species appeared as other organic acids. There was variation in the capacity for C4 photosynthesis among the intermediate species based on the apparent rate of conversion of (14)C label from the C4 cycle to the C3 cycle. In intermediate species such as F. pubescens Rydb., F. ramosissima Klatt., and F. floridana we observed a substantial decrease in label of C4-cycle products and an increase in percentage label in C3-cycle products during chase periods with (12)CO2, although the rate of change was slower than in the C4 species, F. palmeri. In these C3-C4 intermediates both sucrose and fumarate were predominant products after a 20-min chase period. In the C3-C4 intermediates, F. anomala Robinson and f. linearis we observed no significant decrease in the label of C4-cycle products during a 3-min chase period and a slow turnover during a 20-min chase, indicating a lower level of functional integration between the C4 and C3 cycles in these species, relative to the other intermediates. Although F. cronquistii Powell was previously identified as a C3 species, 7-18% of the initial label was in malate+aspartate. However, only 40-50% of this label was in the C-4 position, indicating C4-acid formation as secondary products of photosynthesis in F. cronquistii. In 21% O2, the absorbed quantum yields for CO2 uptake (in mol CO2·[mol quanta](-1)) averaged 0.053 in F. cronquistii (C3), 0.051 in F. trinervia (Spreng.) Mohr (C4), 0.052 in F. ramosissima (C3-C4), 0.051 in F. anomala (C3-C4), 0.050 in F. linearis (C3-C4), 0.046 in F. floridana (C3-C4), and 0.044 in F. pubescens (C3-C4). In 2% O2 an enhancement of the quantum yield was observed in all of the C3-C4 intermediate species, ranging from 21% in F. ramosissima to 43% in F. pubescens. In all intermediates the quantum yields in 2% O2 were intermediate in value to the C3 and C4 species, indicating a co-function of the C3 and C4 cycles in CO2 assimilation. The low quantum-yield values for F. pubescens and F. floridana in 21% O2 presumably reflect an ineffcient transfer of carbon from the C4 to the C3 cycle. The response of the quantum yield to four increasing O2 concentrations (2-35%) showed lower levels of O2 inhibition in the C3-C4 intermediate F. ramosissima, relative to the C3 species. This indicates that the co-function of the C3 and C4 cycles in this intermediate species leads to an increased CO2 concentration at the site of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase and a concomitant decrease in the competitive inhibition by O2.

Molecular properties of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase from C3, C 3-C 4 intermediate, and C 4 Flaveria species

Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPCase; EC 4.1.1.31) from Flaveria trinervia Mohr (C4), F. floridana Johnston (C3-C4), and F. cronquistii Powell (C3) leaves were compared by electrotransfer blotting/enzyme-linked immunoassay (Western-blot analysis), mobility of the native enzyme in polyacrylamide gels and in isoelectric focusing (IEF) gels, peptide mapping, and in-vitro translation of RNA isolated from each plant. The PEPCases from the C3 and C3-C4 plants were very similar to each other in terms of electrophoretic mobilities on gels and isoenzyme patterns on IEF gels, and identical in peptide mapping. Quantitative differences were noted, however, in that the C3-C4 intermediate plant contained more PEPCase overall and that the relative activity of individual isoenzymes shifted between the C3 and C3-C4 intermediate PEPCases. The PEPCase from the C4 plant had a different isoenzyme pattern, a different peptide map, and was far more abundant than the other two enzymes. Western blot analysis demonstrated the cross-reactivity of PEPCases from all three Flaveria species with antibody raised against maize PEPCase. The results provide evidence, at the molecular level, that supports the view of C3-C4 intermediate species as C3-like plants with some C4-like photosynthetic characteristics, but there are differences from the C3 plant in the quantity and properties of the PEPCase from the C3-C4 intermediate plant.

Photosynthetic/photorespiratory characteristics of C3-C 4 intermediate species

The extent of photorespiration, the inhibition of apparent photosynthesis (APS) by 21% O2, and the leaf anatomical and ultrastructural features of the naturally occurring C3-C4 intermediate species in the diverse Panicum, Moricandia, and Flaveria genera are between those features of representative C3 and C4 plants. The greatest differences between the photosynthetic/photorespiratory CO2 exchange characteristics of the C3-C4 intermediates and C3 plants occur for the parameters which are measured at low pCO2 (i.e., the CO2 compensation concentration and rates of CO2 evolution into CO2-free air in the light). The rates of APS by the intermediate species at atmospheric pCO2 are similar to those of C3 plants.The mechanisms which are responsible for reducing photorespiration in the C3-C4 intermediate species are poorly understood, but two proposals have been advanced. One emphasizes the importance of limited C4 photosynthesis which reduces O2 fixation by ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase, and, thus, reduces photorespiration by a CO2-concentrating mechanism, while the other emphasizes the importance of the internal recycling of photorespiratory CO2 evolved from the chloroplast/mitochondrion-containing bundle-sheath cells. There is no evidence from recent studies that limited C4 photosynthesis is responsible for reducing photorespiration in the intermediate Panicum and Moricandia species. However, preliminary results suggest that some, but not all, of the intermediate Flaveria species may possess a limited C4 cycle. The importance of a chlorophyllous bundle-sheath layer in the leaves of intermediate Panicum and Moricandia species in a mechanism based on the recycling of photorespiratory CO2 is uncertain.Therefore, although they have yet to be clearly delineated, different strategies appear to exist in the C3-C4 intermediate group to reduce photorespiration. Of major importance is the finding that some mechanism(s) other than Crassulacean acid metabolism or C4 photosynthesis has (have) evolved in at least the majority of these terrestrial intermediate species to reduce the seemingly wasteful metabolic process of photorespiration.

C3-C 4 Intermediate species in the genus Flaveria: leaf anatomy, ultrastructure, and the effect of O2 on the CO 2 compensation concentration

Leaf anatomical, ultrastructural, and CO2-exchange analyses of three closely related species of Flaveria indicate that they are C3-C4 intermediate plants. The leaf mesophyll of F. floridana J.R. Johnston, F. linearis Lag., and F. chloraefolia A. Gray is typical of that in dicotyledonous C3 plants, but the bundle sheath cells contain granal, starch-containing chloroplasts. In F. floridana and F. chloraefolia, the chloroplasts and numerous associated mitochondria are arranged largely centripetally, as in the closely related C4 species, F. brownii A.M. Powell. In F. linearis, fewer mitochondria are present and the chloroplasts are more evenly distributed throughout the bundle sheath cytosol. There is no correlation between the bundle sheath ultrastructure and CO2 compensation concentration. (Γ) values of these C3-C4 intermediate Flaveria species. At 21% O2 and 25°C, Γ for F. chloraefolia, F. linearis, and F. floridana is 23-26, 14-19, and 8-10 μl CO2 l(-1), respectively. The O2 dependence of Γ is the greatest for F. chloraefolia and F. linearis (similar to that for C3-C4 intermediate Panicum and Moricandia species) and the least for F. floridana, whose O2 response is identical to that for F. brownii from 1.5 to 21% O2, but greater at higher pO2. The variation in leaf anatomy, bundle sheath ultrastructure, and O2 dependence of Γ among these Flaveria species may indicate an active evolution in the pathway of photosynthetic carbon metabolism within this genus.