Characterization of a human locus in transition

Sperm cellular and nuclear dynamics associated with bull fertility

The objective of this study was to ascertain cellular characteristics and the dynamics of the sperm chromatin proteins protamine 1 (PRM1) and protamine 2 (PRM2) in the sperm of Holstein bulls having a different fertility status. Important sperm variables were analyzed using computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA). Sperm membrane, acrosome status, DNA integrity were also assessed using propidium iodide (PI), fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugated to Arachis hypogaea (FITC-PNA), and acridine orange (AO) followed by flow cytometry. In addition, abundances of PRM1 and PRM2 were analyzed using flow cytometry experiments. Differences in sperm decondensation capacity were assessed in bulls of varying fertility using a decondensation assay. As determined using CASA, average pathway velocity, amplitude of lateral head displacement and straightness were different (P < 0.05) for sperm from high and low fertility bulls. There, however, were no differences between the high and low fertility bulls for characteristics of sperm plasma membrane, acrosome, and DNA integrity (P >  0.05). Relative abundances of PRM1 and PRM2 in sperm from the high and low fertility bulls were inversely related (P <  0.0001). Percentages of decondensed sperm were different between high and low fertility bulls (P < 0.0001) and total numbers of decondensed sperm were greater in low fertility bulls than high fertility bulls (R² = 0.72). Results of the present study are significant because molecular and morphological phenotypes of sperm that were detected affect fertility in livestock species.

Sperm nuclear protamines: A checkpoint to control sperm chromatin quality

Protamines are nuclear proteins which are specifically expressed in haploid male germ cells. Their replacement of histones and binding to DNA is followed by chromatin hypercondensation that protects DNA from negative influences by environmental factors. Mammalian sperm contain two types of protamines: PRM1 and PRM2. While the proportion of the two protamines is highly variable between different species, abnormal ratios within a species are known to be associated with male subfertility. Therefore, it is more than likely that correct protamine expression represents a kind of chromatin checkpoint during sperm development rendering protamines as suitable biomarkers for the estimation of sperm quality. This review presents an overview of our current knowledge on protamines comparing gene and protein structures between different mammalian species with particular consideration given to man, mouse and stallion. At last, recent insights into the possible role of inherited sperm histones for early embryo development are provided.

Interrogating the transgenic genome: development of an interspecies tiling array

A single expressing copy of the human protamine domain was randomly inserted into an intron of Cyp2c38. The transgenic locus was shown to recapitulate the level of expression observed in normal human testis while not perturbing endogenous protamine expression. The development of an interspecies tiling array was pursued to enable direct comparison of the orthologous protamine domains in a single experiment. Probe design was adapted to generate species-specific high resolution probe sets that would tolerate repetitive elements. Results from competitive hybridizations demonstrate that interspecies tiling arrays are a valuable tool for parallel analysis of highly similar DNA sequences. This approach provides a rapid and reliable means of interrogating samples prior to deep sequencing analysis. These arrays should readily compliment most DNA isolation and analysis techniques such as ChIP, nuclease sensitivity and nuclear matrix association assays.

Conservation of the PRM1→PRM2→TNP2 Domain

In mouse and human, the genes encoding protamines PRM1, PRM2 and transition protein TNP2 are found clustered together on chromosome 16. In addition, these three genes lie in the same orientation to one another and are coordinately expressed in a haploid-specific manner during spermatogenesis. Previously, we have shown that the human PRM1 --> PRM2 --> TNP2 locus exists as a single chromatin domain bounded by two male germ cell-specific MARs, i.e. Matrix Attachment Regions. A third, somatic-specific MAR element lies immediately 3' of the PRM1 --> PRM2 --> TNP2 domain. This MAR maps to a conserved CpG island 5' of the human SOCS-1 gene. Similarly, two candidate MARs flank the mouse Prm1 --> Prm2 --> Tnp2 domain. Comparative analysis of the mouse and human promoter regions identified several conserved regulatory motifs for each of the genes of this cluster. This further establishes the synteny of this region. Global structural similarities and the functional relevance of the associated candidate regulatory elements are discussed.

The KLAB Toolbox: a suite of in-house software applications for epigenetic analysis

Systems biology presents a new paradigm for elucidating the processes required to organize and sustain life. We now have access to whole genome sequences, gene expression data for multiple cell types, and databases for regulatory elements governing these genes. These resources make it feasible to identify conserved genomic sequences across multiple species, transcription factors regulating the expression of genes with similar expression patterns within a given cell type and to compare expression levels of specific genes between normal and diseased cellular states. In order to utilize this wealth of information, new computational tools that integrate these datasets in a genome-wide context are required. Using the protamine cluster as an example, we present a series of in-house applications that we have developed to integrate, contextualize and visualize datasets across multiple hierarchies.

Premature translation of transition protein 2 mRNA causes sperm abnormalities and male infertility

During mammalian spermiogenesis somatic histones are replaced at first by transition proteins, which are in turn replaced by the protamines, forming the sperm nucleoprotamines. It is believed that transition protein 2 (Tnp2) is necessary for maintaining the normal processing of protamines and, consequently, the completion of chromatin condensation. The transition protein mRNAs are stored in translationally inert messenger ribonucleoprotein particles for up to 7 days until translational activation in elongated spermatids. Substantial evidence suggests an involvement of 3'untranslated region (UTR) in the translational regulation of the Tnp2 mRNAs. In order to determine the role of Tnp2 3'UTR in translational regulation and to study whether the translational repression of Tnp2 mRNA is necessary for normal spermatid differentiation in mice, we generated transgenic mice that carry a Tnp2-hGH transgene. In this transgene, 3'UTR of Tnp2 gene was replaced by 3' 3'UTR of human growth hormone gene. In these transgenic animals, transcription and translation of Tnp2 occur simultaneously in round spermatids which is an evidence for involvement of Tnp2 3'UTR in its translation repression. Premature translation of Tnp2 mRNA caused abnormal head morphogenesis, reduced sperm motility and male infertility. These results show clearly that a strict temporal and stage-specific Tnp2 translation is necessary for the correct differentiation of round spermatids into mature spermatozoa and for male fertility.

Protamines and male infertility

Protamines are the major nuclear sperm proteins. The human sperm nucleus contains two types of protamine: protamine 1 (P1) encoded by a single-copy gene and the family of protamine 2 (P2) proteins (P2, P3 and P4), all also encoded by a single gene that is transcribed and translated into a precursor protein. The protamines were discovered more than a century ago, but their function is not yet fully understood. In fact, different hypotheses have been proposed: condensation of the sperm nucleus into a compact hydrodynamic shape, protection of the genetic message delivered by the spermatozoa, involvement in the processes maintaining the integrity and repair of DNA during or after the nucleohistone-nucleoprotamine transition and involvement in the epigenetic imprinting of the spermatozoa. Protamines are also one of the most variable proteins found in nature, with data supporting a positive Darwinian selection. Changes in the expression of P1 and P2 protamines have been found to be associated with infertility in man. Mutations in the protamine genes have also been found in some infertile patients. Transgenic mice defective in the expression of protamines also present several structural defects in the sperm nucleus and have variable degrees of infertility. There is also evidence that altered levels of protamines may result in an increased susceptibility to injury in the spermatozoan DNA causing infertility or poor outcomes in assisted reproduction. The present work reviews the articles published to date on the relationship between protamines and infertility.

A novel mechanism of protamine expression deregulation highlighted by abnormal protamine transcript retention in infertile human males with sperm protamine deficiency

Sperm protamine deficiency has been associated with human male infertility. However, the aetiology of deregulated protamine expression remains elusive. The objective of this study was to evaluate the underlying aetiology of protamine deficiency in male infertility patients with deregulated protamine expression. Protamine-1 (P1) and protamine-2 (P2) protein concentrations were compared against P1 and P2 mRNA levels in the sperm of 166 male infertility patients and 27 men of known fertility. Protamine protein concentrations were quantified by nuclear protein extraction, gel electrophoresis and densitometry analysis. Semi-quantitative real-time RT-PCR was used to quantify P1 and P2 mRNA levels. P1 mRNA concentrations were significantly increased in patients underexpressing P1 protein versus those with normal and increased P1 levels. In patients with an abnormally low ratio of P1 to P2 (P1/P2 <0.8), there was a significant increase in P1 mRNA retention. Patients underexpressing P2 also had significantly increased mean P2 mRNA levels, although the majority of these P2-deficient patients showed an increased frequency of significantly reduced P2 mRNA levels. This is the first study to concomitantly evaluate P1 and P2 protein and mRNA levels in mature human sperm. Abnormally elevated protamine mRNA retention appears to be associated with aberrant protamine expression in infertile human males. These data suggest that defects in protamine translation regulation may contribute to protamine deficiency in infertile males.

Identification and evaluation of a novel sperm protamine abnormality in a population of infertile males

BACKGROUND

A significant relationship exists between an abnormally high sperm protamine-1 (P1)/protamine-2 (P2) ratio and male infertility. In this study we investigate whether a decreased P1/P2 ratio is also linked to male infertility and we attempt to describe, at the protein expression level, the underlying cause of sperm P1/P2 deregulation.

METHODS

P1 and P2 protein concentrations were quantified in sperm from 272 infertility patients and 87 fertile donors. P1/P2 ratios and protamine quantity were correlated with fertility status using semen analysis, sperm penetration capacity, and IVF data.

RESULTS

We identified four distinct groups in the study: normal P1/P2 fertile donors, normal P1/P2 patients, low P1/P2 patients, and high P1/P2 patients. P1 and P2 were both under-expressed in patients with a normal P1/P2 ratio, but not in fertile donors. In patients with a low P1/P2 ratio, P1 was under-expressed while P2 was over-expressed; in patients with a high P1/P2 ratio, P1 was normally expressed and P2 was under-expressed. Patients with abnormal P1/P2 ratios displayed significantly reduced semen quality and sperm penetration ability.

CONCLUSIONS

We have identified a novel population of infertile males with a reduced P1/P2 ratio. Aberrant P1/P2 ratios arise from an abnormal concentration of P1 and/or P2, either of which is associated with male infertility.

Testisin, a Glycosyl-Phosphatidylinositol–Linked Serine Protease, Promotes Malignant Transformation In vitro and In vivo

Human testisin, a serine protease, is highly expressed in ovarian cancer and premeiotic spermatocytes with relatively little expression in other normal tissues. We first showed that testisin was localized on the surface of cultured tumor cells as a glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol–linked protein. We next explored the biological function of testisin in malignant transformation through manipulation of testisin expression in cell culture model systems. Small interfering RNA–mediated knockdown of endogenous testisin mRNA and protein expression in tumor cell lines led to increased apoptosis and diminished growth in soft agar. Conversely, overexpression of testisin in an epithelial cell line induced colony formation in soft agar as well as s.c. tumor growth in severe combined immunodeficient mice. A catalytic domain mutant was unable to induce soft-agar growth indicating that testisin protease activity is required for transformation. Ectopic expression of testisin in a human ovarian cancer cell line without endogenous testisin expression, led to the formation of larger tumors in severe combined immunodeficient mice. Data presented here provide the first demonstration that testisin can promote cellular processes that drive malignant transformation. Our functional data coupled with the restricted normal tissue distribution of testisin and its overexpression in a majority of ovarian cancers validates this cell surface protein as a target for therapeutic intervention.

Nuclear Matrix Interactions at the Human Protamine Domain

The compact eukaryotic genome must be selectively opened to grant trans-factor access to cis-regulatory elements to overcome the primary barrier to gene transcription. The mechanism that governs the selective opening of chromatin domains (i.e. potentiation) remains poorly understood. In the absence of a well defined locus control region, the nuclear matrix is considered the primary candidate regulating the opening of the multigenic PRM1 --> PRM2 --> TNP2 human protamine domain. To directly examine its role, four lines of transgenic mice with different configurations of flanking nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) encompassing the protamine domain were created. We show that upon removal of the MARs, the locus becomes subject to position effects. The 3' MAR alone may be sufficient to protect against silencing. In concert, the MARs bounding this domain likely synergize to regulate the expression of the various members of this gene cluster. Interestingly, the MARs may convey a selective reproductive advantage, such that constructs bearing both 5' and 3' MARs are passed to their offspring with greater frequency. Thus, the MARs bounding the PRM1 --> PRM2 --> TNP2 protamine domain have many and varied functions.

A complex population of RNAs exists in human ejaculate spermatozoa: implications for understanding molecular aspects of spermiogenesis

The presence of mRNAs in human ejaculate spermatozoa is well established, yet little is known of the representation or function of these transcripts. To address these issues, the complexity of spermatozoal RNA was examined. As expected, testis-expressed mRNAs were detected by RT-PCR in mature human spermatozoa. Interestingly, when a testis cDNA library was probed with total spermatozoal RNA, less than 2% of plaques gave a strong hybridization signal, suggesting a rather unique sperm-derived population. To further define the sequence distribution, 18 strongly hybridizing clones were selected at random for end-sequence analysis. Twelve matched unique sequences in the EST, STS and NR databases, whereas five showed no similarity to any of the sequences in the databases. In addition, one clone belonged to the SINE repetitive element family. As demonstrated by sequencing randomly primed cloned inserts, short (SINE/MER) or long (LINE/ORF2) interspersed repeat-like sequences are also contained as part of the spermatozoal RNA fraction. It is now evident that human spermatozoa contain a rich repertoire of both known and unknown protein-encoding and non-coding RNAs. This provides a unique opportunity to identify and investigate the many genes responsible for the structure and function/dysfunction of the male gamete using spermatozoal RNA as the template.

Temporal expression of the transgenic human protamine gene cluster

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain the fidelity of expression of the genes from the transgenic human sperm-specific nuclear packaging protamine-1-->protamine-2-->transition protein-2 (PRM1-->PRM2-->TNP2) locus.

DESIGN

Controlled human transgene study.

SETTING

Basic science laboratory.

ANIMAL(S)

Age-matched transgenic and nontransgenic mice.

INTERVENTION(S)

Transgenic mice containing the human protamine locus were mated. One testis from each offspring was frozen at -80 degrees C and the other was preserved in formalin.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The temporal expression of the human and mouse protamines was evaluated by Northern blot analysis. Orientation of the transgenic locus was determined by Southern blot analysis. Tissue morphology was assessed histologically.

RESULT(S)

Conservation of transgenic morphology was confirmed. Head-to-tail integration of the PRM1--> PRM2-->TNP2 locus was shown. Temporal expression of the mouse and human protamine genes was maintained in the transgenic state.

CONCLUSION(S)

These results show that the head-to-tail concatomer of the PRMI-->PRM2-->TNP2 locus contains all the necessary elements for appropriate temporal expression while maintaining testicular structure and function.

Human periplakin: genomic organization in a clonally unstable region of chromosome 16p with an abundance of repetitive sequence elements

Periplakin, a member of the plakin family of proteins, has been recently characterized by cDNA cloning, and the corresponding gene, PPL, has been mapped to human chromosome 16p13.3 (Aho et al., 1998, Genomics 48: 242-247). Periplakin has also been shown to serve as an autoantigen in a malignancy-associated autoimmune blistering disease, paraneoplastic pemphigus (Mahoney et al., 1998, J. Invest. Dermatol. 111: 308-313). In this study, we have elucidated the intron-exon organization of human PPL and characterized its promoter region. The flanking 5' sequences were rich in G and C ( approximately 80%) and included multiple AP2 sites and a SP1 site, while no canonical TATA or CCAAT sequences were found. The functionality of the upstream sequences (-709 to +135) as a promoter in cultured epidermal keratinocytes was detected by a CAT reporter gene, and a limited region (-382 to +135) showed activity in cultured dermal fibroblasts, attesting to cell-type specificity of the promoter. The genomic organization, including the intron-exon borders, was determined by direct nucleotide sequencing of human genomic P1 clones. Comparative analysis of cDNA and genomic sequences revealed that PPL consists of 22 exons, with the distribution of exons in PPL being consistent with that of other plakin genes: 21 small exons, separated by large introns, encode the amino-terminal globular domain, and 1 large exon encodes the entire rod and the tail domains. Characterization of four P1 clones spanning the PPL locus revealed multiple Alu repeats, 20 of them within 33 kb of the entirely sequenced segments (0.60/kb), in addition to numerous MIR and L1 elements. These repetitive elements could lead to the clonal instability detected throughout the genomic P1 clones and may give rise to the genomic rearrangements possibly underlying the paraneoplastic pemphigus.

Genesis of a novel human sequence from the protamine PRM1 gene

The members of the male haploid expressed protamine 1 (PRM1)-->protamine 2 (PRM2)-->transition protein 2 (TNP2) locus exist as a single, coordinately expressed genic domain. Previous analysis has revealed that the genes within the human PRM1-->PRM2-->TNP2 domain are inter-related, as they share significant sequence similarity at both the nucleotide and amino acid levels. Analysis described here supports the view that a fourth candidate coding region, gene4/Prm3, was derived from PRM1 during the genesis of the PRM1-->PRM2-->TNP2 domain. In some species, gene4 has diverged to a great extent, which can limit its expression.

Genomic analysis of the mouse protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 gene cluster reveals hypermethylation in expressing cells

To understand the role of chromatin structure in the expression of the mouse protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 genes during spermatogenesis, we have examined the genomic organization of this cluster of "haploid-specific" genes. As seen in the human genome, protamine 2, transition protein 2, and approximately 2.8 kb of a CpG island, hereafter called CpG island-dTP2, were clustered in a small region. Methylation analyses of this region have demonstrated that i) unlike most other tissue-specific genes, the protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 genes were located in a large methylated domain in round spermatids, the cell type where they are transcribed, ii) the protamine 1 gene was only partially methylated in somatic cells and in testes from 7-day-old mice, and iii) the approximately 2 kb upstream and downstream of the CpG island-dTP2 were only partially methylated in somatic tissues. DNase I analysis revealed the presence of at least five strong DNase I hypersensitive sites over the CpG island-dTP2 in somatic tissues, but not in germ cells, and sequence analysis indicated that the CpG island-dTP2 is homologous to a CpG island located approximately 10.6 kb downstream of the human transition protein 2 gene. Although the nature of a CpG island-dTP2 and the function of a CpG island-dTP2-containing somatic tissue-specific DNase I hypersensitive sites in close proximity to the germ cell-specific gene cluster are unclear, the "open" chromatin structure of the CpG island-dTP2 may be responsible for the partial methylation pattern of the flanking sequences including the transition protein 2 gene in somatic tissues.

The use of cloned repetitive sequences as hybridization competitors to detect single copy sequences

To suppress background hybridization due to repetitive sequence elements, competitor Alu containing clones were isolated from a subclone library of human cosmid clone hP3.1. Pre-annealing of the probe-with this competitor increased the signal well above background. In comparison, the addition of the competitor directly to both the prehybridization and hybridization solution was more effective in reducing background. This dramatically increased the signal to noise ratio of the specific hybridization event. Application to fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) is readily apparent.

Nuclear matrix interactions within the sperm genome

Analysis of the haploid-expressed human PRM1 --> PRM2 --> TNP2 genic domain has revealed two regions of attachment to the sperm nuclear matrix. These sperm nuclear matrix attachment regions delimit the DNase I-sensitive domain of this haploid-expressed locus. The domain is intermediately associated with but not attached to the nuclear matrix. DNase I-sensitive genes within the mature sperm nucleus, such as protamine 1, protamine 2, transition protein 2, alpha-globin, and beta-actin, display this intermediate affinity for the sperm nuclear matrix. This may denote their role in templating the male genome prior to fertilization, thus ensuring the formation of a viable male pronucleus during early embryonic development.

Sequence analysis of the conserved protamine gene cluster shows that it contains a fourth expressed gene

Structural data are presented on the protamine gene cluster (PGC) of human, mouse, rat, and bull. By restriction mapping we demonstrate that the organization of the protamine cluster is conserved throughout all four species, i.e., the genes are situated in a head to tail arrangement in the order: protamine 1-protamine 2-transition protein 2. Further, we established the nucleotide sequence of the entire human PGC (25 kb in total) and the 3' portion of the rat protamine cluster (PRM2 and TNP2 genes and intergenic region). In addition, a 1 kb fragment of the bovine and murine protamine cluster, situated between PRM2 and TNP2, was sequenced. This fragment is conserved regarding sequence, position, and orientation in all species examined, and was classified as likely coding region by gene recognition program GRAIL. Using the rat fragment as a probe in RNA blots, we detected a testis-specific signal of about 0.5 kb. Finally, we demonstrate a high density of Alu elements, both full and fragmented copies, in the human PGC and discuss their localization with respect to evolutionary and functional aspects.

A haploid expressed gene cluster exists as a single chromatin domain in human sperm

Mammalian spermiogenesis is marked by the initial disruption of the nuclear-histone-DNA complex by the transition proteins for ultimate replacement with protamines. The genes for three of these low molecular weight basic nuclear proteins exist as a single linear array of PRM1, PRM2, and TNP2 on human chromosome 16p13.2. To begin to address the mechanism governing their transcriptional potentiation, a region of approximately 40 kilo-bases of the human genome encompassing these genes was introduced into the germ line of mice. Fluorescence in situ hybridization and Southern analysis showed that this segment of the human genome integrated into independent chromosomal sites while maintaining its fidelity. Transcript analysis demonstrated that the expression of the endogenous mouse protamine Prm1 and Prm2 genes as well as the mouse transition protein Tnp2 gene were expressed along with their human transgene counterparts. The pattern of expression of these transgenic human genes within this multigenic cluster faithfully represented that observed in vivo. In addition, all members of this transgenic gene cluster were expressed in proportions similar to those in human testis. Copy number-dependent and position-independent expression of the transgenic construct demonstrated that the corresponding biological locus was contained within this segment of the human genome. Furthermore, DNase I sensitivity established that in sperm the human PRM1-->PRM2-->TNP2 genic domain was contained as an approximately 28.5-kilobase contiguous segment bounded by an array of nuclear matrix associated topoisomerase II consensus sites. This is the first description of a multigenic male gamete-specific domain as a fundamental gene regulatory unit. A model of haploid-specific gene determination is presented.

Computer assisted promoter analysis of a human sperm specific nucleoprotein gene cluster

The promoter regions of the clustered human spermatid-specific nucleoprotein PRM1, PRM2 arid TNP2 genes were compared to define regulatory elements that may govern their expression. Sequence alignment revealed two wll conserved motifs, despite a lack of extensive homology. They are located at similar positions within the first 400 nt of their 5' UTRs. Conservation of these motifs may reflect selective evolutionary pressure to maintain their structure. This supports the view that these elements assume a central role in the coordinate regulation of this gene cluster during spermiogenesis. The distribution of binding sites of known transcription factors was also assessed within the regions flanking the 5' ends of these genes. This analysis should prove useful in directing studies that define the signals necessary for the coordinate regulation of this spermatid specific gene cluster.