Sequence-specific Binding of Arc Repressor to DNA

Computational and experimental probes of symmetry mismatches in the Arc repressor-DNA complex

Arc repressor from bacteriophage P22 is a homodimeric member of the ribbon-helix-helix family of transcription factors. Two dimers bind cooperatively to adjacent sites on operator DNA with the antiparallel beta-sheet of each Arc dimer contacting the major groove. Despite the 2-fold symmetry of the dimer, the sequence of the DNA half-site is not symmetric, and thus there is an inherent symmetry mismatch in the complex. Here, using a combination of computational and experimental methods, we further characterize this symmetry mismatch. Continuum electrostatic calculations show that the DNA-contacting side-chains of Gln9, Asn11 and Arg13 each make better electrostatic interactions in one subunit of the Arc dimer than in the other. Based on the computational results, one or both Gln9 side-chains were substituted with Arg or His and Asn11 was similarly substituted with Ile in the context of a single-chain variant of Arc repressor. Although the double mutants that maintain the symmetry of the protein bind much more weakly than scArc, mutants with single Q9R or N11I substitutions bind operator DNA with affinities close to wild-type. Whereas the effects are nearly additive for the mutations at position 9, the effects of single N11I mutations are non-additive. The calculations thus enabled the identification of functionally tolerated mutations in the DNA-binding surface of Arc repressor, which in turn revealed energetic consequences of asymmetric environments in this protein-DNA interaction.

The F plasmid traY gene product binds DNA as a monomer or a dimer: structural and functional implications

The F factor traY gene product (TraYp) is a site-specific DNA-binding protein involved in initiation of DNA transfer during bacterial conjugation. The sequence of TraYp exhibits a unique direct-repeat structure predicted to have a ribbon-helix-helix DNA-binding motif in each repeat unit. The stoichiometry of TraYp binding to DNA was determined to further support the hypothesis that TraYp is a member of the ribbon-helix-helix family of DNA-binding proteins. A glutathione-S-transferase-traY fusion protein was purified and shown to possess almost wild-type DNA-binding activity. DNA-binding experiments were performed in which the DNA ligand was incubated with either the fusion protein, the wild-type protein, or both. The results indicate that TraYp can bind DNA as a monomer or a dimer. Thus a TraYp monomer folds into a stable three-dimensional structure similar to that of a dimer of the ribbon-helix-helix proteins Arc or Mnt. A homology model of a TraYp monomer has been constructed using the co-crystal structure of Arc bound to DNA as a template to provide additional support for this conclusion. In addition, we have shown that an origin of the transfer-deletion mutant lacking approximately half of the TraYp-binding site can only be bound by a monomer of TraYp. The functional implications of this result are discussed.

Dramatic changes in DNA-binding specificity caused by single residue substitutions in an Arc/Mnt hybrid repressor

Arc and Mnt are homologous repressors which recognize operator sequences that differ at 8-10 important positions. Nevertheless, single residue changes in an Arc/Mnt hybrid protein can switch DNA-binding specificity between the two operators and even allow one particular hybrid to bind strongly to both operators. The ability of single residue changes to radically alter binding specificity involves: 'master' residues that mediate some base contacts directly and some base contacts indirectly through residue-residue hydrogen bonds; identical residues which can make alternative sets of DNA contacts in the two operators; and amplification of the effect of each mutation because the proteins bind operator DNA as tetramers.

DNA recognition by beta-sheets in the Arc repressor-operator crystal structure

Transcription of the ant gene during lytic growth of bacteriophage P22 (ref. 1) is regulated by the cooperative binding of two Arc repressor dimers to a 21-base-pair operator site. Here we report the co-crystal structure of this Arc tetramer-operator complex at 2.6 A resolution. As expected from genetic and structural studies and from the co-crystal structure of the homologous Escherichia coli MetJ repressor, each Arc dimer uses an antiparallel beta-sheet to recognize bases in the major groove. However, the Arc and MetJ complexes differ in several important ways: the beta-sheet-DNA interactions of Arc are far less symmetrical; DNA binding by Arc is accompanied by important conformational changes in the beta-sheet; and Arc uses a different part of its protein surface for dimer-dimer interactions.

Energy coupling between DNA binding and subunit association is responsible for the specificity of DNA-Arc interaction

The effects of several DNA molecules on the free energy of subunit association of Arc repressor were measured. The association studies under equilibrium conditions were performed by the dissociating perturbation of hydrostatic pressure. The magnitude of stabilization of the subunit interaction was determined by the specificity of the protein-DNA interaction. Operator DNA stabilized the free energy of association by about 2.2 kcal/mol of monomeric unit, whereas poly(dG-dC) stabilized the subunit interaction by only 0.26 kcal. Measurements of the stabilizing free energy at different DNA concentrations revealed a stoichiometry of two dimers per 21 bp for the operator DNA sequence and for the nonspecific DNA poly(dA-dT). However, the maximum stabilization was much larger for operator sequence (delta p = 1,750 bar) as compared for poly(dA-dT) (delta p = 750 bar). The importance of the free-energy linkage for the recognition process was corroborated by its absence in a mutant Arc protein (PL8) that binds to operator and nonspecific DNA sequences with equal, low affinity. We conclude that the coupling accounts for the high specificity of the Arc-operator DNA interaction. We hypothesize a mutual coupling between the protein subunits and the two DNA strands, in which the much higher persistency of the associated form when Arc is bound to operator would stabilize the interactions between the two DNA strands.

Assembly of the Arc repressor-operator complex: cooperative interactions between DNA-bound dimers

Arc repressor, a member of the beta-ribbon family of DNA binding proteins, binds to its 21-base-pair operator as a tetramer. Here, the Arc dimer is shown to bind specifically to DNA fragments containing operator half-sites, and the equilibrium and kinetic constants for these reactions are determined. DNA-bound dimers are also shown to be transient intermediates in association experiments, indicating that assembly of the Arc tetramer-operator complex occurs by sequential addition of dimers to operator half-sites. When the left or right operator half-site is occupied by an Arc dimer, cooperative interactions increase the affinity of the second dimer by approximately 5900-fold [delta delta G = -5.1 (+/- 0.5) kcal/mol]. This increase in affinity is largely caused by an increase in the half-life of the complex; "non-cooperatively" bound dimers dissociate with a half-life of a few seconds while "cooperatively" bound dimers have half-lives of more than 1 h.

Structure of Arc repressor in solution: evidence for a family of beta-sheet DNA-binding proteins

The Arc repressor, which is involved in the switch between lysis and lysogeny of Salmonella bacteriophage P22, does not belong to any of the known classes of DNA-binding proteins. Mutagenesis studies show that the DNA-binding region is located in the 15 N-terminal amino-acid residues. We have now determined the three-dimensional structure of the Arc dimer from an extensive set of interproton-distance data obtained from 1H NMR spectroscopy. A priori, intra- and inter-monomer nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs) cannot be distinguished for a symmetric dimer. But by using the homology with the Escherichia coli Met repressor we could interpret the NOEs unambiguously in an iterative structure refinement procedure. The final structure satisfies a large set of NOE constraints (1,352 for the dimer). It shows a strongly intertwined dimer, in which residues 8-14 of different monomers form an antiparallel beta-sheet. A model for the Arc repressor-operator complex can account for all available biochemical and genetic data. In this model two Arc dimers bind with their beta-sheet regions in successive major grooves on one side of the DNA helix, similar to the Met repressor interaction. Thus, Arc and Met repressors are members of the same family of proteins, which contain an antiparallel beta-sheet as the DNA-binding motif.