Inclusion of peripancreatic lymph node cells prevents recurrent autoimmune destruction of islet transplants: evidence of donor chimerism

Successful treatment for graft-versus-host disease after pancreas transplantation

Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after pancreas transplantation is a rare but serious complication: All previously reported cases were fatal. We herein report three cases of GVHD after pancreas transplantation with favorable outcomes. Patients with a history of kidney (and pancreas) transplantation subsequently received a pancreas (and kidney) transplantation (i.e., pancreas retransplantation or pancreas after kidney transplantation) and developed acute GVHD. All of them responded to increased immunosuppression (e.g., steroid bolus, antithymocyte globulin) and retained normal graft function. Because the clinical manifestations are non-specific, vigilance is necessary to make an accurate diagnosis. We underscored the importance of a biopsy of involved organs and the clinicopathologic correlation in the early diagnosis of GVHD. Augmented immunosuppression to prevent progression from a self-limited disease to life-threatening pancytopenia or sepsis may be most critical to improve outcome.

Potent induction immunotherapy promotes long-term insulin independence after islet transplantation in type 1 diabetes

The seemingly inexorable decline in insulin independence after islet transplant alone (ITA) has raised concern about its clinical utility. We hypothesized that induction immunosuppression therapy determines durability of insulin independence. We analyzed the proportion of insulin-independent patients following final islet infusion in four groups of ITA recipients according to induction immunotherapy: University of Minnesota recipients given FcR nonbinding anti-CD3 antibody alone or T cell depleting antibodies (TCDAb) and TNF-α inhibition (TNF-α-i) (group 1; n = 29); recipients reported to the Collaborative Islet Transplant Registry (CITR) given TCDAb+TNF-α-i (group 2; n = 20); CITR recipients given TCDAb without TNF-α-i (group 3; n = 43); and CITR recipients given IL-2 receptor antibodies (IL-2RAb) alone (group 4; n = 177). Results were compared with outcomes in pancreas transplant alone (PTA) recipients reported to the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (group 5; n = 677). The 5-year insulin independence rates in group 1 (50%) and group 2 (50%) were comparable to outcomes in PTA (group 5: 52%; p>>0.05) but significantly higher than in group 3 (0%; p = 0.001) and group 4 (20%; p = 0.02). Induction immunosuppression was significantly associated with 5-year insulin independence (p = 0.03), regardless of maintenance immunosuppression or other factors. These findings support potential for long-term insulin independence after ITA using potent induction therapy, with anti-CD3 Ab or TCDAb+TNF-α-i.

Endogenous expansion of regulatory T cells leads to long-term islet graft survival in diabetic NOD mice

Donor pancreatic lymph node cells (PLNC) protect islet transplants in Non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice. We hypothesized that induced FoxP3(+) regulatory T cells (Tregs) were required for long-term islet engraftment. NOD or NOD.NON mice were treated with ALS (antilymphocyte serum) and transplanted with NOR islets +/-PLNC (5 × 10(7) ). In vivo proliferation and expansion of FoxP3(+) Tregs was monitored in spleen and PLN from ALS- and ALS/PLNC-treated recipient mice. Anti-CD25 depletion was used to determine the necessity of Tregs for tolerance. FoxP3(+) numbers significantly increased in ALS/PLNC-treated recipients compared to ALS-treated mice. In ALS/PLNC-treated mice, recipient-derived Tregs localized to the transplanted islets, and this was associated with intact, insulin-producing β cells. Proliferation and expansion of FoxP3(+) Tregs was markedly increased in PLNC-treated mice with accepted islet grafts, but not in diabetic mice not receiving PLNC. Deletion of Tregs with anti-CD25 antibodies prevented islet graft tolerance and resulted in rejection. Adoptive transfer of Tregs to secondary NOD.scid recipients inhibited autoimmunity by cotransferred NOD effector T cells. Treg expansion induced by ALS/PLNC-treatment promoted long term islet graft survival. Strategies leading to Treg proliferation and localization to the transplant site represent a therapeutic approach to controlling recurrent autoimmunity.

Abrogation of recurrent autoimmunity in the NOD mouse: A critical role for host interleukin 4

BACKGROUND

We previously established a clinically relevant strategy to abrogate recurrent autoimmunity and enable long-term islet graft survival, involving antilymphocyte serum (ALS)-depletion of recipient T cells and intraportal administration of donor pancreatic lymph node cells (PLNCs) along with islet grafts. In this study, we investigated whether Th2 cytokines were required for the tolerizing ability of ALS/PLNC treatment in islet transplantation.

METHODS

ALS-treated diabetic NOD recipient mice, and NOD recipient mice deficient in interleukin 4 (IL-4-/-) or 10 (IL-4/10-/-) were transplanted with NOR or NOD.scid islets intraportally along with donor PLNC. Blood glucose levels were monitored to access graft function, sections of graft-bearing livers were histologically examined, and ELISPOT assays were used to assess cytokine profile and frequency of islet-reactive CD4 T cells.

RESULTS

We found that ALS/PLNC was not effective in prolonging islet graft survival in diabetic NOD hosts deficient in either IL-4 (NOD.IL-4-/-) or in IL-4 and IL-10 (NOD.IL4-/-/10-/-) (mean survival time, 36 days), contrasting the long-term survival of islet grafts in wild-type NOD mice (mean survival time, > 80 days). In contrast, PLNC deficient in IL-4 promoted long-term graft survival in wild-type NOD hosts similar to that in wild-type PLNC. In wild-type NOD recipients of either wild-type PLNC or IL-4-/- PLNC, the host autoantigen-specific CD4 T cells produced predominately IL-4 coincident with long-term graft survival, whereas, in NOD.IL-4-/- recipients with rejected grafts, the autoreactive T cells produced interferon gamma and low amounts of IL-4.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate that abrogation of recurrent autoimmunity requires host IL-4 and that manipulation of the autoreactive cytokine profile in long-term diabetes may be an effective strategy for islet transplant therapies.

Viral IL-10-mediated immune regulation in pancreatic islet transplantation

Protection of transplanted pancreatic islet grafts in recipients with autoimmune diabetes depends on the suppression of autoimmune recurrence and allogeneic rejection. The aim of this study was to investigate the efficiency of viral IL-10 gene delivery in the prevention of autoimmune recurrence following islet transplantation. We evaluated the effectiveness of a systemically delivered adeno-associated viral vector (AAV vIL-10) carrying viral IL-10 in protecting islet engraftment. We observed significant prolongation of graft survival after treatment with AAV vIL-10 when using islets from donors lacking autoimmunity. We found that the mechanism of vIL-10-mediated protection was associated with suppression of T cell activation and that donor immune cells that were simultaneously transferred with the islet grafts could induce autoimmune recurrence. AAV vIL-10 gene transfer suppressed previously activated T cells and protected grafted islets from autoimmune-mediated destruction. We conclude that vIL-10 can regulate autoimmune activity and that transfer of its gene may have potential for therapeutic islet transplantation.

Immunological characteristics of pancreas transplantation: review and our experimental experience

Pancreas and islet transplantation is the only treatment that can cure type 1 diabetes mellitus (DM). With the recent advances of operative procedure and immunosuppression, pancreas graft survivals have become better than before, but some problems still remain. It is extremely difficult to establish tolerance and to reverse rejection once it has been initiated because the pancreas graft itself has a strong immunogenicity. It is also known that pancreatic graft failure is sometimes due to autoimmune recurrence. In the clinical situation, however, these immunologic events actually coexist within the pancreatic graft. Thus, it is rather difficult to analyze each of them independently, but possible to delineate each of these immunologic mechanisms with using animal models of type 1 DM such as BB (BioBreeding) rats or NOD (nonobese diabetic) mice. In the current study, we reviewed the immunological characteristics in pancreas transplantation (PTx) based on our experimental experiences together with that of others and investigated the possibility of tolerance induction in PTx.

Factors influencing Islet of Langerhans graft function and monitoring

Transplantation of islet of Langerhans represents a viable therapeutic option for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Dramatic progress has been recently reported with the introduction of a glucocorticoid-free immunosuppressive regimen that improved success rate, namely, insulin independence for 1 year or more, from 8% to 100%. The fate of islet grafts is determined by many concurrent phenomena, some of which are common to organ grafts (i.e. rejection), while others are unique to nonvascularized cell transplants, including transplant cell mass and viability, as well as nonspecific inflammation at the site of implant. Moreover, islet grafts lack clinical markers of early rejection, making it difficult to recognize imminent rejection and to implement intervention with graft-saving immunosuppressive regimens. In the present review, we will address the problems influencing islet graft success and the monitoring of islet cell graft function.

Significant role of intragraft lymphoid tissues in preventing insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus recurrence in whole pancreaticoduodenal transplantation

Graft recurrence of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) was examined. Islet transplantation or pancreas-alone transplantation excluding the duodenum and peripancreatic lymph nodes was compared with whole pancreaticoduodenal transplantation. A Wistar Furth (WF; RT1(u), RT6.2) to major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-compatible diabetes-prone (DP; RT1(u), RT6.1 gene carrier)-biobreeding (BB) rat transplantation model was used. Only DP recipients that had been transplanted with whole pancreaticoduodenal grafts were free from IDDM recurrence (>60 days postgrafting) when treated with anti-intercellular adhesion moluecule-1 (ICAM)-1/leukocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). In the spleen cells of the DP rats that had accepted pancreatic grafts (60 days postgrafting), flow cytometric analysis showed that NKR-P1(+)TCRalphabeta(+) (NKT) cells had proliferated markedly, with the proportion of 12.8 +/- 1.7% in the total splenic T cells, most of which (86.2%) were derived from the donor (RT6.2(+)). By enzyme-linked immunonosorbent assay (ELISA), serum interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) was not detected (<13 pg/ml) in all rats. However, interleukin-4 (IL-4) was detected as 158.8 +/- 28.0 pg/ml in the nonrecurrent DP recipients. These data suggested that to prevent IDDM recurrence in the pancreatic graft, the lymphocytes in the pancreaticoduodenal grafts are necessary. Also, the donor-derived NKT cells might have some immunoregulatory functions with a Th2 deviation.

The effect of methimazole, iodine and splenocytes on thyroid transplants in BB/Wor rats

BACKGROUND

BB/Wor rats develop spontaneous autoimmune insulin-requiring diabetes mellitus and lymphocytic thyroiditis (LT). Our investigations examined the effect of the thyroid-specific agents, iodine and methimazole (MMI) on thyroid graft survival in BB/Wor rats, compared the intrathyroidal cytokine mRNA expression of endogenous and engrafted thyroids, and ascertained whether unfractionated splenocytes could protect thyroid grafts from lymphocytic infiltration.

METHODS

In study 1, 0.025% iodine water-treated LT-prone NB line BB/Wor rats were randomized to receive one of the following treatments: (1) 1.0 x 10(8) splenocytes, IV from LT-resistant WA line BB/Wor rats, (2) WA rat thyroid transplants, (3) both, or (4) neither (controls). In study 2, after thyroid transplantation, LT-prone BB/Wor rats were randomized to receive (1) WA splenocytes, (2) 0.025% iodine water, (3) 0.05% MMI water or, (4) tap water (controls). The incidence of LT was determined by microscopic inspection after hematoxylin and eosin staining. Lymphocytic infiltrates were characterized by immunohistochemistry. Cytokine mRNA was detected by RT-PCR.

RESULTS

Grafts from MMI-treated rats had a significantly lower incidence of lymphocytic infiltration (MMI: 2/5; Tap: 5/5; I 5/5, P<0.05, chi2). IL-10 mRNA was expressed in 77% (7/9) endogenous thyroids and 20% (1/5) of the transplanted WA thyroids (P<0.05, chi2) from iodine-treated rats with LT. There was no difference in IL-12 mRNA expression. Lymphocytic infiltration occurred in 100% of the splenocyte-treated graft recipients. Both endogenous and engrafted thyroids contained CD4 and C8 T cells with scattered IgG staining.

CONCLUSION

Target organ-specific interventions that suppress antigen presentation may have an adjunctive role in transplantation tolerance. The differential expression of IL-10 may indicate preferential Th2 lymphocyte activation in the endogenous tissues.

Immunosuppression preventing concordant xenogeneic islet graft rejection is not sufficient to prevent recurrence of autoimmune diabetes in nonobese diabetic mice

BACKGROUND

We and others have reported previously that the immunosuppressant, leflunomide (Lef), can prevent allogeneic and xenogeneic islet graft rejection in streptozocin (STZ)-induced diabetic animals. However, whether Lef required to prevent islet graft rejection is sufficient to prevent the recurrence of autoimmune diabetes has not been addressed.

METHODS

The effect of Lef on concordant xenogeneic islet graft in STZ-induced diabetic mice and autoimmune nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice were studied. Then, whether Lef prevents the onset of spontaneous diabetes in young NOD mice and the recurrence of diabetes after major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched islet transplantation in diabetic NOD mice were investigated.

RESULTS

In STZ-induced diabetic BALB/c mice, Lef treatment significantly prolonged rat islet graft survival. However, Lef could not significantly prolong rat islet graft survival in autoimmune diabetic NOD mice. For prevention studies, treatment with Lef at 30 mg/ kg/day from 4 weeks to 20 weeks of age significantly reduced the incidence of spontaneous diabetes in NOD mice. However, when the NOD mice were treated from 8 to 24 weeks of age, the incidence of spontaneous diabetes was not significantly reduced as compared to the incidence of diabetes in the untreated female NOD mice at 28 weeks of age. Finally, in the MHC-matched islet transplant model, Lef could not significantly prolong MHC-matched nonobese diabetes-resistant mice islet graft survival in NOD mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Lef preventing concordant xenogeneic islet graft rejection is not sufficient to prevent the recurrence of autoimmune diabetes in NOD mice. We believe that controlling autoimmunity after islet transplantation will lead the way to promote successful clinical islet transplantation in the future.

Prevention of autoimmune islet allograft destruction by engraftment of donor T cells

The results of clinical islet transplantation have remained poor when compared with the consistent success of pancreas transplantation. Autoimmunity has usually been discounted as a cause of islet transplant failure. Previously, we demonstrated that pancreas transplants from the diabetes resistant BB rat (BB-DR) function indefinitely in autoimmune diabetic hosts, but islets from the same donor are vulnerable to recurrent autoimmunity. Addition of 100 million pancreatic lymph node cells (PLNC) to BB-DR islets restores resistance to autoimmunity and leads to repletion of a T cell subset (RT6.1) in the recipients. Autoimmune (BB-Ac) and streptozocin (BB-Sz) diabetic BB rats were recipients of Wistar Furth (WF) intraportal islet or islets plus PLNC transplants with cyclosporine 5 mg/kg/day recipient treatment. One cohort of Brown Norway (BN) islet transplants to BB-Ac with CsA was performed. At the termination of the experiment, recipient peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were characterized by flow cytometry (FACS) for class I, CD4, CD8, RT6.1, and RT6.2, a T cell maturation marker found in WF but not BB rats. All (14/14) WF and 75% (6/8) BN islet transplants to BB-Ac recipients failed after a mean of 42 and 36 days, respectively, despite CsA immunosuppression. WF islets were successful in 6/8 (75%) transplants to BB-Sz recipients (P<0.001 vs. BB-Ac recipients), confirming that autoimmunity is the major cause of islet failure in BB-Ac rats. Addition of PLNC to WF islets increased the survival in BB-Ac to 82% (9/11) (P<0.0001 vs. WF islets alone). Recipients of islet+PLNC express 19.7% RT6.2 compared with 4.6% and 4.0% for WF islets alone in BB-Ac (P<0.01) and BB-Sz (P<0.01), respectively. Autoimmunity is an important factor leading to islet transplant failure in autoimmune diabetic BB rats. Addition of donor PLNC prevent islet allograft failure and leads to recipient chimerism for a donor T cell subset (RT6.2) associated with resistance to autoimmunity.

Histologic findings in islets of whole pancreas allografts: lack of evidence for recurrent cell-mediated diabetes mellitus

Cell-mediated cytotoxicity directed toward pancreatic islets plays a significant role in the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes mellitus. Histologically, autoimmune insulitis appears as mononuclear infiltrates that precede actual beta cell loss. Experimental studies by Bartlett et al. on the BB rat model suggest that whole pancreas transplants are not susceptible to recurrent autoimmune diabetes. To test this hypothesis on clinical grounds, we evaluated the islets in pancreatectomies and percutaneous needle biopsies from 55 whole pancreas allografts. In this material, islet inflammation was never seen independently of allograft rejection, but was always associated with inflammation of the surrounding acinar structures. The degree of islet inflammation and the occasional presence of islet necrosis correlated well with the degree of rejection and only occurred in the higher grades of the latter (grades III-V). We did not observe isolated insulitis as a histological indication of selective cell-mediated cytotoxicity against beta cells.

Islet cell antibodies and glutamic acid decarboxylase antibodies in patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus undergoing kidney and islet-after-kidney transplantation

The humoral immune response to islet autoantigens, here defined by the presence of islet cell antibodies (ICA) and glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD 65) antibodies, was studied in patients with long-term insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) receiving immunosuppressive therapy following kidney and islet-after-kidney transplantation. In a cross-sectional study of 30 kidney-grafted, long-term IDDM patients and 30 matched, nontransplanted IDDM controls, we observed a significant (P<0.05) decrease in ICA positivity by standard immunosuppressive therapy, but not in frequency or index levels of GAD 65 antibodies. Because of this intriguing finding, we investigated, in a pilot study on seven islet-after-kidney transplant recipients, the time course of frequency and levels of ICAs and GAD 65 antibodies relative to islet graft function. Stable islet graft function was seen in the patients with low GAD 65 antibody index levels, whereas rapid islet graft failure occurred in a patient with high GAD 65 antibody index levels prior to transplantation. In addition, GAD 65 autoimmunity reoccurred in one pretransplant antibody-negative patient 2 months after graft failure was noted. In conclusion, these observations suggest that beta-cell autoimmunity directed to GAD 65 can persist despite immunosuppressive therapy and may adversely affect islet graft function, possibly indicating disease recurrence as a major threat to successful clinical islet transplantation.